Shimano Twin Power FD vs XD || Which Should You Buy???

The twin powers in the Shimano lineup are some of the middle to high end reels they offer. With there being several different models of twin powers, it can be difficult to choose which one will be best. Today, I discuss the twin power xd and twin power fd so you can decide which one best fits your needs!
Sponsored and presented by: American Legacy Fishing and Outdoors:
www.americanlegacyfishing.com/
Get your first MTB Box for as little as $10 using code "CRANKIN"!
mtbfish.com/crankinwithchristian
Instagram:
@crankinwithchristian
Camera Gear I Use:
Sony a6500: www.amazon.com/Sony-Alpha-Mir...
Zeiss 16-70 F4.0 Lense:www.amazon.com/Sony-SEL1670Z-...
Rode Videomicro: www.amazon.com/Rode-VideoMicr...
DJI Mavic Mini: www.amazon.com/DJI-Mavic-Mini...
GoPro Hero 8 Black: www.amazon.com/GoPro-HERO8-Bl...
Gorpo Hero 8 Media Mod: www.amazon.com/GoPro-Media-Mo...
GoPro Hero 7 White: www.amazon.com/GoPro-HERO7-Wh...
Yolotek PowerStick: www.cabelas.com/product/YOLOT...
Joby GorillaPod: www.amazon.com/GorillaPod-Ori...
#Fishing #Kayakfishing #Bassfishing #Ohiofishing #Sports #Outdoors #Explore #Adventure #Kayak #MTB #MysteryTackleBox #AmericanLegacyFishing #ShopKarls

[@markkus1134]

Hands down I prefer the FD just got one

[@artificialslinger9730]

Nice video bud. Nailed everything on the head.
just so you know the FD came out In 2020 and XD came out in 2021. Which means we should see a new twin power ( FE ) in 2024. 💪🏼🔥
Also , bull Bay I believe has Sniper 5-10 should definitely check that out if throwing really small baits. That more limber rod will help you Toss them further and easier. Especially if using 5 to 8lb braid

[@giorgiokyr]

Hi there. Nice presentation! Do you know if I can put a 4000 reel spool on a c5000?

[@emnico6063]

Would you recommend the FD for catching GT's in shores?

[@Lord_Hiram]

Would you suggest the FD for trout fishing?

[@jimmyfaherty8588]

What reel cast’s longest, most accurate. And, are they made in Japan or Vietnam?

[@Victor-kt4fh]

Hello tp xd 4000hg good for 30g metal jig?

[@RF3seeker]

Max Drag 2500 shows 9kg 2500SHG shows 4kg... other than some gear ratio and capacity can anyone tell me which reel for trout trolling / casting.

[@samzilla1050]

Which would you get for fluke fishing from shore with like a 7 foot rod using jigs from 3/8-1/2oz possibly up to 3/4oz

[@CrankinWithChristian]

Definitely twin power fd

[@abrahamjoseph6707]

Any good recommendations for a good copolymer line to put on these reel?

[@CrankinWithChristian]

I don’t use copolymer on spinning reels. All spinning reels I use braid to a leader. But I have found vicious line to be great. There is vicious copolymer line which I use for some top water baits for casting Rees

[@fajarpujianto5712]

I have 2021 tp c 3000 xd

[@GregClaud]

Which of these would you recommend for throwing metal for spanish mackerel from the surf?

[@CrankinWithChristian]

Definitely the twin power fd!

[@GregClaud]

@@CrankinWithChristian Do you think it is as sealed as a Saragosa for example?

[@CrankinWithChristian]

@@GregClaud yes I’d say it’s actually better than the Saragosa. Depends on what weight of a reel you want though. The Saragosa 5k is going to be much bigger and heavier than a twin power fd 5k. I had a Saragosa before but ended up selling it. Great reel, but feels super heavy and bulky. I’d prefer personally to throw around a lighter, better built reel like the twin power fd than the gosa. They actually call the twin power fd the “baby Stella” too because of the similarities of the Stella sw and twin power fd

[@ryanhelou7881]

Twin power XD for sure you want the lightest possible reel for Spanish mackerel. Jigging all day can get tiering. I personally use the Vanford for Spanish i hate the feel of the vanford feels too much like plastic but i cant complain cause its so light it.

[@stripervince1]

For big stripers in fresh water, what's your preference ? . Big swimming plugs and lures no live bait. I'm debating on a slammer 4, twin power or a saltiga. Trouble with saltiga is they're all in japan and all beat to shit. Very hard to find a clean one. I don't want a new one, I'm looking for an older one

[@CrankinWithChristian]

Digitaka for the saltigas…. I got 2 saltiga 4k’s and love them. I would pick them over any others any day of the week

[@CrankinWithChristian]

Just realized you said old ones too. But definitely check out the new 2023 saltigas. They are great reels

[@Unplugged704]

2024 is out soon. Wonder how these compare to 24’ model

[@CrankinWithChristian]

Just put up a video unboxing and going over specs of the TP FD compared to the new 2024 TP!

[@gb_luring]

Which of them XD or FD you suggest for saltwater fishing using top water Lures and minnows? For seabass fishing?

[@CrankinWithChristian]

For those things, I mention in the video that I believe the twin power fd I’ll be best! I will have my buddy who fishes the twin powers everyday in salt water comment what he thinks tho!

[@gb_luring]

@@CrankinWithChristian thank you 🙏

[@artificialslinger9730]

@@gb_luring you can use any reel in saltwater. Majority of Shimano reels are technically classified as "freshwater" if you go look them up.
Technically both the XD and FD are classified as " Freshwater " but they are built with SOME saltwater components.
The Shimanos that are really " saltwater " are the SW series ( SW = saltwater )
The " Trick " to any reel rather it's " freshwater " or " saltwater " you have to do basic maintenance if not no matter which is they both will corrode and rust. As long as you rinse them off with freshwater after use , shake off the excess water , air dry for a few hours and then rub them down with some clenzoil they will last a lifetime.
Christian pretty much nailed everything on the head in this video. Having both these reels as well and I personally don't know how sea bass fight but if they are a heavier hitter let's say like a stripper and they will scream a lot of drag and bull dog a lot I'd definitely go with the FD as well. The XD will handle it , but it be more comfortable having that hagane body and that acr spool.

[@gb_luring]

@@artificialslinger9730 thank you a lot for your answer🙏 yes it is like stripped bass but smaller size. I understood that XD is ideal for more finesse fishing and FD is more durable than XD for heavier Lures. OK ok thank you a lot bro🙏

[@artificialslinger9730]

@@gb_luring You're Welcome. Yeah technically the XD is a finesse reel but I use it for just about everything at times. I do a lot of wade fishing so I have the option to take multiple combos with me. So I make sure I get reels that can do anything and handle some hard fights from time to time.
Been using Shimanos 18 years now and their reels have never disappointed me yet.

[@usmankooriyadan3979]

I love FD

[@surfninjafishing8297]

Love my xd super light and smooth

[@CrankinWithChristian]

It’s a sweet reel!

[@Unplugged704]

New 24’ TP FE or last TP SW…. Which is better?

[@CrankinWithChristian]

Haven’t used the sw, so not sure how that model is

[@stevensilva1350]

Just seen this video. I don’t have an XD but I do have the SW and FD twin power. I fish the north east for striped bass. For me the best, is going to be the FD because it was developed in mind with catching the biggest football sized tuna you could on a compact reel.

[@Amir-zx5xh]

New Vanquish or new twinpower for trout?Thanks

[@CrankinWithChristian]

I have no experience with either yet, but did just receive the new 2024 twin power in the mail last week. I have a buddy with both and he said hands down twin power is better.

[@jpt2026]

Where did you buy them?

[@CrankinWithChristian]

Check them out at American legacy fishing!

[@richardperez8113]

.5 ounces is literally nothing

[@thaniga304]

4:39 9+1 gear ratio and 10+1 gear ratio is the best shimano

[@bradwetzel3217]

not 9 to 1 or 10 to 1 ratio. 9+1 bearings and 10+1 bearings

[@derekthoirn3355]

gear ratio is 6.2.1 on the xd