Thank you so much for the critique of my photo. I watch and follow both of you for years and this critique is for me the sing that I learned from you something, thank you for that and for all your effort.
Congratulations, Joanna, you did a great work. Could you please elaborate on your choice of composition? You didn't include the whole tree, but a big section of it. To me, this gives strength to the image, but I'd like to hear from you also, if possible. Thank you. Cheers!
@@cmeluzziI like photos that give me the impresion of some mistery and leave the space for my imagination. Mabye that's why I didn't include whole tree, to leave you with the question :) . But most of the time I just take photo when I tell my self "oh this is it! " I really don't analize to much. But my romantic side of me sees in this picture the birch tree as a Bride wrapped in white tulle :). Best wishes to you Claudio.
Absolutely fantastic. Note the darkest tones of the images are towards the center and the lightest or brightest tones are towards the edge of the picture and it work so well. The transitions are very subtle and the tones soft and relaxing. Beautiful image. With Adam's suggestion I went first with NO NO NO, please don't crop it, such a beautiful image and then suddenly the relationship with the tree behind became obvious. A new perspective, a new interpretation. A bit of separation from the background that I didn't get initially. Equally beautiful in my opinion. Great critic and absolutely stunning picture. Orlando
It's refreshing to hear praise for this fantastic image by two accomplished photographers. We learn as much by hearing what's right with a photo as by hearing what's wrong. Less secure critics would find something to criticize just to prove their expertise. We now know that you don't do that, and that we can trust you to tell us what you really think. Thanks for that!
Beautiful image! Excellent critiques Adam and Alister! Adam, I really found your recommendation on the cropping to really add another perspective to this image. I would never have noticed how that crop would effect the viewing of that image in such an interesting way. Loved it! Thanks for sharing.
A wonderful image from Joanna. It's incredibly interesting to listen to two accomplished photographers critiquing some very good images - in fact,this is what makes these videos so interesting. I was initially concerned about Adam's proposed cropping that I instinctively thought might harm the image. However, I feel he was absolutely correct in bringing some attention to the initially rather faint tree in the rear right, and the end result for me was certainly an improvement in an otherwise lovely image.
Thank you so much for the critique of my photo. I watch and follow both of you for years and this critique is for me the sing that I learned from you something, thank you for that and for all your effort.
Congratulations, Joanna, you did a great work. Could you please elaborate on your choice of composition? You didn't include the whole tree, but a big section of it. To me, this gives strength to the image, but I'd like to hear from you also, if possible. Thank you. Cheers!
@@cmeluzziI like photos that give me the impresion of some mistery and leave the space for my imagination. Mabye that's why I didn't include whole tree, to leave you with the question :) . But most of the time I just take photo when I tell my self "oh this is it! " I really don't analize to much. But my romantic side of me sees in this picture the birch tree as a Bride wrapped in white tulle :). Best wishes to you Claudio.
@@joannatauriel8715 Good to know that, Joanna. Thank you so much for your photo and explanations!
Always a pleasure mate. Looking forward to seeing you soon ❤
Another great critique video from both of you & a stunning photo by Joanna. More of these please guys, we learn so much from them.
Absolutely fantastic. Note the darkest tones of the images are towards the center and the lightest or brightest tones are towards the edge of the picture and it work so well. The transitions are very subtle and the tones soft and relaxing. Beautiful image.
With Adam's suggestion I went first with NO NO NO, please don't crop it, such a beautiful image and then suddenly the relationship with the tree behind became obvious. A new perspective, a new interpretation. A bit of separation from the background that I didn't get initially. Equally beautiful in my opinion. Great critic and absolutely stunning picture.
Orlando
I think the 'static' appearance of the tree in the centre highlights the stillness of winter, when the forest feels very balanced.
This is a great image. I really love the subtle tones and how they just stand out from the snowy background
stunning image... so much to love about it... great critique from both of you
It's refreshing to hear praise for this fantastic image by two accomplished photographers. We learn as much by hearing what's right with a photo as by hearing what's wrong. Less secure critics would find something to criticize just to prove their expertise. We now know that you don't do that, and that we can trust you to tell us what you really think. Thanks for that!
Beautiful image! Excellent critiques Adam and Alister! Adam, I really found your recommendation on the cropping to really add another perspective to this image. I would never have noticed how that crop would effect the viewing of that image in such an interesting way. Loved it! Thanks for sharing.
Excellent review from both of you. I agree the various crop options add a new perspective, while it is also terrific as is.
A wonderful image from Joanna. It's incredibly interesting to listen to two accomplished photographers critiquing some very good images - in fact,this is what makes these videos so interesting.
I was initially concerned about Adam's proposed cropping that I instinctively thought might harm the image. However, I feel he was absolutely correct in bringing some attention to the initially rather faint tree in the rear right, and the end result for me was certainly an improvement in an otherwise lovely image.
These image critique videos with Alister Benn are great. I really learn a lot from them. Great concept. Keep it up!!
I am finding these videos very useful. Thank you. 👍
Brilliant image that I'd be proud to have in my portfolio.
I'd hang that on my wall too, an unexpectedly exciting, luminous image. 😃
I liked the square crop alternative. Great image nonetheless.
A beautiful image, and yes, nigh perfect. Maybe a very supple hit of the blacks slider, just on the tree. What do you think, chaps?
Great series. The only downside is the point that the images are too brilliant to be criticized.
👍👍
Hello everyone, does anyone know how can i submit the pictures??
Plz reply ❤️
Alister masterfully states sentences that mean nothing.