Manchester United: Is criticism of Bruno Fernandes unfair? | The Football Show
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 31 พ.ค. 2024
- ► Subscribe to Sky Sports News: bit.ly/SkySportsNewsSub
Following Manchester United's 4-2 win over Sheffield United on Wednesday, The Football Show panel debate whether criticism of Bruno Fernandes is unfair.
► For the latest developments on this story: qrcode.skysports.com/skysport...
More from Sky Sports on TH-cam:
► Sky Sports Retro: bit.ly/SkySportsRetroSub
► Sky Sports: bit.ly/SkySportsSub
► Sky Sports Football: bit.ly/SSFootballSub
► Sky Sports Boxing: bit.ly/SSBoxingSub
► Sky Sports F1: bit.ly/SubscribeSkyF1
► Sky Sports Cricket: bit.ly/SubscribeSkyCricket
► Sky Sports Golf: bit.ly/SubscribeSkySportsGolf
► To enquire about licensing Sky Sports News content, you can find out more here: www.skysports.com/more-sports... - กีฬา
It is literally Sky Sports that constantly criticise the club and Fernandes and then come up with a segment like this.
Stats are misleading though but you are right about sky
Thank you!
It’s how they get views
Bruno runs more any other premier league player he mindsets is close Rooney injury but plays on
He has just come to form in the last 3 weeks. Plus his general play can be so frustrating, especially when he doesn't score a goal or provide an assist. The criticism has been justified for most of the season, it doesn't change just because he has hit good form.
Bruno is always giving everything to the club the guy deserves respect
You can't demand respect when he throws his arms in the air and complains about his team mates all the time. He heeds to grow up and become a man before he gains respect
@@JustRifff Its called passion
Bruno is wank
@@JustRifff unfortunately you're not in the position to tell him that ... majority of united fans adolized Brunos contribution because he gives everything from the day he stepped in the club.
@@Nick-jf2wv delusional
It's absolutely unfair and disgusting. He's always saving their horrible asses from utter embarrassment yet they use his moaning defective attitude as a way to slam him and throw him under the bus to protect the real trash players all.becuz they just don't like him
Being the best player on a rubbish squad is hardly something to brag about. It's his antics and total lack of leadership, as captain, that should be called out.
Twerking for united again
like when he saved them from a 7-0 defeat against Liverpool? oh no wait he didn't, he went off sulking as usual, never turns up when it matters
@@shutup2751 already knocked Liverpool out of the fa cup this season and you still talking about the 7 nill?...😮
@@shutup2751 it's unfair to assess a player quality by a single match
He’s our best player by a mile, the criticism from our fans is embarrassing (I expect it from rival fans because of his antics)
@BrizzyBri-ib2dd He's poor when everyone else is poor, but when we do well he shines very well.
@BrizzyBri-ib2dd He doesnt always get praised tho. Because of his antics etc, people tend to not look at what he does for the team. Aside from plastic fans from united, some rival fans talk about how bad he is and how little he does for the team. How poor does he really play? He's a creative machine, when the team plays well, he will excel. When everyone's having a bad game or just bad, he can't pull the numbers. And these numbers are when he's in a bad side, what if he's in a side like madrid, city, PSG? These teams with excellent players right now will definitely pull him up.
@BrizzyBri-ib2dd ‘piss poor for weeks’ 7 goals in his last 6 games 😂
@BrizzyBri-ib2dd lol, careful, don't get yourself drown on your negativity
I'm a Utd fan and his antics piss me off, let alone rival fans! As a player, you can't argue with his ability, chances created etc since he joined. But his behaviour sometimes leaves me with the desire to punch him in the face! 😂
Bruno Fernandes has immense talent,quality,the goal against Liverpool at Old Trafford was of the top drawer and the left footed strike against Sheffield Utd tonight was world class, but he can blow hot and cold,at times his performance dips and he cuts a sorry figure on the pitch
Bruno's antics are his weakness but there's no denying his talent, work rate and dedication. A player who's overplayed like him is bound to have bouts of poor form but he steps up when others don't. At his age I'd be looking at a move to win trophies and as a United fan I'd hate to see him go but I'd totally understand.
People are so critical of his "antics" but not Ronaldo his countryman. Who is sometimes so embarrassing to watch.
Bruno is one of the few world class players at United.
Bruno is the only world class player at United. Definitely have some potential and former world class players but only one who actually is.
@@ChristianPattison Kobbie is really effing close. Garnacho as well
@@thegreatchallenge5963It's still too soon for Kobbie and Garnacho. I'd say our only other world class player is Martinez and we've missed him all season.
@@thegreatchallenge5963way too soon but I get what you’re on about
He is not world class
Totally ignore our injuries
Screw you guys, don’t pretend like you care
If you listen to them carefully they didn't even hide it that they don't care. How a Bruno Fernandes headline turned into a 10hag criticism is just wild
the give excusing on Klopp's behalf for two injuries but coitize ten hag with 60 plus this season... uk press is as stupid as there VAR
Bruno gives 100% and is our captain ..absolutely brilliant player
I hate it when people say without this players goals the team would be so and so in the league. Like with no Bruno would Utd just play with 10 men 🤯
People mix up personality and footballing ability that is why the criticism is unfair.
Bruno Fernandes: Personality and average football ability equals very fair criticism.
@@TheDevilsVerdict lool you don’t know what your talking about… average but top 2 for chances created in top 5 leagues in a terrible united team. Been doing this consistently since he signed.
@@Chidori_stream if you take every set piece, and play every game, of course chances created are going to be high. Also, understand what stats people quantify as a chance. The last pass before any attempt at goal. Do you really watch United and believe he is creative, or do you just look at the stats. Against a highline, i give him that. Without doubt, we have one of the laziest football fan bases in football.
United fans we happy with the results but disappointed with the performance but again we had casemiro playing as centre back ten hag has been very good at adapting with the injuries no other manager would have survived with that current backline
Not addressing the VAR and ref decisions is the real disgrace
Yes, he's had bad games... sometimes gone missing in the big games but people forget that he's a high risk high reward type of player.
It's no coincidence that he plays far much better for the Portugal national team... this is because Portugal national team has better players than United.
Also, whenever he shines few talk about it especially the Press who are always kind of witch hunting United especially Ten Hag. Pochetino is having arguably a worst season than Ten Hag but the Press NEVER calls him out.
I strongly believe that if United gets better players in the Summer, Bruno Fernandes will be far than what he is for United presently. He still tries to create chances but they are not converted and so many a time his quality is not noticed. He gives the ball away a couple of times because he's a high risk high reward player. Unfortunately only few understands this.
No matter what anyone says Bruno Fernandes is a good player that gives his all when on the pitch. This is my opinion.
Always plays well for Portugal. They use to say Pogba always played well for France 🤡 Saw him against Morocco in the world Cup when he was through and decided to dive.
He's class, has been since he joined.
Bruno has ONE good game and all of a sudden the criticism is unfair? It's not about goals and assists, it's about his overall game. And his overall game has been below par for a very long time. But, I will praise people when they perform. Take away the goals and assist, he had a much better game than we normally get from him. Calmer on the ball, making better passes and not kicking it away as soon as he gets it.
We need to be better in possession of the ball. Not having Rashford in the team, but also playing Eriksen helped alot with that.
Good points.
Wow great stats against Sheffield Wed- he’s a flat track bully. Goes missing so often when the chips are down, and his attitude on the pitch is simply not what you’d want to see from a captain. He is talented - no doubt. Can do wonderful thing - yes. But he really is a weak link quite often.
Some sense amongst the nonsense. Well done Sir 👏 👍
It’s been 1 game ffs and even that was against the bottom team. Chill out Sky and relax.
still has more G/A than any other midfielder in the league cry more mate
They literally said that he has scored 6 goals in his last 4 games 😂
@@JimmySands-pd7xt and 4 in his last 29 games. Both the team and the players are ridiculously inconsistent for the club's standard
@@prasadwazza9197 highest g/a of any midfielder in the epl. give the man a break
Spot on.
It is absolutely unfair and we ignore other players who do exactly the same thing on media darling teams with respect to the "moaning." He was villified so much at the time he threw his hands in the air against Liverpool that it's entirely ruined his reputation. He covers more ground than anyone else, creates more chances than anyone in the league, tries to drop back and do everything sometimes with teammates not on his level, and understandably gets frustrated when they aren't doing what they should be. Totally underprotected by refs when constantly fouled because he's apparently a "moaner," whereas serial divers beloved by the press get away with it time after time
Inconsistent just like the team under ETH but a great player worthy a place in a top team
Its his moaning like a toddler that annoys Utd fans. No one has questioned his quality
No it's the rival fans and these pundits that do this. Sure we fans can get annoyed at his stroppyness. But personally I get more annoyed at rashfords little strops. At least with Bruno he has a little moan but then runs like a dog and then moans again. Always have loved Bruno and every united fan I know loves him because of his passion for the club.
Am a United fan you Don’t speak for us, it doesn’t annoys us
BRUNO IS A FANTASTIC PLAYER AND A GREAT LEADER
This is the right moment to move ! I believe Bruno will find a team where he can perform better and win trophies!
Bruno is decent, it's his attitude that let's him down
Did I hear "scored a penalty against Coventry"? Shootouts or in-game?
The criticism is...that he's so good, why not do it all the time, especially when it comes to his shooting! He can score from anywhere on the pitch, with either foot!
you realise hes a human being and not a bot from fifa24?
@@BassicKMuzic so is Ronaldo, Messi, Salah, Haaland, etc etc etc... realistically, with that kind of talent, I'm expecting 20 goals a season minimum
@@A-Kaila ronaldo playing in prime madrid, messi in prime barca, salah in prime liverpool, and haaland in a treble winning city side? yeah that seems like a very fair comparison to bruno in this united side... Maybe lower your expectations and see reality better
@@BassicKMuzic ok, Kane(when he was at Spurs), Palmer, Watkins, Solanke, Isak, etc etc etc...Bruno needs to score more, he needs to take more shots, he will score more goals
@@A-Kaila Brunos numbers this are still good season, all things considered. Really dont know what you want tbh
You got to give it to him, the guy doesn’t miss any game even when he’s injured. His problem is he wants to be everywhere in the pitch and it’s not effective or possible. One of the reasons he tries every blade is because Rashford is like a missing player or 10 men.
Fernandez has 143 goal involvements in 229 appearances for United
Paul Scholes had 236 goal involvements playing for United 716 times
Fernandez needs 93 goal involvements from the next 487 games (beyond his career) to match Paul Scholes
Yeah, the criticism is unfair
Bruno is basically a striker. He is the main reason we are so unbalanced in midfield because he is undisiplined in his positioning. Scholes controlled the whole game, Bruno can barely control the ball at times.
@@Kjartan1985 Gimme a break. A striker? Are you having a laugh? A guy who comes down to defend all the time and is criticized for doing hollywood passes forward all the time (how can he make the passes if he is always positioned as the striker). Just cope with the stats even if it doesn't fit your narrative.
I have no arguments about his attitude he is the captain of our football club he expects the best of the players that he is the captain of he should have an attitude if his players are not playing the way he wants and he knows the way they can play
Premier league, apart from being the best league, is also one of the most demanding ones and Bruno has a huge weight over his shoulders, but he's not the one, who people have criticized. Think of Lio Messi when he got criticized by not winning with Argentina, nevertheless he had enough perseverance to get stronger and then he won Qatar world cup with Argentinian team. So, earning everyone's respect takes a little bit time.
its honestly so dumb how they spend weeks criticising bruno, then he gets some form back and suddenly its "unfair". media is a joke
Yes
The only problem is that Bruno whines too much instead of trying to be the mentor who teaches these players how to think and pass the ball rather than be afraid of losing it.
Never once criticised his ability, but his attitude is not the best. He has improved last few games though, but needs to be more consistent
People still here going at the man who actually creates the second most chances in Europe top 5 leagues. If we had better forwards his assists total would’ve been up by a lot. Yes he’ll misplace some passes but that’s due to the type of passes he plays which was known before he was signed. He gets more hate from the English media and people than Rashford who plays like crap due to not being from there.
Sky TNT DM are anti Manchester United have been for years. Bruno one of the best players in the league who gives everything he has every game.
As an Arsenal fan the criticism is unfair of Fernandes hes been one of the most consistent players since Jan 2020 . It’s unfortunately his numbers would have been more superior if players around him knew how to finish.
At present we're only at least a couple of years behind the top 3 but we should be only 1 year or equal by now but due to EtH over spending & not bringing in the necessary players to give us the depth to deal with a 65 game season.
This is what Ronaldo wanted the club to have a chance to succeed but EtH is the reason why we've lost so many games at the half way point cos he was hanging his players out to dry & he's at fault for 6 out of the 12 losses due to poor summer transfers where we want 6 players & only got 3, poor decisions making, poor preparations, poor assessment, poor team selection, poor squad usages & poor In-game management so his Job is definitely under review due to his underperformance as Manager of our Club.
Conclusion
We recruit EtH to come to our Club as an Approved Coach cos he definitely isn't a Manager in our books so he deserves the Sack so It's best for EtH & his team to pack their bags & go back to Ajax to reinvent himself & bring back Ole & his new management team (Ole & his 3 wise men)!
Keep it in the family!
completely unfair... the guy is unreal, first time in years he's injured... in g/a record is astonishing and chance creation is 2nd only to kdb
his outputs for a crap utd side are amazing
If the team is built around Bruno we’ll always be a mid table team. The midfield is unbalance because of the insistence on Bruno being the first name on the team sheet.
Difficult for any player to look good in the chaotic set up the manager makes them play. Most of the players looked better against Sheffield because the team less chaotic.
Bruno and the rest looked good against Sheffield United because they are a championship side. It's typical flat track bullying wen the season is done.
100%. Do you not remember what United was like before him? We were worse than we are now.
BRUNO, BRUNO, BRUNO!!!
How come Sky doesn't talk about how poor Newcastle and Chelsea have been?
We want to be challenging for the league & Europa league next season not delay tactics like Tuchel or Southgate or Potter or DeZerbi or mismanaged by EtH cos we'll be better off with Ole or Outsider like Zidane than EtH cos EtH lacks people skills meaning wrong type of manager to take charge of our club.
The best advice we're prepare to offer is EtH & his team should pack their bags & go back to Ajax to reinvent himself!
Keep it in the family!
Put Bruno into a proper team that is strong in all departments like an arsenal or a man City, I think you'd see more disciple to his game, he creates more than anyone else but I also think his game is negatively affected because of the lack of quality that is around him, and he pulls himself away from where he should be,,I think he could keep the ball better but he is a risk taker and to be fair he's not been at his best but you play better football if your surrounded by better footballers
To make the Europa League are u dump? By qualitying to the FA Cup final they already qualidied to the EL as City has already secured a champions league spot
All the stats about shots faced by MUFC, The True Stat should be Shots On Target. Bet its not high but the won't show that stat. Bruno is Out Performing his contemporaries in the Leagues and the media still try to make it about his attitude. Class is Class and the Media Lacks it
Sky constantly criticizes Bruno
Sky asks us if it’s unfair
Full circle news
He is so special. i feel bad for him sometimes thinking he is wasting his career at United.
Yes!!!
2:40 "probably going to end up with their lowest ever premier league points tally" Really? Our lowest premier league points tally is 58 points, the season before ETH was appointed. We currently have 53 points with 5 games to play. The media agenda on ETH is real. This is why i want him to succeed, we can't let the media continue to sack our managers. Erik Ten Hag has done well at United, I don't think they're many managers out there that can do better, in his circumstances.
Bruno's stats speak for themselves. OK, sometimes he moans a bit and throws his arms up, but that's down to him wanting to win and wants his team mates to want to win. Always puts 100% in for Man Utd , sometimes tries a worldy pass when a simple one would be better but overall invaluable to Utd and it would be nice if all United's players showed as much commitment. One or two haven't this year and everyone knows who they are !
ETH doesnt want to be a counter-attacking team.
Klopps best team is a good example of what ETH has explained what he wants to do.
ETH said in the summer he wants to make United the best transitional team in the world. The fans with real football knowledge were suspicious of him when he said that. And they were right.
@@TheDevilsVerdict and the people with real football knowledge know that United had one of the highest turnover wins in middle and final third of the pitch at the start of the season?
It was working until everyone got injured
@@imo098765 the reason that's the case is because United's 1st line defence is so bad teams take all sorts of chances against us. Football fans today are so lazy. Stats, stats, stats. Actually analyse how those stats are achieved. United have been awful from the first game against Wolves. Opta doesn't tell you that so it can't be true.
More assists and goals than any other midfielder in the prem since he joined United.
Love to see Roy Keane captain this united side especially considering how and why he left United.
he would be villified by the media. He complains the same amount as Bruno does
Its not his ability, its his attitude and body language that irks people!
If he keeps scoring adn assisint ghte way he is, anything is forgivable. But jsut because you're scornig, doesng mean you can't improve as a leader. Better composure. Better discipline. Better emotional stability.
Sky sports are flippy floppy bro they've been hating on Bruno for god knows how long.
HELL YES
Bruno is a United legend
Bruno Fernandes is just great. He should be respected
Its just he set the bar on his first year and anything below that is a failure and the team around his isn’t helping at all.
He is actually the best player on united, the man has almost the most shots on goal and shots in every game of united.
So he shots and misses a lot. What's the point here? Its not rugby. You don't get 3 points when the ball goes over the bar.
@@TheDevilsVerdict uhhh...clearly you have no clue about the game, how are you going to win a if you don't create chances?
@@yasinsharb9453 🤣🤡
Wilcox comes from Southampton and is supposed to determine a playing style for UTD, the biggest club in England? Who is this guy? This does not make sense to me. Anyway
Well he won a Premier League title. Maybe he can tell the players what that's like because none have a clue.
Hes the one who ordered ETH to start playing possession based instead of transitional football. And the one match we play it. We completely dominate, he clearly knows what hes doing
He is the best we have, please respect Bruno
If you wanna see 10 Hags style of play look at the youth. The senior team obviously just cant be assed
As a lifelong United fan he's a great player but he doesn't do it in the big games
Yeah he likes complaining a times instead of focusing on his game either than that he has been United best ever since he joined
No one:
Sky Sports: "Why is Bruno Fernandes being criticized?"
Everyone: "None of us said anything"
Sky Sports: "Does he deserve the criticism?"
Bruno reminds me of Gerrard, world-class midfielder playing for a sleeping giant
The fans love Bruno. Without him it would be dire.
The British media and my mom react in the same manner. My mom wiped my azz and ask why are you crying? Calm down or you will be in timeout. The English media bit down on ETH for two years and when he respond to criticism, they go why is he reacting that way? 🤦♂️🤷♂️
Yes it's. Next question
Not criticizing referees is unfair
Not before this month it wasn’t
Bruno has never missed a game through injury for Manchester United. Get your facts right
Change your minds more than the wind you lot. One minute you’re slating him then you’re questioning whether it’s fair or not. Hypocrites
Even Onana criticism is unfair.
Yes it is unfair if not for Bruno we would be even worse off than we ate Bruno is important for us
If united had signed macalister like I said.. instead of Liverpool they would be flying right now
You should take a note that....the criticism created by publicity is turnishing players image....so stop playing sides against other people's performances.....nobodies is fair in person
Performance against clubs like Sheffield Utd doesn't justify his place in club like Man Utd
It’s Sheffield!
He deserves to be in a better club like Leverkusen.
He’s a whiner, but tbf, where would Man United be without him this season.
Probably 5th.
@@TheDevilsVerdict You’re saying Man Utd would be better off without Bruno?
@@HuwEvans. Absolutely. We would be more solid, organised, and consequently a more rounded team. Hes an absolute liability without the ball and gives it away to much when we have it. If you watched more of the top sides, you would realise why he isn't playing for one of them. I can predict the come back. He plays well for Portugal, if he played in a better team, Ronaldo put him off, the stats say......
@@TheDevilsVerdict Got to love Man Utd fans. Even turn on their best player. Pathetic club these days
@@HuwEvans. what's pathetic about United these days are fans accepting mediocrity. You've clearly never seen a top United side.
Talk of United but there’s 3 top sides competing for the title and not a single United player can get in those 3 teams. United are fckng embarrassing and shouldn’t be mentioned anywhere near the top sides.
man utd should sign gundougan from barcelona to work along side bruno
Nothing to do with Bruno. This segment is a ruse, to criticize ETH because he threw yrll out from the media room
Shirt tooooo tight
Yes, criticizing him is fair , he has had one good game against a team at the bottom of the league all season. For the rest of the season, he has been crap or mediocre at best. Playing well against Sheffield United doesn’t override his horrendous form the whole season. Get serious people!
Criticism of his behavior and manners
Bruno performs well against mediocre teams only but throws his hands in the air against better opponents.
Sky sports we need to talk about Bruno while throwing ETH under the bus
Match rank is actually hilarious
He should just stop trying to shoot the ball all the time, when he should be laying a pass forward.
Stat pads against the bottom most team in PL and his PR does the rest. Classic Bruno scamming his way to potentially a new contract 😂
Utd beat Sheffield utd and suddenly they think they are great
What about trashford
No guy in that team gives his all every single time his put on the shirt.
Criticism of Bruno Fernades is justified. The man has had one good performance all season coming against the league's bottom club