I would accept Anakin, but free his mother and bring her to Coruscant. Anakin already had attachments and to expect him to just throw them off was ridiculous.
Jedi Council: Loving your family is a path to the dark side. Personally caring about others? Dark side. Fear of losing those you care about? You fucking Antichrist.
Loving your family was not illegal many jedi had family. But just like anakin feared losing his mother he feared losing asohka and padme which made him angry
Pre-Jordan Basketball Fan They did think the Sith were basically dead at this point. It was their (Ironically) Confidence and pride that clouded their judgement.
poiuytrewq11422 True but, why risk a very powerful force potential being angry at you. Literally couldnt make a better recipe to create a sith if they tried
I feel like that would have changed his mind set to be honest cause I think that kinda tramatized him cause remember he had murdered a whole village of sandpeople just cutting though everyone and thing and then to feel what it was like as you lose your hand
I think training the Young Jedi to be emotionless is what majorly ended up being their undoing. As they had become dull unable to connect with those around them or feel anything, being so set in their ways that they feared even the basic emotions of love. Which is why Anakin/Vader was able to kill them so easy, not only did he know them inside and out and how each Jedi was with the Force while being so much stronger with it than they were. Anakin killed them with a purpose. To save Padme whom he loved more than anything. Anakin did what he did to save Padme and he used his anger and love for her to do it and that is why he out did most Jedi cause he was able to tap into reserves of emotion and resolve that the Jedi simply did not know how. On top of being more force sensitive than they were.
Darth Sidiuos was pretty evil, but the council did really sucked too. They believed that what they thought was always right. The jedi weren't just blinded by the dark side...they were also blinded by their very own thoughts
if palapatine owned Sith Academy...it would look like dungeon...out of 1000 students 1 would become Sith...others would probably get killed during education either by Sidius or "education"
Enxid It was their pretentiousness, arrogance, and dogmatism that led to their downfall. As much as I love Mace Windu, he is sort of the posterchild for everything wrong with the Jedi.
YouCanCallMeReTro There was nothing wrong with the Jedi. They were right that Anakin would turn evil, which is why Mace and Yoda were against training him. And they didn't see the future because Palpatine clouded their vision, he was just that powerful. The Jedi kept peace in the galaxy while trying their best not to be dictators or soldiers. I honestly dont get why people are so quick to judge the Jedi...
Okay, are the Jedi stupid?! Or is it just Anakin? Palpatine clearly showed his disgust for the Jedi... Yet nobody did anything! HE WAS DROPPING HINTS THAT HES THE SITH LORD LIKE CRAZY!! Geeeez!
*"The Star Wars Expanded Universe is a category for many stories some consider to be... non-canon."* *"Is it possible to learn these stories?"* *"Not from Mickey Mouse."*
Anakin Skywalker Anakin, look at what's become of the galaxy with just ONE of you. A legion's worth of emotionally unstable, sand hating, podracing, aircraft spinning, mood swinging, hand losing, senator stalking, angst ridden, dark side serving, youngling killing, wife choking, mentor hating, empire enforcing, daughter torturing, son fighting Jedis like you would drive the galaxy to oblivion.
I really appreciate all the time you take to make us these videos. When I come home from a bad day at work I'm always happy to see one of your uploaded videos. Thanks for the entertainment!
What if General Grievous discovered the truth behind the framing of the Jedi for the bombing of his shuttle and secret brain implants carried out by the Sith and Banking Clan?
This is just awesome. Such an awesome work that you put into every one of your videos. This is why I love youtube and the internet, user created content is just so great. Thank you for the time you put in man, its greatly appreciated.
The Rule of 2 was stupid. I theorize it was to keep the power from being easily noticed by the Jedi. But after the fall of the Jedi, you'd think there would have been more than Palpatine and Vader.
Sarin Highwind The rule of two ensures the sith remain strong. "The Sith aren't fire, we're poison. Divide us among a thousand cups, and we're an annoyance at best. Concentrate us into one cup, then we can stop the heart of the most mighty dragon."
Palpatine's rule was actually the "Rule of One". He had no intent of giving up his power to any of his apprentices. They were mere pawns to advance his goals and expand his power. Although he somewhat seemed to love Anakin in his own twisted way. That can be seen in his concern about him on Mustafar. It seemed very fatherly. He didn't even show that for Maul even though he supposedly had "raised" him from when he was a child.
I know it's not what you asked, but I'm actually really loving your channel, when it comes to Star Wars. You take your time, and teach us everything, even being so kind as to narrate the comics for us. And you do it with a lot of enthusiasm. It's easy for me to tell that you probably love Star Wars just as much as we do. So I'm glad to have come across this channel!
the Jedi were stupid how can a kid who's only loved one is his mom not have any connections? it'd pretty much cause his connection to his mom to be MUCH stronger than most i think that was part of his strength, being taken from and missing his mom; hell it's why he thought he was in love with the first other person to treat him like a human (padme)
You train the boy but you don't let a wet behind the ears, just became a knight yesterday like Obi'wan train him, you give him to someone old safe and boring untill he gets over his rebellious streak then give him to Windu.
Palpatines sith academy would be pretty cool, with yoda and palpatine racing to find the powerful force sensitives and all the fights and problems that would cause for the galaxy. Love your videos dude. Keep up the great work :)
I would accept him as sidious could've just kidnapped him if he was rejected and if he was and sidious did take him, boom now we have the most powerful force sensitive to ever live raised to his full potential and beyond
paused the video after you said you might not do a good palatine voice....came down to give a like, you have a way of being transparent which is sorta rare. I get a lot of enjoyment from your content and i think that might be part of it. Also the palpatine voice did NOT bring me out of the moment,haha. rock on, and may the force be with you...always.
How you don't already have over 1M subscribers is, as Anakin would put it, insulting to the Star Wars order :) You give a great perspective on things and are very interactive with your followers. You acknowledge that Legends is not canon yet know that there are interesting ideas that should be pulled from it. Keep up the good work.
For a Fan fiction: Ani... Vader kills obi and rescues padme. Palpatine finds him with her, and tries to get rid of her by the force. But Vader overthrows him there and then and returns as a fully human (-an arm) sith emperor, and prepares to crush the rebellion of Mon mothma and find the force beyond the outer rim
and I'm glad Luke didn't go with the "only youngling rule" since it allowed for more diverse students that had a better understanding of the life and the people around the galaxy.
yoda commited suicide in ep 6. its more logic than live for 900 years just to die in ep6 before the finale. yoda wanted to be one with the force in order to help luke in the last battle and to restore balance to the force.
I was thinking about it and looking at it and I know snoke theories are stale but I think Snoke may be part of the Yuuzhan Vong. He's tall, he's "seen the rise and fall of the empire"(vong live 3x the length of humans) his forehead is sloped JUST like them, he has no visible hair, etc. Let me know what you think.
I think I would allow it so long as he had a different master. one such as Mace Windu or Yoda. Or even of Qui-Gon Gin didn't die, he could be his master. Obi-wan was under experienced at the time of Anakin's training.
I'm glad that TH-cam recommended this channel to me, love the videos. As for fanfic suggestions, "What if Yoda let Qui Gon start training Anakin immediately?"
The novel was an amazing read, you were right. I particularly had the quote from Dooku's death stuck in my head for a while. Treachery is the way of the sith.
i have question about the jedi and wartime that maybe you can help me with . in ep 5 while luke is training, yoda mentions that the jedi never use the force for offense or to attack. but in times of of war and conflict when the jedi were asked to lead armies and navy they would often find themselves forming battle strategies and tactics. this would lead them to have to be on the offensive and constantly mobile. so I'm a little confused by sodas reasoning. just wondering i you could help me understand little better behind yodas statement.
Sith Apprentice Wanted. Gender: Any Breed: No preference Force: Required Hang for the dark side: Required If you are interested, please ask at the death star With Dark Greetings Darth Sidious ps: Health Insurance: If They Survive Yes Whether the legal is: Me shit No matter I'm The empire I can do What I want Jar Jar: Yousa Mich Can Lick My Assa If you have problems with sand: I do not care And You Couldn't Be Life Insurance. With Dark Greetings Darth Sidious
Yes I would train Anakin and and trust him with more then what the Jedi did because the Jedi were reading more so heavily, into his clouded future that they tainted him they kept on pushing him away why do you think Palpatine latched onto and it can so easily, is because the Jedi was not treating him the way that they know they should have at the chosen one to actually bring the balance the way it should have been instead of 30 to 40 years, later when he's faced with his son and Palpatine just like how Yoda nearly tried to do the same thing to Luke in episode 5 of Star Wars saying that he's too old when in fact, he's feeling the same exact thing that might happen to him that happened to Anakin. So if the Jedi would have taken a better interest into the training of Anakin and not looks so harshly and deeply into his cluttered future, they practically pushed and a can into that clouded future.
I've learned so much from you. You provide the most amazing information and after I watched episode 1-7 and rogue one I thought I knew everything about Star Wars but I realized I was wrong after only watching ONE of your videos that there is so much more to the Star Wars universe. Keep making more and more videos because as I commented earlier on a past video your the best "info giver" in the galaxy 😁 btw you hearted that comment where I said that so plz heart this comment to :)
What if Anakin saved Shmi from the Sand People? What if Padme had gone along with what Anakin was rambling about on Mustafar? What if Ahsoka found out about Anakin's secret marriage? What if Obi-Wan left the order for Satine, as he mentioned in Clone Wars that he once considered doing? What if Dooku didn't leave the order after Qui-Gon's death? Going alongside the previous, What if Anakin was assigned as a Padawan to Dooku? These are just some ideas of mine for a fan fiction alternate timeline :) Hope you like it! As for whether or not I think I would have allowed Anakin into the Order, I would most definitely, as at least within the Order I could better keep him from falling to the dark side and murdering us all.
Hmm... evil Padme. Anakin/Vader: I can overthrow the emperor! Join me, and we will rule the galaxy as husband and wife! Padme: It goes against everything I stand for and have worked for my whole life, but okay! We've already got heirs on the way. Oh, turns out we're having twins. And that's how Luke and Leia became prince and princess of the empire. Obi-Wan would probably have to die on Mustafar for this to work, though. Anakin could overthrow the emperor, but he'd lack Palaptine's political skills and spend a huge amount of time having to put out rebellion after rebellion. He'd win, but his victories would be pretty much the only thing keeping the empire together. Padme might go along with it for the sake of her children, who she'd probably teach while their father was away. Luke might retrieve his father's old blue lightsaber (assuming that Vader would have adopted a red one by now), and be sent to train with Yoda and overthrow his father. Ideally, he and Leia would take control of Vader's empire and restore the republic. The major wrinkle in the plot is that Vader probably intended for the rule of two to pass down to father and son (this is hinted at in Empire), so he'd be trained as a sith-to-be by Vader at some point. Much of the story could remain the same, or similar. Perhaps Vader found out that Luke was being trained somewhere at Padme's urging and tortured her to lure Luke back, where they'd fight. As for Vader's empire, it would be less stable than Palpatine's, but he wouldn't make the mistake of wasting resources on two Death Stars (Vader wasn't too fond of the idea, something we've known since 1977, at least!) He'd be able to use those resources on a larger fleet, which he'd need if he was constantly busy putting out lots of small rebellions.
I always envisioned Padme, if she did go alongside Anakin's plan, taking advantage of her power to stabilize and reform the galaxy. While the Republic might not formally exist, I would imagine Anakin's empire turning into a constitutional monarchy with Padme being de facto in charge of the political management of the Empire. Anakin probably wouldn't mind, as he would trust in Padme to reform the Empire, and would probably go on a campaign or two to wipe out slavery from the galaxy. Hell, he might even take the 501st into the Coruscant lower levels and just clean up the mess there.
If this were Anakin before he was a Sith, I'd agree, but after becoming a Sith, he would probably cling to every scrap of power he'd be able to get his hands on. If Padme even appeared to interfere, he'd kill her. Or choke her and accidentally kill her. I'm sure he'd clean up quite a few places... by massacring everyone in said places. We'd get an empire free of sandpeople, that's for sure. And gungans, I hope.
I don't know, remember that he wouldn't have guidance on how to be a Sith, and he never really aimed to be a Sith- he would probably try to gain power, yes, but Anakin himself stated that he despised the political system. If Padme gets it right (and I think she could, she is after all pretty smart, and their wishes of reform are similar), then Anakin might very well just concentrate on increasing his Force powers and finding a way to become immortal. Because even though once Palpatine dies and Padme gives birth, Anakin would probably want to make sure his fears would never happen.
Even without aiming to be a Sith, he embraced the dark side. Odds are, he wouldn't have overthrown Palpatine immediately. He'd learn a bit more and then overthrow him. Of course, Anakin had authoritarian views to begin with and said very clearly that he would rule the galaxy. Padme didn't want this, but she could never really get him to stop. She couldn't turn him from the dark side, even if Obi-Wan didn't sneak onto the ship. He'd keep Padme safe. Very safe. Possibly not let her out of the palace he'd usurp from the emperor. Keep her under lock and key.
Awesome video!Plz make a fan fiction about all of Anakins enemy's having high heels,then they would always have the high ground.Or make one about high heels made from sand.That would be terrifying for Anakin
Doolu was great character, in some novels(i forgot wich one) he was alot more present when we learn alot about him and he was cool and original character
I would have had him trained by master yoda. The most powerful and important Jedi gets trained by a kid who just lost his master and became a knight the quick way? No offence to obi wan but he wasn't ready.
I'd have anakin trained by either Yoda or Mace. Mace could teach him how to control his dark side, and yoda could balance his use of the force so it was stuff other than just force pull & choke and fire.
I have a question, that maybe you could make a short video about. what are some force powers that only come from the light side? there are many powers that only come from the dark side, but what about powers that just come from thee light?
You should do a series on the various types of star-fighters. The X-Wing, Y-Wing, tie fighters, jedi-starfighter, etc. Explaining their origins, stats, and their role in the star wars universe.
I have a plot hole Yoda is about 900 years old and in the original trilogy he seemed like a old wise thing that could barely move And in the prequels only about 20 years earlier he was way more athletic and was fighting sith at full speed How would somebody 900 years old take 20 years so dramatically
He probably had access to life extending medicines back in the republic and only became athletic when he is using the force when he was in a combat situation. Most of the time he used a hover-chair, whilst after order 66 he used a walking stick. Also he didn't have to worry about hiding from dark sides agent hunting him down. When he was on Dagobah he was living in a swamp which isn't exactly the healthiest place to live having access only to what he can find in the natural surrounding near where he was living. Also he was avoiding trying exert any significant amount of the force least he would be detected and hunted down by the sith
Living on degoba (idk how the fuck you spell it) probably drained him due to the heavy presence of the dark side. Which was so great it was able to completely hide his connection with the light side of the force. It was probably much greater than that though, considering it apparently hid yoda’s, obiwan’s force ghosts’ and Luke’s presence from darth vader and the emperor all at the same time. Not to mention yoda probably exercised less too. If you don’t use it, you lose it.
In the Legends Book Rule of Two, there was a character named Caleb. He was a powerful healer who had "force" abilities, he collected his force from the nature and even demonstrated not feeling pain by sticking his whole hand in a cauldron of boiling liquid. I'm wondering is there a lot more different type of force users beside the Jedi and Sith?
*Palpatine,* a master manipulator, is a similar character in the movies The Lord of the Rings: *Sauron* who manipulates his Ring power to deceive the elves, man, and others to gain power. It turns out *Palpatine and Sauron* are the biggest deceivers as well as the biggest losers. 😎
Keep up the great work on your videos. I also have an idea for a future video if you have not already covered it, would Anakin have killed Dooku if Obi-Wan was not knocked out.
I'm not sure if you've done this yet, but I'd like to see this. During episode III when Anakin tells Mace Windu about Palpatine being Sidious, and Mace tells Anakin to stay behind while 'he' goes to confront Palpatine, what if Anakin listened and he remained behind at the Jedi Temple and sided with the Jedi after whatever events transpired in Palpatine's office.
I literally just finished Revenge of The Sith last night and am now reading Dark Lord: The Rise of Darth Vader. It's pretty awesome to see this video the day after finishing the book with all of the information still fresh on my mind.
The ROTS novel is one of the best way to expand upon the characters and make their POV more understandable. I personally would like to explore more of were the Jedi went wrong, and how they could make a correction without the crisis of the Sith.
If I can, can you answer a big question for me. I have seen the moives and TV shows about star wars but I never have read the books. But do the books ever talk about the blue guy who is with Dark Sidious? I know he is evil but why or how long has he known the truth about Dark Sidious? Also what happens to them after the 3rd movie where is last seen with Dark Sidious. After Dark Sidious fights Yado?? Maybe you have already made a video about this but I am pretty new to your videos. Thank you.
Master Ani what are we going to do, they have the high ground...
They under estimate our power
Star Wars Theory can you please do "What if Qui-gon Jinn and Obi-Wan Kenobi killed Darth Maul in the Phantom Menace ?"
DO IT
what if askoka stayed in the Jedi order
carlos pareja star wars theory you should do that theory too.
That moment when your gonna tell anakin Palpatine is the Sith Lord but you get your head cut off
#relateable
U got off his hand, he wanted revenge.
According to Palpatine
Did he try in the books? I never got why he would let himself be sacrificied like a worthless pawn like that.
Dooku ur cool
Count Dooku Lol sorry Count Dooku it seems you were a little over your *head*
What If the younglings had the high ground?
Dualme what if they had the high ground...and Sand?
David Kay Anakins worst fears.
CHomab Cjabeb That's cute.
LOL high ground ftw
There would be a lot of small corpses on the high ground I suppose lol
I would accept Anakin, but free his mother and bring her to Coruscant. Anakin already had attachments and to expect him to just throw them off was ridiculous.
Jedi Council: Loving your family is a path to the dark side. Personally caring about others? Dark side. Fear of losing those you care about? You fucking Antichrist.
Loving your family was not illegal many jedi had family. But just like anakin feared losing his mother he feared losing asohka and padme which made him angry
What if Obi-Wan drank Qui-Gon's gin?
Then we would have the Auralnaut's version of Obi Wan.
But his mum said he could
drank, and that was already covered.
Why, Thank You....
As a Jedi you *HAVE* to train Anakin or otherwise you are simply allowing a Sith to have more time to train him. Siths can sense his potenial too.
Pre-Jordan Basketball Fan They did think the Sith were basically dead at this point. It was their (Ironically) Confidence and pride that clouded their judgement.
poiuytrewq11422 True but, why risk a very powerful force potential being angry at you. Literally couldnt make a better recipe to create a sith if they tried
What if Anakin never lost his hand?
In Attack of The Clones
ChickenManiac then he would have 2 hands
Goddess Miranda.Cosgrove hahaha
Maybe he would continue fighting Count Dooku and defeated him.
Or maybe not))
I feel like that would have changed his mind set to be honest cause I think that kinda tramatized him cause remember he had murdered a whole village of sandpeople just cutting though everyone and thing and then to feel what it was like as you lose your hand
He lost a arm
I think training the Young Jedi to be emotionless is what majorly ended up being their undoing. As they had become dull unable to connect with those around them or feel anything, being so set in their ways that they feared even the basic emotions of love. Which is why Anakin/Vader was able to kill them so easy, not only did he know them inside and out and how each Jedi was with the Force while being so much stronger with it than they were. Anakin killed them with a purpose. To save Padme whom he loved more than anything. Anakin did what he did to save Padme and he used his anger and love for her to do it and that is why he out did most Jedi cause he was able to tap into reserves of emotion and resolve that the Jedi simply did not know how. On top of being more force sensitive than they were.
What if the force didn't penetrate us?
Catalin Panduru 💀💀😂
Catalin Panduru LOL true
Frank Snyder Oh but it did on me ;)
luke Skywalker the 2nd hello there!
darth vader Hello father! hows it going?
What if Lando's deal wasn't getting worse all the time?
Then lord Vader wouldn't had to consider leaving a garrison.
Before I clicked on the video, I read the title and I had the idea the Jedi were perverts since they train kids in a temple... alone...
Bobafett 3820 .....I...I..I have nothing to say...
Bobafett 3820 you're a clone
Bobafett 3820 they are jedi not Catholic....
Bobafett 3820 dam son rly lol
Callum Finlayson-Palmer Catholic. That's funny as hell. 😀
Darth Sidiuos was pretty evil, but the council did really sucked too. They believed that what they thought was always right. The jedi weren't just blinded by the dark side...they were also blinded by their very own thoughts
Endix well too much light in one's eyes can blind you to certain truths.
if palapatine owned Sith Academy...it would look like dungeon...out of 1000 students 1 would become Sith...others would probably get killed during education either by Sidius or "education"
Enxid It was their pretentiousness, arrogance, and dogmatism that led to their downfall. As much as I love Mace Windu, he is sort of the posterchild for everything wrong with the Jedi.
YouCanCallMeReTro yeah
YouCanCallMeReTro There was nothing wrong with the Jedi. They were right that Anakin would turn evil, which is why Mace and Yoda were against training him. And they didn't see the future because Palpatine clouded their vision, he was just that powerful. The Jedi kept peace in the galaxy while trying their best not to be dictators or soldiers. I honestly dont get why people are so quick to judge the Jedi...
Your hero, your savior has returned. I'm back bitches and I'm here to rid this comment section of Anakin Skywalker.
Sand i dont like sand!
Sand thank you!
Sand Are you rough and coarse?
Sand you should team up with the high ground and be unstoppable!
Sand I HATE YOU!!!
What if Leia was taken in by Uncle Owen and Aunt Beru and Luke by Bail Organa?
Tommy Burke Prince Luke Organa, Leia Skywalker.
Leia: “Who’s here...?”
C-3PO: “Prince Luke, Mistress Leia.”
Leia: “the prince, he’s HERE?”
Hello there..
Obi-Wan Kenobi general kenobi
You are a bold one
Obi-Wan Kenobi "You wanna buy some death sticksss?"
Death Sticks must be the worst name for a drug ever, who was in charge of marketing these things?
hello
My favorite part of your videos are those little clips that you put in always putting them in at the right time to make the video funny.
Okay, are the Jedi stupid?! Or is it just Anakin? Palpatine clearly showed his disgust for the Jedi... Yet nobody did anything! HE WAS DROPPING HINTS THAT HES THE SITH LORD LIKE CRAZY!! Geeeez!
Starwarsrap1 the old jedi were indeed stupid. look how they ran the order as a whole
Starwarsrap1 stop thinking the characters know wat u know
Yeah, it was very obvious he was after a while but nobody noticed.
Specially with his dialog to Anakin.
True!
But remember this is a movie & movie would be ruined if they knew.... 🎥 🍿
*"The Star Wars Expanded Universe is a category for many stories some consider to be... non-canon."*
*"Is it possible to learn these stories?"*
*"Not from Mickey Mouse."*
**distant 'ha-hah!'**
My Lord is that legal?
I will make it legal
@Nute Gunray it's only *illegal* until you get caught.
Nute Gunray I was not aware.
Darth Sidious DEW IT!!!!
Is it *regar
What if Anakin and Palpatine left Obi-wan in the ship in the beginning of Episode III?
Alexander 2387 How the fuck can you miss spell my name
Red Five Happens.. like when someone misspells misspell. It just happens.
If they were any older, the Jedi would have to deal with a bunch of Anakins.
Miguel Burgos yup
anikin, you are course and rough and irritating. and you get everywhere. inside padme, for example.
Anakin Skywalker Anakin, look at what's become of the galaxy with just ONE of you. A legion's worth of emotionally unstable, sand hating, podracing, aircraft spinning, mood swinging, hand losing, senator stalking, angst ridden, dark side serving, youngling killing, wife choking, mentor hating, empire enforcing, daughter torturing, son fighting Jedis like you would drive the galaxy to oblivion.
The Jedi have been dealing with them for thousands of years with great success.
I really appreciate all the time you take to make us these videos. When I come home from a bad day at work I'm always happy to see one of your uploaded videos. Thanks for the entertainment!
What if General Grievous discovered the truth behind the framing of the Jedi for the bombing of his shuttle and secret brain implants carried out by the Sith and Banking Clan?
Then he would have slaughtered a lot of separatist leaders until Tyrannous killed him. By the way I don't think that's canon anymore.
What if Boba Fett killed Mace WIndu in the clone wars?
Bob Smith That is a good one! I would love to see that fanfic 😃
Bob Smith Jango Fett*
Templar Knight no boba fett, watch the clone wars if you don't know what he's talking about.
Templar Knight watch clone wars its boba
Or what if young little Boba pulled a fast one at the battle of Geonosis?
What if Anakin had the high ground?
What if Anakin noticed the highcround first and instantly jumped to it.
yesssss
what if spock died on Vulcan?
What if the high ground had anakin
Nothing, Maul and Grevious both had highground over Obi-Wan... Obi-Wan only said that, because he is a MEME lord. He was mocking Anakin.
This is just awesome. Such an awesome work that you put into every one of your videos. This is why I love youtube and the internet, user created content is just so great. Thank you for the time you put in man, its greatly appreciated.
What if palpatine abolished the rule of two after the death of plagueis?
The Rule of 2 was stupid.
I theorize it was to keep the power from being easily noticed by the Jedi.
But after the fall of the Jedi, you'd think there would have been more than Palpatine and Vader.
Sarin Highwind
The rule of two ensures the sith remain strong.
"The Sith aren't fire, we're poison. Divide us among a thousand cups, and we're an annoyance at best. Concentrate us into one cup, then we can stop the heart of the most mighty dragon."
Jazzy Dooku is how his name was spelled. I know it was weird.
Palpatine's rule was actually the "Rule of One". He had no intent of giving up his power to any of his apprentices. They were mere pawns to advance his goals and expand his power. Although he somewhat seemed to love Anakin in his own twisted way. That can be seen in his concern about him on Mustafar. It seemed very fatherly. He didn't even show that for Maul even though he supposedly had "raised" him from when he was a child.
@Ava R Grevious is not officially sith
I know it's not what you asked, but I'm actually really loving your channel, when it comes to Star Wars. You take your time, and teach us everything, even being so kind as to narrate the comics for us. And you do it with a lot of enthusiasm. It's easy for me to tell that you probably love Star Wars just as much as we do. So I'm glad to have come across this channel!
the Jedi were stupid
how can a kid who's only loved one is his mom not have any connections?
it'd pretty much cause his connection to his mom to be MUCH stronger than most
i think that was part of his strength, being taken from and missing his mom; hell it's why he thought he was in love with the first other person to treat him like a human (padme)
You train the boy but you don't let a wet behind the ears, just became a knight yesterday like Obi'wan train him, you give him to someone old safe and boring untill he gets over his rebellious streak then give him to Windu.
I would've gone with Yoda or Qui-Gon. Rules about masters and knights being allowed one student be damned.
What if Vader turned to the light side upon learning of Luke's identity, rather than at the very end?
“Fear is the path to the dark side…fear leads anger…anger leads to hate…hate leads to suffering. Let it go, my apprentice.”
What if Padme gave birth to Luke and Leia before Order 66 and Anakin's turn to the dark side.
Palpatines sith academy would be pretty cool, with yoda and palpatine racing to find the powerful force sensitives and all the fights and problems that would cause for the galaxy. Love your videos dude. Keep up the great work :)
I would accept him as sidious could've just kidnapped him if he was rejected and if he was and sidious did take him, boom now we have the most powerful force sensitive to ever live raised to his full potential and beyond
paused the video after you said you might not do a good palatine voice....came down to give a like, you have a way of being transparent which is sorta rare. I get a lot of enjoyment from your content and i think that might be part of it. Also the palpatine voice did NOT bring me out of the moment,haha. rock on, and may the force be with you...always.
What if starkiller had beaten and replaced darth Vader after A New Hope.
How you don't already have over 1M subscribers is, as Anakin would put it, insulting to the Star Wars order :) You give a great perspective on things and are very interactive with your followers. You acknowledge that Legends is not canon yet know that there are interesting ideas that should be pulled from it. Keep up the good work.
For a Fan fiction: Ani... Vader kills obi and rescues padme. Palpatine finds him with her, and tries to get rid of her by the force. But Vader overthrows him there and then and returns as a fully human (-an arm) sith emperor, and prepares to crush the rebellion of Mon mothma and find the force beyond the outer rim
you're editing is great, love the voices and effects!
and I'm glad Luke didn't go with the "only youngling rule" since it allowed for more diverse students that had a better understanding of the life and the people around the galaxy.
yoda commited suicide in ep 6.
its more logic than live for 900 years just to die in ep6 before the finale.
yoda wanted to be one with the force in order to help luke in the last battle and to restore balance to the force.
More like living on a swamp VS in a comfy temple with the absolute best medical staff in the galaxy after suffering horrible PTSD shortens ones life.
awesome videos , very well edited and very entertaining and also well informed . keep up the good work
I dont have the high groumd but im still high.
Trevor Philips I have a joke, want to hear it?
The Lost MC.
Trevor Philips You're still an amateur.
Trevor Philips how's Michael and Franklin?
Holden GulleyRussell Franklin is getting high and Michael is drinking.
Trevor Philips are out doing both?
dude, your channel rocks, but lil ani saying "i hope so" just earned you another sub, well played sir...well played.
If the Jedi didn't accept Anakin then Palpatine would have swooped in right away or Qui Gon would have left the Jedi order in order to train him.
good video and great job on palpatines voice it sounded great, keep up the good work.
I was thinking about it and looking at it and I know snoke theories are stale but I think Snoke may be part of the Yuuzhan Vong. He's tall, he's "seen the rise and fall of the empire"(vong live 3x the length of humans) his forehead is sloped JUST like them, he has no visible hair, etc. Let me know what you think.
But Snoke is Force-Sensitive, not Force-Resistant as the Yuuzhan Vong are.
Brendan hmmm... nice food for thought
I really enjoy your videos!!! Great Theories and answer allot of questions I have sometimes! Keep them coming!
I think I would allow it so long as he had a different master. one such as Mace Windu or Yoda. Or even of Qui-Gon Gin didn't die, he could be his master. Obi-wan was under experienced at the time of Anakin's training.
I'm glad that TH-cam recommended this channel to me, love the videos. As for fanfic suggestions, "What if Yoda let Qui Gon start training Anakin immediately?"
what if the cloning process went wrong and the clones didnt follow order 66.
The novel was an amazing read, you were right. I particularly had the quote from Dooku's death stuck in my head for a while.
Treachery is the way of the sith.
What If Hugo Damask/Darth Plagueis was unwise?
i have question about the jedi and wartime that maybe you can help me with . in ep 5 while luke is training, yoda mentions that the jedi never use the force for offense or to attack. but in times of of war and conflict when the jedi were asked to lead armies and navy they would often find themselves forming battle strategies and tactics. this would lead them to have to be on the offensive and constantly mobile. so I'm a little confused by sodas reasoning. just wondering i you could help me understand little better behind yodas statement.
Sith Apprentice Wanted.
Gender: Any
Breed: No preference
Force: Required
Hang for the dark side: Required
If you are interested, please ask at the death star
With Dark Greetings Darth Sidious
ps:
Health Insurance: If They Survive Yes
Whether the legal is: Me shit No matter I'm The empire I can do What I want
Jar Jar: Yousa Mich Can Lick My Assa
If you have problems with sand: I do not care
And You Couldn't Be Life Insurance.
With Dark Greetings Darth Sidious
Darth Sidious Yousa is not allowed to have apperentice while mesa is yousa masta
Lord Sidious is that legal
Is there benefits?
Gender: Either*
TheCommunistDragon They got a good dental plan.
Your voices are always top notch :D
Yes I would train Anakin and and trust him with more then what the Jedi did because the Jedi were reading more so heavily, into his clouded future that they tainted him they kept on pushing him away why do you think Palpatine latched onto and it can so easily, is because the Jedi was not treating him the way that they know they should have at the chosen one to actually bring the balance the way it should have been instead of 30 to 40 years, later when he's faced with his son and Palpatine just like how Yoda nearly tried to do the same thing to Luke in episode 5 of Star Wars saying that he's too old when in fact, he's feeling the same exact thing that might happen to him that happened to Anakin. So if the Jedi would have taken a better interest into the training of Anakin and not looks so harshly and deeply into his cluttered future, they practically pushed and a can into that clouded future.
I've learned so much from you.
You provide the most amazing information and after I watched episode 1-7 and rogue one I thought I knew everything about Star Wars but I realized I was wrong after only watching ONE of your videos that there is so much more to the Star Wars universe. Keep making more and more videos because as I commented earlier on a past video your the best "info giver" in the galaxy 😁 btw you hearted that comment where I said that so plz heart this comment to :)
What if Anakin saved Shmi from the Sand People?
What if Padme had gone along with what Anakin was rambling about on Mustafar?
What if Ahsoka found out about Anakin's secret marriage?
What if Obi-Wan left the order for Satine, as he mentioned in Clone Wars that he once considered doing?
What if Dooku didn't leave the order after Qui-Gon's death?
Going alongside the previous, What if Anakin was assigned as a Padawan to Dooku?
These are just some ideas of mine for a fan fiction alternate timeline :) Hope you like it!
As for whether or not I think I would have allowed Anakin into the Order, I would most definitely, as at least within the Order I could better keep him from falling to the dark side and murdering us all.
Hmm... evil Padme.
Anakin/Vader: I can overthrow the emperor! Join me, and we will rule the galaxy as husband and wife!
Padme: It goes against everything I stand for and have worked for my whole life, but okay! We've already got heirs on the way. Oh, turns out we're having twins.
And that's how Luke and Leia became prince and princess of the empire. Obi-Wan would probably have to die on Mustafar for this to work, though.
Anakin could overthrow the emperor, but he'd lack Palaptine's political skills and spend a huge amount of time having to put out rebellion after rebellion. He'd win, but his victories would be pretty much the only thing keeping the empire together. Padme might go along with it for the sake of her children, who she'd probably teach while their father was away. Luke might retrieve his father's old blue lightsaber (assuming that Vader would have adopted a red one by now), and be sent to train with Yoda and overthrow his father. Ideally, he and Leia would take control of Vader's empire and restore the republic. The major wrinkle in the plot is that Vader probably intended for the rule of two to pass down to father and son (this is hinted at in Empire), so he'd be trained as a sith-to-be by Vader at some point. Much of the story could remain the same, or similar. Perhaps Vader found out that Luke was being trained somewhere at Padme's urging and tortured her to lure Luke back, where they'd fight.
As for Vader's empire, it would be less stable than Palpatine's, but he wouldn't make the mistake of wasting resources on two Death Stars (Vader wasn't too fond of the idea, something we've known since 1977, at least!) He'd be able to use those resources on a larger fleet, which he'd need if he was constantly busy putting out lots of small rebellions.
I always envisioned Padme, if she did go alongside Anakin's plan, taking advantage of her power to stabilize and reform the galaxy. While the Republic might not formally exist, I would imagine Anakin's empire turning into a constitutional monarchy with Padme being de facto in charge of the political management of the Empire. Anakin probably wouldn't mind, as he would trust in Padme to reform the Empire, and would probably go on a campaign or two to wipe out slavery from the galaxy. Hell, he might even take the 501st into the Coruscant lower levels and just clean up the mess there.
If this were Anakin before he was a Sith, I'd agree, but after becoming a Sith, he would probably cling to every scrap of power he'd be able to get his hands on. If Padme even appeared to interfere, he'd kill her. Or choke her and accidentally kill her. I'm sure he'd clean up quite a few places... by massacring everyone in said places. We'd get an empire free of sandpeople, that's for sure. And gungans, I hope.
I don't know, remember that he wouldn't have guidance on how to be a Sith, and he never really aimed to be a Sith- he would probably try to gain power, yes, but Anakin himself stated that he despised the political system. If Padme gets it right (and I think she could, she is after all pretty smart, and their wishes of reform are similar), then Anakin might very well just concentrate on increasing his Force powers and finding a way to become immortal. Because even though once Palpatine dies and Padme gives birth, Anakin would probably want to make sure his fears would never happen.
Even without aiming to be a Sith, he embraced the dark side. Odds are, he wouldn't have overthrown Palpatine immediately. He'd learn a bit more and then overthrow him. Of course, Anakin had authoritarian views to begin with and said very clearly that he would rule the galaxy. Padme didn't want this, but she could never really get him to stop. She couldn't turn him from the dark side, even if Obi-Wan didn't sneak onto the ship. He'd keep Padme safe. Very safe. Possibly not let her out of the palace he'd usurp from the emperor. Keep her under lock and key.
Awesome video!Plz make a fan fiction about all of Anakins enemy's having high heels,then they would always have the high ground.Or make one about high heels made from sand.That would be terrifying for Anakin
what if the jedi council refused to accept anakin after qui gonn requested he be trained?
As soon as I was done watching this, the video immediatley popped up in my notifications.
What if Sidious died during CW, so Dooku would have became the Sith lord?
I liked Dooku. =(
Doolu was great character, in some novels(i forgot wich one) he was alot more present when we learn alot about him and he was cool and original character
Once agin another amazing video :)!! Gives me the chills with each video knowing how some things can come true in the Star was sarga :)
fanfiction you say?
i think it's time for
what anakin and ahsoka fell in love
Awesome video,! Love this channel!
I would have had him trained by master yoda. The most powerful and important Jedi gets trained by a kid who just lost his master and became a knight the quick way? No offence to obi wan but he wasn't ready.
I'd have anakin trained by either Yoda or Mace. Mace could teach him how to control his dark side, and yoda could balance his use of the force so it was stuff other than just force pull & choke and fire.
you're an awesome storyteller love your work!
What if palpatine was trained as a jedi
I think he already made this one :-D
No he didn't sadly
That was stupendous wave I thought
Yeah, it was
What was Ki-Adi Mundi's lightsaber combat technique?
What if Darth Jar Jar revealed himself to the Jedi
He would be arrested for indecent exposure... :-P
All2Meme What if Darth Plagueis wasn't wise?
Well, he did pick Palpatine as an apprentice, so we need to make our own judgments on Plagueis's wisdom...
Darth Jar Jar is too smart to reveal himself, he wouldnt do it, he operates in the shadows xd
I have a question, that maybe you could make a short video about. what are some force powers that only come from the light side? there are many powers that only come from the dark side, but what about powers that just come from thee light?
I did not read the book what did Anakin say he wanted?!?!?!?
I always seem to come and watch these videos an hour after they're uploaded.
what if Palpatine was in love with Anikan?
finally someone else shares my train of thought
Great video, loved this insight.
What if Anakin had a twin brother or sister?
tomorrow is my birthday so make it a great video. I really enjoy these
DEW IT!
Darth Vader love it when he says that 🤣😭😭😭
You should do a series on the various types of star-fighters. The X-Wing, Y-Wing, tie fighters, jedi-starfighter, etc. Explaining their origins, stats, and their role in the star wars universe.
I have a plot hole
Yoda is about 900 years old and in the original trilogy he seemed like a old wise thing that could barely move
And in the prequels only about 20 years earlier he was way more athletic and was fighting sith at full speed
How would somebody 900 years old take 20 years so dramatically
tie boy6FtW asians look young till their 50s /60s. after they age rapidly. maybe something like this
He probably had access to life extending medicines back in the republic and only became athletic when he is using the force when he was in a combat situation. Most of the time he used a hover-chair, whilst after order 66 he used a walking stick. Also he didn't have to worry about hiding from dark sides agent hunting him down.
When he was on Dagobah he was living in a swamp which isn't exactly the healthiest place to live having access only to what he can find in the natural surrounding near where he was living. Also he was avoiding trying exert any significant amount of the force least he would be detected and hunted down by the sith
Living on degoba (idk how the fuck you spell it) probably drained him due to the heavy presence of the dark side. Which was so great it was able to completely hide his connection with the light side of the force. It was probably much greater than that though, considering it apparently hid yoda’s, obiwan’s force ghosts’ and Luke’s presence from darth vader and the emperor all at the same time.
Not to mention yoda probably exercised less too. If you don’t use it, you lose it.
"When in exile on distant swamp world without practicing your techniques, rusty you will become too"
Why do you assume his species ages gradually?
Really diggin your content!
Train the boy
Could you please do a what if for if R2 didn't fix the Millennium Falcon's Hyperdrive in Empire Strikes Back?
hello there
In the Legends Book Rule of Two, there was a character named Caleb. He was a powerful healer who had "force" abilities, he collected his force from the nature and even demonstrated not feeling pain by sticking his whole hand in a cauldron of boiling liquid. I'm wondering is there a lot more different type of force users beside the Jedi and Sith?
*Palpatine,* a master manipulator, is a similar character in the movies The Lord of the Rings: *Sauron* who manipulates his Ring power to deceive the elves, man, and others to gain power. It turns out *Palpatine and Sauron* are the biggest deceivers as well as the biggest losers. 😎
very well done. sir. may the force be with you.
Hi, can you do a video on why Yoda doesn't recognise R2-D2 in Empire Strikes Back?
Keep up the great work on your videos. I also have an idea for a future video if you have not already covered it, would Anakin have killed Dooku if Obi-Wan was not knocked out.
Just a question when will you reveal the winner of the saber giveaway?
Please, do a video for force-sensitive droids. We know there were a few of them in rare cases. Thanks and keep up with the good work.
I'm not sure if you've done this yet, but I'd like to see this.
During episode III when Anakin tells Mace Windu about Palpatine being Sidious, and Mace tells Anakin to stay behind while 'he' goes to confront Palpatine, what if Anakin listened and he remained behind at the Jedi Temple and sided with the Jedi after whatever events transpired in Palpatine's office.
Good video.I luv tour Star wars videos, it helps me understand.
Thank you for doing the voice!
I literally just finished Revenge of The Sith last night and am now reading Dark Lord: The Rise of Darth Vader. It's pretty awesome to see this video the day after finishing the book with all of the information still fresh on my mind.
Hey Star Wars Theory. Where do you announce the winners of the lightsaber contest? I would like Anakin's lightsaber. Thanks.
The ROTS novel is one of the best way to expand upon the characters and make their POV more understandable. I personally would like to explore more of were the Jedi went wrong, and how they could make a correction without the crisis of the Sith.
Gotta love the updated intro.
If I can, can you answer a big question for me. I have seen the moives and TV shows about star wars but I never have read the books. But do the books ever talk about the blue guy who is with Dark Sidious? I know he is evil but why or how long has he known the truth about Dark Sidious? Also what happens to them after the 3rd movie where is last seen with Dark Sidious. After Dark Sidious fights Yado?? Maybe you have already made a video about this but I am pretty new to your videos. Thank you.