t.A.T.u. has a very special place in my life. I never forget my first impression upon listening to All the Things She Said on the radio. 2002 was such a special year and t.A.T.u. is right tune for it.
Same as me brother I'm sill obsessed with them There's something really special about them that still can break me down. I believe they themselves had no idea what they were doing. t.A.T.u is not merely a music band it's a part of our entity
my daughter used to play them in the car while taking her to school and i got into the music through buying her the cds.Now im almost 60 and still smile when i hear the music as its special memories for myself
They were 14 when they recorded (All the Things She Said) in the studio. And about 17 or 18 years old when the English version of the song was released in the U.S. in 2002. I don't think they were forced to do anything. It was agreed to make something different, controversial, and rebellious to sell records. And it worked. They were successful. Both were born in 1984 and are about 36 years of age now.
I was so obsessed with them! Totally straight but I connected to their style and everything t.A.T.u is! I remember getting made fun of in school for wearing my plaid skirt and chunky mid calf black boots which was inspired by their all the things she said video! I even knew their Russian songs even though I’m sure I was not singing the words correctly! I will absolutely always love them and will blast them anytime their songs play on the radio!
I thought they are being lesbian is only rumor, I didn't know it's fact until I read comments section. 😅 My friends keep telling me this but I didn't believe it. Their videos always got censored in my country, so I thought it just promotes a true friendship between 2 girls and just rebellion phase.
Тату были очень необычными, особенно по музыке. Ничего подобного тогда на российской сцене не было. А все эти нынешние их сольные проекты обычная попса которой навалом.
Лена и Юля дополняли друг друга и были невероятно сильным дуэтом, я не фанат этой группы, но уверен каждый для себя найдет несколько треков от которых мурашки по телу проскочат....
Они всеравно умнички, обе. Стабильных 10лет быть в мировом топе. Пока никто не повторил (из славянских). Волкова и Катина умнички обе. Жаль больше дуэта нет. Но даже спустя 20 лет, их музыка зажигает
@@Alecto44811 You'll always be older than yesterday, but always younger than tomorrow. You'll think how young you are now when you are 47. Keep things in perspective. Appreciate your youth at all stages of life.
Josefine Ejnermark yeah that’s not gonna happen, they aren’t really in good terms from what I remember years ago, they have artistic differences, as much as I want to see them perform together , it’s best that they move on from it
Whatever sadness or problems they have... if they got used, abused or just feel they sold their youth for money... I hope they find some comfort in what they did for millions of people with their music.
I’m actually glad they’re not back together. I think they had a good run and they both seem content to lose the image of t.A.T.u. now that they’re older and more developed as artists. They have different styles they want to pursue, as well. However, it saddens me that they could never just remain friends. Seems like a lot of bad blood that couldn’t be forgiven. I wish they can maybe one day make peace and occasionally collab for a song or performance for old time’s sake, without any drama.
Who's to say they don't get a few Voddies, a coupla conesa weed, and they can sort it like we do in NZ? They worked well at the start, and life's too short to regret the ending
I know Julia was the leader of the band, the more popular one, prettier one whatever. It was a Duo. There were 2 of them. They should have been treated like equals. Towards the end of Tatu Lena felt unappreciated and invisible. Julia became a bit of a bulky towards her too. She scoffed at her talent and worth as an artist, would talk over her in interviews, didn't like it if she got attention, and acted like she was better than her. Julia gave multiple interviews stating that she was the leader and Lena was just a member, she was more talented and creative, mocked her solo career, and said there was nothing special about Lena. And then she wonders why Lena wants nothing to do with her. I love Julia, but I'm happy Lena stood up to her. There was also multiple instances where they were performing on stage and Lena is wearing a midrift or something sexy and Julia walks over and pulls her top down to cover her stomach while shes literally wearing underwear on stage. It's like she couldn't stand the idea of anyone paying attention to someone other than herself. I don't blame Lena at all for wanting to get away. I'm sick of people calling Lena a bitch for being cold to Julia. I understand her feelings and her actions. I think she has handled the whole thing very maturely and gracefully. I'm proud of her.
To be honest, I always thought that Lena was prettier and never understood the hype over Yulia. To me the all concept of TATU is to have two people with equal talent. If Yulia is as great as she thinks she is, she would have made it big as a solo artist. Actually, not only she is only relevant thanks to the LGBT image she used to convey, but she actually made homophobic statements that makes her double-standard.
@@Aria-i5fexactly. I do not care for Julia's solo work. Everyone says that Julia was Tatu but her screaming was jarring to listen to sometimes and got annoying. During their third album when Julia's voice was going bad they still gave her the majority of the lines even though their lines were equal on the demos. Lenas vocals really suited the third albums and she should have been given equal parts with the leads split between the two. Julia acts like she's on par with the likes of Celine Dion or Sarah Brightman but her vocals were never that great. Look at their first album cover. Julia is fully in the shot while Lena is barely in it. The company definitely favored Julia and Vanya was weirdly obsessed with her. I don't think Lena was treated that well....
@@Aria-i5fand yes she kind of screwed herself making those statements. Those are her beliefs, fine. She's allowed to have them. But it was a really stupid thing to say, considering she built an entire career on acting like a lesbian. She even still tried to do the lesbian thing in her first two music videos with girls that looked similar to Lena. And she gave Lena crap for singing Tatu songs when she went solo. She's a total hypocrite...
@@audio91000 Indeed, I never understood why Yulia got way more lines most of the time, expect in All about us, while it was supposed to be a duet, not a solo project. If her voice was pleasant to hear in songs like not gonna get us or how soon is now, it did not suit balads. Honestly, lucky Lena was there to back her up big times.
@@audio91000 To me her statements regarding gay men never made sense. Not only it is homophobic, it is also sexist as to her it seems than women are here to look pretty and nothing more. Also, she said that men are meant to procreate. Then if they can't or dont wanna have children, does it mean that they are not real men? Then the same should apply to lesbian women. I assume that she is just not very smart and should stick up with what she can do meaning singing and dancing.
I grew up listening to t.A.T.u songs and had so many memories affiliated to their voices and music... each and every time I listen to their old songs it's reminiscing .... Lina and Julia are both legends no matter how things turned for Julia
Julia will be alright. She looks better than recent years nowadays guess she got her previous cosmetic surgery fixed :) i believe she's slowly regaining her voice again.
They never been bi they got told to kiss they were best friends but suddenly got feelings for eachother. The black hair girl got married to a man the orange hair girl still wanted to be tatu. Everyone can be bi humans are easy to manipulate
@@mgm8631 you wanna run that by me again plz..and hopefully in Scottish..!.. Or maybe in English.. Am just duh...!...I would appreciate that big time M G M..!..😶..
Both were the spirit of t.A.T.u. The band is dead because there is no more chemistry between them I have nothin against Yulia, but in my opinion, Lena's music is closer than t.A.T.u style than everythin Yulia did so far
@@tonydegouveia4178 I don't see the point of making music similar too t.A.T.u. because t.A.T.u. was Lena and Julia. It won't work...Lena's music is uninteresting and boring. Cause it lacks the fierce energy that t.A.T.u. had, which came from Julia.
@@yorhaunit21o32 Really? She looks more edgy and eye catching before. Like she looks like a typical Russian who did surgery. They have this certain look you know like Darcy & stacey, Anfisa, Shanti (I know most of them aren't RUssians but you get my point, there's a certain look that made them look all alike). Pls dont get me wrong she looks good but very generic too.
@@markusruhlstillreigning6940 Pour ma part j'ai utilisé mon ordi pour tout mettre sur ma carte SD dans mon mobile donc j'ai toujours avec moi, j'aime écouter en aléatoire, ça mixe tous els albums :)
Loved them they became international popstars and broke thought barriers no one dared to go during the early 2000's they both have grown up they couldn't stay the 2 young teenage girls we grew up with they are now adults with fantastic careers I wish them both prosperity and hope to see more of them both in the coming future as for their Friendshil goes deeper than what most people know maybe one day they will tell us why they started fighting I have somewhat of a clue but I'll let them tell it Ya lyublu tebya tatu vsegda
Julia became a plastic doll while Lena a classy lady. Such a pity they don't make music together any more. Believe in goodbyes is sooo good. Guess too much has happened we don't know about
Does plastic surgery really make someone automatically not classy? I disagree with her views on homosexuality, but I wouldnt tear Yulia down for her appearance.
T.a.t.u needs to come back and break is with their crazy sound that is unique!Please girls make one more album that is similar to the first 2 albums u did...please!
Love them so much i couldn’t get enough of all the things she said I played it over and over and just started listening to them again after my daughter was on TikTok and it was on there
Старт был просто безумный, они взорвали чаты !!! Но к сожалению финиш был ужасен, но я их люблю за их творчество, таких уже не будет(((. Скачаю я себе пожалуй в машину лучшие песни))).
indiscutible juntas se veían increíbles brillaban !!!! solistas eran Buenas pero no brillaban de la misma manera la gente las adoraba juntas esas voces juntas eran increíbles perfectas !!!! gracias por dar un estilo tan único ...
Никогда не следил за ними. Но глядя на видео можно сказать, что до 2006 года группа развивалась. Действительно был УРОВЕНЬ. Потом рыжая ещё что-то пыталась делать (причём не плохо) до 2011 года, а дальше видимо опустила руки. А чёрненькую кто-то подменил. Такую шнягу стала петь, противно слушать.
They actually had a pretty unique buzzing heavy 'guitar' layer under the pop. See e.g. 1:10 in Ya Soshla s Uma. Almost sounds like Angelic Process or something like that.
Despite the controversy at the start of their careers I’d say the have developed into beautiful women and great solo artist in their own right who have carved out successful careers for themselves.
из того что видел читал сложилось мнение такое что было два подростка не "стандартных"( вовсе не намекаю на ореинтацию) я о характерах и способностях) которых объединил один креативный "маньяк" в музыке а точнее в шоу бизнесе нашел слабое место толпы девочки лезби создал образ и при довольно сильных текстах и надрывной музыке (нещадно эксплуатируя Юлину склонность к эпатажу ) кстати он скорее подонок чем гений- заставил Юлю рвать голосовые связки что и привело её к хирургу) но способность Лены пахать не только землю но и гранит в желании быть лучшей позволило всей команде добиться ТАКОГО. но время не с чадит и девочки уже стали чуть старше и голоса стали мягче но всё же спасибо продолжаете вызывать эмоции которых хочется ещё и ещё.
Да были времена, настольгия! По мне так "Тату" это Иван Шаповалов! С его уходом группа перестала существовать как целостный проект! Дальше это уже был проект Лена Катина и Юля Волкова! Хотя можно было ещё придумать очень много клёвых сюжетов и не обязательно орать и визжать, а просто писать классные современные по тем временам хиты! Если второй альбом он хоть по стилю и энергетике уже и не "Тату", но хотя бы сильный и качественный, то о третьем я вообще молчу! Сейчас я их даже не представляю вместе и считаю, что уже это делать не надо! Зря Лена согласилась работать с Юлей после песни Never forget you, ох, и зря! Хоть автор и попытался нам больше выделить Волкову, но все, я думаю, видят, кто и как вырос, работая по одиночке!
Михаил, тут не нужно забывать один нюанс, Волкова очень сильно посадила голос на концертах, т.к. именно она брала больше всего партий пока была группа, Катина была как на подпевках, теперь то да Лена выросла, а Юля петь толком не может( по большому счету они обе молодцы, и группа свое время большую популярность набрала, даже без Шаповалова! ни одну нашу группу не знают в странах зарубежья и заокеанья как эту! И песню любят и слушают до сих пор!
@@СветланаМ-о1о это карма! Волкова вечно лезла вперёд и действительно брала больше партий и, правильно, мечтала, чтобы Катина была у неё на подпевках, хотя можно было и без этого! Надо было раньше думать о проблемах с голосом и что-то менять, а не упрямо тянуть на себя одеяло!
уффф прикольно было наблюдать за ними в режиме рилтайм ) мне было 10, когда по MTV ежедневно крутили Я сошла с ума. было здорово! ) до сих пор нравится их музыка, но вот всё, что они делали сольно - ничего не запомнилось.
Все их обаяние заключалась в том что они были невинными девочками которые боролись за себя и за свои чувства не смотря не на что. Пластические операции, попса и развратные видеоклипы все испортили по моему мнению.
She has the right to alter her face as she sees fit. What we're saying is she didn't need that plastic surgery - people would have killed to have her natural face.
Extremadamente talentosas, pero juntas eran una bomba !!!! Diganme nostalgica pero juntas eran dinamita ! A mi si me gustaria que se volvieran a juntar no para siempre como grupo pero si para un proyecto, porque precisamente ya maduraron.... Yo las amo 😘🤩
1:38 I heard this song when I was a child. However, the Russian singer did not expect the song to be released by accident. Because sometimes I thought about the song of a girl and a boy kissing in the rain.
Так необычно, что их музыка для запада значительно отличалась от материала, записанного для России.Американские версии песен более качественные и серьёзные, а для России в то время они решили сделать звучание на подобие "Руки вверх".Вот что значит - коммерческий план.🙃
а ты в курсе что английские версии делались не один в один чтобы были одинаковы? или ты настолько глуп реально думая что тут и текст и названия должны быть переведены из оригинала?)
Love Lena Katina and what she did in TAtu, they will come back again in the future❤️🧡💚💙💜🤍 Your sound levels are really bad from video to video but love what you have done x
Прежде всего, изуродованные тут только исключительно мозги холуяжа-фанатов, что пресмыкаются перед этими выросшими лоли, что ради имиджа изображали ковырялок.
Абсолютно согласен. Когда они только появились на Лену вообще не смотрел. А Юля была божественна. А сейчас Лена стала настоящей женщиной, а Юля превратила себя в пластиковую куклу. Смотреть противно...
Если бы Юля голос не потеряла, её песни бы и дальше были. У неё очень танцевальные и клубные хиты. Хорошие. Если бы её грамотно двигали, она бы многого могла добиться.
😭 forever TATU and i miss 💜 Siempre las amare, todo el tiempo están en mi mente y corazón 🥺 quisiera volver a verlas juntas a Lena y Julia como amigas...
Когда Татушки только появились я был просто очарован Волковой... Для меня она была практически эталоном девушки и спустя 8 лет я нашел на работе практически ее копию которая стала моей женой... Но чудо длилось недолго... Не верьте брюнеткам с короткой стрижкой и красивыми глазами...
If i remember correct. I saw them preform on Jay Leno about 18 yrs ago. The song caught my ear. I've always wondered about them. Thank u for sharing this. I know nothing of ur personal lives. But I do know about water under the bridge. Much luv.
I started to listen to English music in around 2004-2005 when I was a high school student. In 2007 I had a chance to know about t.A.T.u. music and I fell in love with them. Until now, I still listen to their old songs...
Я сам 2006 года, около месяца назад услышал песню "робот", показалась жутко знакомой, но в тоже время казалось что я её впервые слышал. Решил послушать остальные песни тату, и оказалось что половину я чуть ли не наизусть знаю, а остальные где то слышал. И Лена с Юлей оказались очень знакомы внешне.
I first heard them when I was like 5 or 6 Im 18 now and still listen to them. They helped me find and embrace my sexuality(bi). I love their songs so much.
I really wish I was born back when their group first started. I love to see a lgbtq duo band, their supposed to be getting back in spring though! I hope Julia learns how to use her new voice
You can check out their separate 20th anniversary interviews. They are still not in good terms unfortunately. They're not members of LGBTQ community. Back then, Yulia had made homophobic statements but I think it was because out of fear for her son's future/life (Check out Russia's attitude towards gays that time. I don't know how much have changed now). Lena however is always welcome to gay clubs as a guest music artist.
The video is great but you missed a lot of Lena's collaborations, the one with belanova, the one with tkilla the one with Clark Owen, the one with Noemi Smorra...
Vanessa Villagrana I love all those songs! I discluded them because I wanted to focus on their purely solo work. I included Julia’s with Dima Bilan as she does not have as many solo songs sadly
Me gustaba tatu en los años 2000 cuando su sonido iba más orientado al rock... después su sonido no fue el mismo. Pero desde que escuché All the things she said en la radio y por todos lados, la ame.
J'ai adoré ce groupe, leur musique, leur présence sur scène quand elles chantaient on avait l'impression que rien ne les atteignaient...Bref j'étais un de leurs nombreux fan !
t.A.T.u. has a very special place in my life. I never forget my first impression upon listening to All the Things She Said on the radio. 2002 was such a special year and t.A.T.u. is right tune for it.
I believe our grey hairs are showing! ;)
Totally agree w u
Same as me brother
I'm sill obsessed with them
There's something really special about them that still can break me down.
I believe they themselves had no idea what they were doing. t.A.T.u is not merely a music band it's a part of our entity
Hey idyou one miku candy candy
I’m the 400 like
my daughter used to play them in the car while taking her to school and i got into the music through buying her the cds.Now im almost 60 and still smile when i hear the music as its special memories for myself
can't believe they were just 14 yrs old when they started
They were 14 when they recorded (All the Things She Said) in the studio. And about 17 or 18 years old when the English version of the song was released in the U.S. in 2002. I don't think they were forced to do anything. It was agreed to make something different, controversial, and rebellious to sell records. And it worked. They were successful. Both were born in 1984 and are about 36 years of age now.
Same age as me when the vid came out when I was high school. They are beautiful.
@@IncubusOfDeath Lena was born in 1984 and Julia was born in 1985.
@@BettyMareeHOHCountry They were 18 and 19 when they made the video one is a few months older than the other....
@@IncubusOfDeath The video was made in 2000. They were born in 1984 and 1985 so they were 15 and 16.
I was so obsessed with them! Totally straight but I connected to their style and everything t.A.T.u is! I remember getting made fun of in school for wearing my plaid skirt and chunky mid calf black boots which was inspired by their all the things she said video! I even knew their Russian songs even though I’m sure I was not singing the words correctly! I will absolutely always love them and will blast them anytime their songs play on the radio!
I thought they are being lesbian is only rumor, I didn't know it's fact until I read comments section.
😅 My friends keep telling me this but I didn't believe it.
Their videos always got censored in my country, so I thought it just promotes a true friendship between 2 girls and just rebellion phase.
Тату были очень необычными, особенно по музыке. Ничего подобного тогда на российской сцене не было. А все эти нынешние их сольные проекты обычная попса которой навалом.
Да и сейчас нет чего-то такого что они делали раньше
они наверное устали от больших проектов которые были раньше имхо
Да, годная музыка у них была гдето до 2005
Пожалуйста Шура,Hi-Fi,Гости из будущего....
Это отстой
Лена и Юля дополняли друг друга и были невероятно сильным дуэтом, я не фанат этой группы, но уверен каждый для себя найдет несколько треков от которых мурашки по телу проскочат....
Лена и Юля я вас люблю!
Полчаса
Они всеравно умнички, обе. Стабильных 10лет быть в мировом топе. Пока никто не повторил (из славянских). Волкова и Катина умнички обе. Жаль больше дуэта нет. Но даже спустя 20 лет, их музыка зажигает
От силы 2 года были популярны
Nice songs. I'm 31 years old and i grow up with this song's. The best memories for me.
Same here 🙂 30 years old and they were first and last group that I will cherrish forever ♥️
aye im 27 and remember hearing them when i was in school. we getting old
Can I noin the club? 29 here still listening to their jam and have a feeling they'll reunite at some point :)
@@Alecto44811 You'll always be older than yesterday, but always younger than tomorrow. You'll think how young you are now when you are 47. Keep things in perspective. Appreciate your youth at all stages of life.
Same
Почему так грустно?
Спасибо, что ваше творчество сопровождало нашу юность!)
Жаль что вы не можете творить вместе дальше
My top
1. All the things she said
2. Nas ne doginiat
3. All about us
4. Ne ver, ne boisya, ne prosy
5. Prostiy dvizhenia
2002 : I was straight when I heard not gonna get us
2020 : I really miss them back, it feels good to see them together
Did they break up?
@@meena1332 they were never together
Their music genre is very peculiar. Can’t even describe. Somewhat dark and gritty.
yes, tho 'the veronicas' are a duo who also explores that kind of sound.
Grunge metal.
Жаль, что Юля потеряла голос, но это звучание, которого она добилась, вошёл в историю. Ничего более пробирающего я не слышала.
Try Miley Cyrus...
I always thought that their positions should've shifted when they grew up. Lena should've taken the higher pitches, not only live.
Lena kept it real. Whatever happened to Julia... its just sad... But I would like to see a comeback though...
Josefine Ejnermark yeah that’s not gonna happen, they aren’t really in good terms from what I remember years ago, they have artistic differences, as much as I want to see them perform together , it’s best that they move on from it
@@melissavelazquez9757 did they have fall out ??
PrincessMegan Elsa yes , from what I remember
Whatever sadness or problems they have... if they got used, abused or just feel they sold their youth for money... I hope they find some comfort in what they did for millions of people with their music.
I’m actually glad they’re not back together. I think they had a good run and they both seem content to lose the image of t.A.T.u. now that they’re older and more developed as artists. They have different styles they want to pursue, as well.
However, it saddens me that they could never just remain friends. Seems like a lot of bad blood that couldn’t be forgiven. I wish they can maybe one day make peace and occasionally collab for a song or performance for old time’s sake, without any drama.
Who said they are not friends?
Who's to say they don't get a few Voddies, a coupla conesa weed, and they can sort it like we do in NZ? They worked well at the start, and life's too short to regret the ending
@@oxoxoxoxo1155 they were both underage and forced to play "lesbians" for $$$, so it would leave a big trauma and even make enemies out of 'em
@@IncubusOfDeath and the point is? They are homophobes now
windy win how do you know?
I know Julia was the leader of the band, the more popular one, prettier one whatever. It was a Duo. There were 2 of them. They should have been treated like equals. Towards the end of Tatu Lena felt unappreciated and invisible. Julia became a bit of a bulky towards her too. She scoffed at her talent and worth as an artist, would talk over her in interviews, didn't like it if she got attention, and acted like she was better than her. Julia gave multiple interviews stating that she was the leader and Lena was just a member, she was more talented and creative, mocked her solo career, and said there was nothing special about Lena. And then she wonders why Lena wants nothing to do with her. I love Julia, but I'm happy Lena stood up to her. There was also multiple instances where they were performing on stage and Lena is wearing a midrift or something sexy and Julia walks over and pulls her top down to cover her stomach while shes literally wearing underwear on stage. It's like she couldn't stand the idea of anyone paying attention to someone other than herself. I don't blame Lena at all for wanting to get away. I'm sick of people calling Lena a bitch for being cold to Julia. I understand her feelings and her actions. I think she has handled the whole thing very maturely and gracefully. I'm proud of her.
To be honest, I always thought that Lena was prettier and never understood the hype over Yulia. To me the all concept of TATU is to have two people with equal talent. If Yulia is as great as she thinks she is, she would have made it big as a solo artist. Actually, not only she is only relevant thanks to the LGBT image she used to convey, but she actually made homophobic statements that makes her double-standard.
@@Aria-i5fexactly. I do not care for Julia's solo work. Everyone says that Julia was Tatu but her screaming was jarring to listen to sometimes and got annoying. During their third album when Julia's voice was going bad they still gave her the majority of the lines even though their lines were equal on the demos. Lenas vocals really suited the third albums and she should have been given equal parts with the leads split between the two. Julia acts like she's on par with the likes of Celine Dion or Sarah Brightman but her vocals were never that great. Look at their first album cover. Julia is fully in the shot while Lena is barely in it. The company definitely favored Julia and Vanya was weirdly obsessed with her. I don't think Lena was treated that well....
@@Aria-i5fand yes she kind of screwed herself making those statements. Those are her beliefs, fine. She's allowed to have them. But it was a really stupid thing to say, considering she built an entire career on acting like a lesbian. She even still tried to do the lesbian thing in her first two music videos with girls that looked similar to Lena. And she gave Lena crap for singing Tatu songs when she went solo. She's a total hypocrite...
@@audio91000 Indeed, I never understood why Yulia got way more lines most of the time, expect in All about us, while it was supposed to be a duet, not a solo project. If her voice was pleasant to hear in songs like not gonna get us or how soon is now, it did not suit balads. Honestly, lucky Lena was there to back her up big times.
@@audio91000 To me her statements regarding gay men never made sense. Not only it is homophobic, it is also sexist as to her it seems than women are here to look pretty and nothing more. Also, she said that men are meant to procreate. Then if they can't or dont wanna have children, does it mean that they are not real men? Then the same should apply to lesbian women. I assume that she is just not very smart and should stick up with what she can do meaning singing and dancing.
У Лены конечно сольный репертуар поприятней, это было отличное время Хорошая группа. По крайней мере о них узнал весь мир и любил их
I grew up listening to t.A.T.u songs and had so many memories affiliated to their voices and music... each and every time I listen to their old songs it's reminiscing .... Lina and Julia are both legends no matter how things turned for Julia
Julia will be alright. She looks better than recent years nowadays guess she got her previous cosmetic surgery fixed :) i believe she's slowly regaining her voice again.
*Lena, not Lina
@@LoveAndPeace2004 ok thanks
They were one of the first ones to help me discover my bisexuality. I will forever love t.a.t.u with all my heart
Or maybe they forced it on you?
@@ИндийскийЧай-ж6й no, there is no way to force sexuality onto another person you weirdo.
@@ИндийскийЧай-ж6й fuck off bigot
SAME!
They never been bi they got told to kiss they were best friends but suddenly got feelings for eachother. The black hair girl got married to a man the orange hair girl still wanted to be tatu.
Everyone can be bi humans are easy to manipulate
I love Lena, she really is the spiritual legacy of t.A.Tu.
Уже не то. Это хорошая история! Даааа, хорошее было время! А девченкам желаю удачи!
@@mgm8631 you wanna run that by me again plz..and hopefully in Scottish..!.. Or maybe in English.. Am just duh...!...I would appreciate that big time M G M..!..😶..
No,Julia was the spirit of t.A.T.u. Lena was just the other girl
Both were the spirit of t.A.T.u. The band is dead because there is no more chemistry between them I have nothin against Yulia, but in my opinion, Lena's music is closer than t.A.T.u style than everythin Yulia did so far
@@tonydegouveia4178 I don't see the point of making music similar too t.A.T.u. because t.A.T.u. was Lena and Julia. It won't work...Lena's music is uninteresting and boring. Cause it lacks the fierce energy that t.A.T.u. had, which came from Julia.
They have always been a favorite of mine. They had a very distinct sound and dark style in the first decade of 2000.
Why did Yulia have so much plastic surgery? She looked better before.
HEY!!! Respect the drip
Yup, I'm agree, she looks completely different, is like we are looking at other different person.
I disagree she looks AMAZING now
@@yorhaunit21o32 I agree with you, her lips are far to big though if they were smaller she would look amazing!
@@yorhaunit21o32 Really? She looks more edgy and eye catching before. Like she looks like a typical Russian who did surgery. They have this certain look you know like Darcy & stacey, Anfisa, Shanti (I know most of them aren't RUssians but you get my point, there's a certain look that made them look all alike). Pls dont get me wrong she looks good but very generic too.
Still listening to their albums both in english and russian. Love from France 💞
c'est rassurant je ne suis pas la seule en France à écouter tous les albums ^^
@@yoshikasstastrophe on doit pas être nombreux haha. Les CD n'ont jamais quitté ma boîte a gant 😆
@@markusruhlstillreigning6940 Pour ma part j'ai utilisé mon ordi pour tout mettre sur ma carte SD dans mon mobile donc j'ai toujours avec moi, j'aime écouter en aléatoire, ça mixe tous els albums :)
Они слушают русскую музыку, как мы иностранную? Классно че
Слушали*
Современное, конечно, за рубежом никому не нужно. А Татушки были МЕГА популярны. Как сейчас какая-нибудь Ариана Гранде или Билли Айлиш.
Да это прекрасно.. жаль что современную музыку просто.... ну вы поняли..
А ты погугли кто им эти песни писал и подумай еще раз, "русссская" это музыка, или не очень.
Билли айлиш намного круче этих тату. Она хоть слова пишет и музыку помогает записывать.
@@olegtodd8272 беляш айриш - высер, что ты тут забыл?
I was 16 when I heard All the things she said for the first time. I loved them❤️
Same except I just found it a couple weeks ago
Эта группа сделала очень много для популяризации русского языка!
Больше чем все лингвисты России вместе взятых
🤣🤣🤣🤣 да уж точно, прям стал международным языком
@@dengrey1867 он и так является международным, неуч
@@elamtou очень смешно. 😩
@@elamtou кринж
I remember being 8 years old in Greece on holiday seeing a tatu cd instantly recognised them! And begged my mother we buy it! Best cd I ever brought ❤
Песня "Спасите люди мир" прям до дрожи пробивает. Сильная песня👍👍👍👍
I miss you T.A.T.U so much.
I love you both, from the UK and Romania.
Loved them they became international popstars and broke thought barriers no one dared to go during the early 2000's they both have grown up they couldn't stay the 2 young teenage girls we grew up with they are now adults with fantastic careers I wish them both prosperity and hope to see more of them both in the coming future as for their Friendshil goes deeper than what most people know maybe one day they will tell us why they started fighting I have somewhat of a clue but I'll let them tell it Ya lyublu tebya tatu vsegda
Julia became a plastic doll while Lena a classy lady. Such a pity they don't make music together any more. Believe in goodbyes is sooo good. Guess too much has happened we don't know about
Does plastic surgery really make someone automatically not classy? I disagree with her views on homosexuality, but I wouldnt tear Yulia down for her appearance.
@@Travisowski Julia said she wouldn't want her child to be gay because it's hard to be gay in Russia not because she's homophobic (she's bi)
she was so cute >
@@lydiaskye9833 She said she would disown a gay son but not a lesbian daughter
@@serenitymoon825 really? wow that's kind of harsh for her to say considering that they had built their career over the support of the lgbt community.
T.a.t.u needs to come back and break is with their crazy sound that is unique!Please girls make one more album that is similar to the first 2 albums u did...please!
Love them so much i couldn’t get enough of all the things she said I played it over and over and just started listening to them again after my daughter was on TikTok and it was on there
Старт был просто безумный, они взорвали чаты !!! Но к сожалению финиш был ужасен, но я их люблю за их творчество, таких уже не будет(((. Скачаю я себе пожалуй в машину лучшие песни))).
Полностью согласен с вами.
Интересно узнать, что вы думаете о каждой из них.
indiscutible juntas se veían increíbles brillaban !!!! solistas eran Buenas pero no brillaban de la misma manera la gente las adoraba juntas esas voces juntas eran increíbles perfectas !!!! gracias por dar un estilo tan único ...
Помню дискотеки и их песни, как мы орали когда их включали, вот это времена былы 🤘👍💪🔥🔥🔥
Мне очень нравятся песни Юли. В них есть страсть, чувства, они настоящие... Не важно что голос уже не такой сильный, есть огонь!
Pasarán, 100 años más y su música siempre, sonará,
Como el primer día "T.A.T.U" Por siempre,
Que 100 años tonto
Por siempre ❤️❤️🥰🥰🥰🥰😭😭😭😭
@@natalyvolkova3236 hola ricolina que cuentas
@@brayanfranklin9710 buena Banda Alesana
Uno en español
Никогда не следил за ними. Но глядя на видео можно сказать, что до 2006 года группа развивалась. Действительно был УРОВЕНЬ. Потом рыжая ещё что-то пыталась делать (причём не плохо) до 2011 года, а дальше видимо опустила руки. А чёрненькую кто-то подменил. Такую шнягу стала петь, противно слушать.
Волковой крышу снесло, мать двоих детей, но несёт такую чушь , что слушать невозможно. Катиной респект!
Волкова звезду успела словить
@@maileytalks293 и потерять голос...
they have changed a lot ...
You got a nice last name!
I wonder why
@@Anthony-cl3wc our schoolgirls grew from skirts ...
Зефирка Грин that’s because they aren’t kids anymore
Its either called growing up or that's what happens...ya know what I mean I reckon,. You ain't daft...!...
I love them still, even more. No matter how they have changed, but they are still my favourite. My love from Vietnam.
Оказывается, я перестала их слушать примерно с 2005 года совсем 😊 я думала, они с того же года и закончили свою карьеру.. Удивили! 😊
They actually had a pretty unique buzzing heavy 'guitar' layer under the pop. See e.g. 1:10 in Ya Soshla s Uma. Almost sounds like Angelic Process or something like that.
A you tuber named Anna Pest metalized 1000km in the wrong lane, and its utterly amazing.
EXELENTE VIDEO!!! ES PURA DINAMITA PURA, ASI ESTEN SEPARADAS QUEDA EL ESTILO DE TATU... PERO SE LAS EXTRAÑA JUNTAS!!! BUEN TRABAJOOOO!!!
They’re gorgeous! I miss watching them on mtv in my living room as a teen.
Столько иностранцев в комментах, вау
Тату были охеренно популярными за рубежом. Могли меряться с современной американской эстрадой.
На иностранном Ютубе очень популярна их песня "Нас не догонят-Not gonna get us".
@@NeonScorpio777 У них вроде как более популярна "Я сошла с ума" на английском.
@@mojlogoi1077 не знаю давно смотрел)
Даа, я тоже ищу русские комменты с трудом нахожу
Despite the controversy at the start of their careers I’d say the have developed into beautiful women and great solo artist in their own right who have carved out successful careers for themselves.
The controversy made them interesting now they are just more like others
what controversy??
Well, Lena aged way better
из того что видел читал сложилось мнение такое что было два подростка не "стандартных"( вовсе не намекаю на ореинтацию) я о характерах и способностях) которых объединил один креативный "маньяк" в музыке а точнее в шоу бизнесе нашел слабое место толпы девочки лезби создал образ и при довольно сильных текстах и надрывной музыке (нещадно эксплуатируя Юлину склонность к эпатажу ) кстати он скорее подонок чем гений- заставил Юлю рвать голосовые связки что и привело её к хирургу) но способность Лены пахать не только землю но и гранит в желании быть лучшей позволило всей команде добиться ТАКОГО. но время не с чадит и девочки уже стали чуть старше и голоса стали мягче но всё же спасибо продолжаете вызывать эмоции которых хочется ещё и ещё.
Да были времена, настольгия!
По мне так "Тату" это Иван Шаповалов! С его уходом группа перестала существовать как целостный проект! Дальше это уже был проект Лена Катина и Юля Волкова! Хотя можно было ещё придумать очень много клёвых сюжетов и не обязательно орать и визжать, а просто писать классные современные по тем временам хиты! Если второй альбом он хоть по стилю и энергетике уже и не "Тату", но хотя бы сильный и качественный, то о третьем я вообще молчу! Сейчас я их даже не представляю вместе и считаю, что уже это делать не надо! Зря Лена согласилась работать с Юлей после песни Never forget you, ох, и зря!
Хоть автор и попытался нам больше выделить Волкову, но все, я думаю, видят, кто и как вырос, работая по одиночке!
Только Шаповалов сам же свое детище и разрушил.
Михаил, тут не нужно забывать один нюанс, Волкова очень сильно посадила голос на концертах, т.к. именно она брала больше всего партий пока была группа, Катина была как на подпевках, теперь то да Лена выросла, а Юля петь толком не может( по большому счету они обе молодцы, и группа свое время большую популярность набрала, даже без Шаповалова! ни одну нашу группу не знают в странах зарубежья и заокеанья как эту! И песню любят и слушают до сих пор!
@@СветланаМ-о1о это карма! Волкова вечно лезла вперёд и действительно брала больше партий и, правильно, мечтала, чтобы Катина была у неё на подпевках, хотя можно было и без этого! Надо было раньше думать о проблемах с голосом и что-то менять, а не упрямо тянуть на себя одеяло!
Ещё спасибо за музыку Сергею Галояну)
Чувак в 18 лет написал тупо хит)
@@LimePieMusic согласен!
уффф прикольно было наблюдать за ними в режиме рилтайм ) мне было 10, когда по MTV ежедневно крутили Я сошла с ума. было здорово! ) до сих пор нравится их музыка, но вот всё, что они делали сольно - ничего не запомнилось.
Все их обаяние заключалась в том что они были невинными девочками которые боролись за себя и за свои чувства не смотря не на что. Пластические операции, попса и развратные видеоклипы все испортили по моему мнению.
Согласна
Чего испортили?
Im still a huge fan how time flies so fast I'm 30 now..
Haha same girl...and I'm 32 lol x)
Same
Одна из крутейших групп, тащусь от самой первой песни! Спасибо татушки!
Verоnica Да,они были огонь
Don’t make plastic surgery a bad thing, if she feels beautiful let her feel beautiful guilty free
Isa Moe thank you!!!!!
She has the right to alter her face as she sees fit. What we're saying is she didn't need that plastic surgery - people would have killed to have her natural face.
Stfu
Amen
@@itsjemmabond ok???
Like I've said in the other channel. When I listen to your song when you were much younger. And now you have grown up.
Юля и Лена - вы крутые и такими и останетесь в наших сердцах !!!!
As a teenager in the early 2000, TATU always be my idols!
They got older.. Lena is a good looking lady now and Julia look like a Barbie doll
You've just insulted Barbie :D
Лучший проект. Такого к сожалению уже не будет никогда. Жаль, что все так закончилось.
а две Маши ?
все ещё будет только жди
@@florida75 сравнила...
@@florida75 2 маши с тату даже рядом не стоят, извините
Нормально закончилось. Хватит нами одной Пугачихи. Всё должно быть вовремя.
Extremadamente talentosas, pero juntas eran una bomba !!!! Diganme nostalgica pero juntas eran dinamita ! A mi si me gustaria que se volvieran a juntar no para siempre como grupo pero si para un proyecto, porque precisamente ya maduraron....
Yo las amo 😘🤩
Лена Катина всегда вызывала симпатию)
Такой светлый, добрый и жизнерадостный лучик
Love you all song the best...
Still listening this song now 2021 jully
You are my idol 😍😍
I from 🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩
Muchas gracias 🥰❤️❤️❤️me hiciste recordar tanto ameee volver a escuchar por orden.
I love this group. I need to get more of their music. I don't have their solo stuff.
1:38 I heard this song when I was a child. However, the Russian singer did not expect the song to be released by accident. Because sometimes I thought about the song of a girl and a boy kissing in the rain.
Так необычно, что их музыка для запада значительно отличалась от материала, записанного для России.Американские версии песен более качественные и серьёзные, а для России в то время они решили сделать звучание на подобие "Руки вверх".Вот что значит - коммерческий план.🙃
Это потому что английские песни были записаны позади и музыкальное сопровождение доробатывалось
люди инвалиды = Dangerous And Moving
учим английский
Ну тут названия в транскрипции в основном, их песни
а ты в курсе что английские версии делались не один в один чтобы были одинаковы? или ты настолько глуп реально думая что тут и текст и названия должны быть переведены из оригинала?)
Love Lena Katina and what she did in TAtu, they will come back again in the future❤️🧡💚💙💜🤍 Your sound levels are really bad from video to video but love what you have done x
Капец как юля себя изуродовала, смотреть жутко, лена наоборот похорошела, такая красивая, солнечная, приятная 😍 и песни приятно слушать
Н вне знаю последние песни похоже на группу Винтаж по стилю , да и сама она похоже на Аню Плетневу❗Хотя песня не когда крутая❗
Да....🤔
Прежде всего, изуродованные тут только исключительно мозги холуяжа-фанатов, что пресмыкаются перед этими выросшими лоли, что ради имиджа изображали ковырялок.
@@alexblinoff5241 изображали ,чего в этом такого. Зачем вообще зашел тогда ,раз так не нравится
Абсолютно согласен. Когда они только появились на Лену вообще не смотрел. А Юля была божественна. А сейчас Лена стала настоящей женщиной, а Юля превратила себя в пластиковую куклу. Смотреть противно...
Если бы Юля голос не потеряла, её песни бы и дальше были. У неё очень танцевальные и клубные хиты. Хорошие. Если бы её грамотно двигали, она бы многого могла добиться.
Если бы меня грамотно двигали и я мог многого добиться!)
all about us時開始聽❤
小時候有在電視聽到all the things she said……
長大後找不到誰唱的🎉
結果發現～我又愛上他們了
Greetings from mexico i am your fans i am happy with newspapers i listen yo your music i love you very much😘😘😘😘
😭 forever TATU and i miss 💜
Siempre las amare, todo el tiempo están en mi mente y corazón 🥺 quisiera volver a verlas juntas a Lena y Julia como amigas...
I still have footsteps in my head, because of „running trough my head“...
Me faltó escuchar #Shot de Lena y t-killah. Además de #TicToc con Belanova. Son un clásico.
Когда Татушки только появились я был просто очарован Волковой... Для меня она была практически эталоном девушки и спустя 8 лет я нашел на работе практически ее копию которая стала моей женой... Но чудо длилось недолго... Не верьте брюнеткам с короткой стрижкой и красивыми глазами...
Мне вот как-то больше всегда нравилась Лена. Этакий светлый, красивый, жизнерадостный и добрый лучик
О да, особенно её голос😍 Как жаль, что у него такой трагичный конец...
This channel brings some old memories wow
What ever you are well done u just made my day looks better
If i remember correct. I saw them preform on Jay Leno about 18 yrs ago. The song caught my ear. I've always wondered about them. Thank u for sharing this. I know nothing of ur personal lives. But I do know about water under the bridge. Much luv.
Too much surgery Julia, you looked perfect before
I started to listen to English music in around 2004-2005 when I was a high school student. In 2007 I had a chance to know about t.A.T.u. music and I fell in love with them. Until now, I still listen to their old songs...
I love them, but being apart will be never be as good as together.
Thanks for this, I like the direction Yulia has gone with her music
Я сам 2006 года, около месяца назад услышал песню "робот", показалась жутко знакомой, но в тоже время казалось что я её впервые слышал. Решил послушать остальные песни тату, и оказалось что половину я чуть ли не наизусть знаю, а остальные где то слышал. И Лена с Юлей оказались очень знакомы внешне.
А родители не слушали в юности? Возможно генетическая память
@@e.e.9292 нет, они в юности в основном металику и Ленинград слушали, попсу вобще нет
@@e.e.9292 более того они были очень удивлены что я ранее презиравший и ненавидящий попсу так её полюбил
привет, брат по разуму!
А если подойдёшь к зеркалу - есть вероятность увидеть что-то знакомое.
it breaks my heart that one of them got made unrecogniseable :/
I first heard them when I was like 5 or 6 Im 18 now and still listen to them. They helped me find and embrace my sexuality(bi). I love their songs so much.
So GOOD !! 😍😍❤❤
i love the original yulia thanks for not becoming another person lena
❤t.a.t.u por siempre ❤
💖Julia volkova 👭💖
💖Y Lena katina 👭💖
I still love Tatu! ❤️
Amo este dúo, a pesar de que ya pasaron años, me siguen gustando, más la canción All The Thing She Said amo esta canción, las amo
Ver tú video es regresar en el tiempo. 👌
I really wish I was born back when their group first started. I love to see a lgbtq duo band, their supposed to be getting back in spring though! I hope Julia learns how to use her new voice
You can check out their separate 20th anniversary interviews. They are still not in good terms unfortunately. They're not members of LGBTQ community. Back then, Yulia had made homophobic statements but I think it was because out of fear for her son's future/life (Check out Russia's attitude towards gays that time. I don't know how much have changed now). Lena however is always welcome to gay clubs as a guest music artist.
The video is great but you missed a lot of Lena's collaborations, the one with belanova, the one with tkilla the one with Clark Owen, the one with Noemi Smorra...
Vanessa Villagrana I love all those songs! I discluded them because I wanted to focus on their purely solo work. I included Julia’s with Dima Bilan as she does not have as many solo songs sadly
Foarte frumos video clipul ❤😊!
Me gustaba tatu en los años 2000 cuando su sonido iba más orientado al rock... después su sonido no fue el mismo. Pero desde que escuché All the things she said en la radio y por todos lados, la ame.
J'ai adoré ce groupe, leur musique, leur présence sur scène quand elles chantaient on avait l'impression que rien ne les atteignaient...Bref j'étais un de leurs nombreux fan !
2020 update: Believe in Goodbyes
Шикарная нарезка. Спасибо!