I do have to say the Flag people use all the time( I did so too) for the Free Territory was never actually the main flag...Nestor himself said it wasnt "Makhnovist at all" It belonged to the Free Cossacks of Ukraine apparently. butttt it is good enough to be siezed for the cause now a days...
@@MonsieurJack95 There were also some red Cossacks... But yes, this flag often belonged to bandit groups that terrorized the countryside rather than actual anarchists.
Monsieur Jack Most Cossacks were whites by then, but the true Cossacks before were not. Especially the Cossacks in Ukraine (Zaporozhian), they basically told Catherine the great to fuck off and she melted their ass. The word Cossack (Kozak) actually means free man (comes from Turkic).
It probably should also be mentioned that the flag was (and likely still is) used to discredit the Makhnovtchina by trying to link it to pogroms carried out by the Free Cossacks.
C’est magnifique!!!! Je suis Turc et le anarchist. Je d’amours le cover de Partisan!!!! Viva le anarchy!!!! Viva le revulution!!!! Viva l’Commune de Paris!!!! Salutations de la Turqiue ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
It’s the same melody. A lot of those traditional melodies get recycled by different groups, sort of like how almost every socialist movement has its own version of Warszawianka. The Bolsheviks also had their own version, The Partisan’s Song.
@@matthewssilva4781 Bullshit, Russia is hiring Volunteer Battallions from example Germany who are officially nazi. Also they are killing of the civilians. Sorry but your comment is idiotic
Fascists are fighting from both sides, not only from Russia. Only the revolution of the Ukrainian and Russian workers can put an end to the war. From russian councilcommunist🏴🔴
fait attention, quand tu dis au vent, on dirait tu dis "avant" ca change le sens de ta phrase, par moment tu change la prononciation du a en o, du coup ya certain mot qu'on tarde a comprendre, sinon super chanson, belle voie . traduction: warning, when u said "au vent" it seemes that u say "avant", that havent the same sense in youre sentence, and at certain time u change the pronunciation of the "a" in "o", so there are some words which we dont understand right away, but, that's great song, very great is your voice too. sorry for my english language by advance, i dont speak him good but i try
The Anarchist rebellion did not collapse, collapse means it failed on it's own, like the USSR. They got betrayed by the Bolsheviks, their Anarchist society was far from collapsing, quite the opposite actually.
could u play if u find it cause isnt on youtube, the "les nouveaux partisans" song, is a comunist song that i would like listen on piano, i dont mind if u cant
So you imply that Nazis are our comrades right? Nice f*king joke, Putin is not an angel, far from it, but better than the thugs that recruit even CHILDREN to fight a lost war.
Fighting for a tyrant against a tyrant, no fuck both sides and let us remember the civilian russians and ukranians stuck being counted as casualties and wounded of war, because some people can't fucking chill.
@@matthewssilva4781 You seriously buy into those bullshit Russian accusations of Ukraine being 'nazis', when Russia has been sponsoring the far right across Europe for decades, and Russia's own military ranks are filled with nazis to a far greater degree? The anarchists of Ukraine, Belarus and Russia have all sides against Putin, and while the Ukrainian state is far from innocent or benevolent, it is by far the lesser evil. Either open your eyes or sod off.
@@mikkelbjerring2914 In most wars I'd be with you all the way. But in this instance, "fuck both sides" merely means letting Putin win in practice. I'd recommend you read some of the Crimethinc articles on the war. The Ukrainian state isn't one that I'm a fan of. The Russian state is exponentially worse. And I stand in full solidarity with the Ukrainian people resisting the invasion into their lands, the destruction of their homes, and the slaughter of their sons, daughters, brothers and sisters. And yes, in this instance, I'm in favour of sending military aid in their direction too, as we have already been doing. One of the rare few instances when the amoral and vile self-interest of the US military industrial complex just so happens to align with what is morally right, this. Don't let tribalism get in the way of actual morality.
@@TheLostArchangel666 не чего подобного, на Украине к власти пришли радикальные националисты, твой прадед воевал с ними и проливал свою когда сражаясь за освобождение Европы от Гитлера, но Жители Украины в данный момент время полностью поддерживают Идеологию Третьего рейха и поступают как последние гниды. Они грабили и бомбили Донбасс за то что люди проживающие там были просто нацистов на своей родной земле, России около 8 лет пыталась решить этл проблему мирным путём , когда ещё были подписаны минские соглашения. До 2022 года на территории Донбасса не было не одного Российского солдата. После того как Жители Донбасса потеряли огромное количество людей и жителей , они были просто мучениками Киевского режима и его нациских идеалов. Единственное что они могли сделать это попросить Россию что та приняла их в свой состав и помогла раз и навсегда закончить эту войну. Представь эти люди 8 лет жили под обстрелами и каждый день прятались по подвалом своих же домов, но теперь их мучениям настал конец. Россия защитить их от Киева. Твоя прекрасная страна помогает и прикармливает нацистов, ваши ветераны 2 мировой войны отдали свои жизни просто так. Вы полностью уничтожили всё что было освобожденно кровью и мучениями нескольких миллионов человек. И вы за это заплатите, вы предатели не только себя , но даже закон божий. Вы полностью погрязли в дерьме от которого уже не сможете очиститься
Néstor Makhno I mean, if u were in Baltic states, the soviets were worse than the nazi because they were less bad than the red army, they saw nazi still as evil but not as evil
![Comfy Pepe listens the Maknovitchina [Lyrics]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/t1-K_wOdjPE/mqdefault.jpg)
I do have to say the Flag people use all the time( I did so too) for the Free Territory was never actually the main flag...Nestor himself said it wasnt "Makhnovist at all"
It belonged to the Free Cossacks of Ukraine apparently.
butttt it is good enough to be siezed for the cause now a days...
Huh. Didn't know that. Thought most Cossacks were whites though. I admittedly don't know much on em.
@@MonsieurJack95 There were also some red Cossacks...
But yes, this flag often belonged to bandit groups that terrorized the countryside rather than actual anarchists.
Monsieur Jack Most Cossacks were whites by then, but the true Cossacks before were not. Especially the Cossacks in Ukraine (Zaporozhian), they basically told Catherine the great to fuck off and she melted their ass. The word Cossack (Kozak) actually means free man (comes from Turkic).
It probably should also be mentioned that the flag was (and likely still is) used to discredit the Makhnovtchina by trying to link it to pogroms carried out by the Free Cossacks.
Вроде как приписывают атаману Григорьеву.
C’est magnifique!!!! Je suis Turc et le anarchist. Je d’amours le cover de Partisan!!!!
Viva le anarchy!!!! Viva le revulution!!!! Viva l’Commune de Paris!!!! Salutations de la Turqiue ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Long live anarchy, long live Rojava!
Magnifique, thank you comrade !
You have a beautiful voice and good french.
Liberté aux travailleurs.
Comrade? There are idiots believieng in this nonsense?
Cheka killed all idiots...
French is hard. Mispronunciations likely.
You did well comrade.
Love from a jewish french anarchist
true, even for a catalan native...
That's perfect except for "jeté au vent" because "au" is pronounced "o"
@@nazarderkach9320 why not just join the anarchists? There's still some arround
I found English lyrics for this song online if you're interested
www.antiwarsongs.org/confronta.php?versions=1&ver=2991&id=3029&ver2=112910&lang=en
Congratulations for this song! I'm french and I can say that your pronunciation is really good, and your voice is too!
I love this song. Great job comrade.
As a french speaking man,I must say your french is pretty good!
Nice pfp
@@TotallyNotLoki lmao thanks, nice pfp to u as well!
I see we all have great taste in profile pics
this is the best version I've heard
Свободу народам! Свободу украинцам, русским и белорусам!
Mate, your channel is gold. Many thanks
The best version I have ever heard!
This reminds me of March of the Siberian Riflemen, Amazing job by the way your songs are mostly the only ones I listen to now a'days. :)
It’s the same melody. A lot of those traditional melodies get recycled by different groups, sort of like how almost every socialist movement has its own version of Warszawianka. The Bolsheviks also had their own version, The Partisan’s Song.
@@theEndermanMGS yes. A las barricades was Catalan anarchist song from warsiawsianka (sorry if spelt wrong)
The drive out all tyrants part gave me chills. Good job comrade
I love this cover
This accent is like old francois
Nestor Makhno was a hero
I was?
Hey, I'm a big fan of your work! How did you learn to play by ear so well?
Great sound :)
RIP Nestor Makhno and the green army.
He lead the Black army but I get the sentiment.
Beautifull.
Makno-Durruti: la misma lucha, el mismo ideal.CNT
Cool french voice my comrade
¡¡¡ Néstor Makhno !!!
Stay strong against fascism ukrainians ! Love from France
Stay strong Russia 💪
Against Ukrainian Nazism
@@matthewssilva4781 Bullshit, Russia is hiring Volunteer Battallions from example Germany who are officially nazi. Also they are killing of the civilians. Sorry but your comment is idiotic
@@matthewssilva4781 Russia is literally the closest country to fascism there is in modern history
@@themsye USA, Russia, Ukraine, Poland, France, Britain can all be described as fascist states.
Fascists are fighting from both sides, not only from Russia. Only the revolution of the Ukrainian and Russian workers can put an end to the war.
From russian councilcommunist🏴🔴
Ce magnifique!
Cheka killed them all...
fait attention, quand tu dis au vent, on dirait tu dis "avant" ca change le sens de ta phrase, par moment tu change la prononciation du a en o, du coup ya certain mot qu'on tarde a comprendre, sinon super chanson, belle voie .
traduction:
warning, when u said "au vent" it seemes that u say "avant", that havent the same sense in youre sentence, and at certain time u change the pronunciation of the "a" in "o", so there are some words which we dont understand right away, but, that's great song, very great is your voice too. sorry for my english language by advance, i dont speak him good but i try
🏴🏴🏴
Was Makhnovtchina wrote after or before the Anarchist rebellion collapsed?
Pretty sure it was after, when Nestor lived in Paris
The Anarchist rebellion did not collapse, collapse means it failed on it's own, like the USSR.
They got betrayed by the Bolsheviks, their Anarchist society was far from collapsing, quite the opposite actually.
Against Capitalism, against Leninism: for the workers' Platform.
j'adore cet accent...✌😉😁
c'est pas évident...ton accent s'améliore au fur et a mesure la chanson avance...cest de ladaptation rapide
bravo
1:05 shouldnt that be Trotsky’s treaties? I know technically Lenin did it, but it wouldn’t of happened if it weren’t for Trotsky’s mistake
You should do this again
could u play if u find it cause isnt on youtube, the "les nouveaux partisans" song, is a comunist song that i would like listen on piano, i dont mind if u cant
For our comrades fighting in Ukraine against the tyrant.
So you imply that Nazis are our comrades right? Nice f*king joke, Putin is not an angel, far from it, but better than the thugs that recruit even CHILDREN to fight a lost war.
Fighting for a tyrant against a tyrant, no fuck both sides and let us remember the civilian russians and ukranians stuck being counted as casualties and wounded of war, because some people can't fucking chill.
@@matthewssilva4781 You seriously buy into those bullshit Russian accusations of Ukraine being 'nazis', when Russia has been sponsoring the far right across Europe for decades, and Russia's own military ranks are filled with nazis to a far greater degree?
The anarchists of Ukraine, Belarus and Russia have all sides against Putin, and while the Ukrainian state is far from innocent or benevolent, it is by far the lesser evil. Either open your eyes or sod off.
@@mikkelbjerring2914 In most wars I'd be with you all the way. But in this instance, "fuck both sides" merely means letting Putin win in practice. I'd recommend you read some of the Crimethinc articles on the war.
The Ukrainian state isn't one that I'm a fan of. The Russian state is exponentially worse. And I stand in full solidarity with the Ukrainian people resisting the invasion into their lands, the destruction of their homes, and the slaughter of their sons, daughters, brothers and sisters.
And yes, in this instance, I'm in favour of sending military aid in their direction too, as we have already been doing. One of the rare few instances when the amoral and vile self-interest of the US military industrial complex just so happens to align with what is morally right, this. Don't let tribalism get in the way of actual morality.
@@TheLostArchangel666 не чего подобного, на Украине к власти пришли радикальные националисты, твой прадед воевал с ними и проливал свою когда сражаясь за освобождение Европы от Гитлера, но Жители Украины в данный момент время полностью поддерживают Идеологию Третьего рейха и поступают как последние гниды. Они грабили и бомбили Донбасс за то что люди проживающие там были просто нацистов на своей родной земле, России около 8 лет пыталась решить этл проблему мирным путём , когда ещё были подписаны минские соглашения. До 2022 года на территории Донбасса не было не одного Российского солдата. После того как Жители Донбасса потеряли огромное количество людей и жителей , они были просто мучениками Киевского режима и его нациских идеалов. Единственное что они могли сделать это попросить Россию что та приняла их в свой состав и помогла раз и навсегда закончить эту войну. Представь эти люди 8 лет жили под обстрелами и каждый день прятались по подвалом своих же домов, но теперь их мучениям настал конец. Россия защитить их от Киева. Твоя прекрасная страна помогает и прикармливает нацистов, ваши ветераны 2 мировой войны отдали свои жизни просто так. Вы полностью уничтожили всё что было освобожденно кровью и мучениями нескольких миллионов человек. И вы за это заплатите, вы предатели не только себя , но даже закон божий. Вы полностью погрязли в дерьме от которого уже не сможете очиститься
This song has the same melody as Siberian Rifflemen (good thing)
I’m no anarchist, but damn it, what a nice song!
Beautiful idea... And failed... Because of Red Terror...
Vive la révolution!
Siberian riflemen march the same melody but the lyrics completely diffirent
reminds my of the The Partisan's Song
th-cam.com/video/zuMWjejSTlE/w-d-xo.html
@@Mrax_Taylorall have same melody
@@The_BadBasilisk Same language as well
🚩🚩🚩
ah the tune of Siberian Riflemen
You should've ended the song like the black army, on a sour note😥
I bet everyone here hates tankie s more then capitalists and fascists
Tankies are both: capitalists (state capitalism over actual socialism) and fascists ("marxism-leninism"/red fascism).
Now l'appel du grand lenine
Pas d'horreurs staliniennes ici
Lenin, the red nazi.
@@nestormakhno5902 🤮
Néstor Makhno I mean, if u were in Baltic states, the soviets were worse than the nazi because they were less bad than the red army, they saw nazi still as evil but not as evil
@@nestormakhno5902 wtf, are you telling me totalitarianism that was painted red is still totalitarianism? Western bourgeois propaganda!!! /s
Who was the real enemy? Denikin, Wrangel or Lenin, Trotsky? Of course Lenin and Trotsky...
You maight fought with Reds... Communists were youre best enemy...