(BAD!!) Driving: Germany vs. USA | The WORST Drivers?

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ธ.ค. 2024

ความคิดเห็น • 564

  • @carinab.1923
    @carinab.1923 2 ปีที่แล้ว +112

    There have been a few instances when I had to do with the police in Germany and I can confirm that they are your friend and helper. For example: 19 year old Carina has to drive in the middle of the night past an Autobahnkreuz. At that point, I didn't have a navigation system let alone a phone to help me. So I stop on the side of the Autobahn, activate my Warnblinker, pull out my paper maps and try to make sense of where I have to go. Now imagine the police officer tapping on my window and asking if there is a problem, only to be greeted by this young desperate woman and her maps spread out everywhere. He actually called his colleague and they explained to me the proper route. Then they also said that it's illegal to stop like that which now is burned into my brain. But those two guys were a blessing in that horrible, dark and rainy night.
    Anyway, kids: Do not stop on the side of the Autobahn to check your route because you put yourself and others in extreme danger. Better go to the next Rastplatz!

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว +18

      This sounds a lot like an experience my dad had recently. He was pulled over on the side of the road (a rural road in the middle of no where).... the officer pulled over and came up to his window asking what as wrong. My dad said "Oh I am lost on my way to an auction and I don't know where I am. I needed to Google some directions, but I didn't want to do that while I was driving." - The officer was nearly dumbfounded that he was stopped because he didn't want to endanger anyone and was so impressed he thanked him for his thoughfulness.

    • @V100-e5q
      @V100-e5q 2 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      For an American that would be a horrible situation them come to your window and saying: "We are from the government and are here to help."
      To think you're sitting in your cozy dry car and they get soaking wet only to be of assistance!

    • @michaelz.7140
      @michaelz.7140 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@TypeAshton Thats the most normal thing, stop and look for further directions

    • @daviddavidsonn3578
      @daviddavidsonn3578 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      you think cops in Europe are here to shoot you in the head for no reason? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @MSM4U2POM
      @MSM4U2POM 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      In my experience the police are always perfectly reasonable provided you are reasonable with them. Like all of us, I've made stupid mistakaes that I'm not proud of, but on each occasion I simply put my hands up, admitted that I was in the wrong, listened to what they had to say and apologised. These guys have a tough job, and if you make life difficult for them, they'll make it difficult for you. Be civil and the chances are you'll get away with it.

  • @clivewilliams3661
    @clivewilliams3661 2 ปีที่แล้ว +9

    Clearly, in US there is not the emphasis on personal safety as Ashton's seat belt is not properly located. This is noticeable in several other videos where the shoulder belt lies below the shoulder and across the upper arm, this would result in the torso not being properly restrained in an accident. I think that the upper seat belt adjustment is set too low. Jonathon's seat belt wear is exemplary - well done!

  • @Station-Network
    @Station-Network 2 ปีที่แล้ว +111

    When I was on vacation in LA, I decided on a Thursday that I would get a US driver's license. On Friday I went to the test center, took the test with 0 errors, drove 3 times around the block (10 minutes) and got the license. That would be impossible in Germany (fortunately).

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว +8

      Yes in some states the exam is EXTREMELY easy.

    • @klausjuergen
      @klausjuergen 2 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      Don't forget to NOT shoot anyone while driving around the block .... according to Craig Fergusson. ;-)

    • @MBrieger
      @MBrieger 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      I have three driver's licenses. German (old grey one), Mexican ($25 and eye exam, off you go) and California. Now I am no longer current on the requirements in Germany since they came out with the most recent license that is apparently up for renewal after a certain time. Which is the biggest BS, even just to exchange your old one for the new one, if you live abroad. In California, retesting during renewal depends on the violations you may have had. If you had none, all that is needed is an eye exam and off you go.
      Now I have a certain luxury when going somewhere as a tourist and even in the US.
      I can "play" a little dumb and show any of the license when stopped. I could get into trouble in California with a foreign license since as a resident, I have to have a California driver's license. But legally, that is a minor issue for as long as I have a valid one. I once got into a check point in Germany and showed my Mexican one and had no problems.

    • @th5841
      @th5841 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      My wife failed 5 times on her excams before finally succeding...

    • @Kommunisator
      @Kommunisator 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@MBrieger In Germany, they just adopted the EU drivers license (the standardized plastic cards) about 20 years ago. Some things that you were allowed to do with the older ones, but didn't make sense (like driving a 7,5to truck pulling a 14to trailer without taking any test or training or riding a motorbike without limitations if you were older than 25 and had the old grey one) are gone now. If you have an older license, you have to exchange yours, but can keep all the old stuff you were granted back then.
      But no, you don't have to re-take your test at any point - once you got your license, you have it for life. Which is a bit problematic concerning older drivers that don't have the reaction time or eyesight anymore, but still insist on driving everywhere themselves.
      The only people that have to re-take drivers tests are afaik lorry drivers and drivers of public transportation vehicles above a certain age .

  • @pedropenduco3180
    @pedropenduco3180 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    As a Brit I once took a work contract in Louisiana and, because we were there more than 6 months, I went to get a US licence. I was a little shocked at how easy it was. As a for instance, one of my colleagues wanted a motorcycle licence. For the practical part he was supposed to be followed once round the block by the examiner. The examiner explained that he had a hangover so asked my colleague to ride round on his own whilst the examiner checked out of the window! 😮

  • @guenterserwotka8669
    @guenterserwotka8669 2 ปีที่แล้ว +30

    I think you forgot an important difference Germany vs USA: fines in the USA will cause your car insurance to go up, whereas in Germany the premium only goes up if have an insurance claim (from an accident).

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      Jonathan and I were JUST talking about this on our walk. You're right this is such an important difference!

    • @danielbliss1988
      @danielbliss1988 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Not quite universally true. For example Minnesota has the so-called "Dimler ticket", named after the Dimler Amendment, originally written by State Representative Chuck Dimler in the mid 1980s, which makes minor speeding offenses there (typically up to 5 to 10mph over depending on context) not reportable to insurance by keeping them off a driver's record and further allows officers or courts to amend a ticket down to a level covered by the Dimler amendment. The distinction in Germany is that points on the record don't go to insurance like they do in the US.

  • @seanthiar
    @seanthiar 2 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    3:00 There is an option to reduce your points by one single point. You can take a course called "Fahreignungssemiar" once in 5 years and only if you have 5 points or less. The course is offered only by a few certified companies like DEKRA or TÜV and it cost 200-400€

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Ah okay, that makes sense. thank you!

  • @Calamera
    @Calamera 2 ปีที่แล้ว +80

    Fun fact: The MPU in Germany, which you must pass to get your driver's license back, is colloquially called the "Idiotentest" (idiot test). ^^

    • @jpdj2715
      @jpdj2715 2 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      Haha, because the regular exam for a (first) driver's license is not "Narrensicher" ("fool proof" - "you cannot make anything fool proof because fools are so ingenious")

    • @CamaroMann
      @CamaroMann 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@jpdj2715 Yeah, because if you got something fool proof, someone will for sure make a somehow 'better' idiot…

    • @pebo8306
      @pebo8306 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@jpdj2715 That sentence never gets old!LOl

    • @berndhoffmann7703
      @berndhoffmann7703 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      And I have heard of people who struggle to pass it 😜

    • @pebo8306
      @pebo8306 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@berndhoffmann7703 So do I!LOL

  • @SarimDeLaurec
    @SarimDeLaurec 2 ปีที่แล้ว +16

    I remember my driving lessons.
    The instructor told me to stop on the side of a road (not on the Autobahn) and asked what the sign infront of us meant.
    "It means I am not allowed to stop here."
    "Indeed. Now go go go!"
    My cousin on the other hand was told by the same instructor to stop on the side of the Autobahn and asked him, when he was allowed to do that (spoiler, he was not allowed to do that in that instance. If the police cuaght them, the instructor would have gotten into trouble.).
    I liked that instructor. He wanted us to think while driving and not do so distracted or careless.

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Woah I bet that was a bit of reverse psychology. I know when I was practicing to drive my dad took a "sink or swim approach" and had me drive down the highway at rush hour. It made me learn (very quickly) that driving can be overwhelming and you must be extra extra careful.

  • @haukesattler446
    @haukesattler446 2 ปีที่แล้ว +17

    Dear Ashton, talking about safe driving. I did notice that you wear the seatbelt very low (under your shoulder).
    For your own protection the belt should be over your shoulder, like Jonathan does it.
    Usually you can adjust the height of upper mount of the belt on your "B" pillar.
    Just in case Jonathan does drive like Jason Bourne. ;-)

    • @reginas.3491
      @reginas.3491 2 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      That is correct. If you have problems with the belt "cutting" into your neck while wearing it correctly, there are "Gurtpolster" available that soften the hard belt on your skin.
      I'm quite short and always had this problem. And I was mad at myself that I suffered years and years before I could bring myself to buying these (not even expensive!).
      I'll never drive without them again.

    • @cinnamoon1455
      @cinnamoon1455 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@reginas.3491 You can even sew them yourself if you know how to handle a sewing machine. It's a very quick and easy project.

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Thanks! I should have adjusted it when I got into the car share. I'll make sure to do it next time. 😊

  • @ernestmccutcheon9576
    @ernestmccutcheon9576 2 ปีที่แล้ว +23

    Fun Video! The fines for speeding might be lower in Germany, but they balance that out by having speed cameras everywhere, so that the odds that you are going to get a ticket for speeding is much higher in Germany!

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      YES, true, true.

    • @KaiHenningsen
      @KaiHenningsen 2 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      @@TypeAshton On the other hand, Germany is infamous in Europe for its low fines. Pretty much all our neighbors have higher ones.

    • @daemotron
      @daemotron 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      In addition, those fines only apply when you get caught and nothing worse has happened - as soon as a situation gets out of hand (not necessarily an accident, there's the famous "Gefährdung") you're facing far worse sentences, in some cases even under criminal law (e.g. "gefährlicher Eingriff in den Straßenverkehr") - means you end up with a criminal record.

    •  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@KaiHenningsen And they have pretty much the same speed trap systems, so the odds of getting caught are about as high.

    • @NFreund
      @NFreund 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@KaiHenningsen Fines shouldn't be a p***s measung contest who got the longest/highest. German roads are safer than all other European roads - there are other ways to make them even more safe, than just upping fines. (Which don't prevent some of the worst driving errors, which aren't even fined in 90% of the cases)

  • @petrameyer1121
    @petrameyer1121 2 ปีที่แล้ว +19

    That was fun and interesting as usual.
    Allow me to add one point you might have missed: In Germany, you can get points without/before having a driving license. You can get points as a bicycle driver, and be unable to keep your car license or be prevented to attain it at all.

    • @yosgarat3623
      @yosgarat3623 2 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      That's right.
      Cause every rule is for every vehicle on the road. The funny part is that pedestrians are seen as vehicles too. So when you cause an accident because your drunken as an pedestrian you can lose your driver license. (I don't know anyone who in fact lost it in cause of that. But i know someone who did lose it cause he was drunken on bicycle)

    • @anna-ranja4573
      @anna-ranja4573 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Because all are part of the traffic/ Verkehrsteilnehmer and responsable

    • @petrameyer1121
      @petrameyer1121 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@yosgarat3623 My previous statement was incorrect, there are situations where even a pedestrian can get points, see below.

    • @Whiteknuckle157
      @Whiteknuckle157 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Absolutely, I gained my first and only two points in the 70th aged 16 on a bike running a stop singn and causing an accident. Back then there was an 18 point limit. Luckily, never got any further points.

    • @petrameyer1121
      @petrameyer1121 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@UnExcited42 I stand corrected there are indeed cases where pedestrians can accumulate points:
      "Punkte für Fußgänger gibt es nach Angaben des Bundesverkehrsministerium (BMVI) in der Regel bei Zuwiderhandlungen mit Alkohol und Drogen. Aber auch Passanten, die eine geschlossene Schranke an einem Bahnübergang vorsätzlich überqueren, bekommen Punkte. Für diese Regelmissachtung sieht die Punktetabelle Flensburg 1 Punkt vor. Aber auch bei Fußgängern, die sich unerlaubterweise von einem Unfallort entfernen, versteht das Verkehrsrecht keinen Spaß und ahndet solche Verstöße mit 2 Punkten in Flensburg."
      But not for crossing a red light.

  • @calise8783
    @calise8783 2 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    I grew up, and obtained my US license in Massachusetts, one state you showed as one of the more/most difficult driving tests. I had to laugh. Compared to my son’s German driving test, it was waaay to simple and could hardly be classified even as a “test”. And still, I lived in Florida for a few years and THAT test was nothing at all.
    Awww, I feel you on the carsickness. My son got his license this year here in Germany. He is in his “begleitest” driving year being 17. My husband and I give him every opportunity to gain experience including giving him an extra Fahrsicherheitstraining course. So we visited family 3 hours away and allowed him to drive us from Ulm to Frankfurt. My husband sat up front with my son. I was in the back. I can’t tolerate the back for too long. After 2 hours of perfect driving, I made him pullover so I could settle myself and move to the front. So I really feel you.

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Yeah I have always suffered from car sickness. Usually the front seat helps, but it is tough when I am reading notes. The last driving video we stayed mostly in the valley or on the A3. But this time we were doing switch backs in the forest and it proved to be too much.

  • @hansonel
    @hansonel 2 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    Driving is more dangerous in the US IMO for a number of reasons that are related to driving laws, lack of efficient local and regional train and bus networks and possibly culture too. It's way too easy for anyone to get a drivers license here also. In Germany (and other EU countries) I've heard it's much more difficult and expensive to get a licsense. Germans respect driving laws a bit more since it is so expensive to have it suspended - and especially revoked.

  • @Karl-Walter
    @Karl-Walter 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Especially truck drivers in germany are required to wear adequate shoes, driving barefoot or in socks is prohibited. A policeman, that pulled a barefoot trucker over, will insist that proper shoes are put on while driving. Sadly there are many drivers, who treat their cabin as their livingroom and do not apply the obligate footwear.

  • @gabeturner1471
    @gabeturner1471 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    In Pennsylvania if you are on a dark country road at night you are supposed to stop every mile and shoot a flare up towards the sky then wait 10 minutes till moving on.

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Okay so I read that while I was researching for this video and I wasn't sure if that was a real thing. That's CRAZY! Has anyone ever been fined for not doing that?

    • @gabeturner1471
      @gabeturner1471 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@TypeAshton Not that I am aware of, it was to warn livestock to stay away, back before fencing in your herd was more popular, but I think it was just forgotten about in the present day so its technically still on the books.
      Another one that is still "somewhat" enforced is 16 women can not live in a house together cause that is classified as a brothel. Sororities in college do get fined for this on occasion

  • @Cornu341
    @Cornu341 2 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    The last time I checked the German points system it was possible to reduce your points by taking refresh seminars on your own volition. Not sure, if that is still the case after the last reform. In the system before you had much larger point thresholds and the points taken away by those seminars were miniscule in comparison for a serious offender. But it was still a good gesture to someone crossing over from the green to yellow range of points.

    • @seanthiar
      @seanthiar 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Still possible. You can do a course once in five years to reduce one point but only if you have less than 5 points. And only a few companies are authorisized to do such a course like Dekra or TÜV. Don't forget years ago max. points were 15, now there are only 8 and you loose points over time. Some after 2.5years for minor breakings of the law, other after 5years and if the cause for the points was a crime including loss of drivers license it takes 10 years.

  • @CatzHoek
    @CatzHoek 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    There are voluntary options to reduce your points (if you have 1-5 points). You can take a seminar (Fahreignungsseminar/Punktabbauseminar) to get rid of 1 point. However, you can only do that once every 5 years.

  • @XLV750RD01
    @XLV750RD01 2 ปีที่แล้ว +8

    Fact: Parking and speeding tickets don't affect your insurance premium in Germany.
    Causing an accident with one vehicle does not affect your other vehicle's premiums as every vehicle has its separate policy.

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      That is so, so interesting. Jonathan and I were talking about this today - I should have included it in the video notes.

    • @XLV750RD01
      @XLV750RD01 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@TypeAshton Why don't you make a folloiw up video stating consequences for bad drivers. The sequel.
      -
      Europe doesn't allow vehicles to be underinsured or even uninsured. which is a weird concept for an industrialized country like the US If you have a look at your policy you'll see that you're covered for 100 Million Euros.
      Love your well researched and presented videos.

    • @realulli
      @realulli 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Funny enough, if you try to insure another vehicle after getting into an accident, the higher premiums apply.

    • @Andrew-pu7ze
      @Andrew-pu7ze 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      If both vehicles are insured at the same insurance I wouldnt be 100% sure, definetly if you damage a vehicle of the same family/ company which another one of this family/ company you will not be insured for your own damage, even in the voll Kasko.

  • @mizapf
    @mizapf 2 ปีที่แล้ว +11

    Many people believe that fines for driving offenses in Germany are far too low. The problem is not that the state does not dare to take more from the offenders ... it cannot take more.
    The reason is that offenses according to the driving rules are "Ordnungswidrigkeiten" (contravention, a non-criminal offense) and that for this kind of offense there is an upper bound of €1000,- for a fine (Geldbuße), with only few exceptions.
    If you wanted to take a higher fine, or a fine related to the income, you'd have to define a "Straftat" (criminal offense) that can be punished with prison or an amercement (Geldstrafe). The problem is that such an offense typically refers to some generally punishable behavior, not to a non-abidance to some rules.
    Interestingly, people are surprised to hear that showing the finger to other drivers can be punished harder that running over a red light; the former being an insult (which is considered a Straftat), the latter just a contravention.

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Ah this explanation is VERY well done. Thank you for this!!

  • @module79l28
    @module79l28 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Here in Portugal, not only we arrived late at the points' "show" (the points system was implemented only in 2016) but we also did it the opposite way of everyone else: instead of racking up demerit points, drivers were given 12 points and each time they were caught commiting an infraction ("caught" being key word #1), points between 2 and 6 are subtracted from the DL (depending on the severity of the infraction). When the drivers have 4 points left they're mandated to do a Road Safety Course ("mandatory" being key word #2), when they only have 2 points left they'll have to retake a Theory Test, if they reach 0 points they'll lose the DL for 2 years and after that period of time they'll have to retake a driving test. However, if drivers miss the RSC (because key word #2) or fail the Theory Test, they'll lose the rest of remaining points and the 0 points' rule will be applied to them.
    In theory this system should work but in reality it doesn't (because key word #1): a large number of drivers commit enough infractions per day to grant them enough points to lose the DL 2 or 3 times but they don't get caught. The number of drivers who lost all points since 2016, and consequently their DL for 2 years, is so low that if anyone looks at our points system numbers they will think that the portuguese drivers are the best in the world when in reality we're some of the worst.

  • @Tomm9y
    @Tomm9y 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    In the UK the cost of insurance is likely to rapidly increase not only according to the number of points, but also the type of offence. A speeding offence will result in some premium increases, whereas even going through a red light will result in some steep premium increases, more than that it will seriously cost, just to insure yourself. The worse it is, many companies will decline to quote.

  • @gonndirwas9605
    @gonndirwas9605 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    10:15 same in Germany suspended, You get your license back. Revoked, you might redo the training for drivers after some tests and some amount of time.

  • @nordwestbeiwest1899
    @nordwestbeiwest1899 2 ปีที่แล้ว +36

    Wenn ihr schon mal bei dem Thema gute und schlechte Fahrzeugführer seid dann macht doch mal ein aus Spaß eine Theorieprüfung in Deutschland . Es gibt Online Testprüfungen die ihr ohne vorher dafür gelernt zu haben ausprobieren könnt . Würd mich interessieren wie gut ihr seid ? Grüße aus dem Nordwesten Deutschlands .............

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว +13

      Ah that WOULD be a great video (and a good test of our German!) We will add this to the list for future videos.

    • @V100-e5q
      @V100-e5q 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@TypeAshton Highly recommended! I did that once. And failed 4 or 5 times until I got to 100% correct. Some things are new to me as a holder of a grey "Lappen" for 49a.

    • @realulli
      @realulli 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@TypeAshton If you're adventurous and are willing to spend a bit of money, find a driving instructor willing to be videoed and ask him to do a simulated practical exam.

    • @nordwestbeiwest1899
      @nordwestbeiwest1899 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@TypeAshton das könnte sehr interessant werden .

    • @cntrainingcoachingcommunic5900
      @cntrainingcoachingcommunic5900 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Die Prüfungen können auch in englischer Sprache abgelegt werden (und in vielenanderenSprachen). Btw eine ausländische Fahrerlaubnis (aus einem Nicht-EU-Land) kann hier nur für max 185 Tage genutzt werden, danach ist der Erwerb einer deutschen Fahrerlaubnis notwendig, um weiter Auto fahren zu dürfen...

  • @rolandvanravenstein
    @rolandvanravenstein 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Love the audio! Especially the sound effects and the transition and title music!

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Awesome thank you so much!

  • @batoolmutawe9156
    @batoolmutawe9156 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I get car sick a lot, I didn’t think it was a big deal and used to brush it off to bad drivers/bad roads. But I talked to my doctor one day and I was prescribed a medication for it that works in minutes, and honestly, since I started it, I went from walking ~30k steps aday to the normal 8-10k since now I can take the bus or ride a car… if this is a frequent issue, it is worth discussing with your doctor the solution that works best for you and your body.

  • @jonasbartels1716
    @jonasbartels1716 10 หลายเดือนก่อน

    A short add to the beginner drivers in Germany: The status of the beginners driver lasts 2 years which can be extended to 4 years, and is called "Probezeit". During these two years, the rules to lose your license are stricter. Like you mentioned at the image at 14:31, there is 0,00 aclohol concentration allowed when driving. Also driving more than 21 km/h over the speed limit, too short distance to vehicles in front of you, passing on the right or driving over a red light might lead to a longer Probezeit. The sanctions are based on a 3-step-system: At first, if your violation is strong enough, your Probezeit will be extended to 4 years and you need to take an additional class, called "Aufbauseminar" with theoretical classes and observed driving lessons, which are meant to help you reflect your driving style. If you make another violation after the seminar during your extended Probezeit, you get a written warning and a recommendation for an MPU. If you still make violations after that, your license will be taken away. It may also be taken away if you are ordered to take the Aufbauseminar, but can't show prove you've attended it during the time limit (mostly 2 months). More Infos you will see for example on the homepage of the ADAC, the "Allgemeiner Deutscher Auto-Club", in englisch General automotive Club)

    • @MSM4U2POM
      @MSM4U2POM 6 หลายเดือนก่อน

      It's broadly similar in the UK too. Except that here we are polite and call the test for regaining one's licence an "Extended Driving Test" instead of an "Idiotentest", but I concede the german word is better!

  • @ManOfSt33l
    @ManOfSt33l 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    You forgot to mention that if your license is confiscated longer than 2 years at a time in germany (maybe while you failed your first mpu or else) your license expires completely and you have to go to drivers school again (of course only with passed mpu if required). The good thing about this is that all your points in Flensburg also disappear. The points are "glued" to the license and not on the person. If the license expires the points also expires.

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Oh wow I didn't know that!! That is really, really interesting.

    • @KaiHenningsen
      @KaiHenningsen 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      So ... you can get points driving a bike or even as a pedestrian because the points are bound to the person, not the license. And if the license expires, the points also expire, because they're bound to the license, not the person.
      Something doesn't quite feel right there.

    • @KaiHenningsen
      @KaiHenningsen 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@ManOfSt33l Actually, I've lived in Germany for 62 years now. But in any case, I understood what *you* said, I pointed out that this directly conflicts with what *others* said. And it still does. They said that you can, in fact, get points while not having a license.
      Now, I don't know who's right, I was never interested in driving a car, so not all that much interested in the details of how the point system works. But I can compare what different people say and see that there's a conflict.

  • @alfs3
    @alfs3 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    in new orleans/louisiana they have to-go cups and allow you to drink anywhere in public - just like germany - as well as drive-thru daiquiri shops so it's funny you guys mention this here!

  • @NFreund
    @NFreund 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    My instructor was awesome. As a glider pilot, i learned to drive on the airfield at around 15. (Although i have been interested in cars since i was little and i've driven on the lap of my dad on some occasions) He immediatly picked up on that and just let me drive for a bit and then found out on which parts i had to learn a lot. We also did a lot of emergency stuff, like emergency full braking with the ABS, as well as some evasive manoeuvres and high speed driving on the Autobahn (funniest part was, he wanted me to actually reach the cars full speed, which was above 200 km/h and he kept pushing me, while reading a newspaper...he made me recite the things NOT to do when doing higher speeds before and also had me do some emergency braking from very high speeds)
    But - 2 weeks after i got my license, i flipped my dads W124 Mercedes three times...i didn't even get a scratch, but the Landstraße had a realtively long stretch (i crashed right on the beginning of it)...and my instructor actually saw the crash, while teaching another student. No practice with rear wheel drive, a wet grass patch on the side, a little to much enthusiasm...and a ditch on the other side sealed the fate of that car. Been driving W124s for 10 years after that and still have one in the shed...these things where built like absolute tanks and i'm fairly certain, i wouldn't have escaped that easy in any other car. Since then i crashed an advertising pillar (German classic, "Werner - Volles Rooäää!!!" like, i kid you not!) on another car due to a technical defect and crashed on the Autobahn head on, because a semi had to pull out without indicating...and i was looking at the clock at that exact moment. Since then, i've never been distracted while driving and have been driving for over 13 years without a crash.

  • @mauertal
    @mauertal 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I saw a sign on the entrance of a lion park in Australia, where u can drive thru with your car......"Poms on Pushbikes FREE".........But if that was an official one????????

    • @pebo8306
      @pebo8306 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      👍👍👍

  • @arthur_p_dent
    @arthur_p_dent 2 ปีที่แล้ว +11

    10:53 In Germany, there is a comparable difference: that between "Entzug der Fahrerlaubnis" (drivers licence revoked", and "Fahrverbot" (disqualification from driving").
    The chief difference is that the latter is for a set time (1, 2, or 3 months), after which you will automatically get your licence back. (although in certain cases, such as repeated DUI, you may have to pass an "MPU" first, or else possibly have your licence revoked eventualy).
    By contrast, if the licence is revoked, the licence document will be physically destroyed and you will have to apply for a new one (after the minimum time set by the judge; the minimum time is at least 6 months, but the law stipulates that the ban can be forever.) You may have to pass an MPU before you get it. In either case, since it is a brand new licence, it will come with a clean points record.
    Btw, a "Fahrverbot" is easy to get - just run a red light that has been red for more than 1 second, and you get to be a pedestrian for 4 weeks. Although if it is your 1st offense, you will be alllowed to pick the exact time when to serve your disqualification, within a 4 months window.

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      This is an awesome explanation! Thank you so much!

  • @AGWittmann
    @AGWittmann 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Hihihi, the confused Ashton in the last blooper was very funny :D
    But the snippets of us-american and german roads you did show for us were interesting for me, like, the us-engineers design the roads like smaller version of highways. Wide clearing on both sides, gentle slopes and curves, im not sure, but if i would drive on such "mini-highways", i think, i would unwittingly drive faster, because, i will still feel safe with higher speeds on such roads.

  • @michaelgrabner8977
    @michaelgrabner8977 2 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    I don´t know if that is valid today because I don´t drive that much anymore but back in the days when I was young a common unwritten rule was to become extra cautious when encountering a car with a driver wearing a hat (Fahrer mit Hut) on the streets, because those were always the worst drivers ;-D

    • @EyMannMachHin
      @EyMannMachHin 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      As a corollary this also extends to the infamous roll of toilet paper under a crocheted hood in the back window.

  • @trainerfrank9786
    @trainerfrank9786 ปีที่แล้ว

    As an insurance specialist I would like to point out that the data coming from the german insurance association GDV can not show where the worst drivers live. It can only show the number of accidents and the damage done. So other factors like traffic, dangerous crossroads, staged accidents and avarage value of the cars also have an influence.

  • @dazinkeys
    @dazinkeys 2 ปีที่แล้ว +20

    You should have mentioned that the cost of a drivers license in Germany will run you at least 1500 euros and in most states it’s 35 dollars. So the Germans respect the driving laws ( most anyway. ) more so than in the states, as well as in Germany to get the license takes months and you need to go through extensive driving practice

    • @eylolallaneeee
      @eylolallaneeee 2 ปีที่แล้ว +8

      Its more like 2500 on average now. Everything gets more expensive.

    • @samurai5910
      @samurai5910 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@eylolallaneeee It was like 2500 on average a year ago. Now it is at least that or often even more like 4000€.

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Yes this is an excellent point!

    •  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@eylolallaneeee "at least" vs "on average" ;-)

    • @eylolallaneeee
      @eylolallaneeee 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      ​@ Well, last month someone got it for 1,9k, but that was super cheap. So the Median probably is at around 2,5k for us for now, but climbing fast. The Arithmetic mean is probably at 3,5-4k, since there are some outlyer who are up to 7k.

  • @wr6293
    @wr6293 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Good cover of the topic.
    Some comments:
    1) A good indication on where better or worse drivers are living is the Regionalklasse (regional class) of the car insurers as this is based on the number and costs of incidents
    2) DWI and DUI may need explanation (driving while intoxicated & driving under influence)
    3) I had a few encounters in the USA for speeding in the mid and late 1980 when I lived or visited the USA frequently. However I got off with a warning after a longer conversation ich the cop. Don’t know whether that is a thing today still. But it surely never happened to me in Germany!
    4] An MTU I have heard to have been required always to have been required in DUI / DWI
    5) Wearing inappropriate footwear can get you a fine as you said but it can result to loosing your insurance as you acted in gross negligence

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      This is such a great comment! Thank you so much for the additional clarification!

  • @thegreenengineer7994
    @thegreenengineer7994 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    addition to the driving with not propper shoes: when you drive comercially like a Truck or Taxi, this can revoce your license or the insurance, and driving without insurance is illegal in germany

  • @liferethought
    @liferethought 2 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    😂 I identify with both of your versions of driving: I never get sick when I'm driving, but as a passenger the slightest stopping and turns make me quite sick.

  • @remizeeland3505
    @remizeeland3505 2 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    Actually in France it is forbidden to wear slippers or flip flops while driving!
    Also there is/was a law in France that stated that navigation which included warning for upcoming speed cameras was illegal and would result in a fine and confiscation of that device.
    We have goten a fine for parking in front off a post office in France and because we have hard to prenounce and write last name, we had to fill out the ticket ourselves!

    • @karinland8533
      @karinland8533 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      In Germany it is called apropriat footweare

    • @rome0610
      @rome0610 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Well, actual navigation systems don't show speed cameras in France any more, but warn you of (larger) "danger zones". Problem solved...😉

    • @johannschubel4494
      @johannschubel4494 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@karinland8533 Yes, but (theoretically) in Germany you may drive butt naked - there is no law describing a dress code. Only thing is, you meed to cover up before leaving your car and not expose yourself indecenly...

  • @chrstiania
    @chrstiania 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    there's a difference between barefoot and flip flops. driving barefoot is much less of a problem than driving in flip flops. It is actually adviced to drive barefoot if the only other option you have are flip flops or similar shoes that could slip off or get tangled between the pedals.

  • @stephanteuscher6583
    @stephanteuscher6583 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Great as always. I'm so sorry for Ashton. You are a real hero to go through all the car sickness just for the sake of the video.
    Now, a little problem occured: since you talked about bad drivers, no matter what they did, I feel a little awkward. Sometimes I am one of these slightly fast drivers (only once in a blue moon of course) but I don't really feel as a bad driver (of course not - who does). So it would make me very happy if we could agree that drivers who don't drink and never caused an accident in decades can't be bad drivers. 😎

  • @hesky10
    @hesky10 ปีที่แล้ว

    Finland introduced means tested fines, mostly used for speeding, and an article i read announced that a nokia executive received a speeding fine in excess of 100,000 euros as a result of his high salary.
    I think you get a ticket explaining the offence and that your fine will be calculated in due course and you can go to court if you think its too high

  • @berndhoffmann7703
    @berndhoffmann7703 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    12:23 omg, if you are prone to getting car sick, do not read while the car moves. I am usually not getting sea sick, but when reading that is a totally different story..

  • @SvenScholz
    @SvenScholz 2 ปีที่แล้ว +17

    "Duzen" has always to be judged in context. It's not necessarily seen as an insult, it always depends on the circumstances and obvius or not that obvious intentions - to fall into the insult category there has to be an intention to insult someone. If this intention is obvious you don't have to be an official, you can sue the person as well for insulting you. We have freedom of opinion, but not freedom of just insulting other people. A straight forward insult is not an opinion. I can hold the opinion my opposite is an a**hole, i can express that opinion by saying "In my eyes that person over there is an a**hole" but i can't go to the person and call "a**hole" without risking to be sued by that person. Of course in day to day life the risk is very low, but in theory the person could do it.
    But of course if you "duz" an official - not only police staff - in a derogatory manner (and if it is seen as derogatory depends firstly on the recieving part) it can be an "insult to officials" for which you indeed can be fined. If you talk to Police you usually don't know the person so you approach the person like any other person you don't know: with "Sie". As to "duz" a person you don't know in an environment that does not encourage to "duz" in a for everyone involved obvious manner, "duzen" in general is taken as rude and confrontational behaviour. So if you approach towards officials as respectful as you approach towards any other person you don't know, you'll always be fine.
    On the other hand you don't have to act submissive (like "Yes Sir, sorry Sir"), i would presume our police staff would be a little irritated by such behaviour as well, . I would for sure... :-D In german there's the "Sie" form to establish politeness between people who don't know each other, everything on top is not necessary and is seen as exaggerating. If i - as a german - would answer with "Yes, Sir, no Sir, sorry Sir" to a policeman he would ask if i want to "verarsch" him.

    • @rapsack7058
      @rapsack7058 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      There are cases that to uses "Du" form were seen as respectless and insulting and were punished. In this cases the officer said that the person should use the "Sie" form and the person in question ignored it.

    • @berndhoffmann7703
      @berndhoffmann7703 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      love that 'would be a little irritated'
      The only question I have: Does 'Du A-loch' cost more than 'Sie A-loch'?

    • @rapsack7058
      @rapsack7058 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@berndhoffmann7703 Lol, yea the classic one. No, not realy.... but it is up to the judge.

    • @SvenScholz
      @SvenScholz 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@berndhoffmann7703 i would bet on it.. 😀

  • @Jan_Seidel
    @Jan_Seidel 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    My brother wasn't able to pass the MPU until today, which is approx. 15 years.
    He was drunk, crashed a fence and ran away

  • @wolkewolke7704
    @wolkewolke7704 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    I have a friend who lost his driving licence for half a year due to an DUI - after that he had to be checked if he had ever had alcohol during that period of time - it seems that there exist tests ... and if the check that you HAD any alcohol during that period of time you dont get your licence back - have to be testet some months later. I am from Oberösterreich

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      WOAH that's crazy! I mean, it makes sense... having a DUI gives the impression that one could not be responsible with alcohol, but this is a lot different from the US.

  • @Opa_Andre
    @Opa_Andre 2 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Very interesting topic and fun to watch. I'm sorry about you getting sick Ashton during driving which is a horrible experience. I had a lot to do with my granddaughter's car sickness when she was preschool age.
    Another fun fact besides the possibility of getting fined for inappropriate footwear or barefoot driving when being caught in an accident: Did you know that in Germany it is perfectly legal to drive your own car completely naked? You just need to make sure you're dressing up BEFORE leaving your car. And you can be banned and have to leave a public place because you are disturbing the general public with your nudity.

    • @grandmak.
      @grandmak. 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      LOL, have you ever tried ?

    • @Opa_Andre
      @Opa_Andre 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@grandmak. LOL, no - but not because of feeling exposed. In the summer, the leather seats in my car can get pretty hot and you can easily get burned. That's not really practical. But would not bother me to see a pretty woman like that. 🤣

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Okay so... what about if you're driving a convertible? Or a motorcycle? 😂😂😂 Is that still allowed?

    • @grandmak.
      @grandmak. 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@Opa_Andre OPA ! Don't let Oma hear that ! 😂

    • @Opa_Andre
      @Opa_Andre 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@TypeAshton I'm not a lawyer, so I don't know for sure, but I don't think so. If I understood it correctly, you need to be "inside" your car - then the same law / rules apply like in your private household. So I don't think this applies to an convertible - and definitely not to a motorcycle.

  • @ChikinMoose
    @ChikinMoose 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    As a truck driver in Germany, I have to add to the topic of bare foot driving: While, yes, it isn't directly penalized, and can be fined if found to be a contributing factor to an accident, there is also a separate regulation for truck drivers, or actually any professional drivers, coming from the "trade association" (BG Verkehr), listed in the DGUV Vorschrift 70 "Fahrzeuge", § 44 Abs. 2 Unfallverhütungsvorschrift which states " Der Fahrzeugführer muss zum sicheren Führen des Fahrzeuges den Fuß umschließendes Schuhwerk tragen." In translation, this means that a driver has to wear shoes completely enclosing the foot, which automatically excludes bare foot driving, flip flops, etc.
    For professional drivers. The fines for this can vary a lot, and there aren't any publicly available rates, but it can technically be as little as €20 and as high as €30000, as this whole matter falls under "work safety" regulations, and any fines resulting from such violations fit into that bracket, but I might be wrong on that one.

  • @charisma-hornum-fries
    @charisma-hornum-fries 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Oh! About Berlin. It’s probably also because it’s the city with 5he most pedestrians and bikes crammed together with public transport, cars, mopeds, etc. I would never drive a car in Berlin but I love biking there.

  • @thegreenengineer7994
    @thegreenengineer7994 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    the alcohi limit is not quite right for germay, when u show any symptoms of alcohol so no fast reactions etc. the fines start when you have the slightest amount of alcohl and driving under 21 is 0.0 limit...

  • @TheHornoxx
    @TheHornoxx 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    ...guter Beitrag! auch das Frage- Antwortspiel am Ende ;-)

  • @stefanfrank4054
    @stefanfrank4054 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    In germany it is allowed to drive totally naked. But you should better wear shoes because your naked foot can slip off the brake

  • @SirHeinzbond
    @SirHeinzbond 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    one way to find out where in germany are the worst drivers from, is to look at the insurance company, they charge you the most in the most dangerous region (but also the young drivers, foreigners ect) but carefully this includes also rental cars, and they by practice are a big amount of accidents cause many reasons...
    and for who is harder on law, look a bit south, Switzerland and others are not a autoparadies...

  • @joeaverage3444
    @joeaverage3444 ปีที่แล้ว

    Jeff Bridges wore a bathrobe while driving through L.A. in the movie The Big Lebowski, and it didn't seem to get The Dude in trouble. 😅

  • @Aine197
    @Aine197 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    You can get your license suspended in Germany, usually for 30 days, for running a red light, especially if you already have a few points. This is the most likely scenario for how „normal“ people lose their license.
    Usually, they let you choose the month when you hand in your license so that you can organise alternative ways to get around or have it coincide with a long holiday when you don‘t need your license anyway.

  • @sarumanork-orphanage5612
    @sarumanork-orphanage5612 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    12:40 Ooohh that's from the Bourne identity, I just watched it the other night! Great fun actually!
    14:27 Blood alcohol limit is .03% in Germany, it used to be .05%, but they changed it.
    Also it's net null for anyone below the age of 21 and for drivers who have passed their licence 3 years prior or less.
    To put that into perspective, .05% is a small glass of wine, .03% is about a beer and so legally if you want to drink while driving,
    you should consider not finishing your beer or drinking a Radler instead.. which kinda equates that you can't drink while driving...
    You can, but not a terrible lot.
    19:40 -ish, Insulting an officer is illegal, yeah except it's not "Polizeibeamtenbeleidigung",
    but "beamtenbeleidigung", that you're referring to, here. It's not only police officers,
    but also teachers, the people at the Rathaus, even some mailmen have the status of "Beamte".
    Of course you might get in trouble for insulting anybody in Germany, but anyone with a "Verbeamtung" is especially off limits.
    But just imagine, you say your mailman is being a douche and he gets at you with Beamtenbeleidigung,
    it doesn't really happen, but the fact that it could is hilarious ^^

  • @renesalinas9491
    @renesalinas9491 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Dens trafic you'll find in NRW wich is the area with the highest populated area of Germany.

  • @YTUSER583
    @YTUSER583 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Very nice video with interesting information.

  • @alexanderschwarm7755
    @alexanderschwarm7755 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Lights also turn yellow before turning green again, unlike in US.

  • @ralfbauer9625
    @ralfbauer9625 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Hello Ashton, hello Jonathan, happy sunday!
    In my personal opinion the fines in Germany are too low. Look for the scandinavian countries or Switzerland. I call myself a good diverse because whenever possible I User public transportion, only for some journies I use my E- car when it's difficult to reach the destination. Best regards Ralf

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Hi there Ralf! Happy Sunday! We were also really surprised with how low fines are. Thankfully, we've only had a single speeding ticket from a speed camera - but it was only 30 or 35 euros or something like that. Surprisingly low.

    • @ralfbauer9625
      @ralfbauer9625 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Hi Ashton, yor car sickness, remindes of the three basic rulus in car, from the drivers perspective.
      #1 Do not touch any button
      #2 The diversen is in Charge of the music
      #3 Who vommits in the car, has to buy a new one.
      Seriousky, I hope your car sicknes is to Bad and happens often.
      Or is it corraleted to Jonathan's driving

    • @seanthiar
      @seanthiar 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      I'm German and I would like the normal fines (not the court appointed) like they are in Finnland that are income-related. I remember Kimi Raikonnen had to pay 30000€ because his car was overloaded. They assumed his monthly income was 150000€ and set the fine for 30000€ . If you do the same and earn 1500€ I assume the fine would be 300€ in Finnland. Court appointed fines in Germany are already income related. There are many with big cars that behave like idiots but you hear often enough it's cheaper to pay the fine for driving to fast when getting into a speed trap than to loose a contract of a few thousands. That would change if the fine would be high enough to cut deeply into the profit of that contracts.

  • @martinjahnert1527
    @martinjahnert1527 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Nice Video as ever. A law in Germany is, its illegal to drive a car without a reason, you can get fined up to 100€. So if you get stoped by a cop, never answer oh i just drive for fun, it will be an expensive fun. I also get drive sick as passenger when i'm distracted, specially on the way to Feldberg or Schauinsland.

    • @DarkDodger
      @DarkDodger 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      I looked into this, as it seemed strange to me. The only thing I could find was "Unnützes hin- und herfahren" according to §30 StVO. This rule only applies in very specific circumstances, namely inside of towns, and if people are bothered by it. Wikipedia says that it's basically impossible to prove, and it would require you to drive through pedestiran areas at low speeds repeatedly to the point where people were bothered by your existence alone. Is this the rule that you mean?
      Because you can definitely drive for fun. Your post made it sound like having a nice drive through the countryside was illegal.

    • @martinjahnert1527
      @martinjahnert1527 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@DarkDodger yes thats the one I ment. I was fined long time ago for this reason, posing, by a young " Dorfsheriff ". And i was the one who answered I just drive for fun. Sorry that I made it sound like a rule everyone gets fined, but it's possible if you are as stupid as me in my young years.

  • @DonDuracell
    @DonDuracell 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Oh yeah reading while driving is also for me problematic as a passenger. So I feel with you Ashton. 🤢
    I'm in the first days of June in the Black Forest with the motorcycle before heading further South.

  • @jayboom3918
    @jayboom3918 ปีที่แล้ว

    I haven’t been to Germany for a while but there is a law you can get i fine for infrastructures while driving a bicycle and that affects your legal ability to drive a car as well.

  • @edorlas
    @edorlas ปีที่แล้ว

    I currently live in Switzerland: here some fines are based on your income! Famous example is a guy that sold his company for tens of millions, bought a Ferrari and went out to test it out. Obviously drove way too fast (around 30 km/h too fast) and got stopped. Because in that particular year he had a huge income out of the sale of his company, the fine he got was in the millions!!

  • @S_Black
    @S_Black 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    The myth about insulting police officers is that there is a special offense called "Beamtenbeleidigung" (insulting a public employee / officer). There is no such thing. What's true is that insulting people in general is illegal, but if and how this is enforced depends on the circumstances. And it can only be prosecuted if the insulted person bothers to report it, which usually isn't the case. The big exception to that is obviously when you're dealing with police officers in the first place.

  • @manfredfischer8944
    @manfredfischer8944 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Grund für Car-Sickness ist oft, ebenso wie bei der Seekrankheit, wenn man nicht nach draussen sieht, etwas liest oder ins Handy schaut. Das liegt daran, dass die Eindrücke des Gleichgewichtsorgans im Ohr, nicht mit den Sinneswahrnehmungen der Augen (stehendes Bild) übereinstimmen! Also bei solchen Symptomen, nach Draussen (an den Horizont) sehen oder kurz anhalten!

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Ja, ich leide auch sehr stark unter Seekrankheit.

  • @BarbarossaIV
    @BarbarossaIV 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    For me as a german it's nice to hear about my country from another perspektive. Thanks for that.

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Glad you enjoyed the video! Thanks for watching!

  • @wjhann4836
    @wjhann4836 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Well, I assume that curvy streets in the black forest will get very many people sick!
    On the other hand: was it lately more than before 😉😃

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      hahah no, no. Just the car sickness. Unfortunately little Jack also suffers from this as well... which has made for.... a bit of a messy clean up the last few road trips. 😬😬😬

  • @ralfdlouhy9354
    @ralfdlouhy9354 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Hello Black Forest Family,
    another good video. Regarding your comparison between bad and good drivers, I would like to tell you the following. In Germany, the rating (good/bad) is not based on the federal states but on the basis of the person's age. Many statistics show that young drivers (age 18 to 25) and old drivers (age 70+) are among the people with the most accidents.
    The reason for this is the lack of experience among younger people and the fact that older people are overwhelmed by the rules and the ability to react when there is a high volume of traffic. It has been proven that with increasing age, a person's ability to react and pay attention decreases and he is overwhelmed more quickly.
    So make a comparison in terms of age. I think it will also be shown in the USA that states with a very low or very high average age have more accidents.
    I would also like to say something about driving with flip-flops or barefoot. When driving privately, it doesn't really matter whether or which shoes you wear, as long as there is no accident.
    However, if you are on the road professionally as a driver (taxi driver, truck driver, etc.), it is not allowed to wear sturdy shoes, but is prescribed by law by the trade association.
    This is how certain speculations come about.
    I advise you to wear good shoes when driving.
    In cases where a quick reaction is required and the pedals should be pressed well and safely, flip-flops, high heels or bare feet are not very suitable. This can also be proven by studies.
    Finally, a little gimmick about driving in Germany. In Germany, there used to be a program called “The Seventh Sense” that was regularly broadcast on TV. Take a look at it is very funny on the one hand, but unfortunately also very misogynistic, because in the 70s it was still believed that women could not drive a car. Nevertheless, it shows many things that are very instructive on the one hand and funny on the other. Please don't be angry with Ashton when you look at it, we men weren't that far back then :-), today it's been proven that women are better drivers.
    So in this sense all the best and keep it up.
    Many greetings
    Ralf

  • @Nothin-but-the-blues
    @Nothin-but-the-blues 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    The 'Spirzenstrasse' is not the road for someone I would recommend for soomeone who gets perhaps carsick! I drove this way far too often and I'm convinced that
    the area behind the guardrails will be well fertilized every year by co-drivers who have the same problem as you, Ashton (Hope this isn't too harsh), especially in winter
    when it is snowing. The fresh snow makes this road a nightmare because you can't see the track anymore (And driving by hearing is by far not the safest way)!
    Btw.: The 0.05% blood alcohol concentration applies only if you drive without any abnormality. In this case you commit an infringement.
    If you're driving conspuciously (commiting an accident, weaving, too high or too low speed...) the limit is 0,03% and you're commiting a crime!

    • @pebo8306
      @pebo8306 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      👍👍👍

  • @deitschebanana4128
    @deitschebanana4128 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    To reduce car or sea sickness, try anything with ginger e. g. ginger tea, ginger water or ginger drops you can get them in every Rossmann, dm, pharmacy or grocery store. You have to try what suits you best. Nowadays there are even ginger shots available in the vegetable/salad section of mayor grocery stores but I don't know how good these are.

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      I will give that a try! I normally take something called Bodine in the USA - but I forgot to take it this time around.

    • @deitschebanana4128
      @deitschebanana4128 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@TypeAshton There are products similar to Bonine in Germany. Look for "Reisetabletten" in the pharmacy or order from Amazon, but these products can produce side effects. Ginger might be a little weaker than those chemicals at least its natural.

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      I wonder if Ginger might be okay to give to little ones. I always hesitate to give Jack medicine since he's under two - but we have a road trip coming up soon and little guy has puked 4 times now on short car rides.

    • @deitschebanana4128
      @deitschebanana4128 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@TypeAshton Ginger might be too spicy for Jack, maybe if you dilute it enough or try Chamomile tea. Unfortunately remedies for toddlers are mostly chemicals only older kids are able to handle Ginger candies. If you search for "natural remedies for motion sickness in toddlers" you will find a few tips. I'm not sure if these will help since I am no expert in toddlers or kids but its worth a try. My sister always plays a lot with her kids to tire them out or let them go all out on the playground. Once they get on the highway the fall asleep automatically.

  • @gedeuchnixan3830
    @gedeuchnixan3830 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    It might not be forbidden to wear flipflops (cops in Achtung Kontrolle constantly say it is forbidden to drive bare foot or with flipflops/ slippers) but anyway, in case of an accident you better not wearing flipflops or slippers for insurence reasons. Reason being in emergency when you have to hammer the break they can slide off the foot or you can slip sideways off the brake, so not wearing propper footwear you defenitifly getting parcial fault in Germany when the opponant side argues you didn´t brake properly due to the footwear.

  • @dochoe1
    @dochoe1 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    One of the rules I do not under stand is: when overtaking is forbitten by the relevant traffic sign Überholverbot a car is allowed to overtake a motorbike. The other way round it is forbidden? I do not know the reason for this rule

  • @SchlawinerUSA
    @SchlawinerUSA 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    so, watched it finally, but what pops up in my mind, dashcamdriversgermany has a good collection of bad driving in germany :) commented and explained in some cases. and to berlin, my theses is, berlin is a international city.. maybe thats why? and the fines in germany are to low, so many are not intimitaded by fines.. the Quiz was awesome and funny :D and i remember, when i was in PA i was not aloud to have beverages, even if they were closed in the front, i had to have it in the trunk, and even put it in a paper bag carrying to the car.. i kinda laughed at the stores clerk for it.. cause in germany, this no problem, as long as it isnt open.. oh and when have a accident in germany while driving barefoot, chance are that the insurance will not pay :)
    awesome video again!

  • @PPfilmemacher
    @PPfilmemacher 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    7:00 As a Berliner and a car driver my self (for 15 years by now ), I unfortunately have to admit:
    no, the bad driving result is not because of the size of Berlin and the large population (for the most part at least).
    Instead its actually really because of the large amount of bad car drivers, which either ignore on purpose the traffic laws (for example: don’t stoping on Zebras crossings, driving while using their cellphones, don’t doing the „Schulterblick“ at turns or while passing lanes, notorious parking on bicycle lanes and tailgating)
    or they just simply cannot really drive (for example: being totally overwhelmed with the slightest weather changes like snowfall / mist / rain and at multi-lane roundabouts or direction changes at roadworks)
    Also another huge reason for many accidents here in berlin are the cyclists thinking they are indestructible and so acting like rowdies on the streets (or even sidewalks with full of pedestrians), they usually didn’t care if a traffic light is red for them when crossing intersections, driving drunk or under the influence of other substances (This also applies to car drivers) and often riding their bikes at night without any kind of light or reflectors.

    • @m_lies
      @m_lies 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      And I can say that the driving schools are one of the biggest reasons, it's not about preparing you for the streets, it's about how much money they can make without really doing anything! Many driving schools never teach simple things like a motorway, roundabout navigation, and driving on inclines.
      Berlin is also the stronghold of clan crime, sometimes you only have to pay a certain amount of money and you get all the papers... And of course, there are many more reasons

  • @norbertrottenari4516
    @norbertrottenari4516 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    its no longer applied but technically driving in Indiana (as far as i know) you are required to have a person WALK infront of your vehicle and yell "Horseless Carriage"

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      hahahah oh man, really?! That's hilarious.

  • @tomkger5055
    @tomkger5055 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    here´s a little warning for Ashton...if u wear ur seatbelt like this, in case of a frontal accident ( there will will be no mom anymore) u´re head will smash on the dashboard or frontwindow and your neck will beak (expirience of a paramedic). So plz wear it properly OVER your shoulder to protect your life. Nichts desto trotz....keep going, great family:)

  • @johnkitchen4699
    @johnkitchen4699 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Passed my test here in Nevada after driving once round the block including parallel parking behind the only car in the street.
    But I would suggest there is a major flaw in the research - the punishments are only inflicted if the police actually make a stop. In Nevada, Highway Patrol only stop speeding drivers if they are doing over 10mph over the speed limit (the Officer next door explained this to me). Indicating when turning or changing lanes is rare (maybe 25-33% indicate). Check out the death rate on the roads - USA vs just about any country in W Europe and the USA is worse by a factor of 3 or 4 to 1.

    • @arnodobler1096
      @arnodobler1096 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      3% over the speed limit here (applies as a goodwill speedometer deviations)

  • @frida_173uhl4
    @frida_173uhl4 2 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Disregarding traffic rules as a cyclist can (depending on severity of course) also get you points in Flensburg, thus impacting a suspension etc.
    There is also a limit to the points you're allwoed to have as a parent/adult who accompanies a young driver below 18. This can lead to some funny situations at home when teenagers want to list their parents as driving supervisors and then find out that they have too many points to be allowed to do that :-D

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Jonathan was talking to me about this with cyclists! This is really super interesting!!

    • @Andrew-pu7ze
      @Andrew-pu7ze 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Cycling while intoxicated can cause you to loose your license and not be allowed to drive a car.

  • @jpdj2715
    @jpdj2715 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    IIRC, in the 1980s, German TV broadcasted court cases (they may have been re-enacted) and what I picked up from that is that German jurisprudence could get you in jail over a car accident if you had been driving recklessly. If someone died in an accident that might have constituted "culpable death" and got you convicted, when in my/other countries accidents were treated as mere accidents. I can imagine that causing someone else to be handicapped for life also got you convicted along these lines potentially with lifelong alimony payments.

    • @S_Black
      @S_Black 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Just because it's an accident doesn't mean you might not be responsible for it. Going to jail for causing a death like that is not uncommon. The US probably has stricter laws on that.

    • @jpdj2715
      @jpdj2715 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@S_Black - the best country in the world can't be beat and has the most people in jail per capita. Get caught for stealing cookies in the groceries' or kill someone and you're in for life. I got that.
      I should have added that my country was way too lax in its legal approach to culpable death, by the way, and in those 1980s I was impressed by the German approach. It doesn't prevent idiot morons from getting into street races and road rage though.

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Yes, many states term this "vehicular manslaughter" and you could face 20+ years in prison.

    • @jpdj2715
      @jpdj2715 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@TypeAshton - in the jurisprudence of my country, I believe, that manslaughter is between culpable death and murder. In traffic accidents, I presume that manslaughter is more difficult to prove than either culpable death or murder.

    • @KaiHenningsen
      @KaiHenningsen 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@jpdj2715 If I understand the rules for _Totschlag_ correctly, it involves intent that doesn't rise to murder. More likely for accidents seems to be _fahrlässige Tötung_ which seems to correspond to "negligent homicide". But there's also the possibility of the stronger claims. For example, car racing that causes an uninvolved person's death has had the judge call it murder (as in, you knew damn well - or should have known - that this was likely to happen).

  • @bobthebikerny
    @bobthebikerny 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    My ex had the same problem with winding roads and reading a map. Every summer we would go on a 2-week roadtrip to go crawling in caves throughout the US. We first discovered the problem in West Virginia and my solution was to have him put a headlamp on and put a small blanket over his head so his peripheral vision was blocked. No, we weren't spelunkers, we were cavers. Cavers rescue spelunkers. ;-)

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      hahaha I bet that might work! Jack also gets horribly car sick so maybe that could be a solution.

    • @bobthebikerny
      @bobthebikerny 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@TypeAshton I'm sitting here patiently waiting for the talking blanket in the passenger seat.

  • @supernova19805
    @supernova19805 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I'm surprised, Florida wasn't on the worst drivers list. It has become increasingly more hazardous to drive here. Traffic has increased tremendously, and careless and reckless driving has become rampant. For some reason, people in pick-ups are the worst! Just 2 weeks ago, someone drove into my husband's car, while making a lane change w/o looking. Luckily we have dash cams in our cars now. I feel, you really need them here. When my daughter got her license here, all she had to do was pass the written test, then drive around in the PARKING LOT for all of 5 minutes!!!

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Your daughter's experience sounds a lot like Jonathan's in Kansas.

  • @danielbliss1988
    @danielbliss1988 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    The share of drivers with past traffic offenses is not a good way of aligning driving skill. Basically, the northern states in the US enforce traffic standards more than states in the South -- with the exception of the comically easy drivers tests in some northern states. I find as I drive south the level of recklessness generally rises and the level of consideration for other motorists generally drops, although there are areas in the northern US where certain kinds of driving pathology (e.g. grossly excessive speed in the Chicago metro) are concentrated.

  • @ebahapo
    @ebahapo ปีที่แล้ว

    It is indeed illegal to wear flip flops while driving in my country. The rationale behind it is that it could snag on a pedal and impede their proper operation. Then again, it’s a tropical country where wearing flip flops is common most of the year. But driving barefoot is fine.

  • @dorotheehay1945
    @dorotheehay1945 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    In Australia 10km over normal in business car is Australian dollar 473. That is fun.

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Oh shoot, that's expensive!!

  • @eddys.3524
    @eddys.3524 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Where I live your driverslicence in general will be confiscated if speeding over 50kmh or if you're caught while dangerous or reckless driving (art. 5) or DUI over 0.05% or 0.02% for young drivers. When caught speeding over 100kmh you car will be impounded too. If your driverslicence is confiscated the DA will decide if you get it back after paying a fine or if he's going to court. There's no pointsystem in place. Sometimes socalled "educational measures", which are expensive, can be ordered as a requirement to get your licence back too.

  • @Kater9277
    @Kater9277 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    It's not quite true that you get all your licences revoked when you lose one licence. While I interned in a court we had a case where someone had gone 100km/h over the speed-limit on a motorcycle. It was in an area near the Autobahn and no one was hurt, but of course this is an infraction that calls for an immediated loss of your licence. The offender didn't appeal the loss of the motorcycle licence, they were extremely remorseful, but they appealed for the judge to not revoke their car license, because they were a contractor and they needed to drive a van for their work. Since they had no other driving infractions and was very regretful the judge told them she would only give them a fine and revoke their motorcycle license. She didn't want them to lose their livelyhood and completely ruin their life over a momentary lapse in judgement.

    • @eddys.3524
      @eddys.3524 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      In the Netherlands, if your drivers licence is confiscated, suspended or revoked, driving any mode of transportation the licence used to be valid for is a criminal offence. So, if you're caught speeding over 50kmh in your car, you 're also not allowed to ride a moppet anymore until you've got your licence back. Even the mode of transport you're driving/riding can be confiscated.

  • @mirco1205
    @mirco1205 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Well funny thing is, the legal limit of riding a bycicle here in Germany is 1,6 Promille oder what you call it in the U.S.? BAC?

  • @JuJu-zb3zn
    @JuJu-zb3zn 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Would be great to get s better sound quality, still love your chanel

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Yes sorry about that. We bought new microphones and tested them without issue, but for some reason we had new problems here. We will get it fixed.

  • @Grimmrandir
    @Grimmrandir 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    And in germany, I think that you can loose your weapons possesion allowance or the hunting allowance when you loose your drivers licence (because you showed that you cannot be trusted to act responsibly). But I don't know for sure.

  • @jensschroder8214
    @jensschroder8214 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    At a party I met a lawyer who told stories from his practice. Anonymous of course.
    He had a customer who came to him regularly because the customer had problems with the traffic rules. The customer also lost his driver's license because of alcohol and then sought help from a lawyer. The lawyer prepared the customer for the MPU test. But when asked whether the sinful driver wanted to drive home after a glass of beer, he answered literally: "Never in my life, only sometimes...".
    For the lawyer, the driver was a loyal customer, but it went so far that the mother called the lawyer and asked that the guilty driver should not have a driver's license. When the sinful driver came back to the lawyer with a ticket, the lawyer then laid down the defense.
    The reasoning was that no one expected a happy ending when he got his driver's license back in live time.

  • @fuerchtenichts
    @fuerchtenichts 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Just be careful when you meet a german car with a licence plate starting with "OF" ( Ohne Führerschein = without licence).

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Freiburgers always warn of the neighboring "EM" drivers. Kind of like how back in the US, us Illinois drivers would roll our eyes when we see Missouri plates. I think it would be funny to learn who each driver warns others about. 😂

    • @pebo8306
      @pebo8306 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@TypeAshton 😂😂😂--You could write another PHD on this topic!LOL

  • @Sp4mMe
    @Sp4mMe 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Heh. Yeah, reading in cars isn't nice - it's normally caused by the imbalance of having a fixed visual field (so as if you weren't moving) and your inner ear still detecting that you are in fact moving around ... you can try reading in a way where part of your vision is still perceiving the motion but for me it's just not working. A paragraph or so and I got to stop.

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Yeah it's a curse that Ive always struggled with. I also get horribly motion sick on sail boats.

  • @leDespicable
    @leDespicable 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    I can relate regarding the car sickness, I can't read anything or watch anything in the car, if I do that I get sick immediately ^^;

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      SAME. It's bad... and unfortunately Jack has the same problem too.

  • @lordgandalf22
    @lordgandalf22 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    that there isnt a open container law is that we are smart enough to not drink but if they find a open container they do a breath test to make sure you didnt drink it as driver and passengers are allowed to be drunk. And youre license can get permanently revoked so that you need to take a full drivers education again. And the driver education is way harder in europe.

  • @mummamarsh1180
    @mummamarsh1180 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    G’day BFF, thanks again for another well presented video. I was expecting a clip of mr bean to feature in this one . He is always good for a laugh. I had to google where the worst drivers are in Australia. According to a Finder report done before the pandemic, the state with the most reckless drivers was Queensland.
    Some of the dangerous driving habits listed in the report include using mobile phones, eating, driving with your knees, applying makeup, being distracted by children and even shaving while driving.
    The alcohol limit in Australia for driving is 0.05 the same as Germany. We have a lot of speed cameras here, strict speed limits that are actively enforced by police and hefty penalties making your chance of getting caught more likely. Touch wood, after40 years of driving I am proud to say I have only had one fine back in my early 20’s.
    May you always be Safe in your vehicles where ever you are.

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      So funny story... I (Ashton) have a single speeding fine in Germany... and I wasn't even behind the wheel. The car was registered to me, but Jonathan was driving. So when they snapped the speed camera and saw my first name, they just assumed. So I got a nice fine in the mail to "Mr. Ashton Schottler" with Jonathan's face on it. 😂😂😂

    • @KaiHenningsen
      @KaiHenningsen 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      I seem to recall that in my youth, the German limit was 0.08 as mentioned for the US. And also, there are periodically debates about lowering the limit further.

  • @manfredfischer8944
    @manfredfischer8944 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Barfuss fahren in Deutschland ist erlaubt, aber z.b. nicht mit FlipFlops oder HighHeels! (Weil man sich z.B. verhaken oder abrutschen kann)

  • @markferwerda7968
    @markferwerda7968 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    I am an American who lived over 35 years in Germany. This kind of boils it down: German drivers are likely to use their turn signals; American drivers are unlikely to use their turn signals.

    • @TypeAshton
      @TypeAshton  2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Yes I would say this is very, very true.

  • @MrDekuchan
    @MrDekuchan ปีที่แล้ว

    flip flops are not barefoot.....here in germany its illegal to drive with flipflops cause they are lose on the foot. but you are allowed to drive barefoot in all cases.

  • @MHG1023
    @MHG1023 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Regarding driving barefoot we don´t have a specific law here in Germany that prohibits doing so but if caught driving barefoot one may be getting a ticket as a barefoot driver you won´t have full authority over your vehicle (your feet may slip off pedals under certain circumstances and/or you won´t be able to e.g. apply full force on the brake pedali in an emergency situation).
    I am a truck driver and I have witnessed a few road checks on drivers where they were fined for not wearing shoes with straps around heels or even without shoes at all.
    So even driving while wearing shoes without a strap around your heel securing your feet inside the shoes is illegal.
    ... and I´m pretty sure there´s no difference made between driving trucks and POV´s.
    Btw.: The same applies to wearing high heels which are considered equally "unsuitable" for driving.
    If you´re involved in an accident and there´s evidence you´ve been driving without wearing suitable footwear you´ll be held liable by the insurance company.
    That can become pretty expensive.