Song wouldn’t have performed anywhere near what it did if this was the released version. Halsey brought a raw element to the song that was part of its nostalgia relatability. Camila’s version is focused on vocal performance
Actually this is the OG version of the song, Camila said she would sing it at Coachella with the chainsmokers but she ghosted them so Halsey sang it instead. In my opinion i like Camilas very better
I really like the rawness of Halsey's voice on the original that came out. I really don't think this would have performed as well as it did with Camila on it. Her voice sounds better with Shawn.
A few ppl are saying Camilla’s is better but the voices just don’t go well together at all. Camilla has a stunning voice she really does but it doesn’t go well with the chainsmokers
Well....in 2-3 years this song will turn 10 years and maybe they can release a 10 year anniversary edition and call this " Closer (Alternate version) " or " Closer (Camilla's mix) " or something along those lines!!!!
overall hasley takes the cake with the chainsmokers and the way the voices mix and harmonize so well with each others, but the way camilla sings her verse alone gives me such a good look at the song there’s something about it that’s so good
I think if Halsey and Camilla both were in the final version it would be the best. Along for the male parts call in Bieber or Charlie put or Shawn mendes to sing with the chainsmokers
the lyrics on this are so much better here, but halsey's voice matched the chainsmokers better camilla should just make a solo of this tbh bc her voice alone is beautiful
Esto es maravilloso, la voz de Camila es incomparable, es mágica, me encanta, es como ingenua y sensual a la vez, La Ameee😍❤por que no la interpretó ella, estoy llorandoo😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Halsey definitely fixed the lyrics and made it make more sense to the songs vibes. Also Halsey voice is more strong and powerful than camilas so she’s definitely the better singer
No way, Halsey's version is better for sure, more personality and atittude. Camila's runs and adlibs definetly doesn't match with this song... the people are commenting just because it's different in her voice
Bro Halsey takes the W This was so much better with her. I am honestly scared that this was the first version. :') The song by itself isn't bad but it doesn't speak to me the way Closer with Halsey does
People saying this version wouldn't have been a hit are suffering from cognitive dissonance. Both versions are beautiful for their respective reasons and I dont think the song would have been less than number 1 if this version had been the one released
They are both not bad. Camila''s voice is brighter. When the song transitions from the chains to Halsey in the original there is a dullness. If they released this considering that Camila had already done Bad things with MGK and IKWYDLS with Shawn. This would have performed better with Camila considering that this was only the first demo
En ese tiempo ella pertenecía al grupo fifth harmony y la disquera no permitía que grabará otras canciones porque ya el grupo iba lanzar un álbum. Así que rechazaron a camila y la canción se la dieron a halsey. Se filtro una parte con la voz de camila y la gente le gustó pero ya habían lanzado la de halsey. De todos modos fue un éxito pero hubiera sido mejor con camila la verdad. Ella le dio ese toque a la canción
No offense to Halsey, I like her voice, but I always thought that the female lyrics were a bit not there. It just wasn't feminist enough. Why would she say, 'Why did I leave you'! I like not only Camila's voice and vocals, but her lyrics are beautiful.
Nope. She recorded this fr. But couldn't really go with the whole situation of actually releasing and stuff because she was in the group at the time. She mentions it in an interview.
Halsey's lyrics make more sense and her voice sounds nostalgic.
But in terms of the vocals/adlibs Camila was better.
both lyrics makes sense, halsey one is even better because it's more 'polished' and halsey's voice fits the vibe of the song better
No offence but Halsey’s was actually much better. Her voice suited it way better
Song wouldn’t have performed anywhere near what it did if this was the released version. Halsey brought a raw element to the song that was part of its nostalgia relatability. Camila’s version is focused on vocal performance
We never know. We only say this in retrospect.
@@stealthis no I say it with absolute certainty
But Camilla especially at that time was more famous that plays a huge role
This was a demo track. It probably did not have the detail the main song does. But this is just speculation.
Actually this is the OG version of the song, Camila said she would sing it at Coachella with the chainsmokers but she ghosted them so Halsey sang it instead. In my opinion i like Camilas very better
I really like the rawness of Halsey's voice on the original that came out. I really don't think this would have performed as well as it did with Camila on it. Her voice sounds better with Shawn.
I love Camila's voice so much, but this song really fits Hasley better.
I like both versions each has their moments
chainsmoker's and halseys voices just fit too well for this to be considerd better
A few ppl are saying Camilla’s is better but the voices just don’t go well together at all. Camilla has a stunning voice she really does but it doesn’t go well with the chainsmokers
Pretty sure this is an alternate universe and i even love it
3:22 love this part
Fr i got goosebumps
her lyrics and voice aren't bad but halsey really win this, not even with other artist it would bring up the nostalgia and magic of her voice.
Well....in 2-3 years this song will turn 10 years and maybe they can release a 10 year anniversary edition and call this " Closer (Alternate version) " or " Closer (Camilla's mix) " or something along those lines!!!!
I wish they would but it probably won't happen
overall hasley takes the cake with the chainsmokers and the way the voices mix and harmonize so well with each others, but the way camilla sings her verse alone gives me such a good look at the song there’s something about it that’s so good
Omg this version is so beautiful
Ya era hora 😍😍❤️
Después de tantos años por fin la liberaron 🥺🥺
Halsey version is better, but it fits camila as well!!
Camila has better vocals but Halsey had the better lyrics!
halsey just mirrors wut the chain smokers sing
idk halsey fits the song better with her raw vocals, camilla is kinda forgettable here
Estuve esperando años para que la subieran completaaaaaaa 🥺🥺
Y no esta completa esto fue solo el demo, falta el resultado final por que la parte que se filtro se escucha diferente 😊
Pero suena mejor que la original y eso que es demo. Camila le dio ese toque a la canción
❤ love this her voice
I love both versions
No puedo perdonarte Camila
❤️❤️❤️
La culpa no es de ella 😭 fue de la disquera de fifth harmony. Pinché gente desaprovecharon esta obra de arte de camila
Both versions are amazing. But Camila's demo version it's just so sweet and fits very well, so sad it didn't happend :(
I think if Halsey and Camilla both were in the final version it would be the best. Along for the male parts call in Bieber or Charlie put or Shawn mendes to sing with the chainsmokers
Shit. Who would fund the song?
@@valerioharvey7289Exactly😭
@@MarxrileyAoki my mom's credit card
♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Ahora solo escucho closer con la voz de mi hermosa Camila. Tan hermosa ella como siempre>>>>
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Good music keep it up!!!🎉🎉❤❤
❤❤❤
❤❤
the lyrics on this are so much better here, but halsey's voice matched the chainsmokers better
camilla should just make a solo of this tbh bc her voice alone is beautiful
Agreeee
😍😍😍
DID THIS FINALLY RELEASED
Esto es maravilloso, la voz de Camila es incomparable, es mágica, me encanta, es como ingenua y sensual a la vez, La Ameee😍❤por que no la interpretó ella, estoy llorandoo😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
X2 😭
Halsey definitely fixed the lyrics and made it make more sense to the songs vibes. Also Halsey voice is more strong and powerful than camilas so she’s definitely the better singer
Camila nao devia ter descartado essa véi (sim, ela descartou a anos atrás por causa q ela ainda tava na banda
"Por causa que" troca o causa que por "conta de" vai por mim, sou meio chato com gramática rsrsrsrsrsr
If this version was released, it would never became a hit..
I actually like Camila’s version better
No way, Halsey's version is better for sure, more personality and atittude. Camila's runs and adlibs definetly doesn't match with this song... the people are commenting just because it's different in her voice
Que belleza👏👏👏🫶🫶🎶🎶🎶👍
👏👏👏👏🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀
I like Halsey’s lyrics better, but I like the way Camila sang it better.
I’m glad they didn’t release this.
Ngl i like this one better camilla vibes are just it
Bro Halsey takes the W
This was so much better with her. I am honestly scared that this was the first version. :')
The song by itself isn't bad but it doesn't speak to me the way Closer with Halsey does
Both are good
Since we heard Halsey's version more that's why she sounds good in original one
I remember like 5 years ago I would just listen to the little snippet of her singing it 😂 its not on this one tho but still good
Está buena pero Halsey le da el toque
Lyric?
Camilla and Halsey have different ways of singing, which makes the song sound unique both ways. They are both great singers
apparently i'm crazy because i like this one better than halsey's
This is better ❤❤❤❤
I prefer Halsey's version 💯, her vocals and lyrics are perfect for it
Halsey brought life to this song.
People saying this version wouldn't have been a hit are suffering from cognitive dissonance. Both versions are beautiful for their respective reasons and I dont think the song would have been less than number 1 if this version had been the one released
Both are good, but Halsey's version brought life to the song... It makes u sing along...
I love both each did there thing
who is here in 2024? :) 👋🏼😍💦
Maybe her future self told her that the song is meant for Halsey, that's why she ghosted them
i honestly like these lyrics more but idk i think halsey did better overall :p
This one is different from the snippet
Honestly, I think Halsey's version is better and I also like the lyrics of Halsey's version
Wow. Cool. I think they went with the correct person on the released version. But this is alright.
I think that it wouldve done well if camila sang this tbh, after all this was only the first demo.
Meanwhile in alternate universe:
If Camila Cabello took every opportunity instead of ghosting or leaving the songs:
They are both not bad. Camila''s voice is brighter. When the song transitions from the chains to Halsey in the original there is a dullness. If they released this considering that Camila had already done Bad things with MGK and IKWYDLS with Shawn. This would have performed better with Camila considering that this was only the first demo
Camila Cabello would’ve been a Pop Massiah if she wouldn’t hang out with Taylor Swift back then
aquele momento que fica melhor q o original
Tecnicamente esse é o original ksks
Good that it didn’t released 😅
Alguien sabe porque la rechazó?
En ese tiempo ella pertenecía al grupo fifth harmony y la disquera no permitía que grabará otras canciones porque ya el grupo iba lanzar un álbum. Así que rechazaron a camila y la canción se la dieron a halsey. Se filtro una parte con la voz de camila y la gente le gustó pero ya habían lanzado la de halsey. De todos modos fue un éxito pero hubiera sido mejor con camila la verdad. Ella le dio ese toque a la canción
1:30
It doesn't matter...this song would've been a banger anyway.
Let's stop comparing please
Halsey ❤
Halsey's version made it more significantly beautiful. I think it would really flop if Camila sang it.
Love both versions, but this version is more relatable, I’d say 🤍
halsey's version is better.. this one is also good tho
Og version is like soo much better
Is it going to be realse??
Never.
THIS IS SO MUCH BETTER THAN THE ORIGINAL, I'M CRYING 😭😭😭😭
I hope you are joking.
You should get your ears checked lol
Naah halsey sound has that energy with joy🤌❤
Girl.💀
im not sure
This is good ngl but still prefer the original one
@@gaymerskye this what should have been the original but didn't since she bailed on them
@@gaymerskye that I can refute
Halsey better, this is not bad tho
Onter one is better
sorry it's a no no
Better than official. Stunning vocals from Camila ✨
Halsey sounds way better
No offense to Halsey, I like her voice, but I always thought that the female lyrics were a bit not there. It just wasn't feminist enough. Why would she say, 'Why did I leave you'! I like not only Camila's voice and vocals, but her lyrics are beautiful.
Camila's version is better than Hasley's, it's a shame that the final version was not with Camila
Get your ears checked.
I'd hate this song if this version was released.
Some vocals are misplaced man.
Is a beta
@@GeorgiaMcDunhillYou when people HAVE OPINIONS: 😨😥🙄😡👎‼😭💔😰
These old lyrics are so bad lol
A i
3:19 halsey could NEVER
she actually could
@@hanabuni if she could then she would’ve done it
halsey can def do that better 💀 one thing halsey wouldn't do is GHOST ppl for literally no reason
@@liaselleaeri Camila was still under the management of fifth harmony they didn’t allow her to release this collab. Watch her interview lol
@@crono_digger "if she could then she would’ve done it" why would she when it doesn't suit the song?
people stfu saying that this version wouldn't chart because we'll never know.
Is this AI?
Nope. She recorded this fr. But couldn't really go with the whole situation of actually releasing and stuff because she was in the group at the time. She mentions it in an interview.
Not bettet then the original by far i like this but its not better thank godness she declined
IA
No
1) its AI, not IA
2) its not, its just the demo version
Camila's version isso better
Halsey better
This song so mid either way😂
Camila's tone is too annoying for this song
Damn thats cringe😂
Original is far better
she sure knows how to ruin a song lmao
SHUT UP ITS GOOD
Dude get a life ofc you don’t have nothing to do🤡
When has this song ever been good?
This song is bad, she makes this song better ❤❤❤ for sure
@@notagnameok your joking or ABSOLUTELY CRAZY! If you really think this song is bad you probably had a very sad life
❤❤❤❤❤❤