These kids are so unbelievably well trained in Bach. They nearly dance! Only a top Conductor coach can get them this far . I play Bach for nearly 70 years now. Never heard or see something like this. Bravo!
Almost four decades ago, the choir from Indiana University, directed by Donald Neuen, performed in tour the Bach's St Matthew's Passion in a very similar way... astonishing!
En el arte musical verdadero la palabra entrenado no existe simplemente son personas que estudian a diario y tienen aptitudes para la música desgraciadamente en México no existe esa enseñanza avansada
I agree! Bach was, IMO, the master of drama in music, although it's interesting that he never wrote an opera. As for your comment, it would be unfortunate if anyone singing in such a masterpiece would remain unmoved!
Stumbled on this video tonight. Quite overwhelming singing, tremendous verve and energy, focus and concentration. Moved me to tears! Thank you so much from New York and I hope to come see and hear you all sing one day soon!
Man spürt, wie mitgerissen die Jungs sind, wie sie wippen, sich strecken, wogen, Luft wuchten. Wer so in der Musik versinken kann, hat sie verstanden. Wer die Sänger zu dieser befreiten Art zu singen motiviert, ist ein Meister, der diesen Jungs für's Leben begreiflich gemacht hat, was Musik im Körper bedeutet. Nur stehen und singen ohne Bewegung ist nur Absolvieren. Singen und Mitgehen ist Eintauchen und Verinnerlichen. Mein Kompliment und tiefer Dank für dieses Erlebnis!
There simply aren't enough superlatives to accurately describe just how good the Windbacher Knabenchor is. Marvelous, stupendous, outstanding, außgezeichnet, und fantastisch are few that come to mind.
There is definetely a unique timbre which can only be produced by boy trebles. It would beca pity if that was totally sacrificed on the alter of political correctness.
First: greetings from Belgium. Second: I discoved this choir some years ago and it went straight to my top five of boys choirs. They make Bach sound so clear and light... I love this performance.
Beeindruckend und berührend...diese Leidenschaft, Klarheit und Transparenz. Diese Aufnahme ist mitreißend und selten so perfekt gehört Nein, in dieser Perfektion habe ich den Eingangschor noch nie gehört! Tempo, Rhythmik, die Stimmen...ich bin restlos begeistert
Extraordinarily well done ; the rhythmic line is of an absolute beauty, and give this sublime piece his very sacred character. Not to slow, not to precipitate, so we can catch all the magnificence in each note. Thousands of BRAVO. THIS CHIEF IS A GENIUS !
Eine äußerst berührende Umsetzung der herrlichen Einleitung der Johannespassion von dem großen J.S.BACH. Sehr gelungen! Großartig und man genießt jeden Ton!
Wenn man diese Knaben hört und sieht mit welch einem Engagement und freudigem Einsatz sie dieses wunderschöne Werk Bachs singen, dann kann man vertrauen, dass die Welt nicht verloren ist und in Deutschland der wahre Geist lebendig geblieben ist. Ein grosser Trost geht von diesem Konzert aus. Danke 🙏
Prekrasno, zadivljujuće! Zbor je ujedno vježba samokontrole i usklđivanja sa drugima, što je inače nužno u životu! Neposredna nagrada je uživanje u umjetnosti i druženju sa sebi sličnima.
Epoustouflante cette interprétation qui est soutenue et magnifiée par les expressions des choristes, passionnées et habitées par le texte et cette musique sacrée ! Du jamais vu !
The horrific beauty is born. Out of primordial chaos grow the sounds that tear the ears, soul and mind. There is nothing to compare the cathedral of this chorus.
Die schreckliche Sehe des Abysmus der Golgotha richtig am Anfang des Passiones. Der mächtige Schrei der ganze Menschheit zu Gott. Etwas ähnliches zu ein gewaltiger "Warum?". Tiefmal Berührend.
This might be the greatest choral performance ive ever came across. These kids have my utmost respect for the passion and love they pour into that performance.
They are good, and their enthusiasm is heartening. But when all is said and done, amateur is amateur and professionals are on another level. Compare: th-cam.com/video/FyeOPfg_6FE/w-d-xo.html
Herr, unser Herrscher dessen Ruhm in allen Landen herrlich ist! Zeig' uns durch deine Passion, dass du, der wahre Gottessohn, zu aller Zeit, auch in der grössten Niedrigkeit, verherrlicht worden bist. O Signore, nostro sovrano, sommamente e ovunque glorioso! Mostraci con la Tua Passione come Tu, - vero figlio di Dio - pur nell'estrema abiezione fosti per sempre esaltato. Bach, semplicemente un genio che vive per l'eternità.
Oh my, how glorious! Very very impressive choir and orchestra, but oh, the voices just heavenly! Thank you for sharing! Blessed Easter season to Windsbacher Knabenchor!
best performance I know (of many I heard) of this section of The Passion. It is a mysterious piece; singular in Bach's output, and unique in all of music; one is allowed to imagine the agony of the Saviour of Humankind, betrayed and crucified.
The TH-cam algorithm does something right for me every once in awhile. Oh my! These young men sing with such precision, intonation, enthusiasm - young professionals everyone! Amazing and beautiful this rendition brought me to shivering ecstatic goosebumps on the back of my neck and spine!
I believe that moving of the body gives a positive effect on the sound. Pianissimo and forte never had been better audible for me. Complete standstil is not good for breathing. ( My ten cents)
What a pleasure not only to watch but to listen to this excellent choir. Their enthusiasm is infectious. Their obvious enjoyment in performing this work is so very evident.
This is such an inspirational performance with true excellent in musicality, articulation and passion. Such a balanced choir with strong singing in all voices. The choristers give all of themselves into this intense interpretation and Ludwig Böhme is a truly superb conductor. It’s one of the best performances and interpretations of the Johannes Passion I have ever heard. I’m in awe at the nuances in dynamics and emotion which are conveyed ! What a tribute to J.S. Bach !
I marvel at the number of high quality Boys choirs that Germany and Austria have and have seen videos by this choir on many occasions but know very little about them. Bach is the staple diet of all of them, but this short extract is, to my untrained ears at least, right up with any other performances. I need to find out more about the choir. Thank you for the question about the whole concert and the answer, I look forward to watching it all.
here you can find more information about the Windsbacher Knabenchor: windsbacher-knabenchor.de/ and here you can watch the full concert: www.br-klassik.de/concert/ausstrahlung-3297780.html
There are more than 80 boys'choirs in German speaking Europe, and many of them of the highest calibre. We in North America are rather backward in that respect.
Maravilloso!!! Hoy viernes Santo, oír esto me ayuda a centrarme en la pasión del Señor! Gracias pequeños y jóvenes cantores por vuestro buen hacer : que Dios os bendiga!!!
Wie immer sehr schön. Im direkten Vergleich bevorzuge ich zwar den Eingangschor der Matthäus-Passion, aber auch dieses Stück gehört mit zu den besten. Und dann auch noch mit zeitgenössischen Instrumenten...
Nice. Our college choir sang the St. John Passion during Lent of 1973. I was 19. I accompanied rehearsals on the piano, but we sang it with the Charleston Symphony Orchestra.
Jemand hat einmal in etwa sich geäußert: Bach müsste man Strom nennen... Bei diesem großen Komponisten floss die Musik wie ein mächtiger Strom. Man merkt auch, daß Bach alles zur EHRE GOTTES komponiert hat.SOLI DEO GLORIA!!!!!!
Majestic music, J. S. Bach would be blown away. Huge respect for this amount of musical talent, work and enthusiasm. Intense, beautiful, superb performance. Thank you all for that. 🧡🙏🏻
Wow. Superb. Magnificent. Will listen to this Knabenchor from now on at every opportunity. Their conductor is brilliant, as we see and hear just what he elicits from this choir of bright-eyed young men. Thank you. 🙏
No voy a estar la preposición "pero"... Me encanta cómo pronuncia muy bien el alemán y las voces blancas de éste coro masculino se escuchan las 4 voces de este impresionante y mítico coro de introducción al oratorio sacro, lamentablemente se desconoce el poeta de la letra de las arias y corales, Bach supo ponerte tremenda música. Gracias por subir y compartir éste vídeo en TH-cam. ❤😊
Nicht zu viel, nicht zu wenig. Auf den Punkt. Exakt! Jede Linie stimmt. Leidenschaftlich, aber nicht gekünstelt, sondern natürlich. Bin kritisch! Sehr kritisch! Aber hier: Absolut berührend! Danke 🎵
I always think of it as some kind of miracle to get young men and boys to sing at any level. Bach must have had a resource of such singers to perform a new Cantata each Sunday. I’m assuming they were young men and boys such as this remarkable choir. BRAVO!
![[Acapella] The Lion Sleeps Tonight](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mJzmAlRMJT4/mqdefault.jpg)
You can watch the full concert here 👉 www.br-klassik.de/concert/ausstrahlung-3297780.html
Thanks very much from Holland.
Aber die Qualitat is nur mono. Kann man mindestens,das unglaublig schon gesungen Schluss (Ruht wohl) nich auch auf TH-cam setzen?
@@herpideperpi2 das Audio ist definitiv nicht Mono, woher sie diese Info auch nehmen. Die Idee mit dem Schlusschor werden wir im Hinterkopf behalten.
@@Knabenchormagazindanke schon kann nicht warten. Heute abend. R u h t w o h l.
@@Knabenchormagazinput on a headset and you will hear the difference. But now we are getting schluschor I am grateful.
These kids are so unbelievably well trained in Bach. They nearly dance! Only a top Conductor coach can get them this far . I play Bach for nearly 70 years now. Never heard or see something like this. Bravo!
Almost four decades ago, the choir from Indiana University, directed by Donald Neuen, performed in tour the Bach's St Matthew's Passion in a very similar way... astonishing!
En el arte musical verdadero la palabra entrenado no existe simplemente son personas que estudian a diario y tienen aptitudes para la música desgraciadamente en México no existe esa enseñanza avansada
Nearly? They dance.
Diese Musik ist ein göttlicher Atemzug,eine Wiederbelebung der Menschheit
le souffle des garçons et des hommes!
@@michelcelsand was atmen Sie ein? Den Odem Gottes! Tagtäglich!
Wunderschön gesungen! Gerade heute zu Karfreitag eine Wohltat! Danke!
there is a future, if there are boys like them!
l'avenir c'est eux!
Probably the most striking aspect is the sheer enthusiasm for Bach's music which shows in the body and facial expressions of the entire choir.
I agree! Bach was, IMO, the master of drama in music, although it's interesting that he never wrote an opera. As for your comment, it would be unfortunate if anyone singing in such a masterpiece would remain unmoved!
I agree.
mir geht das herz auf, mein junges, deutsches volk steht da und strahlt intelligenz , kultur und wunderbarkeit aus.
Stumbled on this video tonight. Quite overwhelming singing, tremendous verve and energy, focus and concentration. Moved me to tears! Thank you so much from New York and I hope to come see and hear you all sing one day soon!
Wunderschön gesungen
Gelobt sei Jesus Christus!
Man spürt, wie mitgerissen die Jungs sind, wie sie wippen, sich strecken, wogen, Luft wuchten. Wer so in der Musik versinken kann, hat sie verstanden. Wer die Sänger zu dieser befreiten Art zu singen motiviert, ist ein Meister, der diesen Jungs für's Leben begreiflich gemacht hat, was Musik im Körper bedeutet. Nur stehen und singen ohne Bewegung ist nur Absolvieren. Singen und Mitgehen ist Eintauchen und Verinnerlichen. Mein Kompliment und tiefer Dank für dieses Erlebnis!
Es ist wirklich schön zu sehen, wenn junge Menschen Begeisterung für seriöse Musik zeigen. Und singen können die Burschen!
Wunderbar in Worte gefasst! Ich hoffe, es werden noch viele in der jüngeren Generation erreicht!
Бах- это мой Бог! Нет ничего лучше его музыки! Благодарю за эту запись!
Es geht hier um Jesus Christus, der als Gott und Herrscher verehrt wird. Nicht die Musik ist Objekt der Verehrung, sondern Christus.
Love the enthusiasm of these boys and the way they are just giving their all. Well done.
There simply aren't enough superlatives to accurately describe just how good the Windbacher Knabenchor is. Marvelous, stupendous, outstanding, außgezeichnet, und fantastisch are few that come to mind.
There is definetely a unique timbre which can only be produced by boy trebles. It would beca pity if that was totally sacrificed on the alter of political correctness.
Yes, but there's fast and too fast. This is definitely TOO.
But like all boys choir EVERYWHERE, they lack "warmth". Its all regimented and dry.
Exactly, you are absolutely right
Beste Grüße
First: greetings from Belgium. Second: I discoved this choir some years ago and it went straight to my top five of boys choirs. They make Bach sound so clear and light... I love this performance.
Excellent singing! :-) A very disciplined and well-trained choir.
Beeindruckend und berührend...diese Leidenschaft, Klarheit und Transparenz. Diese Aufnahme ist mitreißend und selten so perfekt gehört
Nein, in dieser Perfektion habe ich den Eingangschor noch nie gehört! Tempo, Rhythmik, die Stimmen...ich bin restlos begeistert
Extraordinarily well done ; the rhythmic line is of an absolute beauty, and give this sublime piece his very sacred character. Not to slow, not to precipitate, so we can catch all the magnificence in each note. Thousands of BRAVO. THIS CHIEF IS A GENIUS !
이런 합창하는 청소년들이 있는것과 J.S.Bach 같은 역사적 작곡가들의 멋진 작품이 태어난 당신들의 풍부한 문화적 배경들이 너무 훌륭하고 부럽습니다. 이렇게 보석같은 음악을 부활절 저녁에 만나게 되어 기쁘고 반갑네요. 😊
Большой привет из России! Спасибо! Пожалуйста, продолжайте дальше!
Eine äußerst berührende Umsetzung der herrlichen Einleitung der Johannespassion von dem großen J.S.BACH. Sehr gelungen! Großartig und man genießt jeden Ton!
Wenn man diese Knaben hört und sieht mit welch einem Engagement und freudigem Einsatz sie dieses wunderschöne Werk Bachs singen, dann kann man vertrauen, dass die Welt nicht verloren ist und in Deutschland der wahre Geist lebendig geblieben ist. Ein grosser Trost geht von diesem Konzert aus. Danke 🙏
Prekrasno, zadivljujuće!
Zbor je ujedno vježba samokontrole i usklđivanja sa drugima, što je inače nužno u životu!
Neposredna nagrada je uživanje u umjetnosti i druženju sa sebi sličnima.
Wonderful performance, and inspiring to see the young boys rocking out to Bach!
Epoustouflante cette interprétation qui est soutenue et magnifiée par les expressions des choristes, passionnées et habitées par le texte et cette musique sacrée ! Du jamais vu !
This is so beautiful that it makes me cry.
There is nothing better than this.
rien de plus beau que ça à part les hautes montagnes et les étoiles!
@@michelcels -- Voilà!
The horrific beauty is born. Out of primordial chaos grow the sounds that tear the ears, soul and mind. There is nothing to compare the cathedral of this chorus.
Die schreckliche Sehe des Abysmus der Golgotha richtig am Anfang des Passiones. Der mächtige Schrei der ganze Menschheit zu Gott. Etwas ähnliches zu ein gewaltiger "Warum?". Tiefmal Berührend.
Bravo !, vous êtes vraiment "TOP", merci
This might be the greatest choral performance ive ever came across. These kids have my utmost respect for the passion and love they pour into that performance.
I am deeply moved and really impressively lucky by this marvellous outstanding interpretation.
They are good, and their enthusiasm is heartening. But when all is said and done, amateur is amateur and professionals are on another level. Compare: th-cam.com/video/FyeOPfg_6FE/w-d-xo.html
Herr, unser Herrscher dessen Ruhm
in allen Landen herrlich ist!
Zeig' uns durch deine Passion,
dass du, der wahre Gottessohn,
zu aller Zeit,
auch in der grössten Niedrigkeit,
verherrlicht worden bist.
O Signore, nostro sovrano,
sommamente e ovunque glorioso!
Mostraci con la Tua Passione
come Tu, - vero figlio di Dio -
pur nell'estrema abiezione
fosti per sempre esaltato.
Bach, semplicemente un genio che vive per l'eternità.
Ehrfürchtig ergeben💛wundervoller Lobgesang 🌟Amen🙏
German cherubs singing Bach. Heaven on earth!
Спасибо за столько красивое и чистое исполнение сложнейшего произведения!
Herrlich! Wunderschön!! 1000 Dank! Am Ende des Tages eine Wohltat!❤
Wonderful!
Bravo!
Oh my, how glorious! Very very impressive choir and orchestra, but oh, the voices just heavenly! Thank you for sharing! Blessed Easter season to Windsbacher Knabenchor!
Sehr beeindruckend ❣️😃
Was für ein klasse Chor ❕️👌🏼
Alles Liebe aus Berlin,
Ramsi 🙋🏻♂️😘
The incomparable deed of unfathomable magnificence. If a man can achieve this supremacy, then nothing is beyond his reach.
best performance I know (of many I heard) of this section of The Passion. It is a mysterious piece; singular in Bach's output, and unique in all of music; one is allowed to imagine the agony of the Saviour of Humankind, betrayed and crucified.
Muy precisas palabras y hermosas para el coro 1 del oratorio sacro... Muy poético. Gracias por su acertadas palabras. 😊❤
Lovely sound and beautifully sung! The energy is duly notes.
Божественная энергия уже была в зале! Мощь исполнителей увеличила ее . БРАВО , Маэстро, исполнителям❤❤❤
The TH-cam algorithm does something right for me every once in awhile. Oh my! These young men sing with such precision, intonation, enthusiasm - young professionals everyone! Amazing and beautiful this rendition brought me to shivering ecstatic goosebumps on the back of my neck and spine!
Какая самоотдача исполнителей ! Потрясающе ! И. С. Бах ... Гениев много создала жизнь , но ОН -- ОДИН .!!! Другого ТАКОГО нету !
Very good performance!
L’orquestra, les magnífiques veus, la música…i J.S.Bach! Quanta bellesa junta❤
I believe that moving of the body gives a positive effect on the sound. Pianissimo and forte never had been better audible for me. Complete standstil is not good for breathing. ( My ten cents)
Glorious. Sung as Bach intended, by a chorus of cherubs.
What a pleasure not only to watch but to listen to this excellent choir. Their enthusiasm is infectious. Their obvious enjoyment in performing this work is so very evident.
Wunderbar und herzlichen Dank an die begnadeten Musiker
Herrlich!
Oh my goodness, what excellent musicianship. This is quite a definitive performance. I want more of this group !
Fabulous.
Fabulously homogeneous sound , truly exciting and full of captivating vigour throughout.
That conductor is wonderfully expressive!
The more horrific tragedy in history we can feel trough theese cords of Bach excellently performed by this choir. Thank you
Ich wäre gern live dabei gewesen, eine beeindruckend engagierte Aufführung!
Extraklasse
This is such an inspirational performance with true excellent in musicality, articulation and passion. Such a balanced choir with strong singing in all voices. The choristers give all of themselves into this intense interpretation and Ludwig Böhme is a truly superb conductor. It’s one of the best performances and interpretations of the Johannes Passion I have ever heard. I’m in awe at the nuances in dynamics and emotion which are conveyed ! What a tribute to J.S. Bach !
I'm honestly impressed. They got soul, presence and sincerity. That's how I feel it anyway. Bravo 🙂
I marvel at the number of high quality Boys choirs that Germany and Austria have and have seen videos by this choir on many occasions but know very little about them. Bach is the staple diet of all of them, but this short extract is, to my untrained ears at least, right up with any other performances. I need to find out more about the choir.
Thank you for the question about the whole concert and the answer, I look forward to watching it all.
here you can find more information about the Windsbacher Knabenchor: windsbacher-knabenchor.de/ and here you can watch the full concert: www.br-klassik.de/concert/ausstrahlung-3297780.html
@@Knabenchormagazin Thank you for your kind and helpful reply, I was having some difficulty with the link.
It's a pity however we do not see very much on youtube lately about the other great choirs like Tölzer, Thomaner or Florianer.
There are more than 80 boys'choirs in German speaking Europe, and many of them of the highest calibre. We in North America are rather backward in that respect.
Maravilloso!!! Hoy viernes Santo, oír esto me ayuda a centrarme en la pasión del Señor! Gracias pequeños y jóvenes cantores por vuestro buen hacer : que Dios os bendiga!!!
Bravo!!! Sehr gut
Wie immer sehr schön. Im direkten Vergleich bevorzuge ich zwar den Eingangschor der Matthäus-Passion, aber auch dieses Stück gehört mit zu den besten. Und dann auch noch mit zeitgenössischen Instrumenten...
Super!
THE BEST!
Nuestro padre Bach siempre sublime...
Nice. Our college choir sang the St. John Passion during Lent of 1973. I was 19. I accompanied rehearsals on the piano, but we sang it with the Charleston Symphony Orchestra.
Wonderfull!!! In my language: Maravilhoso!!! ❤
Love, love the Contrabassoon!
Bravo, vielen Danken
Stunning
Как им хорошо... Вместе петь такую красоты
Как трогательно и прекрасно!
"Señor, nuestro Gobernante"
Grandios, danke dafür!
Jemand hat einmal in etwa sich geäußert: Bach müsste man Strom nennen... Bei diesem großen Komponisten floss die Musik wie ein mächtiger Strom. Man merkt auch, daß Bach alles zur EHRE GOTTES komponiert hat.SOLI DEO GLORIA!!!!!!
Una interpretación con una gran maestría. Estos chicos cantan como los ángeles.❤. Me gusta mucho.
Magnífico e sublime!
Parabéns!
Amazing conducting.
Majestic music, J. S. Bach would be blown away. Huge respect for this amount of musical talent, work and enthusiasm. Intense, beautiful, superb performance. Thank you all for that. 🧡🙏🏻
Thanks very much for sharing this! Superb rendition indeed!!!! The dedication of each of the participants is highly emotional. Thanks again.
Fuck me dead! I listen to it non stop the whole day long ...
Wow. Superb. Magnificent. Will listen to this Knabenchor from now on at every opportunity. Their conductor is brilliant, as we see and hear just what he elicits from this choir of bright-eyed young men. Thank you. 🙏
Great
Eccellente esecuzione del coro e dell'orchestra
No voy a estar la preposición "pero"... Me encanta cómo pronuncia muy bien el alemán y las voces blancas de éste coro masculino se escuchan las 4 voces de este impresionante y mítico coro de introducción al oratorio sacro, lamentablemente se desconoce el poeta de la letra de las arias y corales, Bach supo ponerte tremenda música. Gracias por subir y compartir éste vídeo en TH-cam. ❤😊
Superbe version. Bravo !
Magnifique ❤
Nicht zu viel, nicht zu wenig. Auf den Punkt. Exakt! Jede Linie stimmt. Leidenschaftlich, aber nicht gekünstelt, sondern natürlich. Bin kritisch! Sehr kritisch! Aber hier: Absolut berührend! Danke 🎵
Всякое дыхание да хвалит Господа!
Most excellent!!!
When are you coming to the U.S.A. ??? Specifically, New York City ???
Sublime❤❤❤
Bach is fucking jazz ! Timeless.
I wish I had been there to enjoy every moment, it’s just magnificent! Nevertheless in heaven it would be better!
Magnifique ! Très belle interprétation.
They are really the best in Germany.
I always think of it as some kind of miracle to get young men and boys to sing at any level. Bach must have had a resource of such singers to perform a new Cantata each Sunday. I’m assuming they were young men and boys such as this remarkable choir. BRAVO!
I tedeschi sono stati benedetti da Dio con Johan Sebastian Bach
In my humble opinion, better than Harnoncourt's and Richter's version. Bravo!
Ausgezeichnet! Danke!