As India & Canada squabble, we look at votebank politics,Sikh radicals & how AI-182 bombers got away
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ก.พ. 2025
- #icymi #canada #justintrudeau #hardeepsinghnijjar
A massive diplomatic row has erupted after Canadian PM Justin Trudeau, addressing the country’s parliament, spoke of “credible allegations” about a “potential link” between Indian government agents and the killing of Hardeep Singh Nijjar, chief of the Khalistan Tiger Force, this June in British Columbia. The Indian government has dismissed the allegations as “absurd”, and both countries have expelled one diplomat each in the wake of the row. In Ep 1249 of Cut The Clutter, originally published on 9 June, Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta talks about why Sikh radicals have found a haven in Canada, and how Canadian investigators let the men who bombed Air India Kanishka in 1985 get away with it.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/su...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our TH-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Member benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
The solution to vote bank politics of Khalistanis in Canada is getting other peaceful Indian Canadians to become politically active and have bigger force than the fringe Khalistani element. Out of 2.4 million Indian canadians only 700k are sikhs and out of them only a small minority is backing this. They only matter because they are united and loud while others are silent spectators expecting a saviour instead of becoming politically active themselves and contribute to Canadian lawmaking against such terrorists. It will be solved real quick. Indo canadians need to unite and become a stronger political force.
It is good for Modi JI politically , even if it is proved that NIJJAR is killed by Indian secret service, there is nothing western countries do against india, india is strong country economically militarily educationally, western countries need India,.
Once one starts going down the route of assassinations.. well, well, it's a very slippery slope, which can very turn out to be a double-edged sword for ALL SIDES... which folks might regret later but then it's too late
Khalistani
th-cam.com/video/1uQDDQlMpPU/w-d-xo.htmlsi=X_52coTBjM9LLjaj
clown of the highest kind dustbin trudeau😂😂😂😂
There’s a divide in Punjabis and Sikhs who have come to Canada during 80s and who have migrated recently in these couples of years. We people who have migrated recently don’t actually support Khalistan movement at all because we have actually lived in Punjab all our lives and we know the realities. It’s funny how these people who have migrated in 80s are so far from the reality. The other day I was walking in Surrey during Vaishakhi parade / mela and I heard 14 year old Sikh boy say to his 15 year old Sikh friend in canadian English - that Nihang Army is bigger than Indian army. This boy would have never gone to India , and maybe would be born in Canada only , because had he been in India he would have realized that Nihangs are just hashish consuming people and nothing else.
@@vsr3777Bcos the khalistanis are goons. Basically any sikh who doesn't support khalistan is harassed and sent death threats. So they are forced to attend these "protests".
But still million of indians are coming to Canada. The numbers shows that they are running away from a burning house
Those are good and interesting observations.
I think u r talking about naanga sadhus
@@OhiSandhu Least racist khalistani.
Five years ago, Mr. Trudeau brought a convicted khalistani tirorist on his state visit to India.
It's unfortunate to know that he lost a "travel partner".....
khalistan zindabad
@@japneetsingh5015sure, try that in Canada or Pakistan, indians would support u😂
Mind Begs the Question:
If under a PM/Govt
Protesting Rapes - Sedition
Gang Rapists - Freed
PM/Govt - Democratic,Fascist?
@@japneetsingh5015 You can take Pakistan and build your Khalistan there.
indian govt gave him visa ,bhakats are biggest chutiyas.
This story deserved a fresh episode, not an abridged repost....
Yes
Very disappointed
THanks for telling. I know shker can be sneaky... (but I like him). Next time when I pay for his subscription i will ask for discount.
@@jijilru guys even paying to this Uncleji's bullshit..
@@bthebossfulI know. Can't beleive people actually pay this guy 😅
SG is on a vacation this week.
All these smooth talking leaders of the west and developed worlds needs to be shown the right mirror. You can’t allow radicalism to flourish in your backyard and then do some gibberish around sovereignty and national security in your parliament to pander to your vote banks.
Thank you Shekhar for reminding us this message through the Kanishka episode.
It was indian congress party in power that let it go. They did not have the courage to fighrt back. Atleast now support modi and not rahulgandhi or congress. They will take india back to stone age where we all will become slaves again.
What about radicalism, which sprouted its ugly head in Manipur recently?
But you can allow Hindu radicalism and Cow Vigilantes because that is done by the majority, right? Indians should stop calling India a democracy when it actually is a majoritarian nation.
This is hardly the first time the Indian govt has resorted to overseas killings. I would be not a surprise if they were behind the AI bombings.
Why would anyone will call it radical sikh movement when it's obvious it a khalistani terrorist with support from pakistan.
That's why they never add pakistan punjab in their map.
Don't defame our Sikhs for these terrorist.
Don't be naive. These are hate filled sikhs
That is true this has nothing to do with sikhism. This is a khalistani terrorist group and one should only call that.
Unfortunately, these Sikhs that you defend (who don't stand with the terrorists) are not standing up against the terrorist and so are equally culpable.
@@kamalsh6123 how are they not standing up? It's govt job to provide security if they won't why expect from them. Even after that you will find other than jatt sikh everyone else support india.
Real question should be what are we hindus doing we are more in quantity than these khalistani sikh in Canada but still they are able to form govt and we don't. Why ask something of them when we ourselves don't stand up. Where is the hindu front in Canada? Other than haryanvi I don't see anyone else who even think about challenging them in Canada.
there is a divide among Sikhs who are in Canada. 1. One who Trouble in the name of Khalistan. 2. One who are in Canada for earning money and in hope of a Better life.
The Second kind of people aren't the problem. But their name also gets attached when you say 'Khalistani', But mentioning 'Radical Sikh' would imply a subdivision among Sikh, thus Making a reservation for the second kind.
As a response, India kicked out one of their diplomats and gave him 5 days to pack his bags. 1 day to leave and 4 extra days in case his plane breaks down.
That would be Air India.
@@checkfactschecking air India doesn't operate 40 year old piece of junk dumbass 😂
@@checkfactschecking Air Canada
😂😂
The rest of the G-7 countries have supported Canada, which could be better for Vishva Guru.
Air India bombing is an eye opener for Indians how the white actually see the "others" and treat. As, SG pointed out, had it any white country's plane, Canadian could've never ever shown such ignorance and would have promptly taken proactive action to stop and punished the culprit on terror charges without the act of terror actually had happened.
Very true.
The perpetrators of Kanishka bombing were given free pass by Canada and now they preach us about democracy.
I think white Canadians might have been sub-consciously or subtly racist in the 1980s and 1990s, but have probably come a long way through till present.
Western duplicity is the reason India should maintain good relations with Russia.
Russia is nothing , Ukraine is giving them a hard time .
@@mohandhanoa4797not Ukraine but entire west backing them with intelligence, money, ammunition and sanctions on Russia and still Russia is holding on.
So here Not Ukraine>Russia but Russia > Entire west
There are no western soldiers in Ukraine . Ukraine has destroyed over 2000 Russian tanks .. They are crying .@@hiteshkumar6042
Yes, keep backing a loser state. 😂
Russia is the loser state .@@DGoldy303
I had never heard of the Air India bombings until yesterday. Thanks Justin. I bet there are more like me. I hope it doesn’t end up ruining the image of Canadian Sikhs in India although I feel that this is definitely going to have an effect. Especially if others in the community don’t denounce these Khalistani whackos. Another shining examples le for why we shouldn’t let talentless sons and daughters of former prime ministers and presidents run our country.
I’m not sure this one earned a “Thanks Justin,” 😂 happened decades ago. If anything, we’ve had decades of, “Nooo, Canadian Sikhs aren’t like that! it was just a lone whacko!”
Justin gonna need to arrest a couple of these “Kalistani” people, and send to India to stand trial for murders … or, they’ll probably also die violent deaths, that are “difficult to solve.” 😳 I don’t know how to feel about that.
“Goldie Brar” and “Arsh Dall” as examples: both seem to be viewed by India as major criminals and/or connected to terror attacks … possibly living “free” in Canada. 🤔 probably, hiding tho. both should be, “Wanted by RCMP.” but idk.
Justin has 3 choices: (a) arrest about 15 people wanted by India, sort it out. (b) let those people get assassinated, and shut up. (c) actively protect these few people. 😢 rough choice, but (c) is at the expense of these rest of us, who aren’t involved in Kalistan Movement terror attacks. 🤯
Give me one example that has proof and source that links khalistani's to terrorists. People who want independence will obviously be the victims sadly. Im glad that majority of canadians and americans know the truth about 1984 and the ongoing indian assimilation on sikhs and punjabi's @@xanatax1844
After 9/11 its the aviation mishap with max deaths
The State of Canada must take responsibility for the disturbances caused by its own Citizens to Sovereignty of India and its failure to curb the same. The PM of Canada must take accountability for his own failures as an administrator of his own country.
first stop indians immigrating to canada. you cannot even feed them,. they come to canada and beg on the streets. keep them in India it will save trouble for everyone.
When will Canadian leaders.. Sp. Jagmeet Singh and Sikh community show the audacity to condemn, blasting of Air India planes by few Canadian Sikh separatists?? Does anyone remember Kanishka bombing?? Does anyone care for the 300+people killed by Sikhs in Canada? Were those lesser of Canadians and the Sikhs are more... Vote bank?
Sikhi's foundation is in Lahore.. Nankana Sahib is there.. Sikhs MUST fight and get All of Maharaja Ranjit Singh's riasat lost to Pakistan FIRST! Im sure the lovely supportive Pakistani brothers will agree and help Sikhs get their land back.
Freedom of speech.
@@AtillatheFunWhat?
indian gov don’t have right to export there terrorist activities to our Canadian soil. The way indian gov terrorized the Muslims & Christians of india, is really a crime against humanity
I didn't know Canada was also a syndicate state like Mexico.
Read about truckers protest and anti vaccine protest, canada came on them on harsh. It makes modi look normal
modi is super soft when it comes to national security leftist are openly working against india and bjp is doing nothing many forces inside ad outside have ganged up against us @@navdeepsugandhi6476
@@navdeepsugandhi6476believe me Modi is much better than all these western leaders. Indians just have this image of the west but are far from reality.
@@patelaakash267 he is the most racist person alive now. Under the ruling of this racist gov, the minorities of india are getting killed just for eating beef.
@@patelaakash267India bombed the golden temple and committed Delhi riots ??
When has Canada killed its own citizens ??
Another fantastic and very informative video by Shekhar. I could feel the fire in him as he narrated the part where the scanning machine at Toronto airport detected and let out a screech but was ignored. All siad and done, this pandering to radicals will not end well foe all the stake holders. But power is what ultimately matters, even if that is the sole reason for one's downfall.
Thank you, Siddharth, for watching and writing in. I'm glad you liked this episode...best wishes, Shekhar
Thank you SG for bringing out the detailed picture of these radicals in Canada. Makes me more determined to back our own people who may have eliminated these radicals. If all their courts just ignore the facts and let them go free after bombing an aircraft and killing innocents, then it is time to downgrade our relations with such countries.
Sikhs are very active in almost all parties, especially in B.C & Brampton ridings. I think, this may be the last term for Trudeau in Office, but still any future Canadian governments will be soft on Sikh separatist politics. It doesn't affect Canada. Unfortunately, India has a hard choice to make.
The solution to vote bank politics of Khalistanis in Canada is getting other peaceful Indian Canadians to become politically active and have bigger force than the fringe Khalistani element. Out of 2.4 million Indian canadians only 700k are sikhs and out of them only a small minority is backing this. They only matter because they are united and loud while others are silent spectators expecting a saviour instead of becoming politically active themselves and contribute to Canadian lawmaking against such terrorists. It will be solved real quick. Indo canadians need to unite and become a stronger political force.
most insightful comment, Mr. Ram!
Eventually it’ll impact Canada. Do you think these terrorists will keep quiet in Canada? The chickens will come home to roost!
And unlike in the past, Indians won’t be as pliant as they were in the past!
you have no clue how much deep rooted hatred few of these khalistanis have .
My daughter while walking her dog was told " You Indian and your Dog off my Lawn " when that was common area in front of the house on the street.
why do you live among khalistanis? go live in a proper neighborhood.
U should have said bharat mata ki jay.
isse kaam ho jayega? kuch chutiye to comments mai support kar rhe h especially muzlims kyoki Modi unka baap dikh gya naa beech mai hate failaao@@virengojiya2009
What about the Hatred Hindus / Sanatana Dharmi's have towards Muslims & Christians in India?
Pardeep(if you really are),
We have friends from all walks of life; we don’t care about religion much.
Please come to India and see the reality and don’t believe social media university.
Hindus and shikh community persentage is almost equal in canada but shikh commuinities is more impartent in canada ।Hindus communities must think over
That’s not how I feel I’m a Canadian and 60 years old. I remember when that happened. It was horrific. I’ve never seen anything like that on the church.
I hear you, and respect the fact that you might have lived those times horrified, but it doesn’t bode well in history, when the investigation happened appallingly, after 21 years! Will you call a spade a spade? Let’s not whitewash Western “liberal” democracies!
Individual feelings are inconsequential when your government has been hand in gloves with the terrorists and did nothing against bombers.
@@ritikshaw5868individual feeling are very crucial in struggles against terrorist which are responsible for heinous evils against humanity .
I think one thing which you, and all white Canadians, especially who were young at that time, should ask themselves honestly: Would your government have waited 21 years, if the majority of Canadians killed on that flight were whites?
Nothing implying here, to be honest. Just think the question is worth asking and I sincerely don't presume or know the answer.
Well Said Mr. Gupta. Fully agree with you on this
Indian living in Canada and let me tell you Canadians are some of the best people out there. They don’t want this drama. They are already pissed with housing and cost of living. Ordinary Sikhs have nothing to do with this stuff, everybody wants to work and provide for their family. Its the radicals who are a nuisance mostly in BC and Ontario.
That is true however unfortunately Canada does not have a PM but a Chinese stooge in Trudeau so all of this mess.
I have seen otherwise, lived in Toronto for two years before moving to US, thank god. Most sikhs hate others especially hindus. Especially Jaat one are more dangerous. The number of people turning out for the K protest will show you that.
All i ask indian people is dont discrimate against sikhs because of this, there is a difference between Sikhs and Khalistanis. I am a indian born sikh but have lived in canada for 18 years now but dont support khalistan. I have even came as a kid lived in India and livrd peacefully with Hindu Friends, Sikh Friends not even caring about religion but just that we are Indian.
You are wrong buddy
You don’t have to worry the majority of Indian comments I have seen have made sure to make khalisthanis and Sikhs different entities. I personally don’t find any reason in Indians trying to accuse our citizens for something that’s created by an ignorant/ misguided populace. I hope this random and majorly vote Bank politics of a foreign nation doesn’t ruin our relationship with our own citizens. :)
India should hold a memorial service in the place in Ireland where the memorial has been built. We should also do a huge memorial service in Ottawa, Toronto and Vancouver led by Canadians of Indian origin. Air India can lead that effort as it was an Air India tragedy-
@maheshjambardi771
@maheshjambardi771
you have lots of money wipro and soros is already funding them for their propaganda why ur wasting ur money thats why hindus are getting attacked because they have not yet learned how to use money wisely if ur a communist i can understand but if ur hindu shame on u
That is a good suggestion, Mahesh. Thank you for watching and writing in...best wishes, Shekhar
your analysis is excellent. it says a lot about Canada's approach towards Indians and their concept of justice and truth with regard to Indians
It seems like age is showing its effects on you, this was a hot topic and looking forward for your piece and you present a re upload. Delegate some work sanjay ji. Keep rocking.
The story is still developing. Lets wait a couple of days.
One of the most annoying aspects of The Print is that they often have YT videos where they repeat their printed articles verbatim. It is just incredibly lazy.
It's not Sanjay ji .it's shekhar ji .I think age is also catching up with you also😂
@@rajeevdhingra2969 51 people liked this but you only noticed. Kudos to you. People only read S and rest their sub consciousness fill in.😂😂
Thank you for posting this. I didn’t think we could have a worse PM than Trudeau sr….until his son was elected! I am horrified by yesterday’s announcement! We desperately need to get him out of power.
Please ask a question to your pm that if nizzar was a Canadian citizen why he was supporting khalistan ?
Get him out of power so Indians can kill Canadians whenever they want? Lmao Indian bots are so pathetic
That's okay. India is also experiencing the worst Prime Minister ever.
@@DGoldy303 Pappu what are you doing here., go and watch your cartoon..
@@DGoldy303let's trade, you take our village idiot and we get Modi. Deal?
Proud of R&AW💪🏻💪🏻
Your modi bitch is too much of a coward to admit. Because he too scared of sikhs
The Canadian current government is only looking at re-election. Possibly at the cost of India Canada relationship. Thank you for the video
Thank you for watching and writing in, Vivekanand, and for supporting our journalism...best wishes, Shekhar
Fantastic analysis and well researched information
Thank you 🙏 Shekhar ji for this comprehensive piece of information! It is sad that western democracies harbour radical elements in their own backyard or someone else’s backyard (i.e. af-pak region) to terrorise other parts of the world, with no accountability! It’s shameful that the Canadian government didn’t investigate the Kanishka bombing for 21 years and barely convicted 1 person and allowed assassinations of witnesses! The fact that the Canadian PM went to the Irish memorial to call it a “Canadian tragedy” after decades says volumes about the hypocrisy and also racism! I hope the Khalistani supporters smell the coffee and get a reality check on the damage they have caused to the Sikh communities incredible reputation worldwide! I hope Indian government can steer the world on their side, and I am not shy of saying…the ‘right’ side!
I'm glad you liked this episode, my friend. Thank you for supporting our journalism...best wishes, Shekhar
@@ThePrintIndiaShekhar Gupta Sonia ka Kuta. I remember how he sucked up to Cong and Pakistani when he was with NDTV. One of the most despicable and arrogant hacks. A male barkha
Appeasement politics at the cost of national interest, I hope he get what he deserve total humiliation
You need to chill out Indian. You find that things are not as black and white as you want them to be. Just remember Canada is major export of oil and natural gas. Two things India wants and needs. And they want they can make more expensive for you and your country.
I guess Trudeau learning from BJP to appease votes.
I regret my admiration for Trudeau
This is not a function of Trudeau.
1 Separatism is not illegal in most Western nations. The Khalistanis are not violating any Canadian law. Trudeau's exit will not change anything.
2 Trudeau has not control over the police or judiciary. Separation of powers is robust in these nations. It is not like India where the Union government can use agencies like IT Dept, ED etc to settle scores and selectively target certain people.
3 The Khalistani movement existed even before Trudeau came to office.
You liked a nepo baby? How naive of you
@@okeng71487 Lol. Separatism is most definitely illegal in most Western nations and is crushed or has led to long term wars. You don't know what you are talking about. In US, the entire civil war was triggered by the fact that the south wanted to secede. Ireland tragedy is also well known. When there were talks of secession in Spain, the movement got crushed. This is even true in Canada itself! So, educate yourself before writing things down. Trudeau absolutely is responsible for this because he needs the support of the separatists to stay in power. Again, please educate yourself.
@@okeng71487 fair enough! but he is still the PM of his country and his diplomatic acumen is in order to pacify this situation. Successive generations of PMs will have to attempt to defeat the Khalistanis.
@@okeng71487if he goes down pH
All Indian political parties along with media should stand with Indian Government and rise thr voice against Khalistan.
This coverage was admirable! keep up the good work ThePrint👍
I think it is time PIO status of Canadians citizens be suspended, visa rules tightened and Foreigners Registration Act be made applicable to them. Visa application should have a questions: " Do you support the formation of Khalistan". " Did you visit Pakistan in the last five years." It will force people to Google and inform themselves. It is also time to create a quick way to returning Hindu PIOs to acquire Indian citizenship quickly.
4:20 he made a point to call these Khalistani terrorist - radical Sikhs. What does he want? To create rift or paint sikhs as radical.
Radical Sikh is a reality live with it. No waterboutery
Calling the truth is bad ?
Sikhs are not at all radical.. Neither are they terrorists.. There are a few number of Sikhs who are radicalised, out of which miniscule numbers may be terrorists. But you cannot brush the entire Sikh community as radicalised and certainly not as terrorists.
@@TusharAnkit-o2bBy going against Indian they wnet aginst their religion. So they are not Sikhs any longer.
I think that was a wrong statement by Shekhar.
He cannot call this radical Sikhs. It has to be kept as Khalistani supporters.
All Sikhs are amazing people. These handful of less than a few hundred Khalistanis believe in whatever they believe. But Shekhar shouldnt have said 'radical Sikhs'. Thats irresponsible for a stalwart like Shekhar.
*Snakes in your backyard won't bite only neighbours: Hillary to Pakistan*
In Trudeau's much-vaunted rule of law, which seems to only apply to those that agree with him, one is considered innocent until proven guilty. In this instance, since the guilt has not been proven, I'm shocked that Trudeau has destroyed indo-canadian relations even more. Moreover, oppositoon leader Poilievre's comparison to Trudeau's reaction to Chinese interference is right on the money. China held two Canadians hostage, had and may still have their own police stations on Canadian soil, and interfered in the election process, and all Trudeau has done is to try and stall the investigation. Since the last eight years have taught me not to put much weight on what Trudeau says, I am quite open to believing that this is a very convenient way to distract Canadians from Trudeau's pathetic track record of the past few months and years.
Hindus are kindest people. Along with Jain and buddhists hindus are only community which never put separatist demand in any country. hindus are always loyal to their country they live in.
What dalaee Lama doing here in india?
@@lifegamerpro4033dalai lama doest call for genocide of anyone , neither involved in hijacking 😂
The expulsion of the Indian Diplomat might have been to defuse a potential bigger problem. This way if the evidence published is undeniable that they were involved, India would have to decide whether to claim immunity or revoke the immunity and let them be prosecuted in Canada. Now, with the expulsion of a Canadian diplomat there will be some protests but the issue will fade away and not be a diplomatic row. as it was with Devyani Khobraghade in New York
I highly doubt Indian agents were involved in the killing. Most likely, he was killed by a rival gang that was also involved in drug trafficking. Why were traces of drugs found in Trudeau plane?
Why is it that the Canadian sikhs feel so antagonistic towards India. In India itself Sikhs are not looked down on or discriminated. They are a completely amalgamated part of the Indian society
It's good to let the people know how much does Canada really cares about Canadian citizens. 268 killed, and they did not even bat an eyelid for 21 years. Thanks for letting us know what the Brits and the Germans did. Koye dudh ka dula nahi hai. Shame on the Canadians to whine now.
Someone said " Demography is King ". It's absolutely true. In western countries birthrate is falling and immigrants are taking over that place. So, there will be many surprises like this one.
However, I personally believe that during G20 we should have given PM of Canada little more respect, the way we have given respect to Japanese, Italian or Saudi delegates. After all we don't have any problem with Canadian people. ATITHI DEVAI BHABHO.
Atithi devo bhavah is true, however it's wrong to give him a special treatment as he has been continously supporting the Khalistani movement. Indians are being attacked, Hindu temples are being vandalized and still this idiot says they have the right to do so because of his vote bank politics.
He is incorrigible BOY PM.
Yea. We should let the family's of fallen soldiers decide whether we should have dinner or play cricket with enemies.
Its easy to say for you when you lost nothing
It will only bring more pain for Sikhs, Normal Sikh voices should be supported.
U don't worry abt sikh ,, coz they r new target ,, elections r nearby both in india n Canada,,politicians will play dirty game
@@bhavneetkaur723then stand up against the extremism in your religious community instead of crying “politics”.
@s_2341 don't blame her, we all have same virus. How many hindus are standing when someone does similar idiotics. We are just same..It's bit easier to lure martial people. They are more emotional and can easily be used giving examples of glorious past. Only good thing is, Hindu radicals have high regard for Sikhism otherwise it could have burst like hell for all. Just opposite to it, sikh radicals demean Hinduism in every aspect, like renaming various hindu feativals, calling to kill Hindus, demean gods. Only good thing is normal Sikhs are also coming more openly despite getting their life endangered.
Not just terrorists, several dreaded gangsters, including Satinderjit Singh alias Goldy Brar, Arshdeep Singh alias Arsh Dalla and Lakhbir Singh Sandhu alias Landa, have been operating against India from the Canadian soil. On Punjab police's request, Interpol has already issued a RCN against Brar and Dalla and is in the process of issuing it against Landa.
I think this was a self serving announcement by the Canadians who probably failed in their free trade deal with India. These guys have been vocal, their attempts to affect India has reached the mainland with Amritpal Singh and others, activities could be tracked during the farmers protest.
Basically, Canadians have retaliated due to something not happening in the trade negotiations.
I love your content Mr. Gupta, I have been a big fan since the 80’s; but please ask your video editing team to fix the audio in post production. Every time you look downward to read something, you speak close to your microphone and the audio is very very loud. It can be easily fixed in post production.
Sikhs in Canada r financially sound. They have huge agriculture land, at least 100,000 truck companies. Largest no. Of grocery stores, petrol pumps, convenience stores, truck yards, real estate etc so even though sikhs r less but r big contributors to Canadian parties.
In comments everywhere I see our Hindu brothers teasing every person with a Sikh name saying go drive your uber or go clean toilets. You must be lying about their financial wellbeing. What is the basis of your claim?
@@ParminderSingh-ft3cc Majority of truck companies r owned by Punjabi sikhs, it's fact. Trucking companies owned by white christians r not profitable. There r many companies which have at least 100 trucks, 500 trucks, 1000 trucks owned by Sikhs U can Google it. Sikh trucking companies r profitable bcoz of cost cutting their whole operations r managed from India Pakistan Kenya Philippines like accounting dispatching e log books customer care. They pay less to their drivers as many wanted LMIA for Permanent residence from these companies. Even tax evasion like over and under invoicing is common. I also deal with generating fake invoices so I know this. Yeah there r lot of Uber drivers but mostly r new students work permit holders new immigrants and truck drivers who r free after their shift as their is cap on them how much hours they can drive trucks. Even real estate, mortgage brokers insurance agents are mostly Punjabi sikhs who earn more than other ethnicities and religions as Sikhs go to sikh to buy home car insurance for easy communication. Sikhs also own tens of thousands petrol pumps with convenience store and employ students below minimum wages. In every sikh business, illegal immigrants, students who r doing more work than the limit set by govt are employed so Sikh businesses have high margins low cost operations. Even sikhs have 50 thousand acre land 10,000 acre lands. Even my 2nd cousin has 1600 acre logging rights. Where he employ illegal immigrants to increase his margin. All labour intensive businesses r mostly owned by sikhs from home renovations, legal basement, drive thru repair plumber electrician truck mechanics heater ac repair men. These jobs don't sound good to Indian but in Canada they earn more than Bank managers or even IT software engineers. For example I have one friend who is truck mechanic he earns 6 to 8 thousand dollars daily on his Mercedes van. He has employed students on other work vans too for repairs who use his license so daily he earn around 30,000 dollars. Even plumber electrician earn easy 500 to 1000 dollar per day. All these businesses jobs r done by sikhs later they open petrol pump grocery stores tim Hortons etc from their saved money so sikhs r very rich in Canada. Yes life is hard for first 3 years of immigration but later there is enough opportunities.
@@ParminderSingh-ft3cchis claim that immigrants often outperform natives is true but many of first generation immigrant have to work in blue collared jobs.
@@ParminderSingh-ft3cc
You must be kidding. Sikhs are one of the most successful business/entrepreneurial communities in India who have repeatedly shown to strive and grow in adversity. I have rarely seen a Sikh begging. But religious extremism will be their doom.
Coming from PM Trudeau is a big deal. Indian government should take it seriously
Did they provide any evidence or suspects that link India to this murder? No.
Thank you print for bringing very interesting episode.thank you shekar sir.
Thank you, Prakash, for watching and writing in...best wishes, Shekhar
The fun fact is. Major part of Punjab belongs to Pakistan even Kartarpur corridor. I hope so -called khalistani referendums will consider it .
We must ensure that Trudeau is never allowed to step on the Indian soil.
#NoFTAWithCanada
#KhalistanMurdabaad
That kind of hatred will only make things worse. think before you spread hatred.
@@checkfactschecking get lost white man 😂😂😂
@@jaihind3595 you are the one who is lost. I'm a Canadian and act like one. You don't act like a Canadian, you act like someone who wants to murder Canadians.
Nijjar was an Indian Citizen before he became a Canadian and is accountable to the crimes he did before changing his citizenship. Its not like how the credit score works, new country new score.
Soros gang bakring against india govt and supporting khalisthani. Well if india did that we should be proud of them. Proud of their action for eliminating terrorists
Wonder why government/governments arent offensive on Kanishka airline bombing. We lost 11 Indian, doesnt matter if they were crew members or not, but we lost Indian lives and the perpetrators were Canadian citizens..
We should learn from China on how to be offensive...
Shekhar is all seeing , all knowing he saw this coming months ago.🙏🙏🙏
Great report. A proper journalist's report with relevant information and chronology. SG at his finest when he is reporting - as opposed to when he is opining.
C for CANADA C for chu***
what was the GADAR movement? was that not a radical organaisation and movement, supported by the Canadian Governoment? are we not proud of those sikh leaders of Gadar movement? who arranged the arms and ammunations for those rebels of Kamagatamaru? The sikh relations and tie up has a very old roots in Canada. First they were fighing against the British rule, now the same Sikhs are fighting against the Indian Govonment. One was a glorified chapter of Indian freedom struggle, the other is a separatist movement or a radical movement, but in both the cases Canada did the same.
stopped watching news on TV. i prefer this much more now. thanks shekhar.
This is also propaganda
@@harmandeepsinghdhillon3214 when both the extreme left and extreme right criticize you, that means you're not peddling propaganda.
@@rakeshs9678 where is centrist lol
A quote from Hilary Clinton, . "You can't keep snakes in your backyard and expect them to only bite your neighbor," she said. Need I say more?
Gau Raksha people... RSS... Hindutva organisations... All in India's backyard. You won't see it like Pakistan thought of Jihadis as their own. India's government is making the same mistake. Anyone sensible enough would understand this but this vote bank politics!
Instead of abusing canada, India should work on fullfilling long pending demands of Sikhs in Punjab like they should have rights on their waters , also Chandigarh should be transferred to Punjab. All other demands will be dead after these two tasks.
that is your state govt shit, not ours
instead of accepting criticism murdering people, you should first look at yourself, your whole population is dreaming of canada, how can india help you?
education is important
instead of absuing india, khalistanis should make khalistan in canada
It will be difficult. If you see it in Punjab, people vote for Congress or AAP. If central planning is to fulfill Panjab's demand then Congress and AAP oppose it as it will be considered as a vote bank gimmick.
@@peak_911 what's wrong with you. Who talked about khalistan. Have some sense buddy
And What about the rights of others. What just Sikhs have rights not Hindus living in Himachal?
Gupta ji, digressing from the main issue. Was a Canadian citizen assasinated by Indian agents on Canadian soil. Canadian PM has raised it highest levels.
Brilliant analysis by Mr Gupta based on judicious and rational research on the incident 👏 👍
Was waiting for this....
Yup canada blew this to the stratosphere, it will be interesting to see how it will proceed
I know back in time 1984 was hard for Sikhs, so many atrocities and violence happened against sikh community and genocide was committed towards innocent sikhs.I feel ashamed for my people but that was done by govt. of that time.Sikhs do alot contribution in India in every sector & give sacrifices alot for protection of our Hindu religion and nation. Without them India is incomplete, I hope our brotherhood grows more stronger💪 and we Hindu/Sikh solve our problems with dialogues & do work together in India progress otherwise someone else take advantage on us.
Godhra, Manipur, Kashmir, Uttar Pradesh , Himachal Pradesh
What are these?
Superb journalism.
Canada has been dealing with us in bad faith since the 1980s. CSIS was complicit in AI 182. The evidence was systematically removed. Witnesses disappeared. Accused got acquitted and got lenient sentences. And if you think they are soft on Khalistanis, remember Rana of 26/11 attack fame (who has been convicted in US for 26/11 attacks). Rana also operated from Canada and was a Canadian citizen. He helped Headley and CSIS did nothing. Only the US, to save their embarrassment with Headley, cracked down on his associates.
hindu rashtra no question , what sikhs facing daily , without any reasons targeting any minority ,every sikh keep remeber this for 1000 years , they can do anthing before election.
@@Atomicpower-vu9gbRSS are sadhus and sanyasis peaceful right . No just look at zmsnipur in may hundreds of cars scooters houses burnt to ashes . 300 Churches burnt to ashes by RSS. Modi ji did not make a statement to stop the violence . When christian women were paraded naked he spoke . This is RSS AND ITS ACTIONS SHAMELESS DISGUSTING ABHORRENT.
Ok I'll bite. How exactly are sikhs suffering in india? Our last PM was a sikh.
One thing I really like about and prime reason i biught its membership is Shekhar sir's reporting that before he gives his opinion, he lays down all the verifiable facts regarding the topic. This allows viewers to form their own perspective for the issue. Thank you sir.
shekhar sir my only question is what is the big thing for captain Amrinder singh not meeting Sajjan over supporting radical elements when our beloved prime minister vajpayee ji and even our indian state in totality gave grand welcome to Musharaf who we all know single handedly responsible for killing of hundreds of our beloved soldiers.
Sajjan is a homegrown terrorist sympathizer and Musharraf was a leader of enemy state (so he has to accommodated) but sajjan was not that important so was snubbed
@@sehejmodgill9423 i think you need to check facts. both sajjan and musharf born in india and migrated to canada and pakistan when they were 6 and 4 years old respectively. so they were
both in the same league.and if musaraf was head of enemy state sajjan was also defence minister of canada.
The Indian intelligence agencies and police look bloody good compared to the bumbling RCMP. While Canada was generally seen as a friendly welcoming country, the antics of the Canadian Prime Minister has changed that perception and it would take a long time to repair the damage.
Perhaps you are right, my friend. One only hopes the damage doesn't go too deep. Thank you for watching and writing in...best wishes, Shekhar
It is amazing how it’s possible to decry vote-bank politics in a foreign land but refuse to even acknowledge it’s deleterious effects in India.
Gurudawaras have elections but not Hindu temples. Why? Should Hindu temples not have elections so that they enhance Hindu power in Canada?
There is a fundamental difference between the economics of both the religions. Money donated to a Hindu temple goes into the priest's pocket where as in gurdwaras it is not anyone's personal income.. It gets used in ways the gurudwara management decides in consultation with Sikh sangat. Gurudwaras are not centers for anyone's personal enrichment. From what I understand... I might be a little off about Mandirs but what I said about Gurudwaras is 100% true.
Hindus cannot benefit from what they donate at a Hindu temple because only Brahmin priests benefit from it and money is not used for causes/benefit of the Hindu community.
I do not intend to demean or insult anyone, it is just my understanding and reply to the above question.
Apologies to those who feel hurt by my comment here in advance.
@@ParminderSingh-ft3cc from where did you get these nonsense? If South Indian hindu priests get all the donations they will be billionaires .
We don't have an election in mandir cause sanatana isn't an organised religion like other abrahamic religions. We have thousands of sects. There Never was a theocracy in sanatan who will send you to the crusade to convert, pillage or rape other people.
And the donations part.. it is snatched by govt to give subsidies to all citizens,yeah even 'persecuted Muslims and Christians too'
@@ParminderSingh-ft3cc: You are right; even today, the wealthiest 1,80,000 Hindu temples are controlled by corrupt government-appointed Brahmin trustees who use the charity given by Hindus as personal wealth.
The champions of Hindutva will never bring a Law to elect PIOUS HINDUS to manage the wealth of temples as they do not want to end PARWARWAD propagated by the Brahmins.
Sikhs, By LAW, have elected to select the management committee of their Gurudawars. The Brahmins have prevented the government from having similar laws for HINDUS.
The other Hindu temples are inherited from one generation to the next by the Brahmin families who own them......PARWARVAD
Regardless of one's feelings in this matter, we have to recognize that this assassination will greatly damage India's standing in the world, and will generate great worldwide sympathy for Canada, which has a reputation for being a tolerant model democracy. The impatient world will have very little understanding for the Indian position and motives. The UN Human Rights Commission will surely call India out and the world will quickly read the news and see India and Saudi Arabia mentioned in the same breath. As such, we should all be very concerned that the long term damage to India might be very much greater than any benefit.
Robert you need to understand that political assassination is a "Blood Sport" in India. It was the RSS and BJP that assassinated Mahatma Gandhi. They are a fascist organization and they make no bones that political assassination is ok in India and abroad. So they have shot Indian reporters for simply reporting the news.
Let me add to this that possibly, it is Pakistan's dream scenario if the world soon is no longer casting the India-Pakistan friction as between the "world's largest democracy" and a "military dictatorship".
This is how Canadian rule of law works. Accuse a country of assassinating someone without providing any evidence nor suspects.
Before blaming India for his murder ask yourself this question why will India kill someone linked to what's essentially a dead movement in India? Khalistan movement died out in 90s itself. That movement is more active in Canada than in India. If India were to assassinate some terrorist it will be islamic terrorists (who actually pose a risk to indian security) than these bunch of jokers.
India has no hand at all, period. He has been killed in gangwar.
World only understands power and nothing else so one showed any sympathy to Afghanistan after an unjust war was declared on it post 9/11 while Osama Bin Laden was hiding elsewhere. Unfortunately Canada looks weak in this case like a state that fosters terrorists against others like Pakistan. No one takes Trudeau seriously in international politics neither friends nor foes. Hence no consequences for India. Canada has more to loose not India. India wields more power than Canada does at world stage as only importance of Canada is that it is located next to USA.
Vote bank politics is a part of the game. In Canada they can't ignore Sikhs as BJP is hampering on Hindutva in India.
Hindutva is because of one sided secularism
@@Peaceful_World130hindutva is because someone wants power, no other reason
Canada is same as rogue pakistan that shields khalistani terrorists wanted elsewhere.
There has never been a bigger praise of India's capabilities by anyone, we should give a big thank you to Trudeau!
The name Khalistan is a literal translation of the word Pakistan
India should keep its missile ready and direct them towards Canada. Enough is enough, they are against sovereignity of India.
It is a nato member calm ur fantasy, noo one can even think about such thing
It can't even reach Canada. it doesn't even have the range🤣🤣🐶🐶. Canada is 11,000 km far from India. India's maximum range missile can reach 5000 km and 8000 km at most.
Well of course we Chinese has said all along that India was just like the "colonizer" America. And you prove us right. LOL 😂 You claim to be a virtues society now you exposed as the liar you really are. You are outlaw nation just like North Korea.
save manipur , stop unstablimg punjab.
LOL, stop reading WhatsApp forwards... Go and get your monthly free rations paid for by the tax payers... theres 80 crore of you free loaders in India as per Modi ji.. go find some employment and start paying taxes if you ever reach the tax bracket level income.
You mean vote politics in India, as parliamentary elections are due next year. Stop labelling Sikhs as radicals
Canada govt is not following the minoritism politics
If it were following that, they would have protected the Hindus among Indian immigrants who form a minority among in the Hindu-Sikh mix
Shekhar ji, you sometimes are so pedestrian 😢
a minority has to be significant enough to be catered to. For example you will never see jains being appeased at the national level in India, their numbers are too low to affect elections. however Muslims, Sikhs and Buddhists are concentrated enough in electorally important areas that they can be catered to. that is the same case with Hindus and Sikhs in Canada
@@sahils822 With the rate of immigration to Canada, I won't be surprised Hindus become significant in numbers in another 10 years.
Wah wah. What an analysis. Shekhar and team are the best.
This guy moves more than he talks. He might open a sign language channel.
This is the reason why nowadays they don't let you check your airline baggage without you boarding the same flight
Don't pretend and posture. It's not necessary. Canadian PM's anti-India stance should keep SG happy. Whatever, he reads written text well, unlike his fumbling walk the talk.
Thanks Sir.
You explain very will.
I was not aware all this happened
Thanks again
fascism and atrocities of the BJP government must not be allowed to spread to other civilised and liberal countries
which civilised countires ...that support and welcome terrorists...?
@@Prithvichouhan406
RSS is a terrorist group in India
Destined to harm and isolate India, same as with China
lol cope and seethe
Civilized Canada where protestor are crushed under horses. Islamist are the biggest facist.
Atrocities? Name one.
Salute you for the research and the diligence.
Not a fan of Modi & not going to vote BJP in future but stand took against Canada by GoI is good
nobody care your opinion on Modi good or bad
Me 5 years ago , I had said the same thing 😅. This is how bjp gets you
Don't worry modi will be next pm again.... burnol on high sale these days
@@adityajoies who care yours mc
@@nobody4u77 BJP can get me but my vote gets to Congress
The Air India bombing is a national shame for us in Canada. It sickens me, and the unbelievable incompetence of the RCMP, who erased the wire-tap tapes of the two planners after they were transcribed so there was no actual evidence available for their trials, angers me to this day. Bumblers.
I think one thing which you, and all white Canadians, especially who were young at that time, should ask themselves honestly: Would your government have waited 21 years, if the majority of Canadians killed on that flight were whites?
Nothing implying here, to be honest. Just think the question is worth asking and I sincerely don't presume or know the answer.
Keep following this story of diplomatic standoff. Especially the effect it'll have on other relationships of India with western countries. As of now there's nothing serious. Even UK is continuing trade talks with India. However it doesn't seem that Canada, this time would be left high & dry like the Meng Wanzhou case.
Meng wanzhou got scott free, so what are u implying, canada would get a diplomatic win over India?
@@navdeepsugandhi6476 I meant whether other countries especially the G-7 backing Canada solidly in this matter unlike in the case of Meng Wanzhou
@@jaydeepgadhavi5465 I would say it is 20-30 percent chance they will back canada, 10 chance they will back india if India presents its case right but most likely they would seat back and watch
@@navdeepsugandhi6476 👍
You are quite right, Jaydeep. This is certainly a story that needs close tracking, its fallout could be significant. Thank you for watching and writing in...best wishes, Shekhar
To influence India has to buy Canadian politicians the way Chinese do!
True
I just started this video, at 30 seconds, and I am already wondering how SG will find a way to make this BJP's fault and blame Modi for jt
No he'll not.
You are used to hear aaj tak and sudhir chaudhary that shows one sided news . So any bjp criticism is too much for you to digest .
Over 300 people died in Kanishka plane Bombings by khalistanis. And Canada took 20 years to investigate and in the end all were acquitted. Thats the level of support and commitment for the terrorists by the Canadian authorities.
I think we need a fresh episode for this topic!
Quite right, Dheeraj. But I was travelling and could not shoot yesterday. Today you can certainly expect a new episode on this subject. Thank you for writing in...best wishes, Shekhar
This story says canda's inefficiency or either they don't want to catch those terrorist... They also don't consider sikh population as Canadians
Palki Sharma is getting better & better than PRINT
Cuz c is a propagandist
she was always better, stop comparing her with librandu shitty media of india
On a side note, war broke out between Armenia and Azerbaijan a few hours ago. Those Pinaka were delivered on time i guess.
Khalistan's aim is not to break India, Khalistan's aim is the safety & freedom of Panjabis & Sikhs
Indian Media wants to present the first narrative to create hysteria & and consolidate support against it
But it was never about India- only Panjab
They are free and safe but your khalistan i puppet pannu don't want this they just want to break india it's already 40 year nothing happened and nothing will happen
but punjab ain’t yours or any khalistanis who are canadian citizens lmfao it belongs to punjabis living peacefully in india and punjab is a part of indian state, also indians and indian government don’t give a toss what canadians think btw 😅
Hey kid, Chill. Khalistani people are terrorist and their approach are aggressive to others citizen. and Don't compare all Sikh to Khalistani. They are Indians. Your create your country in Canada Khalistan State.
😅😅😅Great Joke attack the Hindu temple and then say this nonsense.
Yea first free Ur "Panjab" in Pakistan where Lahore, nankana Saheb,and kartar saheb is.
Where Sikh girls are kidnapped and forcefully converted and Sikh population is falling.
MAHARAJA RANJIT SINGH'S state is vandalized in Lahore so frequently.
But u Khalistanis don't see it.
Why Indian Govt allowing so much manpower & cash flowing into Canada? Only 1% out of Sikh Population in Canada is extremist but rest are peaceful & hardworking.
Why we ignore the religious extremist in India?