DrPapperman This is a great part of the game. Sometimes I'll be hiding in a corner and when an enemy jumps in and I try to shoot him I just get that dreadful clicking sound and then get shot.
Swithun hahah same like the FG42 has a measly 20 round magazine compared to the other German weapons. The same thing happens when I use the Webley Revolver.
MemeMaster X we need to stop discrimination against clouds. It wouldn't happen if Hillary was president!!!!! Donald Trump is RACIST against ALL clouds!!!! UGH
OMG an Indie developer like New World Interactive whit a old Source Engine still so good vs Frosbite engine of a Big Studio like EA, congratulations to the NW team i am waiting Insurgency Sandstorm ❤
It's not like gun sounds in real life are drastically different, unless you're comparing a .50 cal to a 9mm. Shell sounds and cocking guns are going to sound the same in real life. Besides, they're using the same engine.
RandomVideos how the fuck do you not know what a comparison is yourself? The creator was trying to do the sound quality between each gun right? But the problem is that some guns that he compares have a similar look, but aren't actually the same gun. Think before you text lad.
Day of Infamy is at the moment far superior for gunplay, infantry gameplay and balance. Even with Source engine, models and sounds have as good quality as BF1. Just genius game. I love BF1 too, though.
Igbir True. Geometrically BF1 surpasses all other games. DOI has Source Engine which is not for a realistic immersive environments but rather cleaner and simple. Urban maps however do look great (even better than BF1) on DOI, as every single corner is made by mapper, not with those copy and paste assets which DICE has done since Bad Company 2. (all the maps have same buildings with different colors XD)
I never did understand why gameplay has to be balanced all the time. Seriously, it's war, and war is all about having better numbers than your enemy. Was it balanced when America broke away from Britain? No, the brits had a better military, and the Americans used guerrilla tactics to seize the day. In ww1, the French were sent in to charge at Germans with nothing but swords, and bright red and blue uniforms, and they got mowed down by machine guns, doesn't seem balanced to me. It's all about increasing your own numbers without the enemy knowing. Tactics is how you win a war, not the amount of troops you have. Quality over quantity.
Well... idc what people think... bf1 does have better graphics and sounds... but we can all agree than DOI has the most realistic reload (including insurgency)
+RandomVideos The Fact that the character moves his hands all over the place like he was having a seizure, and the insane speed of it... If you tried to reload that way IRL In the middle of a firefight, you would end up throwing your mags or rounds all over the floor
Garry Cole yes they are, I've talked to see gun nuts before, and yes, they are, not all of them, and most of them are exaggerated, but if you put audio setting on wartapes its sounds more realistic
also I like the fact that in day of infamy your rounds don't go flying all over the fuckin place a hundred meters apart when your shooing an lmg because that shit doesn't happen in real life unless your barrel is a fuckin noodle
+Clorox Bleach when the machine gun weighs over 50 pounds and has a slow rate of fire, recoil really isn't that much of an issue, granted you have the ability to hold the gun up for that long.
Daniel Antony well honestly the only reason I'd say it's rather unlikely is that most of the men in the First World War would have had minimal combat experience so it'd be likely that they won't be able to reload that quickly
Saying BF1 doesn't have realistic sound isn't really a valid criticism. When I play Battlefield, I'm playing a watered down summer blockbuster ultra macho action movie version of WW1, and I can accept that. When I play say Verdun, Day of Infamy, Red Orchestra, Rising Storm etc, it's because I want to play a down to earth gritty realistic version of X war. Chill and enjoy the games you enjoy.
I like how DOI added in that anticipation/jerk when you try to fire an empty weapon. I think it subtly shows the fear and sense of urgency that had to be going through the minds of these soldiers.
Excalibur 4249 You'd be surprised, but the reloads work perfectly for Day of Infamy and I wouldn't have them any other way. They make you be careful with your ammo, reload only when necessary and make you strategize and be a team player, rather than trying to rush head-first into the enemy.
Georg Grech yea I do agree that they aren't bad, I just wish that the operator didn't look like he had nothing to do. It's just it looks a little lazy when the operator is reloading and not like he is in battle. Little things they could have added to give that sense of urgency without making it look like he's rushing the reload would have been preferred imo. For example, instead of calmly grabbing the empty clip to get a new one, he could flick it or push it away so as to show that while he isn't rushing the reload, he is under a time constraint in battle.
Both of them have good sound design, and reload animation are excellent as well. Still can't fathom why the Vickers is a one-man portable MG in Day of Infamy tho.
5Ratar 45 i think the devs realise that as the description is that it is a machine gun that is actually heavy and it is impoaaible to equip both it and heavy kit (unlike every other MG in the game). I assume it is because there were not that many British MGs that were issued to troops.
To be fair, it was basically impossible to use on the move. We have no idea if British troops used it like an actual siege heavy MG, like the Browning 1919 that the Americans used, or the MG42. Those guns were only useful placed on the ground, or on platform.
dogtroop515 comsidering your one comment is about you firing a m249saw with zero recoil and you think doi sounds more realistic YOU HAVE NEVER FIRED A GUN have?
Yeah, the battle field 1 sounds are ramped up and less plain to make the game more exciting you could say, cause in reality most guns sound the same and the size of the blackpowder-charge usually determining the volume
Сергей Бурлаченко Realism does not = better, it's the gameplay and I've never played DOI but From a spectator standpoint, I think bf1 is better but unrealistic at times
Even as a huge Battlefield fan I have to admit .... Day of Infamy feels just soo real. I guess that's the difference between a gamer and a CoD fanboy......we can admit quality if we see it
Ian Smith its unrealistic but not pointless, it makes it far easier to track your shots so you can adjust your aim, quite useful actually. it makes more sense on night maps tho
Ian Smith It's too improve the Feedback of guns and make it easier to Spot enemies (considering how huge the maps are). And how does it make the gunplay worse? I mean it's unrealistic but it actually impoves gunplay!
their reloads are not better, just sloppy as fuck... looks like the soldier would rather die than reload the gun and then there is no urgency in the reload, looks more like a purposefully created vulnerability
just personal opinions i guess, i would rather prefer insurgency's reload versus battlefield's over the top reload. If they kept it lowkey like in the bf3 trailer I would have loved it.
i thought the BF fanbase was mature until all the fucking elitists came in bragging how much more realistic and better BF is in almost or every fucking way, machine gunner takes 15-30 seconds to reload and ready up because the gun and all the other shit hes carrying, in DOI it doesnt take that fucking long to finish reloading and thats why you need to get behind cover how about i say it like this: DOI aims to be realistic, BF1 (or BF in general)is more realistic than COD im not the kind of person that doesnt pay attention to detail on well made animations that take weeks or months to finish on an indie game
Yeah, when a game used by a professional engine is being compared to a Source game, of course DICE have more to work with. Let's be real, the BF1 animations look like you're beating up the gun to load it. Also, if you were loading a very heavy weapon while moving, I'm sure you would take 20 minutes too. Unlike BF1, where you can magically spawn clips at your hand as soon as you remove the empty mag out of the gun.
Day of Infamy reload animations are way better imho. They are more fluid and and has a really smooth transitioning. Most of the weapons are animated by Mr. Brightside, one of the best animators out there (He has a TH-cam Channel). You can't really reload a gun that fast in real life otherwise you'd either break or jam your gun; and also the stress factor induced in the middle of the combat. It takes good training to achieve such speed in reloading.
I like the Day of Infamy gun sounds better. Most of the Battlefield 1 guns just sound like "BOOF" or "BLOOSH", the Day of Infamy guns sound a bit more like the sharp, harsh crack of an actual gun (for the most part). It sounds more like your actually firing a gun, and less like you're listening to a gun being fired on the opposite side of a field while you have a pillow around your head.
BF1: I'M GONNA SMACK THAT HAMMER AND RIP OUT THAT BOLT ACTION! DOI: Hi, I don't want to break my guns :3 I like the DOI sounds better because there isn't a freaking loud as hell echo (unlike bf1) I like the bolt action sounds of bf1 better though
Can't really compare sounds to gameplay, most of the time people are more worried about gameplay than actually listening to what the sound of the gun/rifle is
I dunno man, the BF1 reloads seem too forced and fast, like some robot is behind the gun automatically reloading. On the other hand in Day of Infamy its like a damn sloth is behind the weapon.
Jimmy Fries If you practiced it tremendously or just have a knack at it. Reloading for most average Joe is very slow and inconsistent per reload time. Even under ideal conditions. Let alone being fired at while under stress. Where retrieving the magazine from whatever storage method your using, and then aligning the magazine with the mag well. Sounds easy on paper, but harder in reality.
I saw the thumbnail and bf1's lee-enfield looks like one of those airsoft gun. But if you at day of infamy, the lee enfield. looks gritty or old. And when i saw the whole comparison. I canceled my order for bf1 and got day of infamy for pc. Enjoying it so far.
0:08 to 0:10 Did anybody notice the different sound effect of the M1911 in BF1? PC Gaming Videos, did u change the sound effects of the weapon? Still curious
The Outsider And it sure is. Great weapons and gunplay, objective-based gameplay focusing on teamwork and like $40 cheaper. Even more when it's on sale for like $6.99
My opinions: M1911 - DoI Revolver - BF1 Luger - BF1 Mauser C96 - BF1 Trench Gun - BF1 Lewis Gun - DoI BAR - DoI Lee Enfield - BF1 Springfield 1903 - DoI Gewehr 98/Kar98k - BF1 Grenade - DoI Steilhandgranate - DoI Smoke Grenade - BF1 Vickers MG - Tie Knife - BF1 Flamethrower - BF1
Love DOI's animations. They did an awesome job on them. The attention to detail is next level. The little wiggle of the gun as it shifts while pulling the bolt or pushing in a stripper clip. The BF1 animations are passable, but idk if they knew how to rotate objects when making them.
People dont get that this video compares only the sounds. I dont see all the salt towards bf1, wich has clearly superior souds. BUT MUUUUUUUH REALISTIC GAMEPLAY
wow, they are both really good. call me bias but bf1 sounds are the slightest bit better, obviously graphics are better and gun models are better, but at times unrealistic, especially when it comes to the fast reload.
as big fan of BF series i have to admit, the sounds of Day of Infamy are really perfect! Especially the characteristic metallic sound of moving parts during shooting are really awesome!
Hardocore hello hello, Insurgency Sandstorm is gonna release in September. It is the game they were talking about. Pre orders are open. Only $30. 10% off for beta testers and 10% more off (a total of 20%) for people who own the current insurgency game.
ROUGE JERRY Cause it's faster. But in reality, for the average Joe, reloading is slow and inconsistent. Receiving the magazine, or clip from whatever storage method your using can effect the time. And then getting the mag or clip to align with the mag well. Even under ideal conditions it can still be slow. Now for people who practiced it tremendously or just have a knack at it. Yeah they can get better consistent time.
But who's gameplay is better? I mean think about it. Do you really pay attention to your gun sound? No you just shoot. I'd like to see gameplay comparisons.
UndeniablySmoothGaming you must be kidding me then. All bullets of any kind have black or gun powder, and should not sound that different, and plus, the echo is almost the same for every map.Plus, tracers were not used for every game, mostly in LMG or MGs and scoped rifles.Also, most of these guns don't even fucking exist, only in blueprints and others are just variants and prototypes.How is that realistic? Then there's the spread.When you shoot, it immediately spreads just as the bullet travels from the bullet, but bullets spread more the farther it travels, but in BF1 the bullet spreads and then travels straight, but should've been angled.Also, how does some LMG's and pistols have no upper recoil but the scoped rifles do? Some have the mag in a place that would increase the recoil, but somehow it has less recoil.Even a AT rocket, tank turret, artillery truck cannon, flak cannon, and field gun has less recoil than a scoped rifle, although there are factors where a scope does add recoil, but still, they fire huge shells with tons of powder and a large mechanism that should give huge amounts of recoil. Now there's more, but I think you would get the point by now.
Jamon Cocido the Gewehr 98 & Kar 98 are the same rifle except for the fact that the Kar 98 has a shorter barrel & a rolled bolt. Same action, same trigger group, same ammunition.
BF1: Ah~
DOI: FUCK ME GRENADE!!!
ikr
KJ Lin CS 1.6: *FIRE IN THE HOLE*
Some Weeb Call Of Duty : ding~
I think its "FUCK M8 GRENADE!!!"
JDaniel Martinez As a Londoner, I can confirm it's "Fuck Me" not "Fuck Mate"
I like that in Day of infamy it doesnt auto-reload, you can still pull the trigger and nothing will happen until you reload, a nice subtle touch
DrPapperman yea but i like that style :3
Older Battlefield games have that too but too bad they changed it
DrPapperman This is a great part of the game. Sometimes I'll be hiding in a corner and when an enemy jumps in and I try to shoot him I just get that dreadful clicking sound and then get shot.
DrPapperman Same
Swithun hahah same like the FG42 has a measly 20 round magazine compared to the other German weapons. The same thing happens when I use the Webley Revolver.
A bad day to be a cloud
Jureg or a stone
Kaan Harmandalı or the ground
DAT BOI Well, stones are on the ground.
MemeMaster X we need to stop discrimination against clouds. It wouldn't happen if Hillary was president!!!!! Donald Trump is RACIST against ALL clouds!!!! UGH
TommanderR dude it was a joke against liberals who whine about Hillary losing and blame all their problems on Trump. I’m on the TrumpTrain.
OMG an Indie developer like New World Interactive whit a old Source Engine still so good vs Frosbite engine of a Big Studio like EA, congratulations to the NW team i am waiting Insurgency Sandstorm ❤
GOD FUCKING DAMMIT EA IS A PUBLISHER, DICE STANDS BEHIND THE FROSTBITE
Kikematamitos v
Finally! Someone who understands that EA is not a developer!
you can sign up for the insurgency sandstorm closed alpha right now
Kikematamitos ¿TY ISPANSKIY?
I've got to say, both games have great sound design.
Kokku-San Gaming & Chill true dat
Kokku-San Gaming & Chill agreed
Kokku-San Gaming & Chill until u realize day of infamys sounds sound exactly like insurgency
It's not like gun sounds in real life are drastically different, unless you're comparing a .50 cal to a 9mm. Shell sounds and cocking guns are going to sound the same in real life. Besides, they're using the same engine.
Especially for the engine limitations of Source. Frostbite has always had amazing sounds.
Starting to think that the only rule for comparisons is "If the weapons look the same we'll compare them".
yep
That is literally the purpose of these videos...
MAXZONE47 yep that's exactly how
MAXZONE47 That's literally what a comparison is how the fuck do you not know this!!??
RandomVideos how the fuck do you not know what a comparison is yourself? The creator was trying to do the sound quality between each gun right? But the problem is that some guns that he compares have a similar look, but aren't actually the same gun. Think before you text lad.
*throws grenade*
Fuck me, grenade!
*stares at grenade*
Shit!
*shrapnel hits face*
Greedy Gamer he could be trying to say "Fuck, me grenade!" Because he dropped it...
Greedy Gamer it's "FUCK MATE, GRENADE"
Grenade hits ground and then he says something because grenade is nearby
Tyler Rivera no its not its "fuck me, grenade". its a thing we say in ireland and the uk. you usually say it when you get scared or frightened.
Jason Poillot If somebody doesn't know what "Fuck me" means then they are just... dumb...
Grenade comparison
BF 1: *throws grenade* "Nyeh!"
DOI: *throws grenade* "FUCK MATE! GRENADE!"
-brit
Reginald Copperbottom: “NYEH”
I thought he set "fuck me grenade"
5:07 Lol again "Fuck Me Grenade!"
😂😂😂
Nova Xtreme Why is he saying that like he's not the one who threw it.The fuck?Some nonsense.
It's because it landed too close to him. If it went further he wouldn't of said that.
It's ''Fuck MATE, grenade!''.
Elgamer 200 No it's not
Day of Infamy is at the moment far superior for gunplay, infantry gameplay and balance. Even with Source engine, models and sounds have as good quality as BF1. Just genius game. I love BF1 too, though.
The geometry sorta sucks in DOI :/ but it really looks like a game worth playing.
Igbir True. Geometrically BF1 surpasses all other games. DOI has Source Engine which is not for a realistic immersive environments but rather cleaner and simple. Urban maps however do look great (even better than BF1) on DOI, as every single corner is made by mapper, not with those copy and paste assets which DICE has done since Bad Company 2. (all the maps have same buildings with different colors XD)
Yeah, I think I'll definitely get it. I need something to soothe my WWII craving and it looks brutal and hardcore. Loved insurgency too.
I never did understand why gameplay has to be balanced all the time. Seriously, it's war, and war is all about having better numbers than your enemy. Was it balanced when America broke away from Britain? No, the brits had a better military, and the Americans used guerrilla tactics to seize the day. In ww1, the French were sent in to charge at Germans with nothing but swords, and bright red and blue uniforms, and they got mowed down by machine guns, doesn't seem balanced to me. It's all about increasing your own numbers without the enemy knowing. Tactics is how you win a war, not the amount of troops you have. Quality over quantity.
THE POWWWERRR It's a game not a fucking war simulation.
DOI>>> Sorry BF1
Bynho Silva agreed know something else? DOI isn't politically correct like BF1.
Delta 23 How is bf1 politically correct? Just take a look at cod ww2
Delta 23 there is a thing called, "Opinion"
Well... idc what people think... bf1 does have better graphics and sounds... but we can all agree than DOI has the most realistic reload (including insurgency)
Both are really good imo.
day of infamy reloads are more realistic
Stephan El Shaarawy Did you even read the title of the video?
dariomasi9 He cant give a opinion on the animations because its titled sounds how fucking childish is that
Just said it
Stephan El Shaara What is fake about the battlefield animations anyways?
+RandomVideos The Fact that the character moves his hands all over the place like he was having a seizure, and the insane speed of it... If you tried to reload that way IRL In the middle of a firefight, you would end up throwing your mags or rounds all over the floor
BF1 sound is so good but DOI sound so real
Kawaii Army yeah,but not completely.
SGT. Mamah 2:23
SGT. Mamah bf1 sounds are actually pretty realistic
GAM1NGgeek 369 nope
Garry Cole yes they are, I've talked to see gun nuts before, and yes, they are, not all of them, and most of them are exaggerated, but if you put audio setting on wartapes its sounds more realistic
Gun models in day of infamy are more accurate i like bf1 but for realism day of infamy is better
Hodor Hodor กาก
Hodor Hodor bruh like no recoil on pistols
กิตติพงค์ อานนท์ กาก nigga
กิตติพงค์ อานนท์ ว้าาาาาาว
@@t.k.326 thats racist you said the nword
also I like the fact that in day of infamy your rounds don't go flying all over the fuckin place a hundred meters apart when your shooing an lmg because that shit doesn't happen in real life unless your barrel is a fuckin noodle
dogtroop515 lmao
dogtroop515 wow.Who the fuck said that BF1 is a realism simulator?
dogtroop515 there's this thing called "recoil" maybe you've heard of it?
Clorox Bleach probably not.
+Clorox Bleach when the machine gun weighs over 50 pounds and has a slow rate of fire, recoil really isn't that much of an issue, granted you have the ability to hold the gun up for that long.
I like the reloads in Day of Infamy more. the bf1 reloads seem far too fast for how much he's forcing the guns.
Some Weeb At least it is not like Verdun. Way too fucking slow.
bu-bu-but realism...
Some Weeb Well.It's not impossible to reload with BF1's speed.It mostly depends on the situation and your sanity state.
Daniel Antony well honestly the only reason I'd say it's rather unlikely is that most of the men in the First World War would have had minimal combat experience so it'd be likely that they won't be able to reload that quickly
Some Weeb well when you're in combat and not at the a shooting range....
Both are good but I choose DOI above BF1.
*TRIGGERED*
vertti syrjälä What?
SirFancytheScotsman more realistic, you need teamwork, check corners, suppress the enemy
Brett8792 what?
SirFancytheScotsman What?
Saying BF1 doesn't have realistic sound isn't really a valid criticism. When I play Battlefield, I'm playing a watered down summer blockbuster ultra macho action movie version of WW1, and I can accept that. When I play say Verdun, Day of Infamy, Red Orchestra, Rising Storm etc, it's because I want to play a down to earth gritty realistic version of X war. Chill and enjoy the games you enjoy.
Cinephilia Embodied uncharted is way better than both tbh
BLUE GAMER Hell nah, Mario Kart 8 beats all of them.
i h*ckin luv meinkraf !!!!!!!
I agree, but your claim is really null, considering there is no World War Uncharted game.
TheOneWayDown well spoken.
I like how DOI added in that anticipation/jerk when you try to fire an empty weapon. I think it subtly shows the fear and sense of urgency that had to be going through the minds of these soldiers.
Jackstacs thats bull because they are in no rush to reload their weapon. They are all super sluggish for a war game.
Excalibur 4249 You'd be surprised, but the reloads work perfectly for Day of Infamy and I wouldn't have them any other way. They make you be careful with your ammo, reload only when necessary and make you strategize and be a team player, rather than trying to rush head-first into the enemy.
Georg Grech yea I do agree that they aren't bad, I just wish that the operator didn't look like he had nothing to do. It's just it looks a little lazy when the operator is reloading and not like he is in battle. Little things they could have added to give that sense of urgency without making it look like he's rushing the reload would have been preferred imo. For example, instead of calmly grabbing the empty clip to get a new one, he could flick it or push it away so as to show that while he isn't rushing the reload, he is under a time constraint in battle.
Georg Grech or even better, add those small details while in battle, but when out of battle revert back to these reloads. Imo that would be the best.
Last time I checked the stripper clip for the Lee had to be lifted up to remove and not "flicked off".
Both are good
黃偉涵 And here we see a rare positive comment. Good job you're the real MVP
黃偉涵 thank you
Finally found the middle ground
Both of them have good sound design, and reload animation are excellent as well.
Still can't fathom why the Vickers is a one-man portable MG in Day of Infamy tho.
5Ratar 45 i think the devs realise that as the description is that it is a machine gun that is actually heavy and it is impoaaible to equip both it and heavy kit (unlike every other MG in the game). I assume it is because there were not that many British MGs that were issued to troops.
To be fair, it was basically impossible to use on the move. We have no idea if British troops used it like an actual siege heavy MG, like the Browning 1919 that the Americans used, or the MG42. Those guns were only useful placed on the ground, or on platform.
Rafe The Vickers in DoI can only be hipfired unless it's set on its bipod, iirc
If you can lift 86 kg-s than yea they can carry the vickers
day of infamy sounds more real
dogtroop515 Not completely.
No it's not.BAR and Lewis sound weird.
dogtroop515 comsidering your one comment is about you firing a m249saw with zero recoil and you think doi sounds more realistic YOU HAVE NEVER FIRED A GUN have?
you?
Yeah, the battle field 1 sounds are ramped up and less plain to make the game more exciting you could say, cause in reality most guns sound the same and the size of the blackpowder-charge usually determining the volume
That DOI guy is never ever gonna get a knife kill with that enthusiasm
DOI is better, more realistic
Сергей Бурлаченко Realism does not = better, it's the gameplay and I've never played DOI but From a spectator standpoint, I think bf1 is better but unrealistic at times
Сергей Бурлаченко I think you got it backwards.
O r, So wrong mate. Insurgency and Day of Infamy might not have the graphics of BF1 but they have the leg up in gameplay any day of the year.
FinKicks Really the graphics are from a 2003 engine and they look way better than Bf1 that had nearly 3 years to be made compared to DOI
Shut up battlefield 1 is Better than your mom
Even as a huge Battlefield fan I have to admit .... Day of Infamy feels just soo real. I guess that's the difference between a gamer and a CoD fanboy......we can admit quality if we see it
Vincent Law idk what that has to do with cod but yeah doi is more realistic
And you're one of the few people who are the reasons that the Cod fanboys and Bf fanboys go at each others throuts.
Heroes and generals vs Day of infamy
Fachri Muhammad day of infamy by far
H&G has trash sounds
Jeremy Lim lol true
H&G sounds feels like they were taken out of An old CoD game lol...
jpardoa94 but old cod way more better than that trash 😂
Lol, flamethrowers only cover that much? Only 9 fuckin feet? Hell, most flamethrower could reach beyond 30 feet.
Amateur001 ww1 bud
Isaiah Towers same thing goes, the maximum effective range of the Wex was around 15 meters
Isaiah Towers still had more than 20feet of flame range during WW1, mate.
it's called game balance dude
Yeah, of course. but I've heard that both were supposed to be a real life sim?
poor clouds
kimjongkek poor guy in your profile pic
kimjongkek
kimjongkek nah they fine
I honestly dislike the gunplay in bf1 because every shot appears to be a tracer bullet. It is so unrealistic and pointless
Ian Smith its unrealistic but not pointless, it makes it far easier to track your shots so you can adjust your aim, quite useful actually. it makes more sense on night maps tho
GAM1NGgeek 369 in real life... wait it is BF1
Ian Smith still, how does something that helps, ruin gunplay for you
Ian Smith It's too improve the Feedback of guns and make it easier to Spot enemies (considering how huge the maps are).
And how does it make the gunplay worse? I mean it's unrealistic but it actually impoves gunplay!
Yall forget... Tracers work both ways.
It even said so as one of the death quotes in CoD!
Notice that the SMLE in BF1 at @3:26 doesn't have the hammer locked back when ready to fire. But the SMLE in DoI has it.
TheJuzy In the CTE they have.
TheJuzy that's bc in bf1 it's the mk3 in doi it's the mk4
PBS-Old There is still a hammer... every gun has a hammer. That's what strikes the primer, setting off the round.
jermafobe Technically that's not true, Firearms can have Hammer Assemblies, or Striker Assemblies. There's a big difference.
WaterDamagedBook Ok, then. I can see what warranted that comment. But both games have different assemblies.
Days of Infamy remembers that the Lee-Enfield and the Gewehr have visible hammers.
twitter.com/iKiWYs/status/852852021258485760
Wow! Both equally impressive. I enjoyed them both great video.
I like how in day of infantry how when you need to reload it does not do it for you it makes the tick nois until you reload
Merle Dixon stfu darly
Kaan Harmandalı Why? He is just saying he likes something, darling.
Day of infantry?and also you can reaload everygun when ever you want
@Flightstuff im pretty sure there is an option for that
@Flightstuff welp i have bought day of infamy years ago lol
You forgot about rifle grenade mate
Edgy Teenager The combo of your profile pic and username go so well together.
Some Weeb true
Some Weeb The combo of ur name and ur life got so well too
this is gonna be filled with ahegao, i'm calling it
Make_America_Great_Again Prove it
Battlefield has the better sound effects but I prefere the reloads of Day Of Infamy
Dr. Anonymus yeah it's a lot more low key and less exaggerated
The sounds of DOI are good too, but yeh their reload are better.
their reloads are not better, just sloppy as fuck... looks like the soldier would rather die than reload the gun and then there is no urgency in the reload, looks more like a purposefully created vulnerability
just personal opinions i guess, i would rather prefer insurgency's reload versus battlefield's over the top reload. If they kept it lowkey like in the bf3 trailer I would have loved it.
Dr. Anonymus Damn right.
Day of Infamy has way better animation and weapon sounds in my opinion.
i thought the BF fanbase was mature until all the fucking elitists came in bragging how much more realistic and better BF is in almost or every fucking way, machine gunner takes 15-30 seconds to reload and ready up because the gun and all the other shit hes carrying, in DOI it doesnt take that fucking long to finish reloading and thats why you need to get behind cover
how about i say it like this:
DOI aims to be realistic, BF1 (or BF in general)is more realistic than COD
im not the kind of person that doesnt pay attention to detail on well made animations that take weeks or months to finish on an indie game
Yeah, when a game used by a professional engine is being compared to a Source game, of course DICE have more to work with. Let's be real, the BF1 animations look like you're beating up the gun to load it. Also, if you were loading a very heavy weapon while moving, I'm sure you would take 20 minutes too. Unlike BF1, where you can magically spawn clips at your hand as soon as you remove the empty mag out of the gun.
Randomguy 0011 aside from on grenades
Day of Infamy reload animations are way better imho. They are more fluid and and has a really smooth transitioning. Most of the weapons are animated by Mr. Brightside, one of the best animators out there (He has a TH-cam Channel). You can't really reload a gun that fast in real life otherwise you'd either break or jam your gun; and also the stress factor induced in the middle of the combat. It takes good training to achieve such speed in reloading.
CRIMNALSNEAK And we found our battlefield fanboy
I like the Day of Infamy gun sounds better. Most of the Battlefield 1 guns just sound like "BOOF" or "BLOOSH", the Day of Infamy guns sound a bit more like the sharp, harsh crack of an actual gun (for the most part). It sounds more like your actually firing a gun, and less like you're listening to a gun being fired on the opposite side of a field while you have a pillow around your head.
Dragan232 bf1 recorded the real life gun sounds.How can something sound more realistic than real life.
Ghibirdic Violeta I agree with you but the Hellriegel was not an actual gun record because there's not any models left of that SMG.
Can you do Day of Infamy vs. Day of Defeat? (If you haven't already)
if you havent watched this yet then here
th-cam.com/video/zPTU_p8ljl4/w-d-xo.html
Hehe, "FUCK MATE, GRANADE!!!"
Yeah doi has some brutal words hehe
Rip ears
I just love the DOI flamethrower effects. Really gorgeous fire particles.
Most of the guns sound better in Day of Infamy for me. BF1 is kinda unrealistic at most sounds and has way too much echoing in open spaces.
DoGGyPlays DOI is louder but bf1 uses real audio clips of real guns so
You've obviously never shot a gun before, I see.
DoGGyPlays I sure have
DoGGyPlays This video isn't about realism.
DoGGyPlays I have. Bf1 wins. open space is bf1.
BF1: I'M GONNA SMACK THAT HAMMER AND RIP OUT THAT BOLT ACTION!
DOI: Hi, I don't want to break my guns :3
I like the DOI sounds better because there isn't a freaking loud as hell echo (unlike bf1)
I like the bolt action sounds of bf1 better though
BF1: Oh no! I am gonna load the bolt fast!
DOI: Oh no, I have to load the chamber slow, I don't want any jams.
In doi the devs thinked better cuz if you try to reload a bolt action rifle like a fast john wick it can jam.
Battlefield reloads feels so dramatic.
The Day of Infamy guy doesn’t seem to be in much of a hurry
InfiniteSolutions Probably because he can break the weapon if reloading verrryyy fast?
BF1 has these intense looking reloads and then there's Day of Infamy being chill asf
DOI has real human reload speed
samuel sansregret
Lol ok. So, when you're in the heat of battle, do you reload as fast as the one in DOI?
***** also the horses..they're almost immortal.
Daniel Esen J. Oliviėr Because when you're in a war you're always chill
Daniel Esen J. Oliviėr if no one is there to cover him he would switch to his secondary or have to reload fast
I love how it's a gun sounds video but then we get knifes near the end
I feel bad for the sky :(
:(
He probably shot god on accident
Days of infamy looks more professional, like you're just another soldier. nice touch
Can't really compare sounds to gameplay, most of the time people are more worried about gameplay than actually listening to what the sound of the gun/rifle is
The Vault Guy Yeah but better sound is more immersive.
5:07 me when eveyone on bettlefield is spamming grenades as hell
I dunno man, the BF1 reloads seem too forced and fast, like some robot is behind the gun automatically reloading. On the other hand in Day of Infamy its like a damn sloth is behind the weapon.
That's because you can't load a gun too fast or shit will break.
You'd jam your gun if you reload too fast.
Jimmy Fries
If you practiced it tremendously or just have a knack at it.
Reloading for most average Joe is very slow and inconsistent per reload time.
Even under ideal conditions.
Let alone being fired at while under stress.
Where retrieving the magazine from whatever storage method your using, and then aligning the magazine with the mag well.
Sounds easy on paper, but harder in reality.
In the knife section BF1: " you like my knife,"
DOI: " that's not a knife this is a knife."
I Now I like Bf1 More, But I gotta Say DOI Is better.
I like bf1 more, but I gotta say doi is better
Wait what
Grenade in BF1 : nyeeeh~ " how cute "
Grenade in DoI : FUCK ME , GRENAAAADE !!!!
I saw the thumbnail and bf1's lee-enfield looks like one of those airsoft gun. But if you at day of infamy, the lee enfield. looks gritty or old. And when i saw the whole comparison. I canceled my order for bf1 and got day of infamy for pc. Enjoying it so far.
TheRealNebula glad you're enjoying it mate. It's better than this toxic piece of shit
You are being toxic yourself
5:09 F*ck Me Grenade !!! 😂😂😂
I think battlefield 1 gun sounds are too aggressive sounding where as days of infamy guns sound a lot more sharp and clearer.
That sound of the guns were recorded by the actual guns itself...
@@lex3800 Doesn't mean you can't still mess it up...
Whoah both games really nailed the animation and the sounds there, nice work especially the day of infamy
The way the animation for day of infantry looks when he reloads he seems so calm😂
0:08 to 0:10 Did anybody notice the different sound effect of the M1911 in BF1? PC Gaming Videos, did u change the sound effects of the weapon? Still curious
anyone think the DOI reloads animations are so calm... like they dont give a shit about the battlefield
Absie thanks for letting me know that :)
I love BF1 but this really makes me want DoI. The gun models, sound fx and reload animations are super crisp. Looks like a blast to play.
The Outsider And it sure is. Great weapons and gunplay, objective-based gameplay focusing on teamwork and like $40 cheaper. Even more when it's on sale for like $6.99
day of infamy worth buying?
Ravindra Yi
Absolutely
nope if you ask me
it looks like f2p game that is copying cod ww2
p3t4r how is it copying when it's a mod like 2 or 3 years ago
Day of Infamy is the best money i have ever spend in games
I fucking lost it at 'fuck me grenade! Ah shin!'
Bf1 models with Days of Infamy animations
"Eghh" vs "FUCK ME GRANADE!"
The smoke is better in Day of Infamy
BeKoRs True but you can see the animation is kinda choppy
"Fuck me GRENADE" 😂😂
My opinions:
M1911 - DoI
Revolver - BF1
Luger - BF1
Mauser C96 - BF1
Trench Gun - BF1
Lewis Gun - DoI
BAR - DoI
Lee Enfield - BF1
Springfield 1903 - DoI
Gewehr 98/Kar98k - BF1
Grenade - DoI
Steilhandgranate - DoI
Smoke Grenade - BF1
Vickers MG - Tie
Knife - BF1
Flamethrower - BF1
KillerDud301 sounds like you pulled everything out of your ass.
Daniel Antony Dumbass
G98 and Lee Enfield - BF1?
Fuck me...
KillerDud301 The flamethrower goes to BF1? You gotta be kidding.
Skunk Gaming It's a liquid, not a gas. So yeah goes to Bf1
5:07 THIS ONE KILLING ME LAUGHING "FUCK ME...GRENADE!!!!!"
5:08 DING!!! LOL
nice,maybe mw3 vs mw2 next?
Sure!
PC Gaming Videos thank you :)
hands down to the one of the best quote when throwing a grenade
"FUCK ME GRENADE"
i swear i want mw2 vs mw3 goddamit
will come ;)
Gordon Freeman pea shooter sounds vs pea shooter sounds? okay
3:23 The clip just disappear right there WTF
The smoke in BF1 looks really shitty
I love those "ping" and "ding" sounds from several emptied guns.
B1 reloads way faster
PremiumSkies 21 BF1 is fast paced.
because it's an arcade shooter
thismaneistoobigforyouscrub420 xxddynoscopeblazeit Great logic there.
Love DOI's animations. They did an awesome job on them. The attention to detail is next level. The little wiggle of the gun as it shifts while pulling the bolt or pushing in a stripper clip. The BF1 animations are passable, but idk if they knew how to rotate objects when making them.
People dont get that this video compares only the sounds. I dont see all the salt towards bf1, wich has clearly superior souds. BUT MUUUUUUUH REALISTIC GAMEPLAY
(Hint: IF YOU FUCKING RELOAD A GUN LIKE USAIN BOLT IT WILL FUCKING JAM)
@@sabotabby_ yeah
I love how this channel is shattering FPS communities and friendships.
84% of people in the polls picked it only because they haven't heard of day of infamy 😀
"FUCK ME, GRENADE!" "OH SHI--" [boom]
wow, they are both really good. call me bias but bf1 sounds are the slightest bit better, obviously graphics are better and gun models are better, but at times unrealistic, especially when it comes to the fast reload.
GAM1NGgeek 369 well,BF is just a fast paced game,but in never really does things unrealistically.It'sjust more like a... fantasy or some shit.
*"FUCK ME GRENADE! AH SHI-(KABOOM)"*
I Think DOI is more realistic than bf1
MemeMaster X hint-It is and it really isn’t close.
as big fan of BF series i have to admit, the sounds of Day of Infamy are really perfect! Especially the characteristic metallic sound of moving parts during shooting are really awesome!
COD : PEW! PEW! PEW
pop pop pop*
*ti ti ti
Jeddah boy BLELELELELELELELELELELELELELLELE!
Bop, bop, bop. *"Reloading!"* Bop, bop bop...
(In black female nazi voice speaking English for some reason) "reloading" pew pew pew
I heard they work on a unreal version of day of infamy THAT would be the ultimate shooter for me
Hardocore hello hello, Insurgency Sandstorm is gonna release in September. It is the game they were talking about. Pre orders are open. Only $30. 10% off for beta testers and 10% more off (a total of 20%) for people who own the current insurgency game.
BF1 animations look so angry
+SadSlav center*
It's a fucking war game. It doesn't matter if you live in America or not. Stop spewing bullshit.
the flamethrower on DOI it's beautiful!!
How do people acctually rhink bf1 has better reloads
ROUGE JERRY Because it’s so fast that it mask the ugliness of the animation.
Tempest Jay the animation isn't ugly it's just to fast
Honestly, as far as cycling the bolt really fast in bf1 is very accurate. You are trained to do so, in order to sight your targets faster.
ROUGE JERRY
Cause it's faster.
But in reality, for the average Joe, reloading is slow and inconsistent.
Receiving the magazine, or clip from whatever storage method your using can effect the time.
And then getting the mag or clip to align with the mag well.
Even under ideal conditions it can still be slow.
Now for people who practiced it tremendously or just have a knack at it.
Yeah they can get better consistent time.
Both are actually really awesome~ Love the snap on DOI though.
But who's gameplay is better? I mean think about it. Do you really pay attention to your gun sound? No you just shoot.
I'd like to see gameplay comparisons.
Yummy Pancakez
DoI = Realistic
BF1 = Unrealistic
Just a great video dude, also nice channel ^^
BATTLEFIELD 1-sound Day Of Infamy-reload (but not always)
I'd say BF1 has cooler reload animations but are too fast to be realistic, DOI wins there, as for sounds i prefer BF1 but DOI isn't bad
MrZodiac011 it's fast because the play style is in a fast pace. you don't want the reload to be slow or you'd be killed in bf1
Robert Lenchanko HAHAAHHAHAHAAHAHHAHAAHAHAA No, no it's not
MrZodiac011 speed of reload depends on conditions like state of mind and stuff like that
To be fair, New World Interactive are just a small indie company who don't make triple A games like Battlefield 1.
And they had better games thAn bf1 like doi amd insurgency sandstorm
Battlefield 1 weapons are not realistic
GAWATT Ohh boy,you don't know shit.
GAWATT Are you born in 1916?
Yea ım born in 1900 :D but ım 17 years old :D
UndeniablySmoothGaming you must be kidding me then.
All bullets of any kind have black or gun powder, and should not sound that different, and plus, the echo is almost the same for every map.Plus, tracers were not used for every game, mostly in LMG or MGs and scoped rifles.Also, most of these guns don't even fucking exist, only in blueprints and others are just variants and prototypes.How is that realistic? Then there's the spread.When you shoot, it immediately spreads just as the bullet travels from the bullet, but bullets spread more the farther it travels, but in BF1 the bullet spreads and then travels straight, but should've been angled.Also, how does some LMG's and pistols have no upper recoil but the scoped rifles do? Some have the mag in a place that would increase the recoil, but somehow it has less recoil.Even a AT rocket, tank turret, artillery truck cannon, flak cannon, and field gun has less recoil than a scoped rifle, although there are factors where a scope does add recoil, but still, they fire huge shells with tons of powder and a large mechanism that should give huge amounts of recoil.
Now there's more, but I think you would get the point by now.
GAWATT incorrect, they are quite realistic.
I might start playing day of infamy just so I can hear my guy yell fuck me grenade at the top of his lungs.
M98 and kar98 is not the same
Jamon Cocido the Gewehr 98 & Kar 98 are the same rifle except for the fact that the Kar 98 has a shorter barrel & a rolled bolt.
Same action, same trigger group, same ammunition.
relaxed reload - overload