Great video! Thunderf00t published 3y ago interesting video about Crowder with a very accurate title "Dumbest Climate change denier EVER!!!". The fun starts at 7:50. Crowder posted his video about the "climate warming pause" in the hottest year in recorded history, with every month being the hottest in its category.
I'm glad you finally put out this video. I'm not sure if you were trying to avoid being automatically demonetized or you don't want to get your video hidden by using his first name, but you might want to add it in as to pick up traction.
@Jessica G So then why did rightwing adopt and put onto steroids the one BAD leftwing thing? Another might be chemtrails. Why didn't rightwingers adopt and run with the many GOOD leftwing things? Stopping anti-abortion laws. Equalizing wealth and power for workers: preventing CEOs getting rich off others' labor. Promote veganism primarily for the animals. Fight fossil fuel addiction. If you're going to be chemophobe, then you had better be on the side of the IPCC and against FF addiction. Not alarmist anti-vaxx or anti-chemtrail garbage (chemtrails not even existing, of course).
Great video Tony, an important topic to discuss. Recently I've watched a handful of videos of you and MC Toon argue with flerfs, which can be equal parts hilarious and horrifying, but covering something like this is probably more important. I look forward to more, thank you.
Between climate change denial, anti-vaxx movements and just general NIMBYness, I would think conservatives decided "prevention is not better than a cure" a long time ago...
Anti-vaxx was started and has always been up until March of 2020 a left wing thing. What you just shared there is called revisionist history, being anti-covid gene therapy does not make one anti-vaxx.
@@systematik While it's true there have been and still are some left-wing "all natural" hippies who have been anti-vaxx, I was more talking about the conspiracy nutters who think the government is trying to poison them through vaccines or fluoride in the water or whatever, or even the original "vaccines cause autism" crowd. Between people like Alex Jones, and even Trump making some vaccine-skeptical statements about things like MMR, I'm *pretty sure* this wasn't a left wing thing before 2020...
@@systematik So then why did rightwing adopt and put onto steroids the one BAD leftwing thing? Another might be chemtrails. Why didn't rightwingers adopt and run with the many GOOD leftwing things? Government interference out of abortion. Equalizing wealth and power for workers: preventing CEOs getting rich off others' labor. Promote veganism primarily for the animals. Fight fossil fuel addiction. If you're going to be chemophobe, then you had better be on the side of the IPCC and against FF addiction. Not alarmist anti-vaxx or anti-chemtrail garbage (chemtrails not even existing, of course).
This is an excellent video, thank you. I live in The Netherlands. For obvious reasons, we take climate change extremely seriously. Out infrastructure is very susceptible to changes in global mean surface temperature.
@@PhDTony_original The Maeslantkering storm surge barrier, is a real eye opener when you see it. The technology that's gone into constructing and operating the thing, is mind blowing. It's an engineering masterpiece. However, even this engineering colossus, won't be able to hold back rising sea levels.
@@AndyinMokum I have seen it - it was on the short-list for pictures in this video. The data I have suggest that Earth has enough technical expertise to protect 6 "megacities" from sea level rise. The Netherlands is locked in as one. New York and Shanghai seem locked in as another two. That leaves three slots remaining.
Great video/explanation Tony. Really shows how dishonest/misleading & cherry-picking the deniers are with the data. Also, so very well edited - as always. Sound is practically seamless.
Tony, I've known who you are for some time now, having heard you on many other channels, but apologies for only finding your channel now. Better late than never! Keep up the amazing work 👏
04:54 "...a prerequisite for commenting on climate is knowing what climate is ..." Sounds obvious : but Crowder's show is a gish-gallop presented as comedy. To be really depressed you have to read the comments there, e.g. "When EVERY prediction made since 1943 has been WRONG how do they still have ANY credibility whatsoever?" Yes, that's a real (and typical) comment. Thank you Tony for addressing this.
Thats a brilliant presentation tony, can I ask you a question? Ive heard conspiracy theorists and conservatives say that a volcanic erruption causes the equivelent to 100 years of human impact. Are you able to shed some light on that claim and the impact of volcanos on our climate? as I feel you are a source I can trust. Thanks
The proportions are the opposite. Volcanoes account for about 1% as much CO2 emission as humans do. We can confirm this by direct observation. The carbon dioxide being added to the atmosphere is low in C14 - meaning it has been isolated from the atmosphere for a considerable period. low in C13 - meaning it is organic in origin and no geological as volcanoes are. And it is being emitted as a product of combustion. We can tell that because the partial pressure of CO2 is rising while the partial pressure of oxygen is falling.
Hey PhD Tony.... I consider myself intelligent.... But you are next level.... I follow a guy... But he released a video. I Soooo need ya opinion.... It's a bit over my head 😂 If you respond I link it ... It's kinda scary... But want a PhD to analysis it... Ps love your work
He a earthquake guy.... Been spot on Living in NZ, he reliable.... His latest video is WAY out of the Left field.... Seems legit... Debunk it... Please 🥺🙏
Dr Tony: Could you please destroy Muskrats' and Muskito-brained cultists' delusions that Elon Musk will "save humanity by sending us to Mars"? Thank you!
Sad that the science is decided progressive vs conservative. Blaming one side is one way to ensure the discussions stay out of balance and the real issues will not get dealt with appropriately.
@@PhDTony_original Small-minded thinking is the first thing to abandon. There will be people from both camps who only decide in B&W as thinking would be a flagrant misuse of the word. BS by the barrow abounds from all sides. You have no idea how many from the right are concerned about anthro-caused climate challenges, just as you are uninformed about the leftist side who are hell-bent on destroying everything that holds society together. Please consider rectifying your thinking by asking sincere questions of anyone you disagree with, and you might be surprised. Nuance, not labels, will clear away barriers to dialogue.
@@VaughanMcCue I missed the part where you were discussing facts. All you seem to be doing is whining that people don't like conservatives. Here are some facts for you: In the 1950s the top marginal tax rate in the US was more than 90%. Did capitalism collapse and the US descend into communism? No, the US was able to construct and maintain an immense infrastructure network that improved national prosperity and productivity. The US has the most expensive health care system in the world by a significant margin but ranks 45th in the world in terms of life expectancy. The top 20 countries in the world in terms of life expectancy ALL have socialised health care. An estimated 40,000 Americans die every year from inadequate access to health care. If ISIS did that there would be nukes flying. But because it's conservatives - well what can you do? Socialised health care is cheaper, more efficient and saves lives. And conservative opposition to it is immoral. And spare me whatever fatuous drivel you have prepared about gay marriage, transgenderism or immigration. The problems society faces have exactly one cause: rich greedy fuckwits siphoning off an ever larger portion of GDP and refusing to pay any tax.
@@PhDTony_original Sorry Tony. Much respect for you. I saw Crowder and Steven Crowder popped into my head. He's a right wing racist shill who at all costs avoids debating Sam Seder who is a left wing podcast host. Again sorry Tony I really love and appreciate what you do. I'm playing video games and didn't actually watch your video yet😞
@@oggoblin295 Well, yes, this video is taking on Steven Crowder. I just have no idea who Sam Seder is and what he has to do with Steven Crowder - so I was confused.
@@PhDTony_original Steven Crowder likes to "debate" random college students on campuses on topics that he has memorized a bunch of right wing talking points on. He then gets views from saying, "See, they don't know anything." Stevie refuses to debate anyone who actually studies these topics and knows the facts that crush his parrot points. Sam Seder made him run by ambushing him on a podcast he was a guest on after Stevie refused to debate him for a couple of years. I really hope Stevie is dumb enough to try and counter your points. His ego may make him try.
Thank you for this PhD Tony as an American I am literally losing my hair listening to stupid politics of my country in result of ignorance of climate change. We need to do something as children like my little one will suffer due to the stupid denial of facts.
well, i was gonna listen to this, then i realised you can't seperate an obvious skit from information being presented as fact. you can keep your alarmist religion, i say that because "denial" isn't a word used by proper science.
side note, look at all the public figures who push this alarmism the hardest, they are government officials and/or crazy rich demanding we surrender our quality of life while they fly in private jets to a large airport, then helicopters to a smaller but closer airport then ride in convoys of heavy SUVs to save a few hours on their way to these conferences in exotic or otherwise premium locations. all while they ingnore the pollution of countries like China.
Really? Have you never heard of vaccine deniers and evolution deniers? Sounds to me like you just came up with some bullshit excuse not to challenge your counter-factual beliefs
Excellent video. Must return tomorrow and listen again...
Well, a new video from PhD Tony was totally unexpected, but so happy he did!
Great video, hi tony hope you’re feeling better, and I’m so happy I’ve caught one of your videos the same day it’s gone up 👋
Great one PhD Tony. Sic em! I love your "if you don't know what you are talking about .." quote.
Great video! Thunderf00t published 3y ago interesting video about Crowder with a very accurate title "Dumbest Climate change denier EVER!!!". The fun starts at 7:50. Crowder posted his video about the "climate warming pause" in the hottest year in recorded history, with every month being the hottest in its category.
I'm glad you finally put out this video. I'm not sure if you were trying to avoid being automatically demonetized or you don't want to get your video hidden by using his first name, but you might want to add it in as to pick up traction.
@Jessica G So then why did rightwing adopt and put onto steroids the one BAD leftwing thing? Another might be chemtrails. Why didn't rightwingers adopt and run with the many GOOD leftwing things?
Stopping anti-abortion laws. Equalizing wealth and power for workers: preventing CEOs getting rich off others' labor. Promote veganism primarily for the animals. Fight fossil fuel addiction.
If you're going to be chemophobe, then you had better be on the side of the IPCC and against FF addiction.
Not alarmist anti-vaxx or anti-chemtrail garbage (chemtrails not even existing, of course).
Thank you for the advice. Much appreciated.
almost 2k Lets gooooooooooo
Great video Tony, an important topic to discuss. Recently I've watched a handful of videos of you and MC Toon argue with flerfs, which can be equal parts hilarious and horrifying, but covering something like this is probably more important. I look forward to more, thank you.
Between climate change denial, anti-vaxx movements and just general NIMBYness, I would think conservatives decided "prevention is not better than a cure" a long time ago...
Anti-vaxx was started and has always been up until March of 2020 a left wing thing. What you just shared there is called revisionist history, being anti-covid gene therapy does not make one anti-vaxx.
@@systematik While it's true there have been and still are some left-wing "all natural" hippies who have been anti-vaxx, I was more talking about the conspiracy nutters who think the government is trying to poison them through vaccines or fluoride in the water or whatever, or even the original "vaccines cause autism" crowd. Between people like Alex Jones, and even Trump making some vaccine-skeptical statements about things like MMR, I'm *pretty sure* this wasn't a left wing thing before 2020...
@@systematik So then why did rightwing adopt and put onto steroids the one BAD leftwing thing? Another might be chemtrails. Why didn't rightwingers adopt and run with the many GOOD leftwing things?
Government interference out of abortion. Equalizing wealth and power for workers: preventing CEOs getting rich off others' labor. Promote veganism primarily for the animals. Fight fossil fuel addiction.
If you're going to be chemophobe, then you had better be on the side of the IPCC and against FF addiction.
Not alarmist anti-vaxx or anti-chemtrail garbage (chemtrails not even existing, of course).
This is an excellent video, thank you. I live in The Netherlands. For obvious reasons, we take climate change extremely seriously. Out infrastructure is very susceptible to changes in global mean surface temperature.
For very good reason. One of the most passionate sea level scientists I work with is from the Netherlands.
@@PhDTony_original The Maeslantkering storm surge barrier, is a real eye opener when you see it. The technology that's gone into constructing and operating the thing, is mind blowing. It's an engineering masterpiece. However, even this engineering colossus, won't be able to hold back rising sea levels.
@@AndyinMokum I have seen it - it was on the short-list for pictures in this video.
The data I have suggest that Earth has enough technical expertise to protect 6 "megacities" from sea level rise. The Netherlands is locked in as one.
New York and Shanghai seem locked in as another two. That leaves three slots remaining.
Crowder AIN't the brighest
Bulb in the parcel
Great job, Tony. One of the most frustrating misconceptions in recent years has been that anyone can interpret scientific data correctly.
Ignorance Obliterated, Gibberish Eviscerated.
Brilliant 😁
Good work Tony.
THANK you for calling out this guy (I've never heard of him) for lying and spreading falsehoods.
Great video/explanation Tony. Really shows how dishonest/misleading & cherry-picking the deniers are with the data.
Also, so very well edited - as always. Sound is practically seamless.
The science is not on their side, so they have to do dirty tricks, confuse, mislead, and deceive, just like creationists!
15:39 Who is the woman on the right?
That's a model: Gisele Bundchen
Tony, I've known who you are for some time now, having heard you on many other channels, but apologies for only finding your channel now. Better late than never! Keep up the amazing work 👏
04:54 "...a prerequisite for commenting on climate is knowing what climate is ..." Sounds obvious : but Crowder's show is a gish-gallop presented as comedy. To be really depressed you have to read the comments there, e.g. "When EVERY prediction made since 1943 has been WRONG how do they still have ANY credibility whatsoever?" Yes, that's a real (and typical) comment. Thank you Tony for addressing this.
Thats a brilliant presentation tony, can I ask you a question? Ive heard conspiracy theorists and conservatives say that a volcanic erruption causes the equivelent to 100 years of human impact. Are you able to shed some light on that claim and the impact of volcanos on our climate? as I feel you are a source I can trust. Thanks
The proportions are the opposite. Volcanoes account for about 1% as much CO2 emission as humans do.
We can confirm this by direct observation. The carbon dioxide being added to the atmosphere is low in C14 - meaning it has been isolated from the atmosphere for a considerable period. low in C13 - meaning it is organic in origin and no geological as volcanoes are. And it is being emitted as a product of combustion. We can tell that because the partial pressure of CO2 is rising while the partial pressure of oxygen is falling.
@@PhDTony_original Thanks Tony, keep up the great work against misinformation 👍
Ah, that was a good one! Thanks Tony.
Great vid! Please debate Kent Hovind on MDD. Would be very entertaining to hear you dismantle his arguments.
I would happily debate Kent Govind but I refuse to work with his representative - Standing For Truth - who is a contemptible liar.
30 years, hm? Didn't know that, learned something.
THE SCIENCE IS NEVER SETTLED.
So you believe there's a debate over the shape of the Earth?
I rarely given a "like" before I watched at least half of a video but this one deserves a 👍 already one minute in for its brilliant opening statement.
Potholer did a great job talking about this guy a few years ago... so glad to see he hasn't changed since then.
Hey PhD Tony.... I consider myself intelligent.... But you are next level.... I follow a guy... But he released a video.
I Soooo need ya opinion.... It's a bit over my head 😂
If you respond I link it ...
It's kinda scary... But want a PhD to analysis it...
Ps love your work
Sure, happy to take a look
He a earthquake guy.... Been spot on
Living in NZ, he reliable.... His latest video is WAY out of the Left field....
Seems legit... Debunk it... Please 🥺🙏
@@PhDTony_original th-cam.com/video/z0Ggmi_6JFU/w-d-xo.html
@@nz_kiwi4836 can you give me a name?
Start 5 min in
"I will discuss what science Crowder gets wrong."
Hmmm. I think I can anticipate where this is heading.
Excellent, shared.
Thank you big Oil for Climate Change and Raging Forest Fires Bro!
Dr Tony: Could you please destroy Muskrats' and Muskito-brained cultists' delusions that Elon Musk will "save humanity by sending us to Mars"? Thank you!
Sad that the science is decided progressive vs conservative.
Blaming one side is one way to ensure the discussions stay out of balance and the real issues will not get dealt with appropriately.
That could be remedied by conservatives abandoning anti-science. Which side has the anti-vaccine activists?
@@PhDTony_original
Small-minded thinking is the first thing to abandon.
There will be people from both camps who only decide in B&W as thinking would be a flagrant misuse of the word.
BS by the barrow abounds from all sides.
You have no idea how many from the right are concerned about anthro-caused climate challenges, just as you are uninformed about the leftist side who are hell-bent on destroying everything that holds society together.
Please consider rectifying your thinking by asking sincere questions of anyone you disagree with, and you might be surprised.
Nuance, not labels, will clear away barriers to dialogue.
@@VaughanMcCue If you were capable of nuanced discussion you would not make the comments you do about "destroying society"
@@PhDTony_original Thanks for correcting me with your opinion.
@@VaughanMcCue I missed the part where you were discussing facts. All you seem to be doing is whining that people don't like conservatives.
Here are some facts for you:
In the 1950s the top marginal tax rate in the US was more than 90%. Did capitalism collapse and the US descend into communism? No, the US was able to construct and maintain an immense infrastructure network that improved national prosperity and productivity.
The US has the most expensive health care system in the world by a significant margin but ranks 45th in the world in terms of life expectancy. The top 20 countries in the world in terms of life expectancy ALL have socialised health care.
An estimated 40,000 Americans die every year from inadequate access to health care. If ISIS did that there would be nukes flying. But because it's conservatives - well what can you do?
Socialised health care is cheaper, more efficient and saves lives. And conservative opposition to it is immoral.
And spare me whatever fatuous drivel you have prepared about gay marriage, transgenderism or immigration. The problems society faces have exactly one cause: rich greedy fuckwits siphoning off an ever larger portion of GDP and refusing to pay any tax.
His real name is #coldfeetcrowder.
Oh no Sam Seder, what a fckin nightmare 🤣🤪
Who is Sam Seder and what does he have to do with this video?
@@PhDTony_original Sorry Tony. Much respect for you. I saw Crowder and Steven Crowder popped into my head. He's a right wing racist shill who at all costs avoids debating Sam Seder who is a left wing podcast host. Again sorry Tony I really love and appreciate what you do. I'm playing video games and didn't actually watch your video yet😞
@@oggoblin295 Well, yes, this video is taking on Steven Crowder. I just have no idea who Sam Seder is and what he has to do with Steven Crowder - so I was confused.
@@PhDTony_original huh, the link I tried didn't work. Try again th-cam.com/video/aULN4dCkGQ0/w-d-xo.html
@@PhDTony_original Steven Crowder likes to "debate" random college students on campuses on topics that he has memorized a bunch of right wing talking points on. He then gets views from saying, "See, they don't know anything." Stevie refuses to debate anyone who actually studies these topics and knows the facts that crush his parrot points. Sam Seder made him run by ambushing him on a podcast he was a guest on after Stevie refused to debate him for a couple of years. I really hope Stevie is dumb enough to try and counter your points. His ego may make him try.
"Right wing apologist". Interesting term
Thank you for this PhD Tony as an American I am literally losing my hair listening to stupid politics of my country in result of ignorance of climate change. We need to do something as children like my little one will suffer due to the stupid denial of facts.
well, i was gonna listen to this, then i realised you can't seperate an obvious skit from information being presented as fact.
you can keep your alarmist religion, i say that because "denial" isn't a word used by proper science.
side note, look at all the public figures who push this alarmism the hardest, they are government officials and/or crazy rich demanding we surrender our quality of life while they fly in private jets to a large airport, then helicopters to a smaller but closer airport then ride in convoys of heavy SUVs to save a few hours on their way to these conferences in exotic or otherwise premium locations.
all while they ingnore the pollution of countries like China.
Really? Have you never heard of vaccine deniers and evolution deniers?
Sounds to me like you just came up with some bullshit excuse not to challenge your counter-factual beliefs