Thank you all so much for your kind words! It's because of all these wonderful comments that I feel encouraged to share more of my music. You are truly inspiring! Please subscribe if you want to see more!
Bonjour, je vous découvre. Je suis un inconditionnel de Mark Knopfler et très critique envers les reprises de MK.mais je dois dire que vous m avez fait monter les larmes aux yeux. Il y a bien longtemps que je n avais pas écouté une guitariste (je ne sais pas si ça se dit)aussi virtuose. Je repose ma guitare et continue a écouter vos autres morceaux. Tout mon respect, MADAME. Eric de Nîmes
That is one of the lesser known masterpieces from MK. The interpretation is absolutely gorgeous. It speaks volumes about Knopfler writing. Of course, played by an elite classical guitarist is just magical. You made my day and I thank you!
Bonjour je suis un inconditionnel de Mark knopfler, et vous m'avez fait monter les larmes aux yeux. Je range ma guitare et je continue a visionner vos vidéos. Il y a très longtemps que je n avais pas écouté une guitariste aussi virtuose.tout mon respect,Madame. Eric de Nîmes
Hi Melanie, what a beautiful arrangement en very nice performance of this song. The controlled and relaxed way you play it calls in mind for me the "private investigations" of my inner self. The small vulcanic eruptions that occur in everyday life are smoothed out by acceptance and wisdom. In the end it will all work out.
I can see why this song had redemptive effects, it is a beautiful composition and you play it so well. Great tone and presentation, thanks for sharing! Bill
Goosebumps.... That Dire Straits album was one of my first CDs back in the 80s. I still remember listening to that song with headphones on, when the bass kicks in to the guitar, just before the vocals start. Such a wonderful instrumental cover. Thank you!
Bravo!!! Thank you for your life! I am Brazilian and I am a musician. Listening to you gives me shivers of happiness. Keep inspiring us all. Thank you very much.
Lorsque je vous écoute j'ai envie de poser définitivement ma guitare.... On se dit qu'un tel niveau est inaccessible, pourtant vous y êtes. Que c'est beau! Merci beaucoup!
Wow. Das kann man vermutlich nicht mehr besser machen. Absolut atemberaubend gespielt Melanie. Ich liebe diesen Song ebenfalls sehr und Deine Version berührt mich zutiefst. Weltklasse. Liebe Grüße, Jimmy
Ich weiß nicht wie oft ich diese phantastische Version von Private Investigations schon gesehen habe, aber ich weiß wie gut es tut sie zu hören und das diese Version von Melanie Goertz ein großariges Stück Musik ist und eine unwahrscheinlich phantastische Leistung das Stück so zu spielen. Großen Dank dafür
Thank you very much for this wonderful interpretation of this piece of music. Towards the end I heard fragments similar to those in the classical music of Johann Sebastian Bach. I've been a fan of Dire Straits and Mark Knopfler since 1978, and as I play the guitar myself (not nearly as well as you do), I can appreciate your skills very well. You play with a lot of feeling and empathy, which is very easy to hear.
Indeed it's a mystery for me, too. How do you do this so elegantly, expressive, emotional and relaxed, catching one's attention and mind? You have a wonderful arrangement and play it wonderfully. Melanie, you did it again, as always... my kudos to you! Happy to find such an end for my day, thank you very much 😊
Oh Melanie what a Wonderful Cover !!!!💯💕 It caused in my the same effect that I expereinced the first time I listened to this song !!!! You make the Cover sound of Yours ;. Congratulations ! Greetings from Argentina!💯💕!
Your playing has something really special ... it goes deep inside ... from 2:52 onwards it seems that you are telling the outcome of the private investigations 😉.... smile a little , everything is beautiful around you . Almost forgot .. 🌹
Congratulations on an exquisite performance. You are one of the clearest players I have ever heard on a classical guitar. Your intonation is impeccable. Truly talented. Thank you so much for sharing.
Thanks for sharing great music on the acoustic. True about Mark Knopfler. Not exactly this song song for me, but I relate to how his music has carried me through really difficult parts of my life. Still does.
I think this is your best yet. I have studied playing MK songs for many years and just wonderful to hear them played in a classical guitar format. Your recording sound is spot on.
So glad i subscribed. Sometimes it takes another person's arrangement to bring out aspects of a piece of music you had not hitherto heard. Wonderful arrangement. Beautiful sensitive playing.
Fantastic Melanie, I have always thought of this song as a solo classical guitar piece, you made it sound so good, I hope you keep giving us more from Mark, maybe one of his solo songs too? Golden Heart would sound great. Have you ever thought about some Mike Oldfield tracks?
Thank you all so much for your kind words! It's because of all these wonderful comments that I feel encouraged to share more of my music. You are truly inspiring!
Please subscribe if you want to see more!
My god , such memories this song ! Well Done Melanie ! Life bless you 🫶🏼
Bonjour, je vous découvre. Je suis un inconditionnel de Mark Knopfler et très critique envers les reprises de MK.mais je dois dire que vous m avez fait monter les larmes aux yeux. Il y a bien longtemps que je n avais pas écouté une guitariste (je ne sais pas si ça se dit)aussi virtuose. Je repose ma guitare et continue a écouter vos autres morceaux. Tout mon respect, MADAME. Eric de Nîmes
Keep sharing.... beautiful playing
Lesser known????
This album sold millions
Yeah it’s certainly well known and loved by many. You play it beautifully.
Brings back memories of when I had 'Alchemy' on double Cassette!
Scarred for life...no compensation. Private...Investigations :)
...on double LP...
That is one of the lesser known masterpieces from MK. The interpretation is absolutely gorgeous. It speaks volumes about Knopfler writing. Of course, played by an elite classical guitarist is just magical. You made my day and I thank you!
Bonjour je suis un inconditionnel de Mark knopfler, et vous m'avez fait monter les larmes aux yeux. Je range ma guitare et je continue a visionner vos vidéos. Il y a très longtemps que je n avais pas écouté une guitariste aussi virtuose.tout mon respect,Madame. Eric de Nîmes
Hi Melanie, what a beautiful arrangement en very nice performance of this song. The controlled and relaxed way you play it calls in mind for me the "private investigations" of my inner self. The small vulcanic eruptions that occur in everyday life are smoothed out by acceptance and wisdom. In the end it will all work out.
I can see why this song had redemptive effects, it is a beautiful composition and you play it so well. Great tone and presentation, thanks for sharing! Bill
A soothing ear massage that takes mind and body to some euphoric state rarely visited. More please.....
I wish I had a millionth of your talent then I would call myself good. Awesome performance. Well done. Love and blessings from South Africa.🇿🇦🇿🇦🤗🤗
Goosebumps.... That Dire Straits album was one of my first CDs back in the 80s. I still remember listening to that song with headphones on, when the bass kicks in to the guitar, just before the vocals start.
Such a wonderful instrumental cover. Thank you!
Bravo!!! Thank you for your life! I am Brazilian and I am a musician. Listening to you gives me shivers of happiness. Keep inspiring us all. Thank you very much.
Lorsque je vous écoute j'ai envie de poser définitivement ma guitare.... On se dit qu'un tel niveau est inaccessible, pourtant vous y êtes. Que c'est beau! Merci beaucoup!
There are not words to say how wonderful you performed 🎶✨💫
I discovered you today. What a dream. One of my favourite song of dire straits. Amazing. Thanks.
Fully dressed and just shredding on the guitar! This is how it's done! Love it!
Great Mélanie ! I am a big fan of Mark and it is why I play guitare just for the feelings and you respect this
love you
Tof
Wow. Das kann man vermutlich nicht mehr besser machen. Absolut atemberaubend gespielt Melanie. Ich liebe diesen Song ebenfalls sehr und Deine Version berührt mich zutiefst. Weltklasse. Liebe Grüße, Jimmy
Beautiful and perfect. I can´t believe that M. Knopfler has played this since it is more classic and so different to his common playing style.
Just goes to show what a musical genius he is.
Beautifully played and incredibly soothing to the ear and soul.🙏
Brilliant and beautiful ! Another great cover after Brothers in arms and Local Hero, and i was waiting for this ! thanks
It's a mystery to me. The game commences. For the usual fee-plus expenses. Beautiful!
your channel is so underrated... thumbs up... your description...done exactly that several times
Breathtakingly beautiful playing. Simply stunning...
Yes you perform a beautiful ode to the composer/artist of this masterpiece 👏🏼👏🏼💫🎶 Thanks for sharing 🙏🏽
Thank you Rob!
Ich weiß nicht wie oft ich diese phantastische Version von Private Investigations schon gesehen habe, aber ich weiß wie gut es tut sie zu hören und das diese Version von Melanie Goertz ein großariges Stück Musik ist und eine unwahrscheinlich phantastische Leistung das Stück so zu spielen. Großen Dank dafür
Simply beautiful wonderful playing and this piece makes me think of my past in a good way...
Thank you, and indeed, the good old times!
Thank You! One of my all time favorites played beautifully!
C’est tout simple brillant, remarquable, magnifique…. Bravo et merci ❤
Awesome amazing player woman. Many many thanks for your interpretation and performance.
So beautifully played with great empathy. Thank you.
One of my favourites by MK ……. Lovely interpretation 😊
That was absolutely beautiful. 😊
This song sounds very nice on a classical guitar. Beautiful interpretation.
Wonderful. Touch the soul.
Thank you very much for this wonderful interpretation of this piece of music. Towards the end I heard fragments similar to those in the classical music of Johann Sebastian Bach. I've been a fan of Dire Straits and Mark Knopfler since 1978, and as I play the guitar myself (not nearly as well as you do), I can appreciate your skills very well. You play with a lot of feeling and empathy, which is very easy to hear.
Masterful interpretation! Thank you Melanie, this is such a beautiful and accurate interpretation / arrangement of the original. Just lovely.
Indeed it's a mystery for me, too. How do you do this so elegantly, expressive, emotional and relaxed, catching one's attention and mind? You have a wonderful arrangement and play it wonderfully. Melanie, you did it again, as always... my kudos to you! Happy to find such an end for my day, thank you very much 😊
Thank you. Your interpretation is sublime.
there are many guitar renditions of this song on youtube but your one is the best of those I've seen. Very warm, very clean. Brava.
Wow! Classical guitar with some groove!
Thank you Melanie, nice playing! I love how you picked up the sound of your guitar in the room - sounds really nice.
Wow I love you ❤
Wunderschön!👏🎸🎶👍🌅
Vielen Dank Detlev!
This is quite complex, and you play it beautifully while making it sound easy. Very well done!
This has to be the most relaxed, absolutely spot on version I have ever heard, my heart says thank you........wow!
when I die, I want you to play this on my funeral. 🙂
Oh Melanie what a Wonderful Cover !!!!💯💕 It caused in my the same effect that I expereinced the first time I listened to this song !!!! You make the Cover sound of Yours ;. Congratulations ! Greetings from Argentina!💯💕!
Your playing has something really special ... it goes deep inside ... from 2:52 onwards it seems that you are telling the outcome of the private investigations 😉.... smile a little , everything is beautiful around you . Almost forgot .. 🌹
Commencez ma journée par vous c'était Super Doux et beau à entendre Merci.......je vais vous suivre..🙊🙉🙈
❤😊
Congratulations on an exquisite performance. You are one of the clearest players I have ever heard on a classical guitar. Your intonation is impeccable. Truly talented. Thank you so much for sharing.
I’m not sure how I fell on your channel but I immediately subscribed hoping you never stop.
Outstanding!
This is also so beautiful.. I wish the best for you. Cheers!
A beautiful performance Melanie.🙏🎸🎸
Thank you David! Let's fill 2024 with a lot of guitar music!
Definately!! 😊😊@@MelanieGoertz
Thanks for sharing great music on the acoustic. True about Mark Knopfler. Not exactly this song song for me, but I relate to how his music has carried me through really difficult parts of my life. Still does.
Brilliant....made my year so far. A real joy to listen to
Really nailed that
You’re welcome Melanie. You’re a wonderful musician 🙏🏽🎶
Magnificent playing and arrangement
Extremely beautiful
I think this is your best yet. I have studied playing MK songs for many years and just wonderful to hear them played in a classical guitar format. Your recording sound is spot on.
Calidad indiscutible. Gran interpretación. Enhorabuena.
Julio.
Well done Melanie, this is almost like a classical piece. Also good that I don't have to strain my ears to hear the softly spoken lyrics.
A true masterpiece beautifully pereformed!!
Pięknie (beautiful).
Beautiful as with all you do, thank you
OUTSTANDING!....
Hermoso , realmente hermoso , gracias por este hermosa cancion , saludos desde Buenos Aires - Argentina
Wow 😢
LOVE YOU this is pure magic!!!
Complimenti ! Adoro questo pezzo. ❤️
Best cover of this song I've ever heard.
a stunning arrangement, beautifully played
😊Yet another wonderful interpretation. Thank you for showing it here. Love the way you make my day.
I really love it Melanie ❤
Amazing!!! Bravo!!!👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
That was awesome! 🙌👏👏👏
very beautiful.
Beautiful piece played beautifully. Really nice. Thanks.
I only can say 'wow'! Diep onder de indruk...
Danke schön. Merci et bravo
Un grand bravo pour cette performance.
Nice playing Melanie! 👏🏼👏🏼
So glad i subscribed. Sometimes it takes another person's arrangement to bring out aspects of a piece of music you had not hitherto heard. Wonderful arrangement. Beautiful sensitive playing.
Very good!!! Nice to hear You.
Very cool and so clear ! Outstanding performance ! Thank you very much !
Magnifique. Tellement d’émotions. Vous avez touché mon cœur ♥️. Masterpiece 👏✨✨✨
Fantastic Melanie, I have always thought of this song as a solo classical guitar piece, you made it sound so good, I hope you keep giving us more from Mark, maybe one of his solo songs too? Golden Heart would sound great. Have you ever thought about some Mike Oldfield tracks?
Gorgeous!
Thank you!
How the Heck are you so talented unbelievable ❤
Soo great. I've been listening to Mark Knopfler's music for most of my life. I love your versions and playing. Thank you!
Sei semplicemente incantevole, ti ascolterei per ore... complimenti
Mesmerizing rendition.
Почему мало лайков? Шикарное исполнение!!!
Meravigliosa esecuzione 🌹
Wonderful interpretation, it would be nice to have the transcription in tab
Just thank you
sincerely
d
❤❤❤👏👏👏
Beautiful❤
❤❤❤❤❤
remarkable, another masterpiece made out of the original song
Perfect, Where can I find the score? please
Awsome, live it, Thank You!
Très belle interprétation