I am an Iranian. I wish sone one could translate to Farsi. That I could Share to my family. 👍. God bless you all good teaching. In iran. Many. Many. Iranians accept our loving Jesus I am teaching bible Wish. Could explain. In Farsi too. Can you tell me how I get translated in Farsi ???
You’ll first have to write down whatever is said in this video into English as accurately as possible. Then you can translate the English into whatever language that Google translate can do, or you translate it to Farsi. Then if you want, you can download this video as a copy, use a video editing software to copy the translated text at the bottom in sync with the verbal discussion. Finally upload it to your TH-cam channel.
Hummmm thinking about how I placed an app on my phone to translate a conversation from spanish to English…. Wonder if it has the option of English to Farsi?…?perhaps one can be rented or bought ? Not sure how to reach these guys… I know of a previous Muslim girl that has converted Jesus, has a TH-cam site who answers questions that you write to her.. she is Sonia Azam…put her name in on the TH-cam search… see if she can help
keep spreading acts 17 apologetics and pfander films and dcci ministries and Christian prince and cira international and shamounian and soco films on Facebook and Instagram and twitter and in your country but it is going to take years so take your time and be a messenger parker 😀😀😀😀
@@buhariayobami874 60 cubits tall, Sahih al-Bukhari 3326 In-book reference : Book 60, Hadith The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Allah created Adam, making him 60 cubits tall. Goliath in the Bible was only 6 cubits. That is, about 9 feet 9 inches or about 3 meters Me think they tried to copy the bible and added a zero without knowing the term cubits, what do you think? Samuel 17:4). Maybe the Authors of the 37 Qurans used The Book of Enoch, it talks about huge giants... You won't find that in the Bible.
@@bobfisher1909 The question is was that written in the Quran??? When you have nothing to change with all you direct questions to is “ Haddits “ says is the Haddit the Quran or it’s the first call of Muslims holy book. All I will ask from you will be from the Bible too so don’t be scared.
@@buhariayobami874 , what are you on about? The Quran which one? 1924 Hafs lol. I'm not scared brudder ask away... First call of the holey books lol, what are you on about, wasn't it Uthman in 652 that was to gather up what he could find and write what he thought was good and burn the rest? So 1st where is this book? 2nd, Muslims claim it was oral prior so please tell me what did Uthman burn? 3rd was Uthman there with Muhammad at the time to make it authentic? Please provide evidence to this and you will be a hero in Islam because not even scholars for the past one thousand years have been able to fix the holey Quran according to Dr. Yasir Qadhi one of Islam finest students.
@@bobfisher1909 The challenge has been thrown to you for centuries. If I may ask do you still have a book like if? Even the most intelligent of you worldwide are coming to seeing the miracle or if or do you have a book like it now? Will surely be interested in arguing with you if Only you have a scripture/book which is can direct my arguments to because I may not know which is your own out of all the versions of the Bible around the world . Bring on a question from the Quran that’s my first book of believe and let hear which is yours too. Let’s see the difference in all the Quran’s contents and meanings.
what have you learned from them?they are running there mouths against a religion that makes it a article of faith to believe in Jesus Christ pbuh and all of its followers share this belief there are no two believes about Jesus Christ one belief that he is a Messenger and a Prophet that he was born without a human intervention that he was raised up alive and that he will come back before the end of time why would a Christian insult Prophet Mohammed may peace be upon him and for what reason .
The Quran is plagiarized from different sources The Quran's story is found in Sura 5:27-32. Initially, the O.T. and Quran basically agree on the narrative. In verse 31, the two diverge. "That is why we laid it down for the Israelites that whoever killed a human being, except as punishment for murder or other villainy in the land, shall be deemed as though he had killed all mankind; and that whoever saved a human life shall be deemed as though he had saved all mankind.".
Initially, there appears to be no connection between verses 31 and 32. Why the life or death of one should be as the salvation or destruction of all mankind in not made clear in the Quran. When we turn to another Jewish record - the Mishnah Sanhedrin, we find the link between the story and what follows: "We find it said in the case of Cain who murdered his brother, 'The voice of thy brother's bloods crieth' (Gen. 4:10). It is not said here blood in the singular, but bloods in the plural, that is, his own blood and the blood of his seed. Man was created single in order to show that to him who kills a single individual it shall be reckoned that he has slain the whole race, but to him who preserves the life of a single individual it is counted that he hath preserved the whole race." Mishnah Sanhedrin, 4:5 Here in the Quran is a passage from the Mishnah! The Mishnah is a Jewish commentary on the Torah. How did a Rabbi's commentary on the Torah make its way into the Quran? Simple, Muhammad had heard these teachings from the Jews, and repeated them later as he recited "revelation".
Because the word for blood is in the plural in Gen. 4:10, an ingenious Rabbi invented the supposition that all Abel's offspring had been killed with him which signified that any murder or life-saving act had universal implications. Clearly Muhammad had no knowledge of the source of the theory set out in the Mishnah but, in hearing it related, simply set out the Rabbi's suppositions as the eternal decree of God! Now today, some Jewish Rabbi's thoughts are quoted as revelation in the Quran! This short piece clearly shows, in one way at least, how Muhammad received "revelations". In this case, verbal stories told by the Jews, and Muhammad's memory served him. Here the Quran fails the test of authenticity; it owes much of its substance to other faiths. For some reason Muhammad decided to quote a Jewish story, feeling it has some important meaning, and placed into the Quran. Little did Muhammad know or really understand from what he was really quoting. NOTE: Dating of the Mishnah Sanhedrin is as follows, from the Encyclopedia Judaica, 1996, Keter Publishing House Jerusalem "Commitment to writing began about the middle of the 3rd century CE with RAV (Abba Aricha) and Samuel and was completed with the conclusion of the teaching of Ravina in 499 AD." Likewise the "Introduction to the Babylonian Talmud", Soncino Press edition by Dr. J.H. Hertz states that the Babylonian Talmud " Claims origins from the Babylonian captivity proclaiming the religious and civil law fixed in 444 BEC by Ezra the Sofer (The Biblical Ezra the Scribe) and finalized in 500 AD."
Both these references state that the writing related to 5:32 predate Muhammad.
TH-cam don’t let me post links ( keeping delete) , so you can copy the name of article and search it Mohammed claimed that he was a prophet sent by the God of the Bible, but is it true? 🕋Islamic Jesus Explained ( search it on Mohammad Faridi’s TH-cam channel) It’s not surprising that Mohammed made a mistake about the Trinity. He also made many other mistakes. Muhammad could not even copy the Bible correctly。 He also copied Jewish mythology and pseudepigrapha stories into Quran and mixed with pre-Islam Arab Fairytale , There is no doubt that he is the false prophet predicted by the Bible❗️ 👉The Collection and Sources of the Qu'ran B. JEWISH INFLUENCES IN THE QUR'AN. 👉 Material for the Evaluation of the Sources of the Qur'an 👉The Quran, King Solomon, and late Jewish mythology 👉 MUHAMMAD THE BORROWER 👉 False Prophet Muhammad, Fairytale Muhammad, and Harley Talman
@Abdallah Saleh Here is a desire suit human’s lustful nature: Marry to a 👧 with 🧸when I turn to my 50+ just like 🕋moral model Mo👳🏻♂️ Mo👳🏻♂️is best mankind in the eyes of al-ilah, should we follow the sunnah of him?
Hi Drs. Jay and Al Fadi. Great work in uncovering the counterfeit Narrative. The Bible has another account of a Judge breaking the idols they were worshipping ,after he was called to deliver Israel. When the villagers found their idols broken they confronted the future Judge. It is Giddeon.
can you check comparation of the Warsh and Hafs Quran in Sura 98:6 because some said that in Warsh is written Inosent and in Hafs creatures but other said that in both mean creatures?
Great content! Thank you, Al Fadi! I appreciate the work you do to show the inconsistencies in islam. May the True God of all creation draw people out of the lies they are captive to. They can be set free in Jesus!
@@RevJay_Rides Fastest growing religion in the western world is Islam despite all the lies about about Islam being violent.Thousands are converting to Islam as we speak more and more people have picked up the Quran and found the truth.Churches of Paul invented Christianity are empty.
@@farookdinaully8029 Yes, and all of them will go to hell unless they repent and leave that false religion and turn to the One, True Savior and Lord of all, the King of kings, the Lord of Lords, the Way the Truth and the Life, Jesus Christ.
I have a question. How come Mecca existed as a town when Adam and Eve were the only humans around? I always noticed that a town is full of humans and btw who built it?
Bro Didier please be a bit smart. There was no town at that time yet. The place where Adam was dismissed from heavan is now known as mecca. The place where Adam met Eve is now called Jabar Rahmah in Arafah Mecca.
Mecca, the happiest place on earth. With the statue of Mo riding a Burak and a child Aisha, holding a small ragged doll, on his lap, both found at the entrance to the happiest place on earth.
It is obvious that Quran was clearly talking about Napoléon Bonaparte. Even if his name wad not explicitly there, this means nothing. Muslims pretend that Mekka and Mohamed are so important but Allah doesn't use their names in the Quran. See? Thus Napoléon
When it is only the 'messenger' or 'the home' of the messenger without directly stating a person of location, Paris or Glasgow, Spitsbergen or Vladivostok can be substituted just as Sue or Bobby, Kamala or Ping dropped in. Song Long Ming Dong works just as well.
@@aldredtawasil9339 Sooooo? Why should someone 200 years after that man's death while in custody after losing a war, put any attention to what he held in respect? Stop digging up corpuses to call for respect toward that EDITED BOOK. And what makes you think that tyrant was a Christian? Gandhi was more a Christian than that creature.
@@aldredtawasil9339 I also have a great respect for the Quran. Allah says that i am filthy and I am the worst of creatures. نجس وشر البرية and he will barbecue me forever in hell. How i cannot have respect for him? Are you crazy?
I never knew Muslims were taught that the Garden of Eden was in space. Where did they ever dream that one up from ? It was on Earth of course as God stated ;He gave Earth to His children. (Mankind). Not the evil ones or evil leaders.
Mecca's made up history is partially hijacked from Harran, which is a very old city and was home to Abraham. Around 640, Harran was taken from the Byzantines by the Arab armies, and much later, Caliph Marwan II made it capital of the Islamic Empire from 744-750 until it was conquered by the Abbasids in 750. Marwan II built a mosque in the center of the city and a royal palace on the site of the temple. The town also had a university built in the late 8th century to early 9th. The town was surrounded with a 4 km long and 3 km wide wall with seven gates. I believe Masjid al-Haram could be a reference to either the temple to the moon god Sin, in Harran, or literally the Mosque Marwan II built in the same city, in 744-750, the latter puts a date of no earlier than 744 on the finalised Quran. Archaeologists found 6th century Babylonian steles turned face down and used as steps at the entrances of the mosque. These steles were part of the original Babylonian temple of Sin. Harran exists in a region which was already occupied 6,200 years ago, hence I wouldn't be surprised that stories about Adam and Eve living there existed during the Arab occupation from the 6th century. During the first half of the 6th century, Babylonian King Nebuchadnezzar ruled Harran. The town was home to the Sabian worshippers of the moon god Sin. Facing always to the north, they prayed at dawn, midday and sunset, just like described in the Quran (5 daily prayers is not in the Quran, it's in the hadiths). The principal deity was worshipped in the form of a pillar or holy stone, and under him were the sun god (Shamash), the moon god (Sin), Saturn (Kronos), Jupiter (Bel), Mars (Ares), Venus (Balti), and Mercury (Nabuq). The cult was still practised into the 12th century. The original moon temple at Harran was one of the holiest sanctuaries of the Middle East, and the Harran astronomers were held in high regard by the brilliant court of the Abbasids in Baghdad in the 9th century. Their religious emblem of a crescent and an eight-pointed star was subsequently adopted by a variety of esoteric sects and the spread of the crescent and star symbol, still so prevalent in the Islamic world, seems to date from that time. According to the Old Testament, Harran was also the place where Terah and his son Abraham, his grandson Lot and Abraham’s wife Sarah went after leaving Ur. It was 18 centuries before Christ that Abraham was called from Ur of the Chaldees to go to Canaan according to the Old Testament. He stopped at Harran for several years until God told him to move on: "So Abram departed, as the Lord had spoken unto him: and Abram was seventy and five years old when he departed out of Harran. And Abram took Sarai his wife and Lot his brother’s son and all their substance that they had gathered, and the souls that they had gotten in Harran; and they went forth to go into the land of Canaan (Genesis 12:4-5)." Although Abraham went on to Canaan after his father Terah died, some relatives apparently remained. Much later Abraham sent a servant back to Harran to find a wife from among his relatives for his son Isaac. The traditional site of Jacob's Well (Bir Yakub), where Rebecca drew water for Abraham's servant is about one km northwest of the Harran city walls. According to tradition, Harran was where Jacob laboured for twenty years for his father-in-law Laban. Travellers can follow the so-called "Abraham's Path" that begins in Turkey, runs for 170 km through flattish semi-arid landscapes and incorporates the major sights of Urfa, Göbekli Tepe, the Well of Job, Harran, the Well of Jacob and Sogmatar. The earliest records of Harran come from the Ebla tablets, c. 2300 BCE. They were discovered in the palace archives of the ancient city of Ebla, Syria. They all date to the period between ca. 2500 BC and the destruction of the city ca. 2250 BC.
#Mecca was a dry place,but Taif ( not very far from Mecca) and Medina were full of plants and trees. Mecca was famous for the Kaabah where many Arab tribes have their own deities there. It was not a very big trading centre,but mainly cater for the locals and people(nomads) around the central Arabia,which was mostly desert. Because of this arid desert that,no one invaded it,or spread Christianity there,and most people remained as pagans. #But in the south,Yemen was a thriving Christian centre,and at the north Medina was inhabited by the Arab Jews and Arab pagans. What was important is,the trading route between Syria and Mecca. Yemen had sea routes for trade.The desert Arabia(including Mecca) were not much populated due to the tribal killings,difficulty in child bearing due to heat, high mortality, and the hot weather. #The presence of the Zam Zam well was the proof of Abraham,Hagar and infant Ishmael were there. The well is active till today. Later,both Abraham and Ishmael repaired the damaged or neglected Kaabah,as stated in the Qur'an. Even the Bible states that Ishmael would be given many kingdoms,and hence ,his descendants must be the Arabs. Much later,it was Prophet's grandfather Abdul Mutalib who re-discovered the ruined Zam Zam well,and his descendants were the water providers to the pilgrims prior to Islam. No one documented Mecca because,no one invaded that area-- Hejaz and Central Arabia. Also,as Meccans were pagans,the Christians could possibly ignored it. That's why,the Qur'an says,"Your people had not been warned (before)... and this Qur'an is revealed in their language",..considering Syria,Palestine/Israel,Yemen,Ethiopia were either Christian or Jews. #Adam and Eve might have lived there and even their children. Centuries later,as their descendants mutiplied(i.e. we humans),they started seeking greener pastures,far from the desert. Most of the prophets originated in areas between Egypt till Mesapotamia until Turkey at the North. Only Prophet Muhammad was from the Arabian clan. # Regarding that Mecca was mentioned only a few times in the Qur'an,the word 'masjidil haram"(sacred place) was mentioned at other places. Also,in the Qur'an Jesus, Mary,Adam,Moses,Abraham,etc were mentioned more times than our Prophet, because through His messages,God was talking directly to Prophet Muhammad. That's why you can find words,like,"Say(Qul in Arabic)....(to them)......",many times. # The main issue between Christianity and Islam is the Divinity of Jesus. Islam accepts Jesus' life in most part. The irony is,Judaism is rejecting Jesus totally. Thanks.(mohd iqbal).
Very interesting. Thanks. Once again I wish to bring to your research team that there a Dutch Colonial Muslim tradition in Sri Lanka that Adam landed in the island. Also they have Adam's Bridge (previously Rama Sethu causeway; Ramayana story) which connects Sri Lanka to South India. Ref Ronit Ricci's work in Israel publicised in youtube. In an earlier show Jay Smith mentioned that Eve landed in Kerala. What this means may be that Adam went from Sri Lanka to join up with Eve in Kerala to very long walk to Mecca or take a boat to cross to Yemen and join a camel caravan to Mecca. Is this in any Hadith literature?
@@justaminute3111 Interesting question! Adam would used the animals in Ceylon eg Bullocks. thus later they had bullock carts. Having crossed into South India by the Rama-Sethu causeway ('Adam's Bridge'), he could have continued his journey to find Eve. Final destination Mecca. shorter route would be by sea in a catamaran or Adam's first boat and sail to Yemen. Use camels there to reach Mecca. Thus a first caravan. Possible? God/Allah is on his side.
Thank you for the various thought-provoking suggestions and hints! BUT one must proceed already carefully and it is difficult to think in metamorphosis, in the process... a few millennia ago go there were advanced civilizations in places which are desert today (there are excavations in Iran or Mongolia). Where no tree grows today, there was possibly a garden 6-8000 years ago. There are a lot of meghalitic stone settlements in Arabia, the history points very far back. And if you study carefully the indications of the paradise rivers in the Bible, the paradise in Arabia "touched the earth."
I see where you’re going and its impossible Abraham , and Adam was in mecca. But if You want to make a point with the climate of Mecca, climatologist say that Mecca was a green place few centuries ago. When exactly? I don’t know but it was maybe a greener Mediterranean type climate by the time of muhammed. It’s maybe a false direction, although, it’s important to point out that it’s impossible that Mecca was the center of the world as the Quran claims
You might refer to the last glacial age. I know that the Sahara was green at the time but it was 10 000 years ago at least. It might be correct for Saudi Arabia. It is older than Mecca.
@@sidprice6214 Ask a geologist about Saudi oil formation! It could be older than 200 000 000 years. The youngest possible oil is around 1 00 000 years I think.
@@abdallahsaleh86 😂 Provide 7th Century historical evidence for the Mohammed of Islam Provide 7th Century Qurans Provided 7th Century archeological evidence for a cosmopolitan Mecca in Arabia in the 7th Century Provide 7th Century historical evidence for the Rightly Guided Caliphs As of yet no Muslim or even Muslim Scholars and Historians have found any evidence for the above Islam is based on stories and twisted plagiarism
@@abdallahsaleh86 So you can’t provide 7th Century evidence, it just goes to show how false Islam is Have a read No Mohammed = No Islam, No Islam = No Allah of Islam MUSLIM ISLAMIC SCHOLARS Muslim Islamic scholar Sulimn Bashear at the An-Najah University taught that the Quran and Islam were the products of historical development, rather than coming from Mohammed Muslim Professor Muhammad Sven Kalisch is an Islamic researcher and scholar at the University of Münster. He is also the first person in Germany to hold a Chair of Islamic Religion, believes THE MOHAMMED OF THE QURAN PROBABLY NEVER EXISTED en.qantara.de/content/criticism-of-islamic-theologian-muhammad-kalisch-doubt-about-muhammads-existence-poses
@@abdallahsaleh86 That’s the corrupted Muslim view, started by the Abbasids You still haven’t provided any 7th Century historical evidence for the following; A Mohammed of Islam A Quran/Qurans A Mecca in Arabia The rightly guided caliphs
@@abdallahsaleh86 You poor fellow Dates that cause concern; dates referring to an individual are the dates of their death 647; 15 years after the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Qurans death, in a letter written in 647 by the patriarch of Seleucia he makes no reference to the Arab conquerors as Muslims, or show any awareness of a religion called Islam 680; 48 years after the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Qurans death, in none of Muawiya’s (who defeated Ali in 661) documents, inscriptions, or coins is there any mention or reference to the Mohammed of the Quran and Islam. Indeed, they show Persian Zoroastrian and Christian influences. 691; 59 years after the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Qurans death, is when the term Muslim started to be used (from the Dome of the Rock), up until then they called themselves Saracen, Hagarian, Ishmaelite, Maghraye and Muhajiroun. 691; 59 years after the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Qurans death, is the first time that the word Islam is recorded, which is in the Dome on the Rock, which Abd al Malik had built. 692; 60 years after the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Qurans death, is the first time there is reference to Mohammed, and that is on a coin, which also has the image of Abdul al Malik holding a sword. However, this is most likely Abdul al malik calling himself the ‘Chosen One’ 696; 64 years after the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Qurans death (outside of the Dome of the Rock), is the first time there is Islamic style writing which is on a Coin with no images and a form of the Shahada, done by Abdul al Malik 741; 109 years after the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Qurans death, is the first historical reference to Mecca, 109 years after Mohammed’s death, and that it is in Iraq, not Arabia 765; 133 years after the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Qurans death, tradition has it that Ibn Ishaq writes first biography of Mohammed? But none of his material exists 833: 201 years after the Mohammed of the Qurans death, is the first biography of THE FICTIONAL Mohammed (Sira) which is by Ibn Hisham, and he only writes down the material he likes which (according to tradition) was handed down to him via his teacher from Ibn Hisham, and eliminates the material he doesn’t like. Ibn Hisham is the first person to write down Mohammed’s genealogy, 201 years after Mohammed’s death. This breaks a fundamental principal of a biography, which should be based on eyewitness accounts. 870; 238 years after the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Qurans death, the first Hadith (sayings, rulings and behaviours of Mohammed) are attributed to Al-Bukhari who realizing that oral translation wasn’t satisfactory, wrote down the narrations some 238 years after THE FICTIONAL Mohammed’s death. Tradition has it that Al-Bukhari is given 600,000 narrations, and he whittles them down to 7,397 (nine volumes) narrations that he considered to be reliable. But when you take into account repetitions and variances of the same report, the number is only 2,602. However, the first Hadith (one volume) is only found in the 11th Century, and it is not until the 17th Century that you get all nine volumes together, and there is no original manuscript by Al-Bukhari. Hadith derives from the Arabic root ḥ-d-th meaning “to happen” and so “to tell a happening,” There is a small sect of Muslims that completely reject the Hadiths. 900; 268 years after the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Qurans death, is the first time that Mecca is on an Arabian map. 923; 291 years after the death of the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Quran is when the Tafsir, which is commentaries on the Quran, and the Tarikh which is concerned with Muslim history is written. The author At-Tabari was born in Amol (1122 miles from Medina) and died in Baghdad, 838 miles from Medina, he couldn’t possibly have known Mohammed
@Chris Azure the Abbies were Persians not Arabs being dependent of others to write the Arabic with no one able to do an editorial check prior to distribution dissemination.
@@gilbertjones9157 I was playing off the SIN (Sandard Islamic Narrative) and what Jay said SAD (Standard Abbasid D...). Without going back and listening again, I can't remember what his D was. I offered Deception as an alternative.
No Muslim believes that Abraham lived in Makkah except that he would bring his wife Hagar and his son Ismail there and he would visit them later and build the Kaabah and there he was comanded to sacrifice his son. Thats it. And that man misquoted the Quran. He said 'rihlatu' but is should be 'rihlata' and every child should know that. If he was a muslim and he wants to be truthful he should not accept and speak out such lies. I've no need of watching more from this. May Allah guide you. Ameen
How did the Dome of the Rock in Jerusalem next to the 2nd Temple ever become the third holiest site to the Muslims (even though there is absolutely no mention of Jerusalem in the Quran”? How is this possible?
There is no But But But! As in...... yes Koran says XYZ about violence;.........BUT.............. ! (always thought that the expression 'There is no God but God' as containing some kind of comedy gold).
It seems a bit odd that Al Fadi is interviewing Jay on traditions in Saudi Arabia, when Al Fadi is from Saudi Arabi and Jay is not. Al Fadi should also do his own presentations on this channel, in addition to interviewing others. It would be interesting to hear what he thinks about what he learns in these interviews, as a former Muslim from a Muslim-majority country.
Prophet Noah and the big flood was mentioned in both quran and bible. It supposed to be the biggest disaster even happened where only people in the boat were survived. Any written history documented anywhere of this big tragedy.
I see elsewhere in this series they refer to an actual mecca as being in Syria. That place might well be oldest of cities it's neighhbor , Damascus is certainly very ancient and considered one of the oldest continuously settled cities in the world. Just saying. The claim would make some logical sense in that area...
I’d be cautious when referencing things that have to deal with weather as we know that it changes over time, think Little Ice Age. It’s possible that an area that is now arid was once green, look at the petrified forest in the SW United States.
Linguistically the syllable B and M can be interchangeable ? Bacca becomes Macca ? the most modern example of this interchangeability of the syllable B and M lies in India. You know the city of Mumbai ( that is the original name pronounced in the vernacular language of the local fishermen ) was known earlier as Bombay during the British rule & until 50 yrs after the British left. The word Mumbai was pronounced as Bombay by the European settlers from 17th century Dutch, Portuguese, French and British later Indians too. Mainly the north Indian Hindi speaking people used to pronounce Mumbai as Bumbai. Recently in the last 25-30 years. Bombay & Bumbai was restored to Mumbai. So finally the first beginner syllable B becomes M.
Ibrahim didn't destroyed idols in Makkah but His native city Urr which is located in present-day Iraq, Far from Makkah. Why U people are assuming that city was Makkah if Quran and Hadith didn't mention it? Bakkah means narrow and crowded valley, didn't you people realize that Makkah is surrounded by huge mountains and there is still very narrow plane land to live in. Madina called Yathrib at the time of the Prophet and then called Madina un Nabi and now just called Madina. memorized 1 city with 2-3 names is normal .
See the book by Abraham Katsh called Judaism and the Koran. He shows how many verses in the Quran were drawn from Midrash Rabba (not Mishna) and Pirkei de Rabbi Eliezer. There are also many stories and hadiths drawn from Tractate Sanhedrin in the Babylonian Talmud.
The first thought / question that popped in my mind was: " why is he still wearing Muslim outfit"? Aren't we as God's Children an open book? Not the what you wear defines who you are in the inside but it does says a lot about you. What is the first impression when you see someone dressed like this? I don't no harm its just something like I said before popped in my mind
You are right brother they are paid agent to paint Islam bad and they make millions of dollars from it islamphobic stories . I have one of them confessed in a video.
I don't understand U guys , what was your points, his not Petra his Mecca. And it will remain in Mecca , lies can't change it , Mecca , Mecca is Mecca , and Petra is Petra
God bless this man for being the true muslim for telling the truth about the history of islam. Im biafra jewish! God bless my christian friends ✡️🤝✝️. Yeshua is king!!!
Original sin at least as its defined by the west, is not found in eastern Christianity and never has been. And the Bible most certainly does not teach that we inherit the guilt of Adam. What it teaches is that we inherit the consequences of Adam's sin, namely, death.
Garden of eden was in todays modern day iraq by tigris river. Adam was never in what you allegedly called heaven cause he was allegedly made out of earths clay, mud or dust.
Islam mostly is an Arbi mirror of Christianism and Judaism. Abbasids have tried their best to concoct so that this theology i.e. Islam fits to their local need.
HAEB DS Because they are terrified.These lirs should not be making videos when there is not a Muslim scholar there to reply to them.They are like boxers who keep punching a punch bag and claiming victory.
They are both liers and deceivers and they will never invite a an Muslims scholar to debate with them but only that guy called Al Fadi he dresses to confuse people into believing he is a muslim. They make millions of dollars from such islamphobic videos. I have a video of one of them who confessed. Can send the video in your messenger if you don’t mind. From their we enlighten the people too.
Adam landed on a mountain in Sri Lanka which the British dutifully named Adam's Peak. Adam's footprint is found there. Local Buddhists dispute that, claiming that it is Buddha's footprint. Hindus dispute both claims, insisting that it was where their god Rama stood. Adam climbed down from his peak, and when he reached northern Sri Lanka, he found an artificial bridge built for him, which the Brits named, unsurprisingly, Adam's Bridge. Hindus claim it was the Bridge their god Rama used to cross into the Resplendent Isle, Sri Lanka. Buddhists claim that Buddha crossed that bridge on his way to Sri Lanka and back to Nepal. In any case, Adam climbed down his peak, crossed his bridge into India and headed on to Mecca where he found Eve, enjoying an apple, no doubt, at the famous apple orchards of Arafat.
Actually the story of Adam in Sri Lanka was likely to have been made up by early Muslim settlers from India and converts to Islam in both Sri Lanka and southern India. Sri Lanka has a long standing community of Tamil-speaking Muslims who came from India- they say they came from Arabia. Tamil is an Indian language spoken in Tamil Nadu in India and by the minority Tamils of Sri Lanka and elsewhere. The majority of Sri Lankans speak an unrelated language called Sinhala.
@mysotiras12 a "billion Muslims"? Do you actually believe in that engineered myth? Mahometans don't let conversion out of their cult. They even snatch dead bodies (eg: Lance Corporal Manaim Moorthy, a Hindu and Gar Enggor, a Buddhist of Malaysia) to bolster the ranks of Cult of Peace. They deem toddlers to have embraced their cult (eg: Shadia Nagui Ibrahim, a Coptic Christian of Egypt) when their dads run away and marry Mahometan women. Thousands of Mahometans leave their cult annually (eg: Al Fadi of Saudi Arabia) but the Cult of Peace continues to count them as Mahometans. Then they cook up statistics to cite that magic figure of 1 billion which you have then peddled to me in order to make your point. You are the one who seems to be believing in their fairytales.
It’s amazing how people can get away with lies. He is putting evidence that Quran claims that Macca has olives. The truth is that the quotes from Quran he is referencing are talking about olives. But not a single verse of them claimed that those olives were in the city of Mecca. Those verses of Quran were talking generally about olives, both the tree and the fruit. So Dr. J lied about it and used it as a Claim to refute. Just go and check for yourselves
Trade centres historically have a gate function built in.. a reason why trade must go through a place b from a to c. Mecca has no such thing.. sail past it or go overland through cities riverlands and trade centres ( eg bagdad ) or drop in on mecca .. for no particular reason ..? Hmmm Oman was in antiquity just on the coast but this facilitated trade to India. In other words it broke up the remaining legs to Egypt or bagdad underlining further that mecca would be useless but also in competition with Egyptian out posts. Unlikely in the extreme given how forcefully Egypt defended it's river out posts against Kush or Nubia On an ajacent important trade route. Oman as entrepot port would easily serve all purposes for Egypt and bagdad ...of course Oman and also Yemen do have sites of great antiquity. These places are known trading centres going back 1000 s of years. Such things leave evidence. A LOT of evidence. Likewise we know Damascus is ancient by evidence of multiple layers of cities built there. Not by fantasies written elsewhere...
With all due reapect though the Original Sin was a later doctrine by a church father. It used to be read as that they sinned yes but then when u read about Cain and Abel and Abel slaying Cain. God tells Abel that sin can crouch at your door but you can overcome it. As well with all due respect the gospels and the archeological research is so varied because the gospels the christians read can't agree where Jesus was born. One story says nothing about Joseph and thats thought to be the earliest gospel that was written down. I enjoy your videos but I seem to see this sort of mine is right yours is wrong with the guest. I mean all respect and enjoy your videos.
How would one know it is "the" zamzam well? It could be archaelogically investigated, and if you know of any such work, that might be useful in supporting some settlement point at Mecca at some early stage, if it could be found it was built way before the 8C. They don't allow non-muslims into Mecca and Medina though, so efforts may be rather inhibited. Safa and Marwah are not impressive in Mecca. In Jerusalem Marwah is the Arab name for Mount Moria, and Josephus in his 'Antiquities of the Jews' gave Safa as a name for Mount Scopus, and there is textual evidence that wooden temples got built on the Temple Mount in the 7C, followed by Abd-el-malik's stone masjid. So the masjid al haram looks like it was the temple site in Jerusalem, where 7C Arab warlords built this temple, being destroyed by quakes some times, before the stone one. They weren't fully islamic though as their coins have pictures of kings and some symbols of christian and zoroastrian type. and some seem to have become christians. No evidence I've seen in the 7C documents that they poured forth out of the desert of the Hijaz.
@@I9s7lam5is-S3tu1pid Thanks, but I know that. That was not my question. I am trying to understand why people thought Muhammad's Quran was special. Is there something about the Arabic that I am not able to see because I can't read Arabic? A lyrical quality of meter or rhyme does not mean it is divine, but I want to see what early Muslims found so inspiring? Or was it just enforced by fiat to believe it was special?
@@hazratmuhazmat8831 Quran includes lots of scientific statements that their correctness and validity has been proven only with the current scientific discoveries and developments .These scientific statements in the Quran are considered as miracles of the Quran and as proof of its authenticity from God not invented by humans.
@@farookdinaully8029 I have heard them all and debunked them all. You have to have a weak mind to believe some of the things people claim are scientific discoveries. But I can prove the Quran is just a myth. 1) Show me Dhul Qarnayn's wall, 2) Show me the pebbles that killed the people of the Elephant or 3) Show me the idols that Abraham removed for the Kaaba. Show me 2 of those 3 things and I will say Shahada. Otherwise, you book is just filled with myths.
I am an Iranian. I wish sone one could translate to Farsi. That I could Share to my family. 👍. God bless you all good teaching. In iran. Many. Many. Iranians accept our loving Jesus I am teaching bible Wish. Could explain. In Farsi too.
Can you tell me how I get translated in Farsi ???
You’ll first have to write down whatever is said in this video into English as accurately as possible. Then you can translate the English into whatever language that Google translate can do, or you translate it to Farsi.
Then if you want, you can download this video as a copy, use a video editing software to copy the translated text at the bottom in sync with the verbal discussion. Finally upload it to your TH-cam channel.
@S135tu Di97P toooooooo harrrrrd
Hummmm thinking about how I placed an app on my phone to translate a conversation from spanish to English…. Wonder if it has the option of English to Farsi?…?perhaps one can be rented or bought ? Not sure how to reach these guys… I know of a previous Muslim girl that has converted Jesus, has a TH-cam site who answers questions that you write to her.. she is Sonia Azam…put her name in on the TH-cam search… see if she can help
Don't worry ...
He will make a way just pray
Yep google translate would be a good start. Or maybe a group of people to work on the project. ?
This is great, thanks for sharing Mr Fadi and Dr Jay God bless to both of you
Excellent video. Al Fadi & Jay work well together. Lots of good information.
G y
Ku 66 can. Tvgb 7c.
@@wagihboutrus5845 Heroo si pews
Looking forward to the rest of this series! God Bless you Both!
Awesome content on this channel
Awesome.. always looking forward to new content here 💐
✨ Hallelujah ✝️🙏🏻 LOVE FROM INDIA 🇮🇳❤️
keep spreading acts 17 apologetics and pfander films and dcci ministries and Christian prince and cira international and shamounian and soco films on Facebook and Instagram and twitter and in your country but it is going to take years so take your time and be a messenger parker 😀😀😀😀
Metoo ✝️💟
Very interesting series. I'm watching from Fiji.
GOD bless you gentlemen for the work that you do.
I thought the oldest town was Jericho? I’m looking forward to this series. May the Peace of Christ be upon Al Fadi and Dr. Jay.
First settlements might have been in today south east Turkey - close to the springs or Tigris and Euphrat. There is origin of grain.
@@maxschon7709 but not Mecca
Appreciate the efforts.
90 feet tall Adam built a foot rest to polish his saddles, Goats in space, Nonsense and echo's of the Quran...
Did the Quran say Adam was 90 feet tall? And all what you say are all from the Quran too?
@@buhariayobami874 60 cubits tall, Sahih al-Bukhari 3326
In-book reference : Book 60, Hadith
The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Allah created Adam, making him 60 cubits tall.
Goliath in the Bible was only 6 cubits. That is, about 9 feet 9 inches or about 3 meters Me think they tried to copy the bible and added a zero without knowing the term cubits, what do you think?
Samuel 17:4).
Maybe the Authors of the 37 Qurans used The Book of Enoch, it talks about huge giants... You won't find that in the Bible.
@@bobfisher1909 The question is was that written in the Quran??? When you have nothing to change with all you direct questions to is “ Haddits “ says is the Haddit the Quran or it’s the first call of Muslims holy book. All I will ask from you will be from the Bible too so don’t be scared.
@@buhariayobami874 , what are you on about? The Quran which one? 1924 Hafs lol. I'm not scared brudder ask away...
First call of the holey books lol, what are you on about, wasn't it Uthman in 652 that was to gather up what he could find and write what he thought was good and burn the rest? So 1st where is this book? 2nd, Muslims claim it was oral prior so please tell me what did Uthman burn?
3rd was Uthman there with Muhammad at the time to make it authentic?
Please provide evidence to this and you will be a hero in Islam because not even scholars for the past one thousand years have been able to fix the holey Quran according to Dr. Yasir Qadhi one of Islam finest students.
@@bobfisher1909 The challenge has been thrown to you for centuries. If I may ask do you still have a book like if? Even the most intelligent of you worldwide are coming to seeing the miracle or if or do you have a book like it now? Will surely be interested in arguing with you if Only you have a scripture/book which is can direct my arguments to because I may not know which is your own out of all the versions of the Bible around the world . Bring on a question from the Quran that’s my first book of believe and let hear which is yours too. Let’s see the difference in all the Quran’s contents and meanings.
Very hard to have trade route without water and food!
Thank you for patiently explaining these details for better understanding. God bless & protect you both always.🥰
I learn a lot from both of you guys. Can’t wait for the next episode!
what have you learned from them?they are running there mouths against a religion that makes it a article of faith to believe in Jesus Christ pbuh and all of its followers share this belief there are no two believes about Jesus Christ one belief that he is a Messenger and a Prophet that he was born without a human intervention that he was raised up alive and that he will come back before the end of time why would a Christian insult Prophet Mohammed may peace be upon him and for what reason .
The Quran is plagiarized from different sources
The Quran's story is found in Sura 5:27-32. Initially, the O.T. and Quran basically agree on the narrative. In verse 31, the two diverge.
"That is why we laid it down for the Israelites that whoever killed a human being, except as punishment for murder or other villainy in the land, shall be deemed as though he had killed all mankind; and that whoever saved a human life shall be deemed as though he had saved all mankind.".
Initially, there appears to be no connection between verses 31 and 32. Why the life or death of one should be as the salvation or destruction of all mankind in not made clear in the Quran. When we turn to another Jewish record - the Mishnah Sanhedrin, we find the link between the story and what follows:
"We find it said in the case of Cain who murdered his brother, 'The voice of thy brother's bloods crieth' (Gen. 4:10). It is not said here blood in the singular, but bloods in the plural, that is, his own blood and the blood of his seed. Man was created single in order to show that to him who kills a single individual it shall be reckoned that he has slain the whole race, but to him who preserves the life of a single individual it is counted that he hath preserved the whole race." Mishnah Sanhedrin, 4:5
Here in the Quran is a passage from the Mishnah! The Mishnah is a Jewish commentary on the Torah. How did a Rabbi's commentary on the Torah make its way into the Quran? Simple, Muhammad had heard these teachings from the Jews, and repeated them later as he recited "revelation".
Because the word for blood is in the plural in Gen. 4:10, an ingenious Rabbi invented the supposition that all Abel's offspring had been killed with him which signified that any murder or life-saving act had universal implications. Clearly Muhammad had no knowledge of the source of the theory set out in the Mishnah but, in hearing it related, simply set out the Rabbi's suppositions as the eternal decree of God! Now today, some Jewish Rabbi's thoughts are quoted as revelation in the Quran!
This short piece clearly shows, in one way at least, how Muhammad received "revelations". In this case, verbal stories told by the Jews, and Muhammad's memory served him. Here the Quran fails the test of authenticity; it owes much of its substance to other faiths. For some reason Muhammad decided to quote a Jewish story, feeling it has some important meaning, and placed into the Quran. Little did Muhammad know or really understand from what he was really quoting.
NOTE: Dating of the Mishnah Sanhedrin is as follows, from the Encyclopedia Judaica, 1996, Keter Publishing House Jerusalem
"Commitment to writing began about the middle of the 3rd century CE with RAV (Abba Aricha) and Samuel and was completed with the conclusion of the teaching of Ravina in 499 AD."
Likewise the "Introduction to the Babylonian Talmud", Soncino Press edition by Dr. J.H. Hertz states that the Babylonian Talmud
" Claims origins from the Babylonian captivity proclaiming the religious and civil law fixed in 444 BEC by Ezra the Sofer (The Biblical Ezra the Scribe) and finalized in 500 AD."
Both these references state that the writing related to 5:32 predate Muhammad.
TH-cam don’t let me post links ( keeping delete) , so you can copy the name of article and search it
Mohammed claimed that he was a prophet sent by the God of the Bible, but is it true?
🕋Islamic Jesus Explained
( search it on Mohammad Faridi’s TH-cam channel)
It’s not surprising that Mohammed made a mistake about the Trinity. He also made many other mistakes. Muhammad could not even copy the Bible correctly。
He also copied Jewish mythology and pseudepigrapha stories into Quran and mixed with pre-Islam Arab Fairytale , There is no doubt that he is the false prophet predicted by the Bible❗️
👉The Collection and Sources of the Qu'ran
B. JEWISH INFLUENCES IN THE QUR'AN.
👉 Material for the Evaluation of the Sources of the Qur'an
👉The Quran, King Solomon, and late Jewish mythology
👉 MUHAMMAD THE BORROWER
👉 False Prophet Muhammad, Fairytale Muhammad, and Harley Talman
@Black Stone Worshippers Prophet Mohammed peace be upon him does not speak in the Quran.
@Abdallah Saleh Here is a desire suit human’s lustful nature: Marry to a 👧 with 🧸when I turn to my 50+ just like 🕋moral model Mo👳🏻♂️
Mo👳🏻♂️is best mankind in the eyes of al-ilah, should we follow the sunnah of him?
Hi Drs. Jay and Al Fadi. Great work in uncovering the counterfeit Narrative.
The Bible has another account of a Judge breaking the idols they were worshipping ,after he was called to deliver Israel.
When the villagers found their idols broken they confronted the future Judge.
It is Giddeon.
Great analysis and conclusion
Thank you again for your efforts! God bless you brothers!
Wonderful message God is great all the times.
Depending on which God you're talking about. YHWH God is the only great One... Allah? That's a fake god...
You are great sir👍👍👍🙏🙏
Shalom bro alfadi and Dr Jay peace and mercy dwell upon you
How is Atum heath by now may christ protect her always
@@arwandajunior1122 saw two videos roughly two days later patched and stitched up and jumping right back in.
I loved this episode. Al Fadi and Jay were having such fun setting up this house of cards. Wait until they start debunking. 😃
Exactly
I love debunking very simulating during a party.
can you check comparation of the Warsh and Hafs Quran in Sura 98:6 because some said that in Warsh is written Inosent and in Hafs creatures but other said that in both mean creatures?
Sneaker Corner
Yes you keep waiting while thousands are converting to Islam by reading the Quran.
@@farookdinaully8029 most who read quran realise it is a fairy tale for the weak minded.
Great content! Thank you, Al Fadi! I appreciate the work you do to show the inconsistencies in islam. May the True God of all creation draw people out of the lies they are captive to. They can be set free in Jesus!
Rev Jay
It is funny how the arguments bring against Islam backfires 10 times harder against Christianity.
@@farookdinaully8029 Except that is merely a claim which is not backed up by any truth.
@@RevJay_Rides
Fastest growing religion in the western world is Islam despite all the lies about about Islam being violent.Thousands are converting to Islam as we speak more and more people have picked up the Quran and found the truth.Churches of Paul invented Christianity are empty.
@@farookdinaully8029 Yes, and all of them will go to hell unless they repent and leave that false religion and turn to the One, True Savior and Lord of all, the King of kings, the Lord of Lords, the Way the Truth and the Life, Jesus Christ.
Glory to God, Amen.
The claim that Adam, Noah, Abraham, Lot and everyone else is Muslim when Islam wasn't even born yet.
Satan is a deceiver and a father of lies. And Quran says Allah is the best deceiver!
some christians leads to seriously objectionable conclusion:
discrimination between people just because of race,Creed or color.?
@@aldredtawasil9339 typical deflection. Try a logical argument next time.
I have a question. How come Mecca existed as a town when Adam and Eve were the only humans around? I always noticed that a town is full of humans and btw who built it?
Bible proves moses did pilgrimage to mecca -jewish writer
th-cam.com/video/IW0FrgSd80k/w-d-xo.html
@@musalmahmajid8595 Which Mecca? Edessa Mecca? Petra Mecca? Jerusalem Becca? More likely the Edessa Mecca which was Aba's Hara town.
@@musalmahmajid8595 lies and more lies! Believe in Lord Jesus as your Saviour and get eternal life.
IT's SCAM IN ISLAM👌MECCA?
Bro Didier please be a bit smart. There was no town at that time yet.
The place where Adam was dismissed from heavan is now known as mecca.
The place where Adam met Eve is now called Jabar Rahmah in Arafah Mecca.
I love Yeshua I believe in him The only true savior King of Kings name above all names🙏
Shared!!!! A lot!
Mecca, the happiest place on earth. With the statue of Mo riding a Burak and a child Aisha, holding a small ragged doll, on his lap, both found at the entrance to the happiest place on earth.
Aiaha was engaged before prophet
Married her
@@salman-lf3ly a prophet that did not speak of any real prophecy
حَدَّثَنَا قُتَيْبَةُ، حَدَّثَنَا عَبْدُ الْعَزِيزِ بْنُ مُحَمَّدٍ، عَنْ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ عَمْرٍو، عَنْ أَبِي سَلَمَةَ، عَنْ أَبِي هُرَيْرَةَ، قَالَ قَالَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم " الْيَتِيمَةُ تُسْتَأْمَرُ فِي نَفْسِهَا فَإِنْ صَمَتَتْ فَهُوَ إِذْنُهَا وَإِنْ أَبَتْ فَلاَ جَوَازَ عَلَيْهَا " . قَالَ وَفِي الْبَابِ عَنْ أَبِي مُوسَى وَابْنِ عُمَرَ وَعَائِشَةَ . قَالَ أَبُو عِيسَى حَدِيثُ أَبِي هُرَيْرَةَ حَدِيثٌ حَسَنٌ . وَاخْتَلَفَ أَهْلُ الْعِلْمِ فِي تَزْوِيجِ الْيَتِيمَةِ فَرَأَى بَعْضُ أَهْلِ الْعِلْمِ أَنَّ الْيَتِيمَةَ إِذَا زُوِّجَتْ فَالنِّكَاحُ مَوْقُوفٌ حَتَّى تَبْلُغَ فَإِذَا بَلَغَتْ فَلَهَا الْخِيَارُ فِي إِجَازَةِ النِّكَاحِ أَوْ فَسْخِهِ . وَهُوَ قَوْلُ بَعْضِ التَّابِعِينَ وَغَيْرِهِمْ . وَقَالَ بَعْضُهُمْ لاَ يَجُوزُ نِكَاحُ الْيَتِيمَةِ حَتَّى تَبْلُغَ . وَلاَ يَجُوزُ الْخِيَارُ فِي النِّكَاحِ . وَهُوَ قَوْلُ سُفْيَانَ الثَّوْرِيِّ وَالشَّافِعِيِّ وَغَيْرِهِمَا مِنْ أَهْلِ الْعِلْمِ . وَقَالَ أَحْمَدُ وَإِسْحَاقُ إِذَا بَلَغَتِ الْيَتِيمَةُ تِسْعَ سِنِينَ فَزُوِّجَتْ فَرَضِيَتْ فَالنِّكَاحُ جَائِزٌ وَلاَ خِيَارَ لَهَا إِذَا أَدْرَكَتْ . وَاحْتَجَّا بِحَدِيثِ عَائِشَةَ أَنَّ النَّبِيَّ صلى الله عليه وسلم بَنَى بِهَا وَهِيَ بِنْتُ تِسْعِ سِنِينَ . وَقَدْ قَالَتْ عَائِشَةُ إِذَا بَلَغَتِ الْجَارِيَةُ تِسْعَ سِنِينَ فَهِيَ امْرَأَةٌ .
Abu Hurairah narrated that: The Messenger of Allah said: "An orphan is to be consulted about herself, then if she is silent that is her permission, and if she refuses, then do not authorize it (the marriage) for her" (meaning: when she attains the age of puberty and refuses it.)
Jami` at-Tirmidhi 1109
Nothing like getting an ad halfway in to donate to some guy so he can build a mosque in Florida.
It is obvious that Quran was clearly talking about Napoléon Bonaparte. Even if his name wad not explicitly there, this means nothing.
Muslims pretend that Mekka and Mohamed are so important but Allah doesn't use their names in the Quran. See?
Thus Napoléon
When it is only the 'messenger' or 'the home' of the messenger without directly stating a person of location, Paris or Glasgow, Spitsbergen or Vladivostok can be substituted just as Sue or Bobby, Kamala or Ping dropped in. Song Long Ming Dong works just as well.
🤣
you see that ,even Napoleon Bonaparte as a Christian had a great respect on holy Quran..
@@aldredtawasil9339 Sooooo? Why should someone 200 years after that man's death while in custody after losing a war, put any attention to what he held in respect? Stop digging up corpuses to call for respect toward that EDITED BOOK. And what makes you think that tyrant was a Christian? Gandhi was more a Christian than that creature.
@@aldredtawasil9339
I also have a great respect for the Quran. Allah says that i am filthy and I am the worst of creatures. نجس وشر البرية and he will barbecue me forever in hell.
How i cannot have respect for him?
Are you crazy?
I never knew Muslims were taught that the Garden of Eden was in space. Where did they ever dream that one up from ? It was on Earth of course as God stated ;He gave Earth to His children. (Mankind). Not the evil ones or evil leaders.
اتمنى لو كان في ترجمة ☹❤
God bless you both.thanks for you hard work.
If Adam was thrown down to India, and Eve was thrown down to Mecca, how did he find her again? Was she fitted with a tracking device?
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Mecca's made up history is partially hijacked from Harran, which is a very old city and was home to Abraham. Around 640, Harran was taken from the Byzantines by the Arab armies, and much later, Caliph Marwan II made it capital of the Islamic Empire from 744-750 until it was conquered by the Abbasids in 750. Marwan II built a mosque in the center of the city and a royal palace on the site of the temple. The town also had a university built in the late 8th century to early 9th. The town was surrounded with a 4 km long and 3 km wide wall with seven gates.
I believe Masjid al-Haram could be a reference to either the temple to the moon god Sin, in Harran, or literally the Mosque Marwan II built in the same city, in 744-750, the latter puts a date of no earlier than 744 on the finalised Quran. Archaeologists found 6th century Babylonian steles turned face down and used as steps at the entrances of the mosque. These steles were part of the original Babylonian temple of Sin.
Harran exists in a region which was already occupied 6,200 years ago, hence I wouldn't be surprised that stories about Adam and Eve living there existed during the Arab occupation from the 6th century. During the first half of the 6th century, Babylonian King Nebuchadnezzar ruled Harran. The town was home to the Sabian worshippers of the moon god Sin. Facing always to the north, they prayed at dawn, midday and sunset, just like described in the Quran (5 daily prayers is not in the Quran, it's in the hadiths). The principal deity was worshipped in the form of a pillar or holy stone, and under him were the sun god (Shamash), the moon god (Sin), Saturn (Kronos), Jupiter (Bel), Mars (Ares), Venus (Balti), and Mercury (Nabuq). The cult was still practised into the 12th century.
The original moon temple at Harran was one of the holiest sanctuaries of the Middle East, and the Harran astronomers were held in high regard by the brilliant court of the Abbasids in Baghdad in the 9th century. Their religious emblem of a crescent and an eight-pointed star was subsequently adopted by a variety of esoteric sects and the spread of the crescent and star symbol, still so prevalent in the Islamic world, seems to date from that time.
According to the Old Testament, Harran was also the place where Terah and his son Abraham, his grandson Lot and Abraham’s wife Sarah went after leaving Ur. It was 18 centuries before Christ that Abraham was called from Ur of the Chaldees to go to Canaan according to the Old Testament. He stopped at Harran for several years until God told him to move on:
"So Abram departed, as the Lord had spoken unto him: and Abram was seventy and five years old when he departed out of Harran. And Abram took Sarai his wife and Lot his brother’s son and all their substance that they had gathered, and the souls that they had gotten in Harran; and they went forth to go into the land of Canaan (Genesis 12:4-5)."
Although Abraham went on to Canaan after his father Terah died, some relatives apparently remained. Much later Abraham sent a servant back to Harran to find a wife from among his relatives for his son Isaac. The traditional site of Jacob's Well (Bir Yakub), where Rebecca drew water for Abraham's servant is about one km northwest of the Harran city walls. According to tradition, Harran was where Jacob laboured for twenty years for his father-in-law Laban. Travellers can follow the so-called "Abraham's Path" that begins in Turkey, runs for 170 km through flattish semi-arid landscapes and incorporates the major sights of Urfa, Göbekli Tepe, the Well of Job, Harran, the Well of Jacob and Sogmatar.
The earliest records of Harran come from the Ebla tablets, c. 2300 BCE. They were discovered in the palace archives of the ancient city of Ebla, Syria. They all date to the period between ca. 2500 BC and the destruction of the city ca. 2250 BC.
#Mecca was a dry place,but Taif ( not very far from Mecca) and Medina were full of plants and trees.
Mecca was famous for the Kaabah where many Arab tribes have their own deities there. It was not a very big trading centre,but mainly cater for the locals and people(nomads) around the central Arabia,which was mostly desert. Because of this arid desert that,no one invaded it,or spread Christianity there,and most people remained as pagans.
#But in the south,Yemen was a thriving Christian centre,and at the north Medina was inhabited by the Arab Jews and Arab pagans. What was important is,the trading route between Syria and Mecca. Yemen had sea routes for trade.The desert Arabia(including Mecca) were not much populated due to the tribal killings,difficulty in child bearing due to heat, high mortality, and the hot weather.
#The presence of the Zam Zam well was the proof of Abraham,Hagar and infant Ishmael were there. The well is active till today. Later,both Abraham and Ishmael repaired the damaged or neglected Kaabah,as stated in the Qur'an. Even the Bible states that Ishmael would be given many kingdoms,and hence ,his descendants must be the Arabs.
Much later,it was Prophet's grandfather Abdul Mutalib who re-discovered the ruined Zam Zam well,and his descendants were the water providers to the pilgrims prior to Islam. No one documented Mecca because,no one invaded that area-- Hejaz and Central Arabia. Also,as Meccans were pagans,the Christians could possibly ignored it.
That's why,the Qur'an says,"Your people had not been warned (before)... and this Qur'an is revealed in their language",..considering Syria,Palestine/Israel,Yemen,Ethiopia were either Christian or Jews.
#Adam and Eve might have lived there and even their children. Centuries later,as their descendants mutiplied(i.e. we humans),they started seeking greener pastures,far from the desert. Most of the prophets originated in areas between Egypt till Mesapotamia until Turkey at the North. Only Prophet Muhammad was from the Arabian clan.
# Regarding that Mecca was mentioned only a few times in the Qur'an,the word 'masjidil haram"(sacred place) was mentioned at other places. Also,in the Qur'an Jesus, Mary,Adam,Moses,Abraham,etc were mentioned more times than our Prophet, because through His messages,God was talking directly to Prophet Muhammad. That's why you can find words,like,"Say(Qul in Arabic)....(to them)......",many times.
# The main issue between Christianity and Islam is the Divinity of Jesus. Islam accepts Jesus' life in most part. The irony is,Judaism is rejecting Jesus totally. Thanks.(mohd iqbal).
There was trend in india older days, they name same town name if they move to another place, probably these mecca came from becca
Muslims need to study the history of Islam and of the Quran. Great content in this presentation. Thanks CIRA International
I think that they would be dismayed. It would prove that Islam is built on lies.
Very interesting. Thanks. Once again I wish to bring to your research team that there a Dutch Colonial Muslim tradition in Sri Lanka that Adam landed in the island. Also they have Adam's Bridge (previously Rama Sethu causeway; Ramayana story) which connects Sri Lanka to South India. Ref Ronit Ricci's work in Israel publicised in youtube. In an earlier show Jay Smith mentioned that Eve landed in Kerala. What this means may be that Adam went from Sri Lanka to join up with Eve in Kerala to very long walk to Mecca or take a boat to cross to Yemen and join a camel caravan to Mecca. Is this in any Hadith literature?
If Adam was the first man, then who invented the first camel caravan?
@@justaminute3111 Interesting question! Adam would used the animals in Ceylon eg Bullocks. thus later they had bullock carts. Having crossed into South India by the Rama-Sethu causeway ('Adam's Bridge'), he could have continued his journey to find Eve. Final destination Mecca. shorter route would be by sea in a catamaran or Adam's first boat and sail to Yemen. Use camels there to reach Mecca. Thus a first caravan. Possible? God/Allah is on his side.
Please arrange subtitles or dubbing in various languages so that most people can understand. SUBTITLES are important because he speaks very fast.
Thank you for the various thought-provoking suggestions and hints! BUT one must proceed already carefully and it is difficult to think in metamorphosis, in the process... a few millennia ago go there were advanced civilizations in places which are desert today (there are excavations in Iran or Mongolia).
Where no tree grows today, there was possibly a garden 6-8000 years ago. There are a lot of meghalitic stone settlements in Arabia, the history points very far back. And if you study carefully the indications of the paradise rivers in the Bible, the paradise in Arabia "touched the earth."
No historical accounts of MN ecca until 8 century period,!
Koran and the auditions describe something like Petra and called it Mecca
I see where you’re going and its impossible Abraham , and Adam was in mecca. But if You want to make a point with the climate of Mecca, climatologist say that Mecca was a green place few centuries ago.
When exactly? I don’t know but it was maybe a greener Mediterranean type climate by the time of muhammed.
It’s maybe a false direction, although, it’s important to point out that it’s impossible that Mecca was the center of the world as the Quran claims
You might refer to the last glacial age. I know that the Sahara was green at the time but it was 10 000 years ago at least. It might be correct for Saudi Arabia. It is older than Mecca.
100 centuries ago to be precise, when Mecca was Green.
@@PedofiIe_Muhammad @Didier Favre No archeological verification or geological core samples of ancient pollen or diatoms contain therein.
@@PedofiIe_Muhammad You are joking.
@@sidprice6214 Ask a geologist about Saudi oil formation! It could be older than 200 000 000 years. The youngest possible oil is around 1 00 000 years I think.
Al Fadi maybe brought a clever business man in Mekka to an idea : Olives from Mekka.
Another excellent power point, and another nail in the coffin for SIN
@@abdallahsaleh86 😂
Provide 7th Century historical evidence for the Mohammed of Islam
Provide 7th Century Qurans
Provided 7th Century archeological evidence for a cosmopolitan Mecca in Arabia in the 7th Century
Provide 7th Century historical evidence for the Rightly Guided Caliphs
As of yet no Muslim or even Muslim Scholars and Historians have found any evidence for the above
Islam is based on stories and twisted plagiarism
@@abdallahsaleh86
So you can’t provide 7th Century evidence, it just goes to show how false Islam is
Have a read
No Mohammed = No Islam, No Islam = No Allah of Islam
MUSLIM ISLAMIC SCHOLARS
Muslim Islamic scholar Sulimn Bashear at the An-Najah University taught that the Quran and Islam were the products of historical development, rather than coming from Mohammed
Muslim Professor Muhammad Sven Kalisch is an Islamic researcher and scholar at the University of Münster. He is also the first person in Germany to hold a Chair of Islamic Religion, believes THE MOHAMMED OF THE QURAN PROBABLY NEVER EXISTED
en.qantara.de/content/criticism-of-islamic-theologian-muhammad-kalisch-doubt-about-muhammads-existence-poses
@@abdallahsaleh86
That’s the corrupted Muslim view, started by the Abbasids
You still haven’t provided any 7th Century historical evidence for the following;
A Mohammed of Islam
A Quran/Qurans
A Mecca in Arabia
The rightly guided caliphs
@@abdallahsaleh86
th-cam.com/video/Jlb81KCvYFA/w-d-xo.html
@@abdallahsaleh86
You poor fellow
Dates that cause concern; dates referring to an individual are the dates of their death
647; 15 years after the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Qurans death, in a letter written in 647 by the patriarch of Seleucia he makes no reference to the Arab conquerors as Muslims, or show any awareness of a religion called Islam
680; 48 years after the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Qurans death, in none of Muawiya’s (who defeated Ali in 661) documents, inscriptions, or coins is there any mention or reference to the Mohammed of the Quran and Islam. Indeed, they show Persian Zoroastrian and Christian influences.
691; 59 years after the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Qurans death, is when the term Muslim started to be used (from the Dome of the Rock), up until then they called themselves Saracen, Hagarian, Ishmaelite, Maghraye and Muhajiroun.
691; 59 years after the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Qurans death, is the first time that the word Islam is recorded, which is in the Dome on the Rock, which Abd al Malik had built.
692; 60 years after the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Qurans death, is the first time there is reference to Mohammed, and that is on a coin, which also has the image of Abdul al Malik holding a sword. However, this is most likely Abdul al malik calling himself the ‘Chosen One’
696; 64 years after the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Qurans death (outside of the Dome of the Rock), is the first time there is Islamic style writing which is on a Coin with no images and a form of the Shahada, done by Abdul al Malik
741; 109 years after the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Qurans death, is the first historical reference to Mecca, 109 years after Mohammed’s death, and that it is in Iraq, not Arabia
765; 133 years after the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Qurans death, tradition has it that Ibn Ishaq writes first biography of Mohammed? But none of his material exists
833: 201 years after the Mohammed of the Qurans death, is the first biography of THE FICTIONAL Mohammed (Sira) which is by Ibn Hisham, and he only writes down the material he likes which (according to tradition) was handed down to him via his teacher from Ibn Hisham, and eliminates the material he doesn’t like. Ibn Hisham is the first person to write down Mohammed’s genealogy, 201 years after Mohammed’s death. This breaks a fundamental principal of a biography, which should be based on eyewitness accounts.
870; 238 years after the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Qurans death, the first Hadith (sayings, rulings and behaviours of Mohammed) are attributed to Al-Bukhari who realizing that oral translation wasn’t satisfactory, wrote down the narrations some 238 years after THE FICTIONAL Mohammed’s death. Tradition has it that Al-Bukhari is given 600,000 narrations, and he whittles them down to 7,397 (nine volumes) narrations that he considered to be reliable. But when you take into account repetitions and variances of the same report, the number is only 2,602.
However, the first Hadith (one volume) is only found in the 11th Century, and it is not until the 17th Century that you get all nine volumes together, and there is no original manuscript by
Al-Bukhari. Hadith derives from the Arabic root ḥ-d-th meaning “to happen” and so “to tell a happening,” There is a small sect of Muslims that completely reject the Hadiths.
900; 268 years after the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Qurans death, is the first time that Mecca is on an Arabian map.
923; 291 years after the death of the FICTIONAL Mohammed of the Quran is when the Tafsir, which is commentaries on the Quran, and the Tarikh which is concerned with Muslim history is written. The author At-Tabari was born in Amol (1122 miles from Medina) and died in Baghdad, 838 miles from Medina, he couldn’t possibly have known Mohammed
Standard Abbasid Deception.
@Chris Azure the Abbies were Persians not Arabs being dependent of others to write the Arabic with no one able to do an editorial check prior to distribution dissemination.
@@gilbertjones9157 I was playing off the SIN (Sandard Islamic Narrative) and what Jay said SAD (Standard Abbasid D...). Without going back and listening again, I can't remember what his D was. I offered Deception as an alternative.
No Muslim believes that Abraham lived in Makkah except that he would bring his wife Hagar and his son Ismail there and he would visit them later and build the Kaabah and there he was comanded to sacrifice his son. Thats it.
And that man misquoted the Quran. He said 'rihlatu' but is should be 'rihlata' and every child should know that.
If he was a muslim and he wants to be truthful he should not accept and speak out such lies. I've no need of watching more from this. May Allah guide you. Ameen
How did the Dome of the Rock in Jerusalem next to the 2nd Temple ever become the third holiest site to the Muslims (even though there is absolutely no mention of Jerusalem in the Quran”? How is this possible?
Muslims say i want I want mine mine
There is no But But But! As in...... yes Koran says XYZ about violence;.........BUT.............. ! (always thought that the expression 'There is no God but God' as containing some kind of comedy gold).
@john lowery - I think there was a missing 'a' before but edited out during the recension.
Great Mr!
I agree with Jay Smith and Al fadi.
It is good too. If. As talkings. Writing English. Too. That. My deaf friends reading too. 🙏❤️
I pray islam should come to light.
It seems a bit odd that Al Fadi is interviewing Jay on traditions in Saudi Arabia, when Al Fadi is from Saudi Arabi and Jay is not. Al Fadi should also do his own presentations on this channel, in addition to interviewing others. It would be interesting to hear what he thinks about what he learns in these interviews, as a former Muslim from a Muslim-majority country.
Ur was mistranslated as fire and that is what gave the story of Abraham escaping fire.
Such a great city, and the writers and editors of the quran forgot to mention it more than once.
And all the prophets in the OT forgot to mention the pilgrimage to it...
Prophet Noah and the big flood was mentioned in both quran and bible. It supposed to be the biggest disaster even happened where only people in the boat were survived. Any written history documented anywhere of this big tragedy.
I want to hear the reply of Mr. uthman farooq in regards to this false tradition.
I see elsewhere in this series they refer to an actual mecca as being in Syria. That place might well be oldest of cities it's neighhbor , Damascus is certainly very ancient and considered one of the oldest continuously settled cities in the world. Just saying. The claim would make some logical sense in that area...
Mecca was a sacret city therefore it was a secret.
I enjoy every episode.
Its The best cinema.
Will zakir naik debate Dr Al FADI. or zakir naik wet his pants just by this thought!
I’d be cautious when referencing things that have to deal with weather as we know that it changes over time, think Little Ice Age. It’s possible that an area that is now arid was once green, look at the petrified forest in the SW United States.
I thought Al Fadi is in strong tower user.
💐💐✝️✝️🙏❤️
Linguistically the syllable B and M can be interchangeable ? Bacca becomes Macca ? the most modern example of this interchangeability of the syllable B and M lies in India. You know the city of Mumbai ( that is the original name pronounced in the vernacular language of the local fishermen ) was known earlier as Bombay during the British rule & until 50 yrs after the British left. The word Mumbai was pronounced as Bombay by the European settlers from 17th century Dutch, Portuguese, French and British later Indians too. Mainly the north Indian Hindi speaking people used to pronounce Mumbai as Bumbai. Recently in the last 25-30 years. Bombay & Bumbai was restored to Mumbai. So finally the first beginner syllable B becomes M.
Ibrahim didn't destroyed idols in Makkah but His native city Urr which is located in present-day Iraq, Far from Makkah. Why U people are assuming that city was Makkah if Quran and Hadith didn't mention it?
Bakkah means narrow and crowded valley, didn't you people realize that Makkah is surrounded by huge mountains and there is still very narrow plane land to live in.
Madina called Yathrib at the time of the Prophet and then called Madina un Nabi and now just called Madina. memorized 1 city with 2-3 names is normal .
Adam came down to India which means he was a hindu. That time no other religions exist except Hinduism
See the book by Abraham Katsh called Judaism and the Koran. He shows how many verses in the Quran were drawn from Midrash Rabba (not Mishna) and Pirkei de Rabbi Eliezer. There are also many stories and hadiths drawn from Tractate Sanhedrin in the Babylonian Talmud.
Jay needs to slow down just a little
The first thought / question that popped in my mind was: " why is he still wearing Muslim outfit"? Aren't we as God's Children an open book? Not the what you wear defines who you are in the inside but it does says a lot about you. What is the first impression when you see someone dressed like this? I don't no harm its just something like I said before popped in my mind
Wow, Christians paid TH-camrs are paying so much focal attention to other people’s beliefs and religions that they forget about their own…
You are right brother they are paid agent to paint Islam bad and they make millions of dollars from it islamphobic stories . I have one of them confessed in a video.
Tell us about the talking snake
oppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppps where did we find that map ,,
@Bebopper Bott check the video twice where map?
I don't understand U guys , what was your points, his not Petra his Mecca. And it will remain in Mecca , lies can't change it , Mecca , Mecca is Mecca , and Petra is Petra
God bless this man for being the true muslim for telling the truth about the history of islam. Im biafra jewish! God bless my christian friends ✡️🤝✝️. Yeshua is king!!!
Ibrahim was in Yemen … masr was in Yemen … all events were in Yemen
and there is also No Presence of God in mecca
Original sin at least as its defined by the west, is not found in eastern Christianity and never has been. And the Bible most certainly does not teach that we inherit the guilt of Adam. What it teaches is that we inherit the consequences of Adam's sin, namely, death.
❤️
Garden of eden was in todays modern day iraq by tigris river. Adam was never in what you allegedly called heaven cause he was allegedly made out of earths clay, mud or dust.
Islam mostly is an Arbi mirror of Christianism and Judaism. Abbasids have tried their best to concoct so that this theology i.e. Islam fits to their local need.
If Adam was to be from Kerala then Arabs would have been coal Black skin not other way 😂😂😂
Looks like Islam is questionable ?
Michel Grenier Islam is questionable.
You can be so smart and yet so deluded as well. I'm glad to be atheist.
Hope you are happy as an atheist.
Gbu.
oh, Mecca.... "wherefore" art thou?????????????? ha...
its funny, why don't u guys debate with shiekh usman?🙄😂
HAEB DS
Because they are terrified.These lirs should not be making videos when there is not a Muslim scholar there to reply to them.They are like boxers who keep punching a punch bag and claiming victory.
They are both liers and deceivers and they will never invite a an Muslims scholar to debate with them but only that guy called Al Fadi he dresses to confuse people into believing he is a muslim. They make millions of dollars from such islamphobic videos. I have a video of one of them who confessed. Can send the video in your messenger if you don’t mind. From their we enlighten the people too.
Adam landed on a mountain in Sri Lanka which the British dutifully named Adam's Peak. Adam's footprint is found there. Local Buddhists dispute that, claiming that it is Buddha's footprint. Hindus dispute both claims, insisting that it was where their god Rama stood. Adam climbed down from his peak, and when he reached northern Sri Lanka, he found an artificial bridge built for him, which the Brits named, unsurprisingly, Adam's Bridge. Hindus claim it was the Bridge their god Rama used to cross into the Resplendent Isle, Sri Lanka. Buddhists claim that Buddha crossed that bridge on his way to Sri Lanka and back to Nepal. In any case, Adam climbed down his peak, crossed his bridge into India and headed on to Mecca where he found Eve, enjoying an apple, no doubt, at the famous apple orchards of Arafat.
Interesting, it looks like Adam's story was fabricated from this buddist tradition.
@@jsb1905 Or Hindu tradition.
Actually the story of Adam in Sri Lanka was likely to have been made up by early Muslim settlers from India and converts to Islam in both Sri Lanka and southern India. Sri Lanka has a long standing community of Tamil-speaking Muslims who came from India- they say they came from Arabia. Tamil is an Indian language spoken in Tamil Nadu in India and by the minority Tamils of Sri Lanka and elsewhere. The majority of Sri Lankans speak an unrelated language called Sinhala.
@mysotiras12 I also told my son about the tooth fairy. No one pretended that it was "BS on steroids".
@mysotiras12 a "billion Muslims"? Do you actually believe in that engineered myth? Mahometans don't let conversion out of their cult. They even snatch dead bodies (eg: Lance Corporal Manaim Moorthy, a Hindu and Gar Enggor, a Buddhist of Malaysia) to bolster the ranks of Cult of Peace. They deem toddlers to have embraced their cult (eg: Shadia Nagui Ibrahim, a Coptic Christian of Egypt) when their dads run away and marry Mahometan women. Thousands of Mahometans leave their cult annually (eg: Al Fadi of Saudi Arabia) but the Cult of Peace continues to count them as Mahometans. Then they cook up statistics to cite that magic figure of 1 billion which you have then peddled to me in order to make your point. You are the one who seems to be believing in their fairytales.
adam to kerala in India,,,,
It’s amazing how people can get away with lies. He is putting evidence that Quran claims that Macca has olives. The truth is that the quotes from Quran he is referencing are talking about olives. But not a single verse of them claimed that those olives were in the city of Mecca. Those verses of Quran were talking generally about olives, both the tree and the fruit. So Dr. J lied about it and used it as a Claim to refute. Just go and check for yourselves
🤣🤣🤣🤣
9:10
Love the Muslim dance you do so well. But I suggest to have a spinning top for the little Dervishi.
SAD !!!
What wolfs in sheep clothing want to say.?
The fastest religions in the world Islam ,islam
Trade centres historically have a gate function built in.. a reason why trade must go through a place b from a to c. Mecca has no such thing.. sail past it or go overland through cities riverlands and trade centres ( eg bagdad ) or drop in on mecca .. for no particular reason ..? Hmmm Oman was in antiquity just on the coast but this facilitated trade to India. In other words it broke up the remaining legs to Egypt or bagdad underlining further that mecca would be useless but also in competition with Egyptian out posts. Unlikely in the extreme given how forcefully Egypt defended it's river out posts against Kush or Nubia On an ajacent important trade route. Oman as entrepot port would easily serve all purposes for Egypt and bagdad ...of course Oman and also Yemen do have sites of great antiquity. These places are known trading centres going back 1000 s of years. Such things leave evidence. A LOT of evidence. Likewise we know Damascus is ancient by evidence of multiple layers of cities built there. Not by fantasies written elsewhere...
With all due reapect though the Original Sin was a later doctrine by a church father. It used to be read as that they sinned yes but then when u read about Cain and Abel and Abel slaying Cain. God tells Abel that sin can crouch at your door but you can overcome it. As well with all due respect the gospels and the archeological research is so varied because the gospels the christians read can't agree where Jesus was born. One story says nothing about Joseph and thats thought to be the earliest gospel that was written down. I enjoy your videos but I seem to see this sort of mine is right yours is wrong with the guest. I mean all respect and enjoy your videos.
Hay, I would like to know if Mecca is not the real holy place of Muslims then how came the zam zam well there?
How would one know it is "the" zamzam well? It could be archaelogically investigated, and if you know of any such work, that might be useful in supporting some settlement point at Mecca at some early stage, if it could be found it was built way before the 8C. They don't allow non-muslims into Mecca and Medina though, so efforts may be rather inhibited.
Safa and Marwah are not impressive in Mecca. In Jerusalem Marwah is the Arab name for Mount Moria, and Josephus in his 'Antiquities of the Jews' gave Safa as a name for Mount Scopus, and there is textual evidence that wooden temples got built on the Temple Mount in the 7C, followed by Abd-el-malik's stone masjid. So the masjid al haram looks like it was the temple site in Jerusalem, where 7C Arab warlords built this temple, being destroyed by quakes some times, before the stone one. They weren't fully islamic though as their coins have pictures of kings and some symbols of christian and zoroastrian type. and some seem to have become christians. No evidence I've seen in the 7C documents that they poured forth out of the desert of the Hijaz.
@@collybever No, no it's the flashing Neon signs directing one there.
Al Fadi, when you were a Muslim, did you see something special in the Quran, or were you just mesmerized into believing that?
He was born into an Islamic family right in the heart of Saudi Arabia.
@@I9s7lam5is-S3tu1pid Thanks, but I know that. That was not my question.
I am trying to understand why people thought Muhammad's Quran was special. Is there something about the Arabic that I am not able to see because I can't read Arabic? A lyrical quality of meter or rhyme does not mean it is divine, but I want to see what early Muslims found so inspiring? Or was it just enforced by fiat to believe it was special?
@@hazratmuhazmat8831
Quran includes lots of scientific statements that their correctness and validity has been proven only with the current scientific discoveries and developments .These scientific statements in the Quran are considered as miracles of the Quran and as proof of its authenticity from God not invented by humans.
@@farookdinaully8029 I have heard them all and debunked them all. You have to have a weak mind to believe some of the things people claim are scientific discoveries.
But I can prove the Quran is just a myth.
1) Show me Dhul Qarnayn's wall, 2) Show me the pebbles that killed the people of the Elephant or 3) Show me the idols that Abraham removed for the Kaaba. Show me 2 of those 3 things and I will say Shahada. Otherwise, you book is just filled with myths.
@@hazratmuhazmat8831
You wrote "I can prove prove the Quran is a myth" common then prove it.