Only real men can wear a 44m lug to lug. 🙄 BAHAHHA IN ALL SERIOUSNESS. IM SUCH AN ISIOT HAHHA! How did I not notice that?!?! It’s like Hoedrinkee also edited the video! 🤔 😜
@@BrittPearceWatches hi awesome video. I saved up for Tudor Blackbay 41 mm black dial t. In your opinion, is that a good every day watch? My dream watch is the explorer But I can justify the price tag
This was a fun comparison! Never really looked too closely at the BB36, but compared to the Explorer it looks like a heck of a value. Seems like fro the Explorer you're paying a lot extra to get that in house movement, which is a pretty big upgrade, but beyond that I'm assuming you're mostly paying for heritage and branding. Both are stunning, but oddly I think I like the look of the Tudor a bit better, despite normally not being a fan of the snow flake hour hand.
JUST THE WATCH IS IN THE HOUSE! I can’t believe you watch my videos! 😱❤️ you nailed it. “You’re paying for heritage and branding” YUP! 👏🏻 and with the explorer muddy heritage, it feels mostly like branding. 😜
It's mostly the accuracy difference or quality of the movement. Rolex is +/- 2 Sec, Tudor with SW200-1 or ETA2824 more like +/- 20 Sec - who knows exactly as they don't specify the grade of either movement. The Tudor current in-house base movement is much better now but dearer of course.
Loving your raw, hilarious and tell it like it is style! A very nice change of pace from the typical watch style videos you see on this platform. Keep up the great work, cheers from Hong Kong!🍻
I’ve always wanted a Submariner but rapidly approaching 70 I feel like this would appear as desperate attempt to be young . I decided to buy a BB58 to scratch the Subby itch and am very happy with it. I’m considering buying a Tudor BB 36 for my grandson’s birthday.
The Tudor. I went with the Tudor. I thought I’d love the Explorer based on Bark and Jack videos, but in person it just left me cold. I think there is too much text, and I don’t like Mercedes hands. Snowflake hands all day for me, perfect legibility. Mine keeps perfect time as well, several days after setting, it’s bang on the dot. Crazy accuracy. Only downside is the lack of easy adjustability on the Tudor clasp. BB36 for the win. The 116000 silver dial with arabics, on the other hand, that watch is 🔥
I'll break it down easier folks - Lexus versus Toyota... Infinity versus Nissan.... GMC versus Chevrolet.... done.... An acquaintance of mine is a wine drinker. I'm not a drinker and don't know much about wines other than Reds and Whites. Anyhow, we got to discussing watches awhile back. He related wine to watches by asking "do you know what the best bottle of wine is?"..... " the one YOU like".... Could be a $20 bottle of wine, or a $2,0000 bottle of win.... wear the watch YOU want...
@@bighands69 I’m not sure I understand your point. Do you mean ‘explorer’ as in the specific Rolex model (the Explorer), or a person who loves adventure. Either way I disagree with your statement. I’d still take my BB58.
I don't have a ton of splurge cash and I'm watch nerd. So I own the Tudor, and love it. I'm also not afraid to beat it up. I want an Explorer, and if I have the cash laying around one day I'd probably pick one up. But, I wouldn't wear like like No Fs given like I do the Tudor. Which is part of it's charm.
I've searched TH-cam and this is the best head-to-head comparison of these two watches I have found. Thanks Britt! I have tried on the Rolex, but I have the excellent Tudor on my wrist. Has gone with me to the Alps in France and to the lakes in Washington state and places in between. Both of these watches can work in just about any environment.
I just got a BB36. I absolutely love it! However, I will say that I looked all around my hometown (Miami) and no AD’s had the BB36 in black with a bracelet. I even called the Tudor boutique in NYC and they didn’t have one either. Ended up going pre-owned and got a sweet deal on it. Seems like a they’re starting to become harder to find. Could be wrong though since this is only based on my geographic location and the phone call to NY. Great video!
@@ElijahsAba Sure! Sweet deal for me was getting it at retail. I didn’t have to pay the secondary market price (which was a bit higher.) Not a single scratch, essentially new, box and papers. Pretty happy about it!
I have the outgoing 39mm Exp 1, and while I have many more niche pieces, the Exp 1 is truly a masterpiece. And to be honest is worth the price. Also, the fact that everyone clamors over the subs and gmts and everything just make it so much more appealing to me. It’s a best kept secret. But I love the heritage of a piece and the history. So Rolex Exp 1 for me. (But I do love that Tudor tho lol)
Here's my advice. The Black Bay 36 (Blue Dial) is the way to go. And I'd say it's a better purchase than the Explorer. Here's why: 1. It wears better on the wrist. The new (2021) 36mm Explorer is actually 35mm, and is quite dainty on the wrist. The Black Bay 36 has a better proportioned case and bracelet size. 2. The Black Bay 26 has better lume. Yep, the luminescence on the Tudor is CRAZY. The legibility is perfect. 3. If you get the blue dial, it will look black in most lighting, but wen the light hits it (especially sunlight), the blue pops. I call it a "Hamptons Blue", and it brings a whole new aesthetic dimension to the watch that the Explorer can't. 4. The Black Bay 36 is thinner yet rated for a better water resistance, being 150m. The Explorer is only 100m. 5. The Black Bay 36 movement is easier and cheaper to service,, and still runs on average +/- 2 seconds a day. 6. The crown is set in an hardened aluminium tube, which provides it with extra protection. There are no crown guards here, but the crown is well protected. 7. It's better value for money.
I mean, if I had the money to afford a Rolex, I'd probably have to ask myself "will I be just as happy with the Tudor?" If that answer were yes, I got me a Tudor and stone extras cash in my pocket. If not? I'd probably still get a Tudor since I could probably save up again for Rolex by the time it becomes available again lol
That was kinda my thought process. I sold my Oyster Perpetual (which I was too afraid to wear) and got a Black Bay 36 which I wear almost every day and really enjoy
Problem today is rolex will only be available to certain clients or reseller. So if you happen to find an exp ina rolex boutique and you have the cash. Take it. That's what I did with the 39mm....
I love the db36 because I feel like I'm getting away with something. It's such a great watch for that price. And honestly I believe people will be more likely to use the bb-36 as an everyday / tool watch rather than the Explorer.
100% agree. As the owner of both my BB36 gets more wrist time than the Explorer 🤷🏻♂️ maybe because I wore my Explorer for years before buying the BB36. I honestly just find the simplicity of it refreshing.
Great video. No comparison, not even close. The Rolex is an ultra high quality under the radar watch. Only you will know what you are wearing unless you let someone get really, really close to you. That is the bonus. Add the new 3230 movement with 70 hour power reserve and...
Great show WG!! Great points on this one! Tudor was always the affordable brother ! That was Hans Wilsdof’s plan !;) now that Tudor have their own in house movements, the skies the limit for Tudor! Next thing you know they’ll have there own smelting plant ! Great stuff Brittany !!
My wife and me own Rolex watches but recently I purchased a BB58 for me and the BB36 for her. I think the tudors are great. My wife hasn’t taken hers off for one day.
there's something near simple perfection on the BB36 that I can't stop trying to figure out.. so i keep looking at it. Its intriguing. I'll see if this is just a phase or I keep feeling this way
The Rolex is certainly not TWICE the watch the Tudor is, but it's still a far better, more sophisticated watch with perhaps the most perfect dial and case design ever conceived. So I would save up for the Rolex. But what I want to know is why is it so difficult for people to find 17mm, 19mm, 21mm or 23mm straps, NATO or otherwise? You can instantly find DOZENS of them on eBay with just a simple search. The only problem I see is that people don't generally keep these sizes around at home, and are therefore forced to buy them. So it might be inconvenient, but they are NOT hard to find.
Great vid. So funny, I was just today looking at the blue dial Tudor BB36 and now this 😊. Between the BB36 black dial and the Explorer, I would go for the Explorer.
@@BrittPearceWatches LOL. I am sure god is communicating through you, but I think my bank manager might have some other ideas. What does he know about watches, right ?!😁
Wanted an every day and these too were in the running... The snowflake hand is too big for a small day so after putting my name down for an explorer in a shop I'd never been in before I had an agonising wait..... The next day I collected the explorer and it's just superb 😁
The big difference; price, movement (Explorer has a thousand dollar movement, bb has couple hundred dollars movement), brand recognition, visuals appearance. Finish, fit, quality outside the movement very similar.
I would choose the Rolex. The hands alone does it for me. I was on the waiting list for the Explorer 39mm, but ever since Rolex downsized it to 36mm it has been a no go for me. They shoud offer both sizes to be honest.
The choice for the word Explorer in the lower half of the 214270 mk2 is much better, I’d say. In the new 36 version it is far too busy in the upper half of the dial, also because of the font size: big letters Rolex, then small letters oyster perpetual followed by something in between for the word explorer. Looks like a sheet the eye doctor shows you when your eyesight is being checked. Strangely enough, the same text on the same place in all older 36mm-versions of the Explorer looks just fine to me. Also, the 39 mk2 fortunately has a matt black dial, rather than glossy. Apart from the mediocre 48h power reserve (and maybe the lack of AR-coating, but the absence of it also gives the dial a charming glance in certain lighting conditions), in my opinion the 214270 mk 2 is just perfect if your wrist is not too small.
explorer hands down. especially the new 36mm 2021 version featured in this video. every aspect of the watch has been refined from the previous 36mm explorer from ar coating, bracelet, movement and overall finish and quality. fantastic 1-watch watch. Problem is how to get one at list. Lets be brutally honest, everyone would choose the explorer of the two, but you would settle for the other due to lack of availability and higher cost. If you choose the bb36, you'll never truly be satisfied as a 1-watch collection as long as you know the 124270 exists.
Great video! Thanks for making it. Does the black bay 36 really have white gold hands and indices? I haven’t seen that anywhere but would be cool if that’s true!
Had the 214270 for 2 years. It’s a very well built but sad watch. Mostly has to do with this glossy dial, cold and shiny dial furniture and lack of AR coating. That sums up my feeling about it. Would need to try the BB36 and compare
@@Milofchg the Explorer has been sold some time ago. In that genre of watches, I have found true love with the Sinn556a which I consider an excellent modern interpretation of the 1016.
Big cred for doing the Gosling size even if he’s a white dial guy. You get 36 if you see it pulled off and think you can too for the same reasons or care about the history of sizes and buy it for the same reason. The point is original size.
Although I've not tried on the new Explorer, even the bigger wearing BB36 was too small on my wrist. I can't see liking the even smaller Explorer. I did try on a pre-owned BB41 black and Explorer 39mm at the same shop a couple weeks ago, and while I didn't dislike the BB41, it did wear a bit thicker than the Explorer. Maybe it's the slab sides on the Tudor, but the 39mm Explorer was SO perfect on the wrist. It almost melted away. I'm still so upset that Rolex discontinued that size. I do wish Tudor would come out with a BB38 or 39. That 5mm gap is quite big when it comes to a watch. I totally get why the choice between them was so tough. If the Explorer wasn't quite so expensive, it might have been an easier choice, but they both are great in their own way. For fans of blue, that BB36/41 in blue doesn't is SO choice. Sadly, there isn't a blue Explorer. There was that smaller blue OP with 3/6/9 at one point, but that's gone now. Such a shame, as that was a hidden gem within the Rolex lineup. Nice comparison video, Gringa.
44 METRE lug to lug . Holy moly that's one BIG ASS watch 🤣. Built for a Brachiosaurus! Great video regardless love the classic looks of the explorer but that BB36 especially the new two tone versions looks great!
I have the BB41 but still yearn for the Explorer. But then seeing them side by side like this i actually think the Tudor is better looking and it does seem hard to justify the price difference.
It’s totally a fair one! And I so relate to this! I feel the same about my BB58 you know! I love the sub! But then when I hold them side by side, or try on the sub… I don’t feel all that fussed for it because I love my BB58!
Great video as ever! 36mm is far too small for me.........however.......my missus loves the size, it's perfect for her 5.2" wrist, and likes the Tudor so she doesn't know it yet but it will be in her Santa sock hanging on the fireplace on Christmas eve!! 🎅🎅
I spoke to Rolex Service Centre in London this afternoon. They say if I bring my papers in they will tell me which dealer sold my grey market SkyDweller. We'll see 😁
One can obsess about details. At the end it comes down to the brand name. If you are fine with Tudor, go for Black Bay 36. If you need the Rolex logo, get the Explorer and pay the premium.
I have the Tudor BB 41 in black and an Aquaterra 41 in blue and I probably saved some money...(as you can't get the explorer for 5k EVER!) but I want to drop a bomb here... as I think that the Tudor is both a tool watch and a very elegant one too. Imagine it on the wrist of 007 wearing a tuxedo. You can't say that it would not be elegant... 😉
these 2 watches are exactly what i'm looking to buy. Its such a tough choice. My gut is going to black bay as it has a slightly more rounded bezel and the ceramic ball clasp is superb. However explorer is an iconic watch, the 369 makes it so much more legible.
The explorer 1 hands down for me, the narrative & history of the explorer is a conversation starter (debatable). Have a 112470 in my collection and instinctively have the urge to wear it. Yes, it does fly under the radar but the highly polished case/bezel and reflective sapphire glass draws attention. Adrian from Bark & Jack is partly to blame for it. 😖
The Tudor is a great watch at a decent price. (Though there are plenty of watches with much better specs at this price.) It looks great and if you love the design and size, you'll be plenty happy with it. It's also cheaper to service! With that said, to sum it up, the Rolex 124270 is superior in all these aspects: - made of 904L steel, more resistant to tarnishing and better polish - white gold hands and indices, resistant to corrosion basically forever - movement is highly superior in every way, anti-magnetic and anti-shock etc - excellent interior AR coating, Tudor lacks any AR coating... - on the fly micro-adjustment via easy link, generally more solid bracelet - more elegant case profile which mitigates the perceived thickness - better lume (appears white in more diverse lighting situations) - better crown appearance/positioning Re: water resistance, let's be real. Neither are dive certified. Considering that, there's no difference between 100M and 150M WR. You can swim in either without worry, even more so with the Rolex due to 904L steel being resistant to saltwater corrosion. With all that in mind, I still think the Tudor is an excellent watch - it's just that the Rolex is also definitely worth the price increase! I'm tempted by the Tudor, but I think I'll just wait and save for the Explorer :)
Great vid as usual, but why would you make choose! Both are grails to me. Right now saving for the BB36. And maybe, just maybe after both my girls leave the nest, I’ll start saving for the Explorer. That said, to me these are two totally different watches, I mean, BB36 to me is sportier, while the Explorer is dressier, and both are good enough to be used casually. Anyway, maybe it’s just my fandom taking the best of me, but I love both watches, those are 2/3 of my ‘perfect 3 watch collection’. Keep up the great content. Nice to have Papi’s background participation, although missed the wrist check. Cheers to both of you guys.
Interesting question Gringa. Personally I would be happy with either watch subject to seeing the 36mm on my wrist that is. Both are similar size but they are quite different. The case of the Explorer is more sculpted but the Tudor more sporty as you mention. I think you summed it up perfectly with the Tudor being sporty with a smart edge and the Rolex being smart with a sporty edge. The Rolex being certified could be the deal maker though for those who demand mechanical accuracy.
@@BrittPearceWatches I agree Gringa, I've heard nothing but positive things on the accuracy of Tudor watches. I'd guess Tudor take quite a lot of care regulating all movements regardless if they are manufacturer caliber or 3rd party.
There's definitely more value for money in Tudor. But I would choose the Explorer. It's also my favourite Rolex. Simple and classy and fits every occassion.
The Black Bay 36 is more a statement of getting a GADA that is outside the box and a great value - esp. the older "Smile Dials". I think the Explorer is a watch you must really adore to pick up at the price point (AD, and esp. used) - otherwise picking it up seems more like a check the box or influencer induced buy. Great comparison video!! *I may have commented two years ago, but rewatched today!😂
I like both and I think the BB36 is awesomely priced (like pretty much every other Tudor). But the Explorer (in 36mm) is pretty much my favourite watch ever, because I feel you can do it everything with it. But I do think it is overpriced, even at retail. You say you would pay retail, and I would too (given the opportunity) because of the current Rolex situation. If we could look at it the same way we look at the Tudor, taking the watch and only the watch into consideration, we would consider it overpriced. But If I was looking for a one-watch collection and was confortable with spending that kind of money to do it, the Explorer would be the one I'd get. But I'm not a one watch guy, I don't think I'll ever be and I am totally not confortable with spending that kid of money on a watch. I prefer to have various "budget" watches and keep changing between them (but "budget" is obviously subjective. I have around 10 watches and 500 is probably the most I'd spend in one, for now - and that is a lot of money for some people, not a lot to others). So..I'll just enjoy my various "budget" pieces and wear a Hamilton Khaki Field Auto 38mm the same way I would wear a BB36 or an Explorer.
Superb video as always Gringa! Entertaining and expertly edited. You have a real talent! Also, I proudly own the Tudor BB 36. To my eyes, it is more striking and I did not feel in any way that I was buying an inferior watch. So to each their own! I was also able to get a 10% discount from my AD. Something to consider as well. 😎
Thanks for the video! My issue is that the Tudor doesn’t have the history and heritage behind it like the Explorer does. The question to me is am I willing to pay twice as much for the arguably greatest (subjective I know) tool watch of all time in a modern-spec’d version? That may be worth it!
Great review, Brittany/James, thank you. 1:00 had me burst out laughing. 😂 Can't believe I'm saying this: have to see them side by side, but think I like the Tudor better. 150WR, more readable hands and (to me) better looking dial, and that chamfered edging on the case: sexy. And hate to say it, but value HAS to be a factor for me. My humble opinion. Thanks again🙂👍
You're assessment seems about right to me. The Rolex is a little dressier compared to the Tudor, but the availability is a huge negative. So good luck getting one anywhere near retail price! I would be happy with either one on my wrist, but my bank account (and wife) would probably prefer to see the Tudor.
Great episode! Very funny, as usual If I were to share my honest opinion: 1 Rolex Explorer is an entry level luxury watch that can't be priced accurately 2 Tudor BB is awesome but it's just a watch that is a little bit overpriced
BOOOM. YAS! I always love when people have personal experiences with the watches! I agree woth the explorer! It’s hard. I’m a Tudor and a Rolex fan girl. But the explorer is sometjing magic!
@@BrittPearceWatches I’ve always had and loved Tudor too, but since having the Explorers (214270 and 124270) I feel they are, and look, more grown up and visually ’wiser!’ The 3 & 9 look like smiling eyes, whereas the BB36 is a wide-eyed child in comparison, fittingly. ☺️😳xx
These are both great watches, but both of them need to upgrade their clasps. For these prices, they both should have highly adjustable clasps like the Planet Ocean, etc. Love your channel, Gringa!
There’s something so elegant about the Explorer, just tried it on - the Tudor is more fun n funky. I’d be happy to own either one. If you’re gifting moi - Explorer all the way and I’m not a Rolex fan-girl. Just bought the Omega aquaterra 38 in Summer Blue limited edition after the got on the list for the Explorer. Good thing I got plenty of time to save up! You’re so zany and fun - really digging your content, Laty. I will pray for Gringa. May you own allll you desire
Great episode! So i was one of those people who wanted an Explorer but since it was "hard" to get one I bought the BB36 last spring. At the time a 114270 was about 5K used ( cheap!) but I really felt that the 3K I paid for the brand new Tudor as opposed to a 15 year old Rolex just seemed a no brainer and I was lucky enough to have one that was so well regulated you'd have thought it was a Rolex. But.... in the end I sold it and was able to get a new 214270. So if I could snap my fingers and change the 39mm one I have into the new 36mm one...Yes I would, but that AD ain't havin' it
Good idea to compare both watches, but there is a big gap between both!! 😊 specially in the movement which is the reason why a collector spend money. Spend 2200 for an ETA 2824, in my opinion is too much!!
I’ll say Explorer cause I think it looks more refined and that dial from Tudor kinda looks awkward without the rotating bezel looks great on the 58 but the aesthetic looks a bit imbalance for me. Then again Adrian from Bark and Jack suggested to look at the two tone version and when he said “dirty”, the steel version became a bit dull in comparison. 😂
I love both watches, I do have an Explorer 2020 39mm and just love it. The thing is, in 5 years time my Explorer will still be worth £5k, if not more, but the Tudor will only be worth £1k, if not less. That is the equation ever person looking to buy one of these watches will have to solve. The clever thing to do is buy both watches. Best of both worlds.
I own the Rolex Explorer 2021 36mm. I'll say get the Rolex ONLY at an AD because it's cheaper than a used 39mm and the old 36mm version from 1990-2010. It has a 70 hour power reserve. Although it's only 100 meters water resistance, it has white gold, and adjustable links. Plus it's a Rolex. I held back from buying the Tudor because I know for me it would be a compromise watch. I will always want the Rolex. I will end up buying the Tudor BB 36 because it looks amazing, it's affordable, I prefer 36mm watches, and you can find it at any AD. The other reason I held back on getting a used Explorer 36mm is the clasp and bracelet. It feels cheap and for a watch that was $4k last year, now selling at $7k for a 11-30 year old watch? C'mon.... Then with the Rolex shortage games I couldn't get the 39mm Explorer or a Sub for several years on a waitlist. I was blessed to get this one thanks to my AD rep who knew I wanted an Explorer for many years.
Thisbis such a fair one Kevin! Thank you soooo much for your personal experience as well! I love it when people leave their experiences in the comments! It means so much more than jusy like, my opinion after a couple of weeks with a watch!
Agreed that these are two very different watches. The dial just offers a really different look. Also regarding the clasp, Rolex feels more solid and refined, but I do like that the Tudor clasp is slim. Same thing for the case thickness!
Great video, I think you may have just picked one of the most difficult side by sides there is! Rolex is defo the better of the two, is it better value though? Value for me is a no. The Tudor is my entry level recommendation to my none watch geek friends who want to buy a ‘proper’ watch for a couple of grand. Thanks for the content!👍
My brother has a bb36 and it's very nice. I have a wife and kids and a young but growing business, so I proudly wear a Longines. But one day I'd like an explorer.
I'd say the price comparison is more than 2 to 1 when you can't get the Rolex at MSRP, you have to go secondary/gray market for one and that will cost you $11k so is the Explorer 5 times the watch? NO. However I do drool over an explorer and if/when I get my first Rolex, it will be an Explorer but I also prefer the 38mm.
The main difference between the two is that the BB36 is available in blue. Also, BB36 can actually be worn anywhere without the attention you get from the Rolex crown -- which could be a bad thing in some cases.
Hi Brittany, I am also a Tudor fan (love my BB58), but I don't see these two watches competing with each other. The Rolex is arguably the most iconic field/exploring watch ever, with a storied history and provenance. To me, the Tudor looks like a dive watch that lost its timing bezel. I'm on wait lists at every AD in my town for the Explorer, but I would not buy the Tudor, even at a discount. It just doesn't do anything for me.
If Tudor is using a Sellita, what other watches with Sellita movement can you find and for what price? It Tudor then really worth the money when compared with the competition with the same movements?
Ouuuu it’s fair my friend! It is a fair question! But is not a watch more than it’s movement?! (Idk why I went so Shakespeare with it. I hate myself HahHa)
@@BrittPearceWatches Yes, a watch is more than its movement. That is why I was wondering do others offer more, when Tudor can not pull "But the movement is so much better" card.
I was hoping I'd be convinced I like the Tudor more...but it just didn't happen, despite the Tudor being a really nice, well priced piece. In the dive watch category/size, I prefer what Tudor offers. But in this format, the Rolex design clearly takes the day.
Are you sure the markers are white gold? At this price point I would guess they are Rhodium plated (which is nice too). Even their S&G models aren’t solid gold, mostly capped.
I try to buy Tudor all the time but end up going with an alternative, except for the Pelogos, I got that one. I find I like Tudor’s marketing images but when I go try them on they don’t deliver the same feeling I got when viewing it in a video or an ad.
4:17 “44 metre lug to lug” 😳 did u get the specs of Hoedrinkee again Brit… 🍷🤪
Always great and entertaining content Gringa. 👍👍
Only real men can wear a 44m lug to lug. 🙄 BAHAHHA IN ALL SERIOUSNESS. IM SUCH AN ISIOT HAHHA! How did I not notice that?!?! It’s like Hoedrinkee also edited the video! 🤔 😜
@@BrittPearceWatches hi awesome video. I saved up for Tudor Blackbay 41 mm black dial t. In your opinion, is that a good every day watch? My dream watch is the explorer But I can justify the price tag
This was a fun comparison! Never really looked too closely at the BB36, but compared to the Explorer it looks like a heck of a value. Seems like fro the Explorer you're paying a lot extra to get that in house movement, which is a pretty big upgrade, but beyond that I'm assuming you're mostly paying for heritage and branding. Both are stunning, but oddly I think I like the look of the Tudor a bit better, despite normally not being a fan of the snow flake hour hand.
JUST THE WATCH IS IN THE HOUSE! I can’t believe you watch my videos! 😱❤️ you nailed it. “You’re paying for heritage and branding” YUP! 👏🏻 and with the explorer muddy heritage, it feels mostly like branding. 😜
You also pay for a watch that won't lose its value.
It's mostly the accuracy difference or quality of the movement. Rolex is +/- 2 Sec, Tudor with SW200-1 or ETA2824 more like +/- 20 Sec - who knows exactly as they don't specify the grade of either movement. The Tudor current in-house base movement is much better now but dearer of course.
The fact that you can get a BB36 and a BB58 for the price of an Explorer kind of made this decision much easier for me.
Loving your raw, hilarious and tell it like it is style! A very nice change of pace from the typical watch style videos you see on this platform. Keep up the great work, cheers from Hong Kong!🍻
I’ve always wanted a Submariner but rapidly approaching 70 I feel like this would appear as desperate attempt to be young . I decided to buy a BB58 to scratch the Subby itch and am very happy with it. I’m considering buying a Tudor BB 36 for my grandson’s birthday.
Great comparison- have to give the nod to the Tudor for the much more fun dial. The circular indices COMPLETE ME! All the geometric shapes are a vibe.
Right?!?! I feel this! ❤️👏🏻
Is it me or the crown of the Tudor sticks out a little bit…..
The Tudor. I went with the Tudor. I thought I’d love the Explorer based on Bark and Jack videos, but in person it just left me cold. I think there is too much text, and I don’t like Mercedes hands. Snowflake hands all day for me, perfect legibility. Mine keeps perfect time as well, several days after setting, it’s bang on the dot. Crazy accuracy. Only downside is the lack of easy adjustability on the Tudor clasp. BB36 for the win.
The 116000 silver dial with arabics, on the other hand, that watch is 🔥
I own the BB36 so I'll say Rolex. They are both great just depends on how much you want to spend for that look.
It’s sooo true! Very well said!
I'll break it down easier folks - Lexus versus Toyota... Infinity versus Nissan.... GMC versus Chevrolet.... done.... An acquaintance of mine is a wine drinker. I'm not a drinker and don't know much about wines other than Reds and Whites. Anyhow, we got to discussing watches awhile back. He related wine to watches by asking "do you know what the best bottle of wine is?"..... " the one YOU like".... Could be a $20 bottle of wine, or a $2,0000 bottle of win.... wear the watch YOU want...
I own both. If I had to pick one, I’d go with the Tudor. Lots of reasons….but most importantly I’m just tired of the Rolex ‘stigma’.
Nobody would really say that. The reason people go with the tudor is because there are not explorers out there.
@@bighands69 I’m not sure I understand your point. Do you mean ‘explorer’ as in the specific Rolex model (the Explorer), or a person who loves adventure. Either way I disagree with your statement. I’d still take my BB58.
@@walkerb1734
I mean there are very few Rolex Explorer watches out there.
I don't have a ton of splurge cash and I'm watch nerd. So I own the Tudor, and love it. I'm also not afraid to beat it up. I want an Explorer, and if I have the cash laying around one day I'd probably pick one up. But, I wouldn't wear like like No Fs given like I do the Tudor. Which is part of it's charm.
of course you have both…
I was looking and thought both are lovely looking watches and thought The Tudor looks liked it’s smiling 🙂
I've searched TH-cam and this is the best head-to-head comparison of these two watches I have found. Thanks Britt!
I have tried on the Rolex, but I have the excellent Tudor on my wrist. Has gone with me to the Alps in France and to the lakes in Washington state and places in between. Both of these watches can work in just about any environment.
I just got a BB36. I absolutely love it! However, I will say that I looked all around my hometown (Miami) and no AD’s had the BB36 in black with a bracelet. I even called the Tudor boutique in NYC and they didn’t have one either. Ended up going pre-owned and got a sweet deal on it.
Seems like a they’re starting to become harder to find. Could be wrong though since this is only based on my geographic location and the phone call to NY. Great video!
Tell us more about your sweet-deal. From what I’ve seen online, pre-owned seems to go for the same as new!
@@ElijahsAba Sure! Sweet deal for me was getting it at retail. I didn’t have to pay the secondary market price (which was a bit higher.) Not a single scratch, essentially new, box and papers. Pretty happy about it!
I have the outgoing 39mm Exp 1, and while I have many more niche pieces, the Exp 1 is truly a masterpiece. And to be honest is worth the price. Also, the fact that everyone clamors over the subs and gmts and everything just make it so much more appealing to me. It’s a best kept secret. But I love the heritage of a piece and the history. So Rolex Exp 1 for me. (But I do love that Tudor tho lol)
Here's my advice.
The Black Bay 36 (Blue Dial) is the way to go. And I'd say it's a better purchase than the Explorer.
Here's why:
1. It wears better on the wrist. The new (2021) 36mm Explorer is actually 35mm, and is quite dainty on the wrist. The Black Bay 36 has a better proportioned case and bracelet size.
2. The Black Bay 26 has better lume. Yep, the luminescence on the Tudor is CRAZY. The legibility is perfect.
3. If you get the blue dial, it will look black in most lighting, but wen the light hits it (especially sunlight), the blue pops. I call it a "Hamptons Blue", and it brings a whole new aesthetic dimension to the watch that the Explorer can't.
4. The Black Bay 36 is thinner yet rated for a better water resistance, being 150m. The Explorer is only 100m.
5. The Black Bay 36 movement is easier and cheaper to service,, and still runs on average +/- 2 seconds a day.
6. The crown is set in an hardened aluminium tube, which provides it with extra protection. There are no crown guards here, but the crown is well protected.
7. It's better value for money.
Agreed with all the above, the blue is the one. But for some unknown reason, I still want the explorer….
@@mikeysanchez4567 i guess, it is because of the brand name
I mean, if I had the money to afford a Rolex, I'd probably have to ask myself "will I be just as happy with the Tudor?" If that answer were yes, I got me a Tudor and stone extras cash in my pocket. If not? I'd probably still get a Tudor since I could probably save up again for Rolex by the time it becomes available again lol
SO MUCH YES to this comment! This is really well said!
That was kinda my thought process. I sold my Oyster Perpetual (which I was too afraid to wear) and got a Black Bay 36 which I wear almost every day and really enjoy
Problem today is rolex will only be available to certain clients or reseller. So if you happen to find an exp ina rolex boutique and you have the cash. Take it. That's what I did with the 39mm....
Hi Brittany. Explorer has new 3230 movement with 70 hour reserve not 38 :)
LOL. YOURE RIGHT! Omg. Pray 4 the gringa! 😂🤦🏻♀️
Went to get explorer, left with Tudor. Will never sell. will also probaly get explorer eventually. both great - 1 only tudor everytime
Nice, Congratulations Shaun!
I love the db36 because I feel like I'm getting away with something. It's such a great watch for that price. And honestly I believe people will be more likely to use the bb-36 as an everyday / tool watch rather than the Explorer.
Right?£ 👏🏻👏🏻 I couldn’t agree more!
Yep I agree, you’re more likely to treat the BB36 as a real Toolwatch than an explorer which most people will worry about the resale value of
100% agree. As the owner of both my BB36 gets more wrist time than the Explorer 🤷🏻♂️ maybe because I wore my Explorer for years before buying the BB36. I honestly just find the simplicity of it refreshing.
personally I'd go for the explorer 2 polar dial...........great video as ever brit!!
Great review. I like the Tudor but $3k for a Selitta SW200-1 movement makes it hard for me to justify.
Exactly. It's a Selita watch.
Great video. No comparison, not even close. The Rolex is an ultra high quality under the radar watch. Only you will know what you are wearing unless you let someone get really, really close to you. That is the bonus. Add the new 3230 movement with 70 hour power reserve and...
Great show WG!! Great points on this one! Tudor was always the affordable brother ! That was Hans Wilsdof’s plan !;) now that Tudor have their own in house movements, the skies the limit for Tudor! Next thing you know they’ll have there own smelting plant ! Great stuff Brittany !!
Not really in-house movement (ever heard of Kenissi?) but ok
@@vianouche1 ok it is
RUSS IS HWRE! Stopppppp!!! I so agree you know! Sky is the limit for tudor! You rock darling!
My wife and me own Rolex watches but recently I purchased a BB58 for me and the BB36 for her. I think the tudors are great. My wife hasn’t taken hers off for one day.
I wear my BB36 with a suit every day - it looks awesome while remaining understated - it’s really all the watch anyone could ever really need or want
Got explorer for myself, and bb36 for my son. Both my son’s birth year
there's something near simple perfection on the BB36 that I can't stop trying to figure out.. so i keep looking at it. Its intriguing. I'll see if this is just a phase or I keep feeling this way
The Rolex is certainly not TWICE the watch the Tudor is, but it's still a far better, more sophisticated watch with perhaps the most perfect dial and case design ever conceived. So I would save up for the Rolex.
But what I want to know is why is it so difficult for people to find 17mm, 19mm, 21mm or 23mm straps, NATO or otherwise? You can instantly find DOZENS of them on eBay with just a simple search. The only problem I see is that people don't generally keep these sizes around at home, and are therefore forced to buy them. So it might be inconvenient, but they are NOT hard to find.
New fave watch channel, no BS, straight COLD HARD FAXXX and i actually had a bit of a laugh, you're rad, cheers from NZ :)
Great vid. So funny, I was just today looking at the blue dial Tudor BB36 and now this 😊. Between the BB36 black dial and the Explorer, I would go for the Explorer.
I think god is telling you to get the BB36! 😜 ……. AAAAND the Rolex!
@@BrittPearceWatches LOL. I am sure god is communicating through you, but I think my bank manager might have some other ideas. What does he know about watches, right ?!😁
Great video Britney, keep up the awesome content.
Oh you’re much too kind! Thank you so much! ❤️✨
Wanted an every day and these too were in the running...
The snowflake hand is too big for a small day so after putting my name down for an explorer in a shop I'd never been in before I had an agonising wait..... The next day I collected the explorer and it's just superb 😁
The big difference; price, movement (Explorer has a thousand dollar movement, bb has couple hundred dollars movement), brand recognition, visuals appearance. Finish, fit, quality outside the movement very similar.
I would choose the Rolex. The hands alone does it for me. I was on the waiting list for the Explorer 39mm, but ever since Rolex downsized it to 36mm it has been a no go for me. They shoud offer both sizes to be honest.
Oh Jonas. I FEEL YOU HERE! The hands are so sexy on the explorer!!!
The choice for the word Explorer in the lower half of the 214270 mk2 is much better, I’d say. In the new 36 version it is far too busy in the upper half of the dial, also because of the font size: big letters Rolex, then small letters oyster perpetual followed by something in between for the word explorer. Looks like a sheet the eye doctor shows you when your eyesight is being checked. Strangely enough, the same text on the same place in all older 36mm-versions of the Explorer looks just fine to me. Also, the 39 mk2 fortunately has a matt black dial, rather than glossy. Apart from the mediocre 48h power reserve (and maybe the lack of AR-coating, but the absence of it also gives the dial a charming glance in certain lighting conditions), in my opinion the 214270 mk 2 is just perfect if your wrist is not too small.
explorer hands down. especially the new 36mm 2021 version featured in this video. every aspect of the watch has been refined from the previous 36mm explorer from ar coating, bracelet, movement and overall finish and quality. fantastic 1-watch watch.
Problem is how to get one at list.
Lets be brutally honest, everyone would choose the explorer of the two, but you would settle for the other due to lack of availability and higher cost.
If you choose the bb36, you'll never truly be satisfied as a 1-watch collection as long as you know the 124270 exists.
Great video! Thanks for making it. Does the black bay 36 really have white gold hands and indices? I haven’t seen that anywhere but would be cool if that’s true!
Had the 214270 for 2 years. It’s a very well built but sad watch. Mostly has to do with this glossy dial, cold and shiny dial furniture and lack of AR coating. That sums up my feeling about it.
Would need to try the BB36 and compare
Sell it, then get on a list for the 36mm and with the profit money you will have enough for the BB 36 as well.
Ahhhh no way! Thank you so much for this personal review! 😱 do you think you’ll sell it?!
@@BrittPearceWatches sold it years ago. Bought a SeaMaster300 (first gen) which I flipped and have seller’s remorse about.
@@Milofchg the Explorer has been sold some time ago. In that genre of watches, I have found true love with the Sinn556a which I consider an excellent modern interpretation of the 1016.
Big cred for doing the Gosling size even if he’s a white dial guy. You get 36 if you see it pulled off and think you can too for the same reasons or care about the history of sizes and buy it for the same reason. The point is original size.
❤️❤️👏🏻👏🏻✨
Although I've not tried on the new Explorer, even the bigger wearing BB36 was too small on my wrist. I can't see liking the even smaller Explorer. I did try on a pre-owned BB41 black and Explorer 39mm at the same shop a couple weeks ago, and while I didn't dislike the BB41, it did wear a bit thicker than the Explorer. Maybe it's the slab sides on the Tudor, but the 39mm Explorer was SO perfect on the wrist. It almost melted away. I'm still so upset that Rolex discontinued that size. I do wish Tudor would come out with a BB38 or 39. That 5mm gap is quite big when it comes to a watch. I totally get why the choice between them was so tough. If the Explorer wasn't quite so expensive, it might have been an easier choice, but they both are great in their own way. For fans of blue, that BB36/41 in blue doesn't is SO choice. Sadly, there isn't a blue Explorer. There was that smaller blue OP with 3/6/9 at one point, but that's gone now. Such a shame, as that was a hidden gem within the Rolex lineup. Nice comparison video, Gringa.
Been saving for a while and just picked up a bb36. Going to keep saving then trade up to the explorer in a few years
Good life choices my friend! 👏🏻❤️
44 METRE lug to lug . Holy moly that's one BIG ASS watch 🤣. Built for a Brachiosaurus! Great video regardless love the classic looks of the explorer but that BB36 especially the new two tone versions looks great!
I have the BB41 but still yearn for the Explorer. But then seeing them side by side like this i actually think the Tudor is better looking and it does seem hard to justify the price difference.
It’s totally a fair one! And I so relate to this! I feel the same about my BB58 you know! I love the sub! But then when I hold them side by side, or try on the sub… I don’t feel all that fussed for it because I love my BB58!
I'd love a focused comparison of the bb36 and your black OP, great video!
Can’t comment on the Tudor, but love my explorer 114270
Ouuu can we get an amen?! ❤️👏🏻 keep wearing it in good health my friend!
Great video as ever! 36mm is far too small for me.........however.......my missus loves the size, it's perfect for her 5.2" wrist, and likes the Tudor so she doesn't know it yet but it will be in her Santa sock hanging on the fireplace on Christmas eve!! 🎅🎅
Row-lexxxx so versatile ❤️
ROOOOOWLEXXX
Two Tone Rolex Explorer 🧭 is my choice have fallen in love 🥰 with mine which I got for my birthday 🎂 in May from my parents 🤜
I spoke to Rolex Service Centre in London this afternoon. They say if I bring my papers in they will tell me which dealer sold my grey market SkyDweller. We'll see 😁
One can obsess about details. At the end it comes down to the brand name. If you are fine with Tudor, go for Black Bay 36. If you need the Rolex logo, get the Explorer and pay the premium.
I have the Tudor BB 41 in black and an Aquaterra 41 in blue and I probably saved some money...(as you can't get the explorer for 5k EVER!) but I want to drop a bomb here... as I think that the Tudor is both a tool watch and a very elegant one too. Imagine it on the wrist of 007 wearing a tuxedo. You can't say that it would not be elegant... 😉
Ok the intro got me, subbed.
these 2 watches are exactly what i'm looking to buy. Its such a tough choice. My gut is going to black bay as it has a slightly more rounded bezel and the ceramic ball clasp is superb. However explorer is an iconic watch, the 369 makes it so much more legible.
I just ordered the Tudor Black Bay 36 in blue!! Great review and comparison!
Wich one should I pick? Wilsdorf foundation or this another one from Wilsdorf foundation?
You should probably get the one from the Hans Wilsdorf foundation. Just my opinion tho! 😜
@@BrittPearceWatches LOL you got me 😜 Thanks for the feedback and also for the nice video. Stay gold, Gringa!
The explorer 1 hands down for me, the narrative & history of the explorer is a conversation starter (debatable). Have a 112470 in my collection and instinctively have the urge to wear it.
Yes, it does fly under the radar but the highly polished case/bezel and reflective sapphire glass draws attention.
Adrian from Bark & Jack is partly to blame for it.
😖
Brit I went for the black bay 58 blue better than both !😀😀
I got it on your recommendation love ❤️ it and you
The Tudor is a great watch at a decent price. (Though there are plenty of watches with much better specs at this price.) It looks great and if you love the design and size, you'll be plenty happy with it. It's also cheaper to service! With that said, to sum it up, the Rolex 124270 is superior in all these aspects:
- made of 904L steel, more resistant to tarnishing and better polish
- white gold hands and indices, resistant to corrosion basically forever
- movement is highly superior in every way, anti-magnetic and anti-shock etc
- excellent interior AR coating, Tudor lacks any AR coating...
- on the fly micro-adjustment via easy link, generally more solid bracelet
- more elegant case profile which mitigates the perceived thickness
- better lume (appears white in more diverse lighting situations)
- better crown appearance/positioning
Re: water resistance, let's be real. Neither are dive certified. Considering that, there's no difference between 100M and 150M WR. You can swim in either without worry, even more so with the Rolex due to 904L steel being resistant to saltwater corrosion. With all that in mind, I still think the Tudor is an excellent watch - it's just that the Rolex is also definitely worth the price increase! I'm tempted by the Tudor, but I think I'll just wait and save for the Explorer :)
Great vid as usual, but why would you make choose! Both are grails to me. Right now saving for the BB36. And maybe, just maybe after both my girls leave the nest, I’ll start saving for the Explorer. That said, to me these are two totally different watches, I mean, BB36 to me is sportier, while the Explorer is dressier, and both are good enough to be used casually. Anyway, maybe it’s just my fandom taking the best of me, but I love both watches, those are 2/3 of my ‘perfect 3 watch collection’. Keep up the great content. Nice to have Papi’s background participation, although missed the wrist check. Cheers to both of you guys.
OP 36 vs BB 36 will be a better comparison?
Interesting question Gringa. Personally I would be happy with either watch subject to seeing the 36mm on my wrist that is. Both are similar size but they are quite different. The case of the Explorer is more sculpted but the Tudor more sporty as you mention. I think you summed it up perfectly with the Tudor being sporty with a smart edge and the Rolex being smart with a sporty edge. The Rolex being certified could be the deal maker though for those who demand mechanical accuracy.
Very fair!! But to be fair, I hear nothing but great things about the Tudor’s accuracy! 😱 I can’t fully attest myself! But that’s jusy what I hear!
@@BrittPearceWatches I agree Gringa, I've heard nothing but positive things on the accuracy of Tudor watches. I'd guess Tudor take quite a lot of care regulating all movements regardless if they are manufacturer caliber or 3rd party.
Both are nice watches. I think if you have one or the other you should be happy 😊. Personally, I would go for the Tudor.
This is real talk. I so agree! 👏🏻❤️
There's definitely more value for money in Tudor. But I would choose the Explorer. It's also my favourite Rolex. Simple and classy and fits every occassion.
Wow that Tudor fits you perfectly
The Black Bay 36 is more a statement of getting a GADA that is outside the box and a great value - esp. the older "Smile Dials". I think the Explorer is a watch you must really adore to pick up at the price point (AD, and esp. used) - otherwise picking it up seems more like a check the box or influencer induced buy.
Great comparison video!!
*I may have commented two years ago, but rewatched today!😂
I like both and I think the BB36 is awesomely priced (like pretty much every other Tudor). But the Explorer (in 36mm) is pretty much my favourite watch ever, because I feel you can do it everything with it. But I do think it is overpriced, even at retail. You say you would pay retail, and I would too (given the opportunity) because of the current Rolex situation. If we could look at it the same way we look at the Tudor, taking the watch and only the watch into consideration, we would consider it overpriced.
But If I was looking for a one-watch collection and was confortable with spending that kind of money to do it, the Explorer would be the one I'd get. But I'm not a one watch guy, I don't think I'll ever be and I am totally not confortable with spending that kid of money on a watch. I prefer to have various "budget" watches and keep changing between them (but "budget" is obviously subjective. I have around 10 watches and 500 is probably the most I'd spend in one, for now - and that is a lot of money for some people, not a lot to others). So..I'll just enjoy my various "budget" pieces and wear a Hamilton Khaki Field Auto 38mm the same way I would wear a BB36 or an Explorer.
Superb video as always Gringa! Entertaining and expertly edited. You have a real talent! Also, I proudly own the Tudor BB 36. To my eyes, it is more striking and I did not feel in any way that I was buying an inferior watch. So to each their own! I was also able to get a 10% discount from my AD. Something to consider as well. 😎
Great video thanks for sharing it with us ! I really like the Tudor especially for the price point
Right?! I so agree!
Thanks for the video! My issue is that the Tudor doesn’t have the history and heritage behind it like the Explorer does. The question to me is am I willing to pay twice as much for the arguably greatest (subjective I know) tool watch of all time in a modern-spec’d version? That may be worth it!
Great review, Brittany/James, thank you. 1:00 had me burst out laughing. 😂 Can't believe I'm saying this: have to see them side by side, but think I like the Tudor better. 150WR, more readable hands and (to me) better looking dial, and that chamfered edging on the case: sexy. And hate to say it, but value HAS to be a factor for me. My humble opinion. Thanks again🙂👍
I love the Explorer 36mm, and I am waiting patiently for that phone call telling me it is in stock. Long time saving!
Just make sure your sons can inherit your position in the waiting list.
Oh babes! Keep on waiting!!! It’s coming soon! ❤️✨
You're assessment seems about right to me. The Rolex is a little dressier compared to the Tudor, but the availability is a huge negative. So good luck getting one anywhere near retail price! I would be happy with either one on my wrist, but my bank account (and wife) would probably prefer to see the Tudor.
The Tudor looks so fresh! I'd choose it over the Explorer without a doubt.
Great episode! Very funny, as usual
If I were to share my honest opinion:
1 Rolex Explorer is an entry level luxury watch that can't be priced accurately
2 Tudor BB is awesome but it's just a watch that is a little bit overpriced
I’ve had both - still have the Explorer and it wins easily. Right then, now that I’ve given my uninfluenced answer I’ll get on and watch the video! 😁
BOOOM. YAS! I always love when people have personal experiences with the watches! I agree woth the explorer! It’s hard. I’m a Tudor and a Rolex fan girl. But the explorer is sometjing magic!
@@BrittPearceWatches I’ve always had and loved Tudor too, but since having the Explorers (214270 and 124270) I feel they are, and look, more grown up and visually ’wiser!’ The 3 & 9 look like smiling eyes, whereas the BB36 is a wide-eyed child in comparison, fittingly. ☺️😳xx
These are both great watches, but both of them need to upgrade their clasps. For these prices, they both should have highly adjustable clasps like the Planet Ocean, etc. Love your channel, Gringa!
There’s something so elegant about the Explorer, just tried it on - the Tudor is more fun n funky. I’d be happy to own either one. If you’re gifting moi - Explorer all the way and I’m not a Rolex fan-girl. Just bought the Omega aquaterra 38 in Summer Blue limited edition after the got on the list for the Explorer. Good thing I got plenty of time to save up! You’re so zany and fun - really digging your content, Laty. I will pray for Gringa. May you own allll you desire
Enjoyed your video. Have to ask: wouldn’t the BB36 vs the OP be more of an apples to apples?
Wore both last week on the wrist. Picking the tudor. People were right never meet your heroes 😭 Wish I could like the explorer in person
Great episode! So i was one of those people who wanted an Explorer but since it was "hard" to get one I bought the BB36 last spring. At the time a 114270 was about 5K used ( cheap!) but I really felt that the 3K I paid for the brand new Tudor as opposed to a 15 year old Rolex just seemed a no brainer and I was lucky enough to have one that was so well regulated you'd have thought it was a Rolex. But.... in the end I sold it and was able to get a new 214270. So if I could snap my fingers and change the 39mm one I have into the new 36mm one...Yes I would, but that AD ain't havin' it
Good idea to compare both watches, but there is a big gap between both!! 😊 specially in the movement which is the reason why a collector spend money. Spend 2200 for an ETA 2824, in my opinion is too much!!
I’ll say Explorer cause I think it looks more refined and that dial from Tudor kinda looks awkward without the rotating bezel looks great on the 58 but the aesthetic looks a bit imbalance for me. Then again Adrian from Bark and Jack suggested to look at the two tone version and when he said “dirty”, the steel version became a bit dull in comparison. 😂
I love both watches, I do have an Explorer 2020 39mm and just love it. The thing is, in 5 years time my Explorer will still be worth £5k, if not more, but the Tudor will only be worth £1k, if not less. That is the equation ever person looking to buy one of these watches will have to solve. The clever thing to do is buy both watches. Best of both worlds.
I own the Rolex Explorer 2021 36mm. I'll say get the Rolex ONLY at an AD because it's cheaper than a used 39mm and the old 36mm version from 1990-2010. It has a 70 hour power reserve. Although it's only 100 meters water resistance, it has white gold, and adjustable links. Plus it's a Rolex. I held back from buying the Tudor because I know for me it would be a compromise watch. I will always want the Rolex. I will end up buying the Tudor BB 36 because it looks amazing, it's affordable, I prefer 36mm watches, and you can find it at any AD. The other reason I held back on getting a used Explorer 36mm is the clasp and bracelet. It feels cheap and for a watch that was $4k last year, now selling at $7k for a 11-30 year old watch? C'mon.... Then with the Rolex shortage games I couldn't get the 39mm Explorer or a Sub for several years on a waitlist. I was blessed to get this one thanks to my AD rep who knew I wanted an Explorer for many years.
Thisbis such a fair one Kevin! Thank you soooo much for your personal experience as well! I love it when people leave their experiences in the comments! It means so much more than jusy like, my opinion after a couple of weeks with a watch!
Agreed that these are two very different watches. The dial just offers a really different look. Also regarding the clasp, Rolex feels more solid and refined, but I do like that the Tudor clasp is slim. Same thing for the case thickness!
Great video, I think you may have just picked one of the most difficult side by sides there is! Rolex is defo the better of the two, is it better value though? Value for me is a no. The Tudor is my entry level recommendation to my none watch geek friends who want to buy a ‘proper’ watch for a couple of grand. Thanks for the content!👍
I so feel you on this one! I prefer the Rolex but the Tudor is better value for money!
Great review of two very nice watches. I have both, I prefer the more smooth round fluidity of the Rolex. Thanks for sharing. :)
Oh I feel this! Well said! ❤️👏🏻
My brother has a bb36 and it's very nice. I have a wife and kids and a young but growing business, so I proudly wear a Longines. But one day I'd like an explorer.
I actually like the Tudor better, but neither interest me. Still loved the video.
Rolex is absolutely more refined but the black bay with silver dial is hot!
do you like numerals on the dial? Mercedes hands? eating top ramen for a few years? then the explorer is for you!
LOLLLLLL! It’s all too true! 😂👏🏻
1926 is the elephant in the room
I'd say the price comparison is more than 2 to 1 when you can't get the Rolex at MSRP, you have to go secondary/gray market for one and that will cost you $11k so is the Explorer 5 times the watch? NO. However I do drool over an explorer and if/when I get my first Rolex, it will be an Explorer but I also prefer the 38mm.
This is very well said David!!! I agree with everyone here! ❤️✨👏🏻
That’s the point. Unless you have a friend as AD,it is crazy paying that price for an explorer.
Better look to other brands now.
The main difference between the two is that the BB36 is available in blue. Also, BB36 can actually be worn anywhere without the attention you get from the Rolex crown -- which could be a bad thing in some cases.
The main difference between the two is that the BB36 is available ...... Full stop.
@@philw4053 And the much lower price tag 👌
Nobody who isn’t into watches notices a explorer I. Otherwise I agree with you
Hi Brittany, I am also a Tudor fan (love my BB58), but I don't see these two watches competing with each other. The Rolex is arguably the most iconic field/exploring watch ever, with a storied history and provenance. To me, the Tudor looks like a dive watch that lost its timing bezel. I'm on wait lists at every AD in my town for the Explorer, but I would not buy the Tudor, even at a discount. It just doesn't do anything for me.
If Monta did 36mm with sunburst dial that would be dope. I tried Explorer 39mm and dial left me cold but bracelet was godlike.
If Tudor is using a Sellita, what other watches with Sellita movement can you find and for what price? It Tudor then really worth the money when compared with the competition with the same movements?
Ouuuu it’s fair my friend! It is a fair question! But is not a watch more than it’s movement?! (Idk why I went so Shakespeare with it. I hate myself HahHa)
@@BrittPearceWatches Yes, a watch is more than its movement. That is why I was wondering do others offer more, when Tudor can not pull "But the movement is so much better" card.
I was hoping I'd be convinced I like the Tudor more...but it just didn't happen, despite the Tudor being a really nice, well priced piece. In the dive watch category/size, I prefer what Tudor offers. But in this format, the Rolex design clearly takes the day.
Good review. Great watches, but I can't deal with the Tudor having self winding on it.
Are you sure the markers are white gold? At this price point I would guess they are Rhodium plated (which is nice too). Even their S&G models aren’t solid gold, mostly capped.
I try to buy Tudor all the time but end up going with an alternative, except for the Pelogos, I got that one. I find I like Tudor’s marketing images but when I go try them on they don’t deliver the same feeling I got when viewing it in a video or an ad.