I'm having S'cure for 9 years, set of 3, heavily used (every year at least 2 vacations + multiplr small trips with medium or hand carry) and only this year it got white marks. But true is, I usually carry around 30-32kg in 2 big luggages. Never got anything broken inside. I love the locks - I would never buy any luggage with zipper anymore. And thinking now about new set - S'cure again or Magnum.
The case needs to be flexible! what do you need a liming inside, that's rubbish.Without lining you can clean the inside much better. i never buy suitcases with lining becazse when backing my suitcase is clean, i also use desinfectant.i only have Samsonite case and they last all you life
@@DivaBara88 I like the look of this case with the locks and that it has no zip. I would much rather leave valuables in this case than cases with zips.
Samsonite made the shell specifically to be flexible and bouncable so when it falls or something is dropped on it the suitcase will not crack and just go back to the original shape.
Totally disagree with this guy! He clearly didnt get the point regarding the durability of the thing: -The Magnum is made of PET- plastics. Can U name anything more durable than a PET bottle? Yeah, it flexes and its neither rigid or thick. BUT THATS THE WHOLE POINT! If flexes and takes a punch! AND you will never get your fist thru that thing, even if you say so! I have been using this thing for a long time and it still looks new.
The Samsonite Magnum Eco was designed to be a hard "flexible" case. Magnum Eco is NOT designed to be a hard "rigid" case like the old Samsonite Aeris F'Lite and the S'cure etc. Samsonite should clarify on their website that Magnum Eco is a hard flexible case, and not a hard rigid case. Watch this Samsonite Cosmolite get driven over by a car and still bounce back to normal: th-cam.com/video/svhTFFhS5q0/w-d-xo.html
I dissagree, i had Samsonite hard shell bags for the past decade! They never broke. My carry on is Magnum eco and I believe it’s fantastic! Yes it’s bending, but NOT breaking…
I don’t really get what is wrong with it. All samsonite suitcases are designed to be flexible. This doesn’t mean it will not protect the stuff inside. It is designed to bounce back to its original shape.
I'm having S'cure for 9 years, set of 3, heavily used (every year at least 2 vacations + multiple small trips with medium or hand carry) and only this year it got white marks. But true is, I usually carry around 30-32kg in 2 big luggages. Never got anything broken inside. I love the locks - I would never buy any luggage with zipper anymore. And thinking now about new set - S'cure again or Magnum.
@Gaming Emporium this is my thoughts on it too, the material isn’t weak it’s flexible it will take a smashing and not crack ! Mine has been to many countries and not a mark on it !!
This is a stupid review. It is an empty case that he presses down on and it returns to the original shape with no deformities. That is a good thing. It's light and sturdy. I agree with the lining bit but overall this is a case of someone not actually knowing quality.
Don’t listen to this I had same luggage martial and much cheaper .. guess what.. had it now for 5 years and travel a lot .. still good.. Stop speeding lies !!
Is this your first modern (light) Samsonite? It seems like it. Firstly, the price is on the low end for Samsonite. Their cheaper offerings don't come with a liner. As for it feeling flimsy to you, that's because it's intended to be lightweight. That does not necessarily mean it will get destroyed easily. I've had several different S luggage which have traveled the globe with me. Sometimes they show up on the luggage conveyor belt with a huge dent, but it pops out or can be pushed out. That's just what you get with thin material. However, mine has never cracked or broken.
they didn't add lining to keep it light weight -3,7kg. it make sense, but this material doesn't looks like a proper Polypropylene. i have a same size and same weight luggage from Roncanto and i can confirm that it should not be sooo soft like the one on the video. not a good model at all >< i use my Roncanto for 7 years. but now i have a problem with a lock >< and trying to find same model but there is none in Thailand ((
i was literally gonna check out on my cart then i saw this. Thanks mate. It's unfortunate that a more expensive model such as this is crap compared to some other models.
Thanks for sharing. Too bad that i see it now…its too late. I already bought it and I’ve got problem with the lock! I am at holiday right now and I can’t open the suitcase. Of course I put the right number in it. I‘m locking know for a video who’s explaining, how to open it without numbers 🙈 No, i wouldn’t recommend to buy that suitcase for the reasons you named !🙈 …and to the flexibility: if the suitcase full packed, you have a hard time to close it…to bring it on all sides to the write position!!
This is the typical greenwashing project from multinationals. ALL there products are made of regular plastics, and then they make ONE suitcase to make a statement as being concerned with the environment. Disgusting marketing.
Thank you for your honest review, I was about to click on "purchase" and I saw your video. On the Samsonite website a review was saying that if the suitcase was half empty it could fold and let some white using marks on the shell. I will finally pick a S'Cure DLX or a "Regular" Magnum (not the Magnum ECO) which are made of regular plastic and are way more stronger.
Hey, from a Tim to another Tim: you should get the normal Magnum not the Eco. It has the inner material and feels more stable than the Eco. But it costs 20€ more.
@@Hieucd97 yes it has. I can highly recommend the suitcase i had 2 bigger vacations with it and i was like „Yes! Finally i spent money to something meaningful“. Greetings from Berlin!
thank you for sharing this, i was close to ordering one.
Me too
and me too
Yup.
same
Same :D
maybe the reviewer is not really know what durable and lightweight means.
That’s how that should be , if the plastic is harder is going to crack under pressure . Is really durable. Samsonite offers 10 years guarantee..
I'm having S'cure for 9 years, set of 3, heavily used (every year at least 2 vacations + multiplr small trips with medium or hand carry) and only this year it got white marks. But true is, I usually carry around 30-32kg in 2 big luggages. Never got anything broken inside. I love the locks - I would never buy any luggage with zipper anymore. And thinking now about new set - S'cure again or Magnum.
The case needs to be flexible! what do you need a liming inside, that's rubbish.Without lining you can clean the inside much better. i never buy suitcases with lining becazse when backing my suitcase is clean, i also use desinfectant.i only have Samsonite case and they last all you life
@@DivaBara88 I like the look of this case with the locks and that it has no zip. I would much rather leave valuables in this case than cases with zips.
Samsonite made the shell specifically to be flexible and bouncable so when it falls or something is dropped on it the suitcase will not crack and just go back to the original shape.
My reaction when I saw it bend was "Nice, it's flexible and won't shatter when dropped!", didn't realize people saw it as a negative.
@@Snailman0 I don't think they understand the benefits of the flexibility. They just think well if it flexes it must be cheap and rubbish?
You missed the whole point man, its flexible but durable on purpose..
Totally disagree with this guy! He clearly didnt get the point regarding the durability of the thing: -The Magnum is made of PET- plastics. Can U name anything more durable than a PET bottle? Yeah, it flexes and its neither rigid or thick. BUT THATS THE WHOLE POINT! If flexes and takes a punch! AND you will never get your fist thru that thing, even if you say so! I have been using this thing for a long time and it still looks new.
What you saw as negative I saw as something positive. Being flexible and durable should be good
The Samsonite Magnum Eco was designed to be a hard "flexible" case.
Magnum Eco is NOT designed to be a hard "rigid" case like the old Samsonite Aeris F'Lite and the S'cure etc.
Samsonite should clarify on their website that Magnum Eco is a hard flexible case, and not a hard rigid case. Watch this Samsonite Cosmolite get driven over by a car and still bounce back to normal: th-cam.com/video/svhTFFhS5q0/w-d-xo.html
I dissagree, i had Samsonite hard shell bags for the past decade! They never broke. My carry on is Magnum eco and I believe it’s fantastic! Yes it’s bending, but NOT breaking…
I don’t really get what is wrong with it. All samsonite suitcases are designed to be flexible. This doesn’t mean it will not protect the stuff inside. It is designed to bounce back to its original shape.
Durable, flexible, lightweight...Still going everywhere
I actually love it when there is no lining. Less hiding places for bedbugs that want to crawl in.
I'm having S'cure for 9 years, set of 3, heavily used (every year at least 2 vacations + multiple small trips with medium or hand carry) and only this year it got white marks. But true is, I usually carry around 30-32kg in 2 big luggages. Never got anything broken inside. I love the locks - I would never buy any luggage with zipper anymore. And thinking now about new set - S'cure again or Magnum.
the material is supposed to be flexible in order to avoid cracking, chipping and breaking. LOL.
@Gaming Emporium this is my thoughts on it too, the material isn’t weak it’s flexible it will take a smashing and not crack ! Mine has been to many countries and not a mark on it !!
This is a stupid review. It is an empty case that he presses down on and it returns to the original shape with no deformities. That is a good thing. It's light and sturdy. I agree with the lining bit but overall this is a case of someone not actually knowing quality.
From someone never experienced the durable suitcase lol which is shame, u don’t know its value 😂
I got one, no problems so far.
Don’t listen to this
I had same luggage martial and much cheaper .. guess what.. had it now for 5 years and travel a lot .. still good..
Stop speeding lies !!
jajajajajaja garbage
Solid points made. I’ll avoid this one. Thanks for the honest review. I’d like to see more from you Tim 👍
Is this your first modern (light) Samsonite? It seems like it. Firstly, the price is on the low end for Samsonite. Their cheaper offerings don't come with a liner. As for it feeling flimsy to you, that's because it's intended to be lightweight. That does not necessarily mean it will get destroyed easily. I've had several different S luggage which have traveled the globe with me. Sometimes they show up on the luggage conveyor belt with a huge dent, but it pops out or can be pushed out. That's just what you get with thin material. However, mine has never cracked or broken.
Thanks for showing me this yogurt 😂
You literally saved me hundreds of dollars, thank you!
they didn't add lining to keep it light weight -3,7kg. it make sense, but this material doesn't looks like a proper Polypropylene. i have a same size and same weight luggage from Roncanto and i can confirm that it should not be sooo soft like the one on the video. not a good model at all >< i use my Roncanto for 7 years. but now i have a problem with a lock >< and trying to find same model but there is none in Thailand ((
i was literally gonna check out on my cart then i saw this. Thanks mate. It's unfortunate that a more expensive model such as this is crap compared to some other models.
Thank you for sharing this. I like your honest, unbiased opinions
Thank you for the honest review. I used it to persuade my husband not to buy this Spinner.
Thanks for sharing. Too bad that i see it now…its too late. I already bought it and I’ve got problem with the lock! I am at holiday right now and I can’t open the suitcase. Of course I put the right number in it.
I‘m locking know for a video who’s explaining, how to open it without numbers 🙈
No, i wouldn’t recommend to buy that suitcase for the reasons you named !🙈
…and to the flexibility: if the suitcase full packed, you have a hard time to close it…to bring it on all sides to the write position!!
Thanks! just in time.
Yoghurt cartons!
When I wipe my new eco it gives some color on cotton. Is it normal?
Thx man! As a lot of people, as I see from comments, I was also close to purchase this one) Thx for you review and good luck!)
Thanks. Very helpful. That case really looks like shit.
Thank you, Tim. Truly wonderful stuff.
Thank you for sharing. I almost buy it 😅
How is it? Do you recommend ?
Wow, it looks solid on the website!
Saved me £800. Thank you!!
how does it compare with the s'cure ?
I just ordered it 😢😢😢😂
This one 79 or 81?
Rainproof ?
I was about to buy one
omg thank you so much for the honest review!!! I almost fell for the design and the idea behind it!
This is the typical greenwashing project from multinationals. ALL there products are made of regular plastics, and then they make ONE suitcase to make a statement as being concerned with the environment. Disgusting marketing.
Thanks for the review mate! almost was going to order this piece of trunk... :)
Glad I seen this, was very close to ordering one myself. 230euro you saved me
It's meant to be light and flexible so it won't break...
Thank you for your honest review, I was about to click on "purchase" and I saw your video. On the Samsonite website a review was saying that if the suitcase was half empty it could fold and let some white using marks on the shell. I will finally pick a S'Cure DLX or a "Regular" Magnum (not the Magnum ECO) which are made of regular plastic and are way more stronger.
good video. I was about to order a cabin and a large one until I saw your video. Guess i'll continue shopping.
Thanks for the review!! At least saved me from a bad purchase.
Lol, just like all the other people I was about to buy this until I saw your video 🤣
Hey, from a Tim to another Tim: you should get the normal Magnum not the Eco. It has the inner material and feels more stable than the Eco. But it costs 20€ more.
Hey another Tim, does the normal Magnum has a firm shell like a normal suitcase?
@@Hieucd97 yes it has. I can highly recommend the suitcase i had 2 bigger vacations with it and i was like „Yes! Finally i spent money to something meaningful“. Greetings from Berlin!
@@t.m.5920 Good stuff! Glad to know it can withstand germany wear and tear as I’m planning to go there. Big thank you from ‘Straya
Thank you so much for the money saved!
That wouldn’t even survive the journey to the airport 😂
Hilarious thanks for sharing
dude thanks! great review
Hiya! great vid- this is different to the magnum spinner?
Besides that, the design is really ugly, like from the previous century.
no
Ooh snap!!! I actually bought mine last week... Here I was thinking this would be a good purchase.. 🙊 😭😭 I guess this is me taking it back
Are you happy with it ?
@@paulocesarcunha8100 I changes it for a Hi-Fi Spinner and it’s great…
Thank you very much mate. that's one of the best reviews I've ever come seen.
I was about to buy two of them at a cost of £400...🫣🤑