WAS IT WOKE? | ONE PIECE

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 พ.ย. 2024

ความคิดเห็น • 90

  • @juliesteimle3867
    @juliesteimle3867 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    Not woke. The casting was excellent. The personality and how they looked really fit well. As a fan, everything that you see is rather well suited to the story.

    • @Christian_Ada1
      @Christian_Ada1 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

      It’s very woke but beca YOU like it it isn’t
      The character isn’t Hispanic in the anime, but they hired a Spanish actor to play monkey de Luffy
      So yeah it’s woke
      Going by your community’s tirades

  • @JohnM-ex4be
    @JohnM-ex4be ปีที่แล้ว +6

    You should see some of characters that will come in next few series from manga and anime they're wild but it is the source material from decades ago

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  ปีที่แล้ว

      Looking forward to it!

  • @OriginBullet
    @OriginBullet ปีที่แล้ว +6

    Don't worry about it. If a story is well written and you find you like it. It shouldn't matter too much if it's "woke" or not. One Piece is great and hopefully the live action will encourage more people to read the actual series.

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  ปีที่แล้ว

      I can agree with that.
      A lot of people do worry about wokeness however, and so I make these videos as hopefully a guide for those who are interested.
      I appreciate you taking the time to watch and I hope you found it interesting!

    • @jimbeam-ru1my
      @jimbeam-ru1my ปีที่แล้ว

      there is no such thing as a well written woke story. This bullshit live action is a poorly written hollywood cliche and the only people that like it are the netflix pr firms swamping the internet to write bogus positive reviews and complete imbeciles that could be entertained watching paint dry.

    • @ChrisPierce-y1r
      @ChrisPierce-y1r ปีที่แล้ว

      Yeah cause stories that are woke are not telling a good story they don't have characters with good character arcs cause they are to busy pushing identity politics on u and preaching at u trying to make you feel bad for what sex u are or race or sexuality you are there is no story that is woke that is good

    • @ChrisPierce-y1r
      @ChrisPierce-y1r ปีที่แล้ว

      And one piece is not woke just so u know

    • @jimbeam-ru1my
      @jimbeam-ru1my ปีที่แล้ว

      @@ChrisPierce-y1r it is woke, you're just not smart enough to notice. you're just a propaganda sponge.

  • @RandomUserX99
    @RandomUserX99 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    even that 1 for toxic masculinity is not true - all the male rep is exactly the same as how Oda the creator wanted. You also forget that for female there's also Alvida who is like the worst of them all - incompetent, stupid, and extremely violent. There's zero agenda for Oda. He was just a manga creator who wanted to create a super interesting story.

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      That's fair enough. I mean I only gave it a 1/10, so was only a tiny little thing I had an issue with. But otherwise I definitely don't consider this series woke, or even Nami's character.

  • @Geffi01
    @Geffi01 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Oda, the creator of OP made sure nothing got destroyed by those woke idiots. But Netflix wanted to!

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  ปีที่แล้ว

      Yes I've heard that, respect!

    • @IsaiahBuchanan175
      @IsaiahBuchanan175 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Oda is woke

    • @Geffi01
      @Geffi01 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@IsaiahBuchanan175 To a reasonable extend.

  • @cwega2463
    @cwega2463 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    it’s always ironic seeing all the Anti-Woke youtubers talk about One Piece and praise it for being not woke. do they not realise this show as a whole is literally the most left leaning story in anime? i love One Piece and its themes, but people like you are really misunderstanding and twisting the narrative. fair enough, the major anti government and establishment themes, and LGBTQ (gay, trans, pan, drag queen) characters aren’t there yet, but when they are introduced and the story becomes about taking down and destroying the world government (and the equivalent of the president), don’t be complaining saying “Netflix turned One Piece woke! The Woke Mind Virus Strikes Another Japanese Property!”
    Oda is openly liberal and honestly quite far left leaning.
    obviously people like you and the anti woke crowd don’t actually understand “woke” issues or progressive themes. you all just see shit like race swapping, strong women and feminism and complain about a woke mind virus. since one of the anti woke crowd’s biggest issues with “woke” stuff is strong women beating men casually and joking about it, then if that’s you, you will genuinely hate One Piece. that’s like Boa’s, Pudding’s, somewhat Nami, Robin’s and others entire style of fighting.

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  8 หลายเดือนก่อน

      First of all, I never said anything about One Piece being Anti-Woke. If you want to see me talk about an "Anti-Woke" film, watch my Sound of Freedom video.
      As I said it the video and in many comments, I have no knowledge of the source material or anime whatsoever. All I know about One Piece is what I've seen in this Live-Action show. Therefore I can only judge what i've seen in this show, which I deemed as Not Woke. If when the next season comes out and it has the things that you say it will, then I'll judge it accordingly.
      But as I've said many times, it's not about WHAT they put in a show that makes it woke. It's about HOW they utilise it to promote an agenda that exists outside of the show.

    • @cwega2463
      @cwega2463 8 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@kiksta well One Piece’s agenda in the manga and anime is pushing pro liberal, anti government and pro LGBTQ themes. Oda is inspired by his open disdain towards the conservative japanese government, Luffy is literally referred to as the “Warrior of Liberation” and goes to many oppressed countries and frees them simply because he felt like it. and during all this, there are many powerful, prevalent, and positively represented LGBTQ characters.
      luffy frees a country of slaves who’s population was brainwashed; he liberated a country overcome with fear due to systemic and personal racism from the world government’s fear mongering propaganda in the world; he takes down a whole navy base and a navy prison because he wanted to save his brother, taking down marines in the process. idk how much more anti right, pro liberal and freedom than that.
      and i never said you said One Piece was Anti Woke. I said you’re anti woke and praising one piece for not being woke. but if that’s your opinion, simply all i’m trying to say is don’t start changing your tune from praising it to hating it because it’s political stance is merely different than yours.

  • @cozmyboy
    @cozmyboy 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Latino Luffy, great idea!
    I stopped watching after Nami’s sister was black

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  9 หลายเดือนก่อน

      I thought the actor who played Luffy looked a lot like the animation.
      Will take your word for Nami's sister though

  • @shadowstars4097
    @shadowstars4097 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Honestly, seeing all the race swaps annoyed me at first but the characters stayed as they should have been which made it work, Race and gender swaps don't have to be a bad as long as their character doesn't go from being interesting to 'look at the color of my skin' or 'look I'm a woman now so I'm better'

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  ปีที่แล้ว

      Spot on!

    • @jimbeam-ru1my
      @jimbeam-ru1my ปีที่แล้ว

      "but the characters stayed as they should"
      No they didn't. They tossed out the characters and rewrote them entirely.

    • @jimbeam-ru1my
      @jimbeam-ru1my ปีที่แล้ว

      "but the characters stayed as they should"
      No they didn't. They tossed out the characters and rewrote them entirely.

    • @shadowstars4097
      @shadowstars4097 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Not really, they downgraded the silliness of the characters to be sure but Luffy is still goofy, Zoro is slightly more serious but not over the top, Nami still loves money, Sanji still loves the ladies but isn't as perverted as before "I'm glad for that' Usopp still lie and likes to talk big, really the only person that change almost completely is Garp and it wasn't in a bad or woke way, thank heavens for that @@jimbeam-ru1my

    • @ChrisPierce-y1r
      @ChrisPierce-y1r ปีที่แล้ว

      It might look in the anime that characters are white or whatever but in the animes they are mostly all ment to be Asian Japanese so most the characters in this show where race swapped but because it's live action it works it's not a woke race swapped

  • @johnnylight0
    @johnnylight0 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    One piece is woke in the idea of personal freedom and not letting others make choices for you.
    The ladies tend to be a little more brainy, while the men are more punchy but it's usually played for laughs cuz of how ridiculous the characters are and there's no designated character or trait that is unanimously harped or ganged up on.
    And later on there will be some characters that play into the idea of crossdressing and transgenderism, which is a pretty common thing in anime and usually played as a joke
    And also the idea of revolution and rebellion against the unjust tyrants appears sometimes

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      You're not wrong. You're using woke in its more original context, where as I'm using it in it's more modern connotation, which has been hijacked by the far-left. Or hijacked by the right to use against the far-left, depending on how you see it I guess...
      Otherwise all the themes you mentioned are pretty standard storytelling tropes and not woke at all.

  • @burn2400
    @burn2400 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

    in the source material, luffy doesn't want to be a "good" pirate intentionally, it just so happens. Correct me if I'm wrong

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  11 หลายเดือนก่อน

      I'll take your word for it cause I know nothing about the source material lol

    • @throwaway-jw1ur
      @throwaway-jw1ur 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

      your right, he specifically states he doesn't want to be a hero with his beautiful meat analogy

  • @ComikelZero
    @ComikelZero ปีที่แล้ว

    Yes it was woke, but it just was really really tame and you can tell they wanted to go harder.

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  ปีที่แล้ว

      That may be the case, but I can only judge it on what it is, not what they may have wanted it to be.

  • @comatoastlife
    @comatoastlife 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    did not know that about kobe...no wonder i thought he was acting too femininely

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  9 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Lol

  • @broledge-facts
    @broledge-facts 10 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Dragon will be indian while garp is as white as bread and then luffy is brownish... make it make sense lol

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  10 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Lol I have no idea 🤷‍♂️

  • @wiichannel0118
    @wiichannel0118 หลายเดือนก่อน

    WOKE PIECE
    WOKE WOKE FRUIT
    MONKEY D PRONOUNS

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  หลายเดือนก่อน

      I didn’t see it that way but I respect your opinion.

  • @ChrisPierce-y1r
    @ChrisPierce-y1r ปีที่แล้ว

    Its bassed on a anime the whole story is good because they stuck so close to the original source material the characters are just like how they are in the anime witch came out before all this woke stuff came to life

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  ปีที่แล้ว

      Yes by most accounts, the spirit of the characters was captured accurately, even if they were race swapped.

    • @PrettyNightmare69
      @PrettyNightmare69 ปีที่แล้ว

      It was base on the Manga, not Anime. Yes there is a difference.

    • @ChrisPierce-y1r
      @ChrisPierce-y1r ปีที่แล้ว

      @@PrettyNightmare69 yeah I don't read manga but I know in some animes that are based on manga will be completely different like full metal alchemist the first original anime is way deferent then the manga that's the first time i learned that info but i also did not know the one piece anime and manga where deferent stories

    • @ChrisPierce-y1r
      @ChrisPierce-y1r ปีที่แล้ว

      @@PrettyNightmare69 I am unsure but is the original dragon ball manga go in a deferent direction then the anime ? And I know that the boruto manga is not a separate story it just is ahead of the anime i think

    • @ChrisPierce-y1r
      @ChrisPierce-y1r ปีที่แล้ว

      @@PrettyNightmare69 I am unsure of the Naruto manga and I think sailor moon manga and anime where completely different stories until they did sailor moon crystals it's the anime version of the manga

  • @SAVUFILMS
    @SAVUFILMS ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Best review of all time 10/10 i listen again

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  ปีที่แล้ว

      Wow thanks man! That means a lot!!
      Make sure to subscribe so you don’t miss my future videos 😊

  • @marpj6138
    @marpj6138 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    This is not the right series to look at this way because at its core it is mean to be diverse and it does become more political as we get to know more of the world. And have things considered "woke" is not necessarily bad, inserting it for a check list and compromising good story telling for them is the actual problem - something that One Piece never did despite having a colorful cast. But lets review your points:
    - Racial diversity: there are only one real race swap in the series with Lucky Roux and its a minor character that the actor actually looks good. People complained about Nojiko but in the anime she did have darker skin tone than Nami (being adopted and all it makes sense). Still the world is mean to be diverse, the main crew would be one south american, two european, one african and one japanese if they exist in the real world plus there is lore for why people with Japanese-like culture are in the East Blue for example. With that said Vivi and Miss All Sunday casting for second season will probably create discussion on this topic
    - LGBT representation: there was really nothing in the East Blue and Koby actor did a great job appearing a wet noddle as they should at this point in time. But the second season will have Bon Clay, an Okama (drag queen, probably trans?) introduced in the original story in March of 2000, that is at first an antagonist but will become friendly in this very arc and is a fan favorite for being a good character. His existence have nothing to do with Woke culture or anything but I want to see how people will receive this amazing character. Or even better Ivankov which is heavily based on Tim Curry in Horror Picture Show - that will be fun
    - Toxic Masculinity/feminist message: wow, what a load of crap you said. So is Aliens and terminator 2 woke movies in your eyes? Even more so considering that the whole character arc about Nami was about learning on trusting other and ask for help (which is the opposite of the terrible "strong female" trope we saw the last few years in hollywood). This story is a rare show with a lot of positive masculinity and rolemodels (Shanks, Zeff, Garp) and the same go for females (Makino and Belmere, both which are kinda shafted in the LA). Not only that but each member of the crew have a role and they will do anything for their found family, they are all very capable even if in different areas - Nami is great navigator with more wordly experience, but she can at most fight the foot soldiers. Luffy is an idiot but he is a born leader and strong. Zoro is strong second in command and the one that keeps the head cold when necessary. Sanji is also strong fighter and an amazing chef (which is very important, even the trees are important to prevent scurvy as show in the original work). Usopp was done dirty in this season but he keeps things real and is the heart of the group as well a good inventor (he created his special bullets) and repairing the ship - Nami is show competent in her area and that is not feminist message, that is just good writing
    - Tradition: this is weird since One Piece is a revolution tale. Even the first season Garp side is all about letting the new generation lead. The crew themselves dont care about it, but they are pirates because they refuse to bow to rules they find stupid and will act against those that wronged them or their friends.

    • @marpj6138
      @marpj6138 ปีที่แล้ว

      also last point: anti-capitalism/pro-socialism - neither are really seen in the series as a whole, we do go deep into good and bad rulers and other social themes but not really on economic ones

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  ปีที่แล้ว

      So you basically agree with me on 4 out of the 5 criteria, and the one you disagree on (toxic masculinity/feminist messaging), you call my take "a load of crap" because I gave it a 1/10, whilst I'm assuming you give it a 0/10. For one point of difference you consider it a load of crap? Seems a bit extreme but ok...
      I could understand if I gave it a 9 or 10 but I literally had a tiny little gripe that made me give it a 1.
      And no I don't consider Ripley or Sarah Connor to be woke. And I don't consider Nami a woke character either. I just think they made 1 or 2 small choices that are influenced by post-modern feminism.

  • @halimmohamad8255
    @halimmohamad8255 ปีที่แล้ว

    Good observation bro. I think the idea of One Piece is it present equality and diversity. There are good character and evil. There also good female character and evil female character. I can say that th presentation in One Piece Live-Action or Anime most likely balance.

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Thanks for the compliment man! Yes I agree with that assessment!

  • @jondaan9194
    @jondaan9194 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    maybe you need read the manga
    love you bro

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Can never say never. Have no intentions currently but if the show continues to impress me, then maybe I’ll delve into them 👍

    • @jondaan9194
      @jondaan9194 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@kiksta well thats good, i hope season 2 have awesome adventure like season 1, but what i fear most is next crew of straw hat. will they have good cast or super suck cast. i hope i dont spoiler you. well see next adventure brother.

    • @andrewinat434
      @andrewinat434 ปีที่แล้ว

      ​@@kikstaas a fans, we don't force you sir. Just enjoy the journey

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  ปีที่แล้ว

      @@jondaan9194 Wait, are you saying that Luffy will have a whole new crew in season 2?? Forgive me, I know literally nothing about One Piece 😅

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  ปีที่แล้ว

      @@andrewinat434 will definitely let you know if i get into it 🙂

  • @mightyactionx9391
    @mightyactionx9391 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Dude, One Piece was woke even before the current, shitty, pain in the ass, and misguided and deranged woke was even invented. I mean, the LGTBQ+ community is vital to the storyline. They have an entire kingdom made entirely of them. They have their own culture, their own heirlooms, they even have a king/queen and practices a unique martial art called Okama Kenpo. In fact, three vital fighters of the recently resolved Wano arc are queers. However, they were represented healthily in the narrative unlike the Western LGTBQ+ of the real world which are deranged and getting worse by the day.

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Interesting to hear. I had literally no idea.
      But as you said, they're represented healthily and naturally, which I'm not sure I would consider woke then.
      Wokeness would be using them to push a certain agenda, but just having them existing within a universe, I don't know if I'd consider that woke...

  • @benzohhhhh
    @benzohhhhh ปีที่แล้ว

    Dawg I am crying 😂😂😂😭😭😭 W video

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  ปีที่แล้ว

      Lol glad I made you laugh, definitely wasn't my intention 😅

  • @bpbp7407
    @bpbp7407 ปีที่แล้ว

    dont talk about one piece

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  ปีที่แล้ว

      Was it something I said?...

  • @johnord684
    @johnord684 ปีที่แล้ว

    Nope

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  ปีที่แล้ว

      Agreed

  • @jimbeam-ru1my
    @jimbeam-ru1my ปีที่แล้ว

    Of course this live action is woke, it's netflix. It was obvious that it would be woke when they hired a jew woman to head the project. However, they tried to keep the woke politics more low key to start out with, but they will ramp up as the series progresses. Here are a few woke aspects of the show-
    1. luffy and his grandfather are different races now because progressive politics demand antagonists be white while heroes be black/ brown. It would have been fine for then to make both Garp and luffy mexicans, but to make garp white because he's the adversary and luffy brown because he's the hero is straight out of the woke playbook.
    2. Nami's character was tossed out and rewritten to be in line with feminist sensibilities. In the manga nami is a self centered gold digger that uses her looks to manipulate people. That was tossed out because she wasn't feminist enough. Now the character of nami is just a worn out hollywood cliche. There's nothing interesting about her at all.
    3. The live action is no longer a shonen. woke scumbags would rather kill themselves than create a product for a male audience. This is why the male bonding that occurred in the manga has been stripped from the live action and why girls that are hot in the manga are average in the live action. It's also why Alvida, who asked "who is the most beautiful woman" in the manga asks "who is the most powerful pirate" in the live action. Woke propaganda insists that women can't be concerned about their appearance.
    4. Black/brown people are given roles for no reason than their skin color. shanks crew having more blacks than a tarzan movie is an example of this. Another example of kaya, who looks really fucking stupid with that crappy blonde wig on. But she's brown, so they gave her the part and then triede to make her look white. Woke move there.
    I'd go on but I couldn't stomache more than two episodes of that crap live action.

    • @kiksta
      @kiksta  ปีที่แล้ว

      Wow, I had no idea about these changes.
      Again, I'm only judging the live-action in this video, as i obviously no nothing about the source material.
      Based on what you've explained, I can see how you consider the live-action to be woke. Perhaps I would feel differently too if I had read the Manga.
      That said, I don't consider it woke by today's standards, particularly when you compare it to what Netflix does with almost all their other series. In that regard, it was a breath of fresh air.

    • @ChrisPierce-y1r
      @ChrisPierce-y1r ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Dude most characters in jap anime are Japanese you know that right 😂😂 they race swapped because most Americans would not watch it if they thought it was some Japanese show

    • @ChrisPierce-y1r
      @ChrisPierce-y1r ปีที่แล้ว

      I'll give u the bad guys all being white I did not notice that

    • @ChrisPierce-y1r
      @ChrisPierce-y1r ปีที่แล้ว +1

      the anime is mostly Japanese characters so it makes sense in the American live action they would not all be Japanese I did not notice the other stuff cause it's the first live action anime that I was actually enjoying

    • @jimbeam-ru1my
      @jimbeam-ru1my ปีที่แล้ว

      @@ChrisPierce-y1r that's wrong. i'd be more enthusiastic about the live action if all the actors were japanese and the directors, producers and everyone else associated with it. Then it probably wouldn't be such a giant piece of shit.