Pour moi le nouveau Richter !!! On croit rêver devant une telle perfection. La puissance, le poids de sa technique est pleinement au service de la musique. Un grand bravo du fond du cœur !
When I first heard Seong-Jin play I remember being struck by an unusually intuitive playing that seemed to bring so many things to life on the spot. His story was convincing and mesmerizing without any need for words, and he brought me a little closer to Ravel, whom I had not liked or cared for previously. ... Bravo and cheers to many more years of amazing music making!
Amazing fact is he played this in Hamamatsu competition at the age of 15!!!!! Well,....... rest u guess!!! His musical ability and maturity sensitivity ....creativity.................❤
Jurors look so happy. I think Cho won at an appropriate time. / 2010 Daniil Trifonov(19years old), Third prize in 16th Chopin competition / Seong-Jin CHO(16years old) can't participate in it because of an age restiction. // 2011 Daniil Trifonov(20), First prize in Tchaikovsky competition. / Seong-Jin CHO(17), Third prize in it. // 2015 Seong-Jin CHO(21), First prize in 17th Chopin competition.
This esoteric pilgrimage year song, mixed with torrent of sound and meditation, requires a high degree of concentration on both the playing side and the listening side, but he balances the sound and meditates the falling dolcissimo. Play beautifully.
+eric rouach I saw those Rubinstein Comp. performances recently, but not all because it's not available in the US. However, the performances I've watched are so different styled than his Chopin Competition. I actually LOVED IT! He was full of expressions, that's for sure, and I think due to his "heavy" gestures that the conservative judges did not choose him? Surely, the younger, progressive generation jury actually chose him for their Jury Prize. I actually loved how he was full of expressions, and even ppl who are not familiar with classical music, esp. less-known pieces like Bartok and Liszt would surely enjoy watching his performances because he seemed to be telling the story or theme of the music, like you're watching a movie, u know what I mean? I def. enjoyed watching and listening to his performances altho I was not familiar with certain pieces of music, but he seemed to be telling a story with each piece. Despite his gestures, when you just listen with closed eyes, you can hear how the sound is so clear with expressions. It's a terrible shame that he had to settle for third, and even probably had to tone down his expressions for the Chopin Competition. I hope he can play with the fullest expressions now that he's done with competitions. He's one of very few pianists whom I actually love to watch and listen, the other one is Nobuyuki, and who can't be moved by such a divine artist.
유튜브에 올라와 있는 모든 단테 영상들 그냥 조성진 미만 잡이다... 나는 단테가 리스트 거라 기교적인 부분이 강조되어야한다고 생각하고 처음 조성진 것을 들었을 때 너무 느리고, 너무 감성적이라 별로라고 생각했지만 들으면 들을 수록 울컥하고 올라오는 감정이 진하게 느껴짐. 리스트가 어떤 생각으로 어떤 감정으로 단테소나타를 작곡했는지 가장 정확하게 파악하고 있는 사람은 조성진인 것 같다.
Right in Russia's own back yard, this 17 year old boy (man!) plays this hellishly difficult piece with the power and emotion that some Russian players never reach even in their maturity. Cho did not win this competition (amazingly!), but time will correct the error of these Russian judges!
Well, in that year Trifonov won the competition so, it's fair for me. (I love the playing of both pianists Trifonov and Cho, there are among the best young players)
Who knows what Liszt discussions were regarding the Divine Comedy.. wish i could go back and just over hear his opinions, my favorite composer reflecting on my favorite poet.... always loved this piece.. fantastic playing, very technical though
@@Mavis0709맞아요. 손열음님 조성진님 모두 뛰어났지만 다닐도 진짜 광기가 있었음. 이건 콩쿨이고 결과에 승복해야 한다고 생각해요. 이 때 협연 스테이지에서도 조성진님이 라흐3번인가 했었는데 본인도 실수 많았다고 했고.. 다만 나이를 고려하면 가장 가능성 높은 참가자였다고 할 수 있겠죠. 어쨌든 쇼콩에서 1등 했으니 말 다했죠 뭐
@@CalamityInAction Chopin competition only allows Chopin pieces! How can one participate with Liszt or any other composer? Unless y saw maybe Dmitry shishkin or someone playing mephisto waltz in the same hall or something, but that's not part of the competition it's something called Chopin and his Europe or smth.
You know, it takes some balls to get up and play a meandering mess like this in a competition. Beautiful performance but God, compositionally this is all over the shop. The Benediction de Dieu dans la Solitude might have been a better choice for combining virtuosic moments with extended periods of introspection. It's a little tighter too. For the first 10 minutes of this performance I was thinking this is the farthest into the piece I'd heard without getting bored, so thank you Seong Jin Cho.
how can you have the name “LisztyLiszt” and not like this piece “all over the shop” I mean, it’s a fantasia the Benediction has longer virtuosic lapses - it hardly does anything in that respect until the “recap”.
The Dante Sonata is one of the most exiting, genius and deep works ever written. It’s right up there with the Sonata in B minor. There is nothing messy with this piece. At least when played well. When played properly, it’s one of the most wonderful experiences you can get.
1st prize Daniil Trifonov, 2nd prize Yeoleum Son, 3rd Prize Seongjin Cho... it was too much competitive at that time. In my opinion, Yeoleum son was the best, and Daniil & Seongjin cho should have been 2rd prize corecipient
Very high calibre that year. Much higher than the most recent. Maasleev, where is he? Debarque was amazing but he suffered from a lack of concerto playing with a real orchestra in the final. Lovely player though. So musical. George Li was a gem. They're the two to keep an eye on. Couldn't agree more about 2011 but in fairness, Trifonov has gone on to greatness and he's a beast. Had the pleasure of hearing him live. Seong Jin Cho is a treasure. Deserved this win. Would love to hear more of Yeoul Eum Son. She seems to have gone off the radar a bit. Her Rach 3 at 2011 final was outstanding.
Kkkkkk😂.. i read somewhere that he is incredibly serious on his music but occasional his leasure time was filled wt cartoons wt eating redbean sweet buns!!! So mo wonder!!😂 after all we are human!😂😂😂😂
Pisarenko's interpretation of this piece is certainly formidable, althoug Seong-Jin Cho's bears a different feel which I like a lot as well. Berman is pretty good too.
이런 천재에게 3위를주다니. 일반인들이 감히 천재를 평가한다고? 트리포노프는 피아노에 압도되어 힘들게치는데 자국민이라 1위를 준듯하고. 피아노를 완전히 장악하고 다루는 조성진은 3위. 말도 안되는 심사위원들. 루빈때도 천재기량 완벽발휘했으나 3위를 주니 실소가나오고 썩은음악계가 씁쓸할뿐이다.
트리포노프가 피아노에 압도되서 힘들게 친다는건 무슨 말도안되는 소리죠? 차이코프스키 2011 은 정말 1,2,3 위 순위 납득 완벽하게 가는 대회였어요. 2위가 손열음씨였고 저 세명이라도 대회 통틀어서 무슨곡들 쳤는지는 아시고하시는말씀인가요. 전 차이코프스키 하는 도중부터 계속 봤고 저 세명 1,2,3차 다보고 하는 말인데, 조성진 저도 정말 팬이지만 쇼팽콩쿨이랑 더 스타일이 맞는 학구적이고 깊은해석을 하는 피아니스트고 차이코프스키는 더 화려하고 박력있고 다양하게 치는 사람들이 점수를 잘받아가는 대회에요. 2015 2위인 조지 리만 봐도 알 수 있듯이. 조성진 손열음 둘다 1차때 쳤던 슈만 휴모레스크만해도 전 개인적으로 손열음씨 해석이 더 와닿았고, 트리포노프 콘체르토 소름돋게 잘했는데... 일반인들이 천재를 평가하긴 무슨 차이콥 심사위원들 누군진 알고 다는 댓글인지.
Daniel님의 말에 공감해요. 한가지 더 추가적으로 말씀드리고 싶은건 어느 콩쿨이든 심사위원들은 다 음악계에 깊은 내공이 있으신 음악가 혹은 교수님들이구요. 일반인들이라뇨;;; 어디 나가서 그런 소리 하시면 창피받아요... 저도 11년도 차이콥스키 실황으로 다 봤는데 납득이 간 등수였어요. Trifonov , 손열음, 조성진 연주영상은 다 보셨는지..?? 그리고 루빈스타인 콩쿨은 세계적으로 기량이 뛰어난 피아니스트들이 많이 몰려오는 콩쿨이에요. 다른 콩쿨들과 다르게 나이 약간 있는 연주가들이 나오는걸 보면 알수있죠. 개인적으로 조성진 피아니스트도 루빈스타인 때 정말 잘쳤지만, 쇼팽콩쿨 만큼은 아니였어요. 쇼팽콩쿨에선 정말 소름돋게 실수 거의 없이 연주했죠. 의견을 내시고 싶으시다면, 다 보시고 말씀하셨으면 하네요. 추측성만 짙은 말만 하지마시고...
![[아름다운 목요일] F. Liszt Années de pèlerinage, 2nd Year "Italie", S.161 | Yun Chan Lim, Piano](/img/n.gif)
浜松の時も上手かったですが
より一層間のとり方が自然で且つ
美しくなったように感じます。
強弱の急落も激しくなりより壮大に感じます。
Pour moi le nouveau Richter !!!
On croit rêver devant une telle perfection. La puissance, le poids de sa technique est pleinement au service de la musique. Un grand bravo du fond du cœur !
수많은 단테소나타를 들어도
결국 나의 종착지는
이 곳.
이 신박한 연주는 또 모지...진짜 어디까지 인가 그의 능력은...이 멜랑콜리한 갬성은 대체...
빌드업이 정말 좋네요. 이런 맛으로 클래식 듣는다는 걸 다시금 상기해주는 연주예요.
OMG ! 17 years old and already a pure genius !!!
And, finally, a well deserved GOLD medal at the most prestigious piano competition : The Chopin competition !!
Exactement
@pelegrino there mire well deserved gold medals in chopin competition like pollini
I heard him playing the Dante sonata some days ago live.... I have rarely heard such an electrifying way of making music!
When I first heard Seong-Jin play I remember being struck by an unusually intuitive playing that seemed to bring so many things to life on the spot. His story was convincing and mesmerizing without any need for words, and he brought me a little closer to Ravel, whom I had not liked or cared for previously. ... Bravo and cheers to many more years of amazing music making!
와... 보고 또 봐도 진짜 미쳤다는 말밖에는... 다른 연주자들은 내가 감상하고 싶은 부분에서 너무 빨리 연주하는데 조성진은 차분하게 연주함... 조성진이 아니었으면 나는 단테소나타의 아름다움을 몰랐을수도
와우! 멋진 리뷰
유일하게 리스트를 들리게 해주는 피아니스트..
이게 17살이었다니..
일등 주기도 아까운천재를.. 타고태어나서 이미14세때 완성된 천재피아니스트. 갈고닦아서 되는 일반피아니스트가 범접할수없는.. 쇼팽보다 라흐.차콥.라벨.리스트 그어떤 레파토리도 더완벽히 소화한다.. 조성진에게 어려운곡은 없는듯. 난해한곡일수록 날개단다..세계최고. 세기의 천재!
알캉도 도전해봤으면!!
완성됬다는 표현은 아닌것 같아요!
아직도 계속 발전하고 있다는게 놀라울 뿐^^
@@골드만싹쓰리-q8q 맞아요 음악에 완성이라는것은 없습니다 더더욱 많은 사람의 마음을 울리게 하는것이 음악이죠 모두를 만족시킬수는 없으니까요
One of the great true pianistic talents to emerge recently.
A stunning performance especially at that young age. Bravo! Seong-Jin.
His tonality and artistry of the performance are beyond words...of course having he best piano in the world helps but it is the pianist. Bravo!
Amazing fact is he played this in Hamamatsu competition at the age of 15!!!!! Well,....... rest u guess!!! His musical ability and maturity sensitivity ....creativity.................❤
저 나이에 이미 연주의 성숙도가 익어있으니.. 나가는 대회마다 최연소 경신을 안할수가 없었을듯.. 그나저나 어릴때 통통한거 진짜 귀엽네 ㅋㅋ
다른 차원을 경험하고 온 듯한...
소름돋다 못해 섬뜩하네요
정말 위대하신 분
조성진은 그 어떤 곡이라도 서사를 주고 개연성을 준다. 어떤곡은 다른 피아니스트의 연주를 들으면 뭐 이런 곡을 작곡했냐 싶은데, 조성진 연주를 들으면 납득해버림.
뭐 이런 곡을 작곡했냐
성진님은 어릴때부터 빛이 나네요 내면의 아름다움에서 우러나오는 빛이요 음악도 성진님을 닮는 것 같습니다 아니면 성진님이 음악을 닮으신 것인가요 음악과 성진님 다 빛이납니다^^
놀라운 사실은 이 난곡을 중3 때 하마마츠에서 이미 완벽하게 쳤었다는 것. 역시 천재는 어릴 때부터 완성형.
나는 돌잔치때 쳤는데ㅋ
@@앙기모띠09273 니애미
이곡 알렉산드로 칸트로프가 친거 들어보세요 미쳣습니다 진짜로
@@앙기모띠09273 베리나 꺼져
이 영상이 전설인 이유: 단테와 어울리는 멜랑꼴리한 감성, 완벽한 카메라 각도와 연주, 그리고
*조성진*
Astonishing performance - no words.
피아노를 모르는 사람으로서의 저의 느낌은 나이를 떠나 가장 감성 깊은 연주를 보인건 조성진이었습니다. 전 그래서 그를 사랑합니다. 사실 음악은 그런거 아닌가요?
굿
맞습니다. 감사합니다
어떻게 저나이에 저렇게 모든감정을 표현할수있는지~ 치기도 어려운데 놀라지않을수없다~~
What a wonderful performance !
Wonderful Seong Jin!!!
So much great...!
Love you Seong Jin such young age...!
Perform miracle way..!
Kanna chan
연주도 너무 완벽하지만, 향수가 느껴지는 18살만이 낼 수 있는 소리의 단테라서 더 좋은 것 같아요..
와‥
오 ~ 17세의 조성진! 이때도 대단했네요 오늘도 놀라고 갑니다
유튜브에 있는 많은 단테를 들어봤지만 나에게는 조성진의 단테 연주가 제일 느껴지고 좋다
임윤찬
@@이사믄육 12:19 14:35 진짜 뭔 영화보는줄 어쩜 이렇게 드라마틱하게 연주할수있죠
@@ялюблюестьпутинлол 흠...어쩔티빜ㅋ제..생각...인데여.....님..이중인격?막이랰!!ㅋ😣😣🤬
@@이사믄육 👨👧
Jurors look so happy. I think Cho won at an appropriate time. / 2010 Daniil Trifonov(19years old), Third prize in 16th Chopin competition / Seong-Jin CHO(16years old) can't participate in it because of an age restiction. // 2011 Daniil Trifonov(20), First prize in Tchaikovsky competition. / Seong-Jin CHO(17), Third prize in it. // 2015 Seong-Jin CHO(21), First prize in 17th Chopin competition.
This esoteric pilgrimage year song, mixed with torrent of sound and meditation, requires a high degree of concentration on both the playing side and the listening side, but he balances the sound and meditates the falling dolcissimo. Play beautifully.
❤ 이걸 이제야 듣다니 역시 성진님
he was awarded 3rd prize at the rubinstein comp. and believe me, no one was getting close to his level...
+eric rouach I saw those Rubinstein Comp. performances recently, but not all because it's not available in the US. However, the performances I've watched are so different styled than his Chopin Competition. I actually LOVED IT! He was full of expressions, that's for sure, and I think due to his "heavy" gestures that the conservative judges did not choose him? Surely, the younger, progressive generation jury actually chose him for their Jury Prize. I actually loved how he was full of expressions, and even ppl who are not familiar with classical music, esp. less-known pieces like Bartok and Liszt would surely enjoy watching his performances because he seemed to be telling the story or theme of the music, like you're watching a movie, u know what I mean? I def. enjoyed watching and listening to his performances altho I was not familiar with certain pieces of music, but he seemed to be telling a story with each piece. Despite his gestures, when you just listen with closed eyes, you can hear how the sound is so clear with expressions. It's a terrible shame that he had to settle for third, and even probably had to tone down his expressions for the Chopin Competition. I hope he can play with the fullest expressions now that he's done with competitions. He's one of very few pianists whom I actually love to watch and listen, the other one is Nobuyuki, and who can't be moved by such a divine artist.
Yes, I remember him playing the Liszt Sonata in B minor.
His soul in in hands when he is playing Liszt🎵🤲🎶🙏
연주듣는데 심장이 쿵닭쿵닭거리는 연주네요
조성진 짱
What a wonderful and amazing performance 🎶
어떻게 저 나이에 이런 연주를 할 수 있을까요... ㅠㅠ
Just great...!
Amazing...!
Rektmz ne da thip
지성용 너어는 진짜...
At 17, wow what an achievement
유튜브에 올라와 있는 모든 단테 영상들 그냥 조성진 미만 잡이다... 나는 단테가 리스트 거라 기교적인 부분이 강조되어야한다고 생각하고 처음 조성진 것을 들었을 때 너무 느리고, 너무 감성적이라 별로라고 생각했지만 들으면 들을 수록 울컥하고 올라오는 감정이 진하게 느껴짐. 리스트가 어떤 생각으로 어떤 감정으로 단테소나타를 작곡했는지 가장 정확하게 파악하고 있는 사람은 조성진인 것 같다.
09년인가 하바마츠때는 속도가 더 빨랐어요
아마 .. 일부러 속도 늦춰서 다시 해석한 연주 스타일 같아요~
난 볼로도스
임윤찬 듣고 깜놀
두분다 10대에...정말잘치네요
사실 리스트가 낭만주의 시대를 대표한다는 것을 생각하면 단순히 기교를 넘어서 감정적인 어떤 것을 불러일으키는 쪽이 더 의도에 맞는 것이 아닐까..개인적으로 생각합니다
Right in Russia's own back yard, this 17 year old boy (man!) plays this hellishly difficult piece with the power and emotion that some Russian players never reach even in their maturity. Cho did not win this competition (amazingly!), but time will correct the error of these Russian judges!
I agree. He did win the 2015 Chopin Competition, which was so well-deserved.
Well, in that year Trifonov won the competition so, it's fair for me. (I love the playing of both pianists Trifonov and Cho, there are among the best young players)
I totally agree with you
this song is completely underrated in general.
Who knows what Liszt discussions were regarding the Divine Comedy.. wish i could go back and just over hear his opinions, my favorite composer reflecting on my favorite poet.... always loved this piece.. fantastic playing, very technical though
I thought about the same thing too!!
리스트의 환상곡풍 소나타, 단테소나타
ㅂ-토벤 소나타 13,14번(월광)영향
순례의해-이탈리아의 7번 2:07❤
너무좋다 진짜 우리 나라 사람이라 너무 자랑스럽다!!!
3:38 4:15 5:35 6:41 7:25 8:26 9:48 10:25 10:44 11:04 13:11 14:28
15:08 15:20 15:58 16:23
진짜 너무멋있다
まさに教科書！！
He was only 17 years old at that time jejus
15 years playing...
He started at 9. Started so late. His parents are far from musician.
not 15 years 17 years
international age was 15
Korean age was 15
내가 보려고 만드는 최애 부분 6:33 8:26 9:13 11:09 12:04 16:24
우리의 보물 조성진♡♡♡
14:48, beatiful!
조성진 볼살있는거 너무 귀엽다ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
브라보 리스트
브라보 조성진
와...ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ진짜 피아노 잘치네....
Good!He won the first prize in International Chopin Piano Competition.He is sensitive i think
이때 제대로실력 평가가 됬다면 사실상의 우승자이지 않았나 생각됨
너무 어린나이라 평가에 손해보지않았나싶음..
그건 좀... 비슷한 실력이라 치면 더 어린쪽에 점수 더 줌... 다닐이 본토 홈그라운드 버프에 출중했으니 우승한거죠..
@@Mavis0709맞아요. 손열음님 조성진님 모두 뛰어났지만 다닐도 진짜 광기가 있었음. 이건 콩쿨이고 결과에 승복해야 한다고 생각해요. 이 때 협연 스테이지에서도 조성진님이 라흐3번인가 했었는데 본인도 실수 많았다고 했고.. 다만 나이를 고려하면 가장 가능성 높은 참가자였다고 할 수 있겠죠. 어쨌든 쇼콩에서 1등 했으니 말 다했죠 뭐
이단테 말고는 딴거 못듣겠다
세기의 천재. 그이상이하도 아니다.
아무 이유없이 왜 슬픈지 모르겠어요. 원래 클래식을 들으면 가끔 이런 기분이 드는건가요?
멜랑꼴리해요
조성진의 연주에 그런 감정을 만들게 하는 보이지않는 힘이 있나 보죠
바나나우유로구독자1000명찍기 이래서 잼민이란...
단테소나타가 그래요. 지옥문에 떨어져 생의 희망을 다 버린 죄많은 인간의 공포와 두려움 후회 절망과 슬픔등을 표현한 것이죠
@@김민석-h3h 잼민이....잼민이...그 놈의 잼민이!!!
아행복하다
군더더기가 없는데 마력이 있다. 보통 둘중 하난데 ㄷ ㄷ
뭐 안 친 곡이 없노 이 양반
He must be the first both
이 무렵의 연주가 최고로 들리는 내가 잘 못 된 걸까?
틴에이저가 존경스럽다.
밥먹고 피아노만 치던 시절이기에..
단테소나타 ㅡ17살! 와우.
Playing Liszt at a Tchaikovsky piano competition really makes sense lol
Daniel Ard Mephisto Waltz was played at the Chopin competition
@@CalamityInAction what!? Who!?
@@CalamityInAction Chopin competition only allows Chopin pieces! How can one participate with Liszt or any other composer? Unless y saw maybe Dmitry shishkin or someone playing mephisto waltz in the same hall or something, but that's not part of the competition it's something called Chopin and his Europe or smth.
@@lczq6737 I wrote this comment a while ago. It was Chopin and his Europe
@@CalamityInAction ah yes ofc
진짜개머싯다
🐕짜는 빼주심이? 굉장히 멋져요!!!
8:56 Gesundheit
머져요 ~~ 머죠 !!! 👏👏🙏👍😊
9:14
예고 2학년?
앳된 아가야엿네
앳된 아가야가 오동통 손으로 단테 소나타 부왘 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 귀에 때려박네요 ㅜㅜㅜ
You know, it takes some balls to get up and play a meandering mess like this in a competition. Beautiful performance but God, compositionally this is all over the shop. The Benediction de Dieu dans la Solitude might have been a better choice for combining virtuosic moments with extended periods of introspection. It's a little tighter too. For the first 10 minutes of this performance I was thinking this is the farthest into the piece I'd heard without getting bored, so thank you Seong Jin Cho.
how can you have the name “LisztyLiszt” and not like this piece
“all over the shop” I mean, it’s a fantasia
the Benediction has longer virtuosic lapses - it hardly does anything in that respect until the “recap”.
@@jonathanDstrand everyone has their opinions
The Dante Sonata is one of the most exiting, genius and deep works ever written. It’s right up there with the Sonata in B minor. There is nothing messy with this piece. At least when played well. When played properly, it’s one of the most wonderful experiences you can get.
가지마 베아트리체😭
1st prize Daniil Trifonov, 2nd prize Yeoleum Son, 3rd Prize Seongjin Cho... it was too much competitive at that time. In my opinion, Yeoleum son was the best, and Daniil & Seongjin cho should have been 2rd prize corecipient
Very high calibre that year. Much higher than the most recent. Maasleev, where is he? Debarque was amazing but he suffered from a lack of concerto playing with a real orchestra in the final. Lovely player though. So musical. George Li was a gem. They're the two to keep an eye on. Couldn't agree more about 2011 but in fairness, Trifonov has gone on to greatness and he's a beast. Had the pleasure of hearing him live. Seong Jin Cho is a treasure. Deserved this win. Would love to hear more of Yeoul Eum Son. She seems to have gone off the radar a bit. Her Rach 3 at 2011 final was outstanding.
He shouldn't have grown up physically... It's just perfect enough.
👏👏👏
❤️🧡💛💚💙💜
he still had a bit of baby fat on his cheeks then, but what a career he has now. This isnt a hard piece by Liszt standards.
I wish I could play the piano like this…😂
BrAvo
🌹
8:26-9:40
So beautiful
이거곡명뭐죠ㅜㅜ
리스트 단테요!
❤❤❤❤❤❤
3:16 9:04 10:48 11:48 12:10 13:07
4:50
16:40
Awww look at those chubby cheeks!!!
Simp lol
I think he looks better now
3:34, wtf
4 2:39
15:40
Lol he lost so much weight in those years.
Kkkkkk😂.. i read somewhere that he is incredibly serious on his music but occasional his leasure time was filled wt cartoons wt eating redbean sweet buns!!! So mo wonder!!😂 after all we are human!😂😂😂😂
King of king인 조성진만 보면 좌절감과 무력감이 막 든다.
이망할놈에 단테 때문에 작년 실기 망함..,,
@R 에휴 시비충
@R 개그도 못받아주냐?ㅋㅋ
@R 키신도 단테 치다가 틀렸는데...ㅋㅋㅋ
@R그만큼 난이도있는곡이라는거지 빠가야..ㅋㅋㅇㅋ내손이문제있다해도 내가 니보다는 잘침. ..
@R 바흐 인벤션도 다못끝낸게 걔기기는...하...진짜 시비충 개싫어...
Vitaly Pisarenko is best.
i don.t agree with you
fluorite1971 volodos!!!
Pisarenko's interpretation of this piece is certainly formidable, althoug Seong-Jin Cho's bears a different feel which I like a lot as well. Berman is pretty good too.
양성수 Say it in Pisarenko’s video, not Cho’s.
There is no best.
There's many pros that are perfect.
You either have it or you don't.
Cho does perfect.
Chopin lo suona meglio
이런 천재에게 3위를주다니. 일반인들이 감히 천재를 평가한다고? 트리포노프는 피아노에 압도되어 힘들게치는데 자국민이라 1위를 준듯하고. 피아노를 완전히 장악하고 다루는 조성진은 3위. 말도 안되는 심사위원들. 루빈때도 천재기량 완벽발휘했으나 3위를 주니 실소가나오고 썩은음악계가 씁쓸할뿐이다.
올해 루빈에서는 시몬 너링이 1위했단 소식에 저도 실소를 금치 못하... 정말 이건 아니죠...
트리포노프가 피아노에 압도되서 힘들게 친다는건 무슨 말도안되는 소리죠? 차이코프스키 2011 은 정말 1,2,3 위 순위 납득 완벽하게 가는 대회였어요. 2위가 손열음씨였고 저 세명이라도 대회 통틀어서 무슨곡들 쳤는지는 아시고하시는말씀인가요. 전 차이코프스키 하는 도중부터 계속 봤고 저 세명 1,2,3차 다보고 하는 말인데, 조성진 저도 정말 팬이지만 쇼팽콩쿨이랑 더 스타일이 맞는 학구적이고 깊은해석을 하는 피아니스트고 차이코프스키는 더 화려하고 박력있고 다양하게 치는 사람들이 점수를 잘받아가는 대회에요. 2015 2위인 조지 리만 봐도 알 수 있듯이. 조성진 손열음 둘다 1차때 쳤던 슈만 휴모레스크만해도 전 개인적으로 손열음씨 해석이 더 와닿았고, 트리포노프 콘체르토 소름돋게 잘했는데... 일반인들이 천재를 평가하긴 무슨 차이콥 심사위원들 누군진 알고 다는 댓글인지.
Daniel님의 말에 공감해요. 한가지 더 추가적으로 말씀드리고 싶은건 어느 콩쿨이든 심사위원들은 다 음악계에 깊은 내공이 있으신 음악가 혹은 교수님들이구요. 일반인들이라뇨;;; 어디 나가서 그런 소리 하시면 창피받아요... 저도 11년도 차이콥스키 실황으로 다 봤는데 납득이 간 등수였어요. Trifonov , 손열음, 조성진 연주영상은 다 보셨는지..?? 그리고 루빈스타인 콩쿨은 세계적으로 기량이 뛰어난 피아니스트들이 많이 몰려오는 콩쿨이에요. 다른 콩쿨들과 다르게 나이 약간 있는 연주가들이 나오는걸 보면 알수있죠. 개인적으로 조성진 피아니스트도 루빈스타인 때 정말 잘쳤지만, 쇼팽콩쿨 만큼은 아니였어요. 쇼팽콩쿨에선 정말 소름돋게 실수 거의 없이 연주했죠.
의견을 내시고 싶으시다면, 다 보시고 말씀하셨으면 하네요. 추측성만 짙은 말만 하지마시고...
여기저기에서 이런 댓글달고 다니셨네요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 다른 곳도 내용 비슷하던데 제발 자기의 주관을 바탕으로 멋대로 평가좀 하지 마세요
이때 다닐이든 손썸머든 죄다 물올라서 연주 전부 미친듯이 잘했는대 무슨 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 현재 다닐이 엄청 잘나가는게 그 반증이겠지. 성진형이 정말 대단한 천재지만 다닐이 콩쿨 국적빨 거르고도 잘했는대 국뽕에 씌여서 하는 개소리는 삼가해주세요 ㅋㅋㅋ