Can You Hear The Difference Between a Pianist Who Plays With Emotion and Without it?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ก.ย. 2017
- Can you hear the difference between a pianist who plays piano with emotion and without it? I In this video, I played 2 songs in 2 different versions. In the first version I played with emotion. In the second version I played the song without emotion. Can you hear any difference?
Follow my Instagram! / vinheteiro - บันเทิง
While playing with emotion, he was looking for his soul.
While playing without emotion, he was looking for mine.
Fuck that genuinely got me 😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂
dat calculation tho I'm like #300
Good one 😂
Lol there have been 107 likes since I last saw this comment
“To play a wrong note is insignificant; to play without passion is inexcusable.”
- Beethoven
Northwest said from a genius
johnjohnjohnnycake that is my favorite quote from Beethoven
Northwest I'm agree with Beethoven :)
Yep
He was deafinitely right on this one.
I'll see myself out...
I didn't come here for emotional music, just the cold dead stare of a musician.
😁
You don’t need the text at the top to tell if it’s with emotion or without - his expression makes it so obvious
But the question is "can you hear the emotion?" :P the face does not matter.
Christopher Scott lol hahaha
You know what's crazy man? I closed my eyes and almost started crying, and then I had to stop all of a sudden. When I opened my eyes he had lost his emotion. Dear god that's what this world has come to
@@alxdrksoul agree sometimes people play pieces without emotions and lots of faces and sometimes good pianists play properly the piece (with intensity durability of the notes and all tose factors that add emotion to the music and play it quietly without face expressuons
Stop looking at me like this when i am eating, i feel guilty for not sharing.
Hated 7dtd lol
When I read your comment then looked up to the video, I laughed so hard!
Lmfao😂😂
Omg u made my day :D I can`t stop laughing
Bwahahahaha!
That stare....It feels like he is looking into my soul.
He is
The piano death stare...
Lol
I ant tell the difference XD
as the song reach the end, so am i
Duuude i always watch your old videos and this is the first time that i hear you speak,i am shocked
He isn't angry. He is revolted that almost nobody likes classical music in Brazil.
He always speaked at the end
Last video, he screamed like he lost a limb
And it startled me ! ! 😂
LOL
The main difference I hear soundwise is timing... when playing "with emotion" how long you play a note or how fast you move on to the next one will vary by just a few milliseconds depending on which part of the song you are playing. I guess that's just because you are trying to give it a more natural artistic touch. The "without emotion" is the same notes but with a very rigid and mechanic timing, plus not hitting notes harder or softer either, it's all very plain. These are my thoughts after listening back to both versions with my eyes closed anyways. 😊
not playing rigidly is called rubato btw :)
I'm the type of pianist who plays on an electric keyboard with headphones on, with emotion. When people see me play the piano like that, they always look at me like I'm having a seizure.
Haha
Same
Lol
PlasmaEarth me 2
PlasmaEarth LOL
Might be better if you maybe didnt show yourself playing or which is which, since obviously people will want the emotion one to sound better which can make them think it sounds better
Alex Haldane Exactly! the experiment is definitely not scientifically clear :D
in fact, as for the first piece, I like the "without emotion" version better.
Not if you close your eyes, and listen. There is difference.
Farty Frog when i close my eyes or open it doesnt matter because i know which one is supposed to be emotional
The idea is that you don't watch the video, just hear it. That's what I did, and believe me, you feel the difference and inmediately recognize which is which, knowing which one is with passion or without it doesn't change what you hear.
PD: I'm sorry if my English is not the best, I'm Spanish :)
Marcela Arias yeah im sure thats true. However, knowing the order of things i will never be 100% sure whether i am getting the full effect. I am glad to see someone who did
HOLY SHIT! I never knew he was Brazilian, caught me so off guard that it literally took me a good few seconds to realize he wasn't speaking English. Lol
you're right, the name Vinheteiro doesn't sound Brazilian at all, it's like Mandarin
@@qdequeijo né?! 😂Lerdeza minha; nunca tinha parado p/ perceber e processar o nome do canal, só assistia os videos mesmo... Aí demorou pra cair a ficha XD (estão vendo, crianças? é por isso que temos que continuar na escola haha)
Oh my this is also the first time I see him talk!
Same
Actually it's his first talking more than 'Suuubscribe to this chaaaannell'.
The first time I “SEE” him talk?!? Think again
Scared the heck out of me!
Toria May I know right
When he stares at the camera he looks like detective Hopps from Stranger Things
Phiter Fernandes Seu nome se pronuncia Piter ou Fiter?
Desculpa, fui obrigado a fazer isso kkkkkk
So true
Phiter Fernandes Ooh yeah, thought so...
THIS IS LITERALLY WHAT I THOUGHT AND WAS ABOUT TO SAY
Find a guy that looks at you the way this guy looks at the camera👀
Psycopath.
I would break up with him out of fear
A child
Magma Fox NOo
LOL If I a guy look at me like this I would run and never stop !
is it just me or does everyone feel the emotion is his ‘no emotion’ version
But not nearly as much tho
I don't think you're the only one. To me there is a difference between "with emotion" and "without emotion", but it has a different meaning to different people. When playing the Chopin Impromptu Op.66, some people might want it to sound dry one time and emotional another time since this piece is kind of repetitive. In other words you can't be sure whether a piece has "emotion" or not.
With emotion has changes in tone and softness that are not written in the sheet music specifically. Without emotion, the pianist is just hitting the keys at the right time with no additional input to the instrument. I find it a mark of a master to play with emotion and sound like that is the only way that piece should be played. But I think it is helpful for writing music to step through the music line by line so you can check when something feels missing or doesn't fit.
His non emotion look is super creepy
you know what's really funny, that you didn't catch onto the fact that both times all his dynamics are exactly the same, he played it the same, that's the joke.
There isn't a difference because he played everything identical.
If you weren't pompous and so absorbed in your own "ooooh it's so deep, look at how much I can catch in music with my awesomeness" you would have noticed that.
Ironically he said in one of his videos that you just have to hit the right keys and everyone will like it...
@@tuzki3248 Yeah sadly, some people think it'll make their music become less meaningless if they blow their nose on it every time they play XD
A musician with true skill can shatter your heart through song all the while laughing his ass off, a musician who only has superficial skill will need to resort to external tricks to tell the audience: "HEY THIS IS A SAD BIT!!!" XD
@@tuzki3248 Emotion exist in the subtle changes of tention from note to note or chord to chord, tention can be created tonally like 4th to 7th dissonant transition there's tention there cause finishing a phrase on a 7th doesn't sound complete, until you release the tention afterwards by finishing the progression to either a root note of the same scale or the root note of a different scale for example.
You can create tention simply through volume or how hard you attack a note as well.
Emotion isn't looking like a wet kitten while you play, emotion is subtlety.
When he plays with emotions the notes seem to melt together but without emotions the notes seem isolated
Megstergirl327 that's all in your head bitch
+John P stop being mean
"The notes seem to melt together."
Such beautiful words have never been said.
Mason Lee u hitting on her?
That’s cantabile!
I wish I was able to maintain that kind of intense eye contact! Also, sick piano skills bruv
deadlyNightshade789 bruv al the way
deadlyNightshade789 you didnt see him playing hungarian rhapsody bruh
deadlyNightshade789 what is a "bruv"?
James Comer "bro/bruh" in a British accent
Seriously i would defeat all the bullies if i did that !!
Chopin without emotion... is not chopin
Holy sheep 69 likes *E P I C*
Yeah
But sometimes I turns out too Chopin
With or without emotion. You still play beautifully.
I feel like there's more inflection within the notes when played with emotion. The force of each keystroke varies greatly, and the song really comes alive. Without emotion sounds more monotonous in both volume and overall tone.
Wesley Thoman agreed
Yup. No dynamics
Wow. *Clap clap clap*
and your soul stays in your body
Wesley Thoman You saying that because you Saw the video and didnt listen without watching the video.
I think although they sound very similar, when you play with emotion, the song comes alive in a way...
'cause you see him dance like is enjoying the song and it make you like more too.
That's because when he played without emotion he made a lot more mistakes :P
Répeateàrs Répeateàrs When you play with emotion I find that the dynamics are different.
It's called the placebo effect.
That's called emotion lol i didn't look but i can hear it and feel it they sound very similar in playing wise but in sound and emotion wise they are very different
The emotion pours out of the notes of the music being played, not from the facial expressions of the player. People who criticise music of not having feels based on how overdramatic the musician acts while playing basically don't know much about music to make valid comments and also have never played an instrument.
i agree. the hands do the talking, not overacting.
man just shut up
bluh bluh you don't know music bluh, you sound like an obnoxious elitist.
Let people play and think how they want!
@@deathbunny3048 lol aren't you not letting him "think how he wants" right now tho? 😆 you see how stupid your little theory about letting people continue to think no matter how wrong they are is?
@@wnathanielw Did I put a gun to his head and tell him "if you have another opinion I'll shoot you" or something like that?
No, I didn't, there's plenty of room for free speech.
Doesn't mean I agree with what he says, doesn't mean I agree with how he puts it.
But that's free speech, just cause I don't like it, doesn't mean he isn't entitled to his personal views.
Doesn't make him any less of an elitist.
The piano needs feeling, with out it, it's empty. You have a wonderful touch and feeling even when you tried to play without it. Outstanding.
"With emotion" have more rubato, dynamics and better articulation. "Without emotion" was played flat and straight. It doesn't matter the faces he did.
I think it is fascinating how you can make such meaningless words sound true and professional
Mohmad Ismael wich word
those are just the musical terms that describe his playing styles. Personally I preferred the less dynamical one to some extent. Many musicians play a piece to death with pretentious "profoundness" added to it that simply neither convinces me they see emotional value in the piece, or makes the piece more enjoyable. A good example of a musician whose main style is rhythmic and straight forward, yet carries an enormous amount of genuine emotion, but subtly, is glenn gould. Not to say turning dynamics to 11 never works for a piece, but I find it over used.
The faces is just a joke. You don't know this guy
RedTriangle53 the first one seems to be just an exaggerated distortion of the time, which is a feature that alone doesnt make an interpretation deeper. In this case it didnt work according to me, and i actually prefer the second one, involuntarily played in a more balanced way
Related video: "What Does a Pianist See? | Eye Tracking - Episode 1"
What *does* he see when he's staring at me?
Cleveland Rock he directly into your soul
Cleveland Rock your weaknesses and feeds off of your strengthes.
you play without emotions, thats why hes looking at you
Cleveland Rock he sees how sinful you are
Layla blox Exactly what I wanted to say lolzz
É bonito do mesmo jeito....com emoção ou sem frescura!!!
I love this video because it proves that all the mannerisms and all that are BS it’s all for show for the audience. If there’s any emotion it’s a personal thing inside you.
No lmao
Vladimir Lopez ?? No
No there’s definitely a difference.
I feel like the one with emotion has more perfect timing
Luke Skywalker no it's just got more pauses
Luke Skywalker And without a sustain pedal
eksman187 this all depends on your definition of perfect when it comes to timing. is it perfect if it's measured out to a clock, or is it perfect if it feels perfect?
If your name is Luke Skywalker why do u have an anikan Skywalker picture lol
Laragh O'Reilly I'm wondering about this too.
So is emotion a new brand of pedals or...?
lol
fuck all of u americans this is Brasil Fuck u
Imgoingtochat Otakuversion lmao
Cynicism Post Ideological 😂
SUCH A NICE DAY TO OFFEND PEOPLE MUAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHHAHAHAH
-ITS A JOKE DON'T TAKE IT SOOOOO SERIOUSLY-
This dude gazed into millions of souls all at once
Even though you did not put any emotion into the music when you playing, the music itself has carried the soul of the composer all along. Putting emotion into a song is like a communication to the soul.
A pianist with emotion love moving a lot when he's playing X)
The very word "emotion" comes from latin "e" (prefix: "outwards") + "movere" (verb: "to move"), meaning something which touches your heart and leads you to take some action, i.e. to move.
Raphael Carvalho awesome information! Thanks!! 😊
Rafale25 Narchal e-MOTION
Rafale25 Narchal Go big, or go home
It comes naturally.
i feel as though, even as they're very much the same, the emotional version seems to have inconsistent but subtle pauses inbetween notes whereas the no emotion seems to be very systematically correct in the pauses between each note, thus making it easier on the ears, although this may be me just reading into things with my eyes too much, they may be exactly the same lol
Cesspit sid i agree i cant tell if my eyes are the difference, i think they are the same
Cesspit sid You, I believe, are correct
but weird... i dun know much about piano but the sheet itself will have different demand on the speed and pause...
so if he's playing it 100% correctly, regardless of with or without emotion, it should sound the same? or else it would be different from the sheet, not plying it wrongly i would say but the player must hav add his own element...
Dylan Tan no one really plays a piano piece (song) 100% correctly, the really good pianist change the counting and cheat by a half beat at most. adding an extra half beat to the count would add an extra pause. The difference between the emotion and non emotion are that you hear more of these added beats.
Btw adding the half beat isn’t a bad thing, in fact if you do it in the right spots your music sounds 10x better.
Jnathan Nger try closing your eyes and see if you can hear the difference
V, your face when playing with no emotion is an emotion itself! Omg you spoke and I went through several vids of your channel (binge watching)XD
Always crack me up man! That's why I love your videos!
I can tell a difference. When you play with emotion, you tend to speed up, slow down, emphasize, or minimize different parts of the music. When you don't, you're simply following the sheet music, no emotion, no variance.
When you play with emotion, you can show people what the piece means to you, or your own interpretation of what it should sound like. When you don't, it's not as interesting--it might as well be played by an player piano.
i breathe air I’m a keyboard player and trombone player. Trombone is similar to piano in the fact that it’s obvious and easy to see how emotion matipuoates the tone ( subtle dynamic changes, timbre changes etc). But interestingly keyboard needs just as much emotion- it can feel stiff and electronic or natural and beautiful depending on how you play the same instrument, same dynamics (even with touch sensitivity off).
I feel it’s because of subtle articulation. A common keyboard technique is ‘taking breaths’ - leaving small gaps like you would on a wind instrument or voice to emphasise phrasing and give a natural sound.
@@abijo5052 hummm nop
This comment reminded me of an anime called forest piano, which is a really awesome anime!
Without emotion it can be even played by a computer (and more precise).
well any certain interpretation isnt just following the notes written, you follow the composer who made it up with his soul, still better than just transforming the piece into another version because you can destruct the orginal meaning. If you really want to play with emotions you have to create your own music or variations.
I subscribed, but please... never stare at me again.
Reverse psychology huh
He didn't😂
He always stares he never looks away
Didn’t Anna slapped you?
Don't worry, he's not emotionally attached to you, it's just like staring at blank space! XD
I heard you talking for the very first time and i am subscribing to you for over 3 years
With emotion had such a light and beautiful melody
It sounds a little bit smoother with emotions
Because he's looking at the keys more in that version.
xOTAKU_GAMESx agreed
The song felt very stiff for me when it was playes with no emotion. On the other hand, It was so graceful and soothing in an unexplainable way when he played it with emotions~
Anne Briones I think it’s because of two reasons- the first is that the notes are played in a smooth way, like the waves of the ocean lapping against the shore, especially in the left hands harmony bits. And the second reason is that some notes are played much softer and subtlety which creates a delicate and emotion evoking piece.
Why does kpop is everywhere i go ? 😂
+Une Army true xD
I agree
Those eyes of his pierces to the deepest parts and corners of my soul.
emotion = adding fermatas EVERYWHERE because he is his own director and he’s gonna hold those beautiful notes out as long as he wants to
ok but there is emotion also in the "without emotion" version XD
RattoTakkiOP old habits die hard lol
RattoTakkiOP not as much though
RattoTakkiOP That's rubato, nothing else.
Pluvia Fang grabs Death Note, regains memory
Exactly. I don't think he's capable of playing without emotion.
I cannot hear the difference but I can see it.
Circuit Ideas hear it while closing your eyes just let your ears hear and will notice the different
HeSsA EXO I tried that, and I still didn't hear a difference.
The tempo is considerably more consistent and dynamics are played as marked in the score in the non-emotional one.
There is no difference cuz there’s hardly any emotion to begin with
Circuit Ideas Labs If you close your eyes, the sound is the same. You’re all right
anyway, you are so talented that finally both version are full of emotion ;)
The emotion is in his hands and in my heart the whole time
How do you play without looking... this makes me realise how my skills really suck😅
Bhoova Cy it's muscle memory, impressive for sure but you could be that cool too if you play one song over and over again lol
Billy Thompson ...haha i hope ; yeaaah it is impressive!! *_*
You need to know how to play without looking if u want to play with two hands
I'm doing the same thing with my keyboard.. Xd
Bhoova Cy
It takes a lot of practice
I can do only if I remember the notes
I know the first two pages of Hedwig's theme by heart
Well, I did the test, I listened to the video *before* watching it. I had really no idea which version was which and... I preferred the "emotionless" version :-/
I'm pretty sure that *watching* him play influences our judgement.
I actually tried doing the same thing and I also preferred the without emotion one, I wonder if that's weird 😂
Yukinne Sugiura It isn't weird. Seeing the emotions triggers positive responses in the brain making it appeal better. But if there's nothing to see the brain can't be influenced.
Yukinne Sugiura The brain works in mysterious ways
I preferred the one without emotion as well
I didn’t watch it either and preferred emotional
O piano foi inventado JUSTAMENTE para poder transmitir a emoção na musica, é por isso que ele tem o nome de piano (pianoforte) porque você consegue transmitir as notas com suavidade ou com pesar, dependendo da necessidade.
With emotion there was more articulation and crescendos. Emotion showed beautiful visuals and passion throughout the piece! Great job! Keep up the great work!
Both are beautiful but only one touches the heart
Ambas são bonitas mas apenas uma toca o coração
Não notei diferença, sinceramente kjjj
What language is the bottom one
Portuguese
Arthur Zopellaro ii
Arthur Zopellaro I
I think the footage of you playing preps us into thinking which is better. A black screen labelled "Version A" and "Version B" for each music sample and then a reveal at the end would have been better
Or you could just close your eyes like a smart person.
or scroll down into the comments section
Yes fantastic idea, he could always do another version like that 😄
This man makes me laugh so much. And not a single word uttered. Genius.
Amazing Piano skill plus I enjoy your sense of humor.
Incredible indeed
I was watching the end of the video being all like "oh cool let's hear what he has to say" and then suddenly EITA ELE TA FALANDO PORTUGUÊS
Same
Fe Jung I think it was Itallian. He said Ciao at the end.
Dark Shadow Storm Dark It's portuguese for sure! I know it since it's my native tongue, I'm brazilian... plus, at the end, he says "tchau"... it has a similar pronunciation of ciao
Lucas Pereira I' m Italian, that "ciao" has a different pronounce. Anyways, "ciao" is both "hello" and "bye".
Lucas Pereira you' re welcome ^^
I fear most of the people only recognize the difference between your "romantic" movements and the starring at the camera!! 😂 😂😂
Rolf Eichele I had my eyes closed the whole video, when he was playing with emotion I felt a twinge of sadness and when he played without emotion I felt nothing
Mucha diferencia! Los sutiles toques de intensidad y tempo...
Sem emoção parece um pianista desumilde já com emoção mostra a humildade e o sentimento e valorização que se sente pela música bom minha opinião 😃😃
I can see a difference .. But don't hear it
Ahmad Y.H you're not listening
i heared it now.. with emotion is "put your heart or feel the music with your soul " without emotion" must memorize or its just a normal music" im the type of person who doesnt have an emotion when i play but i realize that when u play with emotion it make me feel at ease so thank u so much im inspired by u now :)
When you played with emotions, my heart started beating more often
Love your impression
Yea
Without emotion it kinda sounds forced and too staccato
it's called pedals.
I think he of course overdid it and exaggerated both versions for the video. But It is like letting a midi file play it by the notes 100% vs. Having all the slight variations in dynamic and tempo that make it somehow nicer to hear.
It sounds more harsh than with emotion.
Also when you play without emoti9n, you play more technically and based on the notes than when you play with emotion somw of the notes aren't exactly (i.e. you hold you some notes slightly longer or blend them together more) what are on the sheet music
I think that's just him over-exaggerating.
Honestly I watched without looking at the video at all and I really couldn’t tell
Catlily Holmes I'm sorry for your ignorance
That's ok, my ears couldn't tell the difference even with the video on the screen :D
I think that when he's playing with emotions we feel more visually pleased because we feel like he's enjoying it and this make us feel better
It's because he moves his body with the music, when he does it with emotion. And when he doesn't it seems like there's no emotion. There's some science behind it but I don't remember all of it. It was in a Ted talk
I thought it was a different song bruh they didn’t even sound the same. If he played the same notes it would’ve been a more direct comparison. I feel like it’s just the power of suggestion tho.
Without emotion still sounds really good
They should've used two different people because you can tell even when he plays with "no emotion" he still spills his heart out in each note even if his face seems serious
Chopin - Impromptu No. 4 Opus 66, fantástica!!!
Ohhh si que lo es :D
To be honest, no I can't! The only difference for me is staring at me or not
Zdgan Gan ye xD
Me too XD
Try to listen out for wooden/robotic qualities. In the emotional one he has a small case of chronic rubato, while adding extra phrasing. Music is an interpretation, and in the one with no emotion is him reading the notes from the page, and not letting the music flow
Or overreacting on the with feeling version it was almost like if he had a seizure lol!
watch that video of a robot playing the violin if you want to see gross emotionless playing
Muy bueno, maestro.
People who have seen your lie in april would understand
Ahh that overrated piece of garbage. Don't bring it here. This place is too "holy" for casual stuff like that
You otaku
Omfg YEEESSSSS
I fuckin love that show. It filled the hole where my soul used to be. I’m no longer a musician, just an educated internet freak hoping to graduate. Who’s with me? We’ll make t-shirts.
Artaxerxes When i don't have any clue of beauty
The Harmonics and sensibilty changes
Piano Neith and tempo
Piano Neith and dynamics
When he plays with emotion it sounds like he's caressings the keys, softly but intensely.
And when he plays without emotion it sounds mechanical.
It's interesting how our emotions affect the way we do everything.
Mr.Vinheteiro plays with emotion,in both situations.Why?because you can't learn something and in fact,in perfection,without loving it!And feeling it!..He loves music for sooo long,as a loving married couple...that he doesn't have to be emotional!😊...Do you get me?😉We love you "Lord",keep going🥰Stay strong and safe all of you💓🇬🇷
Vc é mto engraçado.
E toca muito.
Parabéns
O lord tava parecendo um psicopata no sem emoção kkk
Nem consegui escutar a musica com esse olhar dele! Kkkk
eu na verdade ri mais que a alma kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk
Pois é kkkkk ri demais
kkkkkk
Né kkkkk
No, I can't
Me too.
Vinheteiro 👌
Me too ;-;
The one with emotion is more agogical
feels like just the vibes that’s different
Its amazing how you can still play the piano with out looking at it. 👏👏👏
As a musician, I can say that the difference between emotion and no emotion is obvious. Music without passion sounds lifeless and empty.
Yup. Exactly. Not a great musician or anything, but the one with emotions seemed to differ and sound less robotic or systematic than the first one. I liked with emotion better
I hear emotion in all the songs I hear, no matter how they are played. Maybe that’s just me.
"lifeless and empty"
okay but can you say it with actually meaningful words ?
I hope you haven't abandoned logic. The pieces that he played were the result of extremely good brains that the composers possessed. Not some emotion shit.
And what the fuck does lifeless and empty even mean. Those words can fool a rundown schmuck but not everyone
Well, I preffer emotion concentrated in his fingers than emotion around the body, unfocused... maybe it's only my appreciation.
*Stares in Italian*
PumpJack McGee Portuguese, but close enough
He is brazilian, actually. Therefore, is speaking portuguese
*Stares in a Latin language*
PumpJack McGee *Stares in a romance language* lol
**stares in portuguese**
I’m so glad I shut my eyes the first time around, to hear the difference. It’s interesting to first hear it and then see it. And, wowzers, the stare! 😂 And while I learned to play without looking (blindfold yourself if you’re too tempted to look) when I just play the chord progressions when someone sings accompaniment (my iPad would often freeze or glitch or shut down unexpectedly so I often just tried to memorize it; it was way safer!), when I’m actually playing involved music, there’s just... no way. No way. Maybe in 30 years. I’m hoping.
Such a talent
LINDO VÍDEO, LORD!!!
Obrigado, Laura.
Vinheteiro Ei vinheteiro, escute a banda chamada Hammock music. VC irá adorar
Até me olhando ele toca mais que eu kkkkk
que eu tbm kkk
Velocista de ferro Devem sim, certas músicas exigem isso. Além que quando você estiver em uma apresentação, a única coisa que poderá de entreter é olhar as teclas.
Velocista de ferro piano é um pouco mais difícil de memorizar do que violino (minha opinião)
Outra coisa, eu prefiro ficar olhando as cordas do que as teclas kk
O cara é brasileiro mesmo! Pelo menos um orgulho pra essa nação!
For some reason my heart melted with motion but not the nomotion i think thats how you can tell if they are doing it with life and emotion
"Without emotion"
You mean staring into ur soul
Why you loek at the cam do hard lol
stef schippers terrifying lol
go to school
stef schippers Why’d you fail English... Guess that’s hard too
Y u can’t spel words
miss gameaholic *spell
I'm glad my piano teacher always told me to play with more emotions.
I can hear them clearly without looking the video.
With emotion is so much better it's like he's soooo calm while playing the piano
Acredito eu que a emoção não se manifesta na expressão facial ,mas sim na dinâmica ,onde o músico tem que ter a percepção de onde deve se conter ou se exaltar , tanto no ritmo quanto no volume ,essas nuances sutis que compõem a emoção da música !
a musica eh a mesma, pq as notas não mudam, mas a mensagem e o clima que o autor quer passar com cada nota muda muito!!
pq ser humano eh idiota e gosta da interação com outros, por isso que musicos com mais "personalidade" se destaca mais que aquela estatua tocando algo.
You have to feel the emotions for the perfect rubato and dynamics.
With emotion he moved his head more and without emotion he didn’t
I don't think
I actually like the versions without emotion better o.o
The notes & phrasing sound cleaner and warmer for some reason 😅 I suppose because he would've had to focus more on playing the right notes since he wasn't looking at the keys & you can get swept up in emotion physically without it actually translating to the music
Jacqueline His playing was more consistent "without emotion" every key was more or less played with the same pressure the tempo was laser like consistent. "With emotion" he kinda just rolled with it a little out of time oh well. Hitting the keys with different pressures oh well. It works the same way on guitar.
spiderfan1974 Sorry, "out of time" in music actually means rhythmically incorrect, and I can assure you he was rhythmically correct both times. Without emotion, the music isn't even music anymore. It's just notes.
CoolGuyVR You just don't get it playing with "emotion" you're just playing you are not counting the beat that strictly. There is no thinking about the next chord. Your in the "pocket" so what you practically took the guitar string off with that attack making that note way louder than the rest. So what if you came in a little late on that solo or start of the rythm. So what you missed a note or three or even picked/played a few clams it sounded great. That's playing with emotion.
spiderfan1974 No, it's not. There is a difference between "out of time" and "playing with emotion". The latter is drastically more subtle. I would know, I have been a musician for about 8 years now.
CoolGuyVR And I've been playing instruments for over twenty years now. Are we in a dick measuring contest? If so I win. There are no rules in music, they're more like guide lines. Besides rules are meant to be broken. So I'll use your faulty logic I've been a musician for over 12 more years than you. Ergo I'm right your wrong grow up.
It's weird because when I play with emotion I'm mainly just staring at the keys and subtly smiling to myself because I'm so focused but this guy knows the song really well so he's really playing it out for us
With emo was more legato, without emo was more staccato
I am italiano, how tu stare?
@@giuseppeamore1704 Ahahah Giuseppe, musica usa worldwide termini in italiano, you should saperlo! W l'Itaglia!
@@Vessy95gg Yeah ora i know, grazie for detto at me this cosa molto important, now at scuola i can sorprendere my music professoressa with my linguaggio
Ian Lim and you comment is so anal-o
@@giuseppeamore1704 AHAHAHAHAHAHAHA I'm morta
You may be too talented for this to be a fair test
Always enjoy your videos first time commenting
👍👍👍👍👍