FIRST TIME HEARING Pink Floyd - The Great Gig in the Sky REACTION
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 ส.ค. 2024
- WAIT - before checking out the comments section of this video, make sure to subscribe to this TH-cam channel & ring the notification bell for more awesome content!
SAY THANKS WITH COFFEE :)
www.buymeacoff...
SHOP LATEST COLLECTION
rosalie-reacts...
BECOME A PATRON
patreon.com/rosalieelliott
________________________________
CONNECT
Follow me on rosalieelliottofficial
Follow me on rosalieelliottofficial
_______________________________
Rose E Music
/ roseesongs
theofficialrosee
theofficialrosee
_______________________________
Today's Artist: Pink Floyd
/ pinkfloyd
pinkfloyd
pinkfloyd
![[TH] VALORANT Champions Seoul - Semi-Final - SEN vs TH](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IewhVY9cAmQ/mqdefault.jpg)
I am listening to this band since 1973 ,, this is not music , this is ART .
absolutely!!!
Nice one 👍
LOL Music is Art
Did you borrow my dark side of the moon 8 track?
You too ?! The Dark side of the Moon was the very first record album I ever bought Back in 73. In the Army in 73 I lived in the barracks ( 2 man room) and had a mess hall to live with and used all my pay for High end stereo gear and Pink Floyd holds the record for the most Masters Editions in my album collection with many bought multiple times. Second place was SuperTramp. I lost it all in the Loma Preita earthquake of 89.
It's the transition of death,
From terror to acceptance.
Simply masterful!
You must listen to the whole album. Take 55 mins. And blow your mind!
Is this song about death or dying?…. No. I met David Gilmour back stage at a concert in California 1984. I asked him about the meaning - reason for “Great Gig In The Sky”…. David’s answer was something like…. .I was asked if Pink Floyd would ever do a song about Religion like some others have… so I said, You are referring to the great gig in the sky they call “God“. What words could be used to describe all the pain and suffering caused by religious beliefs. All the crying and wailing from mothers who lost their husbands or sons in a war fought over religious differences. The only vocals should be just the sound of a mothers crying with pain and suffering. That’s the true intentions of the song. We didn’t want to make that public so as to avoid any religious boycott like what happened to the Beatles after Lennon made his comment about Jesus. We could not tell the singer so as to avoid her making any comments that would end up in the media. The speaking heard at the beginning was recorded at Apple records prior to the recording of the song. Roger Waters placed a recorder at the door asking anyone who walked by to answer some questions into the microphone. The janitor stopped and recorded his answer to the question….”Are You Afraid Of Dying”?. It was decided to add the recording to the start of “Great Gig In The Sky”. It leads people to believe the song is about dying, but that is actually not the case. The Great Gig In The Sky…is GOD … The incredible vocals from Clare Torry happened when she did not know what they wanted. David Gilmour told her to pretend her voice is a Saxophone like on other songs on the album, no words, just tones. Results are legendary.
@@AliasMark69 Rick Wright wrote the song. And he has said it was about death. But yeah, it was supposed to be the "mortality/religious" section. But whatever morality play they were at first going for, perhaps as you described hearing it from Gilmore, was overtaken by Claire's vocals, and it became the song she created along with Wright's playing. Especially with the "Why should be afraid of dying.." to start it. The song just evolved into one of the most elegant songs ever written and performed about the experience of death and dying, no matter what the original intent.
@@greenbluemonkey On another point.... Why would the title refer to death? It is only the addition of the comments at the start of the song that leads people astray from the real meaning. The "Great Gig In The Sky"is GOD.
Think of the Human body as clothes souls wear to live in this physical realm. We shed our human body to return to the spirit realm. There the veil is lifted and thought becomes the dominant manifestation. This is why those here are known and heard to the spirit realm. However few within this physical realm know of the spirit realm. Waking dreams, meditation, NDE, and even drugs that alter brain function, like Ayawaska can connect one to that realm.
@@robertforsythe3280 Reality.... No real such thing as a "spirit realm"... just Human imagination.
There’s no better band to apply psychological concepts to than Pink Floyd.
I just love “Psychedelic Prog”
Tull is close,
Yup
This song holds a special place in my heart. I bought the cassette of Dark Side when it first came out. One Sunday on an extremely rare occasions on our way to Grandma's house I asked my dad permission to play my boom box and play The Great Gig In The Sky. My parents listened silently as I cranked it up. My mom kept staring at my dad. After it was over it seemed like there was a pause for eternity. Then all of a sudden my uncool dad said to ten year old me. Son that was one of the greatest songs I ever heard. Play that whole album as much as you like. All of a sudden mom and dad were cool. Later on I found out that my mom and dad brought the dance the Grind from New York City to the Whiskey a Go Go.
So glad you did this version rather than a live performance. The background for this track is so interesting.
This is only one song from PF that is worse live than studio version
@@jareczek1980 Yes, the only song they don't even try to duplicate properly when doing it live. It's always a let down. I do like Bianca Antoinette's live version though.
The only live cover that comes close to Claire is Eva Avila of Brit Floyd. She absolutely KILLS it! Her delivery gives me chills every time!!
IT SUCKS LIVE --too much of too much on stage. CLAIRE TOREY still rules this tune.
The greatest band the world has ever known.
this is a band without a doubt people will be enjoying 100 years from now! and the Beatles, and Led Zeppelin, and Rolling Stones... who'd I miss?
Yes ? Perhaps Bad Company ?
Never has more words been spoken with no words whatsoever.
A song about passing and the mourning... an album that you need to listen to from the start... it's a "story album" PHENOMENAL!
The vocalist here, Clare Torry, was a jazz singer whom the sound engineer recommended to the band. They played the piano track for her and then told her to go into the booth and just sing what she felt. Because of her jazz background, her first take was a lot of "ooh ooh baby" type stuff. The lyricist, Roger Waters, then told her it was a song about dying and to "Go in and have a sing at that." What you're hearing now is her second and final take. After she finished she asked the band if they liked it!!! They obviously said yes, paid her the going rate of 30 quid, and she left, not even sure if her work would end up on the album!
Years later she "negotiated" a much higher and equitable fee for her contribution to this classic.
Multiple inaccuracies here but as a whole you’re not that far off.
You should watch the Clare Torry interview, she explains how David Gilmour was the only member of the band to give her any direction.
@@JohnSmith-vy4oh I spoke to David about the song.... He said he told Clare to pretend her voice is a Saxophone.... Just tones, no words.
Don't forget, she put it off for a week or so, legend.
She finally got a writing credit.
The album is called Dark Side of the Moon, and sold almost 47 million copies, roughly 1 million a year every year (average) for 47 years. Pink Floyd is a must exploration. Most start with Comfortably Numb, ideally the Pulse Concert version
This album was on the Billboard Top 200 albums for almost 18 YEARS. It may be longer now.
I am listening to Pink Floyd more often as I accept my time is running out.
I recently finished reading Nicolas Schaffner's book on Pink Floyd (he lived with them for many years), where he says that Clare Torry was recommended by Alan Parsons, the main sound engineer for this album - an employee of Abbey Road studio, where Pink Floyd recorded some of their albums (he later formed the "Alan Parsons Project"). Clare Torry was a singer who was hired by this studio primarily as a backing vocalist. At first she was confused because the song had no words, so she first sang oh yeh, oh baby... Until David Gilmour told her he wanted her to try using her voice as another instrument. She sang it twice more and then refused and walked away with a fee of £30. She was convinced Pink Floyd wouldn't use the song and it wouldn't be on the album. However, she was surprised that they did include it in the end. Years later she was paid a co-writing fee and still receives the royalties today. Here is a short interview with Clare Torry on the subject: th-cam.com/video/mIW7xZSlZoM/w-d-xo.html
By the way, this whole album is a real emotional experience and you MUST listen to the whole thing - if only for yourself. When you do, I think you'll be a little happier - trust me...
She refused 1/2 way through the 3rd take.
Not only were Pink Floyd and Clare masterful in this song but Alan Parsons knew how this needed to be engineered and contributed to it greatly.
Knowing what was coming and the ride you were in for, when you said lyrics, I almost peed myself laughing.
This song descibes your feelings when you notice that death comes over you... Denial.. Bargaining... Rage.. Disappointment...Grief about spoilt chances.. Acceptance.
well said
Is this song about death or dying?…. No. I met David Gilmour back stage at a concert in California 1984. I asked him about the meaning - reason for “Great Gig In The Sky”…. David’s answer was something like…. .I was asked if Pink Floyd would ever do a song about Religion like some others have… so I said, You are referring to the great gig in the sky they call “God“. What words could be used to describe all the pain and suffering caused by religious beliefs. All the crying and wailing from mothers who lost their husbands or sons in a war fought over religious differences. The only vocals should be just the sound of a mothers crying with pain and suffering. That’s the true intentions of the song. We didn’t want to make that public so as to avoid any religious boycott like what happened to the Beatles after Lennon made his comment about Jesus. We could not tell the singer so as to avoid her making any comments that would end up in the media. The speaking heard at the beginning was recorded at Apple records prior to the recording of the song. Roger Waters placed a recorder at the door asking anyone who walked by to answer some questions into the microphone. The janitor stopped and recorded his answer to the question….”Are You Afraid Of Dying”?. It was decided to add the recording to the start of “Great Gig In The Sky”. It leads people to believe the song is about dying, but that is actually not the case. The Great Gig In The Sky…is GOD … The incredible vocals from Clare Torry happened when she did not know what they wanted. David Gilmour told her to pretend her voice is a Saxophone like on other songs on the album, no words, just tones. Results are legendary.
Pink Floyd is truly “Album Rock”, and this album and nearly all of their albums should be listened to through from beginning to end. This is a very emotional song, without lyrics, taking us though the transfer to “the other side”, the process of dying. Fighting against it, perhaps through pain, acceptance and succumbing at the end of our lives. The album takes us through life. It is a classic that will live on forever. You should analyze Time from this album next.
I've always felt that this song is the pressure release valve to all the tension that's been built up in the first half of the album. Clare pours her heart out, and we slump exhausted on the sofa till we get get up ad cross the room to turn over the LP for side 2 (obviously that's not quite the same with digital media!)
It's a song about dying. From an album about life. One of the greatest albums of all time imho.
This song usually follows the song Time on the album, The Dark Side of the Moon. Whilst touring, this song is performed by three women. It is a beautiful piece.
So much of what you said is also described in the song Time which is found on the same album and leads directly into this track. The whole album is about different aspects of life including money, fame and war. It’s a very beautiful album with profound lyrics. I highly recommend it. Glad I found your reaction and your channel.
Hard to pick "one" song, but when I'm asked which is my favorite song from PF, I tend to answer "Time"... I love everything about it, the genius introduction, where Nick is doing great stuff on percussions, Waters lyrics are crushing, and David's guitar solo is one of the bests, if not THE best. Of course Rick does his job well, as usual, and lead to the following tracks and The Great Gig...
💗 Came for Pink Floyd.
Stayed for psychology. 🌈 🖤
This song to me represents a wounded soul trying to leave the body. I noticed her voice sounds strained at first then it kind of just evens out there in the last verse if you want to call it that. It's like her soul is set free
The story goes. Pink Floyd asked this girl to improvise some vocals. And when she finished the band walked out the recording studio without saying a word. She thought they were disappointed. She didnt realise they were struck dumb in amazement
I've known this song since it was released and must have heard it more than a thousand times.
So I know it inside and out.
And now I love the look on everyone's face hearing it for the first time.
No one expects this absolute masterpiece of textless vocals.
Seeing these reactions is priceless.
(Translated with Google translator)
I always thought her vocals were all the stages of grieving death and not the process of a person dying. It’s not the first time I misinterpreted a song for 50 years.👍🌹❤️
i agree. i heard my wife's reaction to her sons death and in some parts was so similar. i never want to hear it again.
That is the beauty of music, anybody feels it and can interpret it differently. It does not matter
I've heard it interpreted both ways: a person coming to grips with the death of a loved one, and a person coming to grips with their own mortality or impending death.
I think either interpretation can be correct.
You need to check the whole alarm songs in order. In bed, in the dark staring at the ceiling and you’ll see and hear the universe in all its glory. The album is the best I have owned in 63 years and I have thousands.
The perfect song when you feel like screaming ❤
Apparently Clare Torry done these vocal tracks on her lunch break. It wasn't one take, but very nearly. Simply outstanding. RIP Richard
Many people say this song is sung like it has the many stages of excepting grieving and Death with denial, anger, bargaining, depression, acceptance.
Fantastic analysis and reaction - lovely
Saw them 94 beautifulwill never forget the experience
There is music and then there is magic...
Still my favorite track from this masterpiece of an album... bought it the year it came out and it didn't gain momentum at first, but then....WHOOOOOOSH
Clare Torry absolutely created a one of a kind immortal performance.
Beautiful vocalizations. Soothing instrumentation. And great analysis.
I was 14 when this came out. I lost a dear friend that year, so it made me cry early on. I still think of her and now cry start to finish when it comes on.
Her Inflection Was Stunning
You mentioned 'time' a great many times in your commentary, and rightly so, because Time is track 3. Almost as though it had to be. The word that pops into my head is "Symmetry" . In the narrative and theme particularly. Like they began sketching all those connections out long before recording anything. Constructing music in that way is something I almost exclusively see from the classical/orchestral world. An exception being Tool. I forever have Tool and Floyd linked in my head, despite their differences, because both bands are all about searching the far reaches of the wasteland for something different.
I just mentioned that she described the theme of the song "Time" above. It just shows you how accurate PF was in their younger years. Tool is more mathematical.
Thank you for respecting this amazing tune
Thank you for your interpretation. Dear Lady.
Such a moving song without a single word! I remember going to see a really great Pink Floyd tribute band and the ladies they had singing this were so good it brought me to tears!
Also, but sure to check out Shine on you crazy diamond!
That was deep, and such a deep song! As I've aged, I grew into Pink Floyd and their masterful works. Just didn't click with the younger me. Love them now!
Good morning Rose! I got to see Pink Floyd in the mid 90's in Vancouver BC. Amazing show! The highlight for me was Comfortably Numb.
I am an absolutely Pink Floyd fan since 1976 it is one of the best groups of all time I have all albums und I saw they life 1994 in Berlin ✊🤘🤘🤘
Clare Torry did this on the fly in 2 1/2 takes on a Sunday afternoon.. She was paid 30 pounds Time & 1/2 for musicians). She was told the concept of the album & kinda what they wanted. Started to sing. They said no lyrics. She collected herself & told them to hit record. The 1/2 take was part of the third take. She stopped 1/2 way through & said they got what they needed. Next thing a friend told her the album was selling allot in America. She bought it & noticed her name was on the album.
Allot of what you are talking about is in the song "Time" . That is 2 tracks before this song on the album.
Wonderful, amazing reaction! 👏👏👏 Perhaps the best reaction to a Pink Floyd song I've ever seen! Being so good as you are analysing psichological aspects of the meaning of a complex song, you should react to Pink Floyd's songs all the time! Serious, I do believe so! I got some suggestions for you: "Brain damage"; "Shine on you crazy diamond"; "Time"; "Us and them"; "Run like Hell"; "High hopes"; "Wish you were here"; "Hey you"; "Comfortably numb".
Thank you very much. Making a note. Thank you for your suggestions
Saw them live in 94 pulse.best night 🌙 of my life.my life has been shit but this moment gave me hope...❤
Best album created on record...fact...😢😊❤
Beautiful
Always amazes me how much they can say without a single word...
psychology and Pink Floyd - perfect marriage.
You were right not to fully expect this - it is a special and unique piece, it is not indicative of most of their songs - though all of them have dynamic and unique facets.
This song is the embodiment of the 4 stages of death. The start is seeing a love one die with the harsh wailing, to the serene acceptance that is eventually softens.
Wrong.... It is about God, and all the suffering religion has caused.
We Used to sit in a dark smoke filled room just listening to Floyd. Mellow times
Love is the frequency of the creator. This is the great gig in the sky. I wish you well.
Rosalie You are a beautiful woman
Holy *@#! Hearing you speak of life is BETTER than any therapy one could hope to benefit from! Your should charge for your words of wisdom. Im being serious! That was a coaching unlike I've ever received! And I thought this was just a review. Thank you so much for inspiring me! Oh yea, by the way, look for Rachel Fury in the "Pulse" tour album. She gives a twist to Claire's part that will invoke cleansing tears! Love Pink Floyd...absolute legends
Thank you very much. That’s very kind.
Clair Torrey, a session singer. With little direction from the band, belted this out in two takes. She mad her voice an instrument. This is the stages of grief.
The song deals with the six stages of drunkenness. Merry, rowdy, miraculous (scottish), eye of the hurricane, melancholy, sleep.
I am a heavy metal guitarist and I love Pink Floyd!!! I am also into classical and country. So many avenues of music we can take in is the beauty.
Actually...you make a lot of sense (according to me) and I enjoyed listening to the whole thing until the end...doesn't happen that often on TH-cam ;) Thanks and have a great weekend!
thank you very much. glad you enjoyed it.
@@rosalieelliottofficial always do since you have something to say and also have a different angle and perspective on life and music...and the stuff in between. Interesting! Keep it up and I might consider subscribing...my first ever in that case 🙂 Regards!
Absolutely Stunning! Not One Word Sung. WOW!
song is about the process of dying and the pain, anguish and acceptance of it.
The absolute genius of it makes me cry every time I hear it.
According to a documentary I saw, this was recorded by Clare Torrie in a single take!
Peace and Love 🙏❤
Oh my!!! I've loved this song probably over a thousand times in my life! And it still gets me emotional! I also would like to hear MELODY CRISTEA sing this! And with this much emotion!
I've been paying attention to rock music since about 1964 (when I was 7 years old).Started, of course, with The Beatles. When I was in junior and senior high schools, I had a musician classmate friend who had a stereo outfit in his folks' basement. We listened to everything rock, but had a particular fondness for Led Zeppilin, Jethro Tull, Yes, Pink Floyd, Chicago, Steve Miller, Procol Harum, and several others. After decades of cogitation on the subject, and having changed my mind only once or twice before, a few years ago I decided that "Dark Side of the Moon" is the greatest rock album ever.
For "death and dying," give Richard Strauss' "Tod und Verklärung" (Death and Transfiguration) a listen. It's a tone poem, meant to tell a story in music (ohne Worte).
I’m an American psychotherapist living in Germany, and I really enjoyed your reaction to my favorite band. I have always equated this song as the realization of one’s own mortality. The song takes the listener through the Kubler-Ross stages of grief quite beautifully.
Near end she whispers " if you hear this whisper you are dying"
“…what they did vocally…. But also the lyrics “. Little did she know…..! Haha
50 years since I bought the Dark Side Of The Moon vinyl album, this song still gives me goosebumps.
Pink Floyd is not just music; it is an experience.
Dark Side of the Moon was called "...the first concept album..." by a couple of London DJs on their (two hours every Friday night) 'Your Mother Wouldn't Like It' show that featured a different Rock group each week, except they did four Friday shows on Pink Floyd. I recorded all four Fridays on BASF 90 min cassette tapes.
Great approach!! I'm in the middle of a Music Therapy Master collecting data and this was very useful. I'm not new to your channel, always enjoying and grateful. Greets from Tenerife (Canary Islands)... 🌞🌞
oh nice!! feel free to share what you learn in your journey. I can imagine we can learn a lot from you. how exciting to be studying that.
Alan Parsons was the engineer on this album and he picked Claire Torry to sing this emotional piece about ascending to heaven without words. As a mental health professional you should listen to this entire album...
As always Rosalie, your philosophical thoughts of this is so elevated and wise, love it !! You nailed it. The whole album is centered around theese issues and thoughts🧡💛💚🙏🙏🙏
The topic of chasing life brought up here is a main theme of another song of theirs (Time) it fits perfectly with what your discussing! Worth a listen
“All kinds of psychology to unpack in that one!
Enjoyed your post song commentary 👍🍻
Just looked thru our vinyls today. Daughter and grandchildren visited to pick up some records for Xmas weeks.😎. And ofc we went thru the PF ones as well including dark side of the moon. 😋❤️🇧🇻
Shout out to Claire Torry did it in one take 🤯🤓
It was interesting in your analysis of this song there was so much reference to the precluding song TIME.
Loved the reaction and insight/knowledge you added to it.
I love here death anology. With this album beautiful woman. X.merry Xmas.
Great reaction!
Excellent analysis. Kudos!
Do more Pink Floyd!
Greatest band ever!
💕💕👍👍💋💋
The perfection captured in this recording is exquisite
As powerful as this is on its own, it's even more powerful in the context of the whole album, which was written to be listened to all in one sitting. Fun fact: she showed up as a session musician for this gig and they told her what they were looking for. Her first take she used some words and they asked her to do it without lyrics. This was the second take. God damn. The music, the chord progressions, the instrumentation and arrangement is fantastic but all overshadowed by Torry's legendary performance. This album remained on the Billboard 200 chart for over 14 years straight and still sells thousands of copies a week. It's an absolute classic and often cited as the best album ever made.
Brings tears to my eyes every time.
This is about as close to heaven as a song can take you.
As has already been said, it would be hard to have a channel talking about music and psychology without diving into Pink Floyd's discography. The Wall is a masterpiece of psychology wrapped up into a album of excellent music.
Great reaction
In this piece I sense the exit of the one 'departing'
happening in the opening slide up of the guitar as
if the spirit is now set free from the bondage of the
temporal state and lifted into the elements....
I have always felt the anguish of mourning through
her vocal inflections dancing with the instrumentals
as if releasing from those still standing in shock.....
as a 'new birth' is pushing through the pain of loss
and separation while the soul is crying out to under-
stand our final stand in this frail yet awesomely con-
structed carcus we call home as we roam this ball
we have been placed on to walk upon... for reasons?
that only God knows... ''I'm HOME!!!''
You're such a nice reactor, new subscriber in your Channel!
Hope you can do a reaction video of "LEAVE THE DOOR OPEN" (BRUNO MARS, ANDERSON .PAAK, SILK SONIC) sang by a Filipino girl group 4TH IMPACT Thanks.
Here's the Link : th-cam.com/video/FgwTi8xJzR/w-d-xo.html
With 2112 Dark Side Of The Moon is probably the best concept album ever. The album is just as relevant today as it was back in 73.
After my girlfriend passed away I was giving a book called Grieving Mindfully by Sameet Kumar. He is a Psychologist and Buddhist
who teaches that dealing with death and grief is like a spiral stair case. You will have times where you go up and times where you will
go down so he teaches people how to walk a meaningful path so that hopefully one can learn loss is an inevitable part of life. Great book
for anyone who is dealing with the loss of a loved one.
The opening lines remind me of this quote from "Julius Caesar" by William Shakespeare:
“Cowards die many times before their deaths;
The valiant never taste of death but once.
Of all the wonders that I yet have heard,
It seems to me most strange that men should fear;
Seeing that death, a necessary end,
Will come when it will come.”
You are so amazing with your analysis! I have listened to this album for many years. It has always been important to me and you have unlocked so much more. Thank you x
I saw them 94 London. When I listen on headphones at home..it takes me back
If you haven't listened to the whole album you, I envy you. So much, as you will hear it for the first time.
As said, I envy you.
Headphones on.. lights off. Awaaay.. you go.
It's only the beginning saw pink Floyd once live the best 👌 🦋🌹🦋⚡🤎⚡
Best LIVE version of this tune is from
A Momentary Lapse of Reason Tour
with the Concert Film
Delicate Sound of Thunder 1988
Best back-up singers EVER
Rachel Fury, Durga Mcbroom and Margaret Taylor
Your mention of the best back-up "singerS" (plural!) is why I think you are incorrect (though of course, an opinion is never incorrect). Pink Floyd always use three back-up singers to sing the three distinct parts of this track, primarily because it must be such a strain to perform the entire track in one take, solo, live, and there are very few singers willing to try (and good enough). "The Australian Pink Floyd Show" are a tribute band that prides itself on recreating the genius of Pink Floyd, and they had a back-up singer named Amy Smith. She absolutely NAILS this track live, solo, no auto-tune. The best performance of this track ever, with the exception of the original by Clare Torrey. th-cam.com/video/ltt_YScyCVg/w-d-xo.html You can thank me later.
Rachel Fury LIVE Lead vocal on Great Gig in the Sky that BAR (of performance) was set in 1987.
Personally I like Rachel's version even more than Clare Torry's LIVE rendition at Kenworth 1990
~we all know that Clare's studio vocals will be unmatched till the end of time
Didn’t know she was on the album until she saw the album in a shop window
Great response and so glad that you did the research on the background to the song. I did giggle however when you introduced it and referred to your interest in the lyrics…😊 For another amazing song that deals with dealing/coping with loss, check out ‘Routine’ by Steven Wilson (in particular the version with the specially commissioned animated video)
You have just got to love some “Psychedelic Prog”
I love how before the song started you said you were going to dive into the lyrics. "Boy is she gonna be surprised!"
Hahaha true!
@@rosalieelliottofficialseeing on TH-cam at CHRISTIANS REACT TO PINK FLOYD
70s were brilliant , can’t see any of todays artist producing something as good . Now this track is 50 years old
Thank you for this. I've listened to many analyses of this song. Yours may be the most well thought out that I have heard. And I appreciate your message of hope at the end.
thank you very much!