Why Samurai Hardly Used the Katana
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 31 ธ.ค. 2021
- ▼Learn more about this topic▼
How Samurai Trained Physically & Mentally Through Katana Training and Zen Meditation
• Experience How Samurai...
*The content is based on personal studies and experience
There is no intention of denying other theories and cultural aspects
When you imagine a samurai fighting, wouldn’t he be using a katana? However in the past when they actually existed, it was a weapon that they actually hardly used.
During the war eras, the samurai would mainly fight with long range weapons like bows, guns, and spears (including naginata) which were most effective on the battlefield.
In iaido (the katana martial art), we are taught that “a battle with a katana is done within a tatami mat distance (182cm/71in).” So you can understand how close you have to be in order to attack your opponent with a katana, and it would be very strange/unusual to try to use a short range weapon on the battlefield.
Every samurai would carry a katana with them, but it was the last weapon they would use only in extremely close combat or for defensive reasons. In other words, if you are using a sword, it means that you are in a very desperate situation and have no other choice.
During the peaceful Edo period (1603-1868) with no wars, the samurai were always required to always have two katana (one long and one short) by law, as a symbol of their class authority.
However, they would hardly have any occasions to use them either, because if you didn’t have a good reason and an eye witness to prove its legitimacy, even just showing your blade in public could get you thrown in jail or sentenced to death. So the samurai were taught… “If you're not prepared to die, don't pull out your katana."
▼Who is Shogo? What is this channel about?▼
• Shogo’s Self Introduct...
▼Related videos in this channel▼
-How Samurai Trained Physically & Mentally Through Katana Training and Zen Meditation
• Experience How Samurai...
-Transform into the Warlord of Your Dreams! Where You Can Wear SAMURAI ARMOR Used in Movies/TV Dramas
• Where You Can Experien...
-How Difficult is it to Swing a Katana in Samurai Armor?
• Chopping Up Mats with ...
▼MY DREAM▼
• The "TRUE REASON" why ...
“To make every Japan lovers’ dream come true, by making Japan a more secure, comfortable, and safer place for everyone to visit, study, and live in”
I will be using the profit I gain from this channel at restaurants, hotels, and cultural facilities in Kyoto to introduce them. The more you watch the videos on this channel, Kyoto and Japan will become a more exciting place, and you can support your own and others’ dreams in the future even more.
▼Join our Membership▼
/ @letsaskshogo
●Membership benefits
-Limited behind-the-scene videos
• Members-only videos
-Weekly live stream
-Priority reply to comments
Every single yen we earn from this membership, we will be donating to groups of people who are fighting to solve social problems in Japan, the Japanese schools where foreign students can study, or use it to spread the works of people working with traditional culture in Japan to preserve the arts they are doing.
▼[Sub-channel] “Shogo’s Podcast”▼
/ @shogospodcast
Please subscribe!!
The perfect channel to learn about Japanese culture and history in your spare time, during your walk to school or work, and when you are cooking or doing house chores.
Not only will I be covering the topics in this main channel, but also some topics that you will only be able to enjoy in the sub-channel, like answering questions I receive, and my opinions towards some of the comments.
▼[Listen to the real voices of the Japanese] "Voices from Japan series"▼
• [Shogo] Japanese Tradi...
▼[Places recommended to visit in Kyoto] "Kyoto Hidden Gems" series▼
• Playlist
▼Instagram▼
/ lets_ask_shogo
*Please ask me questions through the DM here!（⚠️I do not use e-mail）
♪Music♪
おとわび
otowabi.com/ca...
トーマス大森音楽工房
/ @fm_thomasoomori
ぽるぽるMusic
/ @music-qx3gy
♪Sound effects♪
効果音ラボ
soundeffect-la...
♪Pictures♪
かわいいフリー素材屋 いらすとや
www.irasutoya....
#katana #samurai #japanesehistory - บันเทิง
▼Learn more about this topic▼
How Samurai Trained Physically & Mentally Through Katana Training and Zen Meditation
th-cam.com/video/3C42TUaUQDs/w-d-xo.html
*The content is based on personal studies and experience
There is no intention of denying other theories and cultural aspects
When you imagine a samurai fighting, wouldn’t he be using a katana? However in the past when they actually existed, it was a weapon that they actually hardly used.
During the war eras, the samurai would mainly fight with long range weapons like bows, guns, and spears (including naginata) which were most effective on the battlefield.
In iaido (the katana martial art), we are taught that “a battle with a katana is done within a tatami mat distance (182cm/71in).” So you can understand how close you have to be in order to attack your opponent with a katana, and it would be very strange/unusual to try to use a short range weapon on the battlefield.
Every samurai would carry a katana with them, but it was the last weapon they would use only in extremely close combat or for defensive reasons. In other words, if you are using a sword, it means that you are in a very desperate situation and have no other choice.
During the peaceful Edo period (1603-1868) with no wars, the samurai were always required to always have two katana (one long and one short) by law, as a symbol of their class authority.
However, they would hardly have any occasions to use them either, because if you didn’t have a good reason and an eye witness to prove its legitimacy, even just showing your blade in public could get you thrown in jail or sentenced to death. So the samurai were taught… “If you're not prepared to die, don't pull out your katana."
Hey listen to me is it true that the samurai were always the best warriors in history but what’s the point what makes Japan its greatest value
Why do you write your script in comments? We can see the video y'know?
@@shreddedbagelwabiwabo8342 it's for blind people
@@waterbottlefilms6563
Blind people can hear the video tho (?)
@@shreddedbagelwabiwabo8342 deaf people maybe?
“Remember switching to your katana is faster than reloading”
-Samurai probably
The fact that it is true
Switching to your santo is faster than reloading your katana.
What does katana mean?
@@roberth4395 I think it just means sword, but in English it's that specific type
@@roberth4395it means Japanese sword
Imagine spending years training in the way of the sword to kill the samurai who killed your father, countless hours of pain and misery to become a demon with the blade, you approach the man and he pulls out a pistol and kills you
demon slayer be like
@@raiden7194 Genya be like: 😈🤝
well… then again… this is real life and not an anime
"skill issue"
Katana is crap. It's a light sword. Bigger, heavier in battle wins the day. Artillery is called the KING of battle for a reason.
Heavier weapons run the battlefield.
Elephants are the true king of the jungle not lions. Lions just look the part.
Basically the katana is the same as the combat knife for the soldiers in the military, to be reduced to using it means you're neck-deep in trouble.
More likely a pistol, a secondary weapon which is a sword is to samurai & knight.
@Hedonist Heathen remember, switching to your sword is faster than finding a new spear.
@@TriforceOfTheGods80 And even that is not a perfect comparison because situation where your sidearm was more usefull than your main weapon were more common back in the day.
Saying that sword were just secondary weapons often massively undersell their use on the battlefield. I am not expert in Japanese warfare, but I watched quite a bit of documentary about the late middle age and the renaissance era of europe.
And paradoxally when pikemen became the main type of infantry, sword had bit of a renaissance. Pike were great battlefield weapons but were quite unwieldy, and if melee became too close quarter like during a push of pike they were basically useless.
It is for that reasons that every pikemen had a swords and pike formation often also fielded soldier with shorter weapons like the famous spanish rodelero that used sword and buckler, the english billmen, the swiss halberdier or the famous german doppelsnoder which wielded haberd and zweihander.
Shorter weapons were also used to exploit a gap in a pike formation.
Though as time progressed and pike were no longer used offensively and push of pike were rarer those type of troop were graduall fazed out for more pikemen.
Sword were also often used as the main weapon outside of battlefield, when you were not in formation like during a skirmish or during a siege while climbing a wall or fighting inside a building the sword would be often the only weapon used.
I am ready to bet Katana were used similarly by japanese.
@@benjaminparent4115heres a very simple rundown
Your m1 garand (primary) if common use for mid range conflicts on the battlefirled
Your pistol would be if soneone got up on you and your clip was empty
Your knife is when someone has you physically grabbed (most likely choking) OR you have no ammo left at all
Knife is the last resort. Pistol and Rifle would just be so you are prepared for different scenarios. The knife is what you use in desperate times.
Or the longsword for late medieval knights, who used their longswords as ornament or as a sidearm, their main weapon usually being a mace or poleaxe
The same applies to most societies in history. The weapon of choice for the battlefield was almost always a spear or a kind of polearm along with ranged weapons. The reason is quite simple: if you can outrange your opponent, you can't be harmed.
Until the patch that added damage fall off for spears and bows and the katana rush meta took over for like 3 seasons until it was reverted
Exactly. Combat is all about poking holes in the enemy while keeping yourself from being poked. The further away you are, the better. Nowadays we have weapons that can poke thousands of holes at once from hundreds of km away.
"If you're not prepared to die don't pull out your katana"
That's have a deep meaning, thank you!
This should be taught to people who buy guns. Seeing as so many people don't get that guns are super deadly.
I Think thats a reference from the five Rings
I got goosebumps
@@evanbeers1644 Well in most places in the world that is a standard law. Just dont see it as a reason against sporting purpose, totally fine imo
@@evanbeers1644 it is taught to people who buy guns, it’s just that only the irresponsible people are the ones you see on the news.
Vast majority of gun owners are safe with their weapon. In fact, the most safe person to have a gun is someone who knows how and when to use it.
"If you're not prepared to die don't pull out your katana" has almost as much energy as lelouch saying
"The only ones who should kill are the ones who are prepared to be killed "
Ah, I see you're a man of culture as well.
@@romanshorif2330 where is that from?
@@mihailmilev9909 Code Geass
Protagonist: Lelouch
The quote is from Lelouch
The anime is a masterpiece.
“Live by the sword, die by the sword”
I'm tryna get met friend into anime and we're making our way thru the anime rn
"if you're not prepared to die don't pull your katana" Is such a raw phrase
Nothing looks cooler than a Samurai or Knight in full armor using firearms. That mix of old and new is complete eye candy.
Now you just made me imagine a samurai with an AR 😂
@SonicChao113 they actually make modern Samurai body armor there's this Japanese gal on TH-cam that trains in it with an AR15
It's funny to see anime protagonists boast about their katana skills now that we know that they actually mean "I could not use a bow or gun to save my life".
Yeah Also
Samurai the second they were introduced to guns: LMG MOUNTED, AND LOADED
Anime protagonists usually don't fight as part of a formation in a large scale battle. As a duelling and personal defence weapon a katana (or swords in general) is excellent due to its versatility. But on the battlefield other weapons are more effective.
@@ishashka spears are much more ubiquitous, as historically shown, so it stands to reason more accurate depictions would have them using said primary weapons before a more defensive and secondary weapon like the katana.
Because anime protagonist is stronger than real human.
@@BeeBait spears are only great for battle formations tho
Real Samurai: Jousting archers
Anime Samurai: I can slice planets in half.
+Ground-shaking Sound effect
+color trail
+Epic slowmo effect
+delayed effect of damage
@@loser4182 +character sheathing their katana slowly
"Don't pull out your katana if you're not prepared to die"
And I thought this was a savage phrase original in gintama
Huh Miyamoto Musashi clearly ignored that one
he wasn't really an samurai, samurais have masters but ronins are masterless so that is what Musashi was, he was basically just an swordsman a martial artist
@@minecraftkingest4116 I get what you're saying but I have heard ronin referred to as masterless samurai and most people don't know the difference so I just refer to him as a samurai for simplicity sake. But yes you are correct.
@@stuff485 Oh i assumed that you didn't know the difference cause you know most people don't but okay
@@minecraftkingest4116Someone who won 64 duels to the death and followed bushido all his life isnt a samurai? After all Samurai only means warrior or knight. A Ronin isnt necessarily a samurai but being masterless or born in peace times doesnt make someone not a warrior.
@@CornellD.Cavendish no samurai doesn't mean a warrior they are more like knights they follow masters and Musashi was more like just a swordsman than even a ronin cause he never actually followed someone but he did assist some emperors in later of his life
It'd be great if you covered the firearms usage by the samurai. A lot of people see them as only using swords, bows, and horses completely forgetting that they had access to firearms in the later centuries
Yeah especially Oda Nobunaga loved incorporating firearms into his tactics
That was a very brief period in the very long period of samurai history. Thus why people are often unaware of its usage in addition to swords and bows.
I mean Samurais themselves were not necressary against gunpowder if I remember correctly. They were however against "non samurai's" having access on gunpowder weapons.
It would have made whole society class of samurais useless, if normal peasants without any training could be better than warriors with years of training
The samurais loved their guns, way more than katanas
@@jarskil8862 they were against everyone else having any form of weapon, even if it is a kitchen knife. They themselves loved their guns
This makes Japanese art (mostly samurai) posters even better because you can look at the painting/poster of a samurai holding his katana means that you're witnessing his most desperate time that is captured by the moment
259 likes let me fix that
True its not uncommon to find those with chipped bloodied blades peppered with arrows.
The same in Europe, the sword was just a backup weapon for the spear and polearms.
The Katana is the minimal armament. You have it on you all the time.
For battles of course, you choose the longest possible range.
Like a pistol and a rifle on modern soldiers. You always carry your pistol, when on low intensity, but the rifle is used for combat situations with the pistol as a reserve
The pistol, rifle argument is flawed. In this case the pistol would be the dagger or wakizashi. I'd say a carbine vs a full length rifle is a better analogy for sword vs spears.
Wise man once said
"Those who lived by the sword, get shot by the one who don't"
😂😂😂
Never bring a knife to a gun fight.
@@hawk66100unless you are anime character
Indiana Jones ..
Historically they were closer to mounted bowmen. They’d prefer spears if they used a melee weapon on horseback.
And the blades also got shorter during the edo period due to becoming more ceremonial / being intended for status purposes => became the Katana we know today. The status of carrying a blade was so high, that some of those not allowed to carry one wore empty sheaths for show IIRC...
Spears and staffs have always been the biggest, most efficient and easiest weapon in ground fights, bows and guns really were game changers. But the bow takes so much power to draw for killing force that not just anybody could pick one up and be deadly. Thus, the crossbow.
@@leonamay8776 lipl1
@@dflaming1371omjjj
@@leonamay8776 what about the long katana when did they use those
That photo taken right before a beheading is pretty crazy. What strikes me is how calm both of them looked.
Samurai were like the guy who peaked in high school. Always talking about how awesome he was in the past, and all that awesome stuff that he totally did all the time.
Enemy: *Pulls out blade
Samurai: *Pulls out musket
"parry this you filthy casual"
Ah yes. Mordhau.
Truly the greater fighter
SWORD SAINT ISSHIN INTENSIFIES
*misses*
Dude, it's not hard to reflect
*DEATHBLOWS*
This is actually pretty true for knights as well. The sword was always more of a last ditch weapon with spears being preferable. They liked not getting so close for obvious reasons
Depends on the period. Early knight in chainmail depended a lot on their horse and lance, since chainmail offers significantly less protection than plate and so distance to the enemy was the way to go. In the later middle ages, knights were basically walking tanks, that used more blunt and piercing weapons like flanged maces and poleaxes
*Greatswords have entered the chat*
However, unarmored dueling and self-defense when not armored up were more common than in Edo-era Japan.
Estas en lo correcto. Los caballeros usaban principalmente alabardas, lanzas garrotes. Y es que su armadura era tan eficiente que de hecho la espada era inútil en las guerras
@@UncannyBeagle Which weren't used by knights, at least not typically.
A nknight would probably some sort of polearm (pollaxes were popular), maybe a warhammer or indeed a longsword. There are very specific swords for fighting in and against armor which qualify as primary weapons afaik (2 handed, strong blade, relatively blunt or no edge and a reinforced point).
Remember kids, the most dangerous samurai on the battlefield was the one sniping you with a bow halfway across the field where you can’t even see him.
I heard the same was true for knights and swords. We associate knights and swords, but knights mainly used other battlefield weapons.
Well that’s true of any warrior, spears were the primary weapon everywhere, swords were always just a sidearm.
@alida flus you must really like spears. This is the fourth comment I see you replying hahaha
@alida flus they were use against armored opponents some surviving schools still teach armored combat with swords tho not the katana exactly as people know it today. Japanese swords were even imported to other asian countries use in combat of course they would have also use armor.
The romans being an exception to the rule.
@Loup DeFer even if you could afford a sword it still a poorer weapon overall. People with mony would use halberds, polehammers and so on.
@alida flus Not for show no, but it depends on the era. During the time when armored combat was prevalent in midevil Japan they didn't use the katana, they tended towards the tachi, a much larger curved sword. Katana did not become the main stay until much later.
"Swiching to your katana is always faster than reloading"
Edit: guys it's a joke (apperently a COD one?)
That made sense considering the context
Said every weeb
@@cranberrycracker6847 At a certain distance a blade is more usefull then a gun, so it has a point
@@jonaswerner8480 yeah, thats kinda what swords do, theyre sharp n stuff
@@jonaswerner8480 no, a blade is never more useful than a gun.
The only time you could say that is at very close quarters, when you’re rolling around on the ground, and a knife would be more useful then a gun because you can’t aim the gun at him while you’re rolling around.
But you can’t stab someone with a katana while you’re rolling around.
🤣🤣🤣
My friend died a week ago, I'm listening to this because he's now forever young.
Just imagine a Samurai charging onto battle in horseback with Double pump shotgun 💀
How would he pump them if there's one in each of his hands?
@@GuckFoogle-pk6nsSearch up what double pump shotgun is.
Police: "Sir, why did you pull out your katana, we need a logical reason"
Me: "Because it looks cool"
Police: "Unchain this man immediately!"
Totally the katana over sword any day.
I think animè is the sole reason I fell love with Japanese culture so much they be hyping us up and is where I wish I was reincarnated in the Samurai era
True
Then they all proceed to break dance!
@@parlor3115
The best ending
@@whiteace_t.k.o8060 Remember that Samurai Era where also a very dark past because any mistakes against the orders of the shogun or the Japanese culture, you are forcefully sentenced to death Or decapitation as punishment to die with Honor.
So... be careful for what you're wishing.
"If you're not prepared to die don't pull out your katana."
Not just a katana but basically any weapon.
Yes, but no, yeah any weapon can get you killed, but that depends on the user, in the samurai era, pulling out your katana without any reason could get you killed immediately, nowadays, worst you can get is gettung arrested
Yeah but you weren't carrying other weapons in the Edo period unless you're on one of the very few battlefields of the era.
You destroyed that quote. SMH
@divinegreed8252 my man in England pulling out any weapon will get you shot if you refuse to drop it
"If your not prepared to die, don't pull out your Katana."
Add that quote to the book of kicking butt quotes.
What I’ve learned about a katana is its not only a weapon but a piece of art
Same could be said for every weapon before industrialized mass-production.
@@HivoltageCS no but I mean it was literally that they almost never used it only if they were sure they would die it was almost always just decorative that’s why most look nice
Spear > sword. You can thrust fast with a spear, you don’t lose balance and you can keep your distance while thrusting. Also in Medieval Europe long range weapons were used on the battlefield. However a spear was less useful against knight armor, thus came the halberds, hammers, etc. Before that axes were used against chainmail.
What about the queelag fury sword
Depends where you take the fight. Spears are useless in close quarters/small spaces. Thus they had both :p
Yes I also try to keep as much distance when I’m trusting someone. If you get too close and trust them they can hurt you badly. However I would think you would need to be a bit closer when thrusting a weapon into someone.
@@GiftBeats Most could not afford a sword. Also, a sword always needed repairs after a fight. People who could afford a sword, wore it as a sidearm. Maybe for within small spaces. But really, what kind of small spaces were there in combat situations? A bedroom? A small house? Those are places you wouldn't take a spear with you. We are talking about battle fields here.
Like most couldn’t afford full armor. Samurai often had them selves covered for all ranges/scenarios tho and were upperclass, compared to low class soldiers only being able to afford a spear. Spears were great weapons especially for the frontline, not so much when lines are broken, and it gets dense (that’s a small space for you right there.) I’m not saying one is better then the other, you clearly are. Which is better, bow or spear? Totally depends on the situation doesn’t it.
I feel like swords simply exist as an ideology of battle. They weren’t actually that efficient, nor were they even used very often. It’s just become the thing we associate with a warrior the most. It’s a symbol.
I mean, in a time when you needed to be able to defend yourself from unexpected animals (including humans) and guns were non-existent or werde effectively single shot, a long knife was likely very useful
Pretty true, especially since sword could be made extremely beautiful and ornate, and were often symbols of power like crowns or scepters.
@@wesswise28 And a lance or similar is even better and easier to make... So no.
@@KaiiAyrenNevaeh actual long knives were the most common tbh. A lance and even a sword is too cumbersome to carry if you're gonna use it once every few months if you're really unlucky
@@wesswise28 Fair enough, got caught up in every other comment talking about battlefields. But I'll say a long knive isn't a sword in my book, but I'm not a native English speaker so I might be speaking nonsense over semantics I'm not familiar with.
"If you're not prepared to die, don't pull out your Katana."
That is *_the most_* Samurai quote I have _ever_ heard!
I remember how it blew my mind that this concept not only applied to samurai, but most ancient warriors. You always wanted to keep your distance.
I'm reading the book of five rings by Miyamoto Musashi and he makes countless references to katana fighting on an open field, inside buildings, on horseback, against bows/guns, against single and multiple opponents etc.
Both by him and other schools. He actually chastises other schools for focusing so much on the katana.
dude beat sasaki kojiro with Suns
In the book , he usually used hit and run, and ambush tactic to kill a person...so it's not like one of those flashy movie
@@Hanif_A_F He even did unnerve a person before a duel by letting him wait. He was not above dirty tricks. But i guess thats why he is a swordsman,not a samurai ( other than no noble heretage)
@@Hanif_A_F He is an assassin, aint no honorable warrior
He also way famous for duel wielding.
If anyone’s still blurry on it, think about how military personal like marines have knives on them, but it’s a last resort after your other weapons
big knife
During year 3000, they will have our 21st century era soldier using knifes in history drama instead of gun
Now days pistols play a more similar role to the swords. Primary weapon-Spears & bows then, rifle now. Sidearm- swords then pistols now. Daggers then, knifes now.
K-bar does not equal sword.
Oooorah k-bar!
A pistol is a better comparison. The sword on your hip is a sidearm.
“YOU'RE PUTTING YOUR LIFE ON THE LINE BY POINTING THAT AT ME.” From Shanks has a whole new meaning now. I see why it resonated so deeply with Japanese readers
Getting executed for drawing your katana illegally puts a different twist on "If you're not prepared to die, don't pull out your katana."
In my experience, the sword being disproportionately depicted as a weapon of choice is something most modern cultures are guilty of. Most people would picture a European knight as wielding a sword similar in size to a Katana, with or without a shield, when in reality, since armored knights frequently engaged other armored knights, their main weapon would be a heavy axe or hammer designed to defeat said armor. A knight's arming sword was instead, much like the katana in practice, both a symbol and expression of a noble's privilege, and a last resort on the battlefield.
They even held their longswords at the blade and hit the enemy with the handle because it dealt more damage against armor. Fights between knights weren’t about stabbing or slashing but rather about blunt force
@@oz459 well there was definitely still stabbing and cutting, just not when it would be potentially thwarted because then it would bounce off the armor. The goal was to get into the gaps and joints of the armor, so grappling was a big force they had, so they could pin you, rip off your helmet maybe and then put a dirk straight into you
@@Artameful yes of course. But it wasn’t used to fight. It was used to execute.
Knights wouldve used polearms and spears rather than swords, and even then they wouldve had used the longer two handed swords and not the usual longsword which is a one handed weapon
@@richie_23 “longsword” is a pretty broad category of weapon. It can apply to 1 handed, 1,5 handed and 2 handed blades all the same. Some longswords may as well be considered greatswords; others might be indistinguishable from an arming sword
This is pretty true for swords in general throughout history. Swords were the pistol of the past, a sidearm. (With the exceptions of things like claymores/greatswords) The draw of swords is that they are easy and relatively comfortable to carry on one's person without needing to hold it making them great self defense weapons and sidearms for when your main battlefield weapon is lost or disabled.
Also a big exception of cavalry swords (both roman cavalry and 18th-19th century)
Remember, switching to your katana is always faster than reloading
Arming swords are generally the Glocks of medieval Europe
The Japanese version of a claymore would be something like an odachi, basically an over sized katana, and was used as a primary weapon.
Yeah swords and handguns fulfill very similar rolls. Scabards and holsters make them relatively easy to carry. They can even weight around the same( for instance my steel frame 1911 weighs around 1.75 lbs, and one handed swords would usually weigh around 1.5-2.5 lbs depending on the style and blade length.
"If you are not prepared to die, don't pull out your [weapon]." Timeless quote that I wish all people would follow today.
Reminds me of a country tune, by the late great Johnny Cash - *don't take your guns to town*
That is very interesting, and this makes so much sense, but you'd never think about it given how iconic the Katana is.
Isn't another reason is that the metal they needed for katanas really hard to aquire or refine? I'm not sure as I heard this a long time ago
Japan didn't have a lot of high quality steel while in Europe it was everywhere, so the process took longer to make one.
Yes, but even sword-making cultures with ready access to decent steel rarely employed them as main battlefield weapons. They were usually backup sidearms, personal defence, or for use in duels or similar personal combats.
I don't really know any culture exepct ancient Rome that used sword as a main battelfield weapon.
Probably. Japan is an island so their resources are limited. Thats why their statue making wouldnt use whole blocks of wood like other nations and would use the wood to form an internal skeleton.
@@digitaljanus It depends on what era you're talking about. When we talk about the medieval era, that is certainly true but wouldn't necessarily be true in the classical era or earlier when chainmail and platemail didn't exist, leaving armor that wasn't great against swords.
This is very similar with Sword for European Knights; swords are basically like the Pistol of the past, You only use it if you're desperate
Depends on what kind of sword tho. Zweihander/Montante are Landsknecht's favorite main weapon beside pole weapons in 15th century. Some units used arming sword and sidesword alot with big shields along side other troops that used pole weapons. Sabre are calvary's main weapon around 1796. The Europeans used their swords in battlefield and daily life way more frequently than the Japanese
Actually medieval europe was the only place in time where they actually used swords as main weapons during battle, not everyone obviously but a decent chunk of medieval warriors, especially rich Noble knights did
@@grzexd Are you mixing heavy two handed sword with one handed sword?
Swords were used, but like said by the other commenter above, it was not preferred weapon.
And to compare to air combat, katanas are our guns and bows are our missiles. Even dogfights are romanticized by the public.
Short/one handed sword specifically.
The Samurai were the extremely respectful and disciplined breed of Japan with the highest of morality.
Oh man...
That is such a myth
@@RandomFurry07 for a handful of scums the entire race doesn't get polluted.
Thank you, the best truth I have ever heard. I have been saying this. But, to hear it in a video is priceless. ❤
I didn’t know the ninja turtles got in such serious battles on such a regular basis
😂😂😂
They aren’t samurai, they are assassins. As an assassin you will almost always fight close quarter so a spear or a loud gun doesn’t make sense
Well yeah, all the enemies they face either are covered in heavy armour or fight close range
@@oz459 oooh right
@@oz459 we should have given raph guns and had them snipe people. Shredder would be dead in his first appearance if splinter trained them like actual ninjas.
Ninja's used a lot of guns and even made some of there own. Obunaga was almost assassinated by a sniper for Pete sake. The ninja used a lot of diffrent weapons but they loved guns even if they were loud because they were better at killing without being seen. Same reason snipers are used now of days to assinate targets.
The spear is such a fantastic weapon. So simple yet effective.
It is boring in entertainment industry that is why it is not seen very often
"You may be the greatest swordsman to ever exist, but how will you face THIS!" *Shoots tanegashima*
Remember, switching to a katana is faster than reloading your bow.
range
It makes a lot of sense. Why would you attack in close range and put yourself at a disadvantage when bows existed. Think of it as a hunting dagger
@Lasagna and Spaghetti Nation unfortunately, no one has that.
There's a reason why Raiden Shogun's weapon is a polearm instead of a sword.
Well, now that you mentioned ... it make sense
And Sara Kujou sticks with a bow. Those two team up so well together.
Is there also a reason why she pulled it out of her boobs?
@@neverletmego6414 dev need money
True..
Makes the legends even better.
Regarding swords VS polearms, here's some important information I learned from Skallagrim and Shadiversity:
While most people know about their range advantage over swords, the other major reason spears & polearms dominated melee warfare for millennia is because they are the hardest shaped practical melee format to block, parry, or disarm. A sword's hilt can be snagged and pinned by a stick-shaped weapon, but a spear-like weapon doesn't give enemy combatants any easy spot to deflect or grapple your weapon with. Same downside applies to axeheads, and any other complex weapon design with a concave portion your opponent could use to control your weapon.
Of course later polearms with small axes and hammers also have these surfaces, but that's why we're pretty sure combatants engaged with the spear or stick like side first. Once someone thought they out-grappled their opponent's "blunt" end to create an opening, they would rotate the dangerous-looking part around to deliver a final blow. Opening an attack with the axe portion of a halberd, for example, risked giving your opponent an easy opportunity to snag and pin your weapon with their "stick" side, and get an easy kill.
Meanwhile salty weebs raging about their misconception of Katanas being the ultimate sword and best weapon ever designed.
'While you were studying the blade, I just shot you with this gun.'
@AdmiralOddSock At least the non-very high quality ones at the time, or at least not the modern reproductions
Yeah the spatha is the best sword
@AdmiralOddSock Katana looks cooler + No one is gonna use a katana or any medieval weapon in this and age
@AdmiralOddSock Just saying once again katanas look at least 100x better than European swords
Don't bring a katana to a bow and arrow fight.
@@manabellum *Sad noises in the back*
Anime Protags: "I beg to differ"
Well someone hasn't played Team Fortress
@@mirzapramudya1580 degroot
Just parry the arrows.
Don't forget the ceremonial usages of the katana. Seconding seppuku, etc.
Makes the Katana even cooler, it’s like the last boss phase
Basically pop culture separated use from reality
Well sort of I mean it’s still reality but not the absolute truth like they still were excellent swordsman but it wasn’t their primary weapons
@@thedarklightskin some would have been excellent swordsmen, others would have been incredibly mediocre…
Same problem with Knight's swords in Europe.
They were secondary status symbol weapons but media makes it seem that short sword was some super weapon breaking shields and spears.
@@jarskil8862 I think it really just depends on the swords though in Europe especially
@@jarskil8862 I've literally never heard nor seen something remotely close to what you've just described.
Maybe get better media standards...
"If you're not prepared to die, don't pull out your katana" has the same vibes as "Now that you've drawn your pistol, are you willing to use it? I'm saying that guns aren't for threats they're for actions" (Shanks). Now I think I know where the inspiration for that line came from
"loaded or not, don't ever point a gun at something you're not about to shoot" is a pretty universal gun rule taught by anyone who respects guns.
This is when i learned about "when you pull out your weapon, you are ready to die"
It's a pretty common rule about deadly weapons across many cultures, all the way from ancient times.
Makes me wonder if it was acceptable to only use a katana if you were badass and took everyone down, heading straight into battle. You were prepared to die but you were too worthy to.
Thats a general fighting rule
Spot on. The most used weapon on the battlefield is a spear of all sorts which is hardly spoken of.
Rule of thumb for wars pre-firearms, the longer poke stick wins, unless you're too close, then small pokestick win
My first thought: well, maybe because their opponents weren't actually a rolled tatami mats!?
"Wait, why in Nobunaga Oda's name would I use my brittle saber when I can just Blast my enemies with this cool flintlock rifle or do a drive by with my bow"
-Some Samurai
arquebus reaccs
Or poke them in the face with a spear.
Matchlock... fun fact, in 1600, half the firearms in the world, were in Japan. As well as a third of the world's silver.
Thanks shogo, for your videos, hope your well
thank you for the info master shogo, i am happy to have learned this today
"If you're prepared to die, don't pull out"
I remember my Ex when i didn't do what she said T_T
Everything reminds me of her....
Why would a girl say that?? It's a man's right to not pull out if he doesn't want to
@@eugeneflores6153 Why would a girl say that?? It's a man's right to not pull out if he doesn't want to
@@Logicalsanewhy would you say that? It's women's right to not have a child before they're prepared for it
The thought that samurai used guns fucks with my perception of time so hard
Right? Makes you realize both that the Sengoku Jidai wasn't that long ago, and that the samurai continued to exist for a VERY long time
The katana part is so true Musashi once said: fight as if you are already dead
Is so crazy to think about time periods and understand that Samurai were essentially knights with rifles. That overlap period is crazy
Before watching, bows & spears/ naginata were primary, swords have pretty much always been a sidearm, even in medieval Europe. Essentially swords were the pistols of the past.
I was looking, whether anyone already mentioned, that it's same as in Europe - mythical weapons, that were merely a sidearm or self-defence tool (of civilians) at best…
european swords were much more useful
Having something short range as your main weapon is a death sentences. It's there for close quarters and as a last resort.
@@mmgg1671 Polearms were the primary melee weapon in pretty much every pre-firearm region that had a medieval era, that I can think of. Including Europe.
@@Chicky_Lumps no, in europe swords and claymores were also a primary weapon
"if you're using a katana, it means you're in a very desperate situation"
Reminds me of something.
Is it weaboos ?
The spear is king of hand-to-hand combat for a reason.
Even the medieval samurai knew to take advantage of range. Nobody is really that death hungry.
"If youre not prepared to die dont pull out your katana"
ironically
"If you're not prepared to die, DO pull out your mini-katana"
Wakizashi are rarely used to combat
@@skullcrusade3436 it was mainly used for making sandwiches
@@skullcrusade3436 indoor?
The form of a Samurai using a bow is really beautiful. Archery is so pretty!
Wow this is very very interesting I love learning about this stuff
Glad you brought this up, Shogo. The movies have misled us for decades. Shared.
It's the same story with swords everywhere. Even tho swords are massive in media, they always were backup weapons.
Primary weapon of the Romans for a long time tho.
And ceremonial and status symbol, why they became so popular in media in the first place.
@@Raakarapu Along with spears and bows. They also had immense crossbows on platforms, while Byzantines - who were Romans - had "Greek" fire. Mind you, we're talking about more than 800 years, so there were different developments at different times.
@@garryferrington811 Yes 100% agree. My point (in my head) was that people tend to take things to the extreme like "swords have never been a primary weapon" which while mostly correct isn't always the case. The cladius would not have worked without the scutum. So context is important. Btw no idea if I'm spelling everything right I pretty much speak only finnish and drunk now too.
@@Raakarapu
Dont forget the pilum. It was Just as Important as scutum and gladius
Step 1: Carry two katana (required by law).
Step 2: Unsheathe.
Step 3: Get arrested.
You'd have a Wakazashi and a Katana or a Tachi and a Wakazashi
It’s nice to see governmental logic hasn’t changed much in 300-400 years.
@@MC-24it’s completely logical, so it looks like the stupidity of the governed also remains unchanged
Golden rule of ALL weapons: Don't pull it, lest you gon use it!
The gun was a total game changer.
Enemy showing up with a sword for the fight:
The samurai that brought a 50 cal: The future is now old man.
"Remember, switching to your katana is always faster than reloading"
Meme approved
Samurai A: "Prepare yourself, for your neck should be shredded"
Samurai B: *holding a gun* "Parry this you little-"
"One must be ready to die , once he draw his gun"
-Red Hair Shanks
I always admired Japanese culture in those times I can't imagine what it was like for two actual samurai to face eachother
Drive by with bow and arrow on a horse.
Bow, chit chat, drink tea, say goodbye.
Im sure it was a very big deal and the reason had to be extreme. Dueling in the street was outlawed and the winner was usually ordered to commit suicide unless there was a legitimate reason and witnesses to the entire situation. Sometimes the winner was executed depending on what kind of position his opponent held. For example if a samurai of a lower house killed a noblemam for insulting his lord the samurai would be ordered to suicide and his lord may be disgraced or reprimanded. At one point it was illegal to even draw your sword within the city limits of Edo
@@jbertucci*say goodnight
As in most European countries of the time, the sword is a sidearm. Polearms and bows have greater reach and are easier to use in formation, with the exception of swords specifically designed for that purpose such as the gladius. Polearms and blunt force weapons were also much better at defeating the body armor that would have been in use, either by crushing and immobilizing joints, bashing in the helmet, or simply having enough force behind them to penetrate the armor. Bows, meanwhile, were excellent at massed volley fire that could send entire formations running for cover, or find weak spots in armor via the "infinite monkey" method. And I believe Oda Nobunaga's rise to power speaks well enough for the power of firearms.
Yukari akiyama
Expectations: "I am the way of the sword"
Reality: "BANG BANG B*TCH"
Nice ! 😊 Excellent history lesson.
Basically most movies and shows use Katanas because they look very cool and are heavily associated with Samurai. But the most historically accurate movies/shows/animes depict Samurai using Bows, Spears, Polearms or Guns.
Their point is to be entertaining, so yea, they will use the coolest things with the widest appeals usually
The love of my life, Takeda Shingen, my favorite Samurai
Remember: switching to your Katana is always faster than reloading
Thank you for this video💚 Many people dont realise that sword is mostly status symbol or dueling weapon not battlefield weapon
I read somewhere about Samurai being an Archer 1st, Spearman 2nd and Swordman 3rd... Basically sword are their last stand against enemies when the other two weapons failed.
I learned something just now. Thank You.
It’s a sidearm, much like an arming sword for knights. It’s for self defense and as a backup. Basically “drawing your katana is faster than picking your bow back up”