Still love to see Roger & Dave together again. There's a chemistry there, that's not always evident, yet it's still tangible. There's clearly love as well. God bless them. ♥️🎗⚘🌷♥️🌷⚘ 🎗♥️
Just imagine, Syd was still alive when Floyds played this song... Imagine if he was at the concert and came on the stage to talk to his old friends one last time...
@@ethanstewart4222 I read in interview somewhere with Syd's sister who told them Floyd was playing one last show together and he pretty much shrugged and basically said "ok"
You go into this song, knowing how it’s the most “universal” of all of Pink Floyd’s music, and know the background of how it is very much about Syd Barrett. Then you get to the second half, the “chorus”, and here you realize that the two lost souls in the fishbowl are Gilmour and Waters. And then it hits you that now it’s also about Rick Wright, and the extremely complicated relationship he also had with Waters. And then you’ve come full circle in realizing how universal this song is; it’s more than the four men on stage missing their friend, it’s all of us missing someone in our lives, be it a permanent or temporary loss (though I care to believe such loss is never truly permanent).
Perhaps it is also a call to us all to strive for a space, here, elsewhere, corporeal or otherwise, where we can truly communicate, see and appreciate each other for what we are, without thinking that we can tell.
If she was a great human, you can be too. You too mean a a lot to some people you know or maybe dont know. And you also will be remembered by your offsprings or friends as well some day. Dont panic. Listen to the Floyd and relax and let yourself go ;-)
Erm… not really. Even Waters admitted that he was really nervous during the show and didn’t sing well. This works far better with Gilmour singing the whole thing. All that splitting the vocal served to do was demonstrate once again how much a better performer Gilmour is.
@@cs0rpc TBF Roger's voice worked pretty well in the chorus when he's harmonising with David.... pity they didn't use Rick too, especially now that he's gone
One of my biggest concert going memories is being at the very front barrier all that day with my Dad, who was 67 at the time. Amazing to see that legendary performance from just a few feet away. Since losing my dad Bryan two years ago I've rewatched those magical 24 minutes many times. Wish You Were Here obviously more poignant now. Great memories of an incredible day.
You're a very lucky man Wayne. Epic performance. I was working behind a very busy bar in the Temple Bar area of Dublin that day. I downed tools to watch it. The customers respected my decision and left me alone to watch it. What a special day! Unforgettable historic moment in music history.
Wow man that has to be an amazing memory of your dad. I can deal with the aches and pains of getting older. I'm not very fond of saying goodbye to the people who were pillars in my life. It's nice to have memories of those amazing times with them though. Shine On!
In my opinion this is the greatest live performance/ reunion ever. Very emotional comfortably numb solo when u think the guys fell out for so many years to then play together again, one final time. Legendary. #thefloyd
I have never had the honor to see Pink Floyd live. I listen every day to the albums i have and every day i am amazed by the sheer genius of this band! Thank you Pink Floyd for making a bad day fantastic!
Lyrics: So, so you think you can tell Heaven from hell? Blue skies from pain? Can you tell a green field From a cold steel rail? A smile from a veil? Do you think you can tell? Did they get you to trade Your heroes for ghosts? Hot ashes for trees? Hot air for a cool breeze? Cold comfort for change? Did you exchange A walk-on part in the war For a leading role in a cage? How I wish, how I wish you were here We're just two lost souls Swimming in a fish bowl Year after year Running over the same old ground What have we found? The same old fears Wish you were here
He's working on new material, so here's hoping you get the chance. Doubt any future tours will be anything like the scale of the last few, but with luck he'll still do them. I count myself lucky to have seen it three times, in 2006, 2015 and 2016.
Its a testament to just what a remarkable man Syd was, that hundreds of millions of people watch his former bandmates perform a song, band mates who havent even spoken to the guy for over 30 years, a song entirely about him, and everyone of those 4 guys would have been thinking about him. Syds star shone very, very briefly but my god did it burn bright. Incredibly sweet of Rodger to dedicate this song to him. RIP RKB.
They did not advertise this at all anywhere. I'm watching all day, I get home and he needed a place for his bed and I was more than happy to put em up.
I was 18 and a die hard my favorite band ever and I wanted to watch this on tv so bad. Was going to be aired. But I had a plane flight to California to visit my uncle months in advance and was so sad to miss it!!
@kristoffmarquez8541 spot on sid ,before his troubles was the identikit sexy front man who hated the limelight but to see him later was tragic ,rick wright caused a lot of the friction that caused the breakup of course there was a lot more too it than that but he was a legend wish u were here sid and rick,R.I.P
Увы, такого явления как Pink Floyd больше не будет в истории цивилизации людей. Уже скоро 60 лет как их музыка будоражит сердца миллионов людей, пять поколений слушают и наслаждаются ею. Боже, благослови их всех.
I dont know how i came across this video, but i was there, with my wife and it was the most brilliant experience. the whole day was overwhelminig,,,,, wish you were here. I loved that day
Great memory! I was sitting in the park nearby enjoying some wine and cheese with friends and playing my guitar to the real Pink Floyd, with Dave & Roger singing over my chords 🙃 !
@@michaelhansen3970 This video is all goosebumps, but Paul is Paul. He could just belch into the mic or take a dump on the stage and it would still be epic lol. Just like when George sings the final verse on "My Back Pages" from Dylan's 30th anniversary concert, The Beatles go on last... (yes I know that wasn't the final song of that night, but it was the superset supergroup of the night!). Just having fun here, no argument. But c'mon! Paul HUMBLED?!?!?!? Paul is the biggest rockstar that probably will ever be, and yes- timing does have a lot to do with it (notice I didn't say 'best' rockstar!). Stay awesome, people xox A
![Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here (Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind) [HD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9P16xvwMQ5A/mqdefault.jpg)
The greatest reunion of all time.
Nope, Batty rejoining Leeds was. This might have been if RWs voice didn't sound so wank
And sadly the last one 😔
Still love to see Roger & Dave together again. There's a chemistry there, that's not always evident, yet it's still tangible. There's clearly love as well. God bless them. ♥️🎗⚘🌷♥️🌷⚘ 🎗♥️
There's also Led Zeppelin O2 reunion.
i was fortunate to have been there. It was truly magnificent
Rick's nod after Roger's mention of Syd is priceless.
that was his homie
Whats your opinion on this track:th-cam.com/video/QG_RNiLO2sg/w-d-xo.html
..
This man just blessed my ears
...
@@mattb9968 tearjerker. Truly heart-breaking but beautiful.
Wow I never noticed that. That was quite emotional for me.
Just imagine, Syd was still alive when Floyds played this song... Imagine if he was at the concert and came on the stage to talk to his old friends one last time...
I'm pretty sure he was, this happened in 2005
@@ethanstewart4222 I read in interview somewhere with Syd's sister who told them Floyd was playing one last show together and he pretty much shrugged and basically said "ok"
Unforgotten Being i mean he hadnt been himself for decades so it doesnt surprise me
He showed up during the original recording at the studio and they didn't recognize him...
So sad what happened too him i think he could of been something great had he got clean sooner and not developed schizophrenia
You go into this song, knowing how it’s the most “universal” of all of Pink Floyd’s music, and know the background of how it is very much about Syd Barrett. Then you get to the second half, the “chorus”, and here you realize that the two lost souls in the fishbowl are Gilmour and Waters. And then it hits you that now it’s also about Rick Wright, and the extremely complicated relationship he also had with Waters. And then you’ve come full circle in realizing how universal this song is; it’s more than the four men on stage missing their friend, it’s all of us missing someone in our lives, be it a permanent or temporary loss (though I care to believe such loss is never truly permanent).
you've truly said it all.
Perhaps it is also a call to us all to strive for a space, here, elsewhere, corporeal or otherwise, where we can truly communicate, see and appreciate each other for what we are, without thinking that we can tell.
My grandmother passed away 30 minutes ago. I'm gonna miss you Rosita. You were a great human. I'll always remember you.
Grandma passes away and your first thought is to go on TH-cam and write a comment
@@FirstnameLastname-du9kv F
If she was a great human, you can be too. You too mean a a lot to some people you know or maybe dont know. And you also will be remembered by your offsprings or friends as well some day. Dont panic. Listen to the Floyd and relax and let yourself go ;-)
@@FirstnameLastname-du9kv obviously he came here to listen to this song, idiot
Sorry for your loss!
The things I would do to see this live
A time machine?
Economise enough to buy yourself a ticket for the next show
@@lauravogel2572 good idea, i'm in!
@@ClicStudio Tough be a college student :/
Chris I am too and I’m gonna put a certain amount of money in a side account every months because I want to see this live!
2:26 Gilmour isn't just smiling at mason, he's smiling at all of us!
2:27 how david smiles at nick is so beautiful
Ladies and Gentlemen the best band ever.
Totally agree!!!
Still .......😊
This is sooo gooood it physically hurts😭😭
No, maybe Roger's voice isn't the best, but gives personality to the interpretation and makes you can feel the nostalgic spirit of this song
yeah dude! i feel the same vibe in his voice
Erm… not really. Even Waters admitted that he was really nervous during the show and didn’t sing well. This works far better with Gilmour singing the whole thing. All that splitting the vocal served to do was demonstrate once again how much a better performer Gilmour is.
@@cs0rpc TBF Roger's voice worked pretty well in the chorus when he's harmonising with David.... pity they didn't use Rick too, especially now that he's gone
@@mayoite160 sure they would have done had it not been for Rogers ego
Neither one are technically the greatest singers. But they are 2 of my favorites!
Makes me want to cry. Pink Floyd, greatest band on earth!
Syd might not be in the later pink Floyd records but he still does and prominently his style of music does remain in the core of pink Floyds music
Not really
Last time together..
Dave the best of Guitar!!.
Just like a goodbye song😢 or nostalgia between roger & david
One of my biggest concert going memories is being at the very front barrier all that day with my Dad, who was 67 at the time. Amazing to see that legendary performance from just a few feet away. Since losing my dad Bryan two years ago I've rewatched those magical 24 minutes many times. Wish You Were Here obviously more poignant now. Great memories of an incredible day.
You're a very lucky man Wayne. Epic performance. I was working behind a very busy bar in the Temple Bar area of Dublin that day. I downed tools to watch it. The customers respected my decision and left me alone to watch it. What a special day! Unforgettable historic moment in music history.
@@MARTYC76 Yes very lucky. It was one of those days that will be remembered forever.
@@waynespencer3036 ♥️ treasure it my friend. Once in a lifetime moment.
Incrível
Wow man that has to be an amazing memory of your dad. I can deal with the aches and pains of getting older. I'm not very fond of saying goodbye to the people who were pillars in my life. It's nice to have memories of those amazing times with them though. Shine On!
this makes me cry. everytime.
In my opinion this is the greatest live performance/ reunion ever. Very emotional comfortably numb solo when u think the guys fell out for so many years to then play together again, one final time. Legendary. #thefloyd
I have never had the honor to see Pink Floyd live. I listen every day to the albums i have and every day i am amazed by the sheer genius of this band! Thank you Pink Floyd for making a bad day fantastic!
Lyrics:
So, so you think you can tell
Heaven from hell?
Blue skies from pain?
Can you tell a green field
From a cold steel rail?
A smile from a veil?
Do you think you can tell?
Did they get you to trade
Your heroes for ghosts?
Hot ashes for trees?
Hot air for a cool breeze?
Cold comfort for change?
Did you exchange
A walk-on part in the war
For a leading role in a cage?
How I wish, how I wish you were here
We're just two lost souls
Swimming in a fish bowl
Year after year
Running over the same old ground
What have we found?
The same old fears
Wish you were here
Who actually needs this? 😂😂😂
@@rougeclips9438 why do you have to say something so rude?
My goal in life is to see david gilmour singing this live
Angie C That’s a great goal! I saw him at MSG and he did this that night .. best concert I’ve ever been to.
Had this opportunity during DG tour for rattle that lock here in S-Am. What a bliss...
He's working on new material, so here's hoping you get the chance. Doubt any future tours will be anything like the scale of the last few, but with luck he'll still do them. I count myself lucky to have seen it three times, in 2006, 2015 and 2016.
any luck yet?
Saw him do it three different times!! Never get sick of it!!
Lost a friend yesterday. Randy Smith, wish you were here...Love you bro.
Wish you were here.
I definitely wish I was there too
My niece was!
Perfect song. Favorite part of this one is the sense of calm when it’s David and his guitar doing their duet.
how is this and comfortably numb not their most watched video yet, it's a beautiful performance
2:27 look at that smile
This just spread so much joy that it doesn't even make sense
That smile, that damn smile
That damn smile.
that was do stinkin wholesome
they're making fun of Roger's voice
Have to watch this every now and then. Sure with Roger and Dave could mend things. They made some great music together. Sure would make Nick happy.
2:26 that smile...
Stunning. This was history being written. Best concert ever, albeit for just 4 songs.
This is so beautiful, it makes me cry every time I look at it 😭❤️❤️
🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🎶🎶🎵🎵🎶🎶👍👍
Me too 💔❤️🥺🥺
How can we mortals come up with lyrics that can take us this far!!
Its a testament to just what a remarkable man Syd was, that hundreds of millions of people watch his former bandmates perform a song, band mates who havent even spoken to the guy for over 30 years, a song entirely about him, and everyone of those 4 guys would have been thinking about him. Syds star shone very, very briefly but my god did it burn bright. Incredibly sweet of Rodger to dedicate this song to him. RIP RKB.
Great ending show to a great band
Why do i love British bands so much
Maybe you’re a Pom.😋
David’s smile at nick was so nice to see at 2:27
They did not advertise this at all anywhere. I'm watching all day, I get home and he needed a place for his bed and I was more than happy to put em up.
Played us out at my Mums funeral - will forever be indelibly mum's song
I was 18 and a die hard my favorite band ever and I wanted to watch this on tv so bad. Was going to be aired. But I had a plane flight to California to visit my uncle months in advance and was so sad to miss it!!
3:06 goosebumps
Amazing. Gives me chills across my whole body that leaves me feeling warm.
Wish you were here
This is one of the best moments in music.
I Wish Syd and Rick Were Here.
Wish Syd and Rick Were Here
❤🙏💔
@kristoffmarquez8541 spot on sid ,before his troubles was the identikit sexy front man who hated the limelight but to see him later was tragic ,rick wright caused a lot of the friction that caused the breakup of course there was a lot more too it than that but he was a legend wish u were here sid and rick,R.I.P
If this song doesn't make you feel something you may just be dead or deeply depressed, don't worry though the feeling will return in time
Greatest reunion ever
Увы, такого явления как Pink Floyd больше не будет в истории цивилизации людей. Уже скоро 60 лет как их музыка будоражит сердца миллионов людей, пять поколений слушают и наслаждаются ею. Боже, благослови их всех.
Exactamente digo lo mismo. después de pink floyd...quién ?
How I wish, How I wish they were here.
I cried watching this in disbelief...never thought i will see roger and dave next to each other again
Wish You Were Here, one of the best songs of all time. I love it.
Effectivement 👌,meilleure chanson
If not THE best...
I would put strawberry fields right up there
David and Roger together. A dream ♥️
Sadly maybe this wouldn't happen again, not even in some Dave or Rog's solo bands live.
Oh, how I wanted this meeting to happen again! But luckily I had a chance to see their show. Thank you God
can tell David is filled with all sorts of emotions that night
Verdadeiro Pink Floyd é com estes dois, eles completam-se, a voz do David e a personalidade do Roger. Adoro-os 💖🇵🇹
3:06 Really miss David and Roger harmonizing
The fans are so lucky to see these 04 in the same frame at the same time
I would die to meet these legends someday
2:26 That smile 😍❤
Ya perdi la esperanza de verlos en vivo, es triste pero asi es la vida.
Esperemos que Roger haga otra gira en latinoamerica.
One of the best intros among all much cherished rock hits
Holy shit when the second guitar turned in my whole body got chills. The fucking thingssss i would do you see PF live holy shit.
Duas constelações brilhando no céu da Música 🎸🎸
3:02 great moment!
Together they are the best band ever
thanks for everything Pink Floyd.
Simplesmente Bravíssimo, Bravíssimo, Bravíssimo, Bravíssimo Simplesmente!!!!!
Bealtiful song!
RIP syd and rick gone but never forgotten!!
Rick💔 Bro, Nick is still here🙏
@@niceciante107 thanks man I knew that but got their names switched up for some reason
Thank you pink floyd for bring live 8 back in youtube
How delightful song...
still one of the greatest things on the interwebs..
Magic
I dont know how i came across this video, but i was there, with my wife and it was the most brilliant experience. the whole day was overwhelminig,,,,, wish you were here. I loved that day
Best Floyd song to sing along with 💕
Fantastic music and group since so many years....😎
Awesome
Timeless
2:26 that smile! and again 3:04
greatest wish you were here ever.
Great memory! I was sitting in the park nearby enjoying some wine and cheese with friends and playing my guitar to the real Pink Floyd, with Dave & Roger singing over my chords 🙃 !
17 Years to the day. Missing PF. Wish you were here.
I always get goose bumps when I hear this song.
How Lucky we are!!! Listening this is just a Blowing mind perse!!
Amazing, no words, the best evening.
So no one is gonna discuss about Water and Gilmour's vocal harmonies?
Legends of 2022 hands up!!!
Best band in the World!!
0:36 Nick's like"sigh..stop bloody talking you gobshite"😂 Pink Floyd my favourite and one of the greatest bands..👍🏻
Amazing love!
A lifetime wish to watch Pink Floyd live..! They will always be my all time favs ❤
1:00 I just cannot get enough of this 😊
Thanks you for everything Syd 💎🎶
When you’re on the bill after Paul McCartney you know you’re one of the most anticipated reunions ever.
I think they played before Paul
They played before Paul, who was the last act of the night
@@luuismarquez yep, you're right
Well think about being McCartney being billed after this. He knows that he now has shoes impossible to fill. It must have been a humbling experience
@@michaelhansen3970 This video is all goosebumps, but Paul is Paul. He could just belch into the mic or take a dump on the stage and it would still be epic lol. Just like when George sings the final verse on "My Back Pages" from Dylan's 30th anniversary concert, The Beatles go on last... (yes I know that wasn't the final song of that night, but it was the superset supergroup of the night!). Just having fun here, no argument. But c'mon! Paul HUMBLED?!?!?!? Paul is the biggest rockstar that probably will ever be, and yes- timing does have a lot to do with it (notice I didn't say 'best' rockstar!). Stay awesome, people xox A
Как я обожаю звук флойдовских гитар, ну и конечно их голоса!!!!!
Kesinlikle katılıyorum.
Hasta que se me eriza la piel al ver este vídeo gracias Pink Floyd mil gracias por su música jamás morirá su legado!!!!
Reading all these comments after these years are priceless
Oh what a beautiful song.
Ver essas duas raras estrelas do céu da música juntas se tornou uma constelação no coração eternamente ❤❤
Excellent
my soul is melting
Never gets old
Невероятен Дейвид и като човек и като музикант. Велик.
I wanna be this cool wen I grow old.....nothing but love for Pink Floyd