Padre Pio Movie ~ Warning & Review ~ All Saints Parish
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 มิ.ย. 2023
- Thank you for joining us today at All Saints Parish! #allsaintsparish #allparish #padrepio
Padre Pio Movie- Fr. Meyer Warning
~This is a Rated R film with strong language and 2 scenes of nudity.
~This is an artistic film that needs interpretation and not a "happy" biographical film about Padre Pio.
~If one does not know who Padre Pio is prior to the film it will be confusing; if you do know him and his life, the film will make better sense.
~The film does a GREAT job film showing parts of Padre Pio's Life: celebrating Mass reverently, hearing confession, praying, healing people, bilocating, being attacked by the devil, receiving the stigmata, and having Marian visions.
~The film shows a scene where satan appears as a naked woman, to temp Padre Pio, this is historically true and happened during his lifetime. Young children, teens, those who are addicted to porn, etc- should not see this film/scene; unless they are spiritually mature.
~The film also has a scene where Padre Pio is engulfed by a demonic attack of a thorn bush. Thorn bushes are found also in the life of St. Francis and St. Benedict.
~The film has Padre Pio using a curse word toward an unrepentant sinner who also might be demonically possessed.
~MUCH of the film is caught up in the lives of the people who live in the town and the struggles they have. The producer is trying to make a connection between Padre Pio's redemptive suffering and their lives. Padre Pio wants to offer his life up for them and their sins and suffering. Padre Pio suffers for them!
~Note the number of crosses (crucifixes with no corpus) that are in the film...who is on the cross- Padre Pio! There is a Franciscan tradition of having crosses with NO corpus due to St. Francis (Padre Pio) having the stigmata.
~There is a priest who has given his life to drinking, money, and greed and has put himself on the side of politics- his life is in contrast to Padre Pios.
~One might want to brush up on the early rise of socialism, the thought of Karl Marx, and class tensions in Italy after WWI prior to the film.
Please subscribe to our channel!
Daily Virtual Mass Schedule:
Daily Weekday Masses :
Mon. - 5:45PM, Tues. - 7:30AM, Wed. - 5:45PM, Thurs. - 7:30AM & Fri. - 7:30AM.
Weekend Mass:
4:00PM Saturday Mass 7:30AM, 9:15AM & 11AM Sunday Mass
Fr. Mahan and Fr. Meyer alternate weekly.
Resources for online Mass: allsaintscatholic.net/worship/
Listen to Sunday Homilies! bit.ly/3tQRBDr
Check out our PEACE ON EARTH Daily Advent & Christmas reflections! bit.ly/3V0z1Vg
Visit our parish website! allsaintscatholic.net/
Follow us on:
Facebook - / allparish
Twitter - / allparish
Instagram - / allparish
Podcast - www.podbean.com/pu/pbblog-tet...
Somehow, just playing Padre Pio in this film brought Shia L. to Christ and the Catholic Church. If you know anything about his life, this is a miracle in itself. Time will tell if he continues on this path. I pray he will. I will watch it when it goes to Red Box.
Shia and I both have similar backgrounds growing up Caucasian in LA in Latino neighborhoods during the exact same time. Both in recovery also and very similar upbringings. His podcast he did that went viral hit me hard, I felt his pain. And there are so many people who refuse to see any of us in recovery as people who deserve forgiveness yet they paint themselves as perfect. God is doin work in Shias life that’s for sure.
Shia recently said he is going through RCIA to be confirmed.
He said in an interview it was the Traditional Latin Mass. ❤️
He said in the scenes of Mass where he's crying, it's really his own reaction to it.
It was an interview with Bishop Barron, highly recommend it! As a Traditional Latin Mass goer myself, there really is nothing else like it. ❤️ Nothing more beautiful, more sacred, and nothing is more worthy an act of worship of God. It's so nourishing!
God goes to great lengths to save a soul. His love is unfathomable. ❤️❤️❤️
Well, his newest project has him writing a film about the holocaust so hes not abandoning his jewish roots. But why should he.
Excellent commentary, Father Meyer! We need more wise holy Priests like you. Thank you for your service.
Ditto. We need wise holy priests to NOT GET CANCELLED EITHER. THAT'S ONLY RIGT, GODLY.
I really wish they had spent way more time on Padre Pios character and shown more kindness from Our Lord and Mother mary. Every attack Padre Pio had put on him, Our Lord was always there to offer strength.
St Padre Pio pray for us ❤️🩹
He is dead
ANTI CatholicTroll
@@wesleysimelane3423 If you know who Padre Pio is,then you would know that he answers prayers from Heaven.🙏
@@wesleysimelane3423 He is a Saint In Heaven
@@user-yc9eo8ju3d I know who Pio WAS!. A catholic charlatan whom catholics have taken and turned into some kind of deity, like they always do!
Excerpt from Padre Pio and his friend from Rome: Carlo Campanini an actor., enough said.
Padre Pio’s advice to never take a part in a movie that had immoral content.
Padre Pio had explained to Carlo that the people who made such movies would have to answer to God for their actions. That included everyone from the producers to the actors to the carpenters who built the sets to the people who sold the tickets.
Padre Pio also warned Carlo never to tell off-color jokes or use bad language. If a movie script had even one vulgar word in it, Carlo would not consider being a part of the project. Movie directors and producers could not understand why Carlo was passing up such lucrative job opportunities. When they asked him for an explanation, he simply told them that he was a spiritual son of Padre Pio and that Padre Pio set a very high standard.
Thanks for the great reply. As you show here in your comment, Padre Pio would have us exercise the principle of the integral good.
Fr. ripperger has some good conferences and a book on this.
Wow ! that’s informative….!! All (almost) movies nowadays are filthy to some extent
God bless him.
Thanks for bringing this to our attention...and yes, I wish they had opted for "representation " of the nude temptation, rather than being so graphic....but, I think they were trying to capture the true impact such temptation would have had on Padre Pio, and not over simplify it as an easy hurdle he had to jump over....I think that may be why they may have chosen to not hold back and censor....however,...it will diminish the potential audience. If it's done for this purpose, I can appreciate the contents, and hope that God can too...as God,, Himself, allowed this crude content to tempt Padre Pio in real life. I completely agree that obscenity and vulgar language should not form part of our entertainment, save for the purpose of driving a strong point accross. As Catholics, we live in a world where we HAVE to navigate through such vulgarity and circumstance on the daily...we also need to be mature enough in our faith to talk about it and address these shortcomings in the world, without actively participating in their distribution for entertainment/malicious purposes. Well said!!!...thanks, for your post!!
@@phebiusmcgilvery surely movies like SHAWSHANK REDEMPTION that have made people reconsider suicide are morally good in spite of some profanity. Do you think God has never used someone who has not perfect for a great good. Look at the adulterer Oscar Schindler. Our actions count more than the occasional swear word.
Padre Pio was the first saint i ever head of and how he suffered, and paid the price for being chosen by Our Lord to win back souls for God
SAINT PADRE PIO
PRAY 4 US
I'm shocked that they made a movie about a saint and it's rated R with nudity and swearing....Hello? I'll never watch such a movie and Padre Pio would be deeply offended by it
I think Padre Pio himself would be offended!
The movie is a Trojan horse. It's not at all about Padre Pio. It's terribly disrespectful and offensive. One particular scene is very disturbing, perverted, and blasphemous, and has no business being in a film about Padre Pio . Shia Le Beouf was excellent. It's unfortunate the directors/writers used him to disparage Catholicism and confuse people about Padre Pio. One could walk away from this film thinking Padre Pio was mentally ill and suicidal. As for it being artistic, there is nothing new nor creative in this film. I would describe everything about it as sophomoric. The two questionable scenes were unnecessary except to scandalize the viewer. If you still decide to see this film, know that 1. you will be scandalized and 2. you will be waiting through the credits for the film you were promised.
THANK YOU FR. Meyer for such a TRUTHFUL REVIEW. I've been waiting for this movie to come out & I will discern whether or NOT to watch it. God Bless. Padre Pio is my patron Saint & very much respect him. 🙏🙏🙏
Yes! Thank you so much for this excellent review.
Thank you Father for the warning! May God Bless you🙏💙🙏
This is an EXCELLENT review of an EXCELLENT film. I think it’s easy for Catholics to be scandalized by sin (as we should) but this doesn’t negate that sin is REAL. This film is a true gift.
Man I've heard it is a terrible film and really isn't even about Padre Pio and is very scandalous
The movie is not at all about Padre Pio, he gets very little screen time! Also, the way Padre Pio is portrayed in this small amount of time is a disgrace and this should not be supported by any devoted Catholics. Even if you put everything aside and just judge it as a simple basic movie, even then it is terrible and hard to sit through.
@ragnarl9651 I agree..
Excellent? The movie was an abomination to Padre Pio. This movie was not about Padre Pio, but about the rise of socialism. I can appreciate the connection between Pio and the socialism. Still a terrible film. Shia LaBeouf was good. That’s all.
This is not about Padre Pio. It's a chyt film
St. Padre Pio please pray for us sinners🙏
For there is one God, and one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus - 1 Timothy 2:5 - Not Padre Pío
@@rawevidence540 heck off commie
Thank you very much for this excellent review of the movie. I had just read a review in another location that was very strongly encouraging people not to go see the movie and that these folks walked out of the movie way before it was over. Your recommendations will definitely help people make the decision whether or not to go see the movie. Thank you, as always, Fr Meyer for all your insights. God bless.
Thank you for your thorough and honest review, Father Meyer. I love that All Saints goes to the movies on a regular basis!
Great review, many many people confuse the mortification and doing penance with just tying to purify the self to reach more holiness, not as an act to relieve the suffering of others either in general or in this case of Padre Pio the suffering of his fellow countrymen. Excellent point. Thank you for your review.
Good review Father. I can't wait to see it. I'm glad to see more serious, grown-up religious movies. I don't care if there is "artistic" flexibility. I'm also a grown-up. Now days Disney offends me more often than a bunch of cowboys and Marines drinking whiskey could... usually.
Worst movie ever don't waste your time. Father's description is better than the movie was.
What a great priest. He has such presence and command. More like this, please!
Padre Pio: Miracle Man is a family friendly version of the saint's life. It is a very nicely done film in my opinion and would probably be a better option for people who don't want to see an R rated film. It was originally in Italian and I recommend watching it with the subtitles vs the English dubbed version.
Thank you kindly for your recommendation. God bless you
Yes a far better movie it is for sale by. Ignatius Press
I agree. I did show that movie to my entire family and keep recommending to my students and people in the parish. It is very moving and spiritual as well.
@@MadalenaElisete dónde la puedo ver por favor .link gracias Bendiciones
Excellent review. Thank you Father for all the insight, pros and cons. All that you said was not surprising especially if you have studied the life of blessed padre! The book called The Last Mass of Padre Pio is excellent for those who aspire to his blessed life. God bless and thank you Father for your time concerning this film.
Father, thank you so much for the detailed review. I really appreciate your understanding and warning for the faithful in discerning viewing this film. I have shared your link to a lot of people and hope they come to value what has been created to portray the real struggles of spiritual battles!
Thank you Father! When we finished watching the film it was “wait, what? That’s it?”. Your explanation helps connect the dots very clearly.
The film shouldn’t need a commentary to understand it. The Italian actors in the film were good. Shia was not. More is expected from an actor of his caliber. The actors job is to help viewers get lost in a character. Shia didn’t achieve this. The events happening in Italy post WW1 and the Padre character weren’t properly linked. It was like watching two different story lines.
Thank you, Fr. Meyer! I really am discerning my viewing. I know much of Padre Pio… this was very helpful!
Thank you Father for adding context to this movie. God bless you.
Thank you Fr. Meyer for an honest review and earnest warning. It should also be mentioned, Shia depicted St. Padre Pio using profanity in one of the movie trailers, which contradicts the Saints actions as a child. St. Padre Pio as a child would flee from those who used such vulgarity! Even more repulsive would such impiety be for the Saint as an Adult! The liberties movie producers use in the name of "Art" should never prevail over Truth! "Art" is a human expression that may be pleasing to the flesh, but potentially dangerous for the soul.
Viva Cristo Rey!
Mary, your closing line made me wonder what Fr. Mark Goring will say about this travesty. I know he won't be wishy-washy about it! Excellent points about how truth must prevail over "art," and how what is pleasing to the flesh can be damaging to the soul. So many posters on here trying to posture and puff themselves up as culturally sophisticated Catholics, but instead "professing themselves wise they became fools."
Padre Pio would be so upset by the vile porn in the film. I couldn’t believe it. I still fill icky from having seen it and even trying to skip it.
Thank you Fr. Meyer for this review....
Thank you, Father for this review. I saw it yesterday and fortunately was able to understand the intent of the producers. Definitely not for anyone who likes cleaned up, the feel good movies!
Thank you Fr. Meyer! You are the only one giving an honest review!!
Hi Fr. Meyer from Massachusetts! Love your commentary. I will see this. Padre Pio was an awesome saint!
I have not seen the movie!
I have seen the trailer and I listened to a Franciscan who's been a Priest for 40 years he said it is Garbage! Also of the men that were left that are still alive that new PadrePio said he would never say that 4 letter word! My
understanding, and I could be wrong is that the man who made this film is a fallen away Catholic who is now a Buddhist. A better film is to go see Nefarious and find out what the devil is doing In our world so that people will wake up realize that he is there all the time since we were born and go to confession! Thank you for your review Father🙏
You and the Franciscan are absolutely CORRECT! Don't waste your time on this crap of a movie.
The producer is a porn producer. That’s how he started his career. Hence the vile pornographic scenes
I agree, excellent commentary. I would add that Satan would tempt Padre Pio and come to him in many forms such as the Virgin Mary, an angel, or his superior. The discernment that Padre Pio would use began with asking the person to declare that Christ is Lord. Satan cannot do this and this became the sign that he was dealing with the demonic. My main criticism is that the focus on the film seems to be more about Socialism than about Padre Pio.
I saw it as a family with my sister older kids. I was hoping it would have been discussed the many miracles he performed and much more on his life. It seemed as if they were telling two different stories.
I so badly wanted to see a full-on St. Pio biopic style movie LOL, God Bless these film makers I understand what they did-maybe we can persuade them next to make the Miraculous Pio film that highlights all of the beauty he brought into the world ?! ❤🙏
Thank you Father. I was hesitant to see it based on other Catholics opinions however I agree with you. As adults who have read his diary this will be very interesting and insightful. Not very often do we have a Catholic Saint as the title and subject of a major production. Praying for you and thank you for serving al of us. Your vocation is the most difficult....no days off. Thank you Father...
I struggle with Internet pornography and i was tempted by the scene but I said to myself, if Padre Pio resisted temptation when ''it'' was right in front of him, then I can at the very least move on from that scene in honor of his victory over ''it''.
It doesnt' matter, it is mortal sin to put someone in state of proximate mortal sin.
If it's rated R, there's a good reason to stay away from it for the sake of your soul.
@@asimpleuser123 Oh for pity's sake -- throughout the New Testament, Jesus and the Apostles were proximate to mortal sin nearly every hour of the day. Temptations abound, just like now. Jesus didn't tell everyone to stay away from prostitutes and tax collectors because they can't be helped, they've committed mortal sin so to hell with them. No one seemed to complain when Gibson made an entire movie of torture porn to satisfy his blood lust and didn't spend three seconds on the sanctifying glory and unimaginable love revealed in the Crucifixion. Nope. Just violence and bloodshed and more violence.
I'm not going to clutch my pearls and shield my eyes from a film that depicts the real struggles with temptation and sin we face daily in our lives.
Thank you Fr Johnathan
Peace Be With You Brother 🙏🌹✝️🕊️🛐
Thank you for the review. I was so excited to see a movie about Saint Padre Pio and I was even more intrigued when I heard that Shia LaBeouf had converted to Catholicism because of learning about Jesus and his love and mercy.
Now dear friends, let us remember who we are dealing with. We are dealing with powers and principalities; a battle between good and evil and for our souls.
Let's not get it twisted. Don't be fooled. Who can "appear " as an angel of light? Who is the great counterfeiter and master manipulator?
Who brings discord, violence and nudity? It's his calling card.
Why would having St.Pio using the F word (it's attested by those who knew him that he did not use such language) be necessary?
Why would one choose to have nudity in a film? Would one not be extremely prudent to not compromise the beliefs of the religion one is portraying?
It seems to me that Satan is still trying to wrestle with our great Saint!
A Saint who snatched many souls from Satan's evil grasp!
A priest who bore the wounds of Christ himself dropping the F bomb! Talk about a sucker punch to the very core of those who know and love this great Saint!
What's the adage, one bad apple spoils the whole barrel? That's about how I see it. I don't want my experience with Saint Padre Pio tainted in anyway. We are also instructed to avoid the near occasion of sin.
Very well said! I wish this priest were saying such as you have. I find it disrespectful to Padre Pio and obviously is against the virtues of modesty in speech and dress.
You have explained it very well. I have the same sentiments. Avoid this movie at all costs. I feel like its a trap by the devil. Padre Pio would not like this movie at all.
I’m going to disagree - I’m not saying I loved the movie - but it was spot on / the dialogue I believe was from Padre pios own writing .. the nudity - spot on with what the Padre faced - spot on - the F word maybe / remember Brother Alex, in the movie is actually a priest from Padre Pio”s order - he was their as a consultant too - and the F word was left in .
The bottom line - this was very much who Padre Pio was - I know most , including myself perhaps, wanted to see the Padre Pio greatest hits tribute . All the stories and things we have read . But this was accurate, this was his suffering, this is the temptations he faced and this explains why he received the stigmata . I think we should all watch it again .
Movie about the life of a Saint should be free of Hollywood filth, verbal and nudity .
I'm trying as a catholic to stay in grace so why would I watch a film like that it would harm my faith not strengthen it .I try to stay away from occasions of sin for me to watch this rubbish would be a sin
@@halo1403 very true. This movie feels like a trap by the devil.
This is a very good and useful review. I have a very good understanding of what the film is because of your description. I will ponder and pray about seeing it.
Thank you for the review Fr. Meyer, God Bless You!
You articulated my thoughts exactly. Thank you for sharing your thoughts on this movie.
Thank you very much, Father
I have a love for St. Padre Pio thank you for your insight on it Father🎁🙏🏻…. I did not want to go if it was depicting him unjustly… I will now go see it you have given me a peace of mind about it now🙏🏻
Thank you for this review. Summed up really well . Artistic and conflicting . My husband & I watched it yesterday .
Excellent review!! Thank you father!! Will see it !!
Thank You Father, and God Bless you for this explanation ✝️ I enjoyed the film.
Thank you Fr. Meyer for explaining the movie!
Fr. Meyer, thank you for your review which focused on some key elements and considerations. Very objective and spiritual , much needed.
Thank you Fr for sharing this!!!🙏🙏🙏
Ty Fr. for the warning...GOD Bless You!! 😊🙏📿🤍🌹🕊
Thank you, this review DEFINATELY helps put the film into perspective.....being forewarned, it will be easier to move past the shock of the crude scenes and focus on the life of Padre Pio and the message being expressed in the film, rather than the visuals. I appreciated you sharing this with us. Thanks, and God bless!!!😇😇🙏🙏
Amen praise& thank God.we trust in you for your grace & mercy.❤❤
Thank you Father.
Thank you so Much for the movie review. I was going to take the whole family to watch it so thank you for the warning. I’ll still watch it but just with my spouse.
When I heard that the movie really wasn’t about Padre Pio I was out. Then I saw the scene where the actor who portrays Padre uses curse words, and concluded this is really not about Padre Pio. Thank you for this review 🙏
I'll have to give it a watch sometime. Thank you for your honest review, father
Thank you Father Meyer!
Thank you Father!
Very helpful commentary, Father. Thank you.
Very welcome
Thank you Fr. God bless you. 🕊️
Just saw the movie. It was awful! First it was not about padre PIO, he was like maybe 15% of the actual movie. They didn't tell the story at all, they just threw you into scenes one after another. No story telling/explanations. The music was horrible, the filming was terrible. Half the movie was blurry and than the best part... It was about politics not Padre Pio. I am so disappointed. They could have told an amazing and moving story. Wow 😮
Exactly my take on this film
They probably should have called it something like early trials of Padre PIO.
It was important to show what made the Padre pio that we've heard of and read about.
The history of this movie would have made better sense if someone understood the history during that particular time of the world and particularly the rise of Mussolini. If someone comes into it without knowing the history of that time then it's not going to make sense. I thought Shia LaBeouf did a great job. This movie was targeted towards a very small group of people. So if someone didn't understand the different political pieces than fate really don't understand what created the Padre pio as we've come to know him. Without all those pieces of history of Italy at that time and the rise of Mussolini, I seriously doubt we would be speaking about Padre pio at all. It took those trials and tribulations for him to become the person that we think of in hindsight. If someone doesn't know it's true then I'm sure it just seemed very confusing. I don't think this really was the correct title as I mentioned above. Early trials of Padre pio or something. but still if people aren't familiar with history then they aren't going to understand. So again I think the whole movie was targeted towards a very small audience and pretty sure it was just a small low-budget independent film. You guys should have watched the trailer before you watched it at the theater. The trailer show the most of it was about politics and how this affected Padre PIO. I bet if you go back and watch the trailer right now then you notice it revolves around everything you guys are saying didn't really make sense to you. I didn't learn about the rise of Mussolini and world war in school. I just love history and I already knew so understood exactly that this was a period piece film. Please watch more than one trailer before you go spend money at the theater. If it had been a movie about Padre pio's life then it would have been a biopic and about four hours. Most people do not know who he is.
Propaganda? Do you think?
Exactly. This was more about socialism.
It really seemed like the movie was trying to make martyrs of socialists and using Padre Pio's name just to draw in a different audience.
What really bothered was showing the priest that took money blessing the guns that later shot the socialists.
The music was horrible and nothing seemed to have order. I believe demons have their footprint all over this movie
Thank you, God bless 🙏
Thank you so much for the synopsis and for the warnings Fr. Jonathan! I was initially put off by the "F" word in the movie previews but I'll let the movie speak for itself as Shia Labeouf experienced a conversion playing Padre Pio. I wonder whether he mentioned about Mussolini going to heaven in this movie, or not. God bless.🙏🙏
Mussolini is in purgatory?
@@beatlecristian I read somewhere that mentioned Padre Pio said that he is in heaven. There's a mystic by the name of Elena Aiello who saw Mussolini appear to her from purgatory asking her to pray for him. She also said that he is in heaven, I believe in 1951.
Sorry, the mystic was Edvige Carboni, not Elena Aiello.
I thought it was one of the worst movies I have ever seen. Boring, dark, and dreary beyond belief. Worst of all is that it portrays Padre Pio as an insensitive fowl-mouthed jerk. This movie is not worthy of its name.
@@marksandford3422 I herd the same thing It was garbage
His conversion came from hanging out with the Traditional Latin Mass Fiars.
Thank you for this Father! I wasn’t sure wether to watch or not but you explained it beautifully. I will probably rent it this evening because now I know what to expect.
👍👍👍 !!! Tks!, Fr Meyer.
Thank you for putting this out there father. Have heard conflicting things about this movie about a wonderful servant of God. From Kansas City, MO!
Thanks Father! I loved it too! The ending Holy Mass scene was very Padre Pio vibes.
Thank you Fr.for the synopsis of this film. I will ponder whether to see this or not. I have seen a movie depicting his life a few years ago which was very good. Again thank you and God bless you 🙏
Saw it & you hit the nail on the head! ....those who are reacting against it have lost sight..
Thank you Father for reviewing this movie. I will go to see it but at least now I know what to expect!
Saint Pio is one of my most favorite and patron saints (along with Saint Maria Goretti), so a few months ago I found out about this movie by a clip of it showing up on my YT recommendations.
I eagerly clicked on it, and my delight turned to disgust and shock, the clip show the actor playing Saint Pio using language that he (or any other saint would never use).
I certainly will not be going to this movie. Thanks Father.
Thank you for your review and explaining what we can see/hear in the movie, Father Jonathan. I appreciate it a lot! I wish someone warned me in the same way before watching the movie Father Stu, which scandalized me and my husband. I don’t really understand why we need to hear the f words and see the nudity in an explicit way when there are other artistic ways of conveying the message. I listened to the amazing testimony of the actor who plays Padre Pio and I was looking forward to watching the movie, but I don’t think I will… 😢
Wise choice. My husband and I (27 yrs old) were absolutely disgusted and scandalized by that film. Shia could be Pio in a different rendition of it and do a fabulous job, but seeing as how the producer is a porn producer, you get what you expect. Vile porn.
@@kp3871 Oh my god, the producer is a porn producer?!! This says it all. This movie is actually an attack on Padre Pio. I am not watching it, and will warn others not to.
Great analysis father, is not the same to just hear “garbage movie, do not watch it”
Its better to also know the why
Thank you Father. Appreciate this.
Thank you so much Father
Outstanding unbiased review. Thank you
Thanks for watching!
I just watched last night . I am so shocked why did they even give the name Padre Pio to this movie .. Hardly anything to do with his life…. 🥲🥲🥲
Thank you dear father for this heads up to all .. God bless 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽
Very good, very mature, very concise presentation of the Padre Pio movie. Thank you, Father. I look forward to watching it.
Thanks very much for your helpful review, Father.
Thank you for this honest review.
This was very helpful! Thank you so much.
Glad it was helpful!
Thank you!
Thank you, Father.
Good review. Thanks
Thank you fr. I’ve seen many Catholic channels immediately condemn the film. I appreciate the nuance in your feedback and your astute observations about the intricacies of the spiritual life.
Brilliantly done Father great review
thank you father excellent commentary padre pio pray for us amen
Thank you , Father Meyer: clear and truly helpful review 👍🙏
Glad it was helpful!
Thank you for this video, very useful as I am very interested in this movie and I’ll watch it soon.
Thank you Gather. God bless
Diabolical! They certainly don’t have good intentions making this film
Thanks for your honest thoughts on this film 🙏 Viva Cristo Rey
Excellent review. I think I will watch it. Thank you
Great review and perspective Father. Will check this film out.
Great review. Thank you
Thanks for watching!
This is a great review father. I totally agree on the review. I think many ppl who refused to watch it don't really know Padre Pio's story or even how difficult the lives of saints are. Shia did an excellent portrayal. Not a perfect film but if you go in knowing his story it's absolutely worth watching.
Thank You Father for letting us know about movie.
Thank you for your review, Father. I found the movie to be very interesting in an artsy clunky way. It's a brief moment in a very young Padre Pio's life from 1916 (around 29 yrs old) when he arrived at San Giovanni Rotondo to 1918 when he received the stigmata (around 31 yrs old), which happens beautifully at the end of the movie. It's probably not going to please all the Rotten Tomato critics or pious Padre Pio devotees. But I learned a lot and found your critical analysis spot on with my take on it, Father.
Oscar, you wrote, "It's probably not going to please all the ... pious Padre Pio devotees." Shouldn't we all aspire to be "pious Padre Pio devotees"? And if they are not pleased with this film, there is a good reason that we should reflect upon.
@@g.p.ryecroft Well, as mentioned, it was interesting in an artsy clunky way. The political backstory could have been woven much tighter and edited a lot more to support the Padre Pio story. It seemed like it was 2/3 political and 1/3 Padre Pio. This movie doesn't flow with the balance of a movie like, "Fatima" (2020). Perhaps their Original Screenplay Writer and Editor should have been hired. Makes me wonder how limited the budget was since it seemed like a year to get the movie distributed.
There's no older mature version of Padre Pio and his many miracles, etc. as many know him for. Despite all of this, Shia LaBeouf did an excellent job portraying a young Padre Pio during those 2 years leading to receiving the stigmata. He was ordained in 1910 which puts him at 6 years into his priesthood as this movie starts. I learned of a young Padre Pio's human struggles (demonically tormented, temptations, village politics, etc.) based on his letters to his spiritual director, on which the movie was based. There are some troubling scenes that are understandable. But again, these are scenes recreated from the letters. Also, Padre Pio's life in post-WWI Italy and the politics of the time; which one could see from the movie is history repeating itself in today's world.
@@BellaJones2010 I appreciated your insightful review, Oscar. You gave me a very good idea of what the film is about. Did not know it only covered his younger years. Maybe a sequel? I love the long Italian biopics and will be sticking with those! Thank you for the thoughtful response!
Perfectly stated review, Father. Thank you!
well done. thanks!
Thanks for watching!
At this point, I don't even know if it's even for Catholics