TR-8S vs Digitakt // A lot has changed but which is best? (2024 comparison)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 พ.ค. 2024
- TR-8S vs Digitakt // A lot has changed but which is best? (2024 comparison)
Distribute your music with DistroKid - 7% Discount Link:
►distrokid.com/vip/liamkillen
CONTENT OF THE VIDEO
0:00 Hello // A Relevant and Updated Comparison
2:40 Learning Curve
5:30 Sonic Quality
8:47 Sequencer Comparison
15:03 Sampling
16:46 Compatibility with other Instruments / Software
18:29 Use DistroKid to Distribute your Music
20:04 How i’ve Implemented these into my own Set Up
Interested in purchasing some of the gear mentioned in this video? Support this channel while you're at it by using the affiliate links below:
USA (Perfect Circuit):
►Digitakt: bit.ly/3DJB4UB
►TR-8S: bit.ly/3itO8G3
EUROPE (Thomann):
►Digitakt: bit.ly/3S2pe0C
►TR-8S: bit.ly/47BfQH1
Need help with something? Book a 1 on 1 Consultation:
►www.liamkillen.com/consultation
Stream my Music:
►hyperfollow.com/lkmusic
Other Related Videos:
►TR-8S / 6S Update: • TR-8S / 6S UPDATE! // ...
►More on POs: • The Ultimate Pocket Op...
►TR-6S is Underrated: • How is the TR-6S so un...
►More about DistroKid: • Release Unlimited Musi...
SOCIALS:
►Instagram: / liamkillenmusic
►Tiktok: / liamkillenmusic
#tr8s #digitakt #dawless - เพลง
Distribute your music with DistroKid - 7% Discount Link:
►distrokid.com/vip/liamkillen
Interested in purchasing some of the gear mentioned in this video? Support this channel while you're at it by using the affiliate links below:
USA (Perfect Circuit):
►Digitakt: bit.ly/3DJB4UB
►TR-8S: bit.ly/3itO8G3
EUROPE (Thomann):
►Digitakt: bit.ly/3Rnd2ZM
►TR-8S: bit.ly/3rd1IEP
Digitakt is deeper, but the TR-8S feels more like an actual instrument that you play, instead of a machine you have to work.
Yeah that’s pretty much it
but just don‘t leave the surface of TR-8S, otherwise the real work struggle starts
Analog Rytm is more or a TR-8s competitor in the sense that it's got more performance controls available, internal sound design capability, and separate outputs.
But obviously, they don't match pricewise, TR-8S is 2X cheaper! So that comparison would be interesting, too. I personally went with Rytm because of its pads that both provide a way to finger drum, but are also a performance tool with the pressure macros. Plus I wanted to scratch that analog itch, and the master compressor and distortion on Rytm really deliver.
But I'd probably be happy with a TR-8S, too.
excellent sum up ^ the tr8s interface mode is gonna be useful for those without a console etc so there plenty there if your starting out or pro . the midi clock still needs offset compared to elektron a negative . its just a tad mind.
Welcome to the rytm club you won’t be disappointed it’s a beast, love mine the performance knob is really versatile.@@RPLKTR
Lots of coverage ... content as usual .. great detailed information highlighting the ins ..
outs .. ups .. downs .. hills and valleys .. leaving no stone un-turned .. cheers to your always easy to follow lead ...and thanks!
Cheers to you!
Thanks again Liam! Clear as water, like always. Im looking a decision for my very firt groovebox and you are helping /teaching me a lot. When i have, i will go directly to your patreon samples.
Glad to help and thanks as always for watching!
I can’t speak for the Digitakt but as regards to the Tr8s learning curve, once you’ve got it, you’ve got it! And it’s pure fun times onwards!!!
Absolutely!
tr8s have individual out?
@@joel82045 yep it does, with the digitakt just stereo, but if you load it into your computer via overbridge, you then have 8 individual tracks to process as you please.
The bigger elektron boxes have individual outs 👍
@@joel82045 yes, 1 stereo pair plus 6 individual outs.
Great video - I have the TR8S and I love it.
I've got to say though, I don't know why anyone would get confused as to which to buy in a head to head unless they knew nothing about them. They are massively different - which did come across in your video.
The editor software for the 8S is very good if you are comfortable using a computer to set up your kits, and then performing live later with just the hardware.
Yeah they’re very different and have continued to grow apart over the years
Agreed, the editor is very good.
@@LiamKillen That's what makes them both unique :) ...... Man, what a good to to be alive with audio gear !!
Really love your presentation style man. Very informed and even keel. Subscribed!
Appreciate you! If you’d like access to synth info 2.0- my discord is also very helpful for more specific questions!
discord.gg/xj8J2xJuBP
Digitakt was the last box I purchased from Elektron, having bought the Digitone and Syntakt first. It’s easily my favorite of the three, even in 2024. Digitakt can stand on its own, but it blooms when you pair it with other devices because it communicates so well with its eight MIDI tracks. I slept on the DT and I’m sad that i didn’t get it sooner.
I agree 100% . It also pairs well with the TR-8S 😏
@@LiamKillen truth. I tell everyone who will listen about the digitakt. I honestly think it’s a modern classic and most musicians can benefit from owning one.
Pair it with a multi-timbral synth like access virus. It's insane.
Yeah, I could see using both together with a little synth. The hybrid jammy factor of the 8S seems delightful, but the compositional heft of the DT can’t be beat from that standpoint.
I bought a Syntakt a while back and just wondering if you know whether or not it's different enough from Digitakt to warrant having both?
Super comparison Liam
Thank you as always for watching 😊
Great content!
Thx for watching :-)
I had both but ended up selling the Digitakt. I kept the TR-8S because of how much faster it is to find or audition sounds, as well as inputting weak beats, and being more hands and more performative. Having a fader for each track is pretty really nice.
Yeah if it fits it fits
Fader fox midi controller can fix that
@@lorrenaelliott161 Yea for hundreds more dollars and having to manually setup everything. Not saying it's a bad option, but with the TR-8S, you have everything there.
correct , audition of digi range is lacking auto load for the recorded notes playing and that is totally boring , wears out keys and if you got banks a to h loaded means , three days to audition and not 3hrs .
I've had a TR-8S for a while now and it's been fantastic for me especially given I mostly do techno with it so I'm constantly using the 909 kits on it. It also pairs extremely well with my MC-707 that makes up the other half of my current hardware set up which I'm very happy with and have managed to squeeze several track out of so far. For me where live performability is a key factor even during the composition process it's been a huge boon. Plus never having to really look another TR x0x plugin or sample pack is a very nice thing.
Exactly! Never really got into the Mc 707 I’m sure it’s dope AF
I've enjoyed it, had it since last February and got the TR8S to add to it like 3-4 months ago. It's definitely not every one's cup of tea for one thing making your own patches with it if you get complex can quickly devolve into Roland menu dive purgatory. Granted having the full Zen Core system on a groovebox is nice it just definitely has some downsides to it.
With the two I've managed to get upwards of about an EP's worth of material I'm working on adding finishing touches to and doing final mixdown on here soon hopefully and looking forward to getting even more out of the two together in the near future.
Thanks for this, I haven't seen these devices compared that way. when you play live(if you do idk) anyway are you using Both, or something entirely different.?
I use tr 8s + Ableton mostly- here’s a live perf I recently did actually: th-cam.com/video/TT268te3jkg/w-d-xo.htmlsi=goCNJJ9-HBuiCjPF
Stellar content as always! Can you provide a link to those fancy light blue rca wires w the white?
Check out candy cords from MyVolts!
Thanks! Just what i needed. Got me decided on TR8s, there's no competition in this price range and it looks like a perfect live performance tool.
I think you made the right decision :-)
very odd question but - what are those jack cables? looking for something to make my studio feel as neat as possible :). great video btw
MyVolts Candy Cords!
Thx for watching 😊
Excellent one thks !!! HNY & All the best )))
You too!
love my tr8s and how easy it is having everything in front of you, but would love to see a video just about using the tr8s with Ableton, for someone who's never used Ableton. thanks for the videos!
You mean this? 😊 th-cam.com/video/lbcukLIta5E/w-d-xo.htmlsi=DbrIqb00bIbvpTf8
I’ve been gassing out over the Digitakt a lot recently but been trying to figure out if it would bring enough to my setup, I feel like it’s really awesome like you said for inspiring composition but I’ve already got a TR8s and the brain of my setup is an iPad so probably a lot of the roles it would fill I’ve got covered. I like your sending midi to Ableton trick, I’ve been doing the same with my iPad. Decided I don’t need kit sounds on all faders (I always end up in an “all faders up” situation so it’s good to have some limitations there) so one I’ve just started using as an fx fader for the mix value on an iPad app called Transit, makes for cool transitions.
I bet the digitakt would make for a more solid brain then the I pad- just sayin’ !!
I have the TR-6S and the Digitakt and use them both a lot for very different things. The TR-6S just sounds SO good (as does the DT), and it's very easy to get something going and jam some patterns on it. I'm actually hoping to upgrade to the TR-8S when I can afford it. The Digitakt just fits the way I think about music so well and it's always full of surprises. I kind of use it like a (limited) groovebox, but it's fun to use with external gear as well. Some of the most rewarding sessions I've had is with a setup of just the DT and the 0-Coast, it was kind of amazing how much I could get out of that. And the recent DT updates are so amazing!
I think that once you update to the 8s you will be a VERY happy camper. It teams really well with the Digitakt actually
@@LiamKillen Good to hear! And I've been really enjoying your videos so much recently. The live techno with the Rytm walkthrough last month was great, but I had a few eureka moments with your drum layering video the other day, which I know is from a few years ago. Thanks again!
Interesting, got the Tr8s first. Paired it with a MC707 but quickly thought that downgrading the 8s to a 6s would suit my DAWless setup best, but realised that I am very unhappy with the sound-depth as well as quality of this Roland product line.
End up with keeping the 707 to pair it with a Syntakt and an Access Virus.
Haven't stoped giggling while jamming ever since
Mc 101 + DT is actually 🔥. 101 is a great rompler
When people perceive a degradation in their samples on the Digitakt, it may be due to the forced mono conversion. I don’t remember if it sums the channels or prompts you to pick one, but some stereo samples can sound subdued after that conversion. I used to convert mine before transferring them to the Digitakt.
Yeah absolutely- that’s the thing with it- honestly I’m fine with it
I’m curious what kind of audio cables those are? They look really nice!
All my audio cables are from myvolts!
I use tr6s and digitakt. I use both…switch between them for projects. Keeps it fresh for me. I also sometimes sample from tr into Digitakt. I love 606 based kits :)
Yeah digitakt + tr-6S might even be a better combo in a way because it’s so compact!
Thanks Liam, will be a TR-8S for me then :)
Glad to help
Would like to see you do a video comparison in performance mixing between the Roland MX1 vs the Elektron mixing workflow.
I don’t own the MX1! Yet… 😏
I have both, and it's exactly that. Live/control vs 'power'. to me, the DT wins out. workflow. That sequencer. The sample control. it's also the brains of my set-up now. It's my Desert Island box, for sure.
would love to know ore about the TR8s with Ableton...... that could be fun.
Here’s a video you might be interested in then: th-cam.com/video/9ReiYE60hDQ/w-d-xo.htmlsi=j5cq8ygJhsy4DSvn
So enjoyable to watch
Thanks for watching! Always appreciated
@@LiamKillen ✌🏽☺️✨
In the last section of your video. Where you’re controlling Ableton on the first five voices of the tr8s, are you sequencing those voices with the tr8s also or have you put the steps down in Ableton and then just using it as a controller to change delay, reverb etc?
Those are samples that I’ve made with other DAWLESS gear- so I’m getting that sound while still having the efficiency of using Ableton as a brain
@@LiamKillenI think I worded this wrong. I wanted to know if you are using the sequencer on the tr8s to send midi to Ableton to trigger the drum rack in Ableton or if you had to put steps down in Ableton I’m sure this could be done was wondering if that was the case here and if it was intuitive. Thanks for this video though. Appreciate it.
Is there anything that comes close to the Syntakt Pattern and Track Sequencer for an alternative drum synths thank Nick
Digitakt !!
Also - we discuss this kind of stuff in my discord all the time - if you're not already a member, here's an invite! discord.gg/xj8J2xJuBP
@@LiamKillen thank you and set up the account 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Loving the FM from the TR8S.
Yes! A recent (ish) addition :-)
Would you say your thoughts about the Digitakt mostly apply to the Syntakt as well?
Not as familiar with the syntakt!
New subscriber here. Can you do classic rock style drums that are convincing? I am putting together a studio for the first time, though I have played guitar seriously for 50 years. I have always used a real studio and a good engineer. I want to try it myself. Is the TR-08S what you would choose?
Im struggling here. I leverage my SP404MK2 for sampling but my main drum machine is a Roland T8. Deciding on which of the two is the ideal replacement for the T8 is tough. Do you use the midi controller on thr digitakt often? I could see that as a win over the tr8s
I would just go two steps up with the TR-8S in this case - i actually did a video on exactly this which I think would help you out: th-cam.com/video/dCKqOVWBqbk/w-d-xo.html
forgot to mention digitakt's updates, it turned it into a whole other beast
Great machines, both! If you have only one of them, you can create almost any kind of beat or rhythm. Where the Roland has more tracks and multiple sound sources, the Digitakt can resample, which gives a lot of other possibilities. And yes, mono… but it’s aimed at drums, hits, stabs and short loops. With that kind of source material it’s a creative beast! As I use both of them together (and also a Syntakt) I don’t use the sample import function of the TR-8s at all. I use it as a classic drumcomputer with a lot of hands-on control… as one said before, it’s an instrument. The Digitakt for me is much more of a creative sampler for sculpting beats and top-loops, besides that it’s a great sequencer in a DAW-less set-up.
A solid take for sure! 😊
I have the Rytm, but the Digitakt is still the default machine I turn on if I want to make a beat. I’ve been promising myself that I’ll make a set with just the Rytm so I can get super deep into all the amazing things it can do, but I haven’t done it yet.
Yeah i'm sure you can easily do that. Thanks for watching! :-)
I found it interesting that this comparison focused on stuff you can do with the Digitakt versus stuff you can do with Ableton, using The TR-8S as a controller. As someone trying to create music without the assistance of a laptop, it seems like an apples to oranges comparison. You pointed out some of the great stuff Digitakt is capable of, then you kept showing screens of Ableton when you talked about the Roland. Based on your description, the only things missing from Digitakt for live performance is a few knobs and sliders, which you could easily add by getting something like a MiniLab3.
I can't argue with that - if you're willing to invest in a great controller for the Digitakt, you can of course very easily turn it into a performance machine in itself.
I'm an indie pop/rock musician mostly looking for something to add rhythm when I'm playing solo on guitar or piano and singing. Does one of these feel more suited than the other?
I would recommend the TR-6S! Here's a video: th-cam.com/video/ibaWpyekpJA/w-d-xo.htmlsi=2VsowVyo_2T1OY_j
@@LiamKillen thank you!
I find it very fascinating that each sampler have their own flavor when it comes to the sonic quality. I noticed that the same sample loaded on the SP404 and the DT will end up sounding different in a very obvious way.. It's hard to explain it some times, I would probably compare it to different guitar pickup tones.. Btw, this is why I don't use the SP404mkii as much as I would like to, because to me it always sounds lo-fi even with no effects on. I prefer DT's ''dark'' tone
Yeah the sonic quality is slightly different - and then there's the workflow which just completely changes everything up.
I have them both, and this video basically sums it up. I wish the Digitakt and TR-8s would make a baby. To have the best of both worlds in one machine would be amazing.
Your best bet is to combine them!
@@LiamKillen I agree, I was thinking the same thing. It would be cool to work up a good beat on the 8s then sample it into the Digi to further scalp and mold it into some kind of abandoned warehouse rhythms of my liking. Like dirty it up and filter it down too. The options are limitless. I’m gonna do that, thanks 👊🏼
Recently, I had first live with digitakt and the sound on 70% master was very quite, and when try to make it louder it start to hit the peeks:(( is there some solution for it. Should I get some external gear for it or have some other solutions? 😊
Hmmm that sounds like some sort of issue with the digitakt
That's pretty dope bruh
My guy
I just bought my TR8S... when you take the already made kits you can quickly have fun. However, to really get into the heart of the beast, you have to really invest yourself like any drum machine. On the other hand, I find it really affordable in terms of price and accessibility. I hope that I will give myself the perseverance to complete this device. I really like it at the moment. I spent another 4 hours on it and I feel like I spent 10 minutes.I wonder if we can take an instrument from a predefined kit and paste it into a white pattern? Because frankly there are predefined sounds that are incredible!
I'm glad that you're enjoying it! Def still one of my fav drum machines.
The TR8-S is an machine offering ACB variants of all the Roland classics with samples as added bonus. The Digidakt is a sampler, right? Wouldn't it be more 'fair' to stack it up against the MC-707?
I see where you're coming from but it's sooo much more than just a sampler - its sequencer takes it all to the next lvl. Come discuss it over in the Discord: discord.gg/xj8J2xJuBP
Agreed! Thanks! Digitakt for me. Adding a tr6s later (not tr8s).
Also a good choice though 😏
@@LiamKillen oh, I'll take all of those Perkons, Lxr, DFAM, Syntakt, Tr8s,... Don't get me started! Please... Do not...
It's not a Digitakt but a Model:Samples gets quite abit of Digitakt functionality for a fraction of the price - worth considering if on a budget to pair with a TR8s for sure.
I found your tip on using the TR8s as a performace mixer ane audio interface useful, i map a few sliders and knobs to control synths - cutoff, resonance etc on D16's Phoscyon and some fx as well.. really handy 🥳
Yeah model samples + tr-6S would be like a budget version of this set up
@@LiamKillen yeah totally - you would loose some functionality (sidechaining the Model:Samples via the Roland's analogue ins would be the biggest loss for me) but not enough to make it unworkable
You can use the TR8S as a beat sequencer for eurorack, which I have done often. but I agree that sequencing pitch or midi devices doesnt make much sense
I actually have a tr-8s / eurorack video in the queue!
@@LiamKillen great! I think an under highlighted feature. And the audio in can also attenuate the eurorack audio volume, and you can side chain the audio in, making it a good “interface” or “mixer” for a live session.
Hey! can you tell me about this lrft and right into trs cables please?
i mean where to buy it
I get all of my cables from MyVolts :-)
The TR-8s sounds incredible, especially in this comparison.
It does sound great 😏
I miss my Digitakt. Currently running a TR8-s and MC -707. They work well together. On top of that an added an SP-40 mk2 which I’m not gelling with. The Digitakt is way more intuitive and malleable.
It’s hard to compete with that sequencer
Absolutely love both machines. In the case of the TR-8S I prefer to use it with one pattern, and do everything live on it. If I'm going to program music, I'd much rather use an Elektron. (Syntakt is actually my favorite.) Really, there would be no reason not to have all of them or a couple of them, and use each one to its own strengths. There aren't a lot of things out there that are better than these, so they're still just as relevant as they ever have been. (Maybe the Modor Dr-2 or Erica Perkons, etc. if you want to go in more unique directions.) However, I'd say ANY Elektron is going to be amazing no matter what year it is. (did you catch the 1.7 update for the Rytm?) The Roland machines are great too, for different reasons IMO, but will remain relevant indefinitely. If you get along with the flow, then they are all very usable.
My thoughts exactly 😊
So question is, will you do a new video with tr8s vs digitakt mk2? :-)
yyyup - already brainstorming on it - i've talked about it a little over in my Discord already hehe: discord.gg/xj8J2xJuBP
@@LiamKillen I am not on discord but thanks.
That said, i own the tr6s and was just thinking how curious i would be to see an elektron device with faders one day.
When i first started using the tr6s i could not believe that i will be so happy of the little faders. They are almost a device by themselves. So intuitive to use when jamming. I got the digitakt mk2 but still find it a brainf… in comparisson when it comes down of simply re-leveling channels. The digitakt requires more braincells and concentration somehow
The only thing about the TR8s that makes me sad is no generic driver, it would be so clutch if i could connect it right to my iPad... I think of digitakt as more of a sound design machine, compared to the TR8s it's got much more perimeters for tweaking.
Yeah I’ve heard this before
What you say is specially true for the 6S. It is so small it makes no sense that it is not class compliant.
@@andesneko it would be a MUCH better box with generic drivers!
Anyone knows whether there's a way to connect the two so that you can kind of edit the drum samples live through the digitaly but "perform" them on the 8s?
You can probably find a way to control via midi with the Digitakt’s midi channels but I’m not sure how much sense that would make TBH.
I use the digitakt as loop player in song mode, my drums come out of the tr8. Thats possible sine the latest update on digitakt
So sick!!
I think they make good companions. TR8s for all the "traditional" drum sounds and DT for perc and one-shot samples, clutch!
Exactly !
Is the Digitech Elekdrum still manufactured?
My ultimate sound test with any digital box that I wish these videos would do is sample rate reduction plus pitch shifting (16 levels or something similar). Reduce the sample rate of a sample to 22khz or less, hear if it sounds like metallic trash like on a computer. If so, is just a plugin in a box for me sound wise. And no problem with that cause other aspects count but Im interested in sound. And I think this simple test would tell very obviously about digital calculations on these chips that manipulate the machine’s sound. Im curious about this on digitak.
Interesting! Thanks for this take!
@@LiamKillen I’d love to hear any elektron gear or a prophet x on low sample rates just to see if they could do it like the old guys or if the good musical digital lo fi is gone forever. If you can do it someday I’d appreciate it.
I’m eyeing that digitakt severely. It sounds like once you get passed the learning curve it’s a keeper for sure.
I’m severely recommending it
Tr8s looks very similar to a dj mixer whith 11 chanels😂. Do you think it can act like a mixer controlling the dj mode on sp 404 mk2? And have extra control on effects, like bus 3 and 4 on other 2 chanels? It would help me a lot!! Great content❤❤❤
I don’t think that’s possible because the 404 mk2 is stereo out only to my knowledge
So you can't control the faders on dj mode using midi from the chanels on te tr8? I was dreaming about to do that passing the sound from tr8 into the SP and controlling totaly the sp kinda like a shik controller plus drummachine🥹
Would be nice to map the low, mid and high 404 eq on the 3 nobs per chanel on the tr8
This is a great case for "why not both?"
That’s def a video I will do lol
TR8S plus Digitakt is a killer combo. What’s even better is TR8S into the inputs of a Syntakt and then routed to the Syntakt’s FX track. Means you’re feeding Roland’s ACB modelled XxX sounds into an Elektron analog circuit with a great analog filter. Hugely transforms the TR8S sound (which is great by itself BTW) as you’d expect from digital samples into analog filter. TR8S + Digitakt + Syntakt is an unbelievably powerful beat monster setup, even better if you feed the output from the Syntakt into the Digitakt’s inputs and use the Digitakt compressor sidechained to a kick drum track on the Digitakt. Kinda all you’ll ever need in three boxes.
@@touchthatdialsounds like a nice setup!
where does one find those sweet stereo cables
Myvolts
thanks!
So, do you get a Korg with the TR8S
say wha?
Digitakt allows you to make the hole track or even full live set without anything else added. TR8S is a nice drum machine that is nice to have as an addition to other gear like Microfreak or whatever. I'd rather buy Syntakt instead of TR8S.
My thoughts exactly
I have both and a Rytm because GAS. And I can’t face selling any of them as they’re all great.
The main TR-8S issue I have is that the USB MIDI and multi track audio driver only works by treating the 8S as an audio interface in its own right so on Windows it is tricky to use with an ASIO interface. I tried an ASIO4ALL driver to run both simultaneously which caused timing and latency issues so now I don’t bother with the editor and use physical jack leads on a per drum output basis.
Elektron with the Digitakt can use Overbridge and you can get every track via a plugin in your DAW so that works fine with Windows - just one USB lead and bringing in multiple audio as it effectively bypasses the audio interface.
Rytm is still something I need to try
@@LiamKillen Where it beats the others is in having analogue oscillators and filters available as well as samples. It’s one of the best all round ‘normal’ drum machines before you stray into the madness of things like the Soma Pulsar-23.
I love elektron sound. I have the m:c and i would Iove to get more - analog rhytm, octatrack and a syntakt. But it is so expensive even second hand. I have a verselab which I love but I just saw a mc707 secondhand for half price and definitely considering it. It’s so much cheaper going the Roland route and I have a sp404. I love the size of the elektron. So many decisions. The thing that stumps me about the tr8 is that I can figure out if you’re stuck with only 16 steps and if you can have more- is it the banks? Idk
Yes! There are patterns, banks as well as 8 variations / pattern - so tons of space!
@@LiamKillen thank you, Liam appreciate it
Is the 606 not in the TR 8s? 606 is my favorite Roland kit.
Yeah it's in there
can you live sampling on tr 8s?
No you have to load in your samples, unfortunately.
Digitakt was a super inspiring tool for me: bought it, realized that any DAW is so much more versatile than hardware drum machine, sold Digitakt, incredibly happy.
That’s fair- yeah you can’t compare to a DAW that’s for sure
I just had this happen over the last couple years with MPC and SPs. I was going crazy trying to find the right hardware then started digging into Ableton and barely use my SPs anymore at all.
I have both. Nobody wants to worry about sample space in 2024 or dig through Roland menus. I don't think Digi lacks performance wise. Digitakt wins in my book.
Yeah that’s why I stick to top of the menu classic Roland drum sounds
Do they have sidechaining ?
The 8s does but only on external sources
Digitakt can in a way by using the LFO sine wave w/ sub division parameters like 1/4 notes to control the amplitude.
The TR-8S does, but using external only - and it’s technically not ‘true sidechaining’ by using only the step you chain it to, and not really the audio….however that does have its advantages… and you can also route that to a separate output, because there are a lot of assignable physical outputs
will never get why anyone says elektrons are hard to learn. To me the jomox xbase 999 was a hard one to completely get... The elektrons are just pure logic and bliss tbh.. U don't feel limited quickly and if u seen things once you will remember it because it sounds so amazing
Guess you haven’t tried out the octatrack yet then lol
@@LiamKilleni have 😄 really loved that one too but i’m a bit a nerd/menu diver by nature i guess. Manuals dont mind reading an entire manual and trying everything out. Octatrack in the end (to me) was too limited so i sold it and went with a hybrid setup that includes Bitwig (for me the best option for hybrid with hardware). I kept the rytm and four, really love the sequencer and sounds. OT isn’t super limited but i wanted all synths in the studio to be part of the live set and the OT just doesnt have enough tracks. Sounds great tho but in the end its whatever floats your boat. But tbh a jomox is harder than elektron for example. Deepdiving in a deepmind 12 or deepsampling on a prophet X and really understand what ur doing is also more work than using elektrons..
Both are good.
Yyyup
The more I move towards IDM, melodic techno, future garage, electronica, glitch, etc. the more these sort of drum machines call out to me. This reinforced my interest in the Digitakt. I'm a little bit over my SP404Mk2 a year in. I hate to say it haha.
You won’t get bored of the takt
I wish the TR had the build quality, and screen of the DT. The screen and build on the MC707 is also depressing. I love the aesthetic of the Elektron boxes, they look and feel mature, and professional. But the fact is Roland makes better performance devices. Having faders and knobs per track at your fingertips is how all grooveboxes should be. I’ve tried using a LaunchControl XL with the Elektron boxes but it’s not the same. On the TR I can change the mapping of the knobs on the fly, doing master effect sweeps is easier, it’s all just more jamable. I just hate the screens 😅. At least the SP404mk2 is a step in the right direction, but what the hell were they thinking with the MC707???
We should talk about all of this in my Discord - if you're not already a member :-)
discord.gg/xj8J2xJuBP
I wonder if the rhytm mk2 would have been a more apples to apples comparison?
It’s just way better than the digitakt haha
I just got the tr8s off that 10 sec explanation 👌
my guy
Before anything, sorry, I don't care what anyone says. Electron CANNOT justify what they charge. I make 6 figures but with a family to support, Electron's gear is just utterly, prohibitively expensive for me to access (no matter how good it might be).
So that led to me choosing the TR8s as the dedicated drum module for my live PA.
And boy did I get a surprise that its so much more than just a drum machine. Like it' has been mentioned here, it behaves SO much more like an actual instrument than any other synth/drum machine/groovebox or controller I've EVER laid hands on.
I can spend hours in a perfect flow state jamming out on it exactly like I'm playing a piano/guitar/live drum kit ect ect.
I swear I use the damn thing as much (probably more even) to meditate, than I do to write stuff.
It's just exquisitely designed to use live (in so many different ways/approaches).
My only issue has ever been that I wish it had some kind of poly ability where you could have MIDI pitch control over the individual instrument's tuning. A wider range of pitch modulation in general would also be nice. I can't seem to get a lot of my kicks/bass sounds as low as I want them without re-sampling them externally (say into Ableton), pitching them down then reloading them as user samples back into the TR8s
Otherwise, its just a fkn perfect piece of kit. 😊
I disagree considering that I use the Digitakt more than any other unit I own - i get so much use out of it.
Try the ‘coarse tuning’ effect to get them lower, and apply a gain boost and some saturation… Wowie zowie
Oh you can dj with this
I'm trying to include the 8S with my DJ set up :-)
The best is the yellow sweater.
I love that sweater haha
The TR-8s feels and sounds like a proper drum machine and the Digitakt feels and sounds more like a Teenage Engineering OP-1
Very interesting comparison!
What does the OP-1 sound like? I’ve always dismissed it because of its looks…
I always wanted to love the Elektron boxes, but I just can't get over their incredibly loud clicky buttons.
i looove that clicky sound haha
@@LiamKillen I love making music at rather low volume and I love using and sound designing glichy and clicky sounds as percussion elements where any additional sound made by keys just annoys me. The same is for clicky keybeds of hardware synths.
22:55 you can totally do all what you've just shown with Digitakt
I should have been a bit more clear with that specific statement. What I mean is that the combination of entering in / tweaking parameters in real time is not something you can do with the Digitakt. Unless, of course, you get a midi controller involved but I think still the 8s would be more hands on just because of the simplicity of the layout.
@@LiamKillennah you can still do that!
I would certainly not call the DT's effects "really interesting." I would call the serviceable. The overdrive doesn't get the love I think it deserves. The delay is fine, very much a vanilla digital delay with a filter in the feedback. The reverb is... okay? Like, it gets the job done, but to me it sounds like FreeVerb. Very basic and dull.
The sound quality is great though - I think the Elektron Box reverb is some of my fav in the game.
the Elektron screens SUCK bit time. BUT their retro lit buttons are a big plus in a live situation.
I actually like the screen / graphics!
"dark sound"? all elektron devices have decent converters operating on sufficient sample rate. People are nuts really with this "dark" Octatrack lol.
So many people have mentioned it that i'm starting to think that it's true.
@@LiamKillen normal these days, so many voices and opinions. I did lots of A/B tests of sampling in the Octa and a few different converters directly, the only difference is circuitry sound goes through after sampling, and those offsets are so minimal it is really hard to hear.
Odd premise for comparison, very different devices. And the Elektron is double the price of the Roland for starters.
Opposites in many ways but also lots of similarities! 😊
TR8-S all day
my guy
I got the tr8 when it was released it sounded so bad I returned 3days later
Really!? It can sound thin for sure
octatrack wins . 😂
😏
@@LiamKillen sorry to kill the party xx
@@LiamKillen actually still own tr8s id say its more playable then the digitakt . as they forgot mod wheels on the whole digi range . uhmm
For more expansive and evolving standalone jams, the Digitakt has been optimal with live sampling, trig locks and of course the sweet sweet happy accidents while the TRK button is pressed 🪄
I think the best of both worlds is to use both of them together lol
@@LiamKillen eventually, most probably yes 💎
How about the drumloque....isn't good enough to compete with this two? 🫣😵💫
My take is....no way
can you live sampling on tr 8s?
you have to loadin your samples.