I grew up in Sunni Islam an unfortunately we never Ever were taught anything about what happend with The descendents * of Rasulallah* ...not other than what happend to Imam Ali*😭😭😭
This channel is Mash'Allah. There are things i need to know as a muslim. I may have taken my shahada in 2011 but i am still a baby in islam. Its about time to get serious with my deen and studies. May Allah give you a lot of subcribers and likes too.
Very informative, and researched documentary. Dr. Rebecca put it together very well. She has an encyclopedic knowledge of the subject matter of the Ahlul Bayt, and gives a true representation of history on this matter. Even though I don't follow the Shia school, but a lover of the Ahlul Bayt, I agree with many things that was mentioned. Would love to see more of these types of videos.
I have in my possession, a contemporary to the time of the schism, wrought iron shield which depicts the engraved story of Husayn ibn Ali's (aleihi salem) martyrdom. Beautifully engraved. Next item to find; A Shi'i shamshir to compliment it.
For Professor Kennedy to say at 28:54/49:10 that Husain ibn Ali was living in the safety of Madina, until he arrived in Iraq at the invitation of the people of Kufa, overlooks the fact that Husain left Madina for Mecca months before the Hajj season, for reasons that Yazeed ibn Muawiyyia had demanded allegiance from Husain at the pain of death. Letters from the people of Kufa arrived in Mecca, and not earlier in Madina. So Husain ibn Ali was not safe in Madina. Four persons were required to swear allegiance to Yazeed at the pain of death: Husain ibn Ali, Abdullah ibn Zobayr, Abdur Rahman ibn Abi Bakr and Abdullah ibn Omar. The first two refused - Abdullah ibn Zobayr left Madina to set up his headquarters in Mecca and raise an army. Abdur Rahman ibn Abi Bakr was too ill and died in his bed. Abdullah ibn Omar eagerly submitted. And Husain ibn Ali refused, and stayed in Mecca until the people of Kufa and Basra called for help to address issues of injustice and corruption. En route to Iraq, Husain ibn Ali was offered 20,000 armed men by Tirimmah ibn Adi - an offer he declined to accept, saying that his stand was not an insurrection to achieve power, but to guide the people and restore justice to the persecuted.
After the death of the Prophet Mohamad pbuh, the conflict began between the house of the Prophet "Fatima Ali Hassan and Hussein" pbuh and others. Ahl al-Bayt wanted to preserve the message of Islam and adhere to the commandments of the Prophet, the only weapon that they have the Book of Allah and the commandments of the Messenger of Allah and their faith. The others wanted power in every sense of the word, They had money, weapons and power, and they were not interested in the Qura'an, Islam or the Prophet, but they used Islam to achieve their interests. Unfortunately, power and power prevailed over justice and right. But thanks to the martyrdom of the people of the house, Muhammadi's original Islam continued to this day. But the painful today is that the other side does not want to admit that mistakes have been made, and worst of all, that the facts are in their books but they insist on continuing their hypocrisy and accuse the Shiites of infidelity and out of Islam. Shiites today like Arius in Christianity "Arius was a Unitarian, he was believed in one God and Jesus as a prophet".
Rebecca you should have responded to him when he said umayyads were organized and clever. Ummayads were clever in the sense of being oppressive and organised in being unjust.
Ahul al bayt are more clever and smarter then any human beside our Prophet Muhammed pbuh. If they wanted, they could of had bani ummah wiped off the face of the heart. The reason they didn't do that was a test for us to take example in them. The path of Allah is straightforward. The Ahul al bayt did not care for power and money. The cared for humanity to find Allah in thier example.
Professor Sajjad Rizvi rightly explains the historical accounts written to uphold triumphalist and imperialist Muslim rule. Notwithstanding the fact that historians were in the main subservient to their imperial caliphs, there were some who had the intellectual courage to defend the stand taken by Husain ibn Ali - Tabari and ibn Khaldun have condemned the murder of Husain ibn Ali. Furthermore, the Omavi writer Abul Faraj al-Isfahani in his Maqaatil-at-Taalibiyyeen sets out the injustices perpetrated by the imperial caliphs / kings against the descendents of Abu Talib.
umayyads were never interested in avenging Ameer Uthman ibn Afaan, they were only interested in ruling and dictationg ucz at their time they had all the power and were capable of doing so but they didnt cuz their only desire was rulership but when they started messing things up they knew that Imam Hasan ibn Ali is reowned in society and he is capable of taking a stand so they had him killed by poisoning, later Imam Hussain had enough of it and he took a stand and martyred in Karbala. after a decade or soo there was one Caliph in Umayyad who was Just and a strong Muslim Umar bin abdulaziz who only ruled for 2 and a half years but cleared up all the mess.
If a tradition is not agreed upon by those directly trying to express the revelation and inspiration to a prophet, we should question why it would be religiously valid. We should also question basing our spirituality on secondary or further on versions of importance. We should question why any type of narrative changes.
im sunni ...i think thats the main reason .. what this professor is saying after 36 minutes . i think we don't need such type of khilafat .. who have no respect for people lives ...
She interrupts her guests when she doesn’t like what she’s hearing. She wants to change what’s narrated and written. Sorry lady, Hocine died at a war he lost, and history is written by winners not losers.
People of kufa invite imam Hussain Ra to kufa when Hussain need their help then the kufan disappeared cowardly.they r responsible for the killing of ahlul bayath
The lady in the black jellaba is so one eyed. Trying so hard to demonise the Omayed Khalifate. Hocine wanted power went with his army Lost got himself and his army massacred. Get over it. Power struggle. That was all.
Why shia only celebrate Hussain? why not Ali ibn Abi Talib R.A in Kufa? why no Abu bakar ibn Ali, Umar ibn Ali, Uthman ibn Ali also died in Karbala alongside with Hussain R.A, Sahaba Muhajirin n Ansar, Khalid Al-Walid R.A, Umar Al-Khattab R.A than for conquest of Persia and Levant(Syam, Palestin) Allah know future)
Excuse me my friend you are misguided..there were no such names of omar ibne ali or bakar or utman in the family of ahlubait..these are the fabrication of ummyad dynasty and wrongly propagate the family of alybait as
Good point! The Shiahs turn a blind eye that there were Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman also shaheed along with imam Hussain RA in Karbala. Now can you see how unjust the Shiahs are LOL???
Shiaism is a chain reaction of emotions of people of Kofa who failed to rescue the Imam after the tragic event of Karbala .... Please correct me if I'm wrong ... Thanks
That reaction was pretty short lived. Search for series by the name Mukhtar nama if you prefer watching over reading through books. People who reacted to repent were given the name Tawwabeen. You can see in the series how they were slaughtered and their movement ended then and there. Regarding who are Shia people...there was a massive cover-up by Yazid about the murder of imam Husain. Lots of lies spread, traditions created to divert attention from it, murders of people who spoke of the enormous injustice done to imam Husain. Those who knew the truth, commemorated imam's murder regardless of all attempts to hush the matter, and carried that on over the centuries. These processions and remembrances of the tragedy you see after more than a millennium, is simply by the people who know the truth.. They are the so called Shia.
@@ZebaNaqvi Thanks Zeba , to become Shia is impossible coz only those who were with Ali (Companions of Ali ) were entitled as Shian e Ali , rest of us we can't be Shia . Those who follow the track can be called from Fiqah e Jafria that's the School of Thought .
Jay ! Shi'a are supporters of Imam Ali.we believe prophet muhammad pbuh declared Ali ibn abu talib his successor .the event of Ghadeer khum was the spot where prophet pbuh declared him.As coming to Shias of kofa.they lived very short after the event of karbala.even kofa at that time most of them were supporters of yazeed.they've converted to Shiism in 18 century .but likely many people say that Shiites are mourning because the people of kofa did and that's not right.Janab syeda zainab grand daughter of prophet pbuh started mourning of imam hussain in Damascus prison and later in this continued in medina as well..in Shiism we only follow ahl bait way.prophet pbuh said that I'm leaving 2 things behind .don't leave them at any cost.one is book of God and second is my ahlbait.. there are groups in Shia's as well.as you can see there are zaidis ismailis jaffari Alevis..the concept of Shiism is quite simple .we follow path of Imam ali and his successors imam hasan imam hussain imam zain al abideen imam baqar imam jafar sadiq.imam mosa kazim.imam ali reza imam muhamad taqi imam ali naqi imam hasan askari and final imam is imam mahdi.there is a hadees of prophet pbuh when nabi pak said there will be only 12 imams and hazrat jabir asked prophet pbuh what are the names of those imams and prophet pbuh gave him their names as well and told hazrat jabir that he will see my 5th successor and asked hazrat jabir to pay my greetings to my fifth successor.
I'm not a Muslim, i do not follow Islam. But this man is a newfound inspiration of mine. So sad to hear what happened to him. He's surely in peace.
Thank you, its not everyday a nonmuslim respects us muslims, you help me understand that nonmuslims are very kind
Dear sir!! Go through his life please!! You'll find he was A HERO TO THE WORLD!!
Judai Yugo thanks
Bless you brother
He surely is... May Allah curse be upon his enemies then, now & forever...
Imam Hussain (as) is for all mankind.
May his soul rest in peace and I love his faith!!!
Thank you for this important and well researched documentary 👏👏👏💛🏆
I grew up in Sunni Islam an unfortunately we never Ever were taught anything about what happend with The descendents * of Rasulallah* ...not other than what happend to Imam Ali*😭😭😭
May God pray and say hello to our Prophet Muhammad and to his god and his companions all of him
Save with me , they hide karbala etc everything
This channel is Mash'Allah. There are things i need to know as a muslim. I may have taken my shahada in 2011 but i am still a baby in islam. Its about time to get serious with my deen and studies.
May Allah give you a lot of subcribers and likes too.
Great documentary. Very moving. Thanks for uploading. I'm standing behind the counter at work with tears streaming down my face as I type...
Almighty Allah bless all human beings ❤️
labbek Ya Hussein YA HUSSEIN AS ALAHUMASALEALA MUHAMMUD WA ALE MUHAMMED
labbek Ya Hussein
Ya Hussein
Thank you! May Allah reward you
Absolutely Phenomenal work, extremely well put together, very enlightening.
Very informative, and researched documentary. Dr. Rebecca put it together very well. She has an encyclopedic knowledge of the subject matter of the Ahlul Bayt, and gives a true representation of history on this matter. Even though I don't follow the Shia school, but a lover of the Ahlul Bayt, I agree with many things that was mentioned. Would love to see more of these types of videos.
I have in my possession, a contemporary to the time of the schism, wrought iron shield which depicts the engraved story of Husayn ibn Ali's (aleihi salem) martyrdom. Beautifully engraved. Next item to find; A Shi'i shamshir to compliment it.
Very touching far and beonyd our imagination
حقيقه مؤثر شخصيات أهل البيت ع فوق مستوى الوصف
نموت ويبقى الحسين ...
I am saudi sunni and just finish read about imam hussain 💔
For Professor Kennedy to say at 28:54/49:10 that Husain ibn Ali was living in the safety of Madina, until he arrived in Iraq at the invitation of the people of Kufa, overlooks the fact that Husain left Madina for Mecca months before the Hajj season, for reasons that Yazeed ibn Muawiyyia had demanded allegiance from Husain at the pain of death. Letters from the people of Kufa arrived in Mecca, and not earlier in Madina. So Husain ibn Ali was not safe in Madina.
Four persons were required to swear allegiance to Yazeed at the pain of death: Husain ibn Ali, Abdullah ibn Zobayr, Abdur Rahman ibn Abi Bakr and Abdullah ibn Omar. The first two refused - Abdullah ibn Zobayr left Madina to set up his headquarters in Mecca and raise an army. Abdur Rahman ibn Abi Bakr was too ill and died in his bed. Abdullah ibn Omar eagerly submitted. And Husain ibn Ali refused, and stayed in Mecca until the people of Kufa and Basra called for help to address issues of injustice and corruption. En route to Iraq, Husain ibn Ali was offered 20,000 armed men by Tirimmah ibn Adi - an offer he declined to accept, saying that his stand was not an insurrection to achieve power, but to guide the people and restore justice to the persecuted.
Labbaika Ya Hussain a.s
May ALLAH be please with him,
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭Imam Hussain
لبيك يا حسين
Ya hussain a.s
After the death of the Prophet Mohamad pbuh, the conflict began between the house of the Prophet "Fatima Ali Hassan and Hussein" pbuh and others. Ahl al-Bayt wanted to preserve the message of Islam and adhere to the commandments of the Prophet, the only weapon that they have the Book of Allah and the commandments of the Messenger of Allah and their faith.
The others wanted power in every sense of the word, They had money, weapons and power, and they were not interested in the Qura'an, Islam or the Prophet, but they used Islam to achieve their interests. Unfortunately, power and power prevailed over justice and right. But thanks to the martyrdom of the people of the house, Muhammadi's original Islam continued to this day. But the painful today is that the other side does not want to admit that mistakes have been made, and worst of all, that the facts are in their books but they insist on continuing their hypocrisy and accuse the Shiites of infidelity and out of Islam.
Shiites today like Arius in Christianity "Arius was a Unitarian, he was believed in one God and Jesus as a prophet".
Sajjan Rizvi's insights were very interesting.
Rebecca you should have responded to him when he said umayyads were organized and clever. Ummayads were clever in the sense of being oppressive and organised in being unjust.
Ahul al bayt are more clever and smarter then any human beside our Prophet Muhammed pbuh. If they wanted, they could of had bani ummah wiped off the face of the heart. The reason they didn't do that was a test for us to take example in them. The path of Allah is straightforward. The Ahul al bayt did not care for power and money. The cared for humanity to find Allah in thier example.
Was the beheading of Hussein’s children an act of intelligence or barbaric brutality?
Ofcourse brutality
Labbayk ya Husain
Masha Allah
السلام على الحسين وعلى اولاد الحسين وعلى اصحاب الحسين وعلى نساء الحسين واطفال الحسين.
Professor Sajjad Rizvi rightly explains the historical accounts written to uphold triumphalist and imperialist Muslim rule. Notwithstanding the fact that historians were in the main subservient to their imperial caliphs, there were some who had the intellectual courage to defend the stand taken by Husain ibn Ali - Tabari and ibn Khaldun have condemned the murder of Husain ibn Ali. Furthermore, the Omavi writer Abul Faraj al-Isfahani in his Maqaatil-at-Taalibiyyeen sets out the injustices perpetrated by the imperial caliphs / kings against the descendents of Abu Talib.
YA HUSEIN
Just a reminder:
Arabism has been reported during the rule of Omar ibn Khatab as well
Well doneeeee
Hasssan & Hussain are most famous boys in the world.
He is not only responsible for karbala but events after karbala, such as attack on Medinah n makka burning of kaaba
umayyads were never interested in avenging Ameer Uthman ibn Afaan, they were only interested in ruling and dictationg ucz at their time they had all the power and were capable of doing so but they didnt cuz their only desire was rulership but when they started messing things up they knew that Imam Hasan ibn Ali is reowned in society and he is capable of taking a stand so they had him killed by poisoning, later Imam Hussain had enough of it and he took a stand and martyred in Karbala. after a decade or soo there was one Caliph in Umayyad who was Just and a strong Muslim Umar bin abdulaziz who only ruled for 2 and a half years but cleared up all the mess.
If a tradition is not agreed upon by those directly trying to express the revelation and inspiration to a prophet, we should question why it would be religiously valid.
We should also question basing our spirituality on secondary or further on versions of importance.
We should question why any type of narrative changes.
very impressive objective and agenda-free documentary.
💔يا حسين ليتك حاضرا مولاي أن القوم من بعدك قد ضلوا فمجدوا قاتليك وبايعو دعاة الدين من الوهابية والخمينية
Who is Al-Hussein Ibn Ali?
Which country
Death of YAZEED explains it all as to how much responsible he is
im sunni ...i think thats the main reason
..
what this professor is saying after 36 minutes
.
i think we don't need such type of khilafat
..
who have no respect for people lives
...
A Sallam Alajkum can somebody explain too me please whom kill Husein RA
Is Hussain, the final messenger of Allah?
Rehan Khan NO
No he is son of mohammed dutle
Rehan Khan ..no
No 😐
No
She interrupts her guests when she doesn’t like what she’s hearing. She wants to change what’s narrated and written.
Sorry lady, Hocine died at a war he lost, and history is written by winners not losers.
Who IS AL-HUSSEIN IBN ALI, periods 1917 OPPOSITE TURKEY RULES.....
Triumphant imperialist Islam? Or Triumphant imperialist Muslim?
Aujubillah
People of kufa invite imam Hussain Ra to kufa when Hussain need their help then the kufan disappeared cowardly.they r responsible for the killing of ahlul bayath
@ali faraz the stupid yazid is one person who gave the power in karbala , that's clear peoples of kurbala.
You need to revisit the history and understand what really happened ..
Sunnis follow the ummayads?
No
I am sunni and never
The lady in the black jellaba is so one eyed. Trying so hard to demonise the Omayed Khalifate. Hocine wanted power went with his army Lost got himself and his army massacred. Get over it. Power struggle. That was all.
Astagfarullah
Dislikes=Sins
Likes:rewards
long live sunni
long live umma
you mean long live beheading isis?
LONG LIVE SUNNIS AND SHIAS! !!
Soraya Hamidi long live ISLAM
@@WeWanderWhy ISIS and Shia are same
Why shia only celebrate Hussain? why not Ali ibn Abi Talib R.A in Kufa? why no Abu bakar ibn Ali, Umar ibn Ali, Uthman ibn Ali also died in Karbala alongside with Hussain R.A, Sahaba Muhajirin n Ansar, Khalid Al-Walid R.A, Umar Al-Khattab R.A than for conquest of Persia and Levant(Syam, Palestin) Allah know future)
Safuwan Fauzi lol when we celebrate imam Hussain (as) means were celebrating imam Ali (as) aswell as Nabi Muhammad (pbuh)
Excuse me my friend you are misguided..there were no such names of omar ibne ali or bakar or utman in the family of ahlubait..these are the fabrication of ummyad dynasty and wrongly propagate the family of alybait as
Good point!
The Shiahs turn a blind eye that there were Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman also shaheed along with imam Hussain RA in Karbala. Now can you see how unjust the Shiahs are LOL???
@@naqibbro6571 Uthman was martyred at the hands of the Khwarij. His was the last before Ali alive, but he didn't live to see Karbalah either.
@@JaefarSABNW
What I meant was Omar ibn Husayn and Abu Bakr ibn Husayn RA (also martyred).
Shiaism is a chain reaction of emotions of people of Kofa who failed to rescue the Imam after the tragic event of Karbala .... Please correct me if I'm wrong ... Thanks
That reaction was pretty short lived. Search for series by the name Mukhtar nama if you prefer watching over reading through books. People who reacted to repent were given the name Tawwabeen. You can see in the series how they were slaughtered and their movement ended then and there. Regarding who are Shia people...there was a massive cover-up by Yazid about the murder of imam Husain. Lots of lies spread, traditions created to divert attention from it, murders of people who spoke of the enormous injustice done to imam Husain. Those who knew the truth, commemorated imam's murder regardless of all attempts to hush the matter, and carried that on over the centuries. These processions and remembrances of the tragedy you see after more than a millennium, is simply by the people who know the truth.. They are the so called Shia.
@@ZebaNaqvi Thanks Zeba , to become Shia is impossible coz only those who were with Ali (Companions of Ali ) were entitled as Shian e Ali , rest of us we can't be Shia . Those who follow the track can be called from Fiqah e Jafria that's the School of Thought .
Jay ! Shi'a are supporters of Imam Ali.we believe prophet muhammad pbuh declared Ali ibn abu talib his successor .the event of Ghadeer khum was the spot where prophet pbuh declared him.As coming to Shias of kofa.they lived very short after the event of karbala.even kofa at that time most of them were supporters of yazeed.they've converted to Shiism in 18 century .but likely many people say that Shiites are mourning because the people of kofa did and that's not right.Janab syeda zainab grand daughter of prophet pbuh started mourning of imam hussain in Damascus prison and later in this continued in medina as well..in Shiism we only follow ahl bait way.prophet pbuh said that I'm leaving 2 things behind .don't leave them at any cost.one is book of God and second is my ahlbait.. there are groups in Shia's as well.as you can see there are zaidis ismailis jaffari Alevis..the concept of Shiism is quite simple .we follow path of Imam ali and his successors imam hasan imam hussain imam zain al abideen imam baqar imam jafar sadiq.imam mosa kazim.imam ali reza imam muhamad taqi imam ali naqi imam hasan askari and final imam is imam mahdi.there is a hadees of prophet pbuh when nabi pak said there will be only 12 imams and hazrat jabir asked prophet pbuh what are the names of those imams and prophet pbuh gave him their names as well and told hazrat jabir that he will see my 5th successor and asked hazrat jabir to pay my greetings to my fifth successor.
Ya Hussein