@@demonspawn5164 They're fine games on their own, but they're not really Assassin's Creed games, and I think that rubs a lot of people the wrong way (myself included).
For me, Assassin's Creed III is definitely my top 1. It was the first AC game I played and had many nostalgic memories of it. The finishes and stealth kills really got me hyped back in the days. At the time, I was only 12 years old lol. Yup, completely biased but for me, its a game that is worth replaying after a couple of years.
Yeah I’m of the exact same opinion. I think I would’ve been the same age too. It’s just pure nostalgia for me whenever I play AC3 now, and for some reason people hate Conor or think he’s boring. However I feel the exact opposite and I feel his seriousness is what an assassin is supposed to be. You feel super badass and someone who’s determined and I feel that’s what an assassin is supposed to be.
Me too LOL, I Love that game and definetely my top 3 In AC games. I love the Side Missions, The Peg legg mission Frontiersman Misison And Most of all is the homestead missiob
Yes same it it one of my Favorites I respect what he said but I do not think that it should be cast aside. The game offers the best stealth we have seen in any assassins creed game if you don’t agree your lying also it has some of the best graphics and the story is not half bad and not to mention the parkour, it is the smoothest and coolest of any AC game no game comes close. I can say that he does fly sometimes lol but if you go back and play some of the old games like black flag and ac 3 the lag is way worse and the fame drops are a lot worse. But over all I thing that the lag matters more about what you play on my game is incredibly smooth with minor lag/glitches(remember the game is centered around being a assassin not a warrior the combat looks cool but it’s not fun it’s realistic)
Exactly! Everyone's gripes about all the bugs is what killed unity. If not for that it would be in everyone's S tier. I play it now on the Xbox Series X and it's exactly how it should have been when it came out. It looks like it recently came out on the series x tbh
@@Fizhy Not very long. I didn't know you were doing it. I was just watching LazerzZ video, and then I saw you were live. So I hopped on over here. Edit: Unless you're talking about getting a response from you. In which case, I'm not sure.
I really enjoyed it until reaching the ending, then suddenly the whole story just goes from Cesare seemingly having alot of power to completely losing it all out of nowhere and being betrayed by everyone around him, cutscene after cutscene with no time to intake anything that is happening, out of nowhere im 4 years into the future running at him in some random battlefield. At that point i was pretty lost, no satisfying interaction between Ezio and Cesare, oh and of course the game decided to soft lock right when we were about to have our boss fight, could not even finish the game, 5/10 unfortunately.
I really wish they go back and do sequels for characters like Edward and Bayek, because if they were given another game imo they could potentially be up there with Ezio. But honestly nowadays we’re lucky if we even get the chance to play as an actual Assassin
@@mrmeme2917 Don’t get me wrong I like Valhalla, but it’s like what James and George said recently, the game is pretty much 95% Vikings and only 5% Assassins
@@lukebellamy2673 yeah but they added as much as they could like Codex , Social Stealth ، Hidden Blade , Hoods , Robes , Assassin Bureaus , Fantastic Modern day , Really Heavy Lore , Eagle Vision .. the only thing is that Eivor is not an Assassin wish is Understandable because you have to remember this is a viking game and in games like this you have to prioritize the setting
@@RokuHanmar well I’m assuming the werewolves will not be a high event and will probably just be connected to the lore bit they added in Odyssey that they did to just randomly add mythological creatures with a ton of apples that shape shift them they’ll probably do the same with these and just found these apples since they’re druids that are highly driven by being connected to nature think the animalistic nature achieved with these apples are them being perfectly in sync with nature.
pretty long if you do the side stuff wich is the best part of the game. The only reason i like rogue more than 4 is because it doesn't hold your hand for sooo long with all the tutorials.
I already knew coming into this list that Odyssey would be dead last 😂 it’s my favourite one and I’ve sunk easily 300 hours into the game overall, I love the aesthetic and setting and have a really strong interest in the period of the game and thought the dlcs were very cool. Each to their own I guess, good video man!
Same, its my favorite one due to its gameplay and surrounding but the story is the one that lacks character... not gonna lie I played Valhalla but the combat system does not work for me, I played Origin but the story is just too short and easy to finish...
@@jjfgaming6355 I played the first one, the one with Desmond and Altair... but that was years before, I remember waiting few minutes in every loading screen... Good old days wherein games is not all about the graphics😁
Ezio Trilogy should be the foundation for every AC game to come. Honestly I can't get the right words to describe how AC Brotherhood and AC II makes me feel, those games are really special...
1. Annoyed you got this out the day before mine (Not that our viewrships are anything similar) 2. It is scary how similar our lists are 3. I appreciate your opinions
@@joyconboyz9587 I'm not sure if this is memeing or trolling, but just in case you're not. Both of us have made videos about our opinions, these will not necessarily line up with your thoughts and opinions. Personally I think if you have watched both videos you can understand why we have placed things where we have as outlined in said vids. You don't have to agree, that's the beauty of this life we live, we're all different and if you got joy from Odyssey, power to you mate!
I wouldn't place Syndicate that low. It was a fun game. I like the animated executions of the templars and the grappling hook was awesome! :D I also belong to the camp who thinks AC3 is the third best game after AC2 & Brotherhood. Modern day was also exciting in my opinion in AC3.
Syndicate was a very well made game. The stealth was probably the best in the series and they nailed so many other things. The setting, leveling, characters, etc. were all great.
I hated Syndicate sorry mate. I haven't played a more uninteresting videogame, and It isn't because of the setting, I thought the setting was full of potential. But the game felt like a sterilized Unity. Too afraid to do anything bold.
I agree with you on syndicate, but the grappling hook is so boring to use. They had the opportunity to make it like Spider-Man's webs which would have been awesome
Its my top 1 ac game story brutality stealth everything. And in a time where ac games were becoming stale ac origins just saved it all for me with the slight rpg. Still not as bad as odysseys
@@JKM2468 I kinda get it, the style of the game was a great departure from the previous games and also Connor as a charachter was the complete opposite to Ezio's. But I think that's what I love from the game, being different.
"No books, no wisdom. Just you, fratello mio." There's genuinely something about this moment that brought a tear to my eye when I first played it. Despite already being eight games into the franchise, as someone who never truly spent their entire life immersed in the modern day, it was these moments within the Animus that turned characters like Ezio Auditore and Altair into people. The moments that connected the world, the history and made everything that had happened in lieu and to come matter that much more. I think I'm due for another playthrough of the Ezio trilogy.
The ezio trilogy/story was phenomenal, it just got better and better every time, I remember when ac2 dropped and just coming from ac, it was mind blowing at the time, the last assassins creed game that ever made me feel the same way and full of excitement was black flag, the ending to that game is one of the best in the franchise and a very emotional one, right up there with ezio/altiar, WOW what happened ubi ? How did it all go so tita up 🤔
if it weren't that they put "Assassins Creed" the game would be really good, the reason why the majority has hatred over the game is because it's apart of the Assassins Creed franchise which is quite confusing since the game isn't about an Assassin at all. There aren't any Templars aswell, it just feels like an RPG Sandbox.
It would be an awesome game if not part of the Assassins Creed franchise. Has nothing to do with Assassins, so if they had figured out how to do that or made it another franchise it would have been miles better
I remember when I first begun playing assassins creed about 4 years ago. My dad took me to pick a game, and it just felt right. He recommended revelations just at a guess and honestly, I’m so glad I got revelations first. It allowed me to love the game without constantly wanting to compare it to other games. This is why I see revelations as a true masterpiece and top of the list. Honestly, the writing in revelations is absolutely beautiful. I’m practically in fucking tears while writing this because of the memories me and my older brother had with revelations. Also, odyssey gay lol
I always get a lot of shit for this but Revelations is always going to be my favourite AC game, it has the best ending to any game ever made imo. I personally loved Constantinople and visiting Masyaf as both Altair and Ezio was wonderful.
Revelations is fucking incredible, the music, the story, the Hook Blade, the set-pieces, the level design, the fun bombs you could craft. All of that stuff was awesome, Revelations deserves so much more praise among the AC community.
@@fredster594 it truly does, for all that you mentioned and so much more. It’s sad how underrated it is not even just among the AC community but games in general.
honestly i think most, including me, would agree with you if they weren’t blinded by one thing. nostalgia. i will always love ac2 because i grew up with it and i am just a simp for the setting as a whole. the whole experience was just magical to me as a kid, as still is now. but if i was newely introduced to the series, i would go with revelations.
I think Odyssey would have been better if it took place later and was a Bayek and Aya sequel detailing Aya's assassination of Cleopatra and Bayek expanding The Hidden Ones into Greece.
Black Flag's ending nearly made me cry. Those visuals of all the characters we come to know and love and the amazing rendition of Parting Glass by Sarah Greene as Anne Bonny was just such a powerful combination; Edward then giving his daughter the flower and telling her she can steer the Jackdaw.😥
I completely agree 100%. Black Flag was the game that got me into Assassin’s Creed; I’ve never regretted playing that game. I love it, but I just hope they remaster it, and get rid of some of those annoying ass tailing missions; so repetitive and stupid.
I think Origins left a great foundation and they could have done something like Ezio or continued the origin story into Odyssey and expanded on the gameplay and stealth while staying close to the RPG style
The way you describe Odyssey gives me the sense that you haven't really payed much attention to it. Here's a few pointers from a guy who's finished the game twice with both characters: 1. There are Templars in the game, it's the Cult of Kosmos. They're basically the Templars' predecessors along with the Order of the Ancients. 2. While Alexios and Kassandra aren't Assassins themselves their deeds and beliefs are basically the inspiration for the creation of the Hidden Ones and the Assassin Brotherhood, especially since they are ancestors of Aya from AC Origins. 3. The game's choice system takes advantage of the limited knowledge we have of the time period it takes place in order to allow the player to make their own story as they play the game, which is why they main characters seem without personalities of their own and why you choose genders at the beginning. You shape your character's personality as you please. 4. The side quests do seem unconnected to the main story at first glance but you pay close attention to the story you will realize that there are connections.
Your 3rd point is exactly why it's a bad Assassin's Creed game. The modern day character is supposed to experience his/her ancestor's memories. It's supposed to have happened at some point in time. Being able to have choices, specially genders and different endings throws that point out the window. Just make it male or female and stick to it.
I loved odyssey. Such a beautiful game. Plus the reason it wasn't full on only about assassinations was because ancient Greek was about heroes completing quests and that's what made them heroes (not just killing someone and moving on). And this takes place way before any time period. So assassins was a new thing. And like u said, their ideas and beliefs shape the future games. Well said. Ppl don't understand the story and say ac odyssey is bad
@@Sriram-ig6pr as an RPG might be good at best. But as an Assassin's Creed game is rightfully at the bottom. Ubisoft should have just made an RPG game about ancient Greece. But call it Assassin's Creed game was a bad move. And I'm very impressed that it was the second best selling assassin's creed game at launch
@@Fizhy This is why I am a bigger fan of you rather than Lazerzz no offence to him, but I feel he can be pretty harsh on the later AC games while just ignoring the positives. You on the other hand calmly explain why you do or don't like what you like and encourage people who disagree with you to be proud of their opinions
Yeah I am unashamed to say I actually really like Odyssey, but it may be because I wasn't able to play the originals first except for revelations and therefore my view of it comes from someone who just really loves open world games as a whole.
@@AltairStealth The only thing holding origins from being higher than black flag for me is the levelling system and having to grind to get to a certain level before playing main missions
I think one of reasons the Ezio trilogy is so great is because of their soundtracks. Jasper Kyd did an amazing job composing masterpieces imo which sort of embodies the renaissance period if that makes sense.
The biggest reason for me is replay value. None of the games in that trilogy wasted time setting things up. I have a hard time going back to AC3 and Odyssey because they just take way too long to actually start getting to the juice.
I still find it funny during the release of assassins creed 3 I was complaining that Connors colours were white and blue instead of assassin white and red, if i went back in time and told myself what was happening today I probably would of killed myself 😂
Brotherhood is what made me fall in love with the franchise I was 12 and had just moved states and it brought me comfort and it’s actually the only game I’ve 100% finished in the franchise it breaks my heart how the newer game (odyssey, origins,Valhalla) are turning out
This is an old video of yours but I love that you put the opening sound for each one I recognize all of the ogs before you even said them🤘🏼 I agree with your reasoning for each ranking, thanks for a good video!
The new trilogy: 1. easy origins 2. Valhalla 3. odyssey This is from an assassins creed perspective and not the game itself. Odyssey is a good game defiantly, but just not a good assassins creed
Interesting that your comment here is the only one I’ve seen defending unity, even though it is mechanically one of the best assassins creed games. If the fidelity of all of the games were compared to today’s standards, I would say Unity is the best. I don’t ever see anyone making a legitimate critisism of Unity that is actually true to its CURRENT state.
I loved ac odyssey, i played the older ac games when I was younger like early teens and I couldt get into them. Odyssey brought me back to the franchise and I loved every moment. The brilliant setting, the unique weapons. I enjoyed playing it enough to put in 150+ hours and do everything in the game. So yeh you could say I liked it.
I loved ac Odyssey to the max. My number 1 and ive played all the games. Yes it lacks the Enzio mysteries but imo its fantastic amd better now with the dlcs. I suppose it suits us older gamers who just like to sit and play for hours. Btw a lot of the criticisms are BS
I personally enjoyed odyssey, was beautiful, liked the gear. Idk I'm not a die hard AC fan and just enjoy the games. I also enjoyed unity bc I could do missions with buddies.
AC Odyssey is actually my favorite AC game, that might be because I’m really interested in the culture and mythology of Ancient Greece so I had a blast while playing it, also relevant that this was the first AC game I played.
Yeah I agree the setting of odyssey gives me really good vibes and ancient Greece as a whole is beautiful plus kassandra is a great protagonist in my opinion.
It was your first game thats why, the game is decent I love it but this was not AC game for fuck sake ubisoft stop this shame dont call it AC its fucking not
AC3 imo had the best soundtrack. The theme, freedom fighter, brawl fight music, chasing Charles Lee soundtrack, and fighting music in the frontier were some of the best and catchy soundtracks.
I feel like Origins should be higher on the list tbh. You don't play as an assassin technically, but Bayek's whole story is him acting as a proto-assassin, it's not that disconnected. The RPG elements were still very bearable, the story and soundtrack were great, the game world was by far the most beautiful, and the protagonist was one of the best in the series. I understand Edward not getting a sequel (since his story ended pretty nicely in one game), but Bayek showed great potential as the first mentor of the brotherhood in the DLC, it's a damn shame he didn't get a sequel.
I’ve played most Assassins Creed games, the only ones I haven’t played are Brotherhood and Odyssey, and my personal favorite is Unity. I just loved that game, the movement, the city of Paris was amazing, the story was good (not great) but still to this day I install it and play around in that amazing world. Most underrated AC game ever made.
I created one hell of a concept when I was younger. It would be called Assassin's Creed: Divided *The templars decide to have the states secede so they can do what they want without the government (which is assassin-influenced) interfering *MC actually witnesses the templars decide this but can't stop them *MC is tasked by the council to go to Southern states to help the assassin's in that area (who are being under attack by confederates who are controlled by templars *Tries to sabotage the south from the inside by rescuing slaves and creating a small army (like a mix between the Rooks and Connor's Brotherhood) *World is quite large, housing multiple southern cities *World is divided into districts that need liberated *At some point, MC and his Assassin-milita aid the Union in a battle *MC gains the attention of Abraham Lincoln and the two become friends (like Leonardo and Ezio) *In the epilogue, MC hunts down John Wilkes Booth (who is canonically killed by an assassin), who is a templar *Andrew Johnson becomes president, and is backed by templars and hence begins the templar's modern control over the american government
@@Agent_3141 that was good asf, but the reason they denied it is prob bc of touchy racial issues, or people complaining ab slavery being made into a game
I’m in the same boat. AC II and Brotherhood almost shear the same spot on my list. But after playing both games this past two weeks I feel like AC II is at the top for me.
Personally his top 5 matched mine perfectly, Revelations being the one ik most people arguing over seeing as they either had Fizhy’s perspective or they felt it was rushed And had boring game play mechanics. But definitely seeing Ezio connect to both Altair and Desmond is by far one of my best gaming experiences and I will never forget it
Revelations is undoubtly the worst of the trilogy, and of the OG 1-BF/Rogue games. The main story is terribly written, antagonist is even worse than those 'filler bad guys' like unity and syndicate had, parkour ruined what the previous 2 were trying to build by literally removing big features like climb leap and the ledge grabs with the hook blade are just clunky. It has zipplines, so what? The pacing is the worst in the franchise cuz there isn't a single place in the game where all enemy archetypes spawned. AC2 did a perfect job here adding a brute, armorered guy, seeker, archer and regular guard to every single faction. In Revelations there are 2 factions, one with seekers, brutes and regular guards and one with agiles, elites and jannusaries. The new tool selecting system was a missed opportunity cuz brotherhood had 4 quick selects but you could select 7 weapons using it. In Revelations weapon wheel is the way.
Thanks again for the help moving my fridge freezer fizhy mate appreciate it and remember assassin's creed is only going to get worse for the OG assassin's creed fans Roadhouse
@@aristosachaion1057 do you know what ac is. One of the frist lines of the franchise (i.e the Frist game) condrodict the idea that you can make choices in oddesy.
Over the years my appreciation of Brotherhood and Revelations grows more and more. AC2 used to be my favorite, but every time I fire up Brotherhood I find it’s just more fun to play. And I think people who say Black Flag isn’t a good AC game should take a closer look at it.
AC 2 and Brotherhood are spiritual games. When you move around at night time and listen to beautiful background music. That's like the best experience ever.
Yeah I mean I totally get him not thinking its a good AC game because well...its not. Its just a good open world spartan game, albeit slightly bloated. To say its one of the worst games he's ever played is just sounds too hyperbolic and edgy for the sake of edgy.
@Alex A. Lazzerz is biased I agree but don't call him garbage just for him hurting your ego it's stupid. And also I don't think fizhy is biased or stupid actually his reviews and opinions makes far more sense than of lazzerzs ones. But still i respect lazzerz and his reviews/opinions.
Never played AC until the last year. I started from the beggining and I have finished the AC1 and AC2 and now im playing brotherhood(2-3 hours of playing). So far AC1 is my favourite. I also enjoyed a lot AC2 wich had better gameplay than the first but I think it was a bit repetive at some point.
Just Downloaded assassin's creed odyssey. I'm about 20 minutes into the game and it's fantastic. I don't know what you talking about. Odyssey is great.
Bro you cant form an opinion off of 20 minutes of gameplay. Its not even an Assassins Creed game. Its an ancient Greek RPG with bullshit excuses of artifacts that link to the Isu.
Not at all. Odyssey grabbed me from the get-go and remained compelling throughout the 150 hours I spent on it (covering main mission, all locations, side missions and most cult members). The only thing I objected to was the mythical creature fights - I'd have preferred alternate ways of beating these other than just 10 minutes of trying to whack them whilst avoiding being hit yourself.
I know the majority of the community doesn’t like Odyssey but I love Greek mythology and I didn’t think of it like an assassins creed game. I looked at it just like an open world game and had so much fun.
I can't comment on the list in general because I haven't played all the games but I loved AC3 and ACL. I think AC Odyssey is incredible and plan to play it again once I finish the DLC's
@@bigassfrog6376 odessey is a great game and I've played/own every single assassin's creed game. It's just different with is fine people complain about the lb systems just don't be trash at the game lol.
I went in thinking black flag would be your number 2 or maybe even #3 and was surprised to see you rank Revelations so high. However you made a very compelling argument: this was an amazing game when I first played it. I remember how satisfying the conclusion of Ezio and Altair was. The soundtrack was amazing too! This was a very solid video. Well done!
I own Odyssey and Origins. I got them because I like the time periods, and while I am a fan of the Asassin's Creed games, the three newest one's are clearly not Assassin's Creed games.
@@kingmustard1586 I'll leave this here. th-cam.com/video/_pRZxai0snY/w-d-xo.html Just because you're not an assassin doesn't mean it's not assassins creed. The series is bigger than assassins and templars. the series is about an ideological conflict dating back 75,000 years and the names "Assassin" And "Templar" Are just recent names for both sides of the war. But just watch that video and tell me Valhalla isn't assassins creed.
Idk I understand odyssey’s ranking but personally I don’t agree although you are right it’s the most disconnected and ads the least to the franchise, but for some reason that never bothered me I enjoyed the theme and the open world for me was fun to explore and a liked some of the side missions some had a certain charm to them. Also the navel part was fun but not as good as black flag. Idk I’m always for fun over everything and ac odyssey delivers that fun factor for me and like I said I absolutely love the open world as surface level as it is. Although I do believe I’m biased cause I’m a huge Ancient Greek nerd and it finally delivered that open world Ancient Greek game with some bland but at least the illusion of choice worked for me lmao even more than fallout 4’s did
Also the way I think about the AC franchise is different than most for me it’s always been the historical setting first Assassins and and first civilization stuff second so the new direction they’ve been taking I’ve been enjoying thoroughly although I see why long time fans are upset, and again IMO the writing hasn’t been as good since black flag so I’ve just focused on enjoying the historical setting and content first before the actual story and lore of the franchise
@@xannymanny9754 No, no, no, NO! Assassin's Creed was never ever supposed to be a history game. The main focus of the AC franchise back in the day was to tell a complex sci-fi story about the conflict between two secret organizations, the Historical settings were used to show us how large the conflict really is, and they were used as motivations for modern day story. But of course AC3 changed all of that, and ever since then Ubisoft has only wanted to make Assassin's Creed into open world history games.
@@fredster594 yeah and personally I have no problem with that sure it disappoints older fans which is a shame but nevertheless I like the premise and think they’re fun and IMO fun triumphs all when it comes to games
@@fredster594 i mean history was always a big part of the stories being told in AC, and after AC4 ubisoft stopped giving a shit about historical accuracy while in previous games historical accuracy was high on the list when it came to writing these games
@@kidCashOnline They did have history, yes. But the historical parts wasn't the main focus of the early games and were merely just used as a backdrop. the early games were primarly focused on the characters and conflict between the Assassins and Templars. AC1 is a game that takes place in the Third Crusades but it isn't a "Historical Crusades game" it's a sci-fi game with a touch bit of believability in them. This is why AC3's story was absolutely nothing compared to the previous installments, because the entire game was focused primarly on the American Revolution and not the characters, AC lore or conflict. The historical characters in AC3 sucked as well, because they were so generic and felt like they were just celebrities that were written off the history books, unlike before where the historical characters were unique, fictional and important to Altair & Ezio's story compared to their real life counterpart. AC4 went back to the AC1-Revelations styled storytelling and it was amazing! Edwards story is wonderfully told and uses all of the classic AC elements which made the old games work so wonderfully. And thankfully all of the historical characters are unique and actually feel important in Edward'a journey. Blackbeard, Mary Reed, Roberts, Captain Hornigold etc were all amazing and iconic AC characters because of this. AC4's story is in my opinion the 2nd best narrative in the series next to Revelations. However after this, they've went back to that bland and generic AC3 style of historical storytelling, and now... it's literally just a history game with RPG mechanics.
I really liked odyssey, not as an assassins creed game but as a pretty good RPG. I mean, my standards are very low, so low that the terrible humour made my brain go “haha chicken do funny”.
I feel like odyssey is amazing if you separate it from the other ac games. If you play as a misthios rather than an assassin you will enjoy it much more.
But that is the point. Why play an assassin’s creed game if you can’t play as an assassin? It may not be a bad game but it is the worst AC game there ever was.
@@dreamerzz7348 If the video was ranking the games that keep closest to the initial AC premise than sure. But it's not. It ranks the best games in the series. Odyssey is one of the best games, if not the best game in the series. It's a silly thing to say to drum up controversy.
I have to disagree with Valhalla. I love the combat, the best in the series imo. Story is passionately written, world is organic and beautiful, soundtrack is amazing. Characters are decent and mostly memorable. But it's really long and I personally feel that male Eivor is just better acted so I felt slightly robbed when I discovered that canonically it was female.
Out of the new 3 its the worst,besides it being buggy,its story is bloated as fuck it did not need to be that long I'm saying that its bad(the ending is) but its to long.its combat is worse then odyssey's because of the stun mechanic,because it makes fights to easy and it makes you sit through the same animation you've probably seen a hundred times by now with no variation
I 100% agree, I couldn’t even get myself to finish AC3 or Odyssey, the characters just weren’t memorable. Whereas with Valhalla, I can play for months and come back and remember where I left of as the characters are memorable (make Eivor).
The new 3, origins was the best. The grind meant something and satisfying to get better gear and the story is so well written and characters are super rich. It made me look forward to the grind and the story was made it worth spending so many hours on it. Can’t say the same for odyssey, a bloated mess where grinding is the epicenter of all things with a shit story and bland characters. I haven’t played Valhalla yet but I heard it’s just like Odyssey but I’m willing to try it out.
Female Eivor does not exist, period :D i played the game 2 times and both with male Eivor, but i still think that it is the second worst game of them all, cus nothing beats AC 3. My top 3 are 3 - Assassins' creed 2, 2 - Origins, 1 - Brotherhood
@@the-ironclad It is worse than odyssey, at least the world in Odyssey was beautiful, England was really boring with no big cities, Paris DLS felt more like an actual game than the main game, As for origins i just finished it for a 3 th time yesterday it is amazing, my second favorite.
@@karangtavana1283 not everyone thinks revelations sucked, its still in the top 5 ac games for most people as it should be, the only bad things i can think about with revelations is that it was way too orange and those janissaries.
Putting rogue and unity below vallhala is very questionable as I found unity very fun to play even with the bugs, I experienced very little when playing the game so it didn't really matter but the story was touching showing what happens when you get blinded by love and revenge, and rogue also showed us the difference between templars and assassins you said it makes templars assassins because you played like an assassin, I respect your opinion either way
Valhalla is much better than Rogue. Very fun, better combat, graphics, music, caracters, story, mini-games, setting. It’s also longer to finish and isn’t that repetitive
@@charleslafortune7375 vallhala is just a mindless rpg with no connection to the actual assasin creed franchise, its not bad but its not good and definitely isn't better than rogue where you actually have a decent story that leads up to important events related to other games from the franchise
Can we talk about how amazing the music is in every AC game, I mean, even odyssey has nice music. You should do a music ranking, it’ll be more positive (not that I’m saying this isn’t) but I can’t think of an AC game with bad music.
So happy to see Brotherhood at Numero Uno. My personal choice as well. Immersion and replayability are most important to me. Hence, Brotherhood - ACII - Black Flag. As much as I enjoy and appreciate Revelations. I've only played it once. With the others I've either 100%d or just replayed the story 💯
Dude...Dude...Dude... Why you doing this to your self? Please go replay revialations 😂 Every damn playthrough the game gets better, at first I was disappointed as well but after many years and several replays I got to love it. Not as much as 2 and Brotherhood, but definitely did!
@@Dennis-de1ji appreciate your comment bro ahah that makes sense. The maturity in both storytelling and character dev is a great journey in that game and I kinda miss it 💯🙏
Same I was surprised by his choice of placing this last, he said it didn’t feel assassins creed like but that didn’t really matter. It’s the full story that actually matters and this game gave us a way better idea of the current modern world issue in the story especially the dlc. And the demigod feel was amazing of course
Let the war begin!
yeah but I agree with everything other than brotherhood number 1
I've wronged alot of your viewers, I apologize.
FOR SKYRIM!
Mostly agree but I'd switch Odyssey and Vallhala's places
@@jellyjohn7881 you’ve got to be joking.
That moment when Ezio finds Altair in his library is still the peak of the series for me
You're wrong
@@pedroperez1231 lets not argue
@@pedroperez1231 No you're wrong
@@ilcondottierocartografo6770You get it the Carnage 😂 But no good sir.. You're wrong.
@@pedroperez1231 Don't make me laugh, you're obviously wrong!
I like how the number 12 turns red and the number 1 turns gold. Nice touch 👌
I thought so hahaha
I wish 7 was blue
I 100% agree with him it had NOTHING AT ALL to do with the creed
@@Fizhy I havn't played ac after 4, but are they that bad? Or am I understanding this wrong?
@@demonspawn5164 They're fine games on their own, but they're not really Assassin's Creed games, and I think that rubs a lot of people the wrong way (myself included).
For me, Assassin's Creed III is definitely my top 1. It was the first AC game I played and had many nostalgic memories of it. The finishes and stealth kills really got me hyped back in the days. At the time, I was only 12 years old lol. Yup, completely biased but for me, its a game that is worth replaying after a couple of years.
Same
Same
Plus the first appearance of Ship Battles
Yeah I’m of the exact same opinion. I think I would’ve been the same age too. It’s just pure nostalgia for me whenever I play AC3 now, and for some reason people hate Conor or think he’s boring. However I feel the exact opposite and I feel his seriousness is what an assassin is supposed to be. You feel super badass and someone who’s determined and I feel that’s what an assassin is supposed to be.
Me too LOL, I Love that game and definetely my top 3 In AC games.
I love the Side Missions,
The Peg legg mission
Frontiersman Misison
And Most of all is the homestead missiob
Unpopular opinion, unity is one of my personal favourites in the series.
Your opinion on UNITY is PERFECT with me! It's one of my top 3
Yes same it it one of my Favorites I respect what he said but I do not think that it should be cast aside. The game offers the best stealth we have seen in any assassins creed game if you don’t agree your lying also it has some of the best graphics and the story is not half bad and not to mention the parkour, it is the smoothest and coolest of any AC game no game comes close. I can say that he does fly sometimes lol but if you go back and play some of the old games like black flag and ac 3 the lag is way worse and the fame drops are a lot worse. But over all I thing that the lag matters more about what you play on my game is incredibly smooth with minor lag/glitches(remember the game is centered around being a assassin not a warrior the combat looks cool but it’s not fun it’s realistic)
Exactly! Everyone's gripes about all the bugs is what killed unity. If not for that it would be in everyone's S tier. I play it now on the Xbox Series X and it's exactly how it should have been when it came out. It looks like it recently came out on the series x tbh
Unity is an easy 8.5/10 in my book.
It's a perfectly good opinion to hold i still find Unity as one of the very finest gems this generation.
When two AC TH-camrs have the same bottom 5, you know there's something Fizhy going on.
I wonder how long you've waited for this moment.
@@Fizhy Not very long. I didn't know you were doing it. I was just watching LazerzZ video, and then I saw you were live. So I hopped on over here.
Edit: Unless you're talking about getting a response from you. In which case, I'm not sure.
You're wrong
@@pedroperez1231 How?
Edit: Also, you did realize it was a joke, right? How I purposely spelled Fizhy instead of fishy. Because the channel is Fizhy.
@@DarthTingleBinks HOW are you wrong? I honestly couldn't tell you my good man.
Brotherhood is definitely the best one. I’m playing it again right now and it’s just incredible.
I agree
@Herr Spiegel try dark souls💀
I really enjoyed it until reaching the ending, then suddenly the whole story just goes from Cesare seemingly having alot of power to completely losing it all out of nowhere and being betrayed by everyone around him, cutscene after cutscene with no time to intake anything that is happening, out of nowhere im 4 years into the future running at him in some random battlefield. At that point i was pretty lost, no satisfying interaction between Ezio and Cesare, oh and of course the game decided to soft lock right when we were about to have our boss fight, could not even finish the game, 5/10 unfortunately.
I really wish they go back and do sequels for characters like Edward and Bayek, because if they were given another game imo they could potentially be up there with Ezio. But honestly nowadays we’re lucky if we even get the chance to play as an actual Assassin
Honestly I don't get this ! People Cried over and over Again to have an AC set in Viking times So what happened ?
@@mrmeme2917 Don’t get me wrong I like Valhalla, but it’s like what James and George said recently, the game is pretty much 95% Vikings and only 5% Assassins
@@lukebellamy2673 yeah but they added as much as they could like Codex , Social Stealth ، Hidden Blade , Hoods , Robes , Assassin Bureaus , Fantastic Modern day , Really Heavy Lore , Eagle Vision .. the only thing is that Eivor is not an Assassin wish is Understandable because you have to remember this is a viking game and in games like this you have to prioritize the setting
Evior deserves a sequal game too where she becomes a assassin. No more viking BS the sequal gotta be AC
I just want stealth back. I'll play AC when they come out with a game that has good combat and stealth, not the same combat and no stealth.
Assassins creed in 2021: *mmm yes werewolves great idea*
"Eivor got high" - Ubisoft
@The Second Son’s The explanation for every unnatural event in Valhalla is basically just Eivor got high
@@RokuHanmar well I’m assuming the werewolves will not be a high event and will probably just be connected to the lore bit they added in Odyssey that they did to just randomly add mythological creatures with a ton of apples that shape shift them they’ll probably do the same with these and just found these apples since they’re druids that are highly driven by being connected to nature think the animalistic nature achieved with these apples are them being perfectly in sync with nature.
We don’t know connection to them. It can be mushrooms or drink or something else. 🤷🏻♂️
Connor was kind of a werewolf in the ac3 dlc
I actually like Rogue immensely. I only hate that it was so short. Definitely top 4 for me
pretty long if you do the side stuff wich is the best part of the game. The only reason i like rogue more than 4 is because it doesn't hold your hand for sooo long with all the tutorials.
yea i love rogue too. Its just awsome to be a templar (the good side lol)
Rogue was really something special for me due to playing as a template and being someone who didn't have an Xbox One at the time.
I already knew coming into this list that Odyssey would be dead last 😂 it’s my favourite one and I’ve sunk easily 300 hours into the game overall, I love the aesthetic and setting and have a really strong interest in the period of the game and thought the dlcs were very cool. Each to their own I guess, good video man!
Same, its my favorite one due to its gameplay and surrounding but the story is the one that lacks character... not gonna lie I played Valhalla but the combat system does not work for me, I played Origin but the story is just too short and easy to finish...
Same
Y’all must not have played the old ones when they came out but it isn’t horrible game
@@jjfgaming6355 I played the first one, the one with Desmond and Altair... but that was years before, I remember waiting few minutes in every loading screen... Good old days wherein games is not all about the graphics😁
@@mrqloak1453 true
Ezio Trilogy should be the foundation for every AC game to come. Honestly I can't get the right words to describe how AC Brotherhood and AC II makes me feel, those games are really special...
It should be remaked tho other than that its amazing
2 is overrated. But I agree with brotherhood.
@@karangtavana1283 so is ac4 imo. That being said, it's still good.
Wish they could do what yakuza did with yakuza kiwami 1 and 2
I don’t see how. They play terribly and they’re very dry
I really hate how they just let you choose the character and then just say one of them is canon
1. Annoyed you got this out the day before mine (Not that our viewrships are anything similar)
2. It is scary how similar our lists are
3. I appreciate your opinions
Be sure to send your video my way when it’s up bro
@@Fizhy will do mate, appreciate the support
@@Fizhy why is odyssey the worst it is not
@@Doragon86 bruh the best is not open world like odyssey orgins and valhalla
@@joyconboyz9587 I'm not sure if this is memeing or trolling, but just in case you're not.
Both of us have made videos about our opinions, these will not necessarily line up with your thoughts and opinions. Personally I think if you have watched both videos you can understand why we have placed things where we have as outlined in said vids. You don't have to agree, that's the beauty of this life we live, we're all different and if you got joy from Odyssey, power to you mate!
Fizhy: *makes Assassin's Creed ranking video and places AC3 pretty low on the list*
AC3 fans: Ready the armada
We will use the old ways
Ngl I kinda agree with where he put it
@@lucasfuller9235 I honestly don't, it should be higher then Valhalla imo
I’m just glad its not dead last anymore
@@Ibrahim-wr5fs imo I would switch unity and Valhalla around
i loved syndicate . the level progression felt really simple and interesting
same its my grind game
How? its the only assassins creed I didn't finish and I really despise it
@@fransie1613 what is the "how?" for, seems like ur suggesting they cant have their opinion
@@fransie1613 I feel like you're now only discovering the concept of opinions.
@@huibhogenstijn6665 crazy thought I know but, maybe they weren't making a hostile comment or any suggestions and just wanted further discussion.
I Love Bayek hairstyle not gonna lie !!!
Facts
Yeh
best character
@@julianleitis1882 No
Same
I wouldn't place Syndicate that low. It was a fun game. I like the animated executions of the templars and the grappling hook was awesome! :D
I also belong to the camp who thinks AC3 is the third best game after AC2 & Brotherhood. Modern day was also exciting in my opinion in AC3.
I agree my fav
Syndicate was a very well made game. The stealth was probably the best in the series and they nailed so many other things. The setting, leveling, characters, etc. were all great.
I hated Syndicate sorry mate. I haven't played a more uninteresting videogame, and It isn't because of the setting, I thought the setting was full of potential. But the game felt like a sterilized Unity. Too afraid to do anything bold.
I agree with you on syndicate, but the grappling hook is so boring to use. They had the opportunity to make it like Spider-Man's webs which would have been awesome
Watch Bayek Gladiator Arena th-cam.com/video/1FdoY11b_24/w-d-xo.html
Origins had such a great narrative. Kept me enthralled my entire play through.
I was hyped for the story the place everything but i always had to level up to play the story it kills me. It wasnt really an ac game in my opinion
it was grindy as hell, like i *love* the lore but it's just fucking unplayable on pc
Its my top 1 ac game story brutality stealth everything. And in a time where ac games were becoming stale ac origins just saved it all for me with the slight rpg. Still not as bad as odysseys
@@theholypopechodeii4367 really buggy
@@theholypopechodeii4367 yeah I never encountered any problems either, I’m just going off what other people said
How to run an AC youtube channel:
1. Make a ranking video every year
i look forward to these every year. Jorraptor for is the gameplay enjoyable and Fizhy for how lore friendly it is.
My goodness assassins creed 1 came out 14 years ago...
AC:III remains as one of the most underrated AC games. What a masterpiece.
@@JKM2468 I kinda get it, the style of the game was a great departure from the previous games and also Connor as a charachter was the complete opposite to Ezio's. But I think that's what I love from the game, being different.
Facts AC 3 had t best story
I love AC3. Super underrated.
"No books, no wisdom. Just you, fratello mio."
There's genuinely something about this moment that brought a tear to my eye when I first played it. Despite already being eight games into the franchise, as someone who never truly spent their entire life immersed in the modern day, it was these moments within the Animus that turned characters like Ezio Auditore and Altair into people. The moments that connected the world, the history and made everything that had happened in lieu and to come matter that much more.
I think I'm due for another playthrough of the Ezio trilogy.
Ezio’s trilogy never gets old
The ezio trilogy/story was phenomenal, it just got better and better every time, I remember when ac2 dropped and just coming from ac, it was mind blowing at the time, the last assassins creed game that ever made me feel the same way and full of excitement was black flag, the ending to that game is one of the best in the franchise and a very emotional one, right up there with ezio/altiar, WOW what happened ubi ? How did it all go so tita up 🤔
everyones hatred for Odyssey still surprises me, I actually really love the game
SAME HERE. It admittedly doesn't feel like assassin's creed, but its still super fun to me. And its probably thebmost beautiful map in my opinion too
if it weren't that they put "Assassins Creed" the game would be really good, the reason why the majority has hatred over the game is because it's apart of the Assassins Creed franchise which is quite confusing since the game isn't about an Assassin at all. There aren't any Templars aswell, it just feels like an RPG Sandbox.
Especially when the you play through the DLC! The legacy of the first blade ties the games together nicely in my opinion
It would be an awesome game if not part of the Assassins Creed franchise. Has nothing to do with Assassins, so if they had figured out how to do that or made it another franchise it would have been miles better
Same
I remember when I first begun playing assassins creed about 4 years ago. My dad took me to pick a game, and it just felt right. He recommended revelations just at a guess and honestly, I’m so glad I got revelations first. It allowed me to love the game without constantly wanting to compare it to other games. This is why I see revelations as a true masterpiece and top of the list. Honestly, the writing in revelations is absolutely beautiful. I’m practically in fucking tears while writing this because of the memories me and my older brother had with revelations. Also, odyssey gay lol
This s exactly my story 💯
😂
I always get a lot of shit for this but Revelations is always going to be my favourite AC game, it has the best ending to any game ever made imo. I personally loved Constantinople and visiting Masyaf as both Altair and Ezio was wonderful.
i think revelations hasa the number one story in AC
@@AltairStealth definitely, Darby’s writing was on full display.
Revelations is fucking incredible, the music, the story, the Hook Blade, the set-pieces, the level design, the fun bombs you could craft. All of that stuff was awesome, Revelations deserves so much more praise among the AC community.
@@fredster594 it truly does, for all that you mentioned and so much more. It’s sad how underrated it is not even just among the AC community but games in general.
honestly i think most, including me, would agree with you if they weren’t blinded by one thing. nostalgia. i will always love ac2 because i grew up with it and i am just a simp for the setting as a whole. the whole experience was just magical to me as a kid, as still is now. but if i was newely introduced to the series, i would go with revelations.
One thing I like about AC3. It had the second best memory corridors after AC1.
It was my first game and i was made half the game where is the assassin becuz of no outfit and then ac1,2,4.......
Odyssey was brilliant! It was a real escape during the lockdown and was genuinely laugh out loud funny at points.
It was not an ac game, like, The brotherhood didnt even exist there
For me I’d love a Haythem game as genuine templar, Bayek sequel in Ancient Rome as hinted at kinda in Hidden ones dlc
We need this
That sounds amazing
I think Odyssey would have been better if it took place later and was a Bayek and Aya sequel detailing Aya's assassination of Cleopatra and Bayek expanding The Hidden Ones into Greece.
They better give him a sequel
The Haytham yes!
Bayek i really don't care about.
Black Flag's ending nearly made me cry. Those visuals of all the characters we come to know and love and the amazing rendition of Parting Glass by Sarah Greene as Anne Bonny was just such a powerful combination; Edward then giving his daughter the flower and telling her she can steer the Jackdaw.😥
I completely agree 100%. Black Flag was the game that got me into Assassin’s Creed; I’ve never regretted playing that game. I love it, but I just hope they remaster it, and get rid of some of those annoying ass tailing missions; so repetitive and stupid.
@@bigstinker3897 those tailing missions were even more prevalent in the Ezio trilogy, part of the reason I prefer black flag to those games.
@@Dead_Pegasus I see. Well, I hope they either remaster Black Flag or make an Assassin’s Creed game that is good; these new ones just aren’t it.
@@bigstinker3897while I will admit Odyssey is the worst in the series I like Valhalla
@@Dead_Pegasus While I like the aesthetic of Valhalla, I don’t really like the rest of it. But hey, it’s your opinion, you can like what you want.
I think Origins left a great foundation and they could have done something like Ezio or continued the origin story into Odyssey and expanded on the gameplay and stealth while staying close to the RPG style
Agreed they could have done an Ezio style trilogy. Alot was going on during this time period they would have had so much to work with.
The way you describe Odyssey gives me the sense that you haven't really payed much attention to it. Here's a few pointers from a guy who's finished the game twice with both characters:
1. There are Templars in the game, it's the Cult of Kosmos. They're basically the Templars' predecessors along with the Order of the Ancients.
2. While Alexios and Kassandra aren't Assassins themselves their deeds and beliefs are basically the inspiration for the creation of the Hidden Ones and the Assassin Brotherhood, especially since they are ancestors of Aya from AC Origins.
3. The game's choice system takes advantage of the limited knowledge we have of the time period it takes place in order to allow the player to make their own story as they play the game, which is why they main characters seem without personalities of their own and why you choose genders at the beginning. You shape your character's personality as you please.
4. The side quests do seem unconnected to the main story at first glance but you pay close attention to the story you will realize that there are connections.
Agree, I liked Odyssey very much
Every time a TH-cam hates on odyssey I get the same feeling they didn’t take in the world and probably didn’t play it that much
Your 3rd point is exactly why it's a bad Assassin's Creed game.
The modern day character is supposed to experience his/her ancestor's memories. It's supposed to have happened at some point in time.
Being able to have choices, specially genders and different endings throws that point out the window.
Just make it male or female and stick to it.
I loved odyssey. Such a beautiful game. Plus the reason it wasn't full on only about assassinations was because ancient Greek was about heroes completing quests and that's what made them heroes (not just killing someone and moving on). And this takes place way before any time period. So assassins was a new thing. And like u said, their ideas and beliefs shape the future games. Well said. Ppl don't understand the story and say ac odyssey is bad
@@Sriram-ig6pr as an RPG might be good at best.
But as an Assassin's Creed game is rightfully at the bottom.
Ubisoft should have just made an RPG game about ancient Greece. But call it Assassin's Creed game was a bad move.
And I'm very impressed that it was the second best selling assassin's creed game at launch
I enjoy Odyssey. Definitely not my favourite, but I feel like it’s naughty to say 😂
Hardly, if you like it power to you
I feel like odyssey is an amazing open world fantasy RPG in an unconventional setting, but it fits rather poorly into the overall narrative.
@@Fizhy This is why I am a bigger fan of you rather than Lazerzz no offence to him, but I feel he can be pretty harsh on the later AC games while just ignoring the positives. You on the other hand calmly explain why you do or don't like what you like and encourage people who disagree with you to be proud of their opinions
Yeah I am unashamed to say I actually really like Odyssey, but it may be because I wasn't able to play the originals first except for revelations and therefore my view of it comes from someone who just really loves open world games as a whole.
@@im.bored9478 same. Odyssey is the first AC game i’ve played and I loved every second of it but the story just doesnt fit in with the AC storyline
“No books, no wisdom, just you, fratello mio. Requiescat in pace Altaïr.”
Orgins revelations and black flag are amazing
I love all of them
@@AltairStealth same they each bring something different that I enjoy
They are the top 3 honestly, brotherhood and ac2 after that
@@sharifzahir5263 origins is my second fave
@@AltairStealth The only thing holding origins from being higher than black flag for me is the levelling system and having to grind to get to a certain level before playing main missions
I think one of reasons the Ezio trilogy is so great is because of their soundtracks. Jasper Kyd did an amazing job composing masterpieces imo which sort of embodies the renaissance period if that makes sense.
I miss old Ac games machanics and not open world Ac games
Nostalgia plays a pretty big role as well.
The biggest reason for me is replay value. None of the games in that trilogy wasted time setting things up. I have a hard time going back to AC3 and Odyssey because they just take way too long to actually start getting to the juice.
Revelations has such a good story that I too was brought nearly to tears... and it as well as III are the only ones I’ve played through completely
We can’t run away from ac rankings 😅😂
I’ve been looking forward to this
I still find it funny during the release of assassins creed 3 I was complaining that Connors colours were white and blue instead of assassin white and red, if i went back in time and told myself what was happening today I probably would of killed myself 😂
Brotherhood is what made me fall in love with the franchise I was 12 and had just moved states and it brought me comfort and it’s actually the only game I’ve 100% finished in the franchise it breaks my heart how the newer game (odyssey, origins,Valhalla) are turning out
Oddyssey is genuinely my favorite game I’ve ever played
Ye I don’t see the hate like I respect the people who prefers the old original ac feel but odyssey was so good
Fizhy is extreme in his Odyssey hate, it's actually quite fascinating to see lol. It's one of my favorite games in the series too.
I agree odyssey is an amazing game
@@alexanderedinger exactly
@@alexanderedinger it’s actually a pretty crappy rpg game too
This is an old video of yours but I love that you put the opening sound for each one I recognize all of the ogs before you even said them🤘🏼 I agree with your reasoning for each ranking, thanks for a good video!
I think it would be great if you ranked all the free roam/open worlds in these games from worst to best
If that's something you are looking for next terra tech's channel has something similar
@@lucianocaruso6802 thanks I'll check it out
From worst to best:
AC3
AC1
AC2
AC syndicate
AC revelations
AC brotherhood
AC rogue
AC unity
AC black flag
AC odyssey
AC Valhalla
AC origins
The new trilogy:
1. easy origins
2. Valhalla
3. odyssey
This is from an assassins creed perspective and not the game itself.
Odyssey is a good game defiantly, but just not a good assassins creed
@@RMCL468 Brotherhood, Black Flag and Origins are on top.
Big fan of rogue and unity
Good game, decent stories, bad assassin's creed
Interesting that your comment here is the only one I’ve seen defending unity, even though it is mechanically one of the best assassins creed games.
If the fidelity of all of the games were compared to today’s standards, I would say Unity is the best.
I don’t ever see anyone making a legitimate critisism of Unity that is actually true to its CURRENT state.
Same here!
I loved ac odyssey, i played the older ac games when I was younger like early teens and I couldt get into them. Odyssey brought me back to the franchise and I loved every moment. The brilliant setting, the unique weapons. I enjoyed playing it enough to put in 150+ hours and do everything in the game. So yeh you could say I liked it.
I loved ac Odyssey to the max. My number 1 and ive played all the games. Yes it lacks the Enzio mysteries but imo its fantastic amd better now with the dlcs. I suppose it suits us older gamers who just like to sit and play for hours.
Btw a lot of the criticisms are BS
the suicide is also an opinion
It’s a good game just not a good assassins creed game
@@19blvck sucide is also a statistic
@@19blvck and a very viable option
I personally enjoyed odyssey, was beautiful, liked the gear. Idk I'm not a die hard AC fan and just enjoy the games. I also enjoyed unity bc I could do missions with buddies.
This was a great teir list, good job
very well constructed opinions he has
it wasnt lamo imagine putting the best in last place
@@mihnea9759 u think odyssey is the best?
@HaydenDoesThings LOL
Ya he gave good reasons why he ranked them there and afterall it’s an opinion
Odyssey is my favourite game😂😂😂
Yeahhh an oddssey fan nobody cares bud
@@kingmustard1586 Then why 10 million people download it and the 92% if then liked it??! You dumb
AC Odyssey is actually my favorite AC game, that might be because I’m really interested in the culture and mythology of Ancient Greece so I had a blast while playing it, also relevant that this was the first AC game I played.
Yeah I agree the setting of odyssey gives me really good vibes and ancient Greece as a whole is beautiful plus kassandra is a great protagonist in my opinion.
It was your first game thats why, the game is decent I love it but this was not AC game for fuck sake ubisoft stop this shame dont call it AC its fucking not
I played almost all the AC games and THIS IS MY FAVORITE TOO!! I love this game but it definitely doesn't feel connected to the rest of the series
There you have it: the first and the ONLY AC game you played.
@@methamphetamememcmeth3422 nah, I played Unity, didn’t like the mechanics a bit
Get chills everytime I hear the AC3 theme
AC3 imo had the best soundtrack. The theme, freedom fighter, brawl fight music, chasing Charles Lee soundtrack, and fighting music in the frontier were some of the best and catchy soundtracks.
A wonderfully apt description of Odyssey.
I feel like Origins should be higher on the list tbh. You don't play as an assassin technically, but Bayek's whole story is him acting as a proto-assassin, it's not that disconnected. The RPG elements were still very bearable, the story and soundtrack were great, the game world was by far the most beautiful, and the protagonist was one of the best in the series. I understand Edward not getting a sequel (since his story ended pretty nicely in one game), but Bayek showed great potential as the first mentor of the brotherhood in the DLC, it's a damn shame he didn't get a sequel.
Agreed, but the curse of the pharaohs is by far the best AC DLC made.
@@braddillon4311 fate of Atlantis is also amazing
@@unaihmg9352 I didn’t even finish it, it was that shit for me
Lazzerz : okay here`s my homework but change it a lil bit
Fishy : Fine
*the homework*
True
I’ve played most Assassins Creed games, the only ones I haven’t played are Brotherhood and Odyssey, and my personal favorite is Unity. I just loved that game, the movement, the city of Paris was amazing, the story was good (not great) but still to this day I install it and play around in that amazing world. Most underrated AC game ever made.
Unity is overrated now, considering Unity stans can't resist making it about them when Assassins Creed is being talked about.
Honestly I really think that an American Civil War assassin's creed game would be cool if done correctly
I created one hell of a concept when I was younger. It would be called Assassin's Creed: Divided
*The templars decide to have the states secede so they can do what they want without the government (which is assassin-influenced) interfering
*MC actually witnesses the templars decide this but can't stop them
*MC is tasked by the council to go to Southern states to help the assassin's in that area (who are being under attack by confederates who are controlled by templars
*Tries to sabotage the south from the inside by rescuing slaves and creating a small army (like a mix between the Rooks and Connor's Brotherhood)
*World is quite large, housing multiple southern cities
*World is divided into districts that need liberated
*At some point, MC and his Assassin-milita aid the Union in a battle
*MC gains the attention of Abraham Lincoln and the two become friends (like Leonardo and Ezio)
*In the epilogue, MC hunts down John Wilkes Booth (who is canonically killed by an assassin), who is a templar
*Andrew Johnson becomes president, and is backed by templars and hence begins the templar's modern control over the american government
@@Agent_3141 Holy crap!!!!!!!!!! That is fucking awsome!!! we need to bring this to Ubisoft!!!!
@@andrewpike2398 Funny enough I remember emailing them about it and they denied it
@@Agent_3141 dam that actually sounds really interesting man
@@Agent_3141 that was good asf, but the reason they denied it is prob bc of touchy racial issues, or people complaining ab slavery being made into a game
I’m in the same boat. AC II and Brotherhood almost shear the same spot on my list. But after playing both games this past two weeks I feel like AC II is at the top for me.
Personally his top 5 matched mine perfectly, Revelations being the one ik most people arguing over seeing as they either had Fizhy’s perspective or they felt it was rushed And had boring game play mechanics. But definitely seeing Ezio connect to both Altair and Desmond is by far one of my best gaming experiences and I will never forget it
Lol hi Elijah I’m Elijah
Revelations is undoubtly the worst of the trilogy, and of the OG 1-BF/Rogue games. The main story is terribly written, antagonist is even worse than those 'filler bad guys' like unity and syndicate had, parkour ruined what the previous 2 were trying to build by literally removing big features like climb leap and the ledge grabs with the hook blade are just clunky. It has zipplines, so what? The pacing is the worst in the franchise cuz there isn't a single place in the game where all enemy archetypes spawned. AC2 did a perfect job here adding a brute, armorered guy, seeker, archer and regular guard to every single faction. In Revelations there are 2 factions, one with seekers, brutes and regular guards and one with agiles, elites and jannusaries. The new tool selecting system was a missed opportunity cuz brotherhood had 4 quick selects but you could select 7 weapons using it. In Revelations weapon wheel is the way.
Thanks again for the help moving my fridge freezer fizhy mate appreciate it and remember assassin's creed is only going to get worse for the OG assassin's creed fans
Roadhouse
I’m still playing Odyssey and I love it 😂
Its my fav. AC
@@aristosachaion1057 You either never played any other AC game or you played Odyssey before any other AC game
@@aristosachaion1057 do you know what ac is. One of the frist lines of the franchise (i.e the Frist game) condrodict the idea that you can make choices in oddesy.
@@AdamAziz0 other people are allowed to have different opinions
Same it may not have a lot to do with the whole series but I love the game itself
This list makes me happy, I completely agree with it 😍
Over the years my appreciation of Brotherhood and Revelations grows more and more. AC2 used to be my favorite, but every time I fire up Brotherhood I find it’s just more fun to play. And I think people who say Black Flag isn’t a good AC game should take a closer look at it.
AC 2 and Brotherhood are spiritual games. When you move around at night time and listen to beautiful background music. That's like the best experience ever.
Origins is definitely top 3 for me
Odyssey is so underrated
True
Yeah I mean I totally get him not thinking its a good AC game because well...its not. Its just a good open world spartan game, albeit slightly bloated.
To say its one of the worst games he's ever played is just sounds too hyperbolic and edgy for the sake of edgy.
@@josh043p6 yeah it doesn’t relate to the assassin’s creed storyline well except for the legacy of the first blade dlc but it was still a fun game
I think it gets undeserved hate to be honest. But it's their opinion I guess.
@Alex A. Lazzerz is biased I agree but don't call him garbage just for him hurting your ego it's stupid. And also I don't think fizhy is biased or stupid actually his reviews and opinions makes far more sense than of lazzerzs ones. But still i respect lazzerz and his reviews/opinions.
Never played AC until the last year. I started from the beggining and I have finished the AC1 and AC2 and now im playing brotherhood(2-3 hours of playing). So far AC1 is my favourite. I also enjoyed a lot AC2 wich had better gameplay than the first but I think it was a bit repetive at some point.
Play AC origins. You will fall in love with this game👍👍
AC2 is more repetitive than AC1
so fucking controversial
Just Downloaded assassin's creed odyssey. I'm about 20 minutes into the game and it's fantastic. I don't know what you talking about. Odyssey is great.
You will see brotha
Exactly how I felt but after a lot of hours....... you will see
20 mins right see after 20 days
Bro you cant form an opinion off of 20 minutes of gameplay. Its not even an Assassins Creed game. Its an ancient Greek RPG with bullshit excuses of artifacts that link to the Isu.
Agreed, but now the whole comment section is going to tell you why you are wrong
@@raccoonbigg who cares if its "not even an assassins creed game" a good game is a good game
Am I the only one who love AC Odyssey?
Yes
Not at all. Odyssey grabbed me from the get-go and remained compelling throughout the 150 hours I spent on it (covering main mission, all locations, side missions and most cult members). The only thing I objected to was the mythical creature fights - I'd have preferred alternate ways of beating these other than just 10 minutes of trying to whack them whilst avoiding being hit yourself.
I know the majority of the community doesn’t like Odyssey but I love Greek mythology and I didn’t think of it like an assassins creed game. I looked at it just like an open world game and had so much fun.
Plated odyssey 2500 hours...the best
once i saw odyssey at 12 i knew this guy was on drugs
Worst game in the series lol
@@Misske. imagine
@@alex2huncho630 it is 💀
@@Misske. how
I can't comment on the list in general because I haven't played all the games but I loved AC3 and ACL.
I think AC Odyssey is incredible and plan to play it again once I finish the DLC's
No offence but it seems you aren't a long time (true) AC fan
@@bigassfrog6376 He’s probably a fan of RPG games.
@@assasainscreed786 But c'mon odyssey isn't even a good game, let alone a good RPG. The Witcher 3 is a good rpg. I also kinda liked darksiders 2
@@bigassfrog6376 Meh I’ve not played it yet because it looks too similar to Origins. Witcher 3 is a masterpiece tho definitely one of my fav games.
@@bigassfrog6376 odessey is a great game and I've played/own every single assassin's creed game. It's just different with is fine people complain about the lb systems just don't be trash at the game lol.
it puts a really big smile on my face to see revelations so high up on your list :)
22:40 Gives me goosebumps everytime..
I knew there was a video missing from my life
I went in thinking black flag would be your number 2 or maybe even #3 and was surprised to see you rank Revelations so high. However you made a very compelling argument: this was an amazing game when I first played it. I remember how satisfying the conclusion of Ezio and Altair was. The soundtrack was amazing too!
This was a very solid video. Well done!
I own Odyssey and Origins. I got them because I like the time periods, and while I am a fan of the Asassin's Creed games, the three newest one's are clearly not Assassin's Creed games.
They are, origins and Valhalla are 100 percent assassins creed.
@@ndl0857 Valhalla is not, in ways sure I could see why it would be called AC but overall? No
@@kidCashOnline how is it not assassins creed?
@@ndl0857 ir a vinking u Moran not a assassin u just have a hidden blade that's it
@@kingmustard1586 I'll leave this here.
th-cam.com/video/_pRZxai0snY/w-d-xo.html
Just because you're not an assassin doesn't mean it's not assassins creed. The series is bigger than assassins and templars. the series is about an ideological conflict dating back 75,000 years and the names "Assassin" And "Templar" Are just recent names for both sides of the war.
But just watch that video and tell me Valhalla isn't assassins creed.
Idk I understand odyssey’s ranking but personally I don’t agree although you are right it’s the most disconnected and ads the least to the franchise, but for some reason that never bothered me I enjoyed the theme and the open world for me was fun to explore and a liked some of the side missions some had a certain charm to them. Also the navel part was fun but not as good as black flag. Idk I’m always for fun over everything and ac odyssey delivers that fun factor for me and like I said I absolutely love the open world as surface level as it is. Although I do believe I’m biased cause I’m a huge Ancient Greek nerd and it finally delivered that open world Ancient Greek game with some bland but at least the illusion of choice worked for me lmao even more than fallout 4’s did
Also the way I think about the AC franchise is different than most for me it’s always been the historical setting first Assassins and and first civilization stuff second so the new direction they’ve been taking I’ve been enjoying thoroughly although I see why long time fans are upset, and again IMO the writing hasn’t been as good since black flag so I’ve just focused on enjoying the historical setting and content first before the actual story and lore of the franchise
@@xannymanny9754 No, no, no, NO! Assassin's Creed was never ever supposed to be a history game. The main focus of the AC franchise back in the day was to tell a complex sci-fi story about the conflict between two secret organizations, the Historical settings were used to show us how large the conflict really is, and they were used as motivations for modern day story. But of course AC3 changed all of that, and ever since then Ubisoft has only wanted to make Assassin's Creed into open world history games.
@@fredster594 yeah and personally I have no problem with that sure it disappoints older fans which is a shame but nevertheless I like the premise and think they’re fun and IMO fun triumphs all when it comes to games
@@fredster594 i mean history was always a big part of the stories being told in AC, and after AC4 ubisoft stopped giving a shit about historical accuracy while in previous games historical accuracy was high on the list when it came to writing these games
@@kidCashOnline They did have history, yes. But the historical parts wasn't the main focus of the early games and were merely just used as a backdrop. the early games were primarly focused on the characters and conflict between the Assassins and Templars. AC1 is a game that takes place in the Third Crusades but it isn't a "Historical Crusades game" it's a sci-fi game with a touch bit of believability in them.
This is why AC3's story was absolutely nothing compared to the previous installments, because the entire game was focused primarly on the American Revolution and not the characters, AC lore or conflict. The historical characters in AC3 sucked as well, because they were so generic and felt like they were just celebrities that were written off the history books, unlike before where the historical characters were unique, fictional and important to Altair & Ezio's story compared to their real life counterpart.
AC4 went back to the AC1-Revelations styled storytelling and it was amazing! Edwards story is wonderfully told and uses all of the classic AC elements which made the old games work so wonderfully. And thankfully all of the historical characters are unique and actually feel important in Edward'a journey. Blackbeard, Mary Reed, Roberts, Captain Hornigold etc were all amazing and iconic AC characters because of this. AC4's story is in my opinion the 2nd best narrative in the series next to Revelations.
However after this, they've went back to that bland and generic AC3 style of historical storytelling, and now... it's literally just a history game with RPG mechanics.
when i realized i wasn’t the only leaving new ac games and returning to old ac games is when i knew ubisoft is starting to give up
I think unity is great now personally. I love the co-op.
I cabby get the co op to work. But unity is one of my all time favorites
I SWEAR IS NUMBER ONE FOR ME
You know I wonder how he’s going to react to Werewolves being in the game again? 😆
Judging by his reaction on stream last night...not well.
i bet he's gonna love it like the rest of ac fans
nAtUraL eVolUtIoN
@@thijmen5295 yeah, the best part. 😂
I'm sorry what???
I actually agree with the list and everything you said great video
Fizhy really loves the Ezio trilogy.
And I'm here for it
You're wrong.
I really liked odyssey, not as an assassins creed game but as a pretty good RPG. I mean, my standards are very low, so low that the terrible humour made my brain go “haha chicken do funny”.
One I liked it as a game. Maybe not an assasssin creed 1 but as a game by its self yes. I loved fight those Cyclopes and other mythical creatures
You're wrong
Gameplay was fucking frustrating (especially fighting). How people play this shit for more than 10 mins is beyond me...
@@bigassfrog6376 it’s very interesting how differently people experience games. I liked the combat, to me it flowed very well.
I will say that the story was bland and uninspired
Didn't like it at first, but Odyssey grew on me to the point that now I LOVE it.
HERE THE HATERS COME!!
THIS MONTH'S ACTUAL COMMENTS ARE GOING TO BE WILD
Haters ? I did not see any , although I disagree with Fizhy's List ! I do Respect his Opinions
@@mrmeme2917 There's more people welcoming haters than actual haters
you're wrong
You're wrong
@@mrmeme2917 noice
I feel like odyssey is amazing if you separate it from the other ac games. If you play as a misthios rather than an assassin you will enjoy it much more.
But that is the point. Why play an assassin’s creed game if you can’t play as an assassin? It may not be a bad game but it is the worst AC game there ever was.
If it's not a good assassin's creed game then what's the point.
unpopular opinion, syndicate and unity are one of my favorites in the series
yeah, they are actually so good to play imo
I would like a true remaster of Ezio's trilogy or maybe a remake of a first game
ironically A C Odyssey has become one of my favorites 🎮 Why ? hard to explain 🕹 butt i always Respect you’re Opinion 🍷
Starts watching the video: Odyssey is last place, instant close.
Ha. That's exactly what I just commented. It's one of the best games made.
@@stewartlaprairie2842 its just doesn't have assasins in it the hidden ones are rarely or not even in it's a great game just not an ac
@@dreamerzz7348 If the video was ranking the games that keep closest to the initial AC premise than sure. But it's not. It ranks the best games in the series. Odyssey is one of the best games, if not the best game in the series. It's a silly thing to say to drum up controversy.
Odyssey is still my fav, it's not AC but it's one of the most enjoyable games i ever player inspired me a lot :)
@@skylightstudios3250 change.....*evil laugh*....CHANGE?!!?!?
Odyssey,Valhalla,Origins are all AMAZING!
Origins? Yeah
Valhalla? Dunno, haven't seen it
Odyssey? HAH! No.
Play the originals and then make your decision
I have to disagree with Valhalla.
I love the combat, the best in the series imo. Story is passionately written, world is organic and beautiful, soundtrack is amazing. Characters are decent and mostly memorable.
But it's really long and I personally feel that male Eivor is just better acted so I felt slightly robbed when I discovered that canonically it was female.
Out of the new 3 its the worst,besides it being buggy,its story is bloated as fuck it did not need to be that long I'm saying that its bad(the ending is) but its to long.its combat is worse then odyssey's because of the stun mechanic,because it makes fights to easy and it makes you sit through the same animation you've probably seen a hundred times by now with no variation
I 100% agree, I couldn’t even get myself to finish AC3 or Odyssey, the characters just weren’t memorable. Whereas with Valhalla, I can play for months and come back and remember where I left of as the characters are memorable (make Eivor).
The new 3, origins was the best. The grind meant something and satisfying to get better gear and the story is so well written and characters are super rich. It made me look forward to the grind and the story was made it worth spending so many hours on it. Can’t say the same for odyssey, a bloated mess where grinding is the epicenter of all things with a shit story and bland characters. I haven’t played Valhalla yet but I heard it’s just like Odyssey but I’m willing to try it out.
Female Eivor does not exist, period :D i played the game 2 times and both with male Eivor, but i still think that it is the second worst game of them all, cus nothing beats AC 3. My top 3 are 3 - Assassins' creed 2, 2 - Origins, 1 - Brotherhood
@@the-ironclad It is worse than odyssey, at least the world in Odyssey was beautiful, England was really boring with no big cities, Paris DLS felt more like an actual game than the main game, As for origins i just finished it for a 3 th time yesterday it is amazing, my second favorite.
The tier list of the madlad 😗
bois bois bois
AC1-AC4 back when ubisoft actually cared about their game
well, 3 was shit for the most part, revelations also sucked so your comment makes no sense. The series has always fluctuated in quality.
@@karangtavana1283 your opinion
@@karangtavana1283 not everyone thinks revelations sucked, its still in the top 5 ac games for most people as it should be, the only bad things i can think about with revelations is that it was way too orange and those janissaries.
Putting rogue and unity below vallhala is very questionable as I found unity very fun to play even with the bugs, I experienced very little when playing the game so it didn't really matter but the story was touching showing what happens when you get blinded by love and revenge, and rogue also showed us the difference between templars and assassins you said it makes templars assassins because you played like an assassin, I respect your opinion either way
Valhalla is much better than Rogue. Very fun, better combat, graphics, music, caracters, story, mini-games, setting. It’s also longer to finish and isn’t that repetitive
@@charleslafortune7375 vallhala is just a mindless rpg with no connection to the actual assasin creed franchise, its not bad but its not good and definitely isn't better than rogue where you actually have a decent story that leads up to important events related to other games from the franchise
@@SingularityAli. weird criteria but I can understand
@@charleslafortune7375 I personaly like Rouge more as i dont really like Valhalla but i can see what you mean.
@@SingularityAli. Rogue? Decent story? Lol
Can we talk about how amazing the music is in every AC game, I mean, even odyssey has nice music. You should do a music ranking, it’ll be more positive (not that I’m saying this isn’t) but I can’t think of an AC game with bad music.
You're wrong
Odyssey had the best music imo, the shantys are bangers
@@pedroperez1231 about what? Odyssey? Come on, look past the bad game, the music is still good.
@@Arthur-zb9eh Haaa ha you're so chill. I'm just messing with you. Cause he said it would be Carnage of opinions lol
@@pedroperez1231 your are troll done right
So happy to see Brotherhood at Numero Uno. My personal choice as well. Immersion and replayability are most important to me. Hence, Brotherhood - ACII - Black Flag. As much as I enjoy and appreciate Revelations. I've only played it once. With the others I've either 100%d or just replayed the story 💯
Dude...Dude...Dude... Why you doing this to your self?
Please go replay revialations 😂
Every damn playthrough the game gets better, at first I was disappointed as well but after many years and several replays I got to love it. Not as much as 2 and Brotherhood, but definitely did!
@@Dennis-de1ji appreciate your comment bro ahah that makes sense. The maturity in both storytelling and character dev is a great journey in that game and I kinda miss it 💯🙏
I am haven't played odyssey yet, I am playing origins and right now I love it.
Hey man, i am playing origins too... The theme is amazing and gameplay is awesome... Its one of my favorite game right now
Unpopular opinion: Odyssey is my absolute favorite and have sunk many hundreds of hours into.
Same I was surprised by his choice of placing this last, he said it didn’t feel assassins creed like but that didn’t really matter. It’s the full story that actually matters and this game gave us a way better idea of the current modern world issue in the story especially the dlc. And the demigod feel was amazing of course
that was awesome, 100% agree with this list