I think there are lots of signs Ruby will come back as a stronger version of herself, probably after having spoken with her mom. 1. As soon as Yang asks what if she isn't Ruby anymore, we see the Herbalist come back as an evolved version of himself. 2. If Ruby actually changed to a different person with a new identity and everything, it would invalidate her journey, her pain, and her growth. 3. When the Blacksmith asks what if Ruby could be anyone, leaving Ruby Rose behind, her following behavior is not indicative of wanting to do that. She says she feels like her burden is heavy, and right now she's not cutting it, but becoming an entirely new person would only be a band-aid to that problem. She won't actually learn how to move on from this pain if she becomes someone new. She needs herself to grow. That's why she's hesitant to pick up any of the other weapons, until she sees Summer's. 4. She mentions wanting to have been the hero like those in the stories her mom used to read, and the Cat/Neo makes the observation that deep down Ruby still wants that. 5. "What are you?" was a thematic question in this episode, but it also alludes to the first episode of this season, when Little asked Ruby what she was. She had several answers, most of which confused Little, and Ruby herself began to question what she was as well. Changing into a new person once again nullifies the significance of that question. 6. We've been teased with Ruby remembering her mom a lot this season, but the payoff hasn't happened yet. That leaves two possibilities. One, she becomes her mom (unlikely, impossible, weird, and pointless), or two, she meets her mom (in some form) who helps her understand that she's exactly who she needs to be (or something like that), pointing again to a stronger version of herself. 7. They've created this decidedly real possiblity of Ruby becoming someone else, but if she comes back as herself, she will have chosen specifically to do that, which will make her stronger. It means more if she chooses this herself than it would otherwise, and it provides the avenue she needs for proper character growth. Trials produce endurance. 8. If they did have her become someone else entirely, now not only does the show have to deal with Salem and that side of its complex issues, now the show needs to have the rest of the cast accept it, move on, and get the audience to magically have a history and attachment to this new character in the fight against Salem. It seems clear to me that's not something this show can afford to do, and I think it's self aware enough to know that. It may not know other things about itself, but I think that's one that's a safe bet to rule out. Or maybe I'm wrong and I'll just give up after V9, along with many of the rest of us still sticking around.
@@yothatshizzle I've actually spoken with some people who believe that Ruby was a bad character from the start and that she needs to be erased for someone better to take the lead role. And you know what? They're all self-entitled dicks. The writing team knows what we want. They'll have Ruby the same as she was before, but maybe have her appearance somewhat changed to show that she has grown up a little.
can we just think about the fact that it effectively took Ruby committing suicide (from the perspective of the characters) for them all to go "oh yeah, maybe we have been a bit dickish and asking too much from a *literal child* " like, I love this show, but the fact that they get written as if they all have 0 emotional intelligence and/or empathy makes me feel like I want to bang my head against a wall.
TBF Ruby has consistently through out the show been the one to help and inspire them. She's struggled a couple times but has always seemed to bounce back easily. So the others have unfortunately taken her for granted but it's not entirely there fault. In Volume 1 Ruby told Jaune that being leader is about shouldering the responsibility of your teammates and letting them rely on you to keep moving forward. Ruby has long neglected her own mental state with the belief that she needs to always keep it together or everything will fall apart. WBY is definitely guilty of not taking notice sooner but Ruby has been actively trying to keep it a secret and much like real depression it's hard to know how someone is really doing if they refuse to open up.
Of course Yang loves and cares for Ruby. The problem is that the volume and episodes are too short and too few to really show more interactions and development. Not just with these two but every other character. How cool would it have been during volume 7 atlas montage, we see the teams working with each. This would be hilarious Yang with Nora teasing Jaune with those thirsty moms.
It's not really just the lack of time. Only minutes, both for the viewer and in story, passed between when they saw Ruby beaten on the ground before vanishing. Yang looks a little glum before having a big wide smile when comforting Jaune, not even a sad smile. That looks way off.
Nah, mate. There's been more than enough time since Yang returned in Vol. 5. The show even went out of it's way to set up a conflict between them in Atlus that leads to the group being split up--which supposedly got resolved once they reunited. But the writers wanted to push for the Bumblebee ship and have Yang focus on Blake instead. They sacrificed her time with Ruby for their relationship. That's part of why Ruby lashed out at them earlier.
0:32 I remember at Dante's Inferno; -in 2nd ring of Violence Layer.....who ended their own lives, theyll turn into trees of suffering.....forever in pain physically and mentally This is poetic, as ruby became a tree just like the trees of suffering
Soo, what are the chances that when Ruby comes back 'everything's ok again!' and basically sweep her entire emotional conflict under the metaphorical rug and instead treat this as Ruby getting a power up. Like, there's no conflict after she 'hatches' from the tree, she doesn't have any memory form of loss, she's no longer depressed or has any ptsd, or anything of the sort, nope! She's all better now! here's "classic" Ruby again!
I really hope this doesn’t happen, as it would completely erase her character development. While I don’t think she’ll suffer any memory loss, I’m hoping that her PTSD and depression are still a constant for her.
That actually interesting idea. Like imagine if Ruby will turn into herself from season 1 with zero memories of anything that happened during all this time. That wouldn’t be Ruby we all know now. Same goes for her friends. They all overcame their fears and problems and grown from that. And in contrast to them, Ruby will become “clean sheet". And then her friend would have to choice: return her memories and with them her traumas or leave her as she is.
The setup is wonderful for there to be lasting consequences of WBY’s emotional neglect of Ruby but CRWBY just aren’t brave and/or competent enough to execute.
You can’t. considering what Ruby is doing in that tree, it’s all emotional conflict in there. The only question is if it’ll be a team effort this time instead of Ruby emoting by herself again. If she doesn’t do it alone there will still be plenty emotional conflicts about Ruby changing drastically when they’re in Vacuo. Family drama galore, Taiyang might even punch Qrow for letting this happen if he hears about the presumed dead daughters.
Last episode ended with Ruby seemingly getting to talk to her mom again. Chances are she gets a pep talk that helps her come to terms with recent events, and maybe some insight on Salem, and she matures. Kinda like what happened in Naruto when he fought Pain.
@@mrjokerpt2.041 Doesn’t seem that way in the show with how they push Blake and Yang together with Ruby and Yang barely getting some time together besides a few scenes.
No kidding!! Not one scene ago she was in a giant group hug smiling brightly...like she'd forgotten she just watched her own sister commit SUICIDE Worse yet, there are people actually defending it. This FANDOM is whack
“We done everything we can” lol what? I don’t remember them doing anything or saying anything to ruby , she literally figures and fixes her self, none of them help her, it sucked how they just made ruby like well ok I’m good again , after all she went through, especially her so called sister who always got support from ruby but was to busy being gay to notice …
No matter what happens to Ruby when she comes out... they all need to apologize for taking her for granted and not being there for her when she needed them, especially Jaune.
Nah that goes both ways she did call the people Jaune lived with for decades imaginary right after to Jaune they died. Trauma isn't an excuse. Jaune struck back after being told his feelings didn't matter, long story short both deserve an apology.
@@kylescott9031 I agree with that whole heartedly. They both went through a lot. Ruby lashed out and said some things, and Jaune stuck back with some not so savory things himself. They both were in a terrible headspace at the time: it'd be nice to see them talk things out.
Your telling me!! Not one scene ago she was in a group hug, and was smiling brightly.. Like she had completely forgotten she watched her own sister commit suicide. Worse yet, there will be those who'll defend that
Yang has always shown concern for Ruby, she just never realized how deep her trauma went, and also circumstances often distracted her. Not to mention, were you watching the same Episode 8 as me or not?!
@@MrGksarathy You mean when Ruby ran off and all Yang did was try to pass blame to Ruby? Blake oversimplified it as being angry...but only Weiss and Jaune genuinely tried to empathize with her Even afterwards, Yang still tried to make a half baked excuse Just to avoid any sort of responsibility Just. Like. Raven. Adding insult to injury, not one scene ago she was in a group hug with her friends smiling brightly…almost like Yang had completely forgotten she'd witnessing her own sister commit suicide...
@@Scoonertuna You call asking why Ruby didn't tell her passing blame? Wth? I think Yang, as her sister and someone who raised her as a child, has the right to ask why Ruby didn't come to her or the rest of Team RWBY with her problems. Also, Yang may have been smiling in the group hug scene, but that was after they realized Ascension wasn't death, and right after they found her statue, Yang literally tried to get her out and expressed anxiety that Ruby wouldn't be Ruby anymore.
What will be Ruby's choice at the end of this Volume? What will she become? Whatever the outcome, fingers crossed something comes out so that she can deal with Curious Neo herself.
RT really shot themselves in the foot here. Literally anywhere they go its a double edged sword. If Ruby comes out the exact same person, it supports all the mistakes she’s made without consequences... If she is different and becomes what people need, then it tells the audience it’s ok to disappear and run away because what you are is worthless. Not only that, but Jaune's 30 years of regret is literally undone after one conversation with Weiss...
actually this whole volume was ruby facing both the consequences of her mistakes and that of everyone else’s. i know the show is sorta blaming ruby for everything right now but if you go back you see that it’s everyone’s fault. ruby only called the shots because everyone always expected her to have the answers / make the choices for them. in 6x2 you could tell she made her choice to ask jinn after and only because of her team’s hostility towards qrow and oz. throughout volume 7 she wanted to tell ironwood and seemed to be the only one other than oscar who was struggling to shoulder the burden of when to tell him when it should have been a unanimous decision. she only contributed the idea of using the staff for the evacuation plan but after seeing the hound she was completely hopeless and out of it while the rest of them put together the rest of the plan. if ruby comes out okay like nothing happens it’ll be a big slap in the face because she’s been the one to solve everyone’s problems and now even her own. wby might not mean harm to ruby but they too should face the consequence to not owning up to their own mistakes and allowing ruby to shoulder the blame alone. being a leader doesn’t mean you’re just some punching bag for your teams faults. team jnpr is a great example of what a team should look like even without pyrrha they were always there to pick each other up and when they fought they apologized and changed for the better.
Ruby changing is her accepting that not everything is her fault and she doesn't have to hold the weight of the world on her shoulders. She very likely comes out as a new Ruby, knowing that her successes and failures are what make her Ruby. She has tried so hard to be "the perfect huntress", now she will choose to be herself.
@@マヤ-u9z But it *IS* her fault. Ruby's the one who asked Jinn about Ozpin's secret. Ruby's the one who lied to Ironwood for no reason. Ruby's the one who went behind his back to sabotage the Amity plan... and then did said plan later anyway. I won't blame Ruby for the stuff they did in Argus, stealing an airship, destroying the mecha, blah blah blah, that's on Weiss. But most of the crap that happened was directly because of Ruby's choices. And even the stuff that wasn't, like Weiss not going back alone to Atlas to meet Ironwood and Bumbleby going to meet with Robyn, Ruby is still responsible for her Team in some fashion, that's what being the leader is all about. It's perfectly understandable that Ruby is sick of all of this.
i mean, there's probs a wacky magic reason and perhaps it's because the tree came to them the whole 'for the plot' thing can be pretty much justified entirely here given they're in fairy tale land
I feel like this season is very emotionally dead... like, I understand the emotional beats of everything, but all the characters just can't translate that emotion to the viewers, I mean this is RUBY, Yang's fuckin SISTER, and she barely reacts when she sees her both drink the tea and in this scene, yea she "cries" but that should be the minimum emotion for all of them.
Worse yet, when she ran off all Yang did was try to pass blame to Ruby, Blake oversimplified it as being angry... Only Weiss and Jaune genuinely tried to empathize with her Even afterwards, Yang still tried to make a half baked excuse Just to avoid any sort of responsibility Just. Like. Raven. Adding insult to injury, not one scene ago she was in a group hug with her friends smiling brightly…almost like Yang had completely forgotten she'd witnessing her own sister commit suicide...and NOW I'm expected to believe she always cared? I know they're gonna try to defend this from here to eternity but come on!!!!
I think she would never do such a thing because she owes Yang a lot. She can be sad, but from her point of view, she can never just go "I'M DEPRESSED" to a person who went through many things at such a young age to raise her
Friendly reminder yang almost died 48 hours before all this taking a blow meant for her sister. I repeat she was willing to die for her little sister 48 hours ago. I guess y'all just ignore that tho.
Not really, they foreshadowed this when Weiss looped. The tree comes when you’re ready to go there, not when you think you are. You can’t have something tying you to the Ever After if you want to leave or ascend (your purpose must be completed; Neo broke Ruby after the tree leaves appeared for her, she fed it to Ruby instead of taking her out) and you need something tying you to Remnant if you want to Go through the door. Ruby being at the tree meant the only thing keeping the group there was Jaune’s attachment to the Paper Pleaser’s village and him not accepting the tree until he sees the New versions being the same people at their core
@@pinkymii072 Everything and everyone is not above criticism. I'm a fan but I have the right to make jokes about a show's flaws... What are you gonna do? Doxx or threaten anyone or everyone who disagrees with you?
Yang: what if she isn't Ruby when she comes back out? Then that's your fault :3 should have been looking after your younger sister like a good big sister instead of chasing your own interests. (For context Yang is trash for straight up ignoring Ruby's pain and chasing after Blake hoping for a love intrest and Blake is trash because she chose a chick who barely knows her when she had Son another Faunus who knew her pain her backstory followed her to ensure her safety and nearly died protecting her. I'm all for LGBTQ but Yang literally hand NO redeeming qualities except for being around ALL the time. If I were Blake I would have been like look after your own sister before trying to get me to fall for you.)
Are you saying Yang isn't allowed to have her own interests and be her own person? Yeah, as her sister, she should've picked up that Ruby wasn't doing okay sooner, but come on.
@@fan-sy9fs you don't actually care about plot you just hopped on the stupid bandwagon like the rest of them dear lord go watch my hero academia or something
Hi past me i have a big SPOILER for you! Bad news: She DIDN'T get a re-design, she's basically the same and just went: "I don't have to change since my mom loved me just like i am so NO CHANGE AT ALL... Yaaaaaaaayyyyy, By the way Jaune returned to be young again and he did it because of a Deus Ex Machina, what a dissapointing ending.
@@Rei-Maoni also think everyone will get a new design in vol 10, if they will continue to make the vol 10. Im pretty sure they will tho i have plenty of reasons but im too lazy to type lol. Every after three volumes they get a new design, like in vol 1-3 she was wearing her og combat skirt and in vol 4-6 she got a new one (idk what it's called🥲) and in vol 7-9 she got her haircut, and atlas uniform which is my fav design of her. Im pretty sure they will change her, sadly cuz i love her design. (This is just a theory, opinion, thoughts, IDKKK 🥲🥲)
@@Samuel_Loegan Dude It Annoys me too think people like you, think Yang doesn’t care about Ruby, Newsflash SHE DOESN’T NEED TO HOLD RUBY’S HAND THREW EVERYTHING, if you just go back to V.1 Yang wanted Ruby to grow be her own person on her own. So I highly suggest you to Stop using the same BullShit Excuse that Yang is supposed to be Ruby’s Protector, and so what if Yang want to hang out with Blake so what, is Yang not allowed to live her own life? I swear some of you people will come up with an excuse on Yang being a bad sister and it really pisses me off.
Tf is up with Blake being so UwU? Blushing at a sad yang. What is this writing 😂 blakes changed too much. So clingy even with a depressed/suicidal team member. I dont get weiss and jaune suddenly being close either. Not abfan of ill timed ships. Whoever said bumbleby wasnt able to get canon in previous volumes cos it wasnt the right time is sorely mistaken, but even then christ, the characterisation/development is cracked. Tfw the MC and team relationships are being shafted over ships/pairs. Bruh.
Worse yet, when she ran off all Yang did was try to pass blame to Ruby, Blake oversimplified it as being angry... Only Weiss and Jaune genuinely tried to empathize with her Even afterwards, Yang still tried to make a half baked excuse Just to avoid any sort of responsibility Just. Like. Raven. Adding insult to injury, not one scene ago she was in a group hug with her friends smiling brightly…almost like Yang had completely forgotten she'd witnessing her own sister commit suicide...and NOW I'm expected to believe she always cared? I know they're gonna try to defend this from here to eternity but come on!!!!
@@Scoonertuna aye. It annoys me that Yang went out of her way to help a sleep deprived, depressed Blake back in V2, but god forbid that Ruby has that phase now after she confessed to Blake. Protective older sister my arse. Those two of all people should spot the signs better thab anyone else seeing as they had a phase l, Yang in V4 somewhat
Hey! Its the Herbalist! Nice look! As for Ruby... Couple of enhancements with the eyes, a straighter path she needs to travel on, and her semblance at the point where she can stop time? The list's good for her, and sometimes, a break from the world is all we need.
Can't wait for all this character development and Ruby finally acknowledging they've been messing up to be completely swept under the rug because "yay we can do anything! Back to forgetting the world is ending and mankind is almost extinct because of us! Maybe the writers will let us rewind time so all of our screw ups never mattered to begin with!"
Exactly! As long as they can forgive themselves they will be immune from any and all sort of prosecution ...And they'll all be found Not Guilty for crimes against humanity
"It's not a place you go, it's a place you know." Jaune believed that the tree was death, and refused to have anything to do with it. He tried finding other ways out. Once he saw the Paper Pleasers reborn as the Genial Gems, he accepted what the tree really was. That's all it took to get them there.
You know, a thought occurs. What if the Cat gets into the tree - and gets offered the same choice anyone else does. The ability to change to pursue what you want to be. And in becoming a person who can leave The Ever After and go to Remnant, the Cat becomes Neo and Neo becomes the Cat in truth - a new being born of the two who has their own motivations and drives, rather than the Cat puppeteering a broken girl? Someone driven to understanding others and seeing things as they are, rather than someone who lives amongst lies and loss and greed?
I think the Cat is beyond accepting and trying to better himself, otherwise he wouldn't be trying to use humans to get to Remnant. He's very similar to the Dwarf in the Flask (Fullmetal Alchemist).
@@calvinfujii5921 Ever notice in media whenever a character is Bi or Pan they're always in a relationship with the same gender as them? They always start off a series in a relationship with somebody. Come up and then they break up and then end up with someone who is the same gender...why can't we ever get a reversal of that?
Bro I don't know why but I think if Ruby came out killing people it might make her life a little bit easier, not to sound edgy, but to me she shows too much sentience to human enemies, but she ain't the problem exactly, what I'm trying to say is that no one actually has put their foot down. The only thing that made me happy throughout RWBYs old volumes from a couple years back is literally when Blake and yang killed Adam. This made me happy because they did not hesitate on taking his life, and made conclusion that he had to go or he was gonna keep chasing them. So something that that Ruby has never done was literally embrace reality until that one episode, and not only that, I hope I'm not the only one being able to see that Torchwicks Train of thought is becoming her own right?
you know, pretty sure they could have gotten to the tree ALOT faster by just all taking some reseTea and just chose to continue on as themselves. if everyone in the EverAfter just wind up right beside the gate, then this whole season coulda been skipped over. but thats just an amateur speedrunners perspective.
I Still Hate Jaune for coursing Ruby to Breakdown & Lashing out at her teammates / family. Even More I Still Hate him how he didn't apologize to Ruby for his harsh words at her & didn't come clean for killing Penny Polendina even apologize to Ruby for it too I'LL NEVER FORGIVE JAUNE ARC FOR BEING A HEARTLESS MAN 😡😡😡
It's called Having Nothing Better To Do. Sure some people hate it but they can't help but see where the story goes. But then there's people like Adel Aka who just laughs at every small detail including when characters are killed
@@star22sally67 I will admit that RT hasn't done the best job of showing Yang being concerned for Ruby, but there are "fans" who legit think Yang doesn't love Ruby anymore.
Okay, one scene...and it was for plot relevance...that's the only time they're "allowed" to be sisters. Let's not forget that past episode Ruby ran off all Yang did was try to pass blame to Ruby, Blake oversimplified it as being angry... Only Weiss and Jaune genuinely tried to empathize with her situation... Even afterwards, Yang still tried to make a half baked excuse Just to avoid any sort of responsibility Just. Like. Raven. Adding insult to injury, in this episode she was in a group hug with her friends smiling brightly…almost like Yang had completely forgotten she'd witnessed her own sister commit suicide...and NOW I'm expected to believe she always cared? I know they're gonna try to defend this from here to eternity but come on!
I really hope this doesn't end up becoming some bullshit power upgrade that Death Battle asked the RWBY writers to give to Ruby just so she can beat Maka from Soul Eater in her Death Battle
If the herbalist has proven anything, then there maybe a chance she comes out stronger than ever.( All we can do now is hope)
I just hope she comes back with her memories and personality intact. And maybe just a new haircut.
I think there are lots of signs Ruby will come back as a stronger version of herself, probably after having spoken with her mom.
1. As soon as Yang asks what if she isn't Ruby anymore, we see the Herbalist come back as an evolved version of himself.
2. If Ruby actually changed to a different person with a new identity and everything, it would invalidate her journey, her pain, and her growth.
3. When the Blacksmith asks what if Ruby could be anyone, leaving Ruby Rose behind, her following behavior is not indicative of wanting to do that. She says she feels like her burden is heavy, and right now she's not cutting it, but becoming an entirely new person would only be a band-aid to that problem. She won't actually learn how to move on from this pain if she becomes someone new. She needs herself to grow. That's why she's hesitant to pick up any of the other weapons, until she sees Summer's.
4. She mentions wanting to have been the hero like those in the stories her mom used to read, and the Cat/Neo makes the observation that deep down Ruby still wants that.
5. "What are you?" was a thematic question in this episode, but it also alludes to the first episode of this season, when Little asked Ruby what she was. She had several answers, most of which confused Little, and Ruby herself began to question what she was as well. Changing into a new person once again nullifies the significance of that question.
6. We've been teased with Ruby remembering her mom a lot this season, but the payoff hasn't happened yet. That leaves two possibilities. One, she becomes her mom (unlikely, impossible, weird, and pointless), or two, she meets her mom (in some form) who helps her understand that she's exactly who she needs to be (or something like that), pointing again to a stronger version of herself.
7. They've created this decidedly real possiblity of Ruby becoming someone else, but if she comes back as herself, she will have chosen specifically to do that, which will make her stronger. It means more if she chooses this herself than it would otherwise, and it provides the avenue she needs for proper character growth. Trials produce endurance.
8. If they did have her become someone else entirely, now not only does the show have to deal with Salem and that side of its complex issues, now the show needs to have the rest of the cast accept it, move on, and get the audience to magically have a history and attachment to this new character in the fight against Salem. It seems clear to me that's not something this show can afford to do, and I think it's self aware enough to know that. It may not know other things about itself, but I think that's one that's a safe bet to rule out.
Or maybe I'm wrong and I'll just give up after V9, along with many of the rest of us still sticking around.
@@yothatshizzle I've actually spoken with some people who believe that Ruby was a bad character from the start and that she needs to be erased for someone better to take the lead role. And you know what? They're all self-entitled dicks.
The writing team knows what we want. They'll have Ruby the same as she was before, but maybe have her appearance somewhat changed to show that she has grown up a little.
Bro im out of hope, got some to spare? Ill pay you back 💀
@@gokuandmario4ever what wrong with her current haircut?
can we just think about the fact that it effectively took Ruby committing suicide (from the perspective of the characters) for them all to go "oh yeah, maybe we have been a bit dickish and asking too much from a *literal child* " like, I love this show, but the fact that they get written as if they all have 0 emotional intelligence and/or empathy makes me feel like I want to bang my head against a wall.
TBF Ruby has consistently through out the show been the one to help and inspire them. She's struggled a couple times but has always seemed to bounce back easily. So the others have unfortunately taken her for granted but it's not entirely there fault. In Volume 1 Ruby told Jaune that being leader is about shouldering the responsibility of your teammates and letting them rely on you to keep moving forward. Ruby has long neglected her own mental state with the belief that she needs to always keep it together or everything will fall apart. WBY is definitely guilty of not taking notice sooner but Ruby has been actively trying to keep it a secret and much like real depression it's hard to know how someone is really doing if they refuse to open up.
i mean to be fair, they were all dealing with their own crap and if they actually were perfect you guys would probably complain anyways
@@pinkymii072fr
I think Ruby's gonna come back with the Elden Ring in her chest.
It’s like a Pokémon evolution.
Your Ruby has evolved into *RUBYGON OF THE GOLDEN ORDER*
@@jacksonscott3667 two words Graig blade
Wait… is that boss music I hear?
*Radagon’s theme plays in background*
Of course Yang loves and cares for Ruby. The problem is that the volume and episodes are too short and too few to really show more interactions and development. Not just with these two but every other character. How cool would it have been during volume 7 atlas montage, we see the teams working with each. This would be hilarious Yang with Nora teasing Jaune with those thirsty moms.
It's not really just the lack of time. Only minutes, both for the viewer and in story, passed between when they saw Ruby beaten on the ground before vanishing. Yang looks a little glum before having a big wide smile when comforting Jaune, not even a sad smile. That looks way off.
@@flamelover1746 true. But they gave me just chalked up too bad writing
This volume is terribly paced...Just. Like. All. Previous. Ones!!!
Nah, mate. There's been more than enough time since Yang returned in Vol. 5. The show even went out of it's way to set up a conflict between them in Atlus that leads to the group being split up--which supposedly got resolved once they reunited.
But the writers wanted to push for the Bumblebee ship and have Yang focus on Blake instead. They sacrificed her time with Ruby for their relationship. That's part of why Ruby lashed out at them earlier.
@@danielwilson7193 watch Celtic phoenix, fixing rwby. They give the perfect amount of time for everyone to grow.
0:32
I remember at Dante's Inferno;
-in 2nd ring of Violence Layer.....who ended their own lives, theyll turn into trees of suffering.....forever in pain physically and mentally
This is poetic, as ruby became a tree just like the trees of suffering
coming to the garden, *no sound, no memory*
@@tou22227 while you have the danse of your macabres
Soo, what are the chances that when Ruby comes back 'everything's ok again!' and basically sweep her entire emotional conflict under the metaphorical rug and instead treat this as Ruby getting a power up.
Like, there's no conflict after she 'hatches' from the tree, she doesn't have any memory form of loss, she's no longer depressed or has any ptsd, or anything of the sort, nope! She's all better now! here's "classic" Ruby again!
I really hope this doesn’t happen, as it would completely erase her character development. While I don’t think she’ll suffer any memory loss, I’m hoping that her PTSD and depression are still a constant for her.
That actually interesting idea. Like imagine if Ruby will turn into herself from season 1 with zero memories of anything that happened during all this time. That wouldn’t be Ruby we all know now. Same goes for her friends. They all overcame their fears and problems and grown from that. And in contrast to them, Ruby will become “clean sheet". And then her friend would have to choice: return her memories and with them her traumas or leave her as she is.
The setup is wonderful for there to be lasting consequences of WBY’s emotional neglect of Ruby but CRWBY just aren’t brave and/or competent enough to execute.
You can’t. considering what Ruby is doing in that tree, it’s all emotional conflict in there. The only question is if it’ll be a team effort this time instead of Ruby emoting by herself again. If she doesn’t do it alone there will still be plenty emotional conflicts about Ruby changing drastically when they’re in Vacuo. Family drama galore, Taiyang might even punch Qrow for letting this happen if he hears about the presumed dead daughters.
Last episode ended with Ruby seemingly getting to talk to her mom again. Chances are she gets a pep talk that helps her come to terms with recent events, and maybe some insight on Salem, and she matures. Kinda like what happened in Naruto when he fought Pain.
About time Yang remembered she had a sister
BeeS being forced on us made her that way.
She always remembered hater
I got a good laugh outta that one 🤣🤣
@@mrjokerpt2.041 Doesn’t seem that way in the show with how they push Blake and Yang together with Ruby and Yang barely getting some time together besides a few scenes.
No kidding!!
Not one scene ago she was in a giant group hug smiling brightly...like she'd forgotten she just watched her own sister commit SUICIDE
Worse yet, there are people actually defending it.
This FANDOM is whack
“We done everything we can” lol what? I don’t remember them doing anything or saying anything to ruby , she literally figures and fixes her self, none of them help her, it sucked how they just made ruby like well ok I’m good again , after all she went through, especially her so called sister who always got support from ruby but was to busy being gay to notice …
1:05 So in other words youve learned nothing and refuse to accept that you've done something wrong?
No matter what happens to Ruby when she comes out... they all need to apologize for taking her for granted and not being there for her when she needed them, especially Jaune.
Nah that goes both ways she did call the people Jaune lived with for decades imaginary right after to Jaune they died. Trauma isn't an excuse. Jaune struck back after being told his feelings didn't matter, long story short both deserve an apology.
@@kylescott9031 I agree with that whole heartedly. They both went through a lot. Ruby lashed out and said some things, and Jaune stuck back with some not so savory things himself. They both were in a terrible headspace at the time: it'd be nice to see them talk things out.
This is the only time Yang has shown any genuine concern for her freakin Sister this Volume and it pisses me off.
Your telling me!!
Not one scene ago she was in a group hug, and was smiling brightly.. Like she had completely forgotten she watched her own sister commit suicide.
Worse yet, there will be those who'll defend that
Yang has always shown concern for Ruby, she just never realized how deep her trauma went, and also circumstances often distracted her.
Not to mention, were you watching the same Episode 8 as me or not?!
@@MrGksarathy You mean when Ruby ran off and all Yang did was try to pass blame to Ruby?
Blake oversimplified it as being angry...but only Weiss and Jaune genuinely tried to empathize with her
Even afterwards, Yang still tried to make a half baked excuse Just to avoid any sort of responsibility
Just. Like. Raven.
Adding insult to injury, not one scene ago she was in a group hug with her friends smiling brightly…almost like Yang had completely forgotten she'd witnessing her own sister commit suicide...
@@Scoonertuna You call asking why Ruby didn't tell her passing blame? Wth? I think Yang, as her sister and someone who raised her as a child, has the right to ask why Ruby didn't come to her or the rest of Team RWBY with her problems.
Also, Yang may have been smiling in the group hug scene, but that was after they realized Ascension wasn't death, and right after they found her statue, Yang literally tried to get her out and expressed anxiety that Ruby wouldn't be Ruby anymore.
have you been watching the same show as me
What will be Ruby's choice at the end of this Volume? What will she become? Whatever the outcome, fingers crossed something comes out so that she can deal with Curious Neo herself.
RT really shot themselves in the foot here.
Literally anywhere they go its a double edged sword.
If Ruby comes out the exact same person, it supports all the mistakes she’s made without consequences...
If she is different and becomes what people need, then it tells the audience it’s ok to disappear and run away because what you are is worthless.
Not only that, but Jaune's 30 years of regret is literally undone after one conversation with Weiss...
actually this whole volume was ruby facing both the consequences of her mistakes and that of everyone else’s. i know the show is sorta blaming ruby for everything right now but if you go back you see that it’s everyone’s fault. ruby only called the shots because everyone always expected her to have the answers / make the choices for them. in 6x2 you could tell she made her choice to ask jinn after and only because of her team’s hostility towards qrow and oz. throughout volume 7 she wanted to tell ironwood and seemed to be the only one other than oscar who was struggling to shoulder the burden of when to tell him when it should have been a unanimous decision. she only contributed the idea of using the staff for the evacuation plan but after seeing the hound she was completely hopeless and out of it while the rest of them put together the rest of the plan. if ruby comes out okay like nothing happens it’ll be a big slap in the face because she’s been the one to solve everyone’s problems and now even her own. wby might not mean harm to ruby but they too should face the consequence to not owning up to their own mistakes and allowing ruby to shoulder the blame alone. being a leader doesn’t mean you’re just some punching bag for your teams faults. team jnpr is a great example of what a team should look like even without pyrrha they were always there to pick each other up and when they fought they apologized and changed for the better.
Ruby changing is her accepting that not everything is her fault and she doesn't have to hold the weight of the world on her shoulders. She very likely comes out as a new Ruby, knowing that her successes and failures are what make her Ruby. She has tried so hard to be "the perfect huntress", now she will choose to be herself.
But is the point not for her to become the person SHE wants to be
Jaune's regrets are absolutely not gone. He literally froze up when Cat turned into Penny and when Fake Pyrrha attacked him
@@マヤ-u9z But it *IS* her fault. Ruby's the one who asked Jinn about Ozpin's secret. Ruby's the one who lied to Ironwood for no reason. Ruby's the one who went behind his back to sabotage the Amity plan... and then did said plan later anyway. I won't blame Ruby for the stuff they did in Argus, stealing an airship, destroying the mecha, blah blah blah, that's on Weiss. But most of the crap that happened was directly because of Ruby's choices. And even the stuff that wasn't, like Weiss not going back alone to Atlas to meet Ironwood and Bumbleby going to meet with Robyn, Ruby is still responsible for her Team in some fashion, that's what being the leader is all about.
It's perfectly understandable that Ruby is sick of all of this.
"Why has the tree brought us here?"
The plot, that's why
To drink the Suicide Tea.
Lol. Pretty much.
I know people are gonna defend it, but the context and framing of the story cannot support this shift
i mean, there's probs a wacky magic reason and perhaps it's because the tree came to them
the whole 'for the plot' thing can be pretty much justified entirely here given they're in fairy tale land
I feel like this season is very emotionally dead... like, I understand the emotional beats of everything, but all the characters just can't translate that emotion to the viewers, I mean this is RUBY, Yang's fuckin SISTER, and she barely reacts when she sees her both drink the tea and in this scene, yea she "cries" but that should be the minimum emotion for all of them.
Thank you, someone puts into words why I feel this season, or at least the past 4 episodes have felt off to me.
Yang never act's like RUBY's sister, it was a dumb move to make them sisters to begin with.
Worse yet, when she ran off all Yang did was try to pass blame to Ruby, Blake oversimplified it as being angry...
Only Weiss and Jaune genuinely tried to empathize with her
Even afterwards, Yang still tried to make a half baked excuse Just to avoid any sort of responsibility
Just. Like. Raven.
Adding insult to injury, not one scene ago she was in a group hug with her friends smiling brightly…almost like Yang had completely forgotten she'd witnessing her own sister commit suicide...and NOW I'm expected to believe she always cared?
I know they're gonna try to defend this from here to eternity but come on!!!!
rwby critics when people can show emotions in ways they weren't taught
@@pinkymii072 ?
I wonder if there will ever be a moment where Ruby calls out Yangs shortcomings of being a sister
thats a scene they better not mess up, I wanna full 2 mins of Ruby roasting everyone
I think she would never do such a thing because she owes Yang a lot. She can be sad, but from her point of view, she can never just go "I'M DEPRESSED" to a person who went through many things at such a young age to raise her
@@cheesyborgor8394 I wanna see her go “I’M DEPRESSED” to *a* character though
Who cares
Friendly reminder yang almost died 48 hours before all this taking a blow meant for her sister. I repeat she was willing to die for her little sister 48 hours ago. I guess y'all just ignore that tho.
It feels like they just teleported there for the final act so the writers could pull this climax straight out of their asses. lol
Not really, they foreshadowed this when Weiss looped. The tree comes when you’re ready to go there, not when you think you are. You can’t have something tying you to the Ever After if you want to leave or ascend (your purpose must be completed; Neo broke Ruby after the tree leaves appeared for her, she fed it to Ruby instead of taking her out) and you need something tying you to Remnant if you want to Go through the door. Ruby being at the tree meant the only thing keeping the group there was Jaune’s attachment to the Paper Pleaser’s village and him not accepting the tree until he sees the New versions being the same people at their core
Some real Deus Ex Machina
no matter what they do you guys will ALWAYS be upset
@@pinkymii072 Everything and everyone is not above criticism. I'm a fan but I have the right to make jokes about a show's flaws... What are you gonna do? Doxx or threaten anyone or everyone who disagrees with you?
Yang only cares about Ruby when it’s “plot relevant”
I get the feeling this is supposed to be a touching/sad moment... but it feels so emotionally dead and pointless
Yang: what if she isn't Ruby when she comes back out?
Then that's your fault :3 should have been looking after your younger sister like a good big sister instead of chasing your own interests.
(For context Yang is trash for straight up ignoring Ruby's pain and chasing after Blake hoping for a love intrest and Blake is trash because she chose a chick who barely knows her when she had Son another Faunus who knew her pain her backstory followed her to ensure her safety and nearly died protecting her. I'm all for LGBTQ but Yang literally hand NO redeeming qualities except for being around ALL the time. If I were Blake I would have been like look after your own sister before trying to get me to fall for you.)
Precisly. They have no agency in this story other than ship bait
thank you for putting into words why bumblebee never seemed appealing to me lol
Are you saying Yang isn't allowed to have her own interests and be her own person? Yeah, as her sister, she should've picked up that Ruby wasn't doing okay sooner, but come on.
dear gosh shut up dude. have you ever even had a sibling?
@@fan-sy9fs you don't actually care about plot you just hopped on the stupid bandwagon like the rest of them dear lord go watch my hero academia or something
The Tree is Ever After’s own evolution.
I hope Ruby gets a re-design when she awakens, i never liked her current design, the previous one was better and the first one was the best.
I like her current design more than her Vol. 4 design. But if she does get a redesign, they should at least keep the hair, because it looks cool.
Hi past me i have a big SPOILER for you!
Bad news: She DIDN'T get a re-design, she's basically the same and just went: "I don't have to change since my mom loved me just like i am so NO CHANGE AT ALL... Yaaaaaaaayyyyy, By the way Jaune returned to be young again and he did it because of a Deus Ex Machina, what a dissapointing ending.
@@Rei-Maoni also think everyone will get a new design in vol 10, if they will continue to make the vol 10. Im pretty sure they will tho i have plenty of reasons but im too lazy to type lol. Every after three volumes they get a new design, like in vol 1-3 she was wearing her og combat skirt and in vol 4-6 she got a new one (idk what it's called🥲) and in vol 7-9 she got her haircut, and atlas uniform which is my fav design of her. Im pretty sure they will change her, sadly cuz i love her design. (This is just a theory, opinion, thoughts, IDKKK 🥲🥲)
0:40 So sad for Yang to see her sister, Ruby like this.😢😢😢😢
I would’ve done the same if I saw my own sister in that state.
About Time someone actually see that Yang worries and cares for her little sister Ruby. Unlike the most of those RWBY haters.
@@josephsuh5204 because Yang has been ogling with her cat girlfriend for most of the time than she is with Ruby sadly
@@Samuel_Loegan pretty much
@@Samuel_Loegan Dude It Annoys me too think people like you, think Yang doesn’t care about Ruby, Newsflash SHE DOESN’T NEED TO HOLD RUBY’S HAND THREW EVERYTHING, if you just go back to V.1 Yang wanted Ruby to grow be her own person on her own. So I highly suggest you to Stop using the same BullShit Excuse that Yang is supposed to be Ruby’s Protector, and so what if Yang want to hang out with Blake so what, is Yang not allowed to live her own life? I swear some of you people will come up with an excuse on Yang being a bad sister and it really pisses me off.
It’s fine, Yang! Ruby is just fighting Radagon so she can become Elden Lord.
Tf is up with Blake being so UwU? Blushing at a sad yang. What is this writing 😂 blakes changed too much. So clingy even with a depressed/suicidal team member. I dont get weiss and jaune suddenly being close either.
Not abfan of ill timed ships. Whoever said bumbleby wasnt able to get canon in previous volumes cos it wasnt the right time is sorely mistaken, but even then christ, the characterisation/development is cracked.
Tfw the MC and team relationships are being shafted over ships/pairs. Bruh.
Worse yet, when she ran off all Yang did was try to pass blame to Ruby, Blake oversimplified it as being angry...
Only Weiss and Jaune genuinely tried to empathize with her
Even afterwards, Yang still tried to make a half baked excuse Just to avoid any sort of responsibility
Just. Like. Raven.
Adding insult to injury, not one scene ago she was in a group hug with her friends smiling brightly…almost like Yang had completely forgotten she'd witnessing her own sister commit suicide...and NOW I'm expected to believe she always cared?
I know they're gonna try to defend this from here to eternity but come on!!!!
@@Scoonertuna aye. It annoys me that Yang went out of her way to help a sleep deprived, depressed Blake back in V2, but god forbid that Ruby has that phase now after she confessed to Blake. Protective older sister my arse.
Those two of all people should spot the signs better thab anyone else seeing as they had a phase l, Yang in V4 somewhat
@@Scoonertuna Why you getting so emotional over a show you clearly don’t even like?
Hey! Its the Herbalist! Nice look!
As for Ruby... Couple of enhancements with the eyes, a straighter path she needs to travel on, and her semblance at the point where she can stop time?
The list's good for her, and sometimes, a break from the world is all we need.
Yang stop! If you rush this, you'll only make it worse!
Can't wait for all this character development and Ruby finally acknowledging they've been messing up to be completely swept under the rug because "yay we can do anything! Back to forgetting the world is ending and mankind is almost extinct because of us! Maybe the writers will let us rewind time so all of our screw ups never mattered to begin with!"
I wouldn’t doubt it.
Who cares
@@mrjokerpt2.041 Obviously not RT.
Exactly! As long as they can forgive themselves they will be immune from any and all sort of prosecution
...And they'll all be found Not Guilty for crimes against humanity
Jaune was stuck here for years but never bothered to look in the most obvious place for an exit...
He thought the tree was evil.
And I love how 30 years of regret are literally undone after one conversation with Weiss
Remember the tree isn't a location it's a thought
"It's not a place you go, it's a place you know."
Jaune believed that the tree was death, and refused to have anything to do with it. He tried finding other ways out.
Once he saw the Paper Pleasers reborn as the Genial Gems, he accepted what the tree really was. That's all it took to get them there.
@@Scoonertuna he's literally still traumatized by what happened. He lost his fight against the cat because his regrets were thrown back into his face
You know, a thought occurs. What if the Cat gets into the tree - and gets offered the same choice anyone else does. The ability to change to pursue what you want to be. And in becoming a person who can leave The Ever After and go to Remnant, the Cat becomes Neo and Neo becomes the Cat in truth - a new being born of the two who has their own motivations and drives, rather than the Cat puppeteering a broken girl? Someone driven to understanding others and seeing things as they are, rather than someone who lives amongst lies and loss and greed?
I think the Cat is beyond accepting and trying to better himself, otherwise he wouldn't be trying to use humans to get to Remnant.
He's very similar to the Dwarf in the Flask (Fullmetal Alchemist).
Interesting...but just the idea sounds too much like invasion of the body snatchers.
Oh so now you care about Ruby, where were you when she needed you to begin with?
I don’t want to lose my baby…
1:43 I expected Blake to give Yang a reassuring kiss on the lips.
But that'd be gay!.... Wait a minute.... 🤣
@@SolusArmatura Well technically their bisexual so yeah. 🐝🐝🐝
Yup, they gotta keep giving us those BB winks even after they've confirmed.
@@josephsuh5204 I heard that Yang is actually pan.
@@calvinfujii5921 Ever notice in media whenever a character is Bi or Pan they're always in a relationship with the same gender as them?
They always start off a series in a relationship with somebody. Come up and then they break up and then end up with someone who is the same gender...why can't we ever get a reversal of that?
Bro I don't know why but I think if Ruby came out killing people it might make her life a little bit easier, not to sound edgy, but to me she shows too much sentience to human enemies, but she ain't the problem exactly, what I'm trying to say is that no one actually has put their foot down. The only thing that made me happy throughout RWBYs old volumes from a couple years back is literally when Blake and yang killed Adam. This made me happy because they did not hesitate on taking his life, and made conclusion that he had to go or he was gonna keep chasing them.
So something that that Ruby has never done was literally embrace reality until that one episode, and not only that, I hope I'm not the only one being able to see that Torchwicks Train of thought is becoming her own right?
Off topic but i noticed this small detail of Weiss's eye blinking movement if you do watch closely you'll see it too!
you know, pretty sure they could have gotten to the tree ALOT faster by just all taking some reseTea and just chose to continue on as themselves. if everyone in the EverAfter just wind up right beside the gate, then this whole season coulda been skipped over. but thats just an amateur speedrunners perspective.
I Still Hate Jaune for coursing Ruby to Breakdown & Lashing out at her teammates / family. Even More I Still Hate him how he didn't apologize to Ruby for his harsh words at her & didn't come clean for killing Penny Polendina even apologize to Ruby for it too
I'LL NEVER FORGIVE JAUNE ARC FOR BEING A HEARTLESS MAN 😡😡😡
1:29 whoa, what happened there?
Ascension
guys. Yang remembers she has a sister
Yep...but only when it's "plot relevant"
guys shut uuuppp
Don't worry, she's probably throwing hands with Radagon right now.
Spoilers for Episode 10, Ruby decides she wants Wings.
Proceeds to be reborn as Femto.
And then what?
She recreates the scene with Blake as Casca in front of Yang as Guts?
Me gusta mucho 😍😍😍
If y’all hate this show so much, why are you still watching it, let alone rewatching clips of it?
It's called Having Nothing Better To Do.
Sure some people hate it but they can't help but see where the story goes. But then there's people like Adel Aka who just laughs at every small detail including when characters are killed
@@sonicspeedproductions2.04 So what you’re saying is RWBY haters have no life?
No! Ruby! 😧
I think that branch hovering over her is crescent rose
Really…..it doesn’t look like crescent rose
Anyone who says Yang doesn't love Ruby needs to watch this scene.
One scene doesn't fix the main issue. The criticism isn't "Yang doesn't love Ruby" it's "Yang were not allowed by the writers to show concern"
@@star22sally67 I will admit that RT hasn't done the best job of showing Yang being concerned for Ruby, but there are "fans" who legit think Yang doesn't love Ruby anymore.
Okay, one scene...and it was for plot relevance...that's the only time they're "allowed" to be sisters.
Let's not forget that past episode
Ruby ran off all Yang did was try to pass blame to Ruby, Blake oversimplified it as being angry...
Only Weiss and Jaune genuinely tried to empathize with her situation...
Even afterwards, Yang still tried to make a half baked excuse Just to avoid any sort of responsibility
Just. Like. Raven.
Adding insult to injury, in this episode she was in a group hug with her friends smiling brightly…almost like Yang had completely forgotten she'd witnessed her own sister commit suicide...and NOW I'm expected to believe she always cared?
I know they're gonna try to defend this from here to eternity but come on!
@@star22sally67 Absolutely agree!!
@@galacticknight55544 I'm one of them.
I truly believe if it comes down to saving Ruby and/or blake, Yang would choose Blake 10/10 times.
This is all jaune fault
He pushed a big part of it.
??????
@@kenyaceesay4508 I'm talking about how Jaune pushed Ruby over the edge of the most.
Well jaune arc is a bully he should say sorry to ruby for being a bully
Jaune arc is a stupid Bully
I'm just hoping when Ruby comes back she rejects them all.
That would be funny lol
Finally we got Vacuo the last kingdom, we got Beacon, Haven and Atlas, finally after a filler volume we are going to Vacuo
I really hope this doesn't end up becoming some bullshit power upgrade that Death Battle asked the RWBY writers to give to Ruby just so she can beat Maka from Soul Eater in her Death Battle
She is definitely getting that axe.
THATS SOME BULLSHIT
Loving the love between Blake and Yang and Yang and Ruby. Romantic and familial.
Shame the latter had to be sidelined for the former.
Shame how the latter got 0 screen presence
Shame the writers forgot about the familial part and more focused on romantic.
FAKE
She will either accept her sister or become even more homophobic
Lmfao the writers had to figure out a way to make Ruby less homophobic so they did a mind wipe.
I find it weird how people are memeing about that when it's pretty clear she isn't and was just having a mental breakdown.
every insult is not automatically homophobic, quit the victim bs
@@Zwei22>memeing
@@Zwei22sigh, at this point, it's no longer funny. Hell I never found it funny to begin with
@@Droidsbane you're great, it's never a matter you can just simply joke around with
Ruby If Hadn’t Be Rough And Left Your Friends None Of This Would’ve Happened
Seeing how much bs sone stories are turning and all the transgenderism bs. She is going to come out as Ruben lol