Persona 3 Original VS Reload Battle Gameplay comparison / ペルソナ3 オリジナルvsリロード, バトルパート比較
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ก.ย. 2024
- Persona 3 Original (2006) VS Reload (2024) Battle Gameplay comparison
ペルソナ3 オリジナルvsリロード, バトルパート比較
©ATLUS ©SEGA
他のペルソナの動画
• Persona 5 the Royal VS...
Spike Rickey (スパイク・リッキー) Subscribe / チャンネル登録
/ @spikerickey446
Twitter
sp...
#P3R#persona3reload#persona3#comparison
#ペルソナ3#ペルソナ3リロード#リメイク#比較
I love how they make's the personas interact with each other instead of makoto get naked for a second and then screams.
i miss makoto randomly gettn shirtless (is he naked?) lowkey
I miss the shooting animation for og though
@@anon3600he technically still does that with you switch persona’s
@@XenoPlayerP3 No I meant for the fusion spells how his whole head cocks back
being able to see makoto walking off stage during the jack bros theurgy is honestly such a funny little touch
Dude I’m so glad they kept Ken yeeting his entire body around his spear like a maniac
How does he even do that I feel like the spear should just fold sideways
@@kirbywithaknifeisawesome6028 anime magic
@@kirbywithaknifeisawesome6028 maybe its kinda the same logic with pole vaulting. I wouldn’t know tho I’m just making an assumption cuz I don’t know how pole vaulting works
I appreciate that you recorded all the animations in its original resolution and hardware, makes it look a little more nostalgic in a way.
@@mirel2829 I did not consider that, and stand corrected if that's the case
Its stiill so funny how king frost just pushes makoto out of the camera lmao
King Frost: OUT OF THE WAY PEON! THE KING IS HERE!
Black Jack: Hey, King! Those guys right there called you fat.
King Frost: WHAT?!?
King Frost: THAT'S IT! DEATH BY SNOWMEN!
@@LostArk78 ⛄️
3:19 bros like “you guys do your podcast I’m leaving…”
It's a Manzai (Japanese comedy) routine, that's why the effect is a knock down, the enemies laughed their asses off and fell over
Either that or it was so ba they fel over @@dumpsterplayer5133
@@dumpsterplayer5133 I always saw it as that face fault trope. Like, their jokes were so bad and unfunny the enemies fall over. A good example being the Pokemon anime, when Ash makes a "Cowterpie" joke. Pikachu and Misty's reactions are what I'm referring to.
*teleports to his previous location*
I especially like the new crit animation for Aigis and Yukari
Definetly a lot better than literally just zooming close to the characters
Is more dynamic I think
Is good
Old crit animations were still insane though, that dynamic camera angle for Yukari got me hyped every single time.
3:19 I love how Makoto just walk away lol
They got it handled
"Take the scene, Jack bros!"
The win screens after winning with an all-out attack goes so hard
It's the same as P5.
@@Nepgearafbut better
The Mass Destruction behind them all look awesome as well
@@Nepgearaf it's literally not. P5 has a small dance and or animation, then goes to a very detailed splash screen. P3r has characters go from finishing all out attack, with no special animation after the AoA, and goes to a clvery clean and cool screen. Functionally it's the same, but not in execution
@@TimothyGod A lot of this game is very similar to P5. They couldn't even give us The Answer, without charging for dlc on-top of 70$. Animated cutscenes are fine because the original weren't hard to top. The ingame 3d model cutscenes, running animations, etc, it's just all P5 feeling and weak to me. We can agree to disagree that the game has some cashcow vibes. I completely get it, P5 has more fans than the amount of old fans over the past 2 and a half decades. They are clearly going to cater to you.
They made Aigis into a magical girl and I love it
She is, magical girl with in-built gun
Honestly, she was giving off more Kamen Rider vibes than anything else.
I don’t, prefer the original way more
The only thing I missed about the old Persona is the fail to kill off enemy with the All Out Attack.
Originally, when the AOA failed everyone who rush into the dust got pushed out, but they stand up and rush in again. That animation always hilarious for me.
Too bad that got removed in Reload, I guess it was the director’s choice but I wish they still keep it.
It will look funny tbh. With that skull smoke if success haha.
THANK YOU . You just reminded me of that, it's been almost a decade since I played original P3
Aww, I totally forgot about that! Thanks
i was soooo loking forward to it 😢 i was so sad when i waited and nobody got pushed out lmao
Hombre,te agradezco de hacerme acordar de ese pequeño pero buen detalle del juego,me hacia reir mucho al verlo
Man, it's scary how good Atlus made Reload look. I wonder what else they'll do.
They cold do a remake from Persona 1 and 2, though. But... forget it...
@@RafaelRodrigues-yx4hp but they'll probably do P4 first. P4 is just the safer choice.
@@RafaelRodrigues-yx4hp I'd be down, I've never even seen content from p1 or p2, minus maybe the protags.
@@mako8091 Yes indeed.
@@RafaelRodrigues-yx4hp the credible leaker said there are some works on Persona 2 at Atlus, but didn't specify. They could already be making it, or just in talks if it's worth it.
Tho imagine the first two games in modern graphics, with modern Persona systems added. We can dream.
For Persona 1, I think they would do it around this time if they would want to, as Nanjo group is connected to Kirijo Group as well so would fit with the theme.
最初のカットイン、ベイベベイベと合わせてるの好き
Only thing I miss about The original is The recoil when using Fusion Spells
Oh there is recoil. Just only with one of the fusion spells, and WAY WORSE then visual!
@@sonnitude end game yukari with 11sp mediarahan goes hard
Agree - it looks so cool when his entire torso goes back
The Decarabia and Forneus skill is a recreation of OG P3 which is a reference to SMT3 Nocturne
Cant believe the persona guys are so humble do give a shout-out to less popular games!
Didn't even notice. That's neat
They have a really sad story in Nocturne as well, with you meeting Decarabia as an NPC who is going to visit his friend Forneus, who is the first boss. After you kill him, you find Decarabia in the overworld still looking for Forneus.
3:39 ここほんと可愛すぎて無理笑笑主人公笑笑笑笑笑笑
The funny thing is there being 2 Lokis if you have the dlc
Ah yes, "Loki" and "LOKI!"
I'm a firm believer that the ice giant Loki is better than Akechi's Loki. Akechi's Loki only fit in P5/P5R. It feels outta place in any other game
One is "Loki" and the other is "Come, LOKI!!!"
@@monkey_blu I cant read this without hearing it
18年の時を経て漫才がウケるようになったジャックブラザーズ
長い下積みの成果が…！
3年生組の勝利後カットインが本当に好きすぎる
I like how the Jack brothers even messed. It was just a bad skill in the original game
Early to mid game, the new Jack Brothers is the GOAT for Gatekeepers. Somehow, without fail, always downed enemies for me.
This skill (or should I call it "item") saved my ass in portable a few times though
真田先輩はペルソナ出すとき左手の銃から弾丸(？)を受けるために顔が若干左手側に傾くけどリロード版だとそれがカットインにも反映されていて細かい、独自性も生まれてる
Definitely miss Shinji cranium smashing the shadow in his Crit animation
ジャックブラザーズで歩いていく主人公がなんかかわいい
お前は司会進行か
と思った
Victory screens are such a massive improvement dabg
Crazy how much better and smoother Reload looks
Well, this what happens when you upgrade from RenderWare engine to Unreal 4 engine. That is right. Reload is powered by Unreal 4. In fact, kind of explains why it is easy to mod.
変化をすぐに感じられる動画構成素晴らしい👏最高です
Really wish they changed it so Ken stopped dropping the spear after October 4th.
I read somewhere that he keeps dropping the spear cuz of his height. So his resolve wouldn't stop that from happening
@@rjgamehead True enough, but in P3 FES he didn't drop it either
The cutin animations are still the coolest thing I've ever seen
Might be one of the best P3 comparisons on TH-cam!
*Mitsuru steps on Shadow* God I wish that was me
Same 😭
Same ngl
これほどリメイクが成功したって言える作品、なかなか他には無いと思うよね…。
This is how a remake should be. Absolutely perfect in every way
1:34 as an elementary school kid I would have never be able to move like that
I love how the song say "so kneel down" in the exact moment Makoto destroy the world with the armageddon.
この差を感じられるのも楽しみの一つだからオリジナルもやっててよかったって思った ミックスレイド嬉しい
Persona 3 reload is my first ever persona game I’ve played. Tried getting into 5 but couldn’t bother past the first 5 minutes. P3 reload has changed my perspective. I’m obsessed. I love the aesthetic, the music, the story, and I love how they shoot themselves for their powers 🤣 it’s so subversive. Might make me get into P5 again
You should try P4 next! And then try 5 again. I promise that if you like persona 3 you’ll like persona 4
It was the total opposite for me. I started on p5 $20 from walmart. Then 4 golden and p3 for ps2. Reload is my goty
Persona games are generally hard to get into. You have to get pass the early grind of getting through story stuff. Personally, got into Persona with 4 (OG 4). Then went back to Persona 3 with Persona 3 FES. I tried to play Persona 1 but I couldn't get into it. Nothing against Persona 1 and even 2. Just hope they do remake them. Even if Persona 1 and 2 are VERY dark. Far darker than 3-4-5 together. And 4 does have some rather dark moments. Damn...may just play P4G after I finish P3R and play P5R for the 20th time. Personally P5 is my favorite as I like the MC. Then, again, P4 MC is great too. But, being bias as P4 was my first Persona entry.
5 is better
@@RandyButternubs117he-hell naw
Just realized Ken and Shinji do the same spinning move to jump attack as the final hit for their crit in Reload. Cool little connection there.
I love how Makoto does real fencing movements when landing a crit in Reload.
From Makoto, when he finished, I expected the phrase like "I Don't Care"
You can tell they went all out to make reload as amazing as they could
nunca me di cuenta que junpei cuando pega un critico, pega como si fuese un bate de béisbol, eso lo hace 10000 veces más genial 💜
UPGRADES PEOPLE, UPGRADES!!!
i like how ken's crit animation is somewhat similar to shinji's
I wish you included Aigis’s crit animation in Orgia mode, because it does change in P3 Reload
I didn’t notice until watching this that King Frost straight up runs Makoto over when he appears omg
Brooooooooo, this is lit wow fantastic cut-in summoning too
I just noticed that Ken and Shinji both spin their weapons at the end of their critical hit in Reload.
原作は原作で味があって好きだけど、グラフィック本当に綺麗になったなー。
ゆかりと荒垣先輩のクリティカルはリロード版がすごい好き。
I wonder why Thunder Call (Thor and Take-Mikazuchi) wasn't remade for Theurgy?
I think because in FES and Portable, Shock was the guaranteed crit status. That’s been moved to Freeze, so having a theugy with guaranteed shock probably wouldn’t be as useful. Then again they kept Jack brothers so who am I to judge what goes through Atlus heads?
@@sonnitudehaha ooooh so THATS why i dont crit when hitting shocked enemies smh lol I gotta update my info 😭
Didn't they give it to Akihiko's Theurgy?
Similar but not his @@dariel4122
It likely be added when "The Answer" is added in September as a DLC. After all, as much as people were upset that "The Answer" was not apart of the release. I can understand why they didn't. After all. They have to redo everything, basically. Upgrading from the RenderWare engine to the Unreal 4 engine is not that simple. They have to redo models and scenes. Reason why Reloaded is pretty much a "Remake" than a "Remaster". It is not a simple 1 to 1 upgrade.
Still, Thunder Call, likely be added as a Theurgy. But do not hold me to that. I am not an insider.
2:39 Icon of Aigis change its color to blue and starts sparling when entered orgia mod, nice little detail
I love how finally Fuuka gets some action..
Fuuka and Rise needs to be shown in action more
I can't wait for person 4 remake
I really love this remaster definitely going to buy it
Btw, how is the song called?
the song is "its going down now"
You mean remake?
Persona 3 Reload is a Remake. They basically built the game from the ground up in the Unreal 4 engine. As the original game was built in the RenderWare engine. Which was good at the time of the PS2 and other consoles. But it is a few decades old and they could not pull off what they did with Reload in that engine. This is the reason why the FES story "The Answer" was not apart of the launch and will be its own DLC in September. All because they have to rebuild the game. Likely add story elements they didn't add in the original release. Sure people are salty, but if they educate themselves. They would realize that Altus literally used a whole new game engine to make this game. Something you do not simply plug and play and get rich. They had to rebuild the game from the ground up, mostly.
Also, rumor mill claims they are doing a remake of Persona 4 within the same engine. Which personally. I am all for. Though I am bias, being I got into Persona with P4. Cause at the time it caught my interest more than P3's original release. Now though, I respect P3. The story is wild.
@Qardo God I'd be happy if they do..
Still hoping P3 Reload comes unto the Switch...
The one thing I think I missed from the old fusion spell animations is that the character always did the animation by doing “the point”.
I’ve always believed that it’s entirely on purpose that’s the pose he always strikes
I hope for persona six to go a college setting route maybe with the protag as a detective and even use krensnik as the protag's main person. Since if the rumors are true black and white would fit perfect for krensik/Kudnik to be used.
nice editing
美鶴先輩あんだけフルーレで刺しといてクリティカル演出踏みつけなの女帝の貫禄すぎる
いいね！
I really hope they remake P4 next.
They could call it like Persona 4 Rewatch or something like that.
I think the possibility of this is high since Persona 5R, Persona 3R and "R" are coming. I think it's good to rewatch, that is, to watch it again.
Or Retake, Review, Rewind, Retell? But if it stick to the theme of "Finding the Truth" then it could be Realize, Revelation, or something like that with Re in front of it🤣
Persona 4 Rewind, Seeker, Rewatch, Recorded. Take your pick
To fit the tv theme, they could call it Persona 4: Re-Run
Why remaking Persona 4? What things should be improved and optimised for a Persona 4 remake?
this is freakin awesome
The intro was clean
2:17 when the beat drops at the perfect time ahh moments
Back when the original Persona 3 came out, it was considered one of the best-looking PS2 games out there. But comparing it to Reload, it looks downright primitive. It's amazing what 11 years of technological evolution can accomplish.
Orgia mode is the coolest theurgy and my mind cannot be changed
A true Re-MASTER!
not at all, its a true remake, not a remaster. two different things by definition, look it up
@@rellertrwouldn't that be the case here, as the gameplay is identical, just has more updated areas to explore?
@@TimothyGod not what a remaster means. The gameplay can remain unchanged but if the game has been RE MADE from the ground up, as in, working off of new code, built for a new engine and consisting out of 100% new assets, then it's a remake. If a game is built off of the original source code, and it just upgrades some assets like making low quality textures etc HD now, then it's a remaster.
@TimothyGod nope. A remaster is basically the exact same old game scaled up for a modern platform. The P3P port is a remaster, for example. A remake is an entirely new game made from the ground up, which is what P3R is.
@@rellertr fair enough
Is there any reason Aries got axed from persona 3? He was my early game phys persona in the original.
simply because they decided to replace some of the personas they don't have modern 3d models for with Personas they do have modern models for that weren't in the original P3. (And in this case they replaced Ares with Mithras)
@th0rrrrr Don't they have a 3d model for the DX2 game? I miss MG early spellcaster Dis from P4 and P3. They really should've added the models
@@loserinasuit7880they never use dx2 models in the console games. Probably because they are made to a different standard and because dx2 isn't technically an Atlus game, so idk if they'd even have easy access to them.
@th0rrrrr Yeah it's unfortunate they can't/don't use the Dx2 models, their are more demons in that game than their are in Reload, Royal, SMTV and SH2 combined.
Honestly kinda of a embarrassment on Atlus part.
@th0rrrrr I mean the models would still be the property of ATLUS. I'm just surprised they didn't bother to get more of the original roster.
always found it funny as hell how the protags get booty ass naked when they do a fusion spell, maybe my humor is broken
actually yeah it definitely is
Im loving this new battle theme song ❤
I wish they kept aegis more in line with her end fight animation. But of childlike cuteness to the shadow killing machine
God why did they added that jump element to Shinji's critical anim? Kinda makes the sequence less unique since Ken does the same thing...
And it makes it less badass since originally Shinji never wields his *two-handed* weapons with both arms
its kinda cool how ken can use the spear
Wow Koromaru in this critical hit reminded me a lot of the Canynes from Monster Hunter
Hey I was wondering since you did this, is there any way you could make a video with all the status ailment voicelines? Ex: akihiko p3r charmed "my heart...!" Or confused "whaaats.... going on?"
that intro is SO good
ミックスレイドもっと欲しかったなあ
にしてもすごい進化したな
You know? I actually hsve always wondered why makoto is the only one that is able to summon two personas at once
You forgot the footage of the protagonist using the other weapon types.
@@avelvett
It was "saying it like it exists in the hopes to make it actually exist".
@@avelvett
In Persona 3 FES, the protagonist could use every weapon type (except for guns and knives), feature that I really wanted to also be present in the remake. As such, my original comment was made in a way that assumes the feature is present in the remake, in the hopes that it really did, but alas, it doesn't, and the protagonist can only use "One handed swords"...
リメイクらしいリメイクだったな
ラストも含めて
1:02 I really think Mitsuru's FES animation was better than the Reload one.
While Reload adds a close-up to the character's expression and particles, I do not like how the movements stop at moments. It makes the whole action look a little bit generic. The FES version, however, cleverly connects all the slashes, with synchronized movements that Mitsuru makes along with a short, yet powerful stomp that serves like a finisher. While Reload makes more emphasis, it lacks the fluidity of FES.
Honestly, the old animations look a lot smoother and the timing of the "critical" is more consistent with the end of the attack. I especially notice it with Ken's critical attack. I suppose it's easier when you're dealing with low resolution models though
I didn't know Theurgys were in the original.
They were called fusion spells there, and worked a little different, you needed to have both personas in your inventory still and equip one of them for the option to appear
@joaolima7131 Oh wow, I've never played the OG but that mechanic must've sucked. Imagine keeping the Jack bros in your inventory all the time just for that
I miss Shinjiro's headbut and I also wish we were still allowed to use multiple weapons. I loved The MC's crit animation when using hand-to-hand weapons and wanted to see what they would do with that on modern hardware.
Otherwise, I really love what they did with the presentation of this remake.
P3 Original had Theurgies??? I thought those were new
They didn't,the original Persona 3 had fusion spells,it's just that the protagonist's Theurgies are the fusion spells
anyone knows what the words are saying behind them after a finishing attack? (it looks like mass destruction but i could be wrong lol)
I like the gun revolver ui in the OG, but god damn Yakuza: Like a Dragon controls better 🙏
I kinda hate the way the new battles all just look like they're taking place in a random hallway rather than a unique battle area, same with how clean everything looks, it feels too shiny and the top floor went from crystal/ice to Loki Persona 5
Bro, new one is so cool, what is y'all talking about
i dislike shinji crit aniimation.. dosent fit him and it also just feel like he copies ken? but thats just me
It would more fit in line if Ken copied Shinji because, ya know and for some people (me) I don't use Ken until after getting Shinji anyways since I wait until the last day for Tartarus.
Disturbing the peeeeace, look into my eyeees
what is the name of the song?
it would honestly be a better video if i could hear the changes in voicelines instead of the music
What is the name of this song? I Don't find it
It's going down
ジークフリードとミトラスってどういう関係？
ただ剣を持ったイケメン繋がりだとしたらアトラスらしくないしロキとスサノオみたいにニッチなところで共通点がありそうですね
Persona 3 r. Underwater
Reload ver. Is so sick
The cadenza evoker animation in reload looks great, but the original on is still better, he kinda literally dies. Lol
You're comparing them to the portable version, not FES, which seems more appropriate for most of the animations.
Uhh that IS FES.
That is FES lmao
訂閱20天才能發言，是有多玻璃心啊
aniimation is god level, but gameplay is meh
I did NOT see any MAJOR difference between remake and original and still don't get it why full price of this game is 70 usd.
Because Reload is hardly a remake, it's a *remaster*. Yes $70 is a lot but this is Atlus we're talking about
"I did NOT see any MAJOR difference between remake and original" what is broski jabbering about?
What the fuck?
This game is overhyped and overrated. But I see that's not a problem for atlus fans
@@daakusureyaa no. Its not. Is a masperpiece. You just have shit taste. Im sorry.
And people still swear this is a bad remake