thomase13 The version of different people playing won't make any difference to me! My initial imagination of the interpretation of the music is in my head. And what's in my head is just how Bach himself would play it, so in other words, any other performer who'd play it, it would simply be a disappointment for me if I were to pay attention to their ways of interpretation, so that being said, since nobody in the whole wide world can play it just like Bach did, it won't make me cry not even a single bit! The only reason why his music puts me to tears is because I hear it just like the way he did!!
After countless transcriptions of his contemporaries concertos, the master is ready to play his own hand and write an original concerto for solo harpsichord. As is clearly evident, all that transcribing was practice well spent! Thank you for taking us on this journey Gerubach. We appreciate all that you do for us fellow music lovers. :)
Johann Sebastian Bach died six years before Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart was born. When he was eight years old, Mozart met Johann Christian Bach, who was a son of J.S. Bach and a composer. At that time the music of J.S. Bach was out of fashion, even his children did not compose in his style. When he was older, Mozart did become familiar with the music of J.S. Bach, in particular with his Well Tempered Clavier. In some of his later works, Mozart was influenced by the music of J.S. Bach
.. apropos , I bet a 1000$ against a dime , here we have a transcription of an unknown Vivaldi concerto ; I know this has already been questioned though :( :(
12:44, how could one possibly have the guts to keep a recording where that flow has been broken and not try again recording the third movement from the beginning?
I think the performer thought that not as a climax but as an end of a phrase and the beginning of an other. It's a debatable decision but still comprehensible.
Alberto Marcantonio I understand this logical assumption, and if it would be the case, not of bad taste, but please take a closer look at that precise moment: i see the full stop there as an harsh way of pointing out the end of a section, he breaks the tempo. What is suggest is, wouldn' t it have been of much greater taste performing that logical separation at the beginning of the new section, rather than at the end of the previous one, breaking the flow that should be kept during the whole movement?
To be precise, why not doing there just a staccato, rather that breaking the tempo, and just pausing a little, right before the part played on the "piano" keyboard of the harpsichord?
@@GregoryCoccox I said most Italians, not all Italians to be clear and direct. I love Vivaldi, Scarlatti, both Marcello brothers, Corelli, Monteverdi, Etc
@@user-fu7zf4ck9z I am very pleased about your Italian musical taste. It is evident Zane, that you are not «one of the most» who ignores the ABCs of the Baroque. Very good! Videos like this one (th-cam.com/video/Ra3I4iYvB9I/w-d-xo.html), where we can hear a bad performance of an Italian composer (quoted by you: Marcello) convey the «scenery» of today musical ignorance. An ignorance i mean, that applauds the German '600-'700, almost as if Italians 600-'700 did not exist. And, above all (above all), it was absolutely unfair that German and English composers, 300 years ago, have deliberately plagiarized Italian musical geniuses, not clearly stating their sources about their «re-compositions». Result: The mediocrity that pervades most of today's «brains», manages to pass off these «transcriptions» as if they were «original compositions». Well; On this point I am uncompromising. Veritas premitur, non opprimitur. G.
:( I hate the baroque period it annoys me cause I have to like study this song tunes ughhhhhh 😑 ( people who see this I don’t ask for your reply or concern so ignore this just like you saw it if you have hate only though)
The raw beauty of the third movement puts me in tears!!
Wow!
If THIS version put you in tears, I don't know *what* would happen if you tried listening to Wanda Landowska's performance!
thomase13 The version of different people playing won't make any difference to me! My initial imagination of the interpretation of the music is in my head. And what's in my head is just how Bach himself would play it, so in other words, any other performer who'd play it, it would simply be a disappointment for me if I were to pay attention to their ways of interpretation, so that being said, since nobody in the whole wide world can play it just like Bach did, it won't make me cry not even a single bit! The only reason why his music puts me to tears is because I hear it just like the way he did!!
@@thomase13 l guess very good also the version of Gustav Leonhardt
@RevivalMusic ‘’Very well then, you play Bach your way, and l shall play Bach His way.’’ -Wanda Landowska
Have you considered doing your videos at 60 fps? It would do wonders for the faster movements.
After countless transcriptions of his contemporaries concertos, the master is ready to play his own hand and write an original concerto for solo harpsichord. As is clearly evident, all that transcribing was practice well spent! Thank you for taking us on this journey Gerubach. We appreciate all that you do for us fellow music lovers. :)
RIP Geru...
I can't get over that Trugschluss at 2:09. It's too good
Styze Soulmaker what is that? I can only find german explanations
I think it means something like a "false ending"
@@postmodernmusicalsophist2503 It's called deceptive motion in english. It's when V goes to vi instead of I
My friend Bach is a very good composer, just like me
@Ori Hershkovitz Kasha Mozart did actually encounter Bach's music in his lifetime. He was very impressed with it.
i love you Mozart!!
You never met Bach. He died when you were -6.
Johann Sebastian Bach died six years before Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart was born. When he was eight years old, Mozart met Johann Christian Bach, who was a son of J.S. Bach and a composer. At that time the music of J.S. Bach was out of fashion, even his children did not compose in his style. When he was older, Mozart did become familiar with the music of J.S. Bach, in particular with his Well Tempered Clavier. In some of his later works, Mozart was influenced by the music of J.S. Bach
😹😹😹
Thanks for uploading!
Esta obra es un milagro, algo inaudito e irrepetible en la historia de la música.
Nah, no es para tanto, el propio Bach tiene obras mejores 😅
Bach +Vivaldi = friends
Браво
1:40 this part is too good
Amazing Video? Do you have a patreon or someway to support your videos?
Mamma Mia molto bene!
Please , can you scroll the score of Bach's Pedal exercitium BWV 598?
th-cam.com/video/-FOVnEnzhCg/w-d-xo.html
Gracias
0:24
2017 edition?
I think it was played by a different person than the previous video
The tuning system sounds different from what I remember too but I might be mistaken.
He explains in the private video he has commented upwards
What's new about this video? :'D
Trevor Pinnock played the old version; this version is Sophie Yates.
This recording was published in 1996, so 2017 only refers to Gerubach's version of the Italian concerto.
Piano and forte on harpsichord???
Of course. Different registers, just as on organ.
Yes!
10:00 looks like some Prelude 23 WTC2
Это уже было!!!
Finally a music by Bach at Last!!!
0:22
9:48
.. apropos , I bet a 1000$ against a dime , here we have a transcription of an unknown Vivaldi concerto ; I know this has already been questioned though :( :(
xcando math those harmonies are to complex for vivaldi i think...
Ha, Vivaldi? No way. This is obviously Bach, don't worry.
If anything, it would be more like Marcello than Vivaldi, anyway.
18th
12:44, how could one possibly have the guts to keep a recording where that flow has been broken and not try again recording the third movement from the beginning?
terryss95 I think that's intentional and not an error.
Alberto Marcantonio
For wich reason? That is one of the main climaxes of the 3rd movement, why break the flow? It would be of poor taste...
I think the performer thought that not as a climax but as an end of a phrase and the beginning of an other. It's a debatable decision but still comprehensible.
Alberto Marcantonio I understand this logical assumption, and if it would be the case, not of bad taste, but please take a closer look at that precise moment: i see the full stop there as an harsh way of pointing out the end of a section, he breaks the tempo.
What is suggest is, wouldn' t it have been of much greater taste performing that logical separation at the beginning of the new section, rather than at the end of the previous one, breaking the flow that should be kept during the whole movement?
To be precise, why not doing there just a staccato, rather that breaking the tempo, and just pausing a little, right before the part played on the "piano" keyboard of the harpsichord?
Apart from the 2nd movement, this is such an overrated piece. But man, Bach can do the Italian style better than most Italians lol!
There is no Bach without Vivaldi. And not vice versa.
History Docet.
G.
@@GregoryCoccox I didn't say anything about Vivaldi but alright
@@user-fu7zf4ck9z sure.
I understand. But, when we talk about Italian style (barocco, in this case) I prefer to be clear and direct.
Peace.
G.
@@GregoryCoccox I said most Italians, not all Italians to be clear and direct. I love Vivaldi, Scarlatti, both Marcello brothers, Corelli, Monteverdi, Etc
@@user-fu7zf4ck9z I am very pleased about your Italian musical taste.
It is evident Zane, that you are not «one of the most» who ignores the ABCs of the Baroque. Very good!
Videos like this one (th-cam.com/video/Ra3I4iYvB9I/w-d-xo.html), where we can hear a bad performance of an Italian composer (quoted by you: Marcello) convey the «scenery» of today musical ignorance.
An ignorance i mean, that applauds the German '600-'700, almost as if Italians 600-'700 did not exist.
And, above all (above all), it was absolutely unfair that German and English composers, 300 years ago, have deliberately plagiarized Italian musical geniuses, not clearly stating their sources about their «re-compositions».
Result: The mediocrity that pervades most of today's «brains», manages to pass off these «transcriptions» as if they were «original compositions».
Well; On this point I am uncompromising.
Veritas premitur, non opprimitur.
G.
:( I hate the baroque period it annoys me cause I have to like study this song tunes ughhhhhh 😑 ( people who see this I don’t ask for your reply or concern so ignore this just like you saw it if you have hate only though)
This is not a song.
Thank you for telling us.
Não tem problema algum você não gostar do Barroco e não se preocupe, que com seu comentário já conseguiu seus 15 minutos de fama!