Paul McCartney and/or Wings tier list
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ต.ค. 2024
- Note: tiermaker list failed on initial try and stupidly uploaded wrong image. Should post revised video before the next original.
All official releases 1970 to soundtrack; two compilations marked with * + only live by the group included. No dvd product admitted!
McCartney 8.2/A- only disliked then because Rolling Stone picked traitorous Lennon over “Macca”
Ram 9/A actually hated more but after Linda’s unfortunate death everyone loves it: hmmm
Wild Life 6.2/B gets better with age; definitely underappreciated
Red…Speedway 8/A- obviously much better than its former status among biased rock critics
Band on the Run (UK version without amazing “Helen Wheels”) 10/A+ nothing is less than vintage Paulie
Venus and Mars 9.1/A some like this best although it has a few lesser moments compared to predecessor
At speed of Sound 7/B+ Enjoy democratic approach, dislike approximately half the songs
Wings over America not rated Rockshow dvd good enough: Only diehards will need this
London Town 5.9/B Sadly overrated by some, Mr. Wings giving in to vices already used (often via better compositions) on interesting releases
Greatest * some tracks previously unavailable on LP upon release
Back to the Egg 8.1/A- Obviously his most panned record that is actually great
McCartney II 5.2/B- another so-called grower with surprisingly few bad stuff except couple bonus ones in CD reissue
Tug of War 8.9/A mostly great, probably expected after his ex-bandmate was mercilessly killed
Pipes of Peace 7.2/B+ slightly disappointing but still experimenting with largely positive results for largely-underrated album
Give my regards to Broad Street 5/B- enjoy new songs (all three not counting “playback” closer), hate remainder
Wingspan: Hits and History 7.8/A- very little not found above; grade applies to quality if wanting just one record by this fine artist/band - เพลง