Can a PASSENGER land a PLANE? Presented by CAPTAIN JOE
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ส.ค. 2024
- ✈️WANT TO BECOME A PILOT?✈️ bit.ly/474j06T
📗📗📗GET MY NEW BOOK amzn.to/32TH4x7 📗📗📗
📸 INSTAGRAM FLYWITHCAPTAINJOE: goo.gl/TToDlg 📸
🌐MY WEBSITE: goo.gl/KGTSWK 🌐
🛒👕---► T-SHIRT SHOP goo.gl/Svrqmx ◄ --👕-🛒
📖👨 NEW FACEBOOK PAGE: goo.gl/heUKGb 👨📖
▼▼My FLIGHT-KIT I highly recommend for you guys▼▼
MY HEADSET: amzn.to/2CrTrzz
MY SUNGLASSES: amzn.to/2VY6FNo
MY PILOT BAG: amzn.to/2DiWKux
Company iPad: amzn.to/2W1zM2n
▼▼The VIDEO EQUIPMENT I use in my studio and outdoors▼▼
MY CAMERA: amzn.to/2T1VK3g
LIGHTING: amzn.to/2szSRv4
IN-FLIGHT RECORDINGS: amzn.to/2VY7A0g
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dear friends and followers, welcome back to my channel. Today´s topic is one of the most ask passenger question, "Can a passenger land a plane?". There are so many rumours about this question, it´s just not true.
So a few facts. My friend Carolin, has no connection to the aviation world besides from flying to holiday once in a while, obviously as a passenger.
Now as soon as she sat down, the hardest part was establishing a communication between her and me, the ATC controller. Carolin was totally overwhelmed with all the switches and buttons, that it took nearly 20 minutes to find the push to talk button. In a real-life situation, if a plane does not respond within 20 minutes, fighter jets will be on their way intercepting the aeroplane as it causes a potential threat to national security, depending which land you´re flying across.
Once communication was established, I had to give her instructions on how to set up the approach phase for an automatic landing, better known as AUTOLAND procedure. The AUTOLAND allows pilots to perform a fully automated landing in bad visual conditions, known as CAT3 approaches. More about that in future videos.
Once the approach set up was completed, I had to give her instructions to familiarize with important levers and switches, such as the landing gear lever, the flaps, flight control computer and much more.
Later I guided her via radar vectors towards the airport, constantly descending and reducing the speed accordingly.
But see for yourself.
My opinion if a passenger can land a plane. I´ll be honest with you! It´s impossible! We needed three attempts to just establish basic communication and Carolin accidentally brought the aircraft into a stall. Don´t ask how!
And she was pretty nervous, although she knew it was a simulator. Imagine the anxiety in a real plane!?
I know that there are many videos out there where apparently the passenger landed the plane, but all of the passengers had some kind of flying background. And the likelihood of both pilots being incapacitated is very unlikely.
BIG THANK YOU TO TFC KÄUFER for making this video possible
such as Lockheed Martin Prepar3D flight simulator, here a few more facts about the used simulation:
Scenery ORBX
A320 Flightsimlabs
Simulator Prepar3D v4.1
I hope you enjoyed this video and where able to learn something from it as well.
Thanks for watching, all the best your "Captain" Joe
Background track:
Stellardone - Airglow goo.gl/X3SffS
Outro Song:
Joakim Karud & Dyalla - Wish you were here goo.gl/kJ9pef
ALL COPYRIGHTS TO THIS VIDEO ARE OWNED BY FLYWITHCAPTAINJOE.COM ANY COPYING OR ILLEGALLY DOWNLOADING AND PUBLISHING ON OTHER PLATFORMS WILL FOLLOW LEGAL CONSEQUENCES
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 76 | คู่เอก "ผึ้งหลวง vs สมิงดำ"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9SBshmGQOIM/mqdefault.jpg)
Both pilots: *died*
Flight attendant: Are there any pilots on board?
seconds later
10 Microsoft flight simulator players fighting over who will fly the plane
Lol hehe
If they all corporate, the plane could safely land tho
@@artyyunden8351 yeah, probably. The one with most hours in flight sim will get the captain's seat
@@gildef21 yeah bro
This is literally the story of the movie "snakes on a plane".
*Flight Attendant:* The pilots are dead!!! Can anyone fly a plane!?/
*Passenger:* I will take the controls. I've been training my whole life for this...
*Flight Attendant:* Are you a pilot?
*Passenger:* No, but I play Microsoft Flight Simulator X. Now step aside.
Proceeds to do mach 4 with full flaps and goes to space*
Good one
@@pug2858 IFR is...foggy.
That would be me. At least I've landed a Boeing 747 using ILS in a monsoon so step aside
Make sure to tell ATC to look sharp 'cause you're about to butter the bread with this puppy.
This is so nerve wracking, even knowing it was done on a simulator. You pilots deserve all the praise for the complex work you do.
LET'S HEAR IT FOR THE PROGRAMMERS OF THE ILS AND THE AUTO-PILOT SYSTEMS !!!!!!!! YippEEEEE GUYS AND GALS !!
@@jonandersonmd7994 to turn on the auto pilot it self is hard you dumbo
Can a passenger land a plane?
Passenger lands a plane
Passenger: No, I don't think they could
What?
it's called honesty.
I think he meant a scenario in which she wasn't being guided, and she basically said she couldn't replicate it even though she had just done it. The autopilot, with detailed instructions, doesn't seem insurmountable. As Joe said, the hardest part for a non-pilot would simply be figuring out how to work the radios, find the correct frequency, and actually getting someone to guide you through all of these dozens of steps before something goes very, very wrong. I think if someone has some knowledge of comms, or at least knows the guard frequency is 121.5 (I know that and I'm not a pilot) and how to change the radio frequency (I'm familiar with marine radios, so that's a start) and press to confirm it, they might have a chance. But LOTS of things have to align in place for this to happen. Also, ATCs aren't necessarily pilots - nor would they be familiar with whatever random type of aircraft you're flying around in. They'd have to take time finding a pilot with the specific type rating to guide you through the steps even if you DID manage to raise ATC on the radio.
auto pilot landed the plane
@@VisibilityFoggy facts, aswell as they are stressed,
Notice how they edited out what he said right after saying it took her twenty minutes to establish communication----
"---by which time they would be crashed"...is probably what came after that.
If the cockpit has a USB port to connect my PS4 controller, I can land any plane under the sun.
Me too :d
If it's an Airbus, I almost wouldn't be surprised.
What game makes you think that? Ace Combat?
@@oneofmanyparadoxfans5447 Roblox
@@NieSpoceniLudzie You shouldn't have too hard of a time landing a small aircraft. Just, if you want to survive it, avoid the wake turbulence of larger aircraft.
Imagine instead of Captain Joe, the ATC guide voice was Gordon Ramsay. "Turn to right ya donkeyy"
Togi Mathews 😂😂
I laughed so hard 😂
i was just there
Lmfao
Click the lamb suose butten
wait a second i never entered any weather information and it still lands perfectly with ILS.....
Yeah, I was curious about that as well... Seems like extra nonsense to put on a passenger who would already be stressed out in that situation.
@@ravingfurryforlife It seems like that when the aircraft intercepted the localizer and glideslope from the ILS approach, the aircraft is able to maintain the glideslope and heading , and adjust them real time according to the effect the wind's acting on the aircraft
@@ravingfurryforlife disclaimer: i'm not sure how realistic is xplane and msfs2020 right now, but that's what i observed so far from the 2 simulators
Entry of QNH allows the pressurization system to optimize and temperature for performance calculations, wind for Vapp calculation.
@@MIO9_sh Most people say that xplane 11 has the best physics and msfs2020 has the best graphics and detail but msfs2020 might improve in physics with the directx 12 update coming soon and more updates. Also x plane 11 is better for lower end systems and there are more addons for it currently.
Joe: "Okay, Caroline, I need you now to press the approach mode button"
Caroline: "I don't know which one that is. Ahhh, *that* one!?" (pointing at panel with finger)
Joe: (silence)
Joe thinking to himself: "Dammit, you are not supposed to point at the panel! No video edits"
Caroline: (Realizing she f'd up) explains where the button is this time
I want someone to calmly give me instructions like this basically all day, every day.
If someone spoke so camly and give instrusctions like this lad, I can land it too
I need a new boss too.
If I had captain Joe as my flight instructor, I’d go to flight school from 5 am to 5 pm every day
^ i would go 5am to 5am
They've loaded that cockpit with SO many controls. In a stress situation, most people will just see a maze.
Despite it being a simulation I found myself being incredibly tense watching it.
Same 😂😂😂
Same
Ken May 69th like
OMG me too
Before I started watching these videos I thought being a pilot was a relatively easy job. Go sit in your chair, get the plane up in the air, relax for some hours and get the plane down safely again.
Now I know that everything is caught in procedures to maximize safety. Training for it is higher vocational school.
RyAn AiR Be Like:
oH LeTS MAke ThE PASsEngER FLy
I could feel the pressure by watching it. Imagine if it were real!!!
The plane go bye bye
Im certain i can bring it to the ground. If there would be survivors however...thats a different topic
☢ ƬƝƬƁOƳ-Ɗα-Ɓαωz ☢ Ah the old "They all get down somehow" joke, I bet no one heard that before on a flight related channel...
@@Noise-Bomb Ah the old joke dissector, you must be fun at parties
☢ ƬƝƬƁOƳ-Ɗα-Ɓαωz ☢ You bet I am. Also no hard feelings I just tried to be funny :)
The shade lmao
😂😂😂
I love how the pilot is quietly saying commands and the lady is like:
YEAH
They seem to know each other well, so he knows when she is sure or not. But in a comparable real life scenario I would expect ATC/instructor to ask for a more "CRM" type of response - like for example: "If you do something I asked you to do, could you please say that you did it and tell me what changed. I can't see what's on your screen."
This made me laugh out loud lol
A pilot is whispering . . .
I was repeating his commands once she carried them out. Proper response I guess. That was quite a simulation.
I was once a non-rated aircrew member on C-141B aircraft. DCC for a 2 star general from 21st AF.
@@QemeH roger; "gear down and locked - 3 green's". Flaps 3; "copy - flaps 3".
As an airline pilot myself, I DO think it’s possible. Especially in an airbus. I think the toughest part would be the communications issues you discussed at the end of the video. If the person in the cockpit can’t get a transmission out, then the controller doesn’t even know there’s a person there. They just assume the aircraft is NORDO. But if for some reason radio communications could be established, I think it could be done. I applaud your experiment, and your effort, but I don’t think that you were talking to her with the correct phraseology, and vocabulary that would be most effective and efficient in talking someone through that, with zero aviation experience. You were saying button when you were talking about a knob. You were asking her to find a panel by telling her it had numbers and buttons. That’s a bit unspecific, given the environment. For us, it’s a glare shield, but for the layman, it’d be a dash board. I would have told her, “the panel in the center, up on the dashboard.” Also, as pointed out by others, she doesn’t know what a localizer or an ILS is. So why are you overwhelming her even further with irrelevant acronyms and information? The list goes on, but you get the point. The airbus is extremely automated and quite user friendly. With enough fuel, delay vectors, a long final, and the right person talking them down, I think it’s very doable.
I'm not smart what does NORDO mean
@@RECHARGED77 An unresponsive aircraft by radio.
@@johnrocheleau9946 k
Some parts have been edited out like telling her where to locate important buttons, dials etc., seems like he explained some systems like the MCDU in more detail.
She is quite calm and capable,so to me nothing would be irrevelant, the more she knows the better she could deal with timings or anomalies.
John, I hope you can still answer this despite it being many months later but… assuming that for the moment the plane is okay because it has fuel and autopilot is keeping the plane steady and level, could a passenger get enough information from the cabin crew? Would they at least know the plane’s call sign or which frequencies to use? Would there be any kind of way to call an airport?
Otherwise as someone who knows very little about aviation I’d seriously consider getting my phone out and either googling to see if it would throw up any numbers that might actually get me through to an airport or dial the emergency number of whatever country I’m flying over, say 999 for the UK or 911 for the US and hope they can get some help before I either fly the behemoth into a mountain or run out of fuel. 🤔
Can you imagine, how difficult it must be, to explain something so complex, to someone who doesn‘t know a thing about airplanes over the radio, where you actually can‘t see a thing of what they are doing?
I think that‘s the real challenge here.
Great video!
I dont even know all the buttons on my Calculator bruh
@Chris H allegiant
hahaahahah
Same
@Chris H I mean jet blue is good but thank God you did not say southwest airlines
Hahhahahahhaa bruh
Now I got to know how my mom feels when I teach her how to take screenshot
I still dunno how to do that shit. And I'm 20.
@@cdogthehedgehog6923 On most phones it's pressing the power button and the volume down button at the same time.
@@huzzzer6083 🌹
Comment of the year hahahah
@@huzzzer6083 You just blew my mind
Q: Can a PASSENGER land a PLANE?
A: YES, if he has enough hours in Microsoft Flight Simulator.
A: YES, if they have 69000 hours in xplane 10
MFS is a game, not a simulator.
@@norbert.kiszka ok
@@norbert.kiszka yeah, because regular people play professional simulators instead, derp... OFC it's fucking game, lol
I mean you have higher chance
After 55 hours in Flight Simulator 2020, I can land a A320neo without any assistance. :)
My grandfather flew 4 days of the week on a 747-200B for 35 years I think he could do it, assuming it was Boeing, or Lockheed,
A320neo is a very easy aircraft to learn, I think for a aviation enthusiast
@@freddielo4330 yeah it has so much autopilot if you know how to work autopilot you’ll be fine then you can just Ryanair land
Congrats!
@@wyattwilliams2457 My grandfather could not even turn on the PC to run Flight Simulator.
She now works for Ryan air.
Haha, well meme'ed
And now she's on strike.
deanmoncaster pahahhahha
deanmoncaster yep! That’s why I do not fly with them.
LOL ! :)
”Tell us something about yourself”. ”Well, im deffienetly not a pilot” ”okay lets do it”
YOU'RE HIRED
She knew all the instruments she was just not a beginner her movement was too fast to be just a newbie
I was so confused when I first watched this video but after I taught myself the basics of an a320 and I understood everything, thanks to captain joe!
His soothing voice make me think he’s pissed but still managing to stay calm
he DOES have a calm voice
Passenger: “the pilots are dead, alright how do I land the plane?”
Control: “When you crash, just try to avoid hitting anyone else on the ground too, over.”
they better be waiting me with bunny girls in ground too, at least my ghost can move on on a high note.
Brilliant. lmao
😂
@@TimBrownSenorCafe isnt that easy in real life
Osazua Ebibon could be, get those steps written down and memorised, even practiced before going into landing. Find the nearest flat 100km^2 surface and go for it. If lucky you might only kill half the passangers.
10:06 _"You have now intercepted the ILS and glideslope and you're established on the localizer"_
What she heard: "
ଆପଣ ବର୍ତ୍ତମାନ ଆଇଏଲ୍ଏସ୍ ଏବଂ ଗ୍ଲାଇଡସ୍ଲୋପ୍କୁ ଅଟକାଇଛନ୍ତି ଏବଂ ଆପଣ ଲୋକାଲାଇଜର୍ରେ ପ୍ରତିଷ୍ଠିତ ହୋଇଛନ୍ତି |"
Odia re kahi lekhi cha
Lol
No
@@dgamorshd8209 It’s a joke dude
@@Speed_IOT i don’t remember questioned you
Pilots have the most calming voices. Especially when announcing the altitude to passengers. 😍
I'd do anything he asked me to in that calming + soothing voice! Kelsey teaching Stella to fly was impressive. He remained stoic + patient, + his exceptional ability to remain focused shows why he's so successful. It's perhaps his best asset as a pilot.
@@concierge7574 kelsey and stella?
She just did it and them claims she can’t?!?
I think the point was that they cut out most the learning/searching for the right buttons. I still think it’s possible just not with her.
welcome to women
@@Jeeper1378 I’m convinced I could do it. I could be wrong.
th-cam.com/video/cX-qbte6Mcs/w-d-xo.html
@@mad1337nes The last thing you need is an emotional breakdown before your first solo flight.
Crew: Can anyone fly a plane?
Me: of course (pulls up this video over the plane wifi)
And asks flight attendant to serve drinks and food to other passengers..
"Ladies and gentlemen, this is yo boi BeastMaster69 speaking. I will be taking over as the captain so please remain calm and enjoy your last champagne. Don't worry, it's on me."
Too bad the free wifi bandwidth is divided by the 350 passengers on board watching The Bachelor
@Bappo_The_Great oh, they might take chances with you, dont lift your finger unless you are absolutely sure. ;)
Squawk 7500 for a free airshow.
Ok now she can join RyanAir
She's Ryanair approved
INFERNAL CARD Yeah, she’s now with us
XD 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣👍🏻
Have pilot then why she did instead?
😂😂😂
INFERNAL CARD lmao
When Microsoft flight simulator has better graphics then a real training simulator
of course
So Carolin, we've just watched you land the plane successfully.
Yes.
Do you think you could land the plane?
No.
She couldn't have landed it without help.
@@OortCloud Yeah obviously. No one can tie their shoe laces until they're first showed how.
@@Jon-1919 then how did the first person do this
I really appreciate his super calm voice and directions. Wish this guy had been my instructor.
But I think he should be more specific in giving instructions/directions like where the buttons are. He's saying " Do you see the screen with buttons around it?" Like there's so many screens with buttons!! hahahahah
Actually, one of the reason she finds it so hard was that he wasn't good at all. First, when you start, you should always define a point of reference that SHE can identify quickly. ''Karen, i am gonna ask you to divide the controls you see in four row. The first one is right under the WINDOWS, and start with a button that say 'VLS'. do you see that?' 'ok, the second one is our blue tv screen right underneath that row, do you see that?' 'ok, now the third one contains....' and so on. Second, he should never use jumba-gumba abreviation she have no clue about unless he call the position of it first! You don't say something like 'now i am gonna ask you to turn the rlstr to the right until it says dtrcr...' But rather you say 'to the right of the blue screen, on our second row, there is a button that says 'rlstr'. Find that one.' and so on...
Second, he talks too softly, to the point it was annoying to her i think.
That's my honest opinion.
@@jessikapiche6097 I agree
His voice is so soothing
ASMR before it was cool
Anybody can land a plane. The key is to survive the landing.
Hahha i remember that scene in Madagascar
dude it's hard if u aint a pilot. cause the plane has too many buttons. how on earth should you know all of em.
@@btube4234 it's not that hard to know the switches, modern planes are pretty easy to fly.
@@Yasser-mf9nb yeah, yeah, you must be a genious or something.
I can land it but every one will be dead
Flight attendant: can anyone fly this plane becoz both pilots are dead..
“And me searching for this video in youtube at the moment”😥😥😥
She landed it, so yeah, despite the conclusion at the end.
God help us if Ryanair CEO Michael O'Leary sees this! He'd happily have passengers fly the plane if it meant saving money by getting rid of the pilots 🤣
You still have to weigh it against the cost of losing an aircraft. They're still very expensive things even if you don't give a crap about the passengers. Yes I know you're being funny.
Use your illusion man:)
fba90130 well does he have that? Many big companies doesn't care about people only about making money.
@@Raap123 Not sure what you mean by "that". Aircraft? Getting passengers to fly planes mean losing planes. I don't think you save any money this way.
fba90130 What I mean that are companies who think that you can save money by working whit cheap employees you can make fast money. It's also happening in the European transport market while a Dutch or Belgium driver are to expensive for driving a truck on long distances use a cheaper driver from as example Poland when that driver is also to expensive get rid of him and use one from Bulgaria or Ukraine. And yes they do literally use farmers from that countries who can't even handle a truck. And the Ryanair CEO use the same business called 'free market' so yes it's considered as a joke but there is a point in the comment.
At about 10:30 I realized it's fake, because the landing gear always gets stuck in the movies.
She would have had to open a hatch in the toilet and crawl down through a series of tunnels in the plane. Foiling and knocking out a terrorist that was sabotaging the plane. And then right before the plane touches down. She finds the crank and just in time moves the landing gear down.
Only after saving a puppy that is almost crushed by loose baggage and dismantling a bomb set to explode by the terrorists.
ROFL! And as film critic Roger Ebert said, they always cut the blue wire...
LMAO
Good to point out those attempts at fooling us, the basturds. And final tipoff: no flaming gasoline simulating bomb explosions. Hollywood!
"You have used one inch of sticky tape, God Bless You". "Aargh! What am I doing on the fecking wheel?"
Yeah! And where's that bit with the BJs when she finds all the tyres are deflated, then gets flashbacks to when all the pilots said they loved her...
I think Captain Joe forgot one most important instruction:
"Caroline, breeeathe!"
Yep, in an emergency situation, you have to remember to stay calm and breathe. The brain works better relaxed.
What a fantastic video. It's awesome to see all the steps required even when things are in perfect conditions, the cognitive load on pilots must be insane when things are going wrong!
That's the overall lesson I've gathered. The volume of traffic in the skies, the adverse weather, I'd rather not BE a passenger. Because it wouldn't be better for me waiting to see if we crash or run of the end of the runway.
Tell us a little something about yourself.
"I'm definitely not a pilot"
Thank you for that detailed family history.
FloxyLak Get a life
FloxyLak Now it's 270 likes and 2 replies. Thanks for the help ;)
Touche
touché
lmao
Ryanair: you're hired, graded up to captain, immediate effect. congratulations!
One week later: Captain's on strike.
2 weeks later
Atc: where did you let your tail?
Pilot: somewhere on the runway landing was ryanair style
Atc: quiting job in 3 2 1
3 weeks later: You will now fly the 737 MAX 8 there are no differences.
4 weeks later: Tragic plane crash in Birmingham airport
lmao
Lol
Now add the stress panic and shouting instability, snakes on a plane. The voice is so soothing. In normal abnormal conditions all that would go over person’s head😵💫
Sure, a passenger can land a plane.
It depends on what kind of outcome you fancy.
0 deaths, 20% deaths, 100% deaths.
Sure a passenger can land a plane. All they need is a fully qualified pilot sitting behind them telling them which buttons to push.
Air Traffic Control would probably fill that role. Thats why he didn't confirm whenever she just said "this button?" because ATC wouldn't be able to see like he could.
@@dankyskins4452 Air traffic controllers are not pilots. As a former FAA air traffic controller, I would be saying "does any one know how to land an airbus?" to everyone on the control room floor. Because I certainly would not be able to "talk you down".
@@aaronsnitzer2596 okay that makes sense. I wonder if there is a team that is dedicated to handling these situations then
@@dankyskins4452 To the best of my knowledge, no there is not. There happen to be some controllers that are also pilots on the side, usually just as a hobby, but sometimes they are former professional pilots. That would be the best bet in an emergency situation. But if that particular controller is not at work that day, I have no idea what we would do.
@@aaronsnitzer2596 there should be fully trained pilots in on-call service for these situations, as unlikely as they might be.
I'm a truck driver but I'm sure I could land a plane.
Not so sure if anyone would survive .
Euro Truck Simulator is tons of fun, I hope it's the same in real life
Silvio Deassis yeah me too lol
Hahhaha
:-D yeah, me too. with a descent rate of a falling stone but I'd most likely get it down. :-D
Silvio Deassis lol
I like how the airplane has "Aviate, Navigate, Communicate" written on it
Yes it is, a man named Darren Harrison just did it. Absolute zero flying experience, man is a legend
Captain Joe speaking softly gives out some ASMR.
i was just thinking that lmao
_Plane: _*_BOOOM_*
Same. But her mic ruins it. SHe's too loud
Control tower: can you see the red button?
Lady: yes, pressed
Control tower: you shouldn't
NOW DIE!!!
This scene is from dhamaal movie bruh
@@rushilllll yea
Bomb tech: Cut the blue wire
Bomb Defuser: Done!
Bomb tech: BUT FIRST....cut the red wire!!!!!
Nahi Dabana thaa.
LOL!
I saw a documentary on building the Boeing 777. They said the 777 is so sophisticated, it only takes a pilot, and a dog, to fly it. The pilot - to feed the dog; and the dog - to bite the pilot if he tries to touch the controls. Those 2 bicycle shop mechanics designed and flew the first airplane would be proud !
Me to the ATC : I can do it just tell me where them W, A, S, D, at.
ohhh hahahahahaha
I think in a calm situation the right passenger could land a plane, especially with your voice guiding them. Your voice is very calming and reassuring.
That has happened. I'm not aware of any passenger landing big commercial jets but it has been done with smaller private planes when pilot had medical problems/lost consciousness. With ATC assistance, mind you.
@@stoutlager6325 link
Tatu Laaksonen I get the feeling my husband could the reason I say this in 30years I’ve never seen him panic even after teaching 1500 school kids in every situation imaginable brought some back from ski trips with injured ankles though etc etc . He absorbs the most complex stuff before I’ve started thinking of it so if Air Traffic Control were talking to him he could do it I’m sure
@@elaineblackhurst1509 it is nice to hear that a woman has such trust on her man.
@@Jana-en1ye He's cheating on her.
Landing an airliner: ASMR edition
@No One Yep i gotta second that
Captain real life scenerio will be totally different give the passenger some tough mental situations and then have a try... And am sure if you are giving the instruction anyone can land a plane... You are just amazing Captain...
OMG Joe: your voice is so CALM. You should use your voice to make peace in the middle east on the behalf of U.N
ASMR joe
Joe: Shows how a passenger lands an aircraft.
Also Joe: Concludes that a passenger can't land an aircraft.
Indeed confusing?
But I think the question is could a passenger land an aircraft without a Captain sitting behind them.
@@chrizizdaman it is possible if they send a experienced pilot to the airport tower to connect with you on the radio.
There is a story on TH-cam called "Mayday the passenger who landed a plane.
It's a small Cesna plane where the pilot passed out on a heart attack and the one passenger next to him had absolute no flight experience but he managed to put the plane down safely without a automatic landing system just by voice guidance from the tower.
So technically i think it would be possible to land an passenger plane with a automatic landing system as long as you keep your cool.
@@chrizizdaman
In that case they should have tested it without a pilot sitting behind her. I mean the way they did it was pretty much designed as the case where a passenger is guided per radio over the tower. However, it could be a pretty hard task figuring out how this communication system works. If the tower can speak to the pilot without him pushing a button they could in this case continously tell whats to do in order to speak back. I'm not sure about this point but in any case the conclusion doesn't fit the video very well.
D woodkamp I am not saying it’s impossible I just think it’s very unlikely. If they were to make communication with ATC and be connected to someone, this person would have to have knowledge of the exact plane the passenger is piloting. I just think there are a lot of variables that could happen in a real world scenario to make it quite challenging. Such as communication, operation of the airplanes controls, and even outside factors such as weather. Plus it would be a very stressful situation so the person would have to be very good under pressure. Most airplanes now communicate with the airports computer systems and are guided in for the most part so it’s definitely plausible.
Lands plane.
"It's impossible to land a plane"
@Shaxx And if there were such an emergency that a passenger needed to land the plane, they were be.... Guided!
ATC would talk you in or get an expert to do it
It is not a real plane. It is a simulation.
@@MrError3000YT yup
Too easy
This is so much fun! I was holding my breath as it unfolded. As a newbie in MSFS, I also learned quite a lot about what all buttons do. Thanks!
Capt. Joe's voice was mesmerizing. He's exceptional at explaining things clearly + his accent is fine!
Got our answer today... Air traffic controller guides passenger to safe landing at PBIA after pilot has medical emergency
WEST PALM BEACH, Fla. -
An air traffic controller successfully guided a passenger on a private plane to land safely at Palm Beach International Airport after the pilot was incoherent during the flight Tuesday.
Updated: 6:35 PM EDT May 10, 2022
That was a Cessna plane, that has like 3 buttons to push.
i need this pilot to talk me through my first date
Extend flaps
Loool
Instructions unclear...penis in garbage disposal.
He'd be a good wingman am I right?
Landing gear pulled out too soon.
Caroline is very calm because she knows she in inside a sim, plus the instructions from CPT. JOE is very relaxed and makes anyone follow without fear. Hopefully a situation no one will need.
Good instructor.
Auday Sami need to be someone who is not afraid of dying, that have nothing to lose, cause in a situation like that, you don't have anything to lose. Needs to be someone with this wisdom
+Jose Marques
It is much less scary when you are in control yourself than when you are sitting in the passenger cabin and know that pilot has no clue how to fly.
Yeah fake as fuck but interesting. It's nice thinking air traffic control knows how to coach an unthinkable situation. Thank god foe the FAA & AF.
also, he could see what she was doing, that's not the case when you sit in the tower
I am not afraid of dying and will follow without fear just as long as Cpt Joe is giving the instructions.
-No, a passenger could not land a plane.
-Me after spending hours flying on videogames: stalls the plane and crashes instead of leaving it to the autopilot.
As a former USAF C-5 crew chief, if I had help from an ATC that was as smooth Capt. Joe, I think it would be reasonable possible in gokd weather. Those flight panels and controls were so much easier to navigate than the C-5's old analog indicators. I got out before the C-5M program, so I don't know what the new flight controls look like.
joe: *quietly and peacefully whispering commands"
caroline: *YES*
I'd turn around, get up and deck him after about 5 minutes of that whispering. F***!
I drove a ship in 2016! That was cool!
Jake Domanski I know I love how joe was all nice and calm and carolyn is like YES I HAVE THAT.
99% sure Joe’s hearing got damaged by this.
bobwatters I disagree the soothing voice was the main reason I watched the video
bobwatters his voice is so soothing and sexy lol
So I would say yes, a passenger can land the plane if they can establish communications with someone who knows how to land the plane very well. If not, then they are screwed.
That would be pretty interesting
@bobwatters The situation HAS happend, but not with an airliner. There is a BBC documentation about a passenger landing a small four-seater, which is arguably more difficult as you don't have all the autopilot assistance. And he did it at night with the dead pilot (heart attack) to his side after hours of failed attempts without any knowledge or control over cockpit lights, flaps, trim, etc... In the documentary (search for "Mayday - The passenger who landed a plane") he is complimented not only on his flying skills but also on his airmanship as throughout the nightmare he constantly displays regard for others (like wanting to fly away from towns as to not kill others when he crashes) by the crew of the onlooking air force SAR helicopter they called to "assist" (aka pick up the pieces, they were sure) him. Oh, did I mention that he was 77 at the time and had been flying (as a passenger in a tiny aircraft) for hours before it even began? The dude is a LEGEND.
AND they are sitting in a flight simulator. But, probably not!!!
Exactly. Also, it's only assuming that nothing untoward happens, such as an emergency or anything that requires manual flight of the plane or advanced technical knowledge; otherwise, they are screwed then too! LOL
Can you do it on panic?
Lady lanes plane perfectly, "is it possible for a passenger to land a plane?" Absolutely not. Hmm then what did i just watch.
The pilot voice made me feel to sleep😍🥱🤤
My Scoutmaster used to be a Navy pilot, and this is what he told us when we were doing the aviation MB:
A bad landing is when you crash the plane.
A good landing is when you can walk away from the plane.
A great landing is when you can walk away and use the plane again.
Pendronator absolutely end of story
good logic
Hmmm... My brother always said:
Take-off is tricky.
Flying is like driving with occasional wet roads.
Landing is the easiest; it's walking away from it where it gets hard.
You cannot simulate the stress in a real situation, that would be way different.
Bingo!
This reminds me of Sully
The fact that if you were to crash the plane in simulation mode.....nothing happens just a boom, and you don't die. Real life is definitely way stressful
That could work both ways, I get extremely sharpened in a LoD situation while someone else would turn into limbo mode.
Just watched one documentary of an older gent landing a smaller airplane after his pilot friend succumbed to a heart attack mid air.
I'd prefer a flight-sim pilot to go for it rather than a complete novice though, 100%. They are often aware of terminology and even some of the instruments and physics.
That’s why she said it cannot be done
This was kinda nerve-wracking... And totally awesome!
Very cute reply at 5:04 "thingie"
Never fear ladies and gentleman if in the event of an emergency and the pilot falls unconscious or dies while we are up in the air...i am TH-cam qualified now to land this plane! 😁
Happy & Polka Dots so true!
Lmao
Happy & Polka Dots u meant "land this plane" in oblivion right?
Happy & Polka Dots I fly RC, so I would have you as my co-pilot lol
Me too
Captain Joe's soothing ATC voice is weirdly hypnotic...
Captain Joe does ASMR pilot instructor roleplay to help you sleep.
The plane crashed when the passenger fell asleep on the cloche due to that soothing voice xD
should be included in GPS voicepacks. "at the nex corner , turn right.."
Turn left. Turn left
Oh, my! What a handsome captain! 😍
All those experiments show, first of all, how skilled ATC controllers (or pilots guiding) are who know every knob setting by heart.
Well if my instructor is as cool as Joe, then I will perform barrel roll with a 747 in first shot.
@@Brad-il9mw tell that to the skyking
@@TheElement255 Lmao hell yea bruh, he was a motherfucking legend! Poor guy, r.i.p.
Hector Domino erm probably not you will plummet into the ground
Bradley David or just ruin the fucking joke
@@Brad-il9mw woosh
you have such a calming voice you could talk a cat out of a tree
its on purpose, she ONLY may hear him through the headset.
that's what i thought!
Haha :)
Calm is what that passenger-now-PIC needs to make it through. I'd find the good Captain's voice extremely reassuring.
Wade Hutchinson LOL i agree 🤣
15:30 With all much do respect, I believe it is possible if you had a moderate to seasoned flight attendant to establish or instruct how to use the radio. Without a radio, learning without a trained controller would take a lot of time. I think a key aspect would be the passenger trainee correctly following readback procedures and confirming before touching buttons or knobs. Also turning heading, speed, and alt knobs gently.
Without ILS or with a hydraulic failure, AP Failure, antenna damage, radar loss, or malfunctioning flight controls the odds are so very slim, but never impossible.
This was great. Seeing Carolyn land the plane helped me see what the pilots need to do to accomplish landing.
Joe: "Set flaps to1"
Caroline: *sets flaps to 1*
Real passenger: "Wtf is flaps!?"
Well most people probably know what it means
It doesn't matter, you don't need to know what flaps are. All you would need to know is where to find the button/lever labeled "flaps" and move it to the "1" position when told. It isn't a course on flight theory, it is a pilot basically telling you what to do and you are his hands and feet.
Me: flaps are what saves your life YOU goddamn
There was a 10 minute timelapse clearly labled with the things he showed her - one of those was the flaps lever.
I'm sure it went somthing like this: "Do you see the lever labled FLAPS? It should be at the 0 position now and has positions 1,2,3 and FULL as well. If I say to change the flaps, you pull the lever up and towards you until it is in the right position and then let go to snap it in. Do you think you got that or should we practice with flaps one?"
I know what flaps are but I have no idea how tf to adjust them
I'm amazed by the degree of automation. Assuming you have a passenger that is calm under pressure and can get on coms with ATC, I'd imagine this would be doable.
Definitely. However, he mentioned at the end it took 20 minutes to get her to push the correct button to establish two-way comms. So she was lost in the sauce for 20 minutes just trying to figure out how to get a conversation going with ATC. 20 minutes is a long time. That being said, if a passenger could get comms up in the first 2-5 minutes AND the plane had plenty of altitude, it's not actually a very dangerous situation.
Yes I think so, there where even some cases where a passenger was guided by ATC to land a little cessna, after the pilot died/ got ill. But I am still happy there are 2 pilots in a cockpit of a airline!!
I gotta believe it's rare that someone could suss out the coms without inadvertently hitting the wrong buttons.
As I said, there where some cases where some landet little planes after pilot passed out...
call from your cell phone 911 and explain it to them they can like... patch you through to ATC or something
Captain Joe: Talks various numerical values
Caroline: That's too many numbers for one day
It has been proven many many times over and over that a passenger with no flying experience can land a plane. In May 2022, Robert Morgan, a passenger with no flying experience landed a plane after a pilot medical emergency where the pilot became unconscious. This sort of situation has been happening before and after this TH-cam video was made. However, in the past when a passenger landed a plane it did not get the recognition it deserved in the news media.
I bet you I could land a plane. There might not be any survivors but you can't have everything.
😂😂
thats the same as parking a car..... in the river :|
MOTO-079 Sully is that you?!?!
u mean landing or crashing the plane?
@@goa5373 No, he means, a perfectly controlled flight in to the ground! Ladies and gentlemen I hope you have enjoyed the flight......................bang!
"Roger, Roger."
"We need clearance, Clarence."
"What's our vector, Victor?"
S. Mac what
@@texerie: Ok then, in your case, "What's our vector, Vector?"
@@SMac-bq8sk yes
"And don't call me Shirley!"
Do you like gladiator movies?
I think the “passenger” should’ve done it all by herself to make it more realistic
That’s Captain Joe’s sister !
You guys look the same.
Random passenger: the captain is death can somebody safe us
Random 12 year old kid that has 20 hours in a C172: I’ve got this
Better than nothing! :ddd
I can tell you there will be many of those out there.
That’d be me for real tho lol
I as a passenger would suddenly become a praying mantis
Jk
I , a ten year old - ummmm. Don't you guys know to call mayday
I don’t even know what all the buttons on my car do😂😂😂😂
car? not even my cellphone!
😭😂😂
kykingz78 you should probably not be giving crappy attitude
kykingz78 bawbag
😂😂😂😂
I'm not a pilot, but the very first thing I would think you'd need to do is learn how to use the radio and make sure it's on the right frequency so that you can communicate with ATC, which I believe is 121.500. Put on the headset, then learn how to transmit and receive so that they can hear you, you can hear them, and that you're not talking over them. If you don't have at least this working, you'll have no link for people to tell you what to do.
I would not say its not possible. With AP, someone giving good instructions, it’s possible with the right person.
Hold my fucking beer...
LeRoy Jenkins Oh.. shit
hahahahaha I literally jumped of laughter after reading your comment xD
Hold my chicken and ... LEEROOOOOOOOOOOOOY JENKINS!!
Let's do this
LEEEROOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOYYYYY
JEEEEEEEEENKIIIIIINS
This made me appreciate how efficient pilots are at communicating with the tower. Paragraphs' worth of information in a sentence, with repeating back for confirmation instead of "Yesss....?". it's quite an amazing system
Landing a commercial plane 💯 Landing a Military plane 🎂
Brilliant Joe!!!
Just finished *GTA San Andreas flight school,* 'guess this should work just fine.
did you take in the music at the very end during the landing is from GTA xD
😂😂😂😂😂 San Andreas missions were lit!
hahahahahahahaha can't stop laughing xD your comment deserves more likes dude!
Jorin Walker
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 come on .. i know you are Trevor mom hiding there
Actually, you can't learn to land a real plane just by playing video games. Sorry for being too smart and therefore ruining your expectations.
flight simmer's wet dream
I know!
yeah, and I think there will be always at least one on board nowadays.
+Roelof Hetsen
To land a real plane - yes, that's just a dream. To do what she did - just go for it, if you have the money to spend. I'm pretty sure that your closest pilot learning center will happily give you the chance for a mere 200-300eur, just like they do in my home town.
Flight summer: *gets on the plane* “I hope both pilots and all others with a pilots license dies so I can land this plane”
United Airlines: “call the cops”
*’I learnt how to fly an a320 in under 15 minutes’💀💀💀🤣🤣🤣*
Something just beeped. I love this lady.