Chris Hipkins: Climate and reprioritising government policies | Q+A 2023
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 มี.ค. 2023
- PM Chris Hipkins joins Jack Tame for Q+A’s first interview with him of the year, to discuss the response to recent climate-related weather events, climate change, the reprioritisation of government policies, co-governance, and China.
Subscribe to Q+A: bit.ly/QandASubscribe
Join Jack Tame and the Q+A team and find the answers to the questions that matter. Made with the support of NZ on Air.
WATCH SUNDAY 9AM ON TVNZ1 OR CATCH UP ON DEMAND: www.tvnz.co.nz/shows/q-and-a/
FOLLOW Q+A ON SOCIAL MEDIA
Facebook: / nzqanda
Twitter: / nzqanda
For stories that matter to you and the very latest from Aotearoa and around the world: 1News.co.nz/
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA GF D2 | Summer | ร่วมส่งแรงใจ เชียร์ไทยไปพร้อมกัน](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dN2gLsCJ0T0/mqdefault.jpg)
Hipkins comes across as someone a judge would describe as “ An unreliable witness”
We need more Jack. He’s really grown in the role.
I am not sure why Jack Tame wasted time on a minor subject that reduction in fuel tax for a 6 months would increase in emissions. I agree with Chris Hipkins, that there would a slight increase but over haul it will be almost the same if there was no reduction in fuel tax. The purpose of the reduction in fuel tax was due to the 'cost of living' crisis to help struggling. At least Chris Hipkins is more genuine in his responses than Christopher Luxon is.
At least Chris luxon understands the difference between overall and over-haul
@@overover.. - Are you sure the Luxon understands the difference between overall and over-haul, as his party is supports 'more profit at least costs' neoliberal economics and governance.
@@Anony_mouse2 - I am not sure what your point is?
Asking about fuel taxes and reducing emissions is hardly a "minor subject" if we take the risks of cimate change seriously - as we have been advised to by panels of scientists for over three decades. If PM Hipkins had done his (or his advisers) homework, he would have known from Jack Tame's persistent questioning of National Minister for Climate Change Paula Bennett in 2016 that Tame would be also very persistent about climate change and reducing emissions of greenhouse gases.
@@chrismckellar9350 Labour or National, left or right wing are both the same Vulture.
Where is Jack Tame's evidence that the cyclone would have been prevented by reducing our emissions?
There is none...0 nada👌🏼
Good question!
You do know what an increase in ghg emissions can cause right?
Jack went in with a predetermined plan to get a "gotcha" with the emissions line of questions and wasn't able to pivot when his line of questioning wasn't going well
Ok so I love jacks interviews but this was a bit off.
I totally believe we need to do more for climate change but lower gas prices aren't the problem. We need more people swapping but some people can't but still have to get to places
Why do you think Carbon is bad?
Newsflash, it's necessary for life.
The climate isn't changing g because of Carbon. It's changing like it has for millennia, and there is no crisis.
Increase in emissions. The regions hardest hit by the cyclone include people from a low-socio economic background and those who need physical & financial support. Keeping things like petrol at low cost will ensure these people & anyone involved with clearing/cleaning/support can do what they need to do to help them return to a sense of normality.
Not to mention our fuel price is not the driver of global climate change
Jack needs to go back to school again if he has to ask loaded questions that are factually incorrect to start with how the hell do u think we are going to get anywhere if Hopkins hasent got a clue anyway whats the point in the interview anyway I think Food is more important than Co2 anyway and to say co2 is a bad thing overall is factually incorrect.
Thank you! Finally someone gets it. CO² is a life-giving gas. It's necessary, not harmful.
@@Not_A_Cat And that's a fact.
@@Matthew-zv8qe well the planet has got 15% greener in the last 15 years the clouds and water vapor has alot to do with climate green houses pump about 1000 parts per million into there set up to make the plants grow bigger and stronger and they shed less water so the planet has been getting greener in more harsh environments so thats positive before humans arrived the co2 in the atmosphere was around 1000 to 1200 parts per million thats why the earth took off in regards to greening the more greener the planet the more life in regards to animals etc the oceans need co2 because it keeps the water from becoming more acidic thus more life the great barrier reef is not dying its growing but main stream media don't talk about that ocean level rise is a slow process the oceans have been alot high in the past so we are at about 400 parts per million if it drops down 170 parts million that it its over no plants trees animals fish ... so this Net Zero theory developed by the Elites is total rubbish the 🌎 isn't coming to an End weve got some issues to sort out the word doesn't Green doesn't actually mean its green yes the climate changes thats what it does its just another scare tactic for power and control. 😎
I think Jack did a great job with his questions in regards to getting any form of accountability from the PM.
I think the co governance questioning was great but Chris seemed determined to not admit it's not democratic.
Tames pursuing this inane line of questioning tells me the man's a fool.
Our emissions are so low!!!! Get China and India to do their big
Chippy the Chihuahua ... Cant wait to vote him out
You'll be waiting a very long time as hes 35% most trusted PM and Lux Flake is minus 2
Wow. Tone deaf questions about greenhouse gases in the middle of a cost of living crisis.
Jack is a good interviewer, but I think he needs to acknowledge we are a fossil fuel dependent society, both in our light and heavy vehicle fleets.
The cost of fuel doesn’t just impact individual commuters but the entire supply chain.
Putting pressure on families at the pump or at the checkout (etc) doesn’t help further our transition.
I beg to differ - iike too many young interviewers he lacks the ability to take his ego out of the equation!!
And that's what needs to change though, our reliability on fossil fuels; however, I do think, transiently, the cost of living crisis should be of paramount priority, for now anyway. At least Chris is still going ahead with the imminent light rail project in Auckland (the city with the most transport carbon emissions). However, money needs to be put into the improvement of public transport so more people are encouraged to use it. It's already been proven that people being encouraged to use public transportation significantly reduced transport carbon emissions. I like Hipkins a lot better than Luxon, but maybe Hipkins should cut other pathetic spending that only benefits greedy businesses, like the corporate welfare scheme. Cut that and use that money to keep the clean car scheme in place! That way, people who ACTUALLY are financially struggling won't be negatively impacted, along with the climate.
@@tracygrant7931 what makes you think carbon is bad? Serious question, has anyone ever explained how carbon effect climate?
Cos it DOESN'T. CO² is the gift from God to create life on earth. It's NECESSARY, and the current levels are too low.
@@Not_A_Cat ahhhh carbon dioxide blocks the sun's heat from escaping the earth's atmosphere lol. You didn't know that? The excess increase in carbon dioxide is due to fossil fuels that emit carbon, and it is too much for plants to absorb. Not to mention the gargantuan number of deaths that occur because of fossil fuel emissions.
You obviously don’t understand the experts advice in the paper to cabinet.
Why don’t you stop driving and flying Jack Tame?
NZ celebrates freedom of all religions except rastafarianism... blaze it Jah Jah bless..
A 1 to 2% increase in driving is only going to see a 1 to 2% increase in greenhouse gases... For New Zealand
The overall effect that that will have on major weather events is rather insignificant. Switching the measurement technique from percentage to tons was only done to create confusion, and the uptake of public transportation being labeled as insignificant without any percentage as useful only for arguing one's case that the tax should have been implemented. Only problem is I don't think Jack actually believes that, Jack is only in this to win arguments. Is incredibly difficult to listen to.
Comments are turned off.learn more
This is why the change will happen in October thank God, woeful stuff all the way round. This country needs its 'kiwi commonsense' grounding put back in place pronto.
I like to look at climate change in a tactical way, to address this issue, over all, by breaking it into sections as it is a global issue in so many different areas.
This section that I will call the "bucket section", is what has happen to this country New Zealand.
Basically there is more water in the oceans of the world evaporating into the atmosphere forming clouds and drops it, that is destroying everything that preserves society and it is going to get to be a bigger issue than it is now.
We have no choice but to experiment or be wipe out...
Being tactical is the key for example: The ocean is calculated as flat with hot and cold air then mix together create wind, which create ocean swells, that can range from 1 meter to 50 meter+ swells that hold the clouds at a fix height where the moisture of the cloud reaches its limit which is pick up by satellites that can only travel 2 to 3 hundred KM and as an island like NZ or any coast line annoys its path of the storms set height, the moisture builds up more before it drops it causing hardship for many years of which societies will not have these years to rebuild before the next hit.
So basically we need to hit these rain clouds before they hit land fall which should cut the rain fall by a good 45% and this is just of the top of my head of which I think the NZ.Air Force should stick in there Mind Bucket because it wouldn't take much to burst these clouds I hope as the coast line annoys the storm/clouds heights.
And these bad attitudes going around gives nz a really bad look...stay focus cause it has only just started...this could change the world, without changing it because you still get hit by the storm but it compensates for climate change in this section of climate change "Bucket Section".
NZ contributes sfa to global emissions so give the peeps of NZ a break, as the government is trying to do!
What's the situation with clean water for everyone, solar panels on roofs, wind generated energy on and offshore? Wish those questions had been addressed instead of the interviewer banging on about petrol fuel in cars.
Many Thanks Jack and PM for a useful discussion
If 80% of us approve why is Jack stuck on that line of questioning? We obviously don't care!
I’m definitely not a Labour supporter, but Jake Tame is so out of touch with the emissions.
He has no idea how much normal people are struggling.
This emissions bs...it's like he's married to it
Tame is wasting our time.
governance=bs
Jack Tame turning into a Nat lacky
Maybe QandA could suggest more racism as a solution?
Is Tame obvlivious to what has been going on? It seems so or else he is having a rather bad morning.
WEF APPARATCHIK SELLS OUT COUNTRY TO BLACKROCK
Hilarious, Hipkins is more of a plonker than expected. The angle about a helicopter emitting waste while it saves you from a flooded river and it’s all your fault was a remarkable example of how little goes around in that little orange head.
hes a bureaucrat nt a thinker
If you watch it again, I think you will find Hipkins was using it as an example of how ridiculous Jack Tame's accusation of the fuel tax causing climate disaster on the East Coast was. If anything your comment shows how little goes around your head.
And therein lays the problem.
We need leadership from the heart💚...the true brain, the consciousness that comes from Source💨🤍
Not the temporal ego brain🤯 which leads to cycles of slavery ♾
@@diyguru9677 haha nah he was backed into a corner and the best he could come up with was we need lower fuel tax because …. helicopters…. 😂
Jack the joke
I can bearly afford to live m8
Gas tax cut is just what i need i mean hes advocating EV vehicles and other stuff what more do u want ..get off his back
27:08 is when Jack tame knew he stuff up. 🤣 he even tried to blame the pm hipkins..haha. too many gotchas, fishing for headlines.
Hipkins misrepresenting things again. There’s 7200 people with permanent boil water notices, or less than 0.15% of the population. Hardly a big issue
🙄🙄🙄
Whats a woman Chris 😂😅
Jack Tame is now as much of an embarrassment to his profession as the AMShow hosts. Stop it Jack - it is totally unbecoming. FWIW we have all done a US OE.
Can someonw PLEASE take a look at a South African bowler Saun Pollock and tell me he is not Chirpy, Chumpy, or Crisis brother maybe even his twin!!! As far as the interview just another labour boring bunch of crap