I thought that Dave's performance was best. I liked his interpretation from 24:48 onward was more on point than the others. Loved Brandon's interpretation as well, very dynamic and full of feels. Great set, all!!!
To me the best and most interesting performance was dave's(tasty gloves and fills, I really dug it 😎👌)Brandon was solid and I loved the cymbal smash accent and the double time power 😊👍 Dylan was more a straight shot and professional(like a session drummer playing a low key track so not too much)all of you did great in a different way and I love when you do this, showing different views and play styles of the same song 👏
Second one guy was the best to me. If I was there, will let more space for music, create a tribal pattern just on toms and bass drum, a few touches on cymbals and NO snare, 'cause the original already has the clap sharp sound on 2nd and 4th tempos. .
I love Dave's Power fills and the expression on Dave's face when he first started getting his sea legs😜 , Dylon had killer stick work , Brandon great feel all great drummers
All 3 great. For me, 1st guy Brandon started out too full on though and didn't take it down anywhere. 2nd dude, Dylan had the best performance imho, musical, changed it up, smooth grooves on point. Gave the piece space to breathe. That flam stop💪3rd geezer, Dave had a better 1st half of the song. Too many fills flying by overall. Fill at 25.00 was super, watched that just a few times:) Hats off gents! Be interesting too to hear these guys go up against each other again with a track they can digest for a while.
Dylan arguably has the best technique but Brandon plays with so much nuance. Creates this rolling sense of momentum in the song that ebbs and flows while staying regular.
For me, the second drummer struck the best balance between serving the song (being symbiotic with and being enhancing to the music) and showcasing himself. The choices he made made me want to listen to the music/piece more than I felt with the other two.
Dylan won this...the other two were great but Dylon played something that complimented the music track...solid but with technical parts where they were needed...the first guy lacked detail and the third guy had a little too much...Dylon hit the spot...
1. Dylan. Dylan’s take was the coolest. His fills were most exciting, he started with a tight hihat, ghost notey groove before opening it up and going to ride and his dynamics and feel were by far the best. 2. Brandon. He played pretty busy and not tasteful or good busy imo, but I did like that he went into a double time groove. HOWEVER I think the double time groove would’ve been way cooler with the snares on 1 and 3. 3. David. Nothing in his performance surprised me or really caught me off guard. I thought he played pretty cymbal heavy with a lot of ride and it made the dynamics feel one dimensional. Dylan is my pick. No question. 🤷♂️
Dylan by a wide margin. All excellent, but Dylan had more overall shape, tone, groove, more breathing space, was more connected to the details of the song. Yeah, he missed the last note -- but what a finish he was going for! By the way, "soup to nuts" is a fine dining metaphor. Solution X covers all "courses" from the soup to the post-desert nuts (and cheese?).
I want to see so many more of these! It's awesome seeing the Drumeo guys tear it up on the kit!! And as impressive and badass as Dave and Brandon's were, I think I liked Dylan's the best. He still did some really cool, technically impressive stuff, but it fit within the song the best of the three instead of covering it up
What's so refreshing about this is the raw human performance they all gave. Honest and leaving it all on the table. Some small glitches and scrapes but all part of the first time round play through and illustrative the real everyday drummer experience. I loved it all from all three guys. The moments of slight grit and dirt is what I enjoyed most as iit should the honesty and conviction of each player as they tried to perfectly execute their initial ideas for the piece after only one listen through. Human yet professional at the same time. I hope this is a reoccurring bit for this channel and it's contributors. Too often we see the perfect performance and never the behind the scenes work that lead up to that final perfect take. insightful and shows off the drumeo talent in a great light! I loved this video! More episodes of this theme please
Man...what can I say ...I loved all 4 versions ..really..they were all creative and very musical .Don't have a favorite..I respect all 4 of you guys ..your a blast to watch and listen to ..great drum department episode ..Kyle ...your becoming a great host of the show...you make the show fun to watch and to listen to ...Steve ..
Brandon has quietly become one of my favorite drummers/educators. I think he could hold down the drum chair in most an big band touring right now. Dave and the Foo's? Give Brandon a call. New Rush tour? Brandon's got you. Brian Blade needs a vacation? Fellowship band rings up B-dog... I haven't heard any reggae tunes though. Perhaps that's his weakness. lol
Hey drumeo.can you make presentación latin drums or percusion player.example horacio hernandez.fausto cuevas.diego camacho/ timbal player the noche orquesta. Or cuban latin player or merengue regueton players. Please thanks
Brandon best of the three, but all three did much better than I could. Can tell they are pros and I'm one of those dime a dozen drummers, but still SO MUCH FUN!! 😃
It seems to me like all drummers missed the time signature change at 11:37 but I enjoyed Brandon’s performance the most. Fantastic job by all though for great performances with no guidelines to follow
1. Dylan - I liked the use of toms, this also felt like part of the song, not just drumming over it 2. Dave - I liked the use of the hi-hat 3. Brandon - Too much cymbals, but overall not bad
Soup to Nuts: American English idiom, desc. a full course dinner; from beginning to end. Also: a 1930's film of same name, starring the trio who later became the "Three Stooges" Therefore: think Dave, Brandon & Dylan as The Soup to Nuts Guys !! 😂 🤣thank you Wikipedia.
I loved being the last minute -walk in - gun slinger - ringer - shit our Drummer just realized he’s double booked… we don’t care how you sound just be there by 7:30 for a 9:00 pm downbeat… Especial with good players… all we needed to do was NOT train wreck… Stewart Copeland said that the first take was almost always the best take… Sooo many players feel that way… Freedom… just keep your chops and your mind healthy… and play NOT with your shoulders arm, wrists and fingers… but with your heart , brain , eyes and ears…. I got a ton of call backs… but then the pressure was on.. know the arrangements… that was a lot less free or fun… Sidney Layman… early 1980s… keyboard player for the Airman of Note….kicked…my…butt…. SHE was the gun slinger… I was bruised for a week… all I could do was hang on and NOT suck…. But I got the call back. First takes… are the most fun
1. Kyle (very tasty) 2. Dave/ Dylan (both equally great) 3. Brandon (too much of everything...cymbals, fills, volume...) Very sad to say, because i really love Brandons Vids on all the different Drum Heros.
Would be nice to hear some snare hits thsy weren't always right on the 3 for a little tasty section or something. I liked where Dave was going with the Tom voicing during the verse but then he kind of abandoned it. Great playing each drummer for sure.
I know this sounds weird, but I hate the tempo. Snare on 2 & 4 sounds corny and snare on the 3 sounds super sluggish. SO much music over the last couple decades use this tempo - without even checking I'm dead positive its somewhere between 60 and 70 bpm. It's like EVERY Polyphia song, every dubstep song. It sucks to play drums to, it sucks to dance to and it seems like the whole world for some bizarre reason gravitates towards it when writing.
All 3 guys were fantastic! It was amazing that they all listened to the song just once, and then they all came out with an amazing drum performance that fit the whole format! I favored the last guy playing more than the other first 2, but doesn't mean I liked them any less. I hope there's more of these drum offs in the future as I really liked this a lot. Kudos to getting to watch all 3 bad@$$ drummers. Thanks. 👍😎 - ( it's sad that I just got to watch this 10 months after it was posted though ☹️)
"Soup to nuts" is a saying that comes from food industry, a full course meal starts with apps/soup and ends with sweets/nuts... Didn't like Brandon floor tom part on the first one before the last chorus, I felt like that kinda threw it off, Dylan was best I think, the vibe was on cue
Before the camera focused on the notes, I could have sworn it was blank. Those would have been my notes. My bandmates make fun of me for looking at the paper not for the music but so crowd perception is that I am focused on the music... @18:35
Dylan’s was the most musical, left space and added to the song. Both of the others filled every space with pure drum wankery and would have been thrown out of my studio.
I they should have been given a bigger drum kit. I think the song would have worked even better if they didn’t have to focus almost entirely on the snare. Concert Tom’s are still the &^#!… You really can’t beat their sound in a live concert.
All the drummers did way better than I would have, but I feel Dave performed the song the best. Out of ALL the guys that played it, Kyle did the best and even dropped his stick and didn't loose tempo or anything. WIN FOR KYLE!
For me - Dylan, Dave & by a bit of a margin then Brandon. Just felt Brandon’s was too in my face and felt like it was too showy. Dylan’s take felt comforting to me and Dave’s cymbals were at a level I wish Brandon had been at.
I want a recount 😆. So much fun doing this -- thanks for all the support! Great job to Brandon & Dave.
dang those single stroke fills
I liked your take the most.
Your take was best and I think the comments very clearly verify that.
You're won that contest bro. Great playing n great control👍🏻
Yours sounded the best to my ears, unofficial winner.
I liked Dylan's interpretation the most for his power and tastefulness that captures the track's spirit, but adds some more dynamic fills.
Dylan was the one where it felt like the Drums compliments the music track they played. Clean and subtle. I like his version way more than others.
I thought that Dave's performance was best. I liked his interpretation from 24:48 onward was more on point than the others. Loved Brandon's interpretation as well, very dynamic and full of feels. Great set, all!!!
Are you a musician?
1. Brandon - Jack of all trades, good groove as well
2. Dylan - master of space
3. Dave - master of ghost notes
Way too much conversation at the beginning guys. Still love Drumeo. Keep going with awesome videos.
Dylan understood the spirit of the composition, in my opinion. They were all awesome!
Dylan played what the song needed and called for. He gets my vote.
Dylan followed the off beat accents of the backing track 1/4 way through. Powerful finish. So, Dylan.
Classic, Dylan 😆
@@dylanweightman Haha. Well, no one can argue with that self appraisal. Good one. 👍
AGREED!
Right?
Would love to hear Chris Coleman play his version :D
Live in the moment, bro.
To me the best and most interesting performance was dave's(tasty gloves and fills, I really dug it 😎👌)Brandon was solid and I loved the cymbal smash accent and the double time power 😊👍 Dylan was more a straight shot and professional(like a session drummer playing a low key track so not too much)all of you did great in a different way and I love when you do this, showing different views and play styles of the same song 👏
1st guy was too busy, 2nd guy had the best groove and fit them vibe. 3rd guy had best fills
I love the second guy tecnic. And the 3rd guy opener fills is awesome before the music go to kind of bridge🎉
Can tell your not a drummer like the other 13 people who liked that comment.
2nd
2nd Dylan, he serv the song and played with soul. Great tone control and ghost note. Ma vote from 🇲🇾 ✌🏻
Hahah lol naaa, the 3rd was the busiest and way to much played.
1st held the form consistently, didn't have too much variety and caught the ending
Dave killed it!!!
Hell yes he did! 🤣
BIG DADDY DAVE 📸
This was so much fun to watch 💯💯💯💯💯
Middle guy best feel by far...
Dave reminds me of how Dennis Chamberlin plays the double bass.
Dave blew the other two out of the water.
Yes, Dave was head and shoulders.
Never realized Dave was such a killer drummer.
Everyone at Drumeo is a killer drummer.
Dylan - all the way! He served the song, the pauses were better, letting it breathe more -Imo, it was the most musical approach!
Second one guy was the best to me. If I was there, will let more space for music, create a tribal pattern just on toms and bass drum, a few touches on cymbals and NO snare, 'cause the original already has the clap sharp sound on 2nd and 4th tempos. .
I love the host! he is a very camera friendly dude. Love the ballbusting ;] -m.Ando !
Dylan for sure. I didn't care for Brandon's George of the jungle beat in there, and Dave was overpowering the track.
Dave's was the best for me! Very organic and natural
I vote for the cute guy Dylan 😊 but Dave went pretty well too
I love Dave's Power fills and the expression on Dave's face when he first started getting his sea legs😜 , Dylon had killer stick work , Brandon great feel all great drummers
Dylan's take was really good... Thought it captured what a great half way between Dave and Brandon would sound like
Brandon absolutely won for me. So clean and ended exactly on time. Sounded well thought out.
Its was hot garbage
Yup he ticked the most boxes, got the form, had good ideas, clear fills, caught the ending
All 3 great. For me, 1st guy Brandon started out too full on though and didn't take it down anywhere. 2nd dude, Dylan had the best performance imho, musical, changed it up, smooth grooves on point. Gave the piece space to breathe. That flam stop💪3rd geezer, Dave had a better 1st half of the song. Too many fills flying by overall. Fill at 25.00 was super, watched that just a few times:)
Hats off gents!
Be interesting too to hear these guys go up against each other again with a track they can digest for a while.
Wow having a great day today's Bellucci .
Brandon all the way, Dillon had a nice feel, Dave overplayed ...
Even though all three are great, I prefer the second guy, closer to the tune, better variations.
Dylan arguably has the best technique but Brandon plays with so much nuance. Creates this rolling sense of momentum in the song that ebbs and flows while staying regular.
Everyone at Drumeo is an amazing drummer. It’s what they do.
For me, the second drummer struck the best balance between serving the song (being symbiotic with and being enhancing to the music) and showcasing himself. The choices he made made me want to listen to the music/piece more than I felt with the other two.
yes -- he elevated the music
Best episode by far. They are ALL winners.
No, .... it's just a friendly competition, one winner.
It's healthy to know that the variables of life are not always in your favor.
@@patrickgelder-ph5yd Underrated comment. Nothing wrong with friendly competition to remain humble.
Honestly, before Dylan and Dave played, I knew ot was going to be Brandon. His was just oh so tasty
I vote Dylan merely for the comedic political pleas for votes. 😆
Brandon was the best. The other two followed the song instead of playing the song. It was like they were slightly behind the song through most of it.
Dylan had amazing feel and his ghost note volume was perfect for this track also had a vary consistent sounds all around the kit
Agreed on all points
These videos are way too long. Just get to the good stuff!
😐 Do you not see the timestamps that literally tell you when they play? If it's too long don't watch. Video isn't catered to you
My money is on Brandon. He's learned and internalized so many Grooves, styles, and genres. He just will have a bigger tool box to create with.
I liked Dylan the best bc the drumming flowed with the music more. Brandon too much crash... Dave too predictable.
Dylan won this...the other two were great but Dylon played something that complimented the music track...solid but with technical parts where they were needed...the first guy lacked detail and the third guy had a little too much...Dylon hit the spot...
Dave’s was most appropriate and I thought it sounded the best. I think he would’ve been hired as the studio musician to play it.
1st comment. I feel all the best. but as always, the best is always played last.
Very cool! Great job guys!
Did anyone else see Kyle’s Dolly Parton t shirt??
Dylan did it best. I would prefer his version on a recording.
Brandon had a little too much going on.
All solid performances, I’m gonna give the edge to Dave his just had a little extra feel.
Naaa
1. Dylan. Dylan’s take was the coolest. His fills were most exciting, he started with a tight hihat, ghost notey groove before opening it up and going to ride and his dynamics and feel were by far the best.
2. Brandon. He played pretty busy and not tasteful or good busy imo, but I did like that he went into a double time groove. HOWEVER I think the double time groove would’ve been way cooler with the snares on 1 and 3.
3. David. Nothing in his performance surprised me or really caught me off guard. I thought he played pretty cymbal heavy with a lot of ride and it made the dynamics feel one dimensional.
Dylan is my pick. No question. 🤷♂️
Dylan I thought was the best.
Dylan by a wide margin. All excellent, but Dylan had more overall shape, tone, groove, more breathing space, was more connected to the details of the song. Yeah, he missed the last note -- but what a finish he was going for!
By the way, "soup to nuts" is a fine dining metaphor. Solution X covers all "courses" from the soup to the post-desert nuts (and cheese?).
I personally liked Dylan's playthrough the most, but they were all so good.
Dylan won it at 20:22.
Nobody else did this. Should've done it more.
i go for Brandon, clean...and the progression is on point.
DAVE did AWESOME. Cool little aditions to a standard beat rythm Brandon did good , Dylan was too booksafe for me
In my humble opinion I think three of the gentlemen are all overplayed 🤣🤣
dylan. i would choose him. for playing for the song.....
I want to see so many more of these! It's awesome seeing the Drumeo guys tear it up on the kit!! And as impressive and badass as Dave and Brandon's were, I think I liked Dylan's the best. He still did some really cool, technically impressive stuff, but it fit within the song the best of the three instead of covering it up
Dylan, was more dynamic and complemented the song more!
Loved the breaks, and hitting the accents.
Dylan wins, but all drummers great
What's so refreshing about this is the raw human performance they all gave. Honest and leaving it all on the table. Some small glitches and scrapes but all part of the first time round play through and illustrative the real everyday drummer experience. I loved it all from all three guys. The moments of slight grit and dirt is what I enjoyed most as iit should the honesty and conviction of each player as they tried to perfectly execute their initial ideas for the piece after only one listen through. Human yet professional at the same time. I hope this is a reoccurring bit for this channel and it's contributors. Too often we see the perfect performance and never the behind the scenes work that lead up to that final perfect take. insightful and shows off the drumeo talent in a great light! I loved this video! More episodes of this theme please
Showed* not should. Typo above
Dave had the song perfectly expressed
Watching everyone's head bobbing in sync with the music while they were taking notes was great content.
Man...what can I say ...I loved all 4 versions ..really..they were all creative and very musical .Don't have a favorite..I respect all 4 of you guys ..your a blast to watch and listen to ..great drum department episode ..Kyle ...your becoming a great host of the show...you make the show fun to watch and to listen to ...Steve ..
Brandon has quietly become one of my favorite drummers/educators. I think he could hold down the drum chair in most an big band touring right now. Dave and the Foo's? Give Brandon a call. New Rush tour? Brandon's got you. Brian Blade needs a vacation? Fellowship band rings up B-dog... I haven't heard any reggae tunes though. Perhaps that's his weakness. lol
Don't give me any reggae :D
@@BrandonToews 🤣
Loved all the versions! Such different approaches and techniques from everyone, amazing to watch!
At least they are not up against Chad Smith xD
They were all good, the song sucked. You guys could of found a way better song for them to throw down to.
Dave's version was prettiest imo, I'd vote for his rendition.
Brandon!! i vote for Brandon! i mean i love his sound!
Dave for the win!!!!
Dylan did exactly what the song needed....#1
Don't know the name but the first drummer is definitely the one who best has interpreted the song. Great job again guys !
#2 and #3, both killed it. #1 to show show drummerish for me. Over all# 2 for me
So much fun! I loved this, guys. Everyone did a fantastic job.
Hey drumeo.can you make presentación latin drums or percusion player.example horacio hernandez.fausto cuevas.diego camacho/ timbal player the noche orquesta. Or cuban latin player or merengue regueton players. Please thanks
well played Dylan
Brandon best of the three, but all three did much better than I could. Can tell they are pros and I'm one of those dime a dozen drummers, but still SO MUCH FUN!! 😃
I really loved Dylan's version, to be honest I was even surprised by the votes
Brandon was a close second for me
Dylan takes it 👍🏼
What’s the name of the track??
Enjoyed all 3. I vote Dylan. He let the song breathe. Very tasteful.
It seems to me like all drummers missed the time signature change at 11:37 but I enjoyed Brandon’s performance the most. Fantastic job by all though for great performances with no guidelines to follow
1. Dylan - I liked the use of toms, this also felt like part of the song, not just drumming over it
2. Dave - I liked the use of the hi-hat
3. Brandon - Too much cymbals, but overall not bad
Soup to Nuts: American English idiom, desc. a full course dinner; from beginning to end. Also: a 1930's film of same name, starring the trio who later became the "Three Stooges" Therefore: think Dave, Brandon & Dylan as The Soup to Nuts Guys !! 😂 🤣thank you Wikipedia.
I loved being the last minute -walk in - gun slinger - ringer - shit our Drummer just realized he’s double booked… we don’t care how you sound just be there by 7:30 for a 9:00 pm downbeat…
Especial with good players… all we needed to do was NOT train wreck…
Stewart Copeland said that the first take was almost always the best take…
Sooo many players feel that way…
Freedom… just keep your chops and your mind healthy… and play NOT with your shoulders arm, wrists and fingers… but with your heart , brain , eyes and ears….
I got a ton of call backs… but then the pressure was on.. know the arrangements… that was a lot less free or fun…
Sidney Layman… early 1980s… keyboard player for the Airman of Note….kicked…my…butt…. SHE was the gun slinger… I was bruised for a week… all I could do was hang on and NOT suck…. But I got the call back.
First takes… are the most fun
1. Kyle (very tasty)
2. Dave/ Dylan (both equally great)
3. Brandon (too much of everything...cymbals, fills, volume...) Very sad to say, because i really love Brandons Vids on all the different Drum Heros.
Brandon is, by far, the best of the three!
Waiting for #3 to play but I think #2 brought it so far
Dylan won this IMO
Would be nice to hear some snare hits thsy weren't always right on the 3 for a little tasty section or something. I liked where Dave was going with the Tom voicing during the verse but then he kind of abandoned it.
Great playing each drummer for sure.
Dylan's is best drummer he play like songs sense accord song composed …..all are best Brandon's fill best......N good but Dylan's is best BEAT
I know this sounds weird, but I hate the tempo. Snare on 2 & 4 sounds corny and snare on the 3 sounds super sluggish. SO much music over the last couple decades use this tempo - without even checking I'm dead positive its somewhere between 60 and 70 bpm. It's like EVERY Polyphia song, every dubstep song. It sucks to play drums to, it sucks to dance to and it seems like the whole world for some bizarre reason gravitates towards it when writing.
All 3 guys were fantastic! It was amazing that they all listened to the song just once, and then they all came out with an amazing drum performance that fit the whole format! I favored the last guy playing more than the other first 2, but doesn't mean I liked them any less. I hope there's more of these drum offs in the future as I really liked this a lot. Kudos to getting to watch all 3 bad@$$ drummers. Thanks. 👍😎 - ( it's sad that I just got to watch this 10 months after it was posted though ☹️)
"Soup to nuts" is a saying that comes from food industry, a full course meal starts with apps/soup and ends with sweets/nuts... Didn't like Brandon floor tom part on the first one before the last chorus, I felt like that kinda threw it off, Dylan was best I think, the vibe was on cue
Brandon is a killer 🤘🏻 LETS FVKING GO BOYS! ❤
Before the camera focused on the notes, I could have sworn it was blank. Those would have been my notes. My bandmates make fun of me for looking at the paper not for the music but so crowd perception is that I am focused on the music... @18:35
Dylan’s was the most musical, left space and added to the song. Both of the others filled every space with pure drum wankery and would have been thrown out of my studio.
I they should have been given a bigger drum kit. I think the song would have worked even better if they didn’t have to focus almost entirely on the snare. Concert Tom’s are still the &^#!…
You really can’t beat their sound in a live concert.
All the drummers did way better than I would have, but I feel Dave performed the song the best. Out of ALL the guys that played it, Kyle did the best and even dropped his stick and didn't loose tempo or anything. WIN FOR KYLE!
For me - Dylan, Dave & by a bit of a margin then Brandon.
Just felt Brandon’s was too in my face and felt like it was too showy.
Dylan’s take felt comforting to me and Dave’s cymbals were at a level I wish Brandon had been at.