ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
Physicist Reacts to What If Earth got Kicked Out of the Solar System? Rogue Earth
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ส.ค. 2024
- Come try my free QAL VPN alpha I built that can protect you from quantum computers: www.qalvpn.com/
Reacting to Kurzgesagt's Physicist Reacts to What If Earth got Kicked Out of the Solar System? Rogue Earth: • What If Earth got Kick...
Try out Skillshare using this link to support my channel: skl.sh/MKR204 :)
TWITTER ▶️ / dylanjdance
TWITCH ▶️ twitch.com/dyl...
INSTAGRAM ▶️ / dylanjdance
FACEBOOK ▶️ / dylanjdance
PATREON ▶️ / dylanjdance
MY MUSIC ON SPOTIFY
▶️ open.spotify.c...
Come try my free QAL VPN alpha I built that can protect you from quantum computers: www.qalvpn.com/
"Good movie plot isn't it?" been done already, Leiji Matsumoto's works include the story of a planet that was ejected from it's system and to survive the people of that world transferred their consciousness into machine bodies. Eventually the planet gets captured by our Sun and it becomes our 10th planet (it was written in the 70s so Pluto was still the 9th planet) but it orbits the Sun every thousand years. The story detailing this is "Queen Millennia". It's good sci fi set in the "futuristic" year of 1999.
interesting
No one cares, this is better
@@antoniosmith2610 Literally nobody said that that one was better. Go be a dumbass somewhere else.
@@antoniosmith2610 I care
@@Mister_Skar I implied It had to be a somebody
Imagine a civilization evolving on an incredibly isolated rogue planet in the void between galaxies. The only thing they ever know is pure darkness, and their own world. Given how much the Sun and other stars have shaped our civilization and it's cultures, religions etc... it's crazy to imagine what such a different people might be like.
I know right, I'd be nice to read a sci-fi story based on rogue planets in intergalactic space
They would be stuck under ocean ice pretty much. Unless there's some way to break through a few kilometers of it?
Perhapse a rogue planet orbiting a black hole. The force of gravity on it could be enough to keep it warm like how the moons of jupiter are heated up by it's gravity. Then you could have the energy needed for life to begin growing and thriving. Life that has only known darkness and perhaps some light that comes from any magma that seeps from the core.
I think I just got an idea for a cool short story.
@@MewPurPur Not necessarily, we have to be careful not to be biased thinking only of life as we know it. There's no reason that a silicon based lifeform couldn't exist that has a resistance to much more extreme temperature ranges. A lifeform that is chemosynthetic instead of photosynthetic, that could have an incredibly slow metabolism.
@@justinmcgough3958 i was just about to say something about blanets! i've wondered before what an intelligent civilization would be like on a black hole orbiting planet
Fun fact in 2012 a giant flair came Frome the sun. Powerful enough to cause all electronic system to shot down. Fortunately it happened on the other side of the sun ☀️
Congrats on getting a Beta version man! I wish you all the success with it!
Currently in schooling for my PhD in physics. Love your videos brother, bringing information and fun to the masses. 🤙
Of all the science and physics youtubers, I don't think someone attractive just reacting to someone else's quality videos is "bringing information... to the masses"
@@Heroo01 you’re silly. Hope you have a good day brother. 🤙
@@Diligentwaffle You sure you're old enough to be going for a phd
@@Heroo01 agreed
dylan will you make videos talking about your PhD in astrophysics? (giving advice for undergrads who wanna pursue research and stuff??)
been really enjoying your videos. im a CS major and likes the ideas we used to talk about in my physics classes. its great seeing you dive in a little deeper into ideas in your videos. :)
"Hopefully Jupiter does its damn job"
That killed me 🤣🤣🤣
Damn it Jupiter, come catch these objects already!
As a chemistry student I can only talk about phyics phenomenon so much. Ive always been asking myself how much of these things are actually scientific adequat. Bcs obv they have to break things down on very simple levels so that sometimes things are not factually wrong but maybe a bit too easy. So its interesting hearing other people deeper into that knowledge talking about it.
5:25 lmao great reaction!
I think someone already pointed it out, but you should really watch "... And we'll do it again" from kurzgesagt. It is about how they simplify the topics to explain them
i like how he explains in simple way for the masses to understand the vast knowledge. great video as usual. 😁👍
Great video! I’m trying to become an astrophysicist so these sort of videos are really helpful!
Thanks, and great video :)
So you have heard of the second law of thermodynamics right? Now ask yourself some questions about spacesuits and vacuums.
Then if you still want to become an astrophysicist then do it, you have the profile.
Me too! Even as a kid Iwas always absolutely fascinated by the Cosmos. Thanks to Dr. Brian Cox, Dr. Michelle Thallar.
I would love to make a great scientific contribution!
@@MrSarcasm101 flat earther uh?
really been enjoying the frequent uploads, just don’t get too burnt out man, while it may seem simple on paper, it’s not that simple
Finally, someone that talks about atmospheric pressure in order to have liquid water. A planet doesn't only need to be in the goldilock zone of a star to harbor liquid water. You need suffcient atmospheric pressure to keep that water in a liquid state.
Kurzgesagt has amazing videos, please react to more.
I am loving these videos! The videos by themselves are great, and your added commentary is invaluable!
Something I'm wondering now... what if a rogue star with just the right size passed through in just the right path. Could it capture Earth, so we orbit this new star instead of the sun? Maybe on a highly elliptical orbit, but we might be able to survive right?
Im no physicist, but I guess it would depends on the type of stars and mostly on wether their solar activity is high or not and if we are far enough while still having enough light to heat the planet (altho that could be somewhat dealt with by fusion as said Dylan).
22:18 You know they did a video about that too? Heavy on the biology but still interesting.
th-cam.com/video/4b33NTAuF5E/w-d-xo.html
Another must watch video of theirs is We Lied To You, and We'll Do It Again talking about the oversimplifications that are made to describe the various sciences/
"Don't confuse the description of a thing for the thing itself"
“Hopefully Jupiter does it’s damn job” needs to be a shirt lol just imagine a picture of earth and the planets all happy then theirs buff daddy Jupiter getting wrecked
If I recall right, Kurzgesagt always post their sources and the scientists that assisted them in the description of their videos. If I am right and they do. and anyone disagrees they can see where their info comes from.
**earth goes into the orbit of mars**
Russians: this is fine
Rogue Earth sounds like a pretty good video game.
I'd play that game. But instead of typical sci-fi game, I think it'd work well as Steampunk or Cyberpunk game.
@@Sam-de6qx I imagine it would be based off the original Rogue game but it’s open world.
@@Lamb666 So...exploring settlements and dungeons under the frozen earth and exploring the surface for supplies? I'd play that too.
Jupiter really is a kinda protector by stopping stray objects like meteors from getting to close
Just the thought of a blacker than black sky, not a single star in sight; gives me a ominous feeling.
I love the chad thumbnail
‘If life is going to arris, you need a big daddy like Jupiter’
There is a metal band called "Ashes of Ares" that has a 3 song arc about the Earth being ejected from the system
Jupiter: *I was born for this*
Have you read the three body problem? It’s fantastic hard sci-fi and I’d love to hear you go over it
The center of the Boötes void is probably one of the most loneliest places in the universe.
I am now going to refer to Jupiter as: "Big daddy". 😆
5:43 Jupiters not going to do it’s job if your mean to him
You should react to vsauce. Great video btw ❤️
Or is it?
@@SmallKilos *Jake Chudnow's Moon Men (Vsauce theme) intensifies*
someone did make a movie on this. the chinese "the wandering earth"
and an older movie: "when worlds collide" also hit on this topic.
You're only stuffed on an intergalactic rouge planet until you get FTL.
I always love hour videos tanks for your content
Jupiter, God of War protecting us
Wasn't that mars?
my guy is so handsome
true
“No it does not.”
Uhh, yes it *does.*
Barring the odd shooting star, nothing much appears to be happening up there. The stars twinkle in place and don’t appear to be perceptibly moving in real time. Even the planets and moon you can see. It looks pretty damn peaceful up there, even though it isn’t.
Dylan:"...a Little miniature star..."
Me: The Power of the Sun at the Palm of the Hand.
I KNOW its from Dr. Octavius, from Spiderman.
Dude your one in million! Like the only guy I have ever seen thinking about intergalactic planets lol!!
Man, Jupiter hasn't paid rent in billions of years. It could at least do a little Hoovering.
bro is playin life in chad mode.
Rogue Intergalactic Planets are just the universe’s orphanage
27:45 Legends say he’s still looking for questions as we speak
Maybe not on the topic of rouge plantes, but your description of the book at the end got me thinking. What is happening to planets when their star goes supernova? Would rocky planets be striped away of atmosphere and their surface got melted? Or just would they got completely vaporized? Would gas giants get their gases blown away, their rings disintegrated, moons melted? What about asteroids and comets? What is happening to whole system and what would be left after it? Would building any kind of sanctuary on any planet of that star be even sensible as supernova could melt its surface and destroy any sign of existence of life, or even vaporize whole planet?
There was a Twilight Zone episode about that. The Earth was being flung close to the sun and things were getting very hot on Earth, and then then at the end it is revealed that it was all a dream, but the reality is that the Earth is being flung OUT of the solar system and everyone is going to freeze to death. They didn't specifically SAY it, but obviously the explanation was that a black hole entered the solar system and did exactly what was described in that kurzgesagt video. I think the episode was called midnight sun. I consider that episode to be very ahead of its time because it seems to be the first time anyone had considered that to be an actual possibility.
You should read "A Pail of Air" by Fritz Lieber. It takes place years after a dark star (aka, a black hole) wrenched Earth away from the Sun, minus the Moon . It does depict colonies thriving in the post-solar era.
Excellent analysis, Dylan.
The 2012 prophecy was highly misunderstood:) the Mayans were actually referring to a new age and planetary alignment, beginning that year, not destruction. There is a new age in vernal equinox every 26,000 years. That was my understanding…I enjoy your breakdown of the video thank you!
Kurzgesagt has another video called the "Stellar Drive". It's more upbeat and discusses a solution, how we could avoid such events like close-encounters and being hit by a supernova.
Hey dylan I have a question do you think university is useless or waste of time or money
Good also maybe pull a matrix and dig down where it's warm enough
Speaking of sending probes to Europa, I'd highly recommend watching the movie "Europa Report". It's about a manned mission to Europa, filmed like a found footage documentary. It's great!
I got some bad news about Jupiter, so there's this baldy named Saitama...
Big daddy like jupiter- WHA-
And are they saying in 1 million years from now we would even exist still or not have the technology to obliterate any asteroid or object that comes near us?
This is so far my favorite Kurzgesagt video.
This may be a stupid question for those who know more about this then I do, but - would the opposite be possible? would it be possible for a rogue planet to get caught in the gravity of a sun and become a new member of a solar system?
Yes
They believe there is a planet that is in a massive orbit but every x amount of yrs it comes back threw dont remember exact info but says it was a massive gravity for the planet like Jupiter
If the temperature really dropped as a result of Earth becoming a rogue planet, we could have a lot of fun with superconductivity.
6:46 greetings from Chile btw!
Goodness, that smile thoooughhhhh!
Movie's been done. The Wandering Earth.
Little question that I haven’t managed to find an answer to:
Why when we represent our solar system does every planet asteroid etc are on the same « plane » and why do they all orbit the sun in the same direction ( clockwise or counterclokwise).
Shouldn’t we see planet orbiting « vertically » around the sun relative to us who are apparently orbiting horizontally ( what I mean by that is like we all seem to orbit the sun equator).
I’m not a physicist so I suppose there must be a reason for it but it has always seem strange to see everything that orbit the sun so orderly, all going in the same direction around the sun.
In my mind the solar system should be more like a molecule with electron orbiting like a sphere around it
All objects in the solar system dont orbit the same plane exactly, but mostly do.
Also: Angular Momentum. The suns rotation effects most orbiting objects and get forced into generally the same plane.
Most people don't realize all the stars we can see with our eyes are in our own galaxy.
And we see only very few of them.
I love physics, I like reading, watching and probably the most, thinking about it. Sadly I don't have a degree or even an allowance to study. But I don't need that, all that I need is curisioty and the fact that I will listen more instead of talking. Thank you for your videos, much greeting from germany.
Technically the "2012 Mayan apocalypse" and the "Nibiru" thing were two separate conspiracy theories, but they were commonly combined because conspiracy theories seem to attract each other. And I guess the Nibiru one did get less common after that.
A lot of people believed that the Mayans had predicted a disaster for the year 2012, but there was no such prediction; it was just the Mayan calendar's biggest unit rolling over. (So pretty much exactly the same as predicting that the year 2000 would be special, except dumber because it's not like we had computers running on the Mayan calendar.)
And Nibiru is a piece of pseudoscience made up by a pseudohistorian who can't even read the language of his sources; specifically he claimed that the ancient Sumerians knew about the planets that weren't discovered until modern times as well as one more we still hadn't discovered, and that the undiscovered one had a comet-like orbit. Again, the ideas that it's return would be in 2012 or would bring disaster were tacked on later.
That would be a nice idea for a movie: either earth being shot out of the solar system and the evolution of society, maybe the recolonization of the solar system, If it still was near or the colonization of other planets earth passes.
Pluto laughs and says we're not a planet anymore.
Can you do one with Dyson sphere? I wanted to know if that is really possible?
Ive work in northern canada, worst ive got is -72 with wind chill.
11:20 ENTERPRISE season 1, episode 18 "Rogue Planet"
i would love a list of scifi books that you recommend :D
Especially No War
If the orbit of Neptune change only by 0.1% the whole solar system would become chaotic. See three body problem or N>2 body problem 👍
i'll be really old when that happens
well jupiter did fling things in and out i wonder if earth was actually further out and brought in during jupiters first inwards travel looking at pluto and how much ice id had made me think of this.
I'd be curious to see something on the late heavy bombardment. I take issue with this theory, I'm curious what evidence water excluded that there is for this. It seems like a far-fetched way to get water on this planet and as we have looked at many exoplanets that are orbiting VERY close to their stars who have water, also very incorrect.
the 2012 movie plot is actually not a conspiracy so far fetched. but indeed very many things have to align for it to happen, but than again, many things had to align properly for us to exist and here we are. Also remember that the solid ground we live on is just a fraction of Earth, we are floating practically... Grim!
In theory, an advanced enough civilization on on Earth could, in such a scenario keep the Earth in orbit with the moon or other planet, using it as a rocket to drag earth back
Not sure if the 2012 question was referring to the movie, but the "science" that causes the catastrophy in it actually is a lot more dumb and only briefly touched upon (the movie focuses more about how a survivor group manages to get through and governments prepared or it). Because of an unexplained reason (magic?), the neutrinos from the sun that normally interact rarely with matter start interacting a lot more, causing the earth's mantle to heat up, causing lots of earth-quakes, vulcanism, and in the end tsumanies the size of large mountain ranges all over the planet.
with the mayan callendar, people thought being that their calendar eneded, life would end
Gravity works the way cherios are atracted to eachother by curving the surface of the Milk. Like the Milk or an elastic médium the ether want to resolve the tensión of the curve. This attempt to resolve this tensión is the pull of gravity
Oooh, dude! Watch Europa Report. Interesting film, gave me nightmares! 🌑
11:08
So basically Pitch Black
review their "dyson sphere" -- "stellar engine" -- "cardashev scale" series)
yeah.... I remember it to.. The 2012 phenomenon was a range of eschatological beliefs that cataclysmic or transformative events would occur on or around 21 December 2012...the end of the world....
All from a complete misinterpretation of the end of the Mayan calendar.
the gravity explained as a force is "true" within the Newton Theory approximation. The space-time distortion is within the Relativity Theory. One can talk about it in bath way, you just need to explicitly say in which model you are. the relativity is more precise, but Newton works in lot of situation.
I did not catch it, would the moon follow?
I sometimes think about how much of a nightmare would be to be caught in the middle of boöties void in a spacesuit alone thousands of light years all around of just nothing. That would be freaking terrifying.
Well it wouldn't make any practical different if you were just in between two planets of the solar system.
@@valebliz You could see close stars and objects. Bööties everything is so far you would get mere pen drops of light, barely preceptible to the naked eye, if it's even perceptible at all without powerful telescopes.
there is a story about that - "a pail of air" by fritz leiber. go read it
Everybody let's used the force to get back to the sun if this ever happen 🙃✌
“Dinge erklärt - Kurzgesagt” make fantastic videos and spread an optimistic view into the future.
I don't know. This guy's too handsome to be a physicist.
i think youre talking about planet x, the 9th planet that people think is actually a brown dwarf
Maybe humanity should invest in making something that can detect freezing cold signatures just like how the police can use that tech that shows heat signatures in the helicopter, then maybe we might be able too see more in the universe.
What if there is another planet between mars, earth and venus. And somehow it was tugged out of orbit by a rouge star and jupiter catched that planet. Isn't it a possible reason why a moon would have a liquid water beneath icy surface?
There's a lot of things further out that has more water than earth does, mainly because of how the solar system formed. The outer objects formed with ice/water already on them, while the inner planets got water after they had already formed. Solar winds stripped any of the water away from the inner planets while they were still forming, and it got here later from comets and asteroids