Двоем вы сила!!!Я полюбила тату группу,а не по отдельности.Смотрю как вы исполняете сольные программы.Ничего нет,не захватывает,не затрагивает,нет огня.Не получится завоевать сердца поклонников по отдельности.Скоро забудут как Волкову так и Катину. А помнить будут только ТАТУ. Не ссорьтесь,отдельно вы как все ,не интересные.
en esta presentacion lena se aprovecho de que julia todavia estaba en recuperacion por su cirugia... debio apoyarla!!! son un grupo.. lena aprovecho para lucirse... ya que no pudo hacerlo cuando empezaron su carrera ya que siempre fue la sombra de julia...!!! volkova por siempre... te amo julia eres siempre seras mejr que lena
BrianaKTown she mentioned once in an interview that she is a bisexual. Even though she has already married a guy, she still has a special love for a woman. So I think she still somewhat interested in the tomboy style
I know, I mean she used to wear tomboy clothes with short hair, which many people including me like it. Now she did a surgery and her lips look terrible. I just wish she could be like the time around 2000s
I can't believe that when Russias team came out at the Winter Olympics 2014 , they started playing this song, this song was written by two Russia lesbian couple who were harassed for being gay. Out of all the new songs, they choose this one, that came out in 2009 and also is showing support for something that Russia's laws aren't in flavor. I love the fact that Germany and other counties wore rainbow close to support gays
It was like "bitch, get out of my spotlight". Well, after all the trash Julia said about her, it was Lena's moment to shine and liberate herself from Julia's domination.
Omg I miss them so much!!!! Hopefully they relationship are doing good in real life.. Pls dont blame on yulia's vocal coz she didnt want it happen and she did her best she can..both yulia and lena are amazing.. No matter what tatu is unique :)
Yulia NEVER led Lena like a puppy. It's not that Yulia was in control; but, as Lena has always been a little shy, but not Yulia, it looked like Yulia took control. She even played with Len on stage to cheer her up. Yulia did talk bad about Lena, but only ONCE. And how can you say that Lena has always been nothing?! She's always been... WOW. Both, Yulia and Lena, together or not, they've always been AMAZING, and BOTH have succeded. And Lena WAS distant and cold, but it's understandable.
В живую не получилось. Да еще и песню которую поют более 10 лет. Не понравилось. Вот что значит любить петь под фанеру. Так никогда и не научишься. Когда они были молодыми девчонками все было куда эмоциональнее и интереснее. Сейчас они поют тот свой репертуар. И получается плохо. Да еще и внешность у Юли стала такая. Как будто кучу операций прошла. Неестественная. Помню когда они начинали. Их песни звучали классно. И самый первый альбом так и остался их лучшим альбомом
I think anyone who doesn't think that Yulia doesn't look good is either gay or that they don't like women,Yulia is amazingly gorgeous and so is Lena,i like them both,so stop trying to trash them you bunch of haters.....
great band, they both grew up....here is a trivia question..... which grew up to be an amazing singer that was proud of performing (often shy in interviews) Which played a role, doesn't care about the performance, and plays the shock value still?
You say that Julia's voice sounds bad, and I agree It does...but really? Lena' s voice sounds horrible too. Just cause Lena acually has a voice dosen't mean it sounds good. After 16+ years in the music Industry you should be able too sing, Lena does not even have a throat problem??Im sorry but this is really bad, It is honestly painful to watch and Im a huge t.A.T.u. fan.
This is just sad. All of their chemistry is gone. Every time Julia tries to touch Lena, she pulls away. I'm not blaming either of them. It is just sad to feel the tension between them when they used to perform so well together.
ff7vincent441 Lena don't want. That day Yulia made everything to aproache Lena, but Lena was cold as ice. I watched a movie about that day. P.S.: Sorry for my bad english.
Grajdan Sabina There's no telling for sure what happened or which one does not want to be friends again because of the media and all of the stories/rumors, but either way, whoever it is and whatever the story, it is still sad. P.S. That's okay :)
У меня такое предположение, что в своё молодое время голосила очень хорошо Юля и она была в приоритете в группе и вряд ли она этим как-то понтовалась, но допустим у неё был скверный молодой дерзкий характер. А Лена была такая тихушница пай девочка, слабо поющая, скрывающая зависть. И вот когда у Юли проблемы с голосом, все высокие сложные основные партии поёт Лена. И вы посмотрите как она прямо таки пыжится на сцене, старается очень неестественно, показывает всем видом, что она супер певица, супер артист, хотя сама просто орёт вместо пения, но зато ведь ноты достаёт, а Юля шепчет. И этим поведением для меня Лена выглядит не выросшим ребёнком. Я не знаю точно какая конкретно была конфликтная ситуация, повлиявшая на такое отношение, может Юля чем-то виновата, но видно что Юля старается и помириться, и пойти на встречу - ведёт себя по взрослому. И просто поёт как может, тем не менее выглядит очень классно и выступает, и взгляд, и походка, прямо доносит смысл песни, переживает. Лене даже на коленях я не верю.
I hate to break it to you but neither of these girls has ever sung that well. In their "prime," they used to lip sync all of the time. It doesn't sound like they're lip syncing as much as they used to but you can still hear that they are getting some serious help from the pre-recorded parts.
Лена слишком яростно пыталась показать, что она больше не та скромная девочка, которая всегда была в тени яркой Юли Волковой. Но так переиграла, что мне даже за нее стало немножко стыдно)
@@eliasmo8458 я знаю что у Юли была операция, но дело не только в вокале же. Есть, кстати, видео, где Юля комментирует это их выступление, там она тоже недоумевала на счёт Лениных "замашек", типа "чё это она там такое устроила вообще?!"))
Es verdad lena estuvo muy mal.ahi en esa presentacion muy ridícula pero lena debe cambiar mucho su forma de ser a estas alturas no debe ser así y pensar mejor las cosas en este 2022 y vivir la.vida bien sin rencores y ser buena con los demas
As a t.A.T.u. fan of 7 years, I'll be the first to say this is their worst performance. But what can you expect after them performing solo for over 3 years? Julia's voice was horrible from a botched vocal surgery, but she sang anyways. They performed several times after this and it was great!
+Foxy The Pirate Fox Yulia's voice was harmed from horrible vocal practices. There are actually proper ways to scream and just "screaming" wouldn't have destroyed her voice to the point it is at now. She didn't care about taking care of her voice and she's admitted to it. Unfortunately, she is now paying the price for it.
Actually Yulia did care for her voice, in a few clips on their docos/behind the scenes. Yulia complains to Ivan about screaming all the time and she tells him she knew he didn't care about how all the screaming was effecting her voice. There is a video were Yulia's mother and Yulia are discussing with Ivan about Yulia's up coming cyst surgery. Yulia's mother even said she will make up the money to pay for it, (I'm assuming they were asking Ivan for an increase in Yulia's pay so she could get surgery). Ivan didn't care he just wanted them to perform so he could get his money.
I figured that out after I said that. Anyhow, that must of been a horrible surgery. I also heard the fact that they were required to screamed also hurt it. But cyst are normally easy to remove.
***** This is like her second time her voice got effed up, she already had her voice ruined back in 2005 but it wasn't as bad...now she's pretty much horrible
they haven't sang together in 3 years, so it's to be expected. I just learned of this performance and was very surprised to see how good they still can sing these songs after so much time (they songs are considerably difficult because of the way some of the notes are ordered and especially because the range is pretty extreme in some).
Yo admiro enormemente a ambas, fue un acto muy noble el hecho de que Lena volviera al escenario con Yulia después de lo que esta última dijera sobre ella hace algunos años, Lena siempre tuvo mejor calidad vocal, porque ella es una soprano y su rango vocal le permite llegar a notas altas naturalmente, el registro vocal de Yulia nunca había sido tan amplio, y a causa de forzar sus cuerdas se le generó ese quiste, no es justo que critiquen la posición de las dos, ellas son sensacionales!!!
WTF ???? Que Intención traía Lena Con Soltar así la mano de Julia en El Minuto 3:05 - 3:06 o.O ha de haberse sentido como un Zapato la pobre Juliaa !!! Ojala Todas sus diferencias queden en el pasado y Vuelvana A Ser las mismas de antes ! ♥
Te apoyo, Julia siempre fue la que sobresalió más del dúo... Lena tenía una voz mucho más común y la de Julia era más sobresaliente... Lástima que ahora no alcance notas altas ni cante como antes, pero aún así puede hacer grandes cosas, lástima que lena no la haya apoyado en este concierto. :/
Кто после интервью Собчак?))
Прям все выступления начал пересматривать
да,прям ностальжи)
Ja :-) Srazu prignul sjuda kogda Julka skazala shto Lena s "nastroeniem" priperluas sjuda :D
Тупо слезы накатывают, как вспомню те времена, когда они были девчулями, моего возраста
Школа. Дискотека.
i realy admire julia...she's very brave to sing in front of a huge crowd after having the sugery...i really love t.A.T.u.. :)
Revisiting this after like six years since I last watched. Beautiful ladies, sad their friendship dissolved...
3:00 3:06 4:12 :( eso es crueldad
en los ensayos la hizo llorar 😢 esa actitud de lena..
extraño algo qe se llamaba t.A.T.
Двоем вы сила!!!Я полюбила тату группу,а не по отдельности.Смотрю как вы исполняете сольные программы.Ничего нет,не захватывает,не затрагивает,нет огня.Не получится завоевать сердца поклонников по отдельности.Скоро забудут как Волкову так и Катину. А помнить будут только ТАТУ. Не ссорьтесь,отдельно вы как все ,не интересные.
they were still wonderful
en esta presentacion lena se aprovecho de que julia todavia estaba en recuperacion por su cirugia... debio apoyarla!!! son un grupo.. lena aprovecho para lucirse... ya que no pudo hacerlo cuando empezaron su carrera ya que siempre fue la sombra de julia...!!!
volkova por siempre... te amo julia eres siempre seras mejr que lena
Cuál cirujía?
Jajajajaja
Wow... I see great friendship from great hardships... We all know what happened to them, Im just happy they still sing.
Yulia is so fucking perfect.
Yo tu fans gracias por regresar de nuevo taty ..yo siempre megusta musica rusa .de taty mejor estas junto otras ves. Y siempres ..taty
I love this song :D 3
Yulia,you just destroyed yourself. Shame on you! Loved you so much...Lena is still shining like in the old times.
Valentino D it wasn't just her fault she was doing what that manager producer was saying .
I love Lena, her voice is powerful.. I can't hear Yulia's voice.. Yulia doesn't look like before..
I love Yulia's tomboy style and there relationship before TT__TT
Chester Marshall Taylor lol yulia has always been such a feminine person she hating the whole tomboy style
BrianaKTown she mentioned once in an interview that she is a bisexual. Even though she has already married a guy, she still has a special love for a woman. So I think she still somewhat interested in the tomboy style
Chester Marshall Taylor i know shes bisexual but being bisexual dosn't mean your a tomboy?
I know, I mean she used to wear tomboy clothes with short hair, which many people including me like it. Now she did a surgery and her lips look terrible. I just wish she could be like the time around 2000s
Épico. Definitivamente las amo. Y no supero su separación .😰
It's so cute when they hold hands
Like the old days
I can't believe that when Russias team came out at the Winter Olympics 2014 , they started playing this song, this song was written by two Russia lesbian couple who were harassed for being gay. Out of all the new songs, they choose this one, that came out in 2009 and also is showing support for something that Russia's laws aren't in flavor. I love the fact that Germany and other counties wore rainbow close to support gays
Wow!!! Lena barbaro!!!!! Me encanto como canto! Ojala canten en Rusia despues de todo lo que esta pasando alla, y se den un beso! :)
No doubt that "it's driving me mad, going out of my head", but for me it's driving me mad, going in my ears.
the way Lena sang at 1:55 was really weird.
I agree
It was like "bitch, get out of my spotlight". Well, after all the trash Julia said about her, it was Lena's moment to shine and liberate herself from Julia's domination.
gracias por la explicación. Me alegro de que esté bien
Omg I miss them so much!!!! Hopefully they relationship are doing good in real life.. Pls dont blame on yulia's vocal coz she didnt want it happen and she did her best she can..both yulia and lena are amazing.. No matter what tatu is unique :)
Creo que Lena al ver que Julia no podía cantar cantaba más fuerte. .-.
Pobre Julia
with this perfomance lena gained points!! she was amazing!!
Julia is the one with the heart ❤️
we miss u tatu !!!!!!
k puedo decir son geniales se merecen 100000000000000000 de likes o incluso mas
THEY ARE BAAAAAACKKKK YEAHHHH!!!!! :DDD
Yulia NEVER led Lena like a puppy. It's not that Yulia was in control; but, as Lena has always been a little shy, but not Yulia, it looked like Yulia took control. She even played with Len on stage to cheer her up.
Yulia did talk bad about Lena, but only ONCE. And how can you say that Lena has always been nothing?! She's always been... WOW. Both, Yulia and Lena, together or not, they've always been AMAZING, and BOTH have succeded.
And Lena WAS distant and cold, but it's understandable.
Love this
me gustannn, ustedes cantan bonito..y son hermozas.. mis preferidas. falto show me love.. :D
Yousra... Thanks for this song... iloveyou.. 3 3
В живую не получилось. Да еще и песню которую поют более 10 лет. Не понравилось. Вот что значит любить петь под фанеру. Так никогда и не научишься. Когда они были молодыми девчонками все было куда эмоциональнее и интереснее. Сейчас они поют тот свой репертуар. И получается плохо. Да еще и внешность у Юли стала такая. Как будто кучу операций прошла. Неестественная. Помню когда они начинали. Их песни звучали классно. И самый первый альбом так и остался их лучшим альбомом
Love Lives Forever .Божеее,когда вы уже заткнетесь!!!!Сама тупее пробки и что-то ещё тявкает
i get that Lena was mad and everything, but she could at least try to enjoy being here ! They have so much fans
I like them when i listen to this song i think about my mom she loves that song and now she's dead
I'm sorry x(
oh my god i am so sorry for you .
I'm Sorry To Hear I Have I Simler Story My Uncle used To Love This Song He Died In Car Accident In 2006
amazing
I think anyone who doesn't think that Yulia doesn't look good is either gay or that they don't like women,Yulia is amazingly gorgeous and so is Lena,i like them both,so stop trying to trash them you bunch of haters.....
GENIAL
1:56-2:06 lena super voice
I wish I saw this voice
great band, they both grew up....here is a trivia question.....
which grew up to be an amazing singer that was proud of performing (often shy in interviews)
Which played a role, doesn't care about the performance, and plays the shock value still?
They are the best... t.A.T.u. comeback!! Ps: poor Julia.. she had a surgery at vocal cords :( .. I hope that her voice will improve
julia is a star
Their greatest last concert
stan mas buenaaaaaaaas, esooo siii... WOOOOOOOOOW
the red haired one has more talent it seems, but they are both beautiful. xxx
que pena que Julia no se pueda recuperar de sus problemas en las cuerdas vocales !!! pero igual son unas idolas jajaja
You say that Julia's voice sounds bad, and I agree It does...but really? Lena' s voice sounds horrible too. Just cause Lena acually has a voice dosen't mean it sounds good. After 16+ years in the music Industry you should be able too sing, Lena does not even have a throat problem??Im sorry but this is really bad, It is honestly painful to watch and Im a huge t.A.T.u. fan.
Lena & Julia one of the saddest lovestories in Russian history, I hope they make up
I love
why so long music break in ''All the things she said''
Yulia lost completely her voice, Lena is still singing so lovely but Yulia is most part lip sync
She had a surgery back in time as far as I know
No se fuman ni con pipa
i miss the old tatu...is this them? i love old julia...and what happened to lena? i mean, her voice?? i just cant believe this is tatu...😭😭😭
I bleedin' hope hope
No han vuelto, solo fue un reencuentro, como muchos mas que tuvieron
yeah i did notice that too... specially in 3:05, she literally forces her arm
yeah i miss the kiss also...
Might kinda sound like a perv but... yeah... Kind of a nice touch to the song.
no more kisses anymore
wooooooooooow
back to the old days and the not so recent unpleasantness.
Still ace♥
very niiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiic
Agree!!...
pobre yul, extraño su vos como era antes
*Nas ne dogonyat* 4ever!
Is it me or at min 3:11 Lena forcibly remove her hand from Yulia's? Or was it a part of their performance??
I love Lena...
que le paso a la hermosa voz de Julia?!!??!?!?
i want cry :(
We all do, bro
Is true, Good for Lena because Yulia was very rude wih her during their break-up
Alfinal arreglaron sus problemas?
Never figure out which one is which, but is it me or is the redhead leaps and bounds ahead, vocally speaking?
very sweet baby...
Exacto..
hola disculpen yo tambien soy fan alguno de ustedes sabe si julia se recuperara o ese problema ya sera permanente de su voz :'(
This is just sad. All of their chemistry is gone. Every time Julia tries to touch Lena, she pulls away. I'm not blaming either of them. It is just sad to feel the tension between them when they used to perform so well together.
ff7vincent441 there were anything between them. They were acting the whole time.
Grajdan Sabina Even still, they seemed to, at very least, be friends. Now they do not even want to be near one another.
ff7vincent441 Lena don't want. That day Yulia made everything to aproache Lena, but Lena was cold as ice. I watched a movie about that day.
P.S.: Sorry for my bad english.
Grajdan Sabina There's no telling for sure what happened or which one does not want to be friends again because of the media and all of the stories/rumors, but either way, whoever it is and whatever the story, it is still sad.
P.S. That's okay :)
***** Like I said before, whatever relationship they had, even friendship--it is gone now.
I bleedin' hope hope
Un brindis por todas las personas que nunca superaran la separación de Tatu
SALUD
salud :3
salud 😰😭
salud!!
salud! !
This makes me so depressed. They will never be the same.
I know :(
CruelIntentions6 This should make you happy because they ever existed. Life would have been sad and more depressing without them in it. 💜
У меня такое предположение, что в своё молодое время голосила очень хорошо Юля и она была в приоритете в группе и вряд ли она этим как-то понтовалась, но допустим у неё был скверный молодой дерзкий характер. А Лена была такая тихушница пай девочка, слабо поющая, скрывающая зависть. И вот когда у Юли проблемы с голосом, все высокие сложные основные партии поёт Лена. И вы посмотрите как она прямо таки пыжится на сцене, старается очень неестественно, показывает всем видом, что она супер певица, супер артист, хотя сама просто орёт вместо пения, но зато ведь ноты достаёт, а Юля шепчет. И этим поведением для меня Лена выглядит не выросшим ребёнком. Я не знаю точно какая конкретно была конфликтная ситуация, повлиявшая на такое отношение, может Юля чем-то виновата, но видно что Юля старается и помириться, и пойти на встречу - ведёт себя по взрослому. И просто поёт как может, тем не менее выглядит очень классно и выступает, и взгляд, и походка, прямо доносит смысл песни, переживает. Лене даже на коленях я не верю.
I hate to break it to you but neither of these girls has ever sung that well. In their "prime," they used to lip sync all of the time. It doesn't sound like they're lip syncing as much as they used to but you can still hear that they are getting some serious help from the pre-recorded parts.
Лена слишком яростно пыталась показать, что она больше не та скромная девочка, которая всегда была в тени яркой Юли Волковой. Но так переиграла, что мне даже за нее стало немножко стыдно)
у Юли незадолго была операция на связки, так что ей было сложно петь ярко...
@@eliasmo8458 я знаю что у Юли была операция, но дело не только в вокале же. Есть, кстати, видео, где Юля комментирует это их выступление, там она тоже недоумевала на счёт Лениных "замашек", типа "чё это она там такое устроила вообще?!"))
Да, есть такое) причем как то неуклюже она всё делает, типа драйвовая деваха)))))
Es verdad lena estuvo muy mal.ahi en esa presentacion muy ridícula pero lena debe cambiar mucho su forma de ser a estas alturas no debe ser así y pensar mejor las cosas en este 2022 y vivir la.vida bien sin rencores y ser buena con los demas
God you can see the tension between them. So sad. :'(
Yulia has to sing an octave lower during the high parts (and in most of the songs). her solos sound raspy as fuck. Her voice is gone...
HanyouOnikage Nah, it's getting better as time goes by
why u lying dude
SnazzyBoxx you got no proof
As a t.A.T.u. fan of 7 years, I'll be the first to say this is their worst performance. But what can you expect after them performing solo for over 3 years? Julia's voice was horrible from a botched vocal surgery, but she sang anyways. They performed several times after this and it was great!
+Foxy The Pirate Fox Yulia's voice was harmed from horrible vocal practices. There are actually proper ways to scream and just "screaming" wouldn't have destroyed her voice to the point it is at now. She didn't care about taking care of her voice and she's admitted to it. Unfortunately, she is now paying the price for it.
+Mela S no.. she isnt. we are.. :(
+Chelsea Volkina This the worse? Have you seen their recent performance? They didn't even look at each other!...AWKWARD!
what recent performence? can you link it please?
Actually Yulia did care for her voice, in a few clips on their docos/behind the scenes. Yulia complains to Ivan about screaming all the time and she tells him she knew he didn't care about how all the screaming was effecting her voice. There is a video were Yulia's mother and Yulia are discussing with Ivan about Yulia's up coming cyst surgery. Yulia's mother even said she will make up the money to pay for it, (I'm assuming they were asking Ivan for an increase in Yulia's pay so she could get surgery). Ivan didn't care he just wanted them to perform so he could get his money.
id go lesbian for both of them tbh
Lena is awesome here but.....What the heck happened to Yulia's voice?
She got vocal cyst and had to get surgery to remove it, so it affected her voice (by a lot). And apparently she wont be able to sing like she used to
I figured that out after I said that. Anyhow, that must of been a horrible surgery. I also heard the fact that they were required to screamed also hurt it. But cyst are normally easy to remove.
***** This is like her second time her voice got effed up, she already had her voice ruined back in 2005 but it wasn't as bad...now she's pretty much horrible
una operacion en la garganta
they haven't sang together in 3 years, so it's to be expected. I just learned of this performance and was very surprised to see how good they still can sing these songs after so much time (they songs are considerably difficult because of the way some of the notes are ordered and especially because the range is pretty extreme in some).
dude, Volkova just lost her voice and a surgery on throat…
It's a little sad to spend more than 10 years coming back to sing the same 2 or 3 songs !!
Группа тату как всегда отлична ,и на этом языке они пою офигенно 😍Юля красотка
Es verdad julia siempre lo será 💖 hermosa 👌💋2022
Look at that: 3:00 - 3:06 :(
Also Lena at 04:12
A
Why does she keep trying to touch her it’s not the 2000s anymore ffs
This was THE Greatest moment in the history of The Voice of Romania!!!! Such a GREAT, POWERFUL PERFORMANCE! 💚💚
Yo admiro enormemente a ambas, fue un acto muy noble el hecho de que Lena volviera al escenario con Yulia después de lo que esta última dijera sobre ella hace algunos años, Lena siempre tuvo mejor calidad vocal, porque ella es una soprano y su rango vocal le permite llegar a notas altas naturalmente, el registro vocal de Yulia nunca había sido tan amplio, y a causa de forzar sus cuerdas se le generó ese quiste, no es justo que critiquen la posición de las dos, ellas son sensacionales!!!
WTF ???? Que Intención traía Lena Con Soltar así la mano de Julia en El Minuto 3:05 - 3:06 o.O
ha de haberse sentido como un Zapato la pobre Juliaa !!!
Ojala Todas sus diferencias queden en el pasado y Vuelvana A Ser las mismas de antes ! ♥
Yulia hurt her voice from screams.
No, from operation... wikipedia
CrAsH CZ it is from both. she got the surgery because she hurt her voice from the screaming
+Ian Volkova All these songs like Not gonna get us hurt her voice so much:(
Te apoyo, Julia siempre fue la que sobresalió más del dúo... Lena tenía una voz mucho más común y la de Julia era más sobresaliente... Lástima que ahora no alcance notas altas ni cante como antes, pero aún así puede hacer grandes cosas, lástima que lena no la haya apoyado en este concierto. :/
duas mulheres maravilhosas, com certeza marcaram a vida de muita gente com esse trabalho maravilhoso.
La verdad sea como sea que hayan cantado siempre seran las mejores..las amo t.A.T.u forever!!
I prefered both together. I Love TATU