lol, China sends their massive fishing armadas to places right off the coast of Chile and other South American countries to steal all their fish. They overfished their waters and now have to go half way across the world and steal fish from other countries. It's amazing that the world still puts up with China till this day...
Maps published by the National Mapping and Resource Information Authority of the Philippines (NAMRIA Philippines), clearly marked Scarborough Shoal (Huangyan Island, Panatag Shoal) as *outside the limit of the Philippine territory and confirmed is not part of Philippines* : The National Map of Philippines 2006 (1:1,700,000), The Map of The Philippines (1:1,500,000) published in 2010, Political Map of the Philippines (1:4,250,000) 2008 to 2011.
The West can disrespect international law, but you are an idiot if you ask China to respect it. The Chinese Sea has belonged to China for hundreds of years, and the Philippines has only been independent for how many years.
With the new laws, the Philippines 🇵🇭 will be able to *board and arrest* Chinese vessels, maritime militias or Coast Guard, in the Philippines' EEZ that are not operating on the *defined sea lanes.*
Did the Philippines expand territory over which it is sovereign to help ("pawn") U.S policy of keeping the people in Asian poor? _"we(U.S.) have about 50% of the _*_world's wealth_*_ but only 6.3% of its population. This _*_disparity is particularly great as between ourselves and the peoples of Asia._*_ ..which will permit us to maintain this position of disparity without positive detriment to our national security..we should concentrate our policy on seeing to it that those areas remain in hands which _*_we can control_*_ or rely on..that _*_Japan and the Philippines_*_ will be found to be the corner-stones of such a Pacific security system"_ *- Foreign Relations of the United States 1948 Volume 1 Part 2.djvu/34*
Xi-jinping is Crazy president of China drawing map of China vs the original map of the Philippines West Philippines Sea Philippines Territory not China
It is US given it to China. 😆what a jealousy 😅🤣 _"The Philippines gained independence in 1946, but when nationalists within the Philippine government wanted to claim the Spratlys, their American advisors discouraged them. The Spanish-American treaty of 1898 made it clear that the western limit of the Philippine islands did not include the Spratlys, and the United States was not keen to carry the cost of a Philippine irredentist adventure that might bring conflict with Chiang Kai-shek's regime in China"_ *- Page 11 , War Or Peace in the South China Sea? edited by Timo Kivimäki. Contributor: Nordic Institute of Asian Studies (NIAS) 2002.*
@JEVETHArcosa the original map of the Philippines? 😆Maps published by the National Mapping and Resource Information Authority of the Philippines (NAMRIA Philippines), clearly marked Scarborough Shoal (Huangyan Island, Panatag Shoal) as *outside the limit of the Philippine territory and confirmed is not part of Philippines:* The National Map of Philippines 2006 (1:1,700,000), The Map of The Philippines 2010 (1:1,500,000), Political Map of the Philippines (1:4,250,000) 2008 to 2011.
@@LivingLonger This is nonsense. The U.S. runs the world and makes the rules. If they say it doesn't belong to China, then it doesn't belong to China. The U.S. can break the rules because they make them. China needs to stop causing all of the world's problems and do exactly what the U.S. tells them or Trump will sanction China out of existence! 😂
Proximity does not equal sovereignty. Just because something is close to you, does not mean it's part of your country. The Philippines never had control over these reefs and islands, and it was never recognized by any other country. The territory of the Philippines has clearly been delimited by Spain and the US. The Philippines should stop being surprised that China does not accept its territory from being stolen by them.
Hey CNA journalists! Please use "West Philippine Sea" instead of "South China Sea"when you report Scarborough Shoal as it is within the 200-mile exclusive economic zone of The Philippines and decided by the 2016 Arbitral Ruling of the United Nations Convention on the Laws of the Sea. Again, it is not disputed anymore as the Philippines and only the Philippines alone has the right to explore any resources in that area. Educate yourself and don't mimic the deceptive chinese narrative!
Disputes over land territories of natural islands are governed by general international law, not UNCLOS. The Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) in 2016 does not rule on any question of sovereignty over land territory and does not delimit any boundary between the Parties [1]. [1] PERMANENT COURT OF ARBITRATION - The Hague, 12 July 2016, PRESS RELEASE: THE SOUTH CHINA SEA ARBITRATION (THE REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES V. THE PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA). Page 1.
Oh come on. China president has the history of grabbing land. They are not content what they have year by year china land grab are to much becoz of there Military Powers. Look at India,Nipal,Taiwan,Philippines ect.
Communist China 🇨🇳 end your baseless illegal claims on the Philippines 🇵🇭 ❤exclusive economic territorial waters. Respect your signature on UNCLOS and international maritime laws and rules! In 2016 arbitration awarded to the Philippines 🇵🇭 by the Hague tribunal court!!!Learn the Golden Rule!!!!PEACE!!!
*International laws* are very clear on the South China Sea: - parts of it belong to some ASEAN countries including the Philippines 🇵🇭, - the rest of it is the international water, - no part of it belongs to China🇨🇳 or Taiwan🇹🇼.
There was no such an "International law" or "international ruling" to begin with... it was a Court of Arbitration, which says on its own website that it's NOT AFFILIATED with the United Nations but only a third-party NGO. The PH government lied to its citizens by making it sound like a real international court in the UN that gave a verdict.
IF china will not abide to international law..... Then the International community will NEVER again abide to so called One china policy..... 👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎
China have no right to issuing summon or no one's can dictate to the Philippines sovereign rights, because it's a part of territorial waters, EZZ and jurisdiction area of the Philippines only. Please do not assuming your own illegal interests or etc. You are in trespassing with the real territory of philippines, and that's a fact.... Please clear you original map & just uses your original map. How many times or more to change your map? That Tibet country was bigger than your country, it's illegal & harassment or argument the territory of the other countries?
Philippines lost its sovereignty to USA in 1898. Japan seized the SCS islands during WW2. And unfortunately Japan surrendered those islands to China, not the Philippines, which was still a US colony in 1945. The US made no claim. In 1946, the Americans reminded the Philippines at its independence that the Spratlys was not Philippine territory, both to not anger Chiang Kai-shek in China and because the Spratlys were not part of the Philippines per the 1898 treaty Spain signed with America. China exercised control over them after 1945. So the territorial rights to the SCS features have changed hands several times. Philippines didn't show that it has consistently asserted territorial rights. China exercise the control of the features for around 25 years from 1945 and Philippines have been keeping quiet about it. After oil/gas was discovered in the SCS in 1969, Philippines started to challenge China’s claims of territorial rights over the SCS islands, after having kept quiet for around 25 years prior. What a coincidence. Philippines old 1799 map has been superseded by various events happening after 1799. When Philippines lost control over the SCS features for almost 200 years, it loses its territorial rights over them.
@@conti-vl6tx UNCLOS says otherwise. Just follow the existing international law. We don't care what MAP you are using if it is not recognized by 90% of the world.
@@conti-vl6txChina was not a country in 1945. China was a defeated poor country. Modern China led by CCP became a country in 1949. Philippines is a much older country compared to China. Have you not learn this in school. China school must be this bad or worst. Haha
@conti-vl6tx Your message, it's very fake & would not reliable source of informations. (Based of the following claims of other countries). It's ridiculous claiming & have no legal basis. The Philippines was first country & and it's real independent country before, the Spanish time era or colonized since 1521. Spain rename the Philippine name as what we called "De las Filipinas" and then all islands, cities, other names of philppines will change because of the Spanish time illegal occupation only. The source of information was given to the Philippines, although the names of those islands of the Philippines "rename the original names" but its the same also, China 2012 only, was claimed the spratly islands of the Philippines. (The real question is? How Tibet Country was an independent country & illegal occupied by China). The Tibet country was bigger than China? China was established as PRC. So therefore it's a not a country. It's organization. Please be research or reliable source of information. No need to share a fake news. Meanwhile the Philippines was established 709,000 years ago. And China was established only on 1912 under PRC organization. And illegal occupied more province and countries, like south Mongolia, East Turkestan, Manchuria as what their called "Beijing", Hongkong, Cantonian Island as we called "Hainan Island"(TIBET COUNTRY is bigger than China). No SCS. I'ts no legal basis according UNCLOS.
@truthmustprevailalwi The China Claims are not weak, the 9 dash line has a history which goes back to the period before many countries in south east Asia were independent. So some countries in South East Asia feel that it was unjust that their predecessor Colonial Powers, the Americans, the British and the French did not protect their interest. When Spain sold Philippines to US for $20M. None of the islands listed in the legal document. When PH files independent with UN, none of these islands listed in PH legal documents. In contrast, after Japan surrendered at WWII, UN and UN security agreed to returned all these islands to China. It is in UN record. Tibet was conquered by various parties such as the Mongols prior to the 20th century. In 1720, China invaded and conquered Tibet. Following the collapse of the Qing monarchy, various Chinese territories and local governments such as Tibet and Mongolia attempted to secede from China by unilaterally declaring independence in 1913. Only Mongolia recognised Tibet’s unilateral declaration of independence, whereas China n the international community did not. The attempt at secession eventually failed as the KMT and then the CPC sent troops to recover Tibet. The Tibet separatists surrendered and Tibet was reunified by China in 1950. The Dalai Lama today accepts Tibet as Chinese territory. Only some overseas Tibetan separatists are still trying to secede Tibet from China. Xinjiang was conquered by China in 1755. It also attempted secession after the Qing monarchy collapsed. The East Turkestan Republic was a short-lived satellite state of the Soviet Union in northern Xinjiang (East Turkestan), which existed from 1944 to 1946. Taiwan was conquered by China in the 17th century and ceded to Japan in 1895. In 1945, Taiwan was surrendered by Japan back to China via internationally recognised treaties. Most of China's territorial expansion, like Inner Mongolia or Xinjiang or the rugged mountain regions, took place when China was ruled by "foreign" dynasties, like the Yuan (1279-1368) and Qing (1644-1911). The story of Tibet is more complex. Tibet was first conquered by China under Mongols in 1244, but "enjoy[ed] considerable autonomy under Yuan Dynasty". In the many centuries since this initial conquest, struggles have ensued over Tibet's domination by the different Chinese governments, from the Qing to the republican government. It was only 1950 that Tibet was formally incorporated into the People's Republic of China. China's claims over Tibet therefore come with a highly contested history. This is a simplification of a rich and complex Chinese history, but the significant grain of truth is that for most of the past two thousands years, the Han Chinese have not been militarist or expansionist, despite the many wars they have fought, most of which were within China. UNCLOS the underlying dispute between the claimant countries since 1945 is one of territorial rights over the SCS islands. After oil was discovered in the SCS in 1969, Philippines started to challenge China’s claims of territorial rights over the SCS islands, after having kept quiet for 25 years prior. And UNCLOS is not the proper forum because it does not deal with matters of territorial disputes or to resolve issues of sovereignty, as that field is governed by rules of customary international law on the acquisition and loss of territory, which can be decided by the ICJ ONLY. No jurisdiction means no power to define the sovereignty rights over the disputed islands. If Philippines were serious about its claim, it would have commenced proceedings with ICJ and not a powerless UNCLOS tribunal. Besides, China had already opted out of arbitration by lodging an article 298(1) UNCLOS declaration in 2006, just as more than 40 signatory countries have done.
Firstly, if a Navy personnel is injured by a Coast Guard member, that doesn't sound very elite, does it? Secondly, yes, you have achieved results by directly undermining our sovereign rights!
Who started the provocations in South China Sea? _'Philippine warship (BRP Sierra Madre) personnels driving boats towards China Coast Guard and harassed them. Philippine personnels: "__0:25__ Hey, go away! go away, go away, Go back to China!" China Coast Guards responded: "__0:45__ THIS IS CHINA! Go back to the Philippines!" [Philippine personnels went back to the ship and hide inside warship]'_ *- China Coast Guard responds solemnly to Philippine personnel provocations, New China TV, Jun 21, 2024*
@@LivingLonger😂😂😂Pak urn China. Stop stealing territories. Steals land from India, Bhutan, stealing islands that belongs to Japan, Taiwan and stealing sea rights in Vietnam, S. Korea, Indonesia. C'mon now😂😂😂😂
@@LivingLonger Lmao, the ship & personnel are in the Philippine EEZ. Yet, somehow, China's coast guard keeps getting lost & ends up hundreds of kilometers from their coast, in another country's territorial sea. UCLOS & literally the entire rest of the world have agreed what China is doing is illegal. Bots writing fan-fiction & pretending to be victims, doesn't change that reality.
@@LivingLonger Determining who initiated the provocation depends on the perspective you consider. Both countries assert that the disputed area is theirs and are defending their sovereign rights. However, a significant distinction exists: one nation is acknowledged by the international community and upheld by international law, whereas the other lacks such recognition.
@@passportpropertygroup6962 which nation is acknowledged by the international community? Firstly, the Philippines dispatched BRP Sierra Madre, an old WWII-era warship, to invade Second Thomas Shoal, does that sound very elite to you? Secondly, Maps published by the National Mapping and Resource Information Authority of the Philippines (NAMRIA Philippines), clearly marked (118th degree meridian of longitude east of Greenwich) Scarborough Shoal (Huangyan Island, Panatag Shoal) as *outside the limit of the Philippine territory and confirmed is not part of Philippines:* The National Map of Philippines 2006 (1:1,700,000), The Map of The Philippines 2010 (1:1,500,000), Political Map of the Philippines (1:4,250,000) 2008 to 2011.
The Philippines keeps accusing China of “ bullying and intimidating smaller countries” without mentioning at all the Philippine occupation of and encroachment on China’s territory in Nansha Qundao. That is a real propaganda “trap”. On the issue of Ren’ai Jiao, it’s not the size, but the behavior of a country that determines who is right and who is wrong. Right after the Philippines deliberately grounded its warship on Ren’ai Jiao in 1999, which seriously violated China’s sovereignty, China made démarches to the Philippines, and the Philippines promised to tow away the warship several times. A senior official of the Philippine Department of Foreign Affairs made it clear that the Philippines had no intention of building any facility on Ren’ai Jiao and it doesn’t want to and will not be the first country to violate the Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea (DOC). But 25 years on, not only hasn’t the Philippines fulfilled its promise to tow away the warship, it has even attempted to send construction materials for large-scale repair and reinforcement of the warship in order to build permanent structures on Ren’ai Jiao. The Philippines has gone back on its words, and stirred up trouble to provoke China. This is not only breach of the understandings between the two sides on handling the Ren’ai Jiao issue, but also a violation of the DOC, especially its Article 5 on refraining from action of inhabiting on the presently uninhabited islands, reefs, shoals, cays, and other features. The Philippines is clearly responsible for the current tensions in the South China Sea. China and ASEAN countries have long been committed to properly managing and resolving disputes through dialogue and consultation between states directly involved, and worked together to jointly maintain peace and stability in the South China Sea, which has kept the South China Sea generally stable. But for some time, the Philippines has been pulling non-regional actors into the South China Sea affairs to back Philippine provocations and violation of China’s sovereignty. The Philippines has been pursing selfish gains at the expense of the consensus reached by countries in the region. This is the main reason why the situation in the the South China Sea has escalated and become more complicated. The Philippines need to respect the facts, observe the relevant understandings between the two sides and DOC provisions, follow the consensus reached between China and ASEAN countries, and return to the right track of properly managing and resolving disputes through dialogue and consultation as soon as possible.
Excerpt from a USIP article - It is worth recalling that in 2012, the United States chose to persuade the Philippines to withdraw from Scarborough Shoal (a separate set of features north of the Spratlys) while making no effort to compel the PRC to do the same. In effect, Washington forced Manila to cede that set of features to the PRC.
This is what the Permanent Court of Arbitration (which the Philippines often cited) actually says: "The Tribunal does not see that success on these Submission would have an effect on the Philippines’ sovereignty claims…" Even they themselves knew that it was just a show and cannot alter the reality. AND, every body knows that, any arbitration requires the consent and participation of the opposing parties. China never agreed to participate.
Singapore, the smartest country, as well as the most successful one in ASEAN, has been playing smart geopolitical balancing games between super powers for decades, for the maximum benefit of the country, without being squeezed and sacrificed as cannon fodder by the US or China. Filipino people always look at the success of Singapore with envy, and wonder why they can't replicate the best practices in their homeland and why their country is still deeply trapped in US colony mentality without a clear way out. Truth hurts. A smart leader plays smart geopolitical games and invites American and Chinese companies to build factories in order to generate jobs and increase revenue, while a clueless leader easily gets emotional like a kid, often is played by geopolitical players as chess pieces, invites foreign military to build bases in order to generate tensions and increase the risk of conflicts, and sacrifices the country's development and trade. Japan and S. Korea can sit down for negotiations and cooperations, despite of their long time disputes over the sovereignty of the Liancourt Rocks in the sea between them. That is political wisdom and diplomatic maturity on full display. Other countries such as China and the Philippines can definitely learn from S. Korea and Japan to manage their difference on South China Sea, Taiwan, MILF or whatever, and develop their relationship. Even the leaders of Vietnam and Malaysia are now much smarter, more resilient and pragmatic than P-Noy and BBM, embracing China's trade, infrastructure and investment with open arms, without sacrificing national sovereignty and dignity. Now the Philippines is the only ASEAN member that works as proxy for Uncle Sam in Southeast Asia, and puts itself into current awkward position of either losing face or losing opportunities for economic development. Soon, even Laos and Cambodia will become richer than the Philippines. The Philippines will only compare better than Myanmar.
Hope Philippines implement these laws with teeth. China propagandas and delusional bogus claims won't stop... Philippines should keep making more laws to protect it's sea and people to a hrmful leaders out there
The Philippines is strengthening defense alliance not only with its Mutual Defense Treaty ally the US, but also Japan, Australia, South Korea, UK, Canada, France, Germany and all like-minded nations to uphold the rule of law and freedom of navigation.
- Taiwan is not part of China (when I was in Taiwan, they don't want to be called Chinese, they want to be called Taiwanese) - Hongkong is not part of China (When I was in Hongkong, they didn't want to be called Chinese, they preferred to be called Hongkongers, and they preferred to sing "Glory to Hongkong" than the Chinese anthem) - Tibet is not part of China - Xinjiang is not part of China - Free the Ughyur People in China Camps in Xinjiang - Ughyur People are not Chinese - China must follow the UNCLOS Law - There is no such thing as South China Sea, it should be called Southeast Asian Sea - The 9-dash line is not valid and not legal - Spartly's Island belongs to us South East Asian Nation not to China - West Philippines Sea is for the Philippines not for China - Senkaku Island is part of Japan, not China - Socotra Rock is part of South Korea, not China - Aksai Chin is part of India, not China - Kashmir is part of India, not China - Arunachal Pradesh is part of India, not China - Do Not Trust China - Do not believe in China - China does not respect other countries - China will never be superior to other countries. - Small countries will never be inferior against China. - We will Fight China. - those who react and comment violently in my comment, it means I really hit you hard hahahah, you can't accept the truth, the fact and reality that China doesn't really follow the International law of UNCLOS.
"The Government of the United States of America acknowledges the Chinese position that there is but one China and Taiwan is part of China." *- Former US President Jimmy Carter speaks on the establishment of diplomatic relations with China on December 15th. 1978*
😅 you only want to display episode 2(China reaction) of this latest drama, but not episode 1(PH enacts laws asserting maritime claims). Trying to mislead the audience? episode 1: PH Action. 2024-11-8 Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. has signed two laws reaffirming the extent of his country’s maritime territories and right to resources, including in the South China Sea, where the new laws clash with Beijing’s extensive territorial claims. episode 2: China Reaction. 2024-11-11 China opposes new Philippine maritime law, release drawing of baselines around the disputed Scarborough Shoal in the South China Sea.
@happymelon7129 why didn't you mention the 2021 Chinese maritime law that led to the injuring of Vietnamese fishermen fishing in Paracel islands, a traditional fishing ground if both Chinese and Vietnamese fishermen?
latest drama or facts? 😝Maps published by the National Mapping and Resource Information Authority of the Philippines (NAMRIA Philippines), clearly marked Scarborough Shoal (Huangyan Island, Panatag Shoal) as *outside the limit of the Philippine territory and confirmed is not part of Philippines:* The National Map of Philippines 2006 (1:1,700,000), The Map of The Philippines (1:1,500,000) published in 2010, Political Map of the Philippines (1:4,250,000) 2008 to 2011.
@happymelon7129 Did the Philippines expand territory over which it is sovereign to help ("pawn") U.S policy of keeping the people in Asian poor? _"we(U.S.) have about 50% of the _*_world's wealth_*_ but only 6.3% of its population. This _*_disparity is particularly great as between ourselves and the peoples of Asia._*_ ..which will permit us to maintain this position of disparity without positive detriment to our national security..we should concentrate our policy on seeing to it that those areas remain in hands which _*_we can control_*_ or rely on..that _*_Japan and the Philippines_*_ will be found to be the corner-stones of such a Pacific security system"_ *- Foreign Relations of the United States 1948 Volume 1 Part 2.djvu/34*
Yah China is claiming almost 90% of the South China Sea what we Filipinos calls West Philippine. Their Basis is an ancient Map drawn in the 14th century Ming Dynasty it’s and the say they won’t recognize the UNCLOS the United Nation Law of the Sea ratified and implemented by UN in 1982 which they are signatories. If this is the case Italy can claim the whole Europe and parts of Egypt and Syria and Jordan in the pretext that they are once ruled and occupied by the Roman Empire k! An analogy to Chinas claims on what they call their own South China Sea with their 11 dash line. K
The U S had already accepted the the South China Sea islands belonged to the ROC. Singapore's ex FM George Yeo revealed that the US navy helped the ROC troops to occupy the islands during the civil war.
They punished their selves for claiming others teretory !, the world has already dived in the end of world wars for peace of mind of people in whole world,no claiming others teretory !!!
Its like asking first a permission before you enter your own house in exchange of no harm will be done to you, better like that than being hurt by trespasser. Clearly shows that the Philippines has no more choice than to give up or else violence might happen
With all you respect Madam reporter as well as your station! you are not telling the truth! that seas belongs to the Philippines within 200 miles Exclusive Economic Zone. don't you ever say it belongs to china,,, you just being rude!
This is belongs to the Philippines it is very near in phil. And very very far in China is China know how to compute that distance between phil. And China.?
China should teach the Philippines how to behave themselves. these countries in the region can't understand if you talk to them politely. sometime just give them a tough lesson, they would be more behavior for decades.
There is a lot of misunderstanding and misinformation about international law and the South China Sea. Below is something to help clear up the misconceptions perpetuated by the media and the Filipino government. I hope people will take time to read and digest it. This is important because the mistaken beliefs about international law and Philippines territory are significant obstacles to peaceful resolution of the SCS dispute. Thanks in advance: The UNCLOS treaty is about the maritime entitlements generated by undisputed sovereign territory. The treaty was never meant to be used to resolve disputes over territorial sovereignty. The South China Sea is a dispute about sovereignty. That is why 1. China exercised her legal right to not submit to arbitration and reject the 2016 PCA UNCLOS decision; 2. The PCA did not make any decision or express any opinion about the sovereignty of maritime features; and 3. The PCA did not rule that China’s sovereignty claims were illegal per se ( the PCA had no jurisdiction to arbitrate on sovereignty ). The PCA could not rule out a possible legal basis for China’s claims . Just as one cannot build a house on a poor foundation, one cannot construct sovereignty claims from a treaty about maritime entitlements generated from disputed territory. The Philippines is abusing the rights and procedures under UNCLOS. This risks delegitimising the treaty and damaging international justice. Sovereignty disputes were usually settled by military or economic might. We hope diplomatic negotiations or international law will be used to settle territorial disputes. However, arbitration over sovereignty requires BOTH parties’ consent; to date, a few sovereignty disputes have been settled by arbitration (eg. Pedra Branca & Middle Rock). To cite the 2016 UNCLOS arbitration as the basis for Philippines’ territorial claims contravenes the fundamental legal principle of state consent for arbitration of sovereignty under customary international law. Law-fare in the ICJ or distorted narratives in the court of public opinion will not get the Philippines anywhere; it will only harden China’s position and provoke more physical confrontation on the high seas. A pragmatic solution to South China Sea disputes embraced by several ASEAN members is to shelve their sovereignty disputes (ie agree to disagree) and pursue agreements of cooperation over South China Sea resources through quiet diplomatic negotiations. This approach, initially suggested by Deng Xiao Peng in 1960, has achieved some progress between competing claimant states. An ASEAN-flavoured analogy to explain the SCS dispute: 2 neighbours with mango trees are arguing about a fallen mango on the ground. They cannot prove which tree the mango fell from. Consider the 3 scenarios below: 1. The neighbours fight, accidentally smash the mango and no one gets to taste it; 2. The neighbours stop arguing and sit down to share the mango in peace; 3. One neighbour decides to ask the village crime boss for help. The crime boss’ thugs take the mango forcibly from the other neighbour. However, the crime boss likes the mango so much he decides to keep the mango, collect protection money and tax all future mango harvests from both trees for himself. Despite sovereignty disputes over maritime features, the freedom of commercial navigation and overflight enjoyed by all states in the South China Sea under international law has never been threatened. The South China Sea currently contains some of the safest and freest sea lanes in the world, with more than 100,000 ships and one third of the world's maritime trade passing through every year. Over 60% of China's foreign trade and energy imports pass through the South China Sea; peace and stability in the South China Sea is as vital to China as any other country. China’s interests lie in ensuring that these sea lanes remain safe and accessible to all. The UK & the US themselves blatantly defied the UN and ICJ rulings that affirm Mauritius’ sovereignty over Diego Garcia (which the UK took by force) for many years; they only recently negotiated a controversial settlement with the Mauritian government that excluded the original Islanders themselves to grant the UK and US another 99 years of occupation of Diego Garcia against the recommendations of the UN and ICJ court. Filipinos should also note the US herself has not ratified the UNCLOS treaty.
CHINA DID NOT SUBMIT BECAUSE CHINA KNOWS ITS CLAIM ARE ILLEGAL, IT HAS NO VALID PROOFS TO OWN THE WHOLE SOUTH CHINA SEA INLCIDING THE WEST PH SEA. CHINA'S INTEREST LIE IN ENSURING THAT SEA LANES REMAIN SAFE AND ACCESSIBLE TO ALL? THAT'S WHY THEY BLOCK FILPNO FISHING BOATS AND COASTGUARDS FROM SAILING IN THIR OWN WATERS? STOP BEING AN IDIOT, STOP SPREADING FAKE NEWS. THE LEGAL COURT RECOGNIZES THAT THE WEST PH SEA, NOT THE WHOLE SOUTH CHINA SEA, IS PART OF PH TERRITORY. HISTORICALLY, GEOGRAPHICALLY, LEGALLY, IT ALL FAVORS THE PH, IT IS NOT BASED ON IMAGINATION, GREED AND EXPANIOSIST IDEALS LIKE THE CCP. GET REAL! CHINA'S CLAIMS ARE AS FAKE AND AS UNRELIABLE AS THEIR WORLD FAMOUS, POOR QUALITY MADE IN CHINA PRODUCTS.
@@DavidFoo-kh4ri CHINA DID NOT SUBMIT BECAUSE CHINA KNOWS ITS CLAIM ARE ILLEGAL, IT HAS NO VALID PROOFS TO OWN THE WHOLE SOUTH CHINA SEA INLCIDING THE WEST PH SEA. CHINA'S INTEREST LIE IN ENSURING THAT SEA LANES REMAIN SAFE AND ACCESSIBLE TO ALL? THAT'S WHY THEY BLOCK FILPNO FISHING BOATS AND COASTGUARDS FROM SAILING IN THIR OWN WATERS? STOP BEING AN IDIOT, STOP SPREADING FAKE NEWS. THE LEGAL COURT RECOGNIZES THAT THE WEST PH SEA, NOT THE WHOLE SOUTH CHINA SEA, IS PART OF PH TERRITORY. HISTORICALLY, GEOGRAPHICALLY, LEGALLY, IT ALL FAVORS THE PH, IT IS NOT BASED ON IMAGINATION, GREED AND EXPANIOSIST IDEALS LIKE THE CCP. GET REAL! CHINA'S CLAIMS ARE AS FAKE AND AS UNRELIABLE AS THEIR WORLD FAMOUS, POOR QUALITY MADE IN CHINA PRODUCTS.
also need to follow agenda... 😅 just like this place only want to display episode 2(China reaction) of this latest drama, but not episode 1(PH enacts laws asserting maritime claims). Trying to mislead the audience? episode 1: PH Action. 2024-11-8 Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. has signed two laws reaffirming the extent of his country’s maritime territories and right to resources, including in the South China Sea, where the new laws clash with Beijing’s extensive territorial claims. episode 2: China Reaction. 2024-11-11 China opposes new Philippine maritime law, release drawing of baselines around the disputed Scarborough Shoal in the South China Sea.
In 1975, the secretary of state sent a msg to American embassy in Manila. He concluded that “the MDT commitments do not apply in event of attack on Spratlys”. So, Manila govt should have already known it all along that the SCS islands are not within the Philippine metropolitan region.
LMAO at this fantastical revisionist history. we’re all adults here….Please don’t insult us . There is ZERO misunderstanding by 99.5% of countries with membership in the UN!! NO countries support the mainland claim! This is Stone-cold fact that you cannot dispute. nice try though, half-dollar agent! 👏
I beg to disagree. Refer to the Velarde map, the first map that was made and first published in Manila in 1734 by the Jesuit Cartogrpher, the engraver Pedro Murrillo Velarde, Nicolas de la Cruz Bagay and the artist Francisco Suarez.The Spratly island was included.
@@felycacal3882 Maps published by the National Mapping and Resource Information Authority of the Philippines (NAMRIA Philippines), clearly marked Scarborough Shoal (Huangyan Island, Panatag Shoal) as *outside the limit of the Philippine territory and confirmed is not part of Philippines:* The National Map of Philippines 2006 (1:1,700,000), The Map of The Philippines (1:1,500,000) published in 2010, Political Map of the Philippines (1:4,250,000) 2008 to 2011.
@@felycacal3882 1734 was the Spanish colonial time. The U S granted independence to the Philippines in 1946 but did not cede the SCS islands to the Philippines.
To china stop inches ellegal Clem's to Philippines territory very clear according to the enternational law unclose award WPS is park of the Philippines 200 notecal miles EEZ respect the enternational should follow the rules of the sea.
Go Philippines! Support from Portugal!
@@kapamilyatalks5420 Go China support from Sentosa
@@kapamilyatalks5420 🫶
@@bobafett5757 Support China yourself.
You're good being Chinese Singks than Indian Singks.
@@bobafett5757 Sentosa bot
portugal or chile?
Go Philippines! Support from Chile!
@@kapamilyatalks5420 🫶
@@kapamilyatalks5420 loool dude duno Chile and Portugal is thousand miles apart 🤣
😢eeeeeeeeeeee 1:14 😊 1:14 😅😅r 1:14 😅
@kapamilya is a Tagalog word not Chilean. Poor Filipino even working in far away Chile.
lol, China sends their massive fishing armadas to places right off the coast of Chile and other South American countries to steal all their fish. They overfished their waters and now have to go half way across the world and steal fish from other countries. It's amazing that the world still puts up with China till this day...
Go go philippines. Support. From. USA
Respect the UNCLOS. That is the Philippines teritory
Go Philippines! Support from Sweden!
@@kapamilyatalks5420 🫶
Thank you. Chinese destroyed our corals and abused most of our sea life. They're taking not their own.
Vovospotted!
@@AlvinTe-h2p Unpatriotic ka.
Divisoria in Tondo, manila is dominated by Chinese businesses without giving receipts to buyers it means that their not paying taxes to the government
Absalutely correct.....
Our government should ban chinese from mainland china to come to philippines.
Paano ang nasa govierno alam nila Yan kapitan at mayor bulasa nila puno
NO ONE NO ONE ABOVE THE LAW REPUBLIC ACT.OF THE PHILIPPINES 🇵🇭 UNDER PBBM MARCOS JR. ADMINISTRATION ###✌
Go Philippines! Support from South Africa!
@@kapamilyatalks5420 🫶
@@kapamilyatalks5420 🫶
That is not your .. thats belongs to the Philippines 🇵🇭
Scarborough shoal does not belong to China. They should leave that Philippine Teritorry.
Scarborough Shoal was not a chinese name island? Therefore scarborough shoal or bajo de masinloc belong to the Philippines. That's a fact.
@@truthmustprevailalwi It's also not in Tagalog.
@@teogeorge2203it's spanish...its name during Spanish colonies it's in the velarde map..in 17 century
@rosalienota3405 So it justified that it doesn't belong to Philippines because most Filipinos cannot spell that word.
@@rosalienota3405china.map is from 1405 three hundred years earlier than urs 😂
Maps published by the National Mapping and Resource Information Authority of the Philippines (NAMRIA Philippines), clearly marked Scarborough Shoal (Huangyan Island, Panatag Shoal) as *outside the limit of the Philippine territory and confirmed is not part of Philippines* : The National Map of Philippines 2006 (1:1,700,000), The Map of The Philippines (1:1,500,000) published in 2010, Political Map of the Philippines (1:4,250,000) 2008 to 2011.
2035 to 2050 pilipinas na isa sa pinaka mayamang bansa sa asia.go pbbm
Respect the intl law. How dare you china .
The West can disrespect international law, but you are an idiot if you ask China to respect it. The Chinese Sea has belonged to China for hundreds of years, and the Philippines has only been independent for how many years.
With the new laws, the Philippines 🇵🇭 will be able to *board and arrest* Chinese vessels, maritime militias or Coast Guard, in the Philippines' EEZ that are not operating on the *defined sea lanes.*
Who cares what Philippines does or say?
Even the ASEAN didn't support her cause she is obviously a lapdog.
Let’s see if you have the balls to arrest Chinese coastguards!
If the phil. Authorities have the resolve and the balls it could happen.and there is one more thing ,money talks.
@@boogieman4170 Just wait..💪
Bot
Respect Phillipines Law👊👊👊
@francisoviedo9216
Self invented Pinos law. Haha..ha
What is pinos? @@jacku8304
@@jacku8304 china self invented 9 dash line, then later add plus 1 = 10 dash line... Haha..ha
@@value2860 Historical proof abound and able to keep intruders out. LOl...
@@francisoviedo9216 Why tell us why ?
Thank you all the Country supporting the Philippines WE AS ONE
Did the Philippines expand territory over which it is sovereign to help ("pawn") U.S policy of keeping the people in Asian poor? _"we(U.S.) have about 50% of the _*_world's wealth_*_ but only 6.3% of its population. This _*_disparity is particularly great as between ourselves and the peoples of Asia._*_ ..which will permit us to maintain this position of disparity without positive detriment to our national security..we should concentrate our policy on seeing to it that those areas remain in hands which _*_we can control_*_ or rely on..that _*_Japan and the Philippines_*_ will be found to be the corner-stones of such a Pacific security system"_ *- Foreign Relations of the United States 1948 Volume 1 Part 2.djvu/34*
@LivingLonger your not US your Chinese propandist And member of a demonic country
Bakit dini delete NYO reply ko Masakit ba Ang totoo Na ANG MGA CHINESE AY DEMONYO
Chinisevid a demon COUNTRY THATS ALL
@@LivingLonger Chinese bot need to behave
I believe it is high time for the Phil. government to kick out the chinese embassy in the Philippines.
Xi-jinping is Crazy president of China drawing map of China vs the original map of the Philippines West Philippines Sea Philippines Territory not China
It is US given it to China. 😆what a jealousy 😅🤣 _"The Philippines gained independence in 1946, but when nationalists within the Philippine government wanted to claim the Spratlys, their American advisors discouraged them. The Spanish-American treaty of 1898 made it clear that the western limit of the Philippine islands did not include the Spratlys, and the United States was not keen to carry the cost of a Philippine irredentist adventure that might bring conflict with Chiang Kai-shek's regime in China"_ *- Page 11 , War Or Peace in the South China Sea? edited by Timo Kivimäki. Contributor: Nordic Institute of Asian Studies (NIAS) 2002.*
@JEVETHArcosa the original map of the Philippines? 😆Maps published by the National Mapping and Resource Information Authority of the Philippines (NAMRIA Philippines), clearly marked Scarborough Shoal (Huangyan Island, Panatag Shoal) as *outside the limit of the Philippine territory and confirmed is not part of Philippines:* The National Map of Philippines 2006 (1:1,700,000), The Map of The Philippines 2010 (1:1,500,000), Political Map of the Philippines (1:4,250,000) 2008 to 2011.
China imaginary claim 10 dash line 😂😂😂😂😂
@@LivingLonger This is nonsense. The U.S. runs the world and makes the rules. If they say it doesn't belong to China, then it doesn't belong to China. The U.S. can break the rules because they make them. China needs to stop causing all of the world's problems and do exactly what the U.S. tells them or Trump will sanction China out of existence! 😂
Give it up, it's not yours, it's far from you
FAFO COLONIAL
Proximity does not equal sovereignty. Just because something is close to you, does not mean it's part of your country. The Philippines never had control over these reefs and islands, and it was never recognized by any other country. The territory of the Philippines has clearly been delimited by Spain and the US. The Philippines should stop being surprised that China does not accept its territory from being stolen by them.
@@conti-vl6txIt was never recognized? Do your research bro before commenting here
Far？我不知道你们那的基础教育里有没有地理课程，但是你可以去查一查，美国有一块在太平洋上的领土叫夏威夷。
@@vythryno. It was never recognized.
Hey CNA journalists! Please use "West Philippine Sea" instead of "South China Sea"when you report Scarborough Shoal as it is within the 200-mile exclusive economic zone of The Philippines and decided by the 2016 Arbitral Ruling of the United Nations Convention on the Laws of the Sea. Again, it is not disputed anymore as the Philippines and only the Philippines alone has the right to explore any resources in that area. Educate yourself and don't mimic the deceptive chinese narrative!
Disputes over land territories of natural islands are governed by general international law, not UNCLOS. The Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) in 2016 does not rule on any question of sovereignty over land territory and does not delimit any boundary between the Parties [1]. [1] PERMANENT COURT OF ARBITRATION - The Hague, 12 July 2016, PRESS RELEASE: THE SOUTH CHINA SEA ARBITRATION (THE REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES V. THE PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA). Page 1.
Oh come on. China president has the history of grabbing land. They are not content what they have year by year china land grab are to much becoz of there Military Powers. Look at India,Nipal,Taiwan,Philippines ect.
"West Philippine Sea" not found on world's standard map unless falsely printed in Philippines recently.
@@jacku8304What about thev10dashline of China is it in World Map?
Correct CNA west Phill sea will never be on SCS on china.. bullsit
We Filipinos stand and fight for our rights against aggression in the west Philippines sea
Communist China 🇨🇳 end your baseless illegal claims on the Philippines 🇵🇭 ❤exclusive economic territorial waters. Respect your signature on UNCLOS and international maritime laws and rules! In 2016 arbitration awarded to the Philippines 🇵🇭 by the Hague tribunal court!!!Learn the Golden Rule!!!!PEACE!!!
THE MODERN PIRATES AT IT AGAIN.
@@fkoff7649 It's for China to protect SCS since Philippines can't protect it against US.
@@teogeorge2203Chinese pirates
bobo pinoy go cry
@jocalibusohump Southern Philippines is infested with pirates, not China. You are either naive or ill-informed local.
@@teogeorge2203Pirates
*International laws* are very clear on the South China Sea:
- parts of it belong to some ASEAN countries including the Philippines 🇵🇭,
- the rest of it is the international water,
- no part of it belongs to China🇨🇳 or Taiwan🇹🇼.
Bot
@@lonewolf7992Chinese bot spotted
There was no such an "International law" or "international ruling" to begin with... it was a Court of Arbitration, which says on its own website that it's NOT AFFILIATED with the United Nations but only a third-party NGO. The PH government lied to its citizens by making it sound like a real international court in the UN that gave a verdict.
@ArabicReja973
is @Arneh-Raja973 > 5 Rupees troll from Dharavi slum.
IF china will not abide to international law..... Then the International community will NEVER again abide to so called One china policy..... 👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎
Subukan lang ninyo pasokin ang hindi sa inyong teritoryo
China have no right to issuing summon or no one's can dictate to the Philippines sovereign rights, because it's a part of territorial waters, EZZ and jurisdiction area of the Philippines only. Please do not assuming your own illegal interests or etc. You are in trespassing with the real territory of philippines, and that's a fact....
Please clear you original map & just uses your original map. How many times or more to change your map? That Tibet country was bigger than your country, it's illegal & harassment or argument the territory of the other countries?
Philippines lost its sovereignty to USA in 1898. Japan seized the SCS islands during WW2.
And unfortunately Japan surrendered those islands to China, not the Philippines, which was still a US colony in 1945. The US made no claim. In 1946, the Americans reminded the Philippines at its independence that the Spratlys was not Philippine territory, both to not anger Chiang Kai-shek in China and because the Spratlys were not part of the Philippines per the 1898 treaty Spain signed with America.
China exercised control over them after 1945. So the territorial rights to the SCS features have changed hands several times.
Philippines didn't show that it has consistently asserted territorial rights. China exercise the control of the features for around 25 years from 1945 and Philippines have been keeping quiet about it.
After oil/gas was discovered in the SCS in 1969, Philippines started to challenge China’s claims of territorial rights over the SCS islands, after having kept quiet for around 25 years prior. What a coincidence.
Philippines old 1799 map has been superseded by various events happening after 1799. When Philippines lost control over the SCS features for almost 200 years, it loses its territorial rights over them.
@@conti-vl6tx UNCLOS says otherwise. Just follow the existing international law. We don't care what MAP you are using if it is not recognized by 90% of the world.
@@conti-vl6txChina was not a country in 1945. China was a defeated poor country. Modern China led by CCP became a country in 1949. Philippines is a much older country compared to China. Have you not learn this in school. China school must be this bad or worst. Haha
@conti-vl6tx Your message, it's very fake & would not reliable source of informations. (Based of the following claims of other countries). It's ridiculous claiming & have no legal basis. The Philippines was first country & and it's real independent country before, the Spanish time era or colonized since 1521. Spain rename the Philippine name as what we called "De las Filipinas" and then all islands, cities, other names of philppines will change because of the Spanish time illegal occupation only.
The source of information was given to the Philippines, although the names of those islands of the Philippines "rename the original names" but its the same also,
China 2012 only, was claimed the spratly islands of the Philippines.
(The real question is? How Tibet Country was an independent country & illegal occupied by China).
The Tibet country was bigger than China? China was established as PRC. So therefore it's a not a country. It's organization. Please be research or reliable source of information. No need to share a fake news.
Meanwhile the Philippines was established 709,000 years ago. And China was established only on 1912 under PRC organization. And illegal occupied more province and countries, like south Mongolia, East Turkestan, Manchuria as what their called "Beijing", Hongkong, Cantonian Island as we called "Hainan Island"(TIBET COUNTRY is bigger than China). No SCS. I'ts no legal basis according UNCLOS.
@truthmustprevailalwi The China Claims are not weak, the 9 dash line has a history which goes back to the period before many countries in south east Asia were independent. So some countries in South East Asia feel that it was unjust that their predecessor Colonial Powers, the Americans, the British and the French did not protect their interest.
When Spain sold Philippines to US for $20M. None of the islands listed in the legal document. When PH files independent with UN, none of these islands listed in PH legal documents.
In contrast, after Japan surrendered at WWII, UN and UN security agreed to returned all these islands to China. It is in UN record.
Tibet was conquered by various parties such as the Mongols prior to the 20th century. In 1720, China invaded and conquered Tibet. Following the collapse of the Qing monarchy, various Chinese territories and local governments such as Tibet and Mongolia attempted to secede from China by unilaterally declaring independence in 1913. Only Mongolia recognised Tibet’s unilateral declaration of independence, whereas China n the international community did not. The attempt at secession eventually failed as the KMT and then the CPC sent troops to recover Tibet. The Tibet separatists surrendered and Tibet was reunified by China in 1950. The Dalai Lama today accepts Tibet as Chinese territory. Only some overseas Tibetan separatists are still trying to secede Tibet from China.
Xinjiang was conquered by China in 1755. It also attempted secession after the Qing monarchy collapsed. The East Turkestan Republic was a short-lived satellite state of the Soviet Union in northern Xinjiang (East Turkestan), which existed from 1944 to 1946.
Taiwan was conquered by China in the 17th century and ceded to Japan in 1895. In 1945, Taiwan was surrendered by Japan back to China via internationally recognised treaties.
Most of China's territorial expansion, like Inner Mongolia or Xinjiang or the rugged mountain regions, took place when China was ruled by "foreign" dynasties, like the Yuan (1279-1368) and Qing (1644-1911). The story of Tibet is more complex. Tibet was first conquered by China under Mongols in 1244, but "enjoy[ed] considerable autonomy under Yuan Dynasty". In the many centuries since this initial conquest, struggles have ensued over Tibet's domination by the different Chinese governments, from the Qing to the republican government. It was only 1950 that Tibet was formally incorporated into the People's Republic of China. China's claims over Tibet therefore come with a highly contested history. This is a simplification of a rich and complex Chinese history, but the significant grain of truth is that for most of the past two thousands years, the Han Chinese have not been militarist or expansionist, despite the many wars they have fought, most of which were within China.
UNCLOS
the underlying dispute between the claimant countries since 1945 is one of territorial rights over the SCS islands. After oil was discovered in the SCS in 1969, Philippines started to challenge China’s claims of territorial rights over the SCS islands, after having kept quiet for 25 years prior.
And UNCLOS is not the proper forum because it does not deal with matters of territorial disputes or to resolve issues of sovereignty, as that field is governed by rules of customary international law on the acquisition and loss of territory, which can be decided by the ICJ ONLY. No jurisdiction means no power to define the sovereignty rights over the disputed islands. If Philippines were serious about its claim, it would have commenced proceedings with ICJ and not a powerless UNCLOS tribunal.
Besides, China had already opted out of arbitration by lodging an article 298(1) UNCLOS declaration in 2006, just as more than 40 signatory countries have done.
Mabuhay Sir Gibo &PBM
Firstly, if a Navy personnel is injured by a Coast Guard member, that doesn't sound very elite, does it? Secondly, yes, you have achieved results by directly undermining our sovereign rights!
Who started the provocations in South China Sea? _'Philippine warship (BRP Sierra Madre) personnels driving boats towards China Coast Guard and harassed them. Philippine personnels: "__0:25__ Hey, go away! go away, go away, Go back to China!" China Coast Guards responded: "__0:45__ THIS IS CHINA! Go back to the Philippines!" [Philippine personnels went back to the ship and hide inside warship]'_ *- China Coast Guard responds solemnly to Philippine personnel provocations, New China TV, Jun 21, 2024*
@@LivingLonger😂😂😂Pak urn China. Stop stealing territories. Steals land from India, Bhutan, stealing islands that belongs to Japan, Taiwan and stealing sea rights in Vietnam, S. Korea, Indonesia. C'mon now😂😂😂😂
@@LivingLonger Lmao, the ship & personnel are in the Philippine EEZ. Yet, somehow, China's coast guard keeps getting lost & ends up hundreds of kilometers from their coast, in another country's territorial sea. UCLOS & literally the entire rest of the world have agreed what China is doing is illegal. Bots writing fan-fiction & pretending to be victims, doesn't change that reality.
@@LivingLonger Determining who initiated the provocation depends on the perspective you consider. Both countries assert that the disputed area is theirs and are defending their sovereign rights. However, a significant distinction exists: one nation is acknowledged by the international community and upheld by international law, whereas the other lacks such recognition.
@@passportpropertygroup6962 which nation is acknowledged by the international community? Firstly, the Philippines dispatched BRP Sierra Madre, an old WWII-era warship, to invade Second Thomas Shoal, does that sound very elite to you? Secondly, Maps published by the National Mapping and Resource Information Authority of the Philippines (NAMRIA Philippines), clearly marked (118th degree meridian of longitude east of Greenwich) Scarborough Shoal (Huangyan Island, Panatag Shoal) as *outside the limit of the Philippine territory and confirmed is not part of Philippines:* The National Map of Philippines 2006 (1:1,700,000), The Map of The Philippines 2010 (1:1,500,000), Political Map of the Philippines (1:4,250,000) 2008 to 2011.
Bully, that is, what it is.
The Philippines keeps accusing China of “ bullying and intimidating smaller countries” without mentioning at all the Philippine occupation of and encroachment on China’s territory in Nansha Qundao. That is a real propaganda “trap”. On the issue of Ren’ai Jiao, it’s not the size, but the behavior of a country that determines who is right and who is wrong.
Right after the Philippines deliberately grounded its warship on Ren’ai Jiao in 1999, which seriously violated China’s sovereignty, China made démarches to the Philippines, and the Philippines promised to tow away the warship several times. A senior official of the Philippine Department of Foreign Affairs made it clear that the Philippines had no intention of building any facility on Ren’ai Jiao and it doesn’t want to and will not be the first country to violate the Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea (DOC). But 25 years on, not only hasn’t the Philippines fulfilled its promise to tow away the warship, it has even attempted to send construction materials for large-scale repair and reinforcement of the warship in order to build permanent structures on Ren’ai Jiao. The Philippines has gone back on its words, and stirred up trouble to provoke China. This is not only breach of the understandings between the two sides on handling the Ren’ai Jiao issue, but also a violation of the DOC, especially its Article 5 on refraining from action of inhabiting on the presently uninhabited islands, reefs, shoals, cays, and other features. The Philippines is clearly responsible for the current tensions in the South China Sea.
China and ASEAN countries have long been committed to properly managing and resolving disputes through dialogue and consultation between states directly involved, and worked together to jointly maintain peace and stability in the South China Sea, which has kept the South China Sea generally stable. But for some time, the Philippines has been pulling non-regional actors into the South China Sea affairs to back Philippine provocations and violation of China’s sovereignty. The Philippines has been pursing selfish gains at the expense of the consensus reached by countries in the region. This is the main reason why the situation in the the South China Sea has escalated and become more complicated.
The Philippines need to respect the facts, observe the relevant understandings between the two sides and DOC provisions, follow the consensus reached between China and ASEAN countries, and return to the right track of properly managing and resolving disputes through dialogue and consultation as soon as possible.
Philippines claiming a disputed island with a rusty ship is hardly any international order.
Support Philippines 🇨🇦
Tama media kung mag report kyo gàmitin nyo ang katagang west philippine sea.
just go and conduct your patrol to a shoal ng legally yours. That's belongs to Philippines in history and international law.
Excerpt from a USIP article - It is worth recalling that in 2012, the United States chose to persuade the Philippines to withdraw from Scarborough Shoal (a separate set of features north of the Spratlys) while making no effort to compel the PRC to do the same. In effect, Washington forced Manila to cede that set of features to the PRC.
Be a professional Chinese government and stop stealing other countries territories and follow the international laws.
It's China territory
你家船在我家门口坏了然后你就说这片区域是你们家的海😂
This is what the Permanent Court of Arbitration (which the Philippines often cited) actually says: "The Tribunal does not see that success on these Submission would have an effect on the Philippines’ sovereignty claims…" Even they themselves knew that it was just a show and cannot alter the reality.
AND, every body knows that, any arbitration requires the consent and participation of the opposing parties. China never agreed to participate.
是菲律宾在中国家门口建国！古代中国太仁慈了，担心菲律宾的这些野人没地方生存，就指导它们建立了王国，并成为中国的附属国，早知如此，应该早点将菲律宾现在的国土纳入自己的版图！
@@瑞小爷nagtayo ka ng Bahay na Hindi sau ang lupa ang tawag sayo trespasser😂😂😂
Go phillippines from brazil
According to the Philippines, South Taiwan and North Malaysia are also part of Philippine EEZ.
China needs to behave
China is always well behaved
@@bobafett5757wrong..always stupid..at its highest stupidity.
@@bobafett5757huhhh are you blind or something.you’re so funny 😂😂😂
China only knows misbehave and that's their attitude..
@@bobafett5757China always doing too much
*China has every right to defend its sovereignty*
China has the right to occupy all the islands and all things on earth including moon
Pirate
Hello😂😂😂
WUMAO PIRATES
😠😠😠😠😠😠😠👎💪
Singapore, the smartest country, as well as the most successful one in ASEAN, has been playing smart geopolitical balancing games between super powers for decades, for the maximum benefit of the country, without being squeezed and sacrificed as cannon fodder by the US or China.
Filipino people always look at the success of Singapore with envy, and wonder why they can't replicate the best practices in their homeland and why their country is still deeply trapped in US colony mentality without a clear way out.
Truth hurts. A smart leader plays smart geopolitical games and invites American and Chinese companies to build factories in order to generate jobs and increase revenue, while a clueless leader easily gets emotional like a kid, often is played by geopolitical players as chess pieces, invites foreign military to build bases in order to generate tensions and increase the risk of conflicts, and sacrifices the country's development and trade.
Japan and S. Korea can sit down for negotiations and cooperations, despite of their long time disputes over the sovereignty of the Liancourt Rocks in the sea between them. That is political wisdom and diplomatic maturity on full display.
Other countries such as China and the Philippines can definitely learn from S. Korea and Japan to manage their difference on South China Sea, Taiwan, MILF or whatever, and develop their relationship.
Even the leaders of Vietnam and Malaysia are now much smarter, more resilient and pragmatic than P-Noy and BBM, embracing China's trade, infrastructure and investment with open arms, without sacrificing national sovereignty and dignity. Now the Philippines is the only ASEAN member that works as proxy for Uncle Sam in Southeast Asia, and puts itself into current awkward position of either losing face or losing opportunities for economic development.
Soon, even Laos and Cambodia will become richer than the Philippines. The Philippines will only compare better than Myanmar.
If china didn't behave Philippines will let UMS rent pagasa island and the rest island in escoda
You know the PLA nuclear submarine is prone to sinking right.
😂😂😂😂😂 you wish 😂😂😂
@PeacePeace-xw8wc it's not a wish but reality it's all over the news.
@@Budywieser 🤣🤣😂😭😭😅
Hahaa
We are still getting stronger, Can you see the example of ISRAEL vs IRAN? Small but terrible.
@@johnleyvlog8820 But in contrast for Philippines, she is poor and useless.
Through military means is the only way to resolved the issues in SCS!
2025 SCS will have drama.
$ad for PH.
DT : PH for trade.
XI : Price ?
@@happymelon7129 cry me a river china😛
所以菲律宾做好迎接中国军队的准备了吗？
@@hongqinyuan7534 yes... anytime. the question is.. are you prepared?
@@jonzkiecopy4267 中国军队就在黄岩岛，你们倒是派个人上去啊？
🇵🇭
CAN beat China？
Hope Philippines implement these laws with teeth. China propagandas and delusional bogus claims won't stop...
Philippines should keep making more laws to protect it's sea and people to a hrmful leaders out there
@angelosupsup3726
Then China will confiscate more guns and severed fingers.
It belong to philippines not in china...
We have no overlapping territories to Beijing.They have no territories in there at all to overlap with us.
leave scharborough shoal thats no yours!
Don't call it South China Sea. It was, it is, and it will always be West Philippine Sea
West Philippine Sea not Recognized. China's South China Sea.
China get out of Philippine territory
👏👏👏👍👍👍 china must continue to defend their SCS against Philippines and USA illegal intrusion.
🖕👎👎👎👎👎👈,,,defend to your bullshit country😅😅😅
Who say you have the right and what sovereign right do you have it's against international law but china still insist they have the right
Chinese Pirates strikes again
tanga strikes again
The Philippines is strengthening defense alliance not only with its Mutual Defense Treaty ally the US, but also Japan, Australia, South Korea, UK, Canada, France, Germany and all like-minded nations to uphold the rule of law and freedom of navigation.
- Taiwan is not part of China
(when I was in Taiwan, they don't want to be called Chinese, they want to be called Taiwanese)
- Hongkong is not part of China
(When I was in Hongkong, they didn't want to be called Chinese, they preferred to be called Hongkongers, and they preferred to sing "Glory to Hongkong" than the Chinese anthem)
- Tibet is not part of China
- Xinjiang is not part of China
- Free the Ughyur People in China Camps in Xinjiang
- Ughyur People are not Chinese
- China must follow the UNCLOS Law
- There is no such thing as South China Sea, it should be called Southeast Asian Sea
- The 9-dash line is not valid and not legal
- Spartly's Island belongs to us South East Asian Nation not to China
- West Philippines Sea is for the Philippines not for China
- Senkaku Island is part of Japan, not China
- Socotra Rock is part of South Korea, not China
- Aksai Chin is part of India, not China
- Kashmir is part of India, not China
- Arunachal Pradesh is part of India, not China
- Do Not Trust China
- Do not believe in China
- China does not respect other countries
- China will never be superior to other countries.
- Small countries will never be inferior against China.
- We will Fight China.
- those who react and comment violently in my comment, it means I really hit you hard hahahah, you can't accept the truth, the fact and reality that China doesn't really follow the International law of UNCLOS.
" full of sound and fury and BS , signifying NOTHING "
@@DavidFoo-kh4riball sheet meyo lantyaw ni.hahahha
@@DavidFoo-kh4ridavid meyoyong
知道了，让我我们来点实际的你现在可以拿着扫把进攻中国了，把你的梦变为现实🤣
"The Government of the United States of America acknowledges the Chinese position that there is but one China and Taiwan is part of China." *- Former US President Jimmy Carter speaks on the establishment of diplomatic relations with China on December 15th. 1978*
Chinese Pirate overlapping Asean Territory
😅 you only want to display episode 2(China reaction) of this latest drama, but not episode 1(PH enacts laws asserting maritime claims).
Trying to mislead the audience?
episode 1: PH Action.
2024-11-8 Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. has signed two laws reaffirming the extent of his country’s maritime territories and right to resources, including in the South China Sea, where the new laws clash with Beijing’s extensive territorial claims.
episode 2: China Reaction.
2024-11-11 China opposes new Philippine maritime law, release drawing of baselines around the disputed Scarborough Shoal in the South China Sea.
Just like showing 0000c-t -7 drama , but not what has happened before it.
@happymelon7129 why didn't you mention the 2021 Chinese maritime law that led to the injuring of Vietnamese fishermen fishing in Paracel islands, a traditional fishing ground if both Chinese and Vietnamese fishermen?
latest drama or facts? 😝Maps published by the National Mapping and Resource Information Authority of the Philippines (NAMRIA Philippines), clearly marked Scarborough Shoal (Huangyan Island, Panatag Shoal) as *outside the limit of the Philippine territory and confirmed is not part of Philippines:* The National Map of Philippines 2006 (1:1,700,000), The Map of The Philippines (1:1,500,000) published in 2010, Political Map of the Philippines (1:4,250,000) 2008 to 2011.
@happymelon7129 Did the Philippines expand territory over which it is sovereign to help ("pawn") U.S policy of keeping the people in Asian poor? _"we(U.S.) have about 50% of the _*_world's wealth_*_ but only 6.3% of its population. This _*_disparity is particularly great as between ourselves and the peoples of Asia._*_ ..which will permit us to maintain this position of disparity without positive detriment to our national security..we should concentrate our policy on seeing to it that those areas remain in hands which _*_we can control_*_ or rely on..that _*_Japan and the Philippines_*_ will be found to be the corner-stones of such a Pacific security system"_ *- Foreign Relations of the United States 1948 Volume 1 Part 2.djvu/34*
@@LivingLongerwhen paper tiger,always showing military but malnourished soldier😜😜😜😜😜
China literally this area FAR fr ur coastline...Also respect internatuonal law & order..Follow UNCLOS.
Yah China is claiming almost 90% of the South China Sea what we Filipinos calls West Philippine. Their Basis is an ancient Map drawn in the 14th century Ming Dynasty it’s and the say they won’t recognize the UNCLOS the United Nation Law of the Sea ratified and implemented by UN in 1982 which they are signatories. If this is the case Italy can claim the whole Europe and parts of Egypt and Syria and Jordan in the pretext that they are once ruled and occupied by the Roman Empire k! An analogy to Chinas claims on what they call their own South China Sea with their 11 dash line. K
What nations can stop Chinese Pirates??
the people of Chinese didn't follow of law about territory sea water the Philippines sea territory they want to take it even if it's not thiers
This is Phillipine Sovereign Area.
The U S had already accepted the the South China Sea islands belonged to the ROC. Singapore's ex FM George Yeo revealed that the US navy helped the ROC troops to occupy the islands during the civil war.
source: pulled right out of my arse
@@mercer865 Yeap....and it's no effort at all
Anothey liar telling a mythical story😂
😂😂😂
west philipines sea,..GOD bless pilipinas,..🇵🇭🙏
上帝有多少军队
They punished their selves for claiming others teretory !, the world has already dived in the end of world wars for peace of mind of people in whole world,no claiming others teretory !!!
I think foreign affairs might be receiving money from china….
Or maybe they are bought….
The Philippines don't have the ball to kick Chinese embassy out 😂😂😂😂😂, that's the reality 😂😂
ASEAN might kick the Philippines out.
Kicking an embassy out means severing ties permanently.
Ever wonder why Japan still has an embassy in China despite its past atrocities?
@GASIA-cw8iw That's a bit difficult to do if you are one of the founder of the association, unless that country violated the association rules....
Hahaha shame on you. I think you need to go back to school 😂
@@GASIA-cw8iwMalaysia has a change of heart. She will not support China anymore due to Chinas demand to remove the oil rig in Malaysia’s EEZ
That's a provocation.
#westPHsea
Stop china sea wps.😡
Congrats China sana palagan nyu palagi ang pinas
Congrats china nasa inyo na lahat ng lupain sa pilipinas.. masayang masaya at excited na mga pinoy maging province of china.. 😍
This is west philippine sea not china sea its a big mistake to understand😂😂😂
China crying like a baby 🍼
Its like asking first a permission before you enter your own house in exchange of no harm will be done to you, better like that than being hurt by trespasser. Clearly shows that the Philippines has no more choice than to give up or else violence might happen
SARA DUTERTE OUR NEXT PRESIDENT OF PHILIPPINES & SABAH SOON AT 2028
Go pro china
China you must think twice because phillipines are not alone🇵🇭🇺🇸🇰🇷🇯🇵🇬🇧🇮🇳🇪🇦🇮🇱🇩🇪🇨🇦🇦🇺🇹🇼🤔🤔🤔
With all you respect Madam reporter as well as your station! you are not telling the truth! that seas belongs to the Philippines within 200 miles Exclusive Economic Zone. don't you ever say it belongs to china,,, you just being rude!
Scarborough shoal is a teritory of philipines
Now Chinese Navy takes over control over the Huangyan island. Come if you dare.
We Pilipinos are willing to give our life to protect our Country i challence china to stop thier stupidy for we were not thier subject
Nasan n yung matapang n hindi susuko puro lng salita wala nmn nang yayari puro protest
This is belongs to the Philippines it is very near in phil. And very very far in China is China know how to compute that distance between phil. And China.?
Nasa teritoryo nang Pilipinas ang chinese ccg anyare sa bagong batas naipatupad sa pcg natin..
Scarborough belongs to the Philippines china os too far out.
China should teach the Philippines how to behave themselves. these countries in the region can't understand if you talk to them politely. sometime just give them a tough lesson, they would be more behavior for decades.
There is a lot of misunderstanding and misinformation about international law and the South China Sea. Below is something to help clear up the misconceptions perpetuated by the media and the Filipino government. I hope people will take time to read and digest it. This is important because the mistaken beliefs about international law and Philippines territory are significant obstacles to peaceful resolution of the SCS dispute. Thanks in advance:
The UNCLOS treaty is about the maritime entitlements generated by undisputed sovereign territory. The treaty was never meant to be used to resolve disputes over territorial sovereignty. The South China Sea is a dispute about sovereignty.
That is why
1. China exercised her legal right to not submit to arbitration and reject the 2016 PCA UNCLOS decision;
2. The PCA did not make any decision or express any opinion about the sovereignty of maritime features; and
3. The PCA did not rule that China’s sovereignty claims were illegal per se ( the PCA had no jurisdiction to arbitrate on sovereignty ). The PCA could not rule out a possible legal basis for China’s claims .
Just as one cannot build a house on a poor foundation, one cannot construct sovereignty claims from a treaty about maritime entitlements generated from disputed territory. The Philippines is abusing the rights and procedures under UNCLOS. This risks delegitimising the treaty and damaging international justice.
Sovereignty disputes were usually settled by military or economic might. We hope diplomatic negotiations or international law will be used to settle territorial disputes. However, arbitration over sovereignty requires BOTH parties’ consent; to date, a few sovereignty disputes have been settled by arbitration (eg. Pedra Branca & Middle Rock).
To cite the 2016 UNCLOS arbitration as the basis for Philippines’ territorial claims contravenes the fundamental legal principle of state consent for arbitration of sovereignty under customary international law. Law-fare in the ICJ or distorted narratives in the court of public opinion will not get the Philippines anywhere; it will only harden China’s position and provoke more physical confrontation on the high seas.
A pragmatic solution to South China Sea disputes embraced by several ASEAN members is to shelve their sovereignty disputes (ie agree to disagree) and pursue agreements of cooperation over South China Sea resources through quiet diplomatic negotiations. This approach, initially suggested by Deng Xiao Peng in 1960, has achieved some progress between competing claimant states.
An ASEAN-flavoured analogy to explain the SCS dispute:
2 neighbours with mango trees are arguing about a fallen mango on the ground. They cannot prove which tree the mango fell from. Consider the 3 scenarios below:
1. The neighbours fight, accidentally smash the mango and no one gets to taste it;
2. The neighbours stop arguing and sit down to share the mango in peace;
3. One neighbour decides to ask the village crime boss for help. The crime boss’ thugs take the mango forcibly from the other neighbour. However, the crime boss likes the mango so much he decides to keep the mango, collect protection money and tax all future mango harvests from both trees for himself.
Despite sovereignty disputes over maritime features, the freedom of commercial navigation and overflight enjoyed by all states in the South China Sea under international law has never been threatened. The South China Sea currently contains some of the safest and freest sea lanes in the world, with more than 100,000 ships and one third of the world's maritime trade passing through every year. Over 60% of China's foreign trade and energy imports pass through the South China Sea; peace and stability in the South China Sea is as vital to China as any other country. China’s interests lie in ensuring that these sea lanes remain safe and accessible to all.
The UK & the US themselves blatantly defied the UN and ICJ rulings that affirm Mauritius’ sovereignty over Diego Garcia (which the UK took by force) for many years; they only recently negotiated a controversial settlement with the Mauritian government that excluded the original Islanders themselves to grant the UK and US another 99 years of occupation of Diego Garcia against the recommendations of the UN and ICJ court. Filipinos should also note the US herself has not ratified the UNCLOS treaty.
A very clear and precise explanation of the situation here...if PH still do not get it than no use talking further
CHINA DID NOT SUBMIT BECAUSE CHINA KNOWS ITS CLAIM ARE ILLEGAL, IT HAS NO VALID PROOFS TO OWN THE WHOLE SOUTH CHINA SEA INLCIDING THE WEST PH SEA. CHINA'S INTEREST LIE IN ENSURING THAT SEA LANES REMAIN SAFE AND ACCESSIBLE TO ALL? THAT'S WHY THEY BLOCK FILPNO FISHING BOATS AND COASTGUARDS FROM SAILING IN THIR OWN WATERS? STOP BEING AN IDIOT, STOP SPREADING FAKE NEWS. THE LEGAL COURT RECOGNIZES THAT THE WEST PH SEA, NOT THE WHOLE SOUTH CHINA SEA, IS PART OF PH TERRITORY. HISTORICALLY, GEOGRAPHICALLY, LEGALLY, IT ALL FAVORS THE PH, IT IS NOT BASED ON IMAGINATION, GREED AND EXPANIOSIST IDEALS LIKE THE CCP. GET REAL! CHINA'S CLAIMS ARE AS FAKE AND AS UNRELIABLE AS THEIR WORLD FAMOUS, POOR QUALITY MADE IN CHINA PRODUCTS.
@@DavidFoo-kh4ri CHINA DID NOT SUBMIT BECAUSE CHINA KNOWS ITS CLAIM ARE ILLEGAL, IT HAS NO VALID PROOFS TO OWN THE WHOLE SOUTH CHINA SEA INLCIDING THE WEST PH SEA. CHINA'S INTEREST LIE IN ENSURING THAT SEA LANES REMAIN SAFE AND ACCESSIBLE TO ALL? THAT'S WHY THEY BLOCK FILPNO FISHING BOATS AND COASTGUARDS FROM SAILING IN THIR OWN WATERS? STOP BEING AN IDIOT, STOP SPREADING FAKE NEWS. THE LEGAL COURT RECOGNIZES THAT THE WEST PH SEA, NOT THE WHOLE SOUTH CHINA SEA, IS PART OF PH TERRITORY. HISTORICALLY, GEOGRAPHICALLY, LEGALLY, IT ALL FAVORS THE PH, IT IS NOT BASED ON IMAGINATION, GREED AND EXPANIOSIST IDEALS LIKE THE CCP. GET REAL! CHINA'S CLAIMS ARE AS FAKE AND AS UNRELIABLE AS THEIR WORLD FAMOUS, POOR QUALITY MADE IN CHINA PRODUCTS.
😂PH knew, but need to follow master agenda.
also need to follow agenda...
😅 just like this place only want to display episode 2(China reaction) of this latest drama, but not episode 1(PH enacts laws asserting maritime claims).
Trying to mislead the audience?
episode 1: PH Action.
2024-11-8 Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. has signed two laws reaffirming the extent of his country’s maritime territories and right to resources, including in the South China Sea, where the new laws clash with Beijing’s extensive territorial claims.
episode 2: China Reaction.
2024-11-11 China opposes new Philippine maritime law, release drawing of baselines around the disputed Scarborough Shoal in the South China Sea.
恭喜菲律宾不需要面对中国海警了，直接面对中国海军了😂
haha very funny you Chinese ccp
@@永不止步-r6o doldog ka
China should stop using the fairy tale map, instead use the actual map there you can see that china very far beyond of their territory claims😂
WEST PHILIPPINE SEA......
Conducted inspection in thier dreams😅😅😅
A drawing map is not a legit....😂
Malaysia sabbah is given by the brunei
Ukraine 2.0 in Asia.
Chinese bot
In you're dreams pirates,😜😜😜😜😜
In 1975, the secretary of state sent a msg to American embassy in Manila. He concluded that “the MDT commitments do not apply in event of attack on Spratlys”. So, Manila govt should have already known it all along that the SCS islands are not within the Philippine metropolitan region.
LMAO at this fantastical revisionist history.
we’re all adults here….Please don’t insult us .
There is ZERO misunderstanding by 99.5% of countries with membership in the UN!! NO countries support the mainland claim! This is Stone-cold fact that you cannot dispute.
nice try though, half-dollar agent! 👏
I beg to disagree. Refer to the Velarde map, the first map that was made and first published in Manila in 1734 by the Jesuit Cartogrpher, the engraver Pedro Murrillo Velarde, Nicolas de la Cruz Bagay and the artist Francisco Suarez.The Spratly island was included.
@@felycacal3882 Maps published by the National Mapping and Resource Information Authority of the Philippines (NAMRIA Philippines), clearly marked Scarborough Shoal (Huangyan Island, Panatag Shoal) as *outside the limit of the Philippine territory and confirmed is not part of Philippines:* The National Map of Philippines 2006 (1:1,700,000), The Map of The Philippines (1:1,500,000) published in 2010, Political Map of the Philippines (1:4,250,000) 2008 to 2011.
@@felycacal3882 1734 was the Spanish colonial time.
The U S granted independence to the Philippines in 1946 but did not cede the SCS islands to the Philippines.
To china stop inches ellegal Clem's to Philippines territory very clear according to the enternational law unclose award WPS is park of the Philippines 200 notecal miles EEZ respect the enternational should follow the rules of the sea.
Go Philippines ❤❤
West Philippine sea
West philippines. Sea. Belong to manila capital
English word in news english in sub title taxt cover the whole video what is the fact?
It's a liar Chinese Ccp😂😂😂😂