Emma's love getting a whole underworld arch and then coming back while robin just disappears and his death is barely dealt with....the writers make me so maddd
In a show that always does flashbacks and has characters always willing to bend the laws of magic. there's always a chance of seeing people again. Yes this episode was bittersweet as you lost one and gained one but Regina did say in season 4 that her happiness was not a man but feeling at home in the world.
I both loved and hated this episode I loved that Hook was able to come back but Robin should of been able to come back too him and Regina deserved their happily ever after also.
this theory is totally wrong... hook will get his he, gold too and the biggest problem is that also the evil queen and spoiler alert 6th season!!!!! ...and evil Robin hood will have. they simply didn't know what to do with the carachter and killed him
NOT THE GTA EDIT LOOLLLLLL. Yeah I was peeved too. I'm STILL mad what happened to Robin. Like, bro didn't just die he was MEGA ULTRA ERASED. Honestly, the reasoning for Hook's return narratively works just fine for me. I thought it was done well and made sense, and as much as I love the tragic hand-hold at the elevator, I think I still would've preferred if he had gotten the ambrosia and gotten out that way. But like, Hook was my only reason to still watch this show anymore haha. I liked Robin AND Hook a lot, I love Regina and Robin. As salty as I am with Robin's conclusion, I sure ain't upset Hook came back. I might as well have one of the characters I like not die, even better it's my fave. Ngl tho, bro has several levels of plot armor for sure, but! He is a survivor after all xD
I agree with u, I hate this episode. before this episode aired, I knew robin was gonna die cause some fans outside watched them film a lot of outside scenes and 2 of them tweeted that there is a funeral scene and we saw a bts pic on Instagram of the whole cast together besides Sean being in it so we was ugh it’s robin who dies
2:41 This comment makes me wonder, have you ever seen the show The Good Place? Because to put in in non-spoilery terms that's a concept that is brought up and considered multiple times in the show. (If you haven't seen it, it's definitely worth a watch either to react to or just for your enjoyment outside the context of the channel). Also, Robin 😢
Hook is god’s gift to women. 😉 As for how it’s fair. Well, it wasn’t exactly fair when Regina crushed Graham’s heart and he died in Emma’s arms. It also wasn’t fair when Zelena caused Neal’s death and he died in Emma’s arms. So Regina and Zelena have now lost both the men they loved and Emma has the man she loves back. Sounds to me like long overdue karma. 🤷♂️
Yeah, ever since Emma said she was going to the underworld in the mid season finale (in a very airy un-emmary voice, I might add), the whole plot the series fell apart.
She did watch it, but only just before she started watching Season 7 as nobody ever informed her about it. I accidentally stumbled on it and told her about it. (also, just a side note as it's a pet peeve of hers when people spell her name wrong and so I have to point it out, It's Shannan with an A)
There are many who still don't understand why Killian came back and Robin died and wasn't brought back to life as Killian. it's because kilian helped from the underworld where he belonged hades and i don't deny it robin also helped and it was unfair that they took his life but he helped from the earth and killian was the one who found the pages of the book. In a few words he was the one who solved everything and it was unfair that Robin died and Killian came back a few minutes later, but Zeus did it as a favor because he really deserved it and defeated Hades, that's why they gave Killian more credit
yep yep. I'm as upset as everyone else what they did to Robin, Loved him and Regina. But I sure as hell wasn't complaining that Hook came back. I might as well get someone lol. Plus he was the sole reason I was still watching if I'm being honest
i was waiting for this specific episode for a long time lmaoo. one of the most controversial especially when the show was on air. We were fine with both hook and robin dying because the fandom thought this might be a way for swanqueen to become a reality but the writers immediately ruined that by bringing hook back. i hated the story in this episode but the actors made me love it equally. props to the actors in the show tbh, they're so talented.
I get people wanted swanqueen and people are totally allowed to ship I just get annoyed that people acted like they were queerbaited and that if Hook and Robin were gone they would get Emma and Regina there were no plans to ever make them happen. Some were actually sending death threats to the writers it was insane.
@@darkcrazybeautiful89 I hate that too. Nobody is entitled to their ship just because they want it. I really preferred Emma and Neil, but it wasn't to be, and I moved on. Also, why can a female friendship not be a good thing all on its own? I never understood that, especially since Emma and Regina are one of the best friendships I've seen on TV.
Don't worry! Robin Hood actor will be back in season 6! I will not give any spoilers cuz I know you don't like those! However he's no longer a main character so when he does come back he's just guest starring for a couple episodes! It will also be midway through the season so you're going to have to wait 9 episodes or so!
I though you were excited seeing hook, i know you like that carachter. but i'm happy you are not, because it is the proof that that situation sucks. even for that not hating him like me. ps: i don't undersand the repeated scenes. why?
This épisode représents everything that killed thé show for me... Thé show died when it became thé captainswan show and didny Care about anything rlse... Thats why Season 7 was thé best Season of thé last 4 BY FAR
@@AfterShowReactions really ? I liked it personnally i thought thé New characters were really cool and finally some fresh air from thé old same characters that thé show didnt even use anyway xD I Mean yeah thé storyline was weird sometimes but Season was trash anyway si cant bé worse... And thé finale of Season 7 was a much better show finale than Season 6 for me too xD
Emma's love getting a whole underworld arch and then coming back while robin just disappears and his death is barely dealt with....the writers make me so maddd
‘Regina, you are my future.’ 😭😭😭why did they do that !!! Great reaction btw !
Killing off Robin was one of the most unnecessary things and then dare to bring back Hook minutes after Robins funeral that was just disrespectful
In a show that always does flashbacks and has characters always willing to bend the laws of magic. there's always a chance of seeing people again. Yes this episode was bittersweet as you lost one and gained one but Regina did say in season 4 that her happiness was not a man but feeling at home in the world.
I both loved and hated this episode I loved that Hook was able to come back but Robin should of been able to come back too him and Regina deserved their happily ever after also.
This is a tragic moment and all... but damn, your "about this MUCH to cry voice" is hilarious
Fun fact Lana who plays Regina is best friends with Rebecca mader and Sean Maguire to this day
Girl I was so mad that they killed Robin.
As rumple says to his father few EPs ago, villains don't get happy endings, so they killed of robin so Regina doesn't get a happy ending again
this theory is totally wrong... hook will get his he, gold too and the biggest problem is that also the evil queen and
spoiler alert 6th season!!!!!
...and evil Robin hood will have.
they simply didn't know what to do with the carachter and killed him
Never been so offended? Buffy seeing red.
NOT THE GTA EDIT LOOLLLLLL.
Yeah I was peeved too. I'm STILL mad what happened to Robin. Like, bro didn't just die he was MEGA ULTRA ERASED. Honestly, the reasoning for Hook's return narratively works just fine for me. I thought it was done well and made sense, and as much as I love the tragic hand-hold at the elevator, I think I still would've preferred if he had gotten the ambrosia and gotten out that way. But like, Hook was my only reason to still watch this show anymore haha. I liked Robin AND Hook a lot, I love Regina and Robin. As salty as I am with Robin's conclusion, I sure ain't upset Hook came back. I might as well have one of the characters I like not die, even better it's my fave.
Ngl tho, bro has several levels of plot armor for sure, but! He is a survivor after all xD
I agree with u, I hate this episode. before this episode aired, I knew robin was gonna die cause some fans outside watched them film a lot of outside scenes and 2 of them tweeted that there is a funeral scene and we saw a bts pic on Instagram of the whole cast together besides Sean being in it so we was ugh it’s robin who dies
2:41 This comment makes me wonder, have you ever seen the show The Good Place? Because to put in in non-spoilery terms that's a concept that is brought up and considered multiple times in the show. (If you haven't seen it, it's definitely worth a watch either to react to or just for your enjoyment outside the context of the channel).
Also, Robin 😢
I've reacted to all of the good place on patreon :) it was selected by patrons and its $2 if you wanted to check it out :)
Hook is god’s gift to women. 😉
As for how it’s fair. Well, it wasn’t exactly fair when Regina crushed Graham’s heart and he died in Emma’s arms. It also wasn’t fair when Zelena caused Neal’s death and he died in Emma’s arms. So Regina and Zelena have now lost both the men they loved and Emma has the man she loves back. Sounds to me like long overdue karma. 🤷♂️
Bruh
By this point in the series I was only there for Hook. So pretty...
Yeah, ever since Emma said she was going to the underworld in the mid season finale (in a very airy un-emmary voice, I might add), the whole plot the series fell apart.
Oh! Does anyone know if Shannan reacted to “A Knight With Cruella” dvd extra scene after this arc? She would have such a great reaction to it.
She did watch it, but only just before she started watching Season 7 as nobody ever informed her about it. I accidentally stumbled on it and told her about it. (also, just a side note as it's a pet peeve of hers when people spell her name wrong and so I have to point it out, It's Shannan with an A)
@@TonyWasHere My bad on the typo lol. Thank you.
There are many who still don't understand why Killian came back and Robin died and wasn't brought back to life as Killian. it's because kilian helped from the underworld where he belonged hades and i don't deny it robin also helped and it was unfair that they took his life but he helped from the earth and killian was the one who found the pages of the book. In a few words he was the one who solved everything and it was unfair that Robin died and Killian came back a few minutes later, but Zeus did it as a favor because he really deserved it and defeated Hades, that's why they gave Killian more credit
yep yep. I'm as upset as everyone else what they did to Robin, Loved him and Regina. But I sure as hell wasn't complaining that Hook came back. I might as well get someone lol. Plus he was the sole reason I was still watching if I'm being honest
Blah blah blah
good episode
i was waiting for this specific episode for a long time lmaoo. one of the most controversial especially when the show was on air. We were fine with both hook and robin dying because the fandom thought this might be a way for swanqueen to become a reality but the writers immediately ruined that by bringing hook back. i hated the story in this episode but the actors made me love it equally. props to the actors in the show tbh, they're so talented.
I get people wanted swanqueen and people are totally allowed to ship I just get annoyed that people acted like they were queerbaited and that if Hook and Robin were gone they would get Emma and Regina there were no plans to ever make them happen. Some were actually sending death threats to the writers it was insane.
@@darkcrazybeautiful89 yeah this was when the fanbase became really toxic because it was a three-way ship war.
@@darkcrazybeautiful89 I hate that too. Nobody is entitled to their ship just because they want it. I really preferred Emma and Neil, but it wasn't to be, and I moved on. Also, why can a female friendship not be a good thing all on its own? I never understood that, especially since Emma and Regina are one of the best friendships I've seen on TV.
Don't worry! Robin Hood actor will be back in season 6! I will not give any spoilers cuz I know you don't like those! However he's no longer a main character so when he does come back he's just guest starring for a couple episodes! It will also be midway through the season so you're going to have to wait 9 episodes or so!
I though you were excited seeing hook, i know you like that carachter.
but i'm happy you are not, because it is the proof that that situation sucks.
even for that not hating him like me.
ps: i don't undersand the repeated scenes. why?
This épisode représents everything that killed thé show for me... Thé show died when it became thé captainswan show and didny Care about anything rlse...
Thats why Season 7 was thé best Season of thé last 4 BY FAR
Nodding in agreement
This comment just broke my brain. Season 7 is an absolute fucking mess.
Nodding in agreement
@@AfterShowReactions really ? I liked it personnally i thought thé New characters were really cool and finally some fresh air from thé old same characters that thé show didnt even use anyway xD
I Mean yeah thé storyline was weird sometimes but Season was trash anyway si cant bé worse...
And thé finale of Season 7 was a much better show finale than Season 6 for me too xD
Completely agree
God I can't believe the thing the bolt and rumple got it and wake up Bella with and keep the magic god I hate him so much