Return to Sender: Can India satisfy the aspirations of its medical student returnees from Ukraine
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 เม.ย. 2022
- The Ukraine crisis exposed us to the world of Indian medical students who are forced to do their MBBS abroad for want of adequate seats. A combination of malpractices by college administrators and creeping reservations have left very few options of higher education for India's middle-class.
#mbbsreturnees #ukrainestudents #medicalstudents
Correction:
MCI, Medical Council of India recognises the medical colleges abroad, not IMA. Bisbo regrets the error
Tutorial video on how to join Bisbo's discord
Discord tutorial video link: • How to join Bisbo Discord
Discord joining link: / discord
Instagram: @gobisbo
Facebook: Bisbo
Twitter: @Bisboworld
Sources
Times of India
NEET hits capitation fee, private medical colleges hike tuition charges; September 28, 2016.
Medical seat scam in Karnataka may have links across India; October 16, 2019
Quota for the rich? 28% of MBBS seats cost over Rs 10 lakh per year in tuition fees; March 7, 2021
NEET could not stop commercialisation of medical education, Anbumani Ramadoss says; June 23, 2021
Deemed universities not following SC, ST, OBC quota rules, says students’ body; July 18, 2021
NMC fee plan for pvt med seats could face challenges; February 28, 2022
Why students from India go abroad to study medicine? March 1, 2022
Why students from India go abroad to study medicine; March 1, 2020
NMC allows fgn med grads to finish internship in India; March 5, 2022
At least 80% of Indians can’t afford private MBBS seat; March 6, 2022
India Express
Long legal battle to preserve CMC Vellore’s admission process ends; Arun Janardhanan; April 30, 2020
The New Indian Express
What drives our students abroad? March 3, 2022.
The Federal
Is NEET driving students abroad to study medicine? March 1, 2022.
NDTV
A 'NEET' Affair: Evolution Of Medical Entrance Exams In This Decade; December 29, 2019
College Dekho
Top 6 Countries for Indian Students to Study MBBS Abroad at Low Cost; March 30, 2022
Stoodnt
MBBS Abroad for Indian Students: Top Countries, Cost and Eligibility; May 10, 2019
PSP Education
Finest Countries to Study MBBS Abroad for Indian Students.
Careers360
NEET Reservation Criteria 2022: EWS, OBC, PWD, SC, ST & Others; March 5, 2022
Hindustan Times
Naveen's death a reflection of NEET's 'shameless face': Kumaraswamy; March 30, 2022
NEET UG 2021 to be held in 11 regional languages; March 30, 2022
The Hindu
Mapped: Distribution of Medical Colleges in India; January 17, 2018
Karnataka medical seat scam: I-T searches reveal undisclosed amount of over ₹402 cr; February 19, 2021
The Telegraph
Take Ukraine-returned students in medical colleges: IMA urges PM; March 30, 2022
The Week
Confusion Galore; Sneha Bhura; Apr 10, 2022
India Today
How successive govts are flunking education budgets, NDA worse; January 31, 2020
27% OBC, 10% EWS reservation in All India Quota for medical education; July 29, 2021
What ails our medical education? Kaushi Deka, Rahul Noronha & Amitabh Srivastva; April 4, 2022
Business Line
Forced into exile; March 4, 2022
Deccan Herald
Naveen's parents urge govt to end medical education mafia, quota system; March 3, 2022
Rediff
'Student life is very good in Ukraine'; March 4, 2022
Times Now
'If medical education policies were right earlier...', PM Modi blames previous govts for Indian students going abroad; March 3, 2022
University World News
Indian medical students fleeing Ukraine demand study places; March 11, 2022
Omkar Medicom
MCI approved and recognised medical colleges in abroad.
/ 1500742687347015683
Why no one talks about reservation and quota sysytem in India?
Despite doing MBBS from top colleges of India (AIIMS), a general category male student from middle class is ELIGIBLE for only 19% of seats even in his home state. (And below 19% in some states, even 0).
81% of seats in medical pg are reserved under caste based reservation, ews reservation and other quotas.
India is extremely bad at valuing merit. All parties just want to increase their votebank by increasing quotas and reservation, leaving a few people hopeless.
NEET is obviously better than older system making it uniform for all from all states.
BUT RESERVATION IS WAY ABOVE 50%
@@toolkit2005 😭😭reservation destroyes lives
Not only reservation but India's population is so huge and medical seats are limited ,huge amount of students compete for mbbs seat and many of them who don't get addmission in india they go abroad , if indians reproduce a little less it will be also good for country
Reservation ruining india
Salute to these FMGs and their parents, they are facing a tough time I almost moved to tears, as it is their lives we're talking about here...
We hear and value your concern, Akhilesh.
Thanks you sir
2:11
A small correction
IMA is an NGO, a body of doctors
It has nothing to do with recognition of medical colleges
It's the NMC (earlier MCI) which does the recognition part
Thanks Vedant. We regret the error. The correction is made in the footnote.
Exactly IMA was actually started by Christian doctors and is not related to gov in any way.
Some of my thoughts you brought in front of everyone thank you @Bisbo.
- Corruption Exists in every field
- General category students suffer in every India's govt exam
- IT jobs saved so many students' life from being unemployed
- Central government job is now a dream for many people who don't know about the loopholes and get trapped by wasting so much time and effort.
- New generation youth are fascinated by other foreign countries and they are already migrating to other countries for degrees and income.
Nice to hear from you, Hrushikesh.
Hi I m writing this Just so that people know my story....
I scored 570 in neet 2019 , state uttar Pradesh, general quota , 95.8 % in 12 boards. I could'nt get a seat in in govt medical college , I missed by 4 marks, went to Ukraine .
So ?..
Not interested
Damn, this video covered a great problem that we are facing as a country, faulty and corrupt medical seats mafia. And it breaks my heart to hear that they taking dowry for the money they spent. Such a shame
NEET is an exam for Rejection rather then Exam for Selection
Someone said education is purely business. And I agree 100% that too old syllabus in engineering colleges and medical students hardly we can find giving good treatment for patients
Unbased Rubbish .crores must be getting treated really well n getting back to routine daily .Its common sense .Do ur research.Some do keep suffering even after trearment but that can happen anywhere .Indian docs r good .Be proud of them
indian doctors/surgeons are good , no doubt about that but the technology they use is outdated and the mode of education upcoming doctors is outdated too ,isn't it !?
@Ishaan Jain which one?
@Ishaan Jain bill pass hua tha na?
( Open +middle class ) category students suffer most.
Thanks to 50% non sense reservation in Govt. Medical Colleges😭
Every improvement becomes a problem in INDIA...... merit basis exams will create whole new set of problems like how the marks of different boards will be compared and on top of that we cannot deny setting in board exams as the ruby rai incident happened in bihar
Do you know even the most brilliant students in Bihar board can't get very high grades because of general marking. Ruby Rai incident was highlighted but there are states in South India and other state boards which give free marks to even their failure students and Andra Pradesh is example of that . Do more research about it
Last year in Punjab , thousands of students got 100 percent marks , even to those who couldn't even write their names properly
There can be more rounds for admission, instead of just one which is exam . In foreign universities student needs to clear multiple round to get an admission like esay on your career, letter of recommendation from your teachers, interview, any extraordinary skill, any national award or Olympiad winner etc is considered.
@@adityarana2897 That'll complicate the things even more in my opinion
@@AlokKumar-uv5co no this will make good engineers/Doctors who really wants to create something in there stead off just making money.
@@adityarana2897 Bad idea. US has this system for all kinds of college education and every body hates it. The indian way is more straightforward and imo, just better.
Hey Bisbo! I'm from Karnataka, yes this news was overshadowed in our region but you made sure to conver many major topics but to be honest it's all over. People are over it and it's the same thing going on!!!
Its sad that We are loosing many talents due to this but situation is still same!!!!
Hi Vignesh. Nice to hear from you. This is the most saddening aspect that issues die down without any solution.
@@BisboWorld there are lot this or information under the tabe, somebody has to face the consequence!! Only then others will blow the whistle and dig deep!!!
Edit: damage is done till then!
Abolish the caste system and quota first... There will be ample seats then...
Caste system already abolished. Time to scrap Reserved seats.
Give scholarship, not Reservation
RESERVATION AND PRIVATE SECTOR ARE MAIN EVIL HERE
Being a general mbbs graduate from Indian government medical college . You should have talked about-
1. A SC/ST students getting same marks is studying in government colleges of India while a general student of similar marks is forced to study in abroad .
2. Only Meritorious should become a doctor - it should never be like that I will become a doctor because I just want to be a doctor and don't want to study. Other students work really hard - this is called COMPETITION.
3. FMGE is not tough if you have completed all 19 subjects successfully .my friends are studying in Ukraine and Russia too - and MOST OF THEM are not serious and only thing they do is partying and not studying seriously as passing exam their is not that tough even they pay some money to pass exams
4. Pre Neet Era was full of malicious activities - black marketing was so high. So neet is obviously the better choice
OC are only 20%,......
By removing reservation there will be only OC developement but not overall India developement
@@ranvijayrao4209 OBC s acquire 40 Percent of total country's population and are enjoying reservation benefits. Better Google and get your facts right first bro.
@@SHUBHAMKUMAR-rz6kk i said oc, not obc
@@ranvijayrao4209 my bad brother
only sc/st are getting reservation? are obc invisible? dumb fcuk
If anyone wants to do a MBBS gets seat then we will have doctors who are not good practionors obviously the ratio of admission needs to improve but not everyone should get seat.
How does neet determine if you are a good practitioner or not?
@@adityachk2002 if you can't dedicated 2 year of your life to study lot less syllabus to Crack neet then how we can belive that you will dedicated 10 years to study every small thing to become a doctor there are people who bought the mbbs seat spending lakhs and crores struggling to complete 1 year and taking 3 to 4 years for it something your want and passion doesn't make up to what it's needed after all it's about literally saving lives
@@VamsiDheeraj not everyone is as privileged to go to coaching coaching centres and crack it
@@adityachk2002 Coaching classes doesn't help in cracking this exams that's just marketing not everyone who pay high fees crack this exams. If you are willing to study with discipline for 2 years you can crack the exam nothing else is important.
@@mayurpujara3250 True that... All that matters for NEET is that we should have strong concepts and self-study and revise repeatedly. Surely those who go to coaching have an advantage but self study is the ultimate practice which no one can escape... The only problem with NEET is it's focus on NCERT (which is actually an advantage too) that is way too different from what state books focus on. This makes it very difficult for village/small town and ultimately poor aspirants.
I think u should also note that many who go to Russia and Ukraine don't even qualify NEET.
And yes fees should decrease but i don't think it'll stop Indians who don't qualify neet to go abroad. And the fact is many who don't qualify neet also go (yes there are many who just miss the cutoff). And they have to clear mci or next their too passing rate is 24 % who only signifies that people going abroad most of them were not qualified to get a seat in India even after considering that India had enough medical seats and less fees.
Abolishing neet is not a good idea. Every medical entrance even of usa uk are multiple choice based and there is more corruption at board based exams. Neet must remain it tests on logical thinking rather than rattofy
And also note the salary of doctors in government its barely basic minimum after dedicating this amount of time in just studying. Rather than increasing only seats government should increase payment of rural doctors.
That are some important points you made, Somesh. Especially regarding rural medical services. Good to hear from you.
@@BisboWorld Keep up the good work❤️
This a great but deeply flawed video. Why is the cost of Medical Education 4 times Ukraine?
I will explain since i work in healtcare. Please note that if NEET removed donations but the results were fee hikes in private medical colleges. Hence the true reason is that it cost ₹300-500 crores to open private medical colleges in India. The reasons is due to irrelevant, onerous and outdated norms set by Medical Council of India (MCI).
Blaming private medical colleges is misleading. They are a product of the system. South Indian states want this to continue because most South Indian medical colleges are owned by politicians
Does it costs less to build a medical college outside india ??
@@ankitsharma4050 .. Outside India, an already profitability running large hospital can be converted to medical college easily. The owner of the hospital just need to construct few new lecture hall etc in a different location in the same city. In those countries, The hospital and academic block for non clinical subjects can be in different campus. But, in India, everything has to be in the same campus. That is why , even though a medical college with 100 MBBS seats needs only 500 beds, many profitably running private hospitals with more than 1000 beds are not able to get converted into medical colleges in India, Because these large private hospitals with more than 1000 beds don't have extra land to construct the lecture halls etc in the same campus. Earlier the minimum area needed for medical college in the same location was 20 acres, now reduced to 5 acres. While a medical college for 100 students needs only 500 beds. But, creating a totally new profitably running hospital with 500 beds in a new location is very difficult. Because most of the hospitals of the new private medical colleges do not have enough patients and are making loss and not profit, this loss making hospitals have to be compensated by taking more fees from students.
Such a harsh and unbelievable reality, Thanks Bisbo for giving limelight for such ignored but important topics
Yeah even I couldn't study medicine as we didn't have 100 Lakhs to splurge on a seat!! Sad 😶
Sad to hear that, Vinit 😐
U can try next year and get good score and can join in govt medical college
I appreciate bisbo bringing the ukraine FMG issue to limelight and I totally agree with the corruption and black market running by the private medical colleges in india..... but NEET has made the seat allocation almost transparent ... the number instutitional or donations seats hav come down ... even they are been allocated through counselling....
There are alot of updates....
I really wonder why people say doing medicine needs alot of money... there are government colleges where u get scholarship and they also provide a free seat... u jus need to make to the list.... not everyone who is passionate can get a seat... u need to work hard and make to the top of list to get a medicine seat....
And people who opt to study abroad are the ones who couldnot make to the merit list becoz of many reasons like reservations.... that doesnot mean u need to buy a seat from private college... u can try another year and get good score and get a free seat...
And there are no unworthy doctors... even rich kids who pay and join in medicine ... hav to work hard in wards and professors in medical colleges will not giv a damn thing whether u r rich or not.... there are very few incidents where doctors who joined through donations killed people ..... all the incidents we here about are fake doctors getting fake degree and practicing...
Bisbo should hav spoken to some medical faternity and get more info regarding the admissions
we have toughest exams in the world but what is the point of having toughest exam when we do not have colleges and education as per international standards ..
Yes bro colleges and schools want international standards so after decade they fill equal
Thanks sources are important, thanks for citing.
Thank you for bringing this story. Issue of these students neds to be heard & resolved.
Indeed 🙏
As always a great presentation by bisbo. Less medical seats and faculty vacancies shld be looked into
You guys cover a problem which remain unseen for most of the people, great job✌🏼✌🏼✌🏼
Thank you for this message 👍🏻
Glad I was able to clear NEET coming from a middle class family...
But to be honest, becoming a doctor for me was purely due to respect and social approval which came with the profession...But gradually I started loving this field..When I see patient's smile after recovery.
Thank you for covering this issue!
Underrated TH-cam for sure
Bisbo, thanking you for bringing in light the untold story of such events happening in India.
Glad to do that 🙏
When will our systems start to function properly. Everything is corrupt and a common mans childrens dreams get shattered due to this inefficiency and greed . Thank you bisbo for bringing this injustice into light.
We hear your concern, Salu.
Bisbo... you're really doing great.. Best Wishes From Our Study family ❤️
It's good that we are getting regular content from bisbo...
Kuddos team you are doing a great job.. ❤️Bisbo
Next we are expecting one video in 3 days😅😅🔥🔥.
Thanks a lot, Vineeth 🌹
We are working on that. Hopefully, we will get to it somtime in future 😊
There are some serious lacunae in our health system that needs to be addressed expeditiously like increasing out of pocket expenditure, most of middle class people outside the health insurance shelter, more private hospitals than public, demand supply gap of doctors and nurses that is well below WHO recommendation etc. Government should increase public spending in social infrastructures like health sector, increase seats in medical colleges, ensure transparency in medical and PG admissions, encourage AYUSH and standardising it to international level etc. Pandemics like COVID is an eye-opener to the crucial role this sector plays in our lives and livvelihoods. We need to explore our demographic dividend, else it could become a demographic burden.
Very well elaborated on government's responsibility
The key fact of the matter is we need to teach the parents that the alphabet of the carrier making does not end at option Group A or Group B its up to Z now... So running behind a career that is highly demanding both in terms of merit and time is not worth for!
Abolishing NEET is not the right option as simply it opens up portals of corruption at state ends. One nation one test is legitimate and acceptable.
Coming to the Ukrain refugees, It's really difficult for NMC to manage them based upon things that it opens up the debate of merit Vs non-merit. One can sympathize but offering them seats is very demanding as it has many legislative angles as well.
Important contradictions you elaborated upon, Dr Maulik. Nice to hear from you.
Great video you always come with a masterpiece 👏🏻
Thank you, Shashank 🙏
@@BisboWorld how many abroad students come to india for practise only 17% . Just see that too .
Yours animations and editing is best from all the videos I have seen till date on TH-cam .
Thanks Himanshu
Thanks bisbo for making vedio on FMG’s ….we FMG’s r always are underrated in the society….
Believe me..As a doctor I am telling you..don't opt for medical..there is absolutely no demand..u will be thrown into villages and surroundead by goons..There is neither respect nor money nor quality of life... I am shocked why ppl r spending to so much to opt a life of misery.. instead invest ur time and money in building complexes..ul be rich and relaxed
We hear your concern, Amit. We do need more n more doctors, though.
@@BisboWorld I agree we need more doctors but who's gonna get their hands dirty? Most PPL who.opt for medical don't know the ground reality..they realise it only later..No offense but it's easy to say we need more doctors sitting in ur studio with AC room in a metro but only doctors know the real pain..earlier atleast they used to get paid well..now it's a thankless job
Much More Awaited & Un Expected Video Very Good Bisbo
Thanks a lot 🙏
You missed one point though many students who are in Ukraine have scored as low as 150/720 in Neet. If they are not tested on returning how can the quality be controlled.
Why can’t the same exam be mandatory for all doctors after finishing mbbs .India is some of the only few countries in the world which doesn’t test a doctors capacity after 5 years of learning. Apart from some privately run university exams riddled with controversy , instead of a proper country wide exam like screening test.
@@Omarmalayail new exit test is coming called NEXT from 2023 which everyone needs to pass to get licence government private and fmgs
@@4yush828 they were talking about a common eligibility test for 50 years, let's see if India deserves capable doctors.
@@Omarmalayail NEXT exam will begin from 2023 compulsory for all graduating doctors national or abroad whoever wishes to practice in India.
good That there is a real national screening exam to know the quality of all doctors .
Nice one Bisbo :)
Big round of Applause 👏🏻👏🏻
Plz make a video on Sri Lanka crisis.
Thanks Rohit. It's coming up next.
Wonder ful to see
Nice video bisbo !
Thanks Aditya
Absolutely true. This is harsh reality.
The pre-NEET era somewhat looks like the European system, where the candidate must pass college-level biology, chemistry, and physics in order to enter medical school.
Post graduation and superspecality degrees are beyond reach of even Middle class and even Doctor parents!!!!
In India their parents will have to pay capitation fees of Rs. 1.5 crores and after that fees of Rs. 50 lakhs. Total cost of becoming a doctor is Rs. 2 crores. Students can become a doctor for 10 percent of that amount in Eastern Europe or Ukraine!
The gap is humongous, Nihal. That's why government decision to lessen fees in some seats of private colleges is welcome move.
@@BisboWorld The irony is that India needs more doctors. Even then they are making it so costly and unaffordable, I can't understand why! On top of that there is so much corruption in the education sector!
@Ishaan Jain why the f*ck you spamming everywhere
@Ishaan Jain The left instinctively opposes everything! As someone said, if the left has a future in India, then India has no future left!
U can get good score and can also join in govt medical college where they charge very nominal fees....
Brilliant Bisbo
🙏
Maybe India can satisfy the aspirations of its medical students but not the parents of medical aspirant's parents, who go to any extent to see their child become a doctor, no matter what the child wants to become.
As they show in 3 idiots, profession is decided at a child's birth.
what I find most interesting is that you people (the ones pitting on Indian students from Ukraine ) in here agree with a student with 140 marks to take a private medical college beacuse of money , but you don't agree on taking in a student scoring 500 and going abroad to pursue MBBS. The main thing which is a cure to the reservations or money or other corruptions in medical field until and unless any change occurs is that do education from Abroad including PG and specialization and then we return to my India and serve the people. Lastly, Abroad education is also very good, I m a student of Ivano Frankisvk National Medical University , Ukraine.
Recently PM Modi has announced that 50 percent of all seats in Private Medical Colleges will enforce governmental fee welcome the step but not only fee we need much more infrastructure on medical occasion, keeping politics aside State and Centre should work collaboratively to show the world How Democracy works professionally everytime. Respect to all Doctors in the entire country who somewhere around working round the clock to help patients!!
Most Politicians own a medical college lets see if that works !
@@RoshanDixit I don't think it will work.
Because It was just announced during Elections😁.Also, as you
pointed out most of private clgs are owned by politicians themselves😂
This is indeed a very hopeful step
bhai , mast analysis kiya
Thanks Sandeep
Wow Bisbo Great Video Bisbo
Contemporary Burning Global Question What's the Future of Ukraine Medical Students No Media focussed on this
I like the video
Thank you 🙏
Similar issue with CPS colleges of physicians and surgeons....post graduate diploma courses after MBBS...they increase the duration of course from one and half year to Two years in 2011; but yet not recognised for secondary DNB and outside maharshtra Gujarat and Rajasthan...
Many aspirants are waiting to complete their secondary DNB ..in respective specialities...post diploma ..
Shameful govt. Last 10yrs Modi did nothing except to make Adani richer.
So bad to hear about Naveen death ; as Bisbo said I also just out from selection because of 1 marks . I’m now study at Ternopil university, Ukraine
"Those that don't make it get return on their investment in the form of dowry during marriage" - that line was just hilarious.
Undoubtedly,
Bisbo possess some nice sense of humour.......
Love from Karnataka ❤️❤️
All FMGs don't represent the poor rural aspirants. If they don't get MBBS, they try for BDS, BAMS, BHMS, BUMS. What happened in Ukraine is terrible. But if you can buy your way to become a doctor your intentions are more inclined towards recovering the money spent abroad than to do public service.
Superb video
Am not sure about all the South Indian states, but in AP and Telangana 10+2 marks are not considered for medicine seat, we have high standard EAMCET exam
What happens to students who come back to India after studies but don't clear the Indian certificate exam? Apart from getting hefty dowry, what do they do to earn a living?
Bisbo, I think you missed elaborating this part.
But overall a great informative video. Well done
They may illegally setup clinics etc, which is dangerous. One such case happened with advance robotics hair transplant center in Chennai India.
Basically you must be careful.
@@zinniadas879 that's wonderful bro 👏👏
Thanks Rahul. Well pointed. A lot of them apparently drop medical careers as well. Many do other things side by side, as they keep giving the FMGE side by side. There are no restrictions on number of attempts.
@@BisboWorld thanks for enlightening Bisbo. It's such a pity that government has been ignoring such a grievous shortage of doctors and not doing anything to enable the overseas educated doctors to start filling the shortages. Afterall they are also well educated and trained. This issue must be taken up by GOI
I know some who join coaching centres for preparation of neet. Some practice abroad. Those whose parents have a nursing home work as manager of their hospital/ clinic and also have respect for being dr.
A good overall video
Although Bisbo should have done research from all aspects of this sensitive topic before making the video
This is not some random topic you just pick up and make a video on
You barely scratched the surface of this issue
This topic deserves an entire series of videos because there are so so many points of view
Thanks for your suggestions, Vedant. We will brainstorm on it.
I love watching bisbo
I myself has faced disadvantage of reservation
I got 97% in boards in class 12 in 2019
But I couldn't make in to good college of du
Whereas my friend with quota get into hansraj in 80s
So yeah reservation sucks
I agree brother 🥲😥😥
But Bisbo's will never talk about it ...
But ur forefathers are guilty so they have right to take reservation...jai bhim
@@jotsingh2595 sarcasm 💀💀💀
@@famousman3714 oof 🌚
The present Government aim is to build 1 medical colleges in each district. Already many new colleges are comming up in North India . The main problem is teaching staff. This could be addressed by recruiting retired teachers of medical colleges on a decent consolidated remuneration and permitting to teach on 3/4 medical colleges.
That's a novel suggestion, Ashok.
Its a god sent opportunity to escape from field of medicine
They shud innovate or do some awesome business
There is nothing left for medicine in india
Being a doctor is a curse here now!!
First of all seen bisbo
Astounding price tag for medical study I must say. No wonder they outside
there's need for doctors. there r plenty who want to become doctors. but this demand and supply never meet.
Surely need to enhance the infrastructure for that
2:17 Indian Medical Association is a group of doctors. It doesn't have ANY AUTHORITY to recognize any institution or anything (not even a toothpaste). It is MEDICAL COUNCIL OF INDIA, now called NATIONAL MEDICAL COUNCIL that recognizes institutions. Please make this correction.
7:35 Distance learning can help with theory, but what about practical learning in medical techniques? They need hands-on training.
@bisbo Please do a proper research. Not satisfied with the way you covered this episode.
FMGE is not tough at all , especially accounting the last 3-4 years.
Lack of transparency in the exam content has been the problem, Avneesh
@@BisboWorld yes sir you're right. At least the paper or answer key or the candidate's response. Right now none of this has any kind of transparency
BISBO Kindly make a narration on MD Vs DNB and the stepmother love on DNB course by Government
Before, neet atleast even after paying donation the fees were on cheaper side for the private colleges back then.
There are also management seat in the Government Medical College in Rajasthan government is taking donation and giving admission to the nonmeritourious students
If you want to survive in this country means, you need to born as SC/ST. You will easily get govt jobs, and less fees for all the courses, you can file sc st gang war case on anybody who fights with you...and many moreee....so pray to god, so that you will be an SC in this country!
No need to do internship after passing fmge for graduates of philippines and also its not easy to took admission in philippines because they also have entrance exam which have to be cleared before admission in medical colleges there, the exam is called as NMAT (National Medical Admission Test)
Hello Bisbo.
I appreciate your content a lot.
Big fan of your channel 🙌 ✌
I m from Assam [Bodoland]
Would you plz 🙏 consider putting up a content of our legal Demands of Bodoland?
Expecting a positive reply from Bisbo🤞
Thanks for your suggestion. We will think about it.
When this video will upload in other bisbo language channels
Reservations for economically backward can be understood...but reservation based on birth religion...is ridiculous!!!
2nd before refresh 🥳
We want to remove reservation system slowly in services sector
Like ca
This is old news! The number of doctors and seats in India has risen sharply in the recent times! The system shouldnt get saturated like engineering and rather look to improve quality than quantity!
Both should probably be improved even further, Anubhab
Nice
17:16 what a voice over! 😂 😂 A moment of laughter in between the serious issue!
Thanks Tenzin 😉
Please remove reservation for these dirty SC/ST, bcz of them...many topper GM category students are droping their dream of becoming doctor :(
Instead of having 25 lakh engineering seats in india where demand is low supply is high we should have atleast 5 lakh medical seats in india by 2022 instead of 1.5 lakh only
Seats need to be increased in a big way, indeed.
Just highlight why the difference in fees. What are the difference in norms to run a medical school in India versus these countries. Do a study and you ll see huge difference. Land to building to faculty requirements in India is huge compared to these countries. That's the only reason India has less colleges and it's that expensive. Nothing else.
So just dilute the norms. Then immediately number of colleges and seats will shoot up exponentially. That can be done for almost all programs. But then only numbers won't mean actual quality. A different problem will come up.
this is only short term crisis may be 2-3 yrs lost but the more serious issue is annually lacs of foreign university Doctor fails to pass Indian Medical exam .....they have sent 5-6 yrs in foreign and 20-30 lacs still unable to call themselves registered Doctor in India
Here's a real story than even belittle my success. I've passed MBBS and my friend too. I'm not naming him but here's his struggle. His mother expired and father used to drink when he was in 10th. Didn't even had a pakka house. He lived in a jhopda that has grass coverings. He worked on a pharmacy and cloth store for a mere 2000 a month just to survive. Seeing his condition, coaching teachers forgave his fees. Cracked NEET and still worked as a pharmacy boy to survive. Passed MBBS with marks more than me. Worked as a medical officer for a year and then built a pakka house. Did any of you who flied to Ukraine by paying lakhs of fees deserve more than him? Another story, we used to voluntarily teach on a periodic basis for tribal students in Melghat Maharashtra. It was a collective effort of the collector in that region. That year 3 students cracked NEET , did anyone who didn't qualified deserve more than them? The race is same for everyone, just so you had a backup plan and it failed deserve a seat? Ask yourself would you have reattempt that exam and studying another year? IAS has only 180 seats, people spend 10 years chasing it. Just so medical education has commercialised you can't claim it. It's the fault of politicians with black money and lack of seats. There's no easy way. I respect every FMGE with few have worked with myself. After MBBS too, it's my third attempt for PG seat, I can't afford private seat and there's no other way. Hope you got my point.
I don't think indian government is ever going to do anything about unemployment unless and until there is some kind of elections
Key to success is just move out of this country and help the Indian economy from outside
These corrupt politicians made thier sons and daughters chairmen and CEOs of big organisations by using our money
Bisbo pls do one on Vyapam scandal. Our request. Thanks
Population. Reservation. Corruption. Biggest problems in our country
Please make a video on caste reservation in college seats
Make video on job corruption that continually happened in every govt presents, ..
U did what tv9 and other kannada news did not do, I did not know this before
Glad to know, Aniketh. Thanks.
The Ukrainian parents had the money to send their children atleast to Ukraine for MBBS. If goverment gives them MBBS seats, it'll be injustice to those people who completely left the dream of becoming a doctor because they couldn't afford even Ukraine.
Also, having not enough seat for everyone who wants to be a doctor isn't a nation's problem because who doesn't want to be a doctor? But the country will fail if everyone wants to become a doctor is given an MBBS.
+1
Satheesh, as you point out, the country does fail when youth are not able to become doctors, just because they can't afford it.
@@BisboWorld eligibility should also be considered it's not like everyone who wants to become doctor should be made into doctor, compatibility is the main isssue we want good doctors not many doctors. Seats should increase fees should decrease that's all right but that will NOT stop illegible students to go abroad to become doctors. If only 24 % pass fmge it only implies that 76 percent were not compatible or elligible to be doctors then too they went. So yes people who just miss the cut off deserve to get a seat which are increasing drastically in this era. But who don't even qualify neet should not go because they don't know what they are getting intoo if u can't score 360 in neet ug how will u pass the fmge or next. You'll be wasting ur time and money. Plus government should increase seats upto 1000/1 ratio only. We don't want doctors to become next engineers just the numbers no quality. That is a uniform neet is essential to level up uniformity. People have taken a tremendous interest in this topic recently but they should also note that many who go abroad to Russia and Ukraine do not qualify mci screening or fmge and yes intership is necessary after clearing as scenario in Indian health care and russian / ukrain is two different worlds.
It's human life ur playing with so compatibility and eligibility is of utmost importance
Reservation is still the biggest hurdle and obstacles for many students of general category whose parents don't have more money.
quota system is really bad 😢😢
Can you make a video on situation of China return students...who are still here for more than 2 years
We will think about this as a separate topic, Abhisek.