B-Segment SUV Battle: Proton X50 FS 🆚 Hyundai Kona 1.6T N Line 🆚 Perodua Ativa 1.0H 🆚 Honda HR-V RS
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 มิ.ย. 2024
- Who comes out tops in Part I of this B-segment SUV battle?
00:00 - Introduction
02:06 - Boot Space Test
05:10 - Interior Space/Comfort Test
07:55 - Slalom Challenge
09:27 - Parking Test
13:13 - Fuel Consumption Test
15:30 - NVH Test
20:45 - Conclusion/Results
21:54 - Cubby Hole Test
Website: www.carlist.my
Facebook: / carlist.my
Instagram: / carlistmy
Tiktok: / carlistmy
CarTell: / cartellmy - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
wow didnt expect the ativa interior/ comfort is better than x50 when the interior space in ativa is smaller than the myvi
Exactly, for me I tested both x50 and ativa, ativa rear seat space is just too small compare to x50
best comparison well done lads
thumbs up for u guys
Kind words LSD, thank you!
Great review ! Transparent results
You guys fun! Please produce more comparison video like this
Thank you Fikri, if you're interested in a B-segment sedan comparison, here's one: th-cam.com/video/S15iVptuq5M/w-d-xo.html
I still think x50 is the good middle ground. Not that expensive, with every bell and whistle. Got the better interior imo.
You guys do the great video..kipidap..
Guys: this kind of comparo video format.. class act la.. truly ups the ante with local car reviews.. I know it takes more time & much more effort to do this, but for us prospective buyers..definitely a big help! I watched your b segment sedan comparo too.. And definitely love the 'thumbs up, thumbs down' parts hahahaha.. I'd love my passengers to enjoy the ride too! Keep this up!!!!
Pl))9p
Review yang mantap.. terbaik
Good content, subscribed.
Assalamualaikum and hi, what a great comparison video, I do love this type of presentation format video, btw can you guys make a similar comparison for hatchback / compact car class in future, tq if so 😍
Terima kasih Aiman, appreciate the kind words. We will definitely consider your idea, thank you!
@@carlist_my yup, can compare new myvi, yaris, city hb, iriz
@@kayprime20 We'll work on it!
I must say this is a good comparisons done so far. Good job guys
Good comparison video. I believe, Hyundai Kona is the underrated car. Hyundai itself is very underrated in Malaysia, not sure why though. But other than boot space, Kona beat every other B segment cars. It's built for Fun to drive and Adreline rush. It's definitely not your usual city car and its produced 198PS with 7 speed DCT is something very powerful. The feel is totally different !
Hah! This is the most perfect review i ever wathched!!! Congrat carlist... I really enjoy this review..
Terima kasih! Appreciate the support and kind words.
Klu nk test betul2 buka cover tu yg kat bonet tu, sbb org kalau jalan jauh mrk akan buka cover tu utk muat brg byk,
Should have gotten the latest cx3 as well, older platform like the hrv but mazda has refined it so much compared to my 2017 model the 2020 model has better noise insulation, better handing and comfort even though on the outside it looks simillar. Plus the it would be interesting to compare the 2.0NA against the turbos is there really no replacement for displacement. Anyways kudos nice video !
Agreed and we did ask Mazda for the CX-3 but unfortunately, they did not have a media review unit available for this comparison video.
Kudos for a brilliant video lads!! Another interesting factor if you could add in the future, the current price range for the cars compared. Which would be one of the biggest decision making factors of car buyers out there. 😞 that X50 didn't fare so well in the test lol.
Thank you Zaslan, we did mention the specific price of each vehicle in the video but for comparisons of this nature we generally try to group them according to segment and not necessarily price point because sometimes you just might find that despite the price, a more affordable model might score/ rank better.
Hi where is Ativa Slalom challenge? Can’t find it
Mantap bang 👍
lreally love this, could you make more of these with different segment / type cars
Belum beli tak percaya comparo sana sini, lepas beli Honda BR-V baru kesal. Dari luar memang cantik tapi periksa teliti selepas mula pandu baru kenalpasti isu2 seperti bunyi luar, bau eksos dalam, getah pintu nipis, bunyi getaran depan belakang dll. Kecewa dengan Honda Malaysia sebab mengikut "mereka", mereka ada buat ujian banyak!?!
I would like to look at the performance test.
Great comparison guys..next c-segment.
Thank you kindly, we'll work on it.
ativa AV or H spec?
Good comparison
next video blh tambah harga dan maintenance dalam score table..yg mana lg jimat.
5 tahun waranti, servis kat Honda.....menangis poket owner HRV 2017.
Hi guys great video perfect for someone like me who js considering to get an suv. I have a question, is it safe to get proton x50? Because im really worry about the reliability of this car..problems that may occur even if i take really good care if it and as well as the spare parts..
Initially im considering honda hrv..second hand..but after my deep calculation for monthly payment its kinda bit pricey with around rm900 over for 9 years plus the roadtax itself is kinda pricey with rm289 and insurance rm3000 over..unlike proton x50 its only around rm800 over monthly with roadtax rm90 and insurance rm2000 over..
So..for financial aspect i cant sacrifice my money for honda hrv..and can only afford x50..but yea my main concern is the reliability of it..and spare part..
Appreciate the kind words Celetials. Now with regard to reliability, you nailed it - you take care of the car with periodic maintenance and it should serve you well. As for the spare parts Proton are currently working on addressing that issue but if you're buying a new car, it's not really something you should have to worry about unless of course the car gets into an accident and requires a specific part.
@@carlist_my thank you so much! Perfect info and i pray that ur contents keep growing ya!
i know this is old and many time people had requested, but i am excited to see car sedan segment B like Vios, City, Almera, Persona, Mazda 2 compete together.
th-cam.com/video/S15iVptuq5M/w-d-xo.html
Can add one more comparison test which is driving experience on bad weather. Which I think with current circumstances, people would love to see the outcomes!
Ooo...Interesting idea except we don't have a bomoh at our disposal to 'create' bad weather, but still an idea worth considering.
I'm the X50 owner. About the fuel consumption test, I had done for 3 mode with cruise control/without cruise control, my test results:
minimum 13km/l
maximum 16km/l.
175km-187km long distance driving on incomplete pan borneo Highway Sarawak. Thanks for your video, I really like the comparison and your opinion on these product. I am very surprised that the Proton X50 was the lowest scored compared with the another 3 product.
Gong Xi Fa Chai Woo and thank you for your support. We did a mixture of city and highway driving to get the most balanced km/l pricing. Worth bearing in mind also is that driving style also plays a role in fuel consumption.
Which variant bro ?
Hi Carlist, Hyundai Kona electric bulan depan ke dijual kat pasaran
Sudah pun mula dijual di pasaran Hafiz.
Part drive drift tu ATIVA MANA?
Mantap Abg kangkang ala² van dem
Already bought the hrv just because of no sst+massive rebate and total all of it equal to 10% downpayment.
This was the comparison for HRV selling points.
Great video, and format! Love the practical approach of what users look for. But X50 being the lowest *cries
Thank you James! At the end of the day, if the X50 works for you and it could, then go for it! There's a lot of pros too with the X50.
It's a very informative video , but something is off here, because I don't feel the tests were sufficient enough to rank out these Cars. And yes to be asking one's opinion is very much questionable as one might not feel what the others felt *need to use proper gadgets. Not the slalom test tho, that needs to be conducted by a professional/well trained for sure, good job on that. So yeah, keep it up . Oh and yeah, we have Sepang circuit btw, if im not mistaken they're welcoming people. Overall, 👌
ativa fuel consumption.. 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻, overall result no.2. good value for money.
Hmm...Perodua Ativa acctually total can put 12 can. Front can put 10 can including the cup holders (driver seat and passenger seat). But this is a great comparison video. Hope can see more video like this in the future.
Thank you Yi Lee, we've got more coming up!
Test is well reviewed.
Intro padu... terbaik... x sakit ke bang?
Setakat sekarang okay lah lagi - si Sharil memang agak fleksibel.
You should do drag race
A drag race requires a safe and secure environment for both man and machine, that is not readily available in the Kang Valley.
@@carlist_my you can try on Sepang Circuit
Mana New 2008?
Have a suggestion to do drag test the 4 model
We'll keep that in mind for the coming one's Saga!
@@carlist_my thank you
Order hari ni bila boleh dapat bro? 😆
Apa2 pun klw modified..x50 lagi ramai follower 👍...
uncle parking should make his own youtube
Sy sudah selesa dgn model Korea (Kia), Sblm ni pernh test drive Kona 2.0 active mmg syok gilerrrr dari segi kepuasan pemanduan, selesa, ride& handling padu. Tiada bunyi rattling pelik2 and dalam kabin agak senyap.
Tapi yg ni model spec N-line harga x masuk akal akan tetapi engine 1.6T power teruk 198Ps 265Nm syokk ooo lenjannnn layan koner pun syok sebab tu kot Hyundai letak nama Kona..😂
X50 pun Xboleh lawan Kona cuma X50 FS menang dari segi harga and value for money.
Tobat pakai kete Korea, sparepart mahal susah pula nk dpt,mungkin kt negara lain sebaliknya..
@@safarwadio1781 spare parts senang je dapat , parts Kia share dengan HYUNDAI xde masalah pun, parts mmg la mahal sebab tiada local parts, parts semua mai dari luar bukan mcm p1 and p2 parts local yg buat mmg la harga murah xkn la xtau beza local parts and parts dari luar.
Corolla Cross is what segment?
It sits between the B and C but is more closely compared to the C-segment.
should consider performance@drivetrain rating rather than parking test 🤣
Will be considered, thank you Yusuf.
I'm sold on the cubby hole test alone. 🤣
Suv tapi boleh offroad tak?
Suv - sub urban vehicle. For off roading I dont think its suitable lah
ativa slalom test tu kenapa xde? ada sape2 boleh terangkan apa masalah steering tu? xfaham.. ty
Hyundai kona n line is the one to pick. Unless for those ppl worry resales
kudos guys. may consider to put the tumbler also as there's lots of yuppies tapauing drinks enroute office/home on daily basis
Had been drive Ativa vibration harshness i think Ativa the most worst and feel exhausted after long journey..the underfloor lot of vibration during iddle, steering small frequency vibrate i can feel, start shock really can feel the engine swing unbalance due to natural imbalance 3 piston..all in all kimchi kia is the most underrated but actually good to buy..
Ativa is perodua respond to SUV fever... is literally a bandwagon...
Wait until 5years and checkup the NVH. Perodua is good short distance reliable but once u go. For Korean or conti car there's no return back ( at least in my case) .
Different levels
how about CX3?
We did ask Mazda for the CX-3 but unfortunately, they did not have a media review unit available for this comparison video Steven.
If u have taken the Activa AV the tyres I believe is the more premium Bridgestone plus if u factor in the price then Activa rating will surely go up. Agree? Note : Latest : I just checked. The Activa AV actually uses Bridgestone Turanza so it’s the same tyre as the Activa H variant.
SUV battle who is going to win the value cash
Thanks for the video. It highlights my concerns on certain aspect in picking up new ride. Ativa for me is enough.
You're welcome Nik! Enjoy your new ride.
One of the best comparison videos that matters to many normal buyers.
However it will be good include a longer on the road comfort comparison and be part of the fuel consumption comparison
We have that coming up soon Derek, where each of the guys will provide their assessment of each vehicle they're driving.
Hahaha the intro is amazing
Thank you, thank you!
Great video but u missing out one point... Add up the PRICE point. 😁
But im still go for the sexiest one.. X50😍
Among these 4 models.. X50 is the longest to wait😅 .. that means the car is the choice of many people
It does have the longest wait time true, it is a good proposition sure, is it the sexiest? That's up to each individual to decide but thank you for the support.
X50 bcoz of design..look elegan..
The longest waiting time it is proven..that it is most chosen by people.
Hayyaaa long wating not because many people like it....it because chip shortage
maybe also because the kilang is so slow to produce it... not necessarily too much demands... hahaha...
X50 power. Honda pun ada. Tp more to x50 now
One more need to be added : services cost for 5 years for every car
I think the best comparison is about the price bro..just my 5cent.chill
should add 1 new model 2008
How about the toyota corolla cross ?
The Corolla Cross is more C-segment Winnie, hence it will be better to compare it against the X70, and the like.
Why no corolla cross?
Because Corolla Cross is C Segment
A professional Racer should took that risk to do slalom test for ATIVA and I believe the marks for slalom alone supposed to be 5 marks.
It’s 30 marks + 5 marks. Ativa should get 35 total marks
Hrv win ...still relevant even old model
Boleh beli ke? And yet the best selling suv car that year 😂
👍👍
lol, the introduction is so funny
Thank you! Sharil wants to headspin on the car for the next video he says.
if hrv are that good, why did honda stop making it and produce a new one
Where Ativa slalom test??. Capable or not capable for slalom test??🤔
exactly. what happened ?
In the minit 11 have mention Ativa threw up a steering error that why no slalom challenge for Ativa.. but still can win with x50 😂😂😂😂 what a review
Good comparison. I am a proud X50 user 😁
safety features kena bagi markah jugak sepatutnya
Yup, safety first sepatutnya
Betul, kalau pasal safety, honda paling last🙈
That guys Allways condemn X50 in previous video. So what!
And surprising they didn't test top speed 0-100km
@5:48 fast xD
Pls do a drag race haha
We'll plan for that David.
How about Toyota Corolla Cross ?
The Corolla Cross straddles two segments, the B and C Azrul, but it is better to compare against the X70 and its like.
@@carlist_my | I see.. I thought Corolla Cross same category with X50 or HR-V. Noted with thanks. 😊
Hope next video have Malay subs...ohyeah
Ativa bukan A segment ke?
For your reading pleasure: www.carlist.my/news/what-segment-does-the-2021-perodua-ativa-belong-to-82202/82202/
Fitting in people test was not accurate and right, should do dimensions measurements settle, simple je like maths, larger dimensions measurements wins tats all.
The dimensions of the car are readily available in the spec sheet but the bigger question here is how does that translate to people? If we went by spec sheet size the Kona should have come in second in the boot space comparison as on paper it has the bigger volume.
Waaah can do split like that
where's peugeot 2008?
The Peugeot 2008 was only very recently launched in Malaysia, after this video was shot.
i want to laugh when we are testing the interior hahahaha
Ativa not a B segment Suv Mazda Cx 3 okey
ativa is the best one😛♥️♥️🥰
That split is not neccessary 😂😂
Subaru xv?
compare the safety of the car........do u know how many car drivers die from 1986? all are make in Malaysia cars? why nobody write down the death statistic data sheets? just FREE to show off compare this car to that car?
The Kona looks like someone who tried so hard to look different to the point they forgot the main objective which is to look good
Wait, it doesn't look good?
The back of the car looks like it is trying hard to fill the blank 🤢🤮
tapi kalau tgk mesti tau tu hyundai
hyundai more to europe
now toyota pun dha masuk europe nye styling hahaha
Patut kasi drag mesti semua makan asap dgn kona
Kemungkinan besar anda betul!
hrv is not bad..interesting..
Impressive line up, it would be greater if Ford Puma is also included
Unfortunately we don't have the Puma here in Malaysia.
Video dh okay tp utk aku lg okay klau cuma guna 1 bahasa saja. Mcm pening skit sat2 english sat malay
it seems ativa wins. The most value for money
As a value proposition, the Ativa is a very compelling option.
it's the cheapest among the 4 for a reason....
Hey! Janda baik is my home here..why there no teaser to do the fc test here as we also may want to greets you all bros..
Ativa representing toyota..for sure i choose ativa,, value for money b4 and after sales
Slalom pn x lepas🤣