3D Sound - Binaural Recording of a Musical Performance (feat. Peter and Kerry)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ก.ค. 2024
- The entirety of the video is shot from the listener's perspective and therefore, through the use of the binaural recording technique, you will be able to hear the position of the musicians 'move' around you as the viewpoint of the camera changes.
Featuring Peter and Kerry: / peterandkerry
Track: 'I Don't Know' from La Trimouille (Tape Club Records)
Stream: / 01-i-dont-know
iTunes: itunes.apple.com/gb/album/la-...
Additional musicians: Mark Rainbow (Piano), Sarah Bateson (Vibraphone), Maddie Cutter (Cello), Joel Grainger (Violin).
Produced by Jon Alexander at the Institute of Sound Recording (University of Surrey): www.tonmeister.co.uk
Recorded using:
Cortex Manikin Mk2 Binaural Head and Torso Simulator
Focusrite VRM Box
Reaper (tracking)
ProTools 8 (edit and post)
Canon 6D
Technical Credits:
Jon Alexander: Audio and Video Recording
Michael Cousins: Recording Assistant
Stephen Savory: Video Post-Production
Special thanks to Dr. Russell Mason and Chris Watling - เพลง
![If you can't hear this then you're not an audiophile [See description for link to followup video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/48PxwspDvrE/mqdefault.jpg)
![If you can't hear this then you're not an audiophile [See description for link to followup video]](/img/tr.png)
![บุษบา - เมนทอล [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IGnWPokSEis/mqdefault.jpg)
![BOWKYLION - เจ้านายคะ (work-life imbalance) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6bFj8G2pOi4/mqdefault.jpg)
came here for 3d sound, stayed for the amazing music.
yep!
+Ali Hassan Yeah...I can't hear 3d, some problem with the earphones perhaps. But stayed her for the song.
+Vivid Kothari Maybe crank the volume up?
+Donald Lv Don't hurt your ears though.
Donald Lv
Nope. My earphones are the cheapest in the world. They can't play this sound properly. they are literally 2 USD (150 in my currency). ;)
I came here because I'm interested in binaural sounds. But... wow! Your music is so nice, relaxing, warm and makes me kind of "emotional" if I may say. This was a wonderful experience. Thanks a lot for making and uploading this video!
Come..
Hey Pierre j'étais aussi ici pour le son binaural mais quelle belle piece!
Hi pierre
Hi there, if you're interested in binaural, maybe you'd like to have a listen here then ;-)
th-cam.com/channels/1dafhGGfpt1sxHkz6MGcbw.html
Beautiful comment am looking through wet pupils writing this
I too came for the binaural, but stayed for the music.
Fantastic song.
I wish the start wasn't in mono though.
This, do they think we stumbled across this video randomly and needed to know the difference between mono and binural? Not even a fair comparison considering most(literally almost all) music is in stereo, not mono.
@@poppinlochnesshopster3249 Yeah! They should have used more microphones and record the way they use to do (one mic close to each voice and instrument, wich record into it's own mono track) - then they make a standard production with mixing and mastering. That's what they should start with - then switch to the binarual recording. That will really show how much better the binarual recording is.
I guess they just made it simple - they recorded everything in binarual (wich is ironically much easier than recording it the standard way, since nothing more than 2 microphones and a stereo recorder/camera is needed). To "simulate" the standard bad sound, they just took the sound from one of the 2 microphones and mix it out on both channels (or just mixed the stereo channels together), on the first part of the audio track. But as you say - it's not really a fair comparison, because even the standard recordings are stereo for the most part.
Also - one part of what makes this recording better, is the stereo information. Stereo is recorded naturally by using 2 omnidirectional microphones with a distance in between (sometimes with a dummy head in the middle to simulate the effect of the head). The stereo on the standard production on the other hand is just faked by take a mono track and convert it to a stereo track, then adjust volume between left and right channel before it's put into the mix
- that doesn't sound very natural, since there is no time difference between channels as it will be in real life (a sound coming straight from the left for example, will more sound like you have a faulty headphone/speaker on your right side, rather than the sound is actually coming from the left). Make the whole sound track mono, will not show this important difference.
@@Speeder84XL All I could think of while reading this was how horrendous The Beatles in stereo sound.
I like the transition.
You appear to be completely missing the concept of binaural music, which is explicitly a single point recording location with reflector features mimicking the human ears to add full spherical information into the recording.
Man... I listened to this song 8 years ago and now I'm going through my favorite videos and oh my... What a beautiful memory 🥲🥲
Same
Time flies
strange how fast things pass by
We have 4K and 60FPS on TH-cam, It's now time for something approaching lossless audio as well.
16bit 44kHz is lossless and well above the human hearing range (physical limitation goes way below that). Don't let anybody fool you.
Paco Maco
Agreed. Try doing a blind ABX test. Most people can't tell the difference between 128kbps AAC and Lossless audio files. TH-cam uses 126kbps AAC.
*****
I'd have agreed if you said 320kbps or V0 but 128kbps... With proper gear 128kbps sounds awful.
LancerFIN very few got the "proper" gear. They target the average Joe.
Paco Maco And you can't see more than 24 fps. Right? Right?
this deserves so much more views than it has
Atlantis for fuckin real man 👌😽
and than it will ever have
I've played piano in orchestra for 7 years. I have lot of stage experience, and one thing I have always loved is being able to hear each individual sound's contribution to the piece. Never had I thought to experience a live sounding performance on headphones, yet here we are. There is a significant difference between listening to music (to sounds) and experiencing music. This... This is experiencing, and I hope to see more artists take on this approach to future albums.
Hey! I film short concert videos using binaural stereo. I hope you can enjoy them as much as this video :)
Lyrics:
“I would not say everything's changed
It's too lazy to exaggerate
Maybe it's transition
Which hurts more
Than the cleanest of all breaks
And i did not think you'd hear me say
‘I did not know it at
The time’, etc
For every time that we both laughed
Hysterically just like we always
Did, I think i broke
Down into tears
Or every time we danced
I broke into tears
(I would have asked you then and there to marry me)
(I would have asked you then and there to marry me)
Sometimes you'll give a little look
And sometimes we're like a little book
Of our own language I'm
Still learning all the time
(I would have asked you then and there to marry me)
(I would have asked you then and there to marry me)
And I would not draw a line through your name
But I still close my eyes and hear you say
‘Well yes it's love but that
Is just not enough’
(I would have asked you then and there to marry me)
(I would have asked you then and there to marry me)
For every time that we both laughed
Hysterically just like we always did
I think I broke
Down into tears
Or every time we danced
I broke into tears
(I would have asked you then and there to marry me)
(I would have asked you then and there to marry me)
(I would have asked you then and there to marry me)
(But something made me lose all my vocabulary)
(I would have asked you then and there to marry me)
(I would have asked you then and there to marry me)
(I would have asked you then and there to marry me)
(But something made me lose all my vocabulary)
(I would have asked you then and there to marry me)
(I would have asked you then and there to marry me)
(I would have asked you then and there to marry me)
(But something made me lose all my vocabulary)
(I would have asked you then and there to marry me)
(I would have asked you then and there to marry me)
(I would have asked you then and there to marry me)
(But something made me lose all my vocabulary)”
The last part: only three times.
A depressing and hard subject. The song is pretty but so serious and frankly... quite depressing.
Toivo Kallio it’s life, and beautifully painful, wouldn’t want it any other way
Thank you
Thanks😃
I wish all music was recorded with Binaural sound. Sounds so much better.
Definitely!! Why is it not though ? Most people buying speakers I guess and music being recorded once I suppose...
Itz more of a voice thing where u can really fell it an fall into avareness 👉💙 binaural is not acurate in terms of voice being the same as the other itz sightly changes in speed but not off like most of the music today, best example is hiphop they fuck it up with the melody and drumkit are not the same, some is there and the othere is a couple milisecz behind or forwards so yeah, how i see this is more of a message and being with the song, THATZ MUSIC 😽👌
but it isn't versatile and doesn't suit everything, it's like saying, "why are all monitors 2D and not 3D? everyone can wear 3D glasses!" except not
@@David_Logr that and recording 3D audio would be much more difficult than recording in stereo. There would be way more phase issues present when recording.
@@HarmonyxRuLz yup, also that
I found this song over 4 years ago, and always find myself coming back to it. A lot of memories attached to it. Thanks for the music.
I feel like I've been sucked into another dimension of music! Binaural music is truly amazing!
+fmadiva Yessss! but there is not enough of it!
@@TheBumpothegreat My channel focusses on short concert videos recorded using binaural stereo. I hope you can enjoy :)
For those wondering, the song is called 'I Don't Know by Peter and Kerry' :) Beautiful live performance !!
Harry Rutter 👍
Where can you find this version of the song? I like it so much better than the album version.
I’ve been looking for it everywhere & can’t find this version on a downloadable platform. I’ve probably listened to this song a thousand times via TH-cam though lol
@@seminoldschool7032 download it
@@seminoldschool7032they have a similar version on Spotify, it’s labeled as the acoustic version. It’s a little different but pretty similar to this!
This moved me on a level I didnt was there...I love how music can make you so emotional to the point of tears..anyhow beautiful song
I wonder if musicians like this know how much joy they bring to others?
Too bad the gong player wasn't there.
Sorry i was late
Why isn't all music recorded this way
Not just music- why isn't EVERYTHING recorded this way?!?!?! Binaural audio is so freaking cool! The microphones aren't even that expensive! The Free Space from 3dio is only $500 USD, compare that with some other high end ones that are much more expensive!
Because it negatively affects speaker reproduction due to the accumulated echo from recording room + your room.
a proper listening room should be acoustically dampened to some degree anyway
also, HIFI is usually made for reproduction through speakers, so they place microphones a couple metres apart to record an acoustical performance. it approximates the distance between home speakers in a good setup. technically, that's a binaural recording too. the difference is, when made like this, for headphones, the microphones are much closer.
it is only suited for live music, though. when recording for example a rock band in a studio, there are dozens of inputs from various microphones, instruments, a drum kit can have 4-5 dedicated mics, one for every piece of kit, etc.
would be an interesting experiment though to try.
Binaural recordings are intended for listening through headphones, since using the same recording on a home speaker system would cause distortions from cross-talk between the channels. Since there's a bigger market for loudspeakers than headphones, most recordings will be done in the traditional stereo format.
Although I agree, it would be nice to have more recordings done this way, but it requires more effort on the studios. Maybe iTunes could do something like a binaural library or a way to toggle between stereo recordings and binaural. If more people are switching to binaural sound, then that might give studios an incentive to actually do those type of recordings -- because I'm pretty sure lots and lots of people are now using portable audio in this day and age.
Close your eyes and imagine the musicians around you, it's like you're really sat with them, just incredible.
I have now been using this as a main reference whenever I get new audio gear. Amazing recording, music, artists!
the future of music recording
Robert Rattler Yes and check out Lou Reed's "Street Hassle' from 1978, one of the rock n roll pioneers of binaural audio
Yeah, all the way from 1951.
+lois velasquez de la Cruz But truly awesome dude ;)
Radio head did it as well
Hooke Audio it's true !!
i remember watching this about 6 years ago and bawling my eyes out, i was going through a horrible period of my life back then but eventually things got better, a while ago i thought that life is finally starting to be good to me
but here i am again, listening to the same song 6 years later, back at square one because i've fucked everything up again
This sounds so huge and natural! Thanks for this!
Awesome!
I can't believe how amazing the soundscape is on this. i wish binaural would become something bigger in the music world its an amazing stereo image that can't be recognized by the general public
Hey you should come check out my short concert videos recorded using binaural stereo. I hope you enjoy :)
Need more of these Binaural recordings of Peter and Kerry. Beautiful overall experience
I like how games are more ahead when it comes to binaural audio than music. I hope the dawn of binaural music is near and upcoming.
Great job on this video. hope you guys can make more of this. Well played.
Doctor Rabbit So immersion is not a benefit to you when you listen to music? because for me, i listen to music to escape, to imagine, to get motivated, etc. so adding more immersion to it is a big deal imo. you are right that in games it gives more use to binaural sound to properly have a feel on the 3D space that you are currently playing. but, it can be say to music too, having your imagination elsewhere while listening to music then you can here the music's balance on both your ear gives it more dimension and immersion that i can appreciate.
+MrUnknownPunk Because music most of the time not played by headphones, this only works for headphone. If you play it with speaker it would have a too much reverb effect, making the sound blurry, not as clear as usual recording.
This version of the song is so tender and MAGICAL! I had a hard time not crying from the beauty of the souls of the performers. Thank you for creating this work of art in this world.
I really enjoyed this, not just the binuaral experience, but the whole thing, wonderful singing
the backup singers voice when she says marry me 😍😍
Amazing. Such harmony and naturalness of sound cannot be achieved by any number of the most expensive microphones on each performer.
I cannot get over how good this is. It's not often I am mind blown by an artist. This song gives me shivers, makes me super sad and really happy at the same time. I AM SO CONFLICTED I LOVE IT.
I wish all songs have a binaural version so we don't have to buy expensive audiophile grade earphones with vast soundstage to produce this kind of sound.
Jonathan Rae Crisanto I have to say with high performance headphones this is such a wonderful experience though. It will drastically improve headphone performance but with poor detail and response and a lot of distortion it's not going to sound as good as supposed to be.
LOL!! You don't get good sound just because you buy " audiophile grade earphones with vast soundstage" - it's as simple as shit in = shit out. Information that was never captured during the recording and lost during mastering of the music, will not come back just because you get a good playback system.
People who buy expensive sound system just wastes their money in most cases (except for those who listen to classical music, where you can find a few good recordings). But again (as I wrote before) - it's all about profit. The producers make good money on their crap and that's all they care about.
Also when it comes to audiophiles - they will often hear an improvement as they change or upgrade their sound system (some of it isn't even a real improvement, but just placebo - for example when it comes to speaker cables). That's enough for them to continue chasing "good sound". Those improvements is so tiny compared to what they would get with a better recording. But since they are missing a reference for how it should sound, they just carry on. It's like moving centimeters when your goal is still 2 kilometers away.
"binaural vision"
I have audiophile grade headphones and wholy fuck this sounds fucking good
You'd be surprised how good these recordings sound with cheap headphones.
I use this video to text out every new pair of headphones I get. Great song!
What I find so magical - switching to the binaural recording completely eliminates the room echo, even if I only listen to a single channel (left or right). What a wonderful song, thanks!
Why isn't every song recorded this way?
+Anam Paiseanta I don't think you understand how taxes work.....
***** who is "they"
+Eric Melendez that's your homework dude :D
+PicuPiee how is it my job to understand his argument? He failed to present it.
Just take a look at European countries, and mostly at Scandinavia, are you sure taxes don't work?
Came for binaural stayed for the greatest song I've heard till now
I miss this video. It's been 5-6 years I think since my last listen to this. ♥
Can we just take a moment to say how beatiful the co-ordination and vocals are.
This is a beautiful song, the instruments sound absolutely beautiful. Thankyou for this, I really appreciate music like this!
I love to watch musician playing, when I saw that I'm asking myself, how wars how bad things can happens in the world, there is so much beauty, love and peace in the act of playing music together, it's a magical time.
In this life or the next ones, I would like to be a musician (but not only that, multi-arts if possible :-)
thank you for this beautiful song
holy shit binaural audio is amazing. Gives closed-back headphones actual soundstage
Hi there, if you're interested in binaural, maybe you'd like to have a listen here then ;-)
th-cam.com/channels/1dafhGGfpt1sxHkz6MGcbw.html
Listening to this song felt like a good memory . 💖
All songs should be recorded like this!
This was the most enjoyable thing I have experienced with my HD800's so far. Thanks for this
+AlphaRISC Open headphones on this are ridiculous......
Alpharisc Agreed, but listening on HD700's.
OMG!!! with a good set of audio equipment, this is almost realistic performance. Thanks a lot, we need more like this!💗💗🥰🥰
this is one of the most beautiful recordings of one of Peter and Kerry's songs I've ever heard. A major bravo to those involved!
Wow, not into this kind of music but this was truly beautiful to listen to
Sounds like it comes straight out of little big planet
+beep813 I was thinking the exact same thing!!!
This has to be the most beautiful masterpiece of music and sound on youtube.
I get so emotional listening to this. Such a beautiful song, recorded in such a wonderful way. I just wanted to say thank you to all involved for bringing such a lovely work of art into this world.
How does this only have 25k views...
The WHOLE video I was just hoping and praying someone would smash that huge gong in the back. Other than that disappointment, this video is freakin' amazing.
every time i buy any thing related to sound i come back here. Then i listen to this song again and again for the next few week. this song it just beautiful
I was checking my headphones on another video, I loved this and hence I am here , anyone else?
pure musical bliss
There gonna get lots of views just because I'm gonna re listen so many times. Lol
Ckcorynthiohn Provided you have open backed headphones, you can get a similar effect for all your music with crossfeed: www.foobar2000.org/components/view/foo_dsp_meiercf
Ckcorynthiohn Hey I love this video, particularly the ideas concerning binaural beats gamma
. Another resource I also found useful for memory increasing exercises
was Corbandy Binaural Beats Crusher - search google if you like
why am i only watching this now?!? this is amazing
Unlike others here, I actually love how the recording begins in mono. It's like starting off colour blind and suddenly seeing full colour for the first time. The timing of it is perfect too.
I didn't notice a strong 3D effect. When the piano player sang he sounded like directly in front, when he was actually far to the right.
Maybe it's the room's acoustic properties.
I guess it depends on what headphones you use. The pianist sounded off to the side for me (where he was). It isn't the strongest I agree but it is there.
Read the posting notes. The focus moves with the Camera. H800's here and the recording isn't bad.
qwasd0r It also strongly depends on each person's corpulence (head, shoulders, torso...), and for binaural recording, they usually use an average dummy for that (although, not sure if they used one for this recording). So it is not really surprising that the rendering may sound diferent for you, guys :-)
Using HD800s, E70, or W50 I can not only tell where piano is from, other instruments and singers' positions are easy to tell to. It's actually creepy when I listen to this at night before sleep. So I guess you need more accurate headphones.
best if i close my eyes while listening.
this needs a Spotify version
I'm 8 years late to the party... I can't get enough of this....
Now make it binaural AND VR, that would be something else entirely
now with the quest and other VR headsets.. its not too far away
Amazing performance, amazing technology. How is binaural not a 'thing' yet ?? Everything that has a headphone option should have binaural option too.
They do use it in a lot of songs but not very noticeable. I've notice that they use it a lot on Battlefield 4 with a ps4 it's awesome
You need quite an elaborate (and expensive) set up to record binaural. The acoustics in which the recording is made need to be very good as well. It has actually been used quite a lot over the last 40 years or more in recording chamber music, jazz and other acoustic music. Lots of "audiophile" recordings use binaural set-ups.
It is sometimes also used to mix a little room atmosphere back into a mix where each instrument is recorded onto a separate channel. I actually work at a venue where concerts are recorded that way. The thing is, it can only be used with performances that are recorded live. But in a way it has always been a bit of a thing, just not for music that is recorded in parts and then mixed together.
Frauhofer made is possible to compress 21:2-Sound (Cinema DTS) or 7.1 (DTS) to Binaural Stereo. So this sounds like a Cinema. The Sound comes from a circle around you. But with Binaural you hear the distance and height from the source. If you hear binaural music on streets you cannot differ the music and the reality.Binaural sounds a little bit faked, if your hear it with loud-speaker. For recording you need a human head and a complexive ear-shell.
***** 5.1 and 7.1 headsets are pretty much snake oil any way, regarding sound binaural recordings (especially the barber shop demo on YT) proves that you have 2 ears and so 2 speakers can be all that is required for fully directional audio with headphones. You shouldn't need 5.1 headsets or Dolby upmixing which fakes 3D sound which as with any type of simulation pales in comparison to the proper way.
This is why binaural should be more of a thing in mainstream media, music, games and movies because quite frankly it's more than capable of being much better than even surround sound speakers. Once again the barber shop demo proves the insane accuracy and shows you just how convincing a normal pair of headphones (not 5.1 headsets or anything) can be with binaural. It's actually quite frightening!
***** one word 3ds
Beautiful song, wonderful performance, and a fantastic job capturing it! You all made something really special here.
Amazing performance and audio work! Such a pleasure to hear
“Than the cleanest of all breaks” this song is so sad
you should have said the 1st minute is mono recording cause I was about to say it's not binuaral.
nth2tell It said it in the top left corner that it was Mono. Lol
This is Amazing. You guys sing amazing! Plus the binaural audio... It gives me goosebumps!
I went from watching them to being there my self hearing as it sounds. Beautiful. Am having a memory created by them thank you… ❤
WOW
(Sennheiser HD 598)
I hear you. (V-Moda crossfades ) for me. 😎
+beebop shopbop hot damn DT 770 250
+Nick Santos very nice also. Feels good to have nice headphones doesn't it? Never want to waste money on cheap ones again!!!
+beebop shopbop and next time, I'm gonna get either the AKG K712 Pro or Sennheiser HD600 coz they're both great for heavy metal, and overall they're versatile
WOW
(Apple Earpods)
*cries*
Morph the names together and you get Kety Perry
Keter Perry*
absolutely beautiful! wish i could put this in a loop and listen to it for a long time. such a sweet melody. well done.
A few years ago after discovering binaural videos I was surprised to see that no one thought of creating binaural music! I just came across this and I'm jumping around because it's absolutely AMAZING. Great song. Good job, guys.
Bangalore, is this ur side job?
Bangalore after she becomes the FMG
take my like you piece of shit bastard!
This Bangalore way back when her boyfriend was still alive
Anyone else here from the Ultimate Headphone Test video?
my heart is melting for the music 🥰 may you guys all have a fantastic day
This is amazing, so much talent! Binaural recording is really incredible, especially when it's done properly.
there's no 3D sound but it sounds wonderful!
There is no what m8?
Is there a soundcloud/iTunes of this?
Peter and Kerry- I don't know
wonderful! overwhelmed by this style recording and quality of music. Great stuff. Make more!
This is incredible and so sweet. I can listen to this for days!
I really want to know this song!,, what is the name of it I want to buy it on iTunes and learn the lyrics lol
"I Don't Know" - Peter and Kerry
***** That's a shame, at least we know it's by Peter and Kerry...
***** no that really is the song name.
***** no shit sherlock
how is your headphone quality
Very good. $400 kind of good lol.
@@corbinbender5122 mine is $100 dollar kind of good (corsair hs70) to my untrained ears it sounds quite amazing. I have read reviews by people who are audiophiles who have said the sound is great for the price though.
I've loved this performance ever since I saw it around a year ago.
Tbh I like this way way more than the album version
2018?
2019?
2020?
2050
Lovely performance, cracking shorts Peter!
I too came here for the 3D sound and stayed for the music and lyrics. On repeat now all day. Love it.
I still come to listen to this beautiful piece of art💗💗Love both versions but this one in particular gives me this nostalgic vibe😭
Hi there, if you're interested in binaural, maybe you'd like to have a listen here then ;-)
th-cam.com/channels/1dafhGGfpt1sxHkz6MGcbw.html
Just lovely. Thank you.
That's one gorgeous song! And this style of recording ... wow!
same boat as most came for the binurial audio and this song jams!! you are all amazing!!!
This is beautiful. I have been trying to master Binaural in my Productions like this one. This is amazing.
Beautiful performance. Love it so much.. My hands are tapping, my head is moving side to side, to the song...
this song is amazing, the vocals are perfect, you guys are amazing!
beautiful, just beautiful
Such a beautiful performance
Really loved this performance. Thank you. Of course the recording was Absolutely Superb but I loved the song, the singers and the musicians and will replay this video often. Very best wishes to all involved.
Simlply awesome! So sweet and emotional...
This is incredible. Everyone of them singing has beautiful voices! Piano player and Glock!!
Really good perfomance and recording. Thank you so much for this!
Please. More.