December video will be me following through with a promise I made back in the Q&A, January will (fingers crossed) be Collins, then Mannerheim for February-March. Have a wonderful day :)
Fun fact: Makhno was known to frequently cross- dress as a disguise, a talent he picked up during his youth in the theatre. *He may well have been the world's first femboy theatre kid.*
Fun fact: The flag most commonly associated with the Free Territory (56:27) actually belonged to the forces of the Ukrainian insurgent Svyryd Kotsur, but Zelman Ostrovsky (russian author) attributed it to Nestor Makhno. When asked about it, Makhno said something like "these guys are not anarchists"
Fun fact: My Mennonite grandparents were born in the Mennonite settlements in Zaporizhzhia. They didn't have a good opinion of anarchists. They were better than the Bolsheviks though, who executed my great grandfather under false pretenses. Until recently, we thought he was sent to the gulags, but the records were found somewhat recently.
Fun fact: Makhno was known to frequently cross- dress as a disguise, a talent he picked up during his youth in the theatre. *He may well have been the world's first femboy theatre kid.*
@@erdood3235 Yeah, I'm not sure. I heard this from some other video and haven't found other sources (although the video did provide some citations). There was a wealthier family that took him in for a while, though.
She was the truck stop bathroom's favorite attraction aside from the cigarette machines and urinals. I'd defo wanna get Maurie on them paternal DNA analyses for the children, as they love fighting each other more than anything.
@@fredizgredi All forms of anarchism have a non-traditional economy due to their decentralized nature so it's incomparable to capitalist statistics and analysis of a statist economy.
Something bizarre I've noticed, is that I've seen someone from just about every corner of the political spectrum who likes or at least respects Makhno. Of course you have the libertarian socialists who like him for obvious reasons, a few weeks ago I saw a video from an unironic anarcho-capitalist praising him and the Makhnovschina... but I've also met an edgelord Catholic nationalist (who was perhaps a bit too friendly to Mussolini) who liked Makhno, as well as a pro-Russian guy who otherwise hates Ukraine but loves Makhno and the other anarchists, notably Shchus. The only ideological grouping I don't think I've directly seen someone from that likes Makhno is authoritarian leftists, but I don't doubt there's at least one auth-left who likes Makhno. A true testament to this guy's charisma, I guess
@@Steelytheanarchist The only reason I dislike him is because of the terrible mistake he made by not allying with pro-Ukrainian powers against the reds. He realized it a little too late, and thus was defeated. Along with the rest of Ukraine…
@alekshukhevych2644 for sure. I totally agree with you there. But that mistake doesn't go onto his hat mostly since those decisions were made democractically. Sadly enough the people chose very fucking wrong.
Fun fact: Makhno was known to frequently cross- dress as a disguise, a talent he picked up during his youth in the theatre. *He may well have been the world's first femboy theatre kid.*
_Rhetoric: Hey, psst--Word on the street is you're ready to start building _*_anarchism_*_ again!_ Mahkno: "Again"? _Rhetoric: Yes - you're ready to start building anarchism _*_again._*_ You've built it before, _*_they've_*_ built it before. Hasn't really worked out yet, but neither has _*_love_*_ - should we just stop building love, too?_
Makhno's mistakes boiled down to "he trusted this guy that was known for being an asshole because he had no choice and said guy burned a village to the ground."
Genuinely wanted to cry by the end of the video. It's really bittersweet to see the many various dreams and desires of countless men and women, for a better living liberated from the bleak mundanity and endless toil that burdened their lives, thrusted upon a nation in a time of horrific, turmoil, the unimaginable strife of countless men who were really just lost in a certain time and place, trying to endure a chaotic time of political chaos, and eventually a bloody free-for-all, only for random chance to pick out one of the many of these random, then ignored, now forgotten masses, to have had been, if for just a moment, a living symbol of sincere hope and perseverance for all of them, people having been not much unlike him, and which had even made the privileged autocrats and juntas of the lands beyond tremble before his image, all before ultimately ending up back to being an irrelevant, impoverished nobody, having to live out the rest of his life in the same plight, the same pit of desperation and poverty that he had once broken himself out of, along with the many oppressed peasants just like him, who had fought alongside him. At the end of the day, the many acts of sheer will, bravery, determination, and inevitable sacrifice, in spite of any and all odds of probable failure and defeat, from both him, and the many individuals in this period, and across time in general, both remembered and lost to history, often never even recognizing the impacts they would have made in their lives, and the world they would have helped to shape, merely stood in faith; the faith for a better world, created without subjugation, without any unjust authority, or oppression, was built for the happiness of all mankind, everwhere. That ideal of progress and liberty, of equality, and reason, shared throughout the long struggles of many generations across the many peoples of the earth before us, have left their mark forever, and which had reached their children far beyond what they could have ever imagined, their collective efforts, in spite of many of their lives having been believed by many in the present to have been failures or meaningless footnotes, if remembered at all; still impact us even today, their small impacts, their countless projects, their triumphs and indeed their moments of failiure, have brought their many future generations a never ceasing inferno of light seen by all the fighters of today who challenge any and all unjustified forms of oppression, that which would beam throughout the earth, to the many currently forgotten and mistreated of the world, and who would one day complete the fight of their ancestors before them had started, a light which no dark any storm brought by any autocrat or oligarchy, no matter how absolute the power, the draconian might of any self-serving despot, or dictator, could ever hope to truly blot out forever. Makhno, for all of his individual failings, as was true for all of us then, as much as now, was without the slightest bit of doubt, a true father to all of those who looked up to him, and an equally true grandfather for all of the freedom fighters, rebels, and partisans who still fights injustice and despotism everywhere in his name, and for it, has been memorialized in my eyes as a certified kin-... um... individual of non-hierarchical power and justified, horizontal authority! 🏴
the horror is that's still an empty place in English-speaking Internet segment, despite Ukrainian soldiers love battle-girls and death-girls arts, and Ukrainian society literally names war boys as "our tommy-cats" (наші котики), so to be more succeeded in your searches, you'd better to use English-Ukraine translator...
I remember an anarchist friend of mine relating the story you opened the video with to me back when I was but an ignorant liberal in 2002 and it moved me. Anarchism needs more heroes like Makhno to inspire the sort of bravery and connection to the world within your sphere of influence it takes to change fate.
Novatore, Baukunin, Jules Bonnot....the early american individualist anarchists....there's a few, yet none of them should be sympathetic to socialism and the like. Can't recommend Novatore enough.
Clicked on the video and it just kept going. Expected maybe a 10 minute or 15 minute video then eventually i noticed it was a whole hour. Never subbed so fast
@nickgotvyak5890 best bet is with fire n sword, already got eastern europe as a setting and some firearms, it would genuinely surprise me if the mod community hasn't made a 1910's total conversion
@@ЕгорТрегубов-щ8ю «Я поразился этому требованию, но делать было нечего. И я, не владея СВОИМ РОДНЫМ УКРАИНСКИМ ЯЗЫКОМ, принужденно должен был уродовать его так, в своих обращениях к окружавшим меня, что становилось стыдно…"
@@ЕгорТрегубов-щ8ю Он никогда не считал себя русским, даже при разговоре с Ленином ему было неприятно что тот называл Украину югом России, читай воспоминания Махно
tbf, if you go into it, with more peaceful methods, like makhno did, it is much easier to occupy a country. Also it can't really be called occupation, as the Makhnoists were Ukrainian and it was more of a liberation. I guess the people there were willing to accept anyone, who was against the status quo.
A couple of factoids: - the scar along his jaw is not from a sabre but from a bullet that hit him from the back in his final pursuit to the Romanian border - my sister has a friend who claims to be Makhno's distant relative (a fact that his family kept in secret during soviet times). I don't know if it's true but his appearance really checks out (no gorgeous hair tho)
Based Ukrainian Jack Sparrow, inventor of the drive by, iconic drag queen, killer of oligarchs. Perhaps the most based man in history… aside from John Brown obviously.
Makhno cant have any rest, even his statue being constantly attacked by his enemies! Damn i am completely mind blown by this story. This single man by the age of 44 had done more for the freedom of the worker than every communist in my country usually does in their life time.. i hava to become a better activist.
You should make a video about Maurice Duplessis, you did promise it in the video about Adrien Arcand. Plus, I think machine politics is very interesting.
@@wasmachichhier1514 I mean he was pretty anti-jedi, and in Legends lore he was a tribal warlord before being picked up by Dooku. I would say that it is fair to point that out though since he's not particularly anti-state. My main point was that he just has some funny similarities which I assume was never intended, but amuses me nonetheless.
@wasmachichhier1514 anti-establisment would probably fit better, he hated the republic for legitimate evils they committed, but he was a warlord fighting for the CIS so certainly pro-state
Maybe Makhno was not Napleon or Alexander. But the looks of it, he was the best commander on the field in the Civil War, and seemly less bloody when it comes to war crimes.
Let's be honest, as soon as you started this series on the Ukrainian War of Independence we have all been waiting for our Based Anarchist Boy. Mother Anarchy loves her sons!
That is hilariously ironic that a man who hated nationalism and nations as a whole being held as a symbol of Ukrainian resistance and nationalism and that’s based
I would argue that yes he wouldnt really like it being used as a nationalist symbol but in the face of this conflict based on Imperialism, opression and lies vs Ukraine, he would most likely not protest much. But of course he would do some shitfucks here and there on both sides :troll:
A guy stopped me this morning n asked me if i was a soldier in maknos army, cuz i wear a budenovka with a skull n bones on it during winter. It caught me so off-guard cuz its not something you expect to hear at a gas station in Detroit at 9am. Stay frosty out there boys!
Been binge watching your videos. Thank you for this temporary wrap up of the Russian Civil War (of which Ukraine ended up unfortunately dying from) with Nestor Makhno!! Keep up the great work!!
SPARTAN RETURNS! Side note: I have a job now, and also a major future plan - if things here in Canada (or, at least, here in the shithole that is Alberta) get particularly, then I'm making a beeline for an Australian city within the next 10 years (not sure which one yet tho... gotta get that figured out). In anticipation of this, I wonder if there's any Australians who are worthy of a video on this channel?
Dude went from Grunt, Commissar during WWII, First Secretary of the Ukrainian Communist Party after WWII, then holding both of the most powerful titles in the Soviet Union of "Premier of the Soviet Union" and "First Secretary of the USSR" respectively.
Coincidentally, the rich landlord and his privileged sons who radicalized Makhno as a youth by beating their farmhand were Mennonites. Not something I was told as a half-ethnic-Mennonite kid, but Mennonite historians have started talking about it over the past few years. (They've also started talking about the very uncomfortable history of Mennonites in WW2, which is a whole 'nother thing.)
2:41 damn big relatable; probably explains why I fell in love and married a girl/woman with dead parent(s)/siblings/everyone and been with her ever since--I can certainly imagine how it influenced Mahkno for sure
I always though that nationalism and thigh highs goes hand in hand, just like HOI4 or being into computers. But it was never as wild as this. But on a serious note, its a monumental video. Definetely more than i'v learned in russian history classes.
For some reason we've bought into the lie that change can be achieved within the ruleset of the establishment, that our masters will give us an out if we were to just keep begging We will never win abiding by the game we are given, the bourgeoisie only play in blood and only blood can drown them.
I heard about Makhno a while ago, and since discovering your channel I was excited to see you cover him. You did history justice, and my respect for him only increased since seeing this video. It's strange identifying with someone who you disagree with ideologically, but respect enough you wish they were more successful, despite the fact they've been dead for 90 years.
December video will be me following through with a promise I made back in the Q&A, January will (fingers crossed) be Collins, then Mannerheim for February-March. Have a wonderful day :)
Fun fact: Makhno was known to frequently cross- dress as a disguise, a talent he picked up during his youth in the theatre. *He may well have been the world's first femboy theatre kid.*
Thank You! Great video. As always, next level content.
can you do some more of the requests from the Q&A after that, or are there other plans for that point?
Hey, can you do one for Ernst Junger and Peter Kemp? 👍
Please make a video about Stepan Bandera
never clicked on a notification so fast i feel like an alcoholic being given a surprise casket of wine for christmas
REAL
Cask? Hope you stay out of the catacombs….
Only Russia and Ukraine are able to make Warhammer look like a Telettubies' setting.
Russia + Eastern Europe + The Balkans is indeed the Mallus of our reality.
those lands are watered with blood
Fr like how many groups and fucking wars broke out during this time like it makes game of thrones look like a dr sues novel
@@maxtinosl7545 i blame gopnik squatting for the tragedies in those regions.
Its funny even "Anarchy's Finest Son" is still a failure.
Fun fact: The flag most commonly associated with the Free Territory (56:27) actually belonged to the forces of the Ukrainian insurgent Svyryd Kotsur, but Zelman Ostrovsky (russian author) attributed it to Nestor Makhno. When asked about it, Makhno said something like "these guys are not anarchists"
Once again Russians cement their eternal hegemony even in spirit over uKKKrainians
well what kind of flag did he use then
@universe8607 Plain Black and Red flags, sometimes with Anarchist phrases on then
@@universe8607 an anarchist society doesnt need an official flag... that's kinda the point.
@@marxistvalorie not using any standardised means of identification during a multi-sided civil war is not a good idea
Fun fact: My uncle was a member of the 1st Donetsk Corps, and fought at both Dibrivka and Peregonovka 🎉
Great uncle* I should put emphasis on that
@@DonetskChildrenBidenBombaI was gonna say, damn how old are you?! Lol
@@audiosurfarchivelmao
So fucking based
Fun fact: My Mennonite grandparents were born in the Mennonite settlements in Zaporizhzhia. They didn't have a good opinion of anarchists. They were better than the Bolsheviks though, who executed my great grandfather under false pretenses. Until recently, we thought he was sent to the gulags, but the records were found somewhat recently.
Fun fact: Makhno was known to frequently cross- dress as a disguise, a talent he picked up during his youth in the theatre. *He may well have been the world's first femboy theatre kid.*
A friend asked how was he in the theater if he was from poor background
based and redpilled
@@erdood3235 Yeah, I'm not sure. I heard this from some other video and haven't found other sources (although the video did provide some citations). There was a wealthier family that took him in for a while, though.
Well, that's a disappointment.
Anarchist femboy theatre kid
This guy isn’t as talked about as he should be. Definitely one of the most interesting people in history. Thanks for making a video on him.
Agry, he was a fenomen
Especially in this day and age, what with our capitalist healthcare systems and state-sanctioned and supported mega-exploiters like Bezos and Musk.
According to who? Why don't you do something about it instead of waiting for others? You don't need permission to do things in life.
Mother anarchy sure has a lot of children. Wonder if they all share the same father?
She was the truck stop bathroom's favorite attraction aside from the cigarette machines and urinals. I'd defo wanna get Maurie on them paternal DNA analyses for the children, as they love fighting each other more than anything.
mother anarchy is a really generous woman
Nah mother Anarchy is a chad with a male harem.
@chestnut4860 based™
@chestnut4860 Sounds gay.
Fun Fact: During the Second World War, there was a attempt at restoring Anarchism in Ukraine between 1942 - 43 called "Green Guard of Ukraine" 1:03:54
I also believe he should do a video about the Ukrainian Insurgent Army!
anarchy is as good as economy of burundi
@@fredizgredi All forms of anarchism have a non-traditional economy due to their decentralized nature so it's incomparable to capitalist statistics and analysis of a statist economy.
Least fascist anarchist movement
@@realworld7049 all for the commune, non againt the commune , all towards the commune
Something bizarre I've noticed, is that I've seen someone from just about every corner of the political spectrum who likes or at least respects Makhno. Of course you have the libertarian socialists who like him for obvious reasons, a few weeks ago I saw a video from an unironic anarcho-capitalist praising him and the Makhnovschina... but I've also met an edgelord Catholic nationalist (who was perhaps a bit too friendly to Mussolini) who liked Makhno, as well as a pro-Russian guy who otherwise hates Ukraine but loves Makhno and the other anarchists, notably Shchus. The only ideological grouping I don't think I've directly seen someone from that likes Makhno is authoritarian leftists, but I don't doubt there's at least one auth-left who likes Makhno. A true testament to this guy's charisma, I guess
Ultimate Based Radical Centrist Status: ***Liked by every political group***
Makes sense since he’s (ironically) become a symbol of nationalism in Ukraine
These people you've "met" are they just politics fags on internet?
Yeah that would be me I guess the auth-left guy.
I think it’s partially because people are impressed by his ability to pull it off
Ah yes Makhno. They could never make me hate you.
@@Steelytheanarchist The only reason I dislike him is because of the terrible mistake he made by not allying with pro-Ukrainian powers against the reds. He realized it a little too late, and thus was defeated. Along with the rest of Ukraine…
@alekshukhevych2644 for sure. I totally agree with you there. But that mistake doesn't go onto his hat mostly since those decisions were made democractically. Sadly enough the people chose very fucking wrong.
@@Steelytheanarchist "I've said it before and i'll say it again; democracy simply doesn't work"
@@ADHDisYippeeeeeeeeee democracy especially a direct one can work. Yet it is not without it's errors. This was a big time one
@@Steelytheanarchist No i'm with you, I just felt like quoting the simpsons
I clicked this SO QUICK
Anarchy momma loves her sons!
Fun fact: Makhno was known to frequently cross- dress as a disguise, a talent he picked up during his youth in the theatre. *He may well have been the world's first femboy theatre kid.*
A
Well that’s good, because your mother doesn’t love you
@@nikoclesceri2267eat a**
@@nikoclesceri2267 cope and seethe reactionary
_Rhetoric: Hey, psst--Word on the street is you're ready to start building _*_anarchism_*_ again!_
Mahkno: "Again"?
_Rhetoric: Yes - you're ready to start building anarchism _*_again._*_ You've built it before, _*_they've_*_ built it before. Hasn't really worked out yet, but neither has _*_love_*_ - should we just stop building love, too?_
[Thought Gained:
Makhnovian Socio-Economics]
@@MRPR My man. Absolute brilliant followup, especially given what the name they went with was.
Sweet fuck this was inspired
@denizmergen418
LOGIC [Easy: Success] - Mazov and Makhnov sound almost _too_ alike. Are we sure we are not talking about the same man?
Makhno's mistakes boiled down to "he trusted this guy that was known for being an asshole because he had no choice and said guy burned a village to the ground."
Genuinely wanted to cry by the end of the video.
It's really bittersweet to see the many various dreams and desires of countless men and women, for a better living liberated from the bleak mundanity and endless toil that burdened their lives, thrusted upon a nation in a time of horrific, turmoil, the unimaginable strife of countless men who were really just lost in a certain time and place, trying to endure a chaotic time of political chaos, and eventually a bloody free-for-all, only for random chance to pick out one of the many of these random, then ignored, now forgotten masses, to have had been, if for just a moment, a living symbol of sincere hope and perseverance for all of them, people having been not much unlike him, and which had even made the privileged autocrats and juntas of the lands beyond tremble before his image, all before ultimately ending up back to being an irrelevant, impoverished nobody, having to live out the rest of his life in the same plight, the same pit of desperation and poverty that he had once broken himself out of, along with the many oppressed peasants just like him, who had fought alongside him.
At the end of the day, the many acts of sheer will, bravery, determination, and inevitable sacrifice, in spite of any and all odds of probable failure and defeat, from both him, and the many individuals in this period, and across time in general, both remembered and lost to history, often never even recognizing the impacts they would have made in their lives, and the world they would have helped to shape, merely stood in faith; the faith for a better world, created without subjugation, without any unjust authority, or oppression, was built for the happiness of all mankind, everwhere.
That ideal of progress and liberty, of equality, and reason, shared throughout the long struggles of many generations across the many peoples of the earth before us, have left their mark forever, and which had reached their children far beyond what they could have ever imagined, their collective efforts, in spite of many of their lives having been believed by many in the present to have been failures or meaningless footnotes, if remembered at all; still impact us even today, their small impacts, their countless projects, their triumphs and indeed their moments of failiure, have brought their many future generations a never ceasing inferno of light seen by all the fighters of today who challenge any and all unjustified forms of oppression, that which would beam throughout the earth, to the many currently forgotten and mistreated of the world, and who would one day complete the fight of their ancestors before them had started, a light which no dark any storm brought by any autocrat or oligarchy, no matter how absolute the power, the draconian might of any self-serving despot, or dictator, could ever hope to truly blot out forever.
Makhno, for all of his individual failings, as was true for all of us then, as much as now, was without the slightest bit of doubt, a true father to all of those who looked up to him, and an equally true grandfather for all of the freedom fighters, rebels, and partisans who still fights injustice and despotism everywhere in his name, and for it, has been memorialized in my eyes as a certified kin-... um... individual of non-hierarchical power and justified, horizontal authority! 🏴
Average leftist meme
Silence idealist
You are mentally hill, seek help
Where do you live? What country? And when were you diagnosed as being on the spectrum?
@@DiamorphineDeath Not doxing myself but yes
Cossack catgirl gf... You know what? You make a compelling argument to start searching through some artist's right now...
the horror is that's still an empty place in English-speaking Internet segment, despite Ukrainian soldiers love battle-girls and death-girls arts, and Ukrainian society literally names war boys as "our tommy-cats" (наші котики), so to be more succeeded in your searches, you'd better to use English-Ukraine translator...
I remember an anarchist friend of mine relating the story you opened the video with to me back when I was but an ignorant liberal in 2002 and it moved me. Anarchism needs more heroes like Makhno to inspire the sort of bravery and connection to the world within your sphere of influence it takes to change fate.
Novatore, Baukunin, Jules Bonnot....the early american individualist anarchists....there's a few, yet none of them should be sympathetic to socialism and the like. Can't recommend Novatore enough.
Clicked on the video and it just kept going. Expected maybe a 10 minute or 15 minute video then eventually i noticed it was a whole hour. Never subbed so fast
Dude's life was j some guy's first mount & blade campaign irl
Unironically would play a mod like this
@nickgotvyak5890 best bet is with fire n sword, already got eastern europe as a setting and some firearms, it would genuinely surprise me if the mod community hasn't made a 1910's total conversion
@alasdairbell4354 fire and sword is for the first one, I might look up if bannerlord got any tho
I'm pretty sure there was mod for the first m&b. Maybe for warband too
Ukrainian Tyler Durden
Он считал себя русским .
@@ЕгорТрегубов-щ8ю «Я поразился этому требованию, но делать было нечего. И я, не владея СВОИМ РОДНЫМ УКРАИНСКИМ ЯЗЫКОМ, принужденно должен был уродовать его так, в своих обращениях к окружавшим меня, что становилось стыдно…"
@@besconst источник цитаты ?
@@ЕгорТрегубов-щ8ю Махно Н.И. Воспоминания. Т. II, III, С. 94, 29.
@@ЕгорТрегубов-щ8ю Он никогда не считал себя русским, даже при разговоре с Ленином ему было неприятно что тот называл Украину югом России, читай воспоминания Махно
Amazing Channel. WHERE HAVE YOU BEEN… WHY AM I NOW FINDING YOU!? Looking forward to seeing what you do next and thank you for sharing this!
Hello from Zaporizhzhia :)
This guy's video titles always go so hard🙏🏾
BASED TIMES... where does he show up on the wrestler tierlist?
I think a solid C. He's got the character but his health issues would limit his physical abilities imo
Good to see you again
1:30 most accurate representation of who Makhno was really
35:00 I love how literal anarchists managed to occupy more of ukraine than current day russia did
tbf, if you go into it, with more peaceful methods, like makhno did, it is much easier to occupy a country. Also it can't really be called occupation, as the Makhnoists were Ukrainian and it was more of a liberation. I guess the people there were willing to accept anyone, who was against the status quo.
You gotta make a video about Thomas Sankara
YES
Right before my shift at work! Thank you dude!
"Anarchofemboyism is real. You must suffer with this knowledge."
No, I refuse to accept reality (cringe) and replace it with my own delusions (based).
Based
Anarchofemboyism is as based as you get tho
Based
We women need to stop having children as soon as possible.
If you need any help for a deep dive into anarchist history and ideology please reach out! It’s one of the few things I feel qualified to talk about
A couple of factoids:
- the scar along his jaw is not from a sabre but from a bullet that hit him from the back in his final pursuit to the Romanian border
- my sister has a friend who claims to be Makhno's distant relative (a fact that his family kept in secret during soviet times). I don't know if it's true but his appearance really checks out (no gorgeous hair tho)
Just when I thought my weekend couldn’t be any better.
Two things:
1: They didn't use the skull flag
2: They didn't call it the free territory(ies)
ANARKHIYA-MAMA, ZA NAS!
Belaya armiya, chornyy baron
Snova gotovyat nam tsarskiy tron
No ot taygi do britanskikh morey
Krasnaya Armiya vsekh sil'ney!
@@realworld7049 except it sucked more impressive then Sasha Grey in her best)))
i read the caption underneath kropotkin as "legendary bread haver" and that too would have been correct
FINALLY!!!
Based Ukrainian Jack Sparrow, inventor of the drive by, iconic drag queen, killer of oligarchs.
Perhaps the most based man in history… aside from John Brown obviously.
I’m Nestor Makhno, and I approve this message.
this video is incredible! thanks for the work and study
Makhno cant have any rest, even his statue being constantly attacked by his enemies! Damn i am completely mind blown by this story. This single man by the age of 44 had done more for the freedom of the worker than every communist in my country usually does in their life time.. i hava to become a better activist.
You should cover william joyce.
You should make a video about Maurice Duplessis, you did promise it in the video about Adrien Arcand. Plus, I think machine politics is very interesting.
The lesson of so many of your videos is dont trust reds
So, the lesson of Joseph McCarthy then?
That opens up a lot of loopholes...
@@theotherohlourdespadua1131 what do you mean by htis
Wait a minute, anti state, chronic respiratory issues, Eastern European accent, leads a major rebel army… was this man just IRL General Grievous?!?
Since when was grevious anti state i mean the seperatiste did Form a top down from of Gouvernement so it was a state
@@wasmachichhier1514 I mean he was pretty anti-jedi, and in Legends lore he was a tribal warlord before being picked up by Dooku. I would say that it is fair to point that out though since he's not particularly anti-state. My main point was that he just has some funny similarities which I assume was never intended, but amuses me nonetheless.
@wasmachichhier1514 anti-establisment would probably fit better, he hated the republic for legitimate evils they committed, but he was a warlord fighting for the CIS so certainly pro-state
7:55 anarcho capitalism is basically a joke.
Anarchism is basically a joke
Make sure to tell that to the ancaps. They'll reward you with a free helicopter ride.
40:55 My city mentioned! Faith in humanity restored
Maybe Makhno was not Napleon or Alexander. But the looks of it, he was the best commander on the field in the Civil War, and seemly less bloody when it comes to war crimes.
Let's be honest, as soon as you started this series on the Ukrainian War of Independence we have all been waiting for our Based Anarchist Boy.
Mother Anarchy loves her sons!
44:05 Ovseenko, Trotsky, gde suka boepripasi?
Wouldn't it be really funny to see an Antonin Artaud episode drop?
“Wake up, Spartan just dropped a new video” 🗣️🔥
That is hilariously ironic that a man who hated nationalism and nations as a whole being held as a symbol of Ukrainian resistance and nationalism and that’s based
If there's one unifying ideology I Ukraine- it's anarchism
@@micindir4213 эм нет анархизм наоборот выступает против нации как Махно так то против унр воевал и ненавидел Петлюра.
@@ЕгорТрегубов-щ8ю повіяло російським лайном: звідки ти надибав фублів на впн?))
All the anarchist comrades shall unite here, we shall make our stand here at this video moment in time
URA!
@ADHDisYippeeeeeeeeee you've earned a sub comrade
Standing here because you already lost every battle in real life
@@realworld7049 no we didn't dumbass
@@realworld7049 Rojava Zapitasts Disagree
I would argue that yes he wouldnt really like it being used as a nationalist symbol but in the face of this conflict based on Imperialism, opression and lies vs Ukraine, he would most likely not protest much. But of course he would do some shitfucks here and there on both sides :troll:
when will there be a video on Alexander Men?
Fingers crossed for one on Eamon De Valera
I always look forward to these uploads. Keep the great content coming!
Actual sources! This is amazing. There are youtubers ten times ur size which cite none. Keep it up 🎉
Just discovered your channel. Thank you great content on a niche topic.
A guy stopped me this morning n asked me if i was a soldier in maknos army, cuz i wear a budenovka with a skull n bones on it during winter. It caught me so off-guard cuz its not something you expect to hear at a gas station in Detroit at 9am.
Stay frosty out there boys!
Could you make a video about Thomas Sankara?
The guy stared at the face of Death many times and many times he got away. Such an adventurous life.
I guess this means Stepan Bandera will be next?
i dream that one day you will talk about the Italian Commie movement for a full hour like this
Don't forget that he also wrote many of the songs of the Ukrainian Anarchists lol
Where did your Lincoln Rockwell video go? It made me laugh so hard.
Been binge watching your videos. Thank you for this temporary wrap up of the Russian Civil War (of which Ukraine ended up unfortunately dying from) with Nestor Makhno!!
Keep up the great work!!
Это была не Украина а гуляй поле к анархической республики не может быть название нац государства .
Long live the late Nestor Makno
Looking like a haunted oompa loompa definitely makes this guy even scarier
Who needs sleep when you have Mother Anarchy.
Holy crap I’ve been waiting for third for months lest fucking goooooooo
Makhno was just a chill guy 💯🔥🗣️🙏🕎🕎🥦👩🏿🏫✍️👽😾🦶🧌🧌🧌🧌
No parents!
No bedtimes!
Lmao
SPARTAN RETURNS!
Side note: I have a job now, and also a major future plan - if things here in Canada (or, at least, here in the shithole that is Alberta) get particularly, then I'm making a beeline for an Australian city within the next 10 years (not sure which one yet tho... gotta get that figured out). In anticipation of this, I wonder if there's any Australians who are worthy of a video on this channel?
1:03:04 what is this timeline bro??!
Dude went from Grunt, Commissar during WWII, First Secretary of the Ukrainian Communist Party after WWII, then holding both of the most powerful titles in the Soviet Union of "Premier of the Soviet Union" and "First Secretary of the USSR" respectively.
He unironically sounds so fuckign based
Fun Fact : - The Russian Army is only 5km from the town where Nestor Makhno grew up!
To be fair they've been there for almost 2 years
Is it like a force field
@@tamerlane9889Makhno’s Ghost fighting against Tyranny to this day
More like a f*cked fact
Анархия мама, за наш!!
massively underrated channel. Honestly.
Coincidentally, the rich landlord and his privileged sons who radicalized Makhno as a youth by beating their farmhand were Mennonites. Not something I was told as a half-ethnic-Mennonite kid, but Mennonite historians have started talking about it over the past few years. (They've also started talking about the very uncomfortable history of Mennonites in WW2, which is a whole 'nother thing.)
Yo bro I was Wondering if you could Cover Said mohammedi a very obscure yet interesting character
28:51 Sadly, in any conflict, there are always horrible people who just know how to repet the violence that they were taught.
2:41 damn big relatable; probably explains why I fell in love and married a girl/woman with dead parent(s)/siblings/everyone and been with her ever since--I can certainly imagine how it influenced Mahkno for sure
13:56. My favorite part
I always though that nationalism and thigh highs goes hand in hand, just like HOI4 or being into computers. But it was never as wild as this. But on a serious note, its a monumental video. Definetely more than i'v learned in russian history classes.
Please, the sudden sound fx are unnecessary and startling.
Great!
what happened to dirlewanger video?
I love your videos!
Hey how about an video on otto strasser and his weird nazbol ideology?
based is nestor makhno, better than most other of the leftists dare I say. thank you for making videos on all of the best political figures
For some reason we've bought into the lie that change can be achieved within the ruleset of the establishment, that our masters will give us an out if we were to just keep begging
We will never win abiding by the game we are given, the bourgeoisie only play in blood and only blood can drown them.
I saw the intro card, and you had my attention.
you think we could get a video on Benjamin Butler?
May I suggest perhaps one of the funniest funni men(tm) Eduardo Rózsa-Flores, very awesome video by the way!
Do you have a link I can donate to you ?
Makhno makes me wish I could call myself an anarchist
You could make one about Petar II Petrović Njegoš,he was cool af
Am I going insane or did spartan do a videon on rockwell that was taken down?
He did
bro, i dont know what the next video will be but if it were about someone from the spanish civil war it would be hella based
I heard about Makhno a while ago, and since discovering your channel I was excited to see you cover him. You did history justice, and my respect for him only increased since seeing this video. It's strange identifying with someone who you disagree with ideologically, but respect enough you wish they were more successful, despite the fact they've been dead for 90 years.