How Long Can We Make The Wall?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 ก.ย. 2024
- I take a look at all the different versions of Pink Floyd's The Wall, such as the film, it's companion piece The Final Cut, and it's multiple tours, trying to see how much I can add onto the original album
What always throws me off is how Hey You was removed from The Wall movie, out of all things because of it's thematic development. So essentially there exists a true Film edit that includes the original Wall studio lineup.
Hey You was shot but they didn't think it looked unique enough compared to the rest of the film. You can edit it back into the movie if you want
th-cam.com/video/xqLRuMmrlfg/w-d-xo.html
The Show Must Go On was not shot
When I figured out that outside the wall flowed perfectly into in the flesh I was so excited. It's also crazy they decided to do that bc with just vinyls and tapes back then, nobody would really get it
The first time I ever listened to the whole album (after I had become infatuated with the floyd), I was listening on Apple Music, and it auto looped so clearly! I was amazed! They made music for literally 40 years ahead of their time
@@houserhouse Same scenario here, I just got Apple Music free trial and that’s the first album I wanna try.
Even tho I used Spotify before but I just do random plays and the whole album was just on background of my studies so I didn’t really experience The Wall how it was intended to
@@merisproject it's one of the best albums ever imo
no we all all got it like over 40yrs ago,,where you been?
I actually made countless extended mixes of The Wall over the years. My latest, which I made last year, breaks the 3 hour threshold and is 55 tracks long, every song in each act segueing into each other.
Act I (42:12)
1. Prelude (We'll Meet Again) (0:55) - the one from the demo with all the radio effects, starts with "we came in" before the radio click
2. In the Flesh? (3:38) - includes a very short cut instrumental segment, taken from the movie I believe
3. The Thin Ice (2:52) - includes extended intro from the movie
4. Another Brick in The Wall (Part 1) (3:07) - includes extended intro taken from a documentary or a promotional video or something like that I believe
5. One of the Few (1:40)
6. Teacher, Teacher (3:01)
7. The Happiest Days of Our Lives (1:20)
8. Another Brick in The Wall (Part 2) (6:18) - includes a live keyboard and guitar solo
9. The Hero's Return (2:42)
10. The Gunner's Dream (5:18)
11. The Hero's Return (Part 2) (1:15)
12. Young Lust (Part 1) (4:27) - the bluesy demo version
13. Mother (5:32)
Act II (55:20)
1. When the Tigers Broke Free (3:41)
2. Two Suns in the Sunset (5:25)
3. Goodbye Blue Sky (2:39)
4. Welcome to the Machine (7:09)
5. Have a Cigar (7:11) - used the uncut jam from the boxset
6. What Shall We Do Now? (4:02) - movie version
7. Young Lust (Part 2) (4:52) - used a live rendition, doesn't sound too jarring with the other songs
8. Sexual Revolution (4:41) - the demo version
9. One of My Turns (3:32)
10. Don't Leave Me Now (3:59)
11. Empty Spaces (2:05) - album version, it's where it was originally meant to go
12. Another Brick in The Wall (Part 3) (1:21)
13. The Last Few Bricks (3:32)
14. Goodbye Cruel World (1:05) - only shorter than the album cut because of how I split the tracks
Act III (45:24)
1. Hey You (4:50)
2. Is There Anybody Out There? (Part 1) (2:49)
3. Nobody Home (5:01) - includes a live guitar solo
4. Vera (1:18)
5. The Post War Dream (2:43)
6. Bring the Boys Back Home (1:39)
7. Paranoid Eyes (3:46)
8. Get Your Filthy Hands Off My Desert (1:00)
9. The Fletcher Memorial Home (4:13) - an edit that removes the spoken word bridge, leaving it only instrumental
10. Southampton Dock (2:01)
11. The Final Cut (5:08)
12. Is There Anybody Out There? (Part 2) (0:57)
13. Is There Anybody Out There? (Part 3) (2:39) - in hindsight I probably should've merged these two
14. Comfortably Numb (7:15) - uses a live solo
Act IV (40:14)
1. The Show Must Go On (2:47) - includes a cut verse and intro taken from the live version
2. Master of Ceremonies (0:55)
3. Not Now John (4:50)
4. In The Flesh (4:33)
5. Run Like Hell (5:12) - includes a LOT of cut segments from different sources, some from the movie, some from a promotional EP I believe
6. Waiting for the Worms (4:02) - includes a couple of extra bars in the outro taken from the movie
7. Stop (0:27) - only shorter than the album cut because of how I split the tracks
8. Your Possible Pasts (4:19)
9. The Trial (5:32)
10. Who's Sorry Now (2:31) - demo version of The Show Must Go On with different lyrics, placed after The Trial in one of the demo versions
11. Outside the Wall (1:53) - uses a demo version to make the segue into the next track easier on the ears
12. It's Never Too Late (1:23)
13. The Thin Ice? (1:16) - the instrumental reprise of The Thin Ice, just thought it'd be appropriate to call it that
14. Postlude (The Little Boy That Santa Claus Forgot) (0:28) - ends with the same radio click from the prelude, ending with "isn't this where", completing the loop.
There's some stuff I know I left out and could've included, such as the demo version of Another Brick in The Wall, Part 1 with different lyrics (the Reminiscing demo), the movie version of Bring the Boys Back Home (maybe using that and mixing Roger's vocals in?), and the 8 minute The Last Few Bricks (Part 2) which was played once when the wall builders weren't done in time, and in hindsight I probably should've put some tracks in different places, but I'm still happy with how grand, ambitious (and admittedly pretentious) the mix is. I could send it over if you wanna hear it.
I would be very interested if you have the time to upload thi to somewhere
Mine is very similar to this but I think the Final Cut section in yours gets a little diluted
Please upload it somewhere, I'm begging you
Please upload it, would love to hear it :)
I'm working on a slight revision that's even longer but it cuts out some of the more boring bits (like the open section in Sexual Revolution) and incorporates some more cut verses and demo bits but I'll see what I can do afterwards
Technically speaking, What Shall We Do Now doesn't follow Empty Spaces, the whole track is actually WSWDN. ES was originally a reprise of the first half of WSWDN and was placed before Brick3. It eventually replaced WSWDN on the album but the key had to be trasposed up from D to E so that it could flow into Young Lust. On The Wall Live In Berlin WSWDN is actually credited as Es, while on Is There Anybody Out There? it's split into two tracks as ES and WSWDN.
What I would love to hear is how Side 2 would have sounded before WSWDN was cut, and how the songs would have segued into one another. My theory is that the long instrumental introduction of Empty Spaces (complete with the backwards message) was actually the intro of WSWDN, and ONLY WSWDN; the introduction of Empty Spaces, over Don't Leave Me Now's final chord fading out, would have been much shorter. What's more, the tempo of Empty Spaces, when slowed down to be in D minor again, matches the tempo of Another Brick In The Wall Part 3 perfectly, so the two songs would have segued very well. It then raises the question of where would the TV smashing have gone. I think there may have been an instrumental intro to Brick 3 which the smashing noises would have played over and was another casualty of the cuts for the vinyl release. Brick 1's intro was also longer originally, with the final chord of The Thin Ice fading into a synth playing a D minor chord, and then the chug-chugga-chug guitar of Brick 1 starting cleanly.
The musical similarities between "Welcome to the Machine" and the beginning of "Empty Spaces" always made me think that was Waters saying "You want to know how Pink got here? Go listen to 'Welcome to the Machine.'" Hell, throw in "Have a Cigar" before "Machine" to show Pink getting wooed and wowed by the industry, then getting ground to pieces in "Machine."
any of you guys have social lives? I mean I have loved Floyd sine 72 but wow , must have very understanding girlfriends and wives ...yeah sure
@@jestermindcrime1773 what?
This concept is absolutely off its fricking nut. But if you really want to break the 3hr mark then you need to stitch and extend songs. The Comforably Numb solo can be very long if using alternative live sources. The last few bricks is also a long one which can be extended. Drop the live solo in "Nobody home" into the mix. Suddenly you have a unnecessarily long wall to scale.
Also to consider:
The 8 track extended intro to Young Lust.
The extended film intro to The Thin Ice
An extended intro to In The Flesh? That has the backing vocals of the verse on their own before the lead vocals come in, as heard in the movies.
An extra verse sung live as a part of The Show Must Go On
wow, how could i never had seen this incredible video before? As a fan of pink floyd, this is a awesome material
Haha thanks! My channel, specifically my other Pink Floyd video, recently got an uptick in views out of the blue so that's probably why you're only seeing it now
I LOVE The Wall Rebuilt in all of its 4 hour long glory. Its hauntingly beautiful.
from this video you have gained your 1000th sub!! good video
Version 1: Original Studio Album
(1:19)
Version 2: The Film Edit
(1:53)
Version 3: The Final Cut Edit
(3:19)
Version 4: Is There Anybody Out There? Edit
(4:53)
Version 5: Final Wall Oddities
(5:51)
Version 6: Pushing Your Luck Edit
(7:40)
Version 7: Random Bullshit Edit
(8:59)
Version 8: Shit I Have Never Heard Of Cut
(10:42)
Version 9-infinity: The Loop Cut
(12:27)
How aren't you a bigger youtuber!?!? Your content is just gold
All in all, these edits are just another brick in the wall
My personal extended edition of The Wall, which I heard last night under effects of LSD:
1) We'll meet again
2) In the flesh?
3) The thin ice
4) Another brick in the wall (Pt.1)
5) One of the few
6) Teacher, teacher
7) The happiest days of our lives
8) Another brick in the wall (Pt.2)
9) Mother
10) When the tigers broke free
11) Goodbye, blue sky
12) Young lust (Pt.1)
13) Sexual revolution
14) Empty spaces
15) Young lust (Pt.2)
16) What shall we do now?
17) One of my turns
18) Don't leave me now
19) Another brick in the wall (Pt.3)
20) Goodbye, cruel world
21) Hey, you
22) Is there anybody out there?
23) Nobody home
24) Your possible pasts
25) Vera
26) Bring the boys back home
28) Comfortably numb
29) The final cut
30) I can't breath anymore (from the first Gilmour solo album)
31) The show must go on
32) In the flesh
33) Run like Hell
34) Not now, John!
35) Waiting for the worms
36) Stop.
37) The trial
38) Outside the wall
39) Spare bricks (The thin ice demo)
40) It's never too late
“…under the effects of LSD”
ik it’s your life and all, but just reminding you what happened to Syd with LSD
anyway, good edit, this is exactly how I imagined the Wall (just wihout spare bricks at the end, or not now john)
SOMEBODY MAKE THIS A PLAYLIST PLEASE
quality content need more views
I once took any outtakes, demos that were different enough from the originals and some of the final cut and made a version with around 80 songs. I've never listened to it all the way through.
why not? how you gonna know if it is any good? or if you even really did it,,,never know mite have been a dream , and does this happen often ?
@@jestermindcrime1773I've heard around half, but It's over 4 and a half hours long, almost every song has a second version, Another Brick In The Wall has 9, so I've never had the time or the focus to get through as it drags on and continues repeating itself.
@@_.Jamie_Smith._ it's cool was messing around..you guys have way more of a attention span then me.... cool but love this shit tks
You could of included songs from Richard Wrights wet dream
The full version of “In the Flesh” should see the light of day along with “What shall we do now?”
To me, my mix would just swap in what shall we do now for empty spaces, have the longer versions of Bring the Boys Back Home and Outside the Wall, and put 'Fletcher Memorial Home' after Vera.
I wouldn't use The Final Cut as it is arguably about Pink after the wall came down. Maybe I would've released it as a single.
Throw in have a cigar, that one mentions pink, probably not the same one but it can fit somewhere
Ps: you really missed out on not calling this video “How tall can we make the wall”
I kinda think it would be funny if I talked to the wind was thrown on there. despite being by king crimson, the song is about isolation so why not
I recently made my own fan edit of the movie. I added hey you as well as a couple songs from the final cut video ep
Link?
Maybe dark globe from the madcap laughs could come before or after Don't leave me now?
Side three of The Wall can be up to forty five minutes. I know this from experience.
really? from "experience" you say,,,well ok then, don't mess around ,you know how serious thus is
Gods work
So… what is the final track listing
you forgot to mention the 1990 Roger Waters The Wall Live in Berlin! which was a HUUUUGE concert. pretty sure it got officially put out on DVD.
Alright this is cool and all, but where can I listen to this edit?
179 fucking minutes, that'll need it's own milk crate to store all those 12x12s
Oh hey Sylver!
there's also Eric pryz's proper education which is kinda a remix of another brick pt2
There's a few more demo's on the immersion box set that never made the cut. Teacher Teacher is another
There are a lot of demos you aren't including that should be there. A lot of the Final Cut is from the POV of survivors of WWII and don't fit. The Gunner's dream is his father's soul drifting off to Heaven, and fits well after Tigers Part 2. Joining In the Flesh together negates the entire narrative structure: both versions are the same moment in time from different perspectives, one of the audience, the other of the performer. The entire narrative takes place in Pink's head as he comes out on stage, and without the two versions of ITF the narrative is shattered
What's the final tracklist then?
The Little Boy That Santa Claus Forgot
Rem Song
MC: Atmos
In The Flesh?
The Thin Ice
Another Brick In The Wall ( Pt. 1 )
When The Tigers Broke Free
Bring The Boys Back Home ( Film Version )
Your Possible Pasts
One Of The Few
The Hero's Return ( Pt. 1 )
The Gunner's Dream
The Hero's Return ( Pt. 2 )
Paranoid Eyes
The Happiest Days Of Our Lives
Another Brick In The Wall ( Pt. 2 )
The Ballad Of Jean Charles De Menezes
Mother
The Post War Dream
Goodbye Blue Sky
Welcome To The Machine
What Shall We Do Now?
Young Lust
Sexual Revolution
One Of My Turns
Don't Leave Me Now
Near The End
Empty Spaces
Another Brick In The Wall ( Pt. 3 )
The Last Few Bricks
Goodbye Cruel World
There's No Way Out Of Here
Hey You
Is There Anybody Out There? ( Pt. 1 )
Nobody Home
Southhampton Dock
The Final Cut
Get Your Filthy Hands Off My Dessert
The Fletcher Memorial Home
Vera
Bring The Boys Back Home ( Album Version )
Is There Anybody Out There? ( Pts. 2-3 ) ( I Think??? )
Comfortably Numb
The Thin Ice ( Reprise )
The Show Must Go On
MC: Atmos 2
In The Flesh
Run Like Hell
Not Now John
Waiting For The Worms
Stop
The Trial
Outside The Wall
It's Never Too Late
Two Suns In The Sunset
We'll Meet Again
I honestly always felt really disappointed about them getting rid of when the tigers broke free. Like it’s not the best song he’ll quality wise it might as well be filler but from a narrative perspective I feel like it adds a lot as in the album edit the father’s death is only hinted to twice (Vera Lynn and another brick in the wall part 1) even though it plays a huge role in pinks psychology growing up.
You hace to be fucking insane to listen to an album for 3/infinite hours
Could shine on you crazy diamond be apart of the wall? Just wondering?
Honestly should have added ummagumma
k thats pushing it,,,care to explain
ummagumma
@@jestermindcrime1773 Ummagumma
To "flesh" out The Wall?
Believe me, we see what you did there.
Do we really need more and more applause?
th-cam.com/play/PL5Axozg9cJovI6CIekNst4QkmRLftibA8.html this playlist right here is an extended version of the wall that i personally prefer
What shall we Do now is way different than empty spaces because empty spaces goes after don’t leave me now on the original list (the surviving misprints)
Except that's not all, you can still add more.
A Great Day For Freedom from The Division Bell mentions a wall coming down at the beginning, and could make a great closer to the album. I'd personally put it after The Trial. The wall has just come down, and people are happy about it. This brings us to 183:11.
And THAT'S STILL NOT ALL. During The Wall Berlin TV concert, the end song was replaced with another song called The Tide Is Turning, I'm presuming to give the album a more uplifting ending. So, you can stick that in there as well. I think this one would come after The Trial and before Great Day for Freedom, it's the immediate fallout and it's showing how Pink is now trying to change himself as a person. This gives us another 6:45 or so of content, give or take as the actual vocals version has never been released properly, and this brings our total album length up to 189 minutes and 56 seconds, or in other words, 3 hours, 9 minutes and 56 seconds of Wall.
A Great Day for Freedom is specifically about the Berline wall and not related to The Wall album
The Tide Is Turning is originally from Waters' album Radio KAOS and was put there to promote that album as t was new at the time. I thought about including it, but I think it's pretty unrelated. I think it works more thematically for a charity event, then the actual Wall proper
@@BlueTomorrows yeah that's true. It's funny how both of them are related to Berlin honestly, that's kind of weird. But yeah, my god that Berlin concert is one of the most extra concerts I've ever seen. There's just so much excess and commercialism, and I think the changing of the ending could also kind of be viewed as that as well. Like, they didn't want to have it end on a sad note, so they just changed the ending of it. But then I guess that can also be viewed as a more uplifting ending for the story considering the context of Berlin it's set in, it's the message of "yes, things are finally changing and things are going to get better"
But then like you said it also served to promote Radio KAOS as well, but yeah.
I call the addition of these two songs to The Wall, the "Uhhhhhh yeah ok sure I guess this works kind of maybe sort of I guess" edition.
The question is..who., in Holyoke's Holy Hell, needs another 7th or 8th ''remaster-ing'' or for that matter,' another fuckin Water's tour of The Wall???!?
Ideas for more BS
•Have A Cigar
•Ballad Of Jean Charles de Menezes
•The Tide Is Turning
•The Moment Of Clarity
•You Know I’m Right
That’s all I can think of at the moment.
the longest version of the wall i made with fan edits have 123 songs😅
The Wall Uber track listing: All the Pink Floyd albums from DSOTM to The Wall.
nope to general a statement,,,you gotta expand
The original Sexual revolution could of been good with young lust