Can you provide citations for your historical claims, that is historical evidence? If I heard you correctly - 1) the Churchill government was controlled by 'the Jews' 2) that the Roosevelt government was controlled by the 'Jews"? 3) that the October Russian revolution was controlled/lead by Jews? 4) that the numbers of Jews that died in the Holocaust is much less then commonly accepted? 5) evidence that before Stalin took (supreme?) power, and Trotsky was in government, 'the Jews' controlled or led the Russian government? 6) and that before Stalin, there was not official government sponsored atheism directed towards Jews? I have a history degree. You said you have done lots of reading. Please provide your sources. I request that you not retreat behind 'Im just asking questions' or 'dont cancel me.' I am not asking for evidence for 7) whether the US should have helped Britain or the Communists, or 8) whether Britain should have declared war when Germany invaded Poland or 9) whether Stalin was worse then Hitler. I affirm the truth of the Holy Trinity and the Holy Scriptures.
I teach history at a Classical Christian School and I hear you Saint. Liberalism is a sacred idol that thou shall not touch. Some of the kids may entertain a different perspective, but it's often the parents often you find the most resistance.
As a fellow history degree holder, can you provide citations for more controversial historical claims that 'saint' made throughout his broadcast? If I understand him right, that the 1) Churchill government and the 2) Roosevelt government were influenced or controlled by 'the Jews'? 3) And that the October revolution in Russia was led/influenced/controlled by the 'Jews'? 4) And that some much smaller number of Jews died in the Holocaust? Note I asked for historical evidence. So I hope your response will not be 'whats wrong wirh asking questions' or 'dont cancel me' or 'whats wrong with being provocative.'. I'm not asking about the pro or con on whether 5) the US should have declared war after Germany declared war on the US or whether 6) the US should have not aided the Soviets or Britain or that 7) Britain should have stayed out of the German-Polish war or 8) whether it is a true statement when God breathed Scripture teaches that the Gentiles and the people of Israel killed the Lord Jesus Christ. Nor whether 9) what I characterize as Saint noticing that not all descriptions of Nazi Germany are 100 percent Accurate or what I will parody as 10) the 'North Korea actually has good food.' (claims that Nazi Germany wasn't as bad as you might think or that others were worse or they were anti communist). 11) I will also ask you why Roosevelt denied Jewish refugees and declined to bomb camps as requested by Jewish leaders? 12) and why the British government fought a war with Zionist Jews in British controlled Palestine? 13) Saint tried to salvage the 'Judeo-Bolsheivk' mythology of the Russian revolution by claiming that once Stalin took over, then the Jews were persecuted by the Soviets and then Stalin could ally with the Nazis, but provided no citations besides talking about one atheist, Trotsky. Can you provide them?
I think the distinction some "critics" are worried about is whether you're saying "jews are often leftist and that sucks because leftists bad", or if you're saying "jews are often leftists therefore jews bad". (Seems like you clearly mean the first one; they are afraid you mean the second.) I oppose censorship of any discussion topic; in my experience it just leads to more extremism -- "they're only censoring us because they know we're right!", when non-censorship would allow real debate to debunk any part which is untrue.
I'd just like to add a caution to this video (which was very interesting). When you find out that a lot of what you had taken for granted was false, please be careful not to just uncritically believe the other side's propaganda. This topic, more than almost any other is characterized by an abundance of propaganda and false information on all sides.
31:48. Sorry to be that guy but Fascism doesn’t not come from “right wing” thought. Its father, Giovanni Gentile, used to be a Marxist and el Duci was a member of the Italian socialist party. Yes it does have ideas that could be considered right wing, but many of its thinkers were more left wing socialist such as Goebbels and the Strasser brothers. They had the word “socialist” in NS for a reason and not just to sound cool. Stanley Payne wrote many great books that go more in depth on Fascist history and nuance
I tend to think of it as the right of the radical left. Stalin was crazy far left, but he believed a lot of things that would fall on the right today (like not thinking men are women). The whole left/right thing breaks down outside of a very specific context.
@@whosweptmymines3956 Yeah I would agree that Stalinism is more on the left than any of the Fascist movements that took off in the 20th century. Many “puritan” Marxists called Stalin a “Red Fascist” since he had to deviate from Lenin’s and Marxist’s ideas
![[UNCUT] The Loyal Pin ปิ่นภักดิ์ EP.4 (4/4)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/d3l5rxl5CVo/mqdefault.jpg)
Thanks so much for having me on! I had a blast being spicy!
Can you provide citations for your historical claims, that is historical evidence? If I heard you correctly - 1) the Churchill government was controlled by 'the Jews' 2) that the Roosevelt government was controlled by the 'Jews"? 3) that the October Russian revolution was controlled/lead by Jews? 4) that the numbers of Jews that died in the Holocaust is much less then commonly accepted? 5) evidence that before Stalin took (supreme?) power, and Trotsky was in government, 'the Jews' controlled or led the Russian government? 6) and that before Stalin, there was not official government sponsored atheism directed towards Jews? I have a history degree. You said you have done lots of reading. Please provide your sources. I request that you not retreat behind 'Im just asking questions' or 'dont cancel me.' I am not asking for evidence for 7) whether the US should have helped Britain or the Communists, or 8) whether Britain should have declared war when Germany invaded Poland or 9) whether Stalin was worse then Hitler.
I affirm the truth of the Holy Trinity and the Holy Scriptures.
Great show, Jay Dyer told me about you lol.
Transparency about one's views is indeed a mark of intellectual integrity. Right on.
I teach history at a Classical Christian School and I hear you Saint. Liberalism is a sacred idol that thou shall not touch. Some of the kids may entertain a different perspective, but it's often the parents often you find the most resistance.
There ain’t nothing wrong with (classical) liberalism my brother.
As a fellow history degree holder, can you provide citations for more controversial historical claims that 'saint' made throughout his broadcast? If I understand him right, that the 1) Churchill government and the 2) Roosevelt government were influenced or controlled by 'the Jews'? 3) And that the October revolution in Russia was led/influenced/controlled by the 'Jews'? 4) And that some much smaller number of Jews died in the Holocaust? Note I asked for historical evidence. So I hope your response will not be 'whats wrong wirh asking questions' or 'dont cancel me' or 'whats wrong with being provocative.'. I'm not asking about the pro or con on whether 5) the US should have declared war after Germany declared war on the US or whether 6) the US should have not aided the Soviets or Britain or that 7) Britain should have stayed out of the German-Polish war or 8) whether it is a true statement when God breathed Scripture teaches that the Gentiles and the people of Israel killed the Lord Jesus Christ. Nor whether 9) what I characterize as Saint noticing that not all descriptions of Nazi Germany are 100 percent Accurate or what I will parody as 10) the 'North Korea actually has good food.' (claims that Nazi Germany wasn't as bad as you might think or that others were worse or they were anti communist). 11) I will also ask you why Roosevelt denied Jewish refugees and declined to bomb camps as requested by Jewish leaders? 12) and why the British government fought a war with Zionist Jews in British controlled Palestine? 13) Saint tried to salvage the 'Judeo-Bolsheivk' mythology of the Russian revolution by claiming that once Stalin took over, then the Jews were persecuted by the Soviets and then Stalin could ally with the Nazis, but provided no citations besides talking about one atheist, Trotsky. Can you provide them?
@@TheOtherCalebit came out of masonry of course it's bad
@@jakebarnes3054 The forefathers of classical liberal political economy were definitely not freemasons.
I think the distinction some "critics" are worried about is whether you're saying "jews are often leftist and that sucks because leftists bad", or if you're saying "jews are often leftists therefore jews bad". (Seems like you clearly mean the first one; they are afraid you mean the second.)
I oppose censorship of any discussion topic; in my experience it just leads to more extremism -- "they're only censoring us because they know we're right!", when non-censorship would allow real debate to debunk any part which is untrue.
One of your best. Next you should interview zoomerhistorian
I'd just like to add a caution to this video (which was very interesting). When you find out that a lot of what you had taken for granted was false, please be careful not to just uncritically believe the other side's propaganda. This topic, more than almost any other is characterized by an abundance of propaganda and false information on all sides.
Jesus is my Führer ☦️✝️✋🏼
"Füher" is not actually a word, but, whatever.
What was the name of that Watergate podcast, King?
The first WBS 😂
31:48. Sorry to be that guy but Fascism doesn’t not come from “right wing” thought. Its father, Giovanni Gentile, used to be a Marxist and el Duci was a member of the Italian socialist party. Yes it does have ideas that could be considered right wing, but many of its thinkers were more left wing socialist such as Goebbels and the Strasser brothers. They had the word “socialist” in NS for a reason and not just to sound cool.
Stanley Payne wrote many great books that go more in depth on Fascist history and nuance
TLDR: Fascism isn’t “right wing, but more like “radical centrist” thought
I tend to think of it as the right of the radical left. Stalin was crazy far left, but he believed a lot of things that would fall on the right today (like not thinking men are women). The whole left/right thing breaks down outside of a very specific context.
@@whosweptmymines3956
Yeah I would agree that Stalinism is more on the left than any of the Fascist movements that took off in the 20th century.
Many “puritan” Marxists called Stalin a “Red Fascist” since he had to deviate from Lenin’s and Marxist’s ideas
Could you list the recommended reading list from militant @ATimeForWar38 please?