Bharat Ek Khoj | Episode-48 | Extremists And Moderates
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ก.ค. 2020
- Bharat Ek Khoj-The Discovery of India
A Production of Doordarshan, the Government of India’s Public Service Broadcaster
Episode 48: Extremists And Moderates
With Mohan Gokhale as Gopal Krishna Gokhale, Sudhir Kulkarni as Bal Gangadhar Tilak, Tom Alter as Chairman, Achyut Potdar as Prof. Jinsivale, Madhav Achwal as Govind Ranacle, and John Holyer as Journalist. The script is by Govind P. Despande and the consultant is Prof. Y.D. Phadke.
Nehru opines that the early stages of the political movement were dominated by the ideological urges of upper middle classes. With the coming-of-age of the National Congress founded in 1885, anew type of leadership appeared, more aggressive and defiant, representing the much larger number of lower middle classes as well as youth. The powerful agitation against ‘Partition’ of Bengal had thrown up many able and aggressive leaders but the real symbol of the ‘radical’ new age was Bal Gangadhar Tilak from Maharashtra with his power base around Pune. ‘Moderates’, who favoured constitutional methods, became identified with Gopal Krishna Gokhale, whose power-base was among Mumbai intelligentsia.
The first signs of polarisation in the Congress ranks loom large in Maharashtra in late 1890‘s. In the prevailing debate on the ‘Age of Consent Bill’, Gokhale declines to go against the government. ‘Radicals’ like Tilak argue about the futility of revisionist petitions to the government. Revolutionary slogans are in the air, tempers run high and conflicts seem inevitable. To avoid confrontation, opinions of Dadabhai Naoroji, universally regarded as the father-figure of the country, are sought but to no avail.
Gokhale accepts the need for patience, and moves easily between the presidency of Congress and membership of the Viceroy’s Council. His contrived view is that the establishment of railways has hastened the policy of free trade. Tilak experiments with mass-focus appeals like the politicisation of festivals, patriotic crusades based on the legacy of Shivaji and exhortations to Civil disobedience, and printing seditious poetry in his newspaper ‘Kesari’. Reports of incidents of defiling idols and molesting women by the Tommies bring charges of sedition on Tilak. Gokhale is left in a quandary and hastens to pardon him in public.
Sentenced to prison, Tilak becomes a martyr for the Nationalist cause. As Nehru notes, the explosion that greeted the ‘Partition’ of Bengal in 1905 finds its echo in Tilak’s incendiary speeches, while in Gokhale’s camp, there is consolatory anticipation that the incoming Secretary of State is going to be sympathetic to the Nationalist cause. Gokhale continues to be the voice of moderation, yet the pamphlets and petitions flood everywhere, announcing extension of Swadeshi protest to the whole of India. It spreads in a remarkable display of united and effective action. Congress, however, disowns the movement. At the 1906 Congress in Nagpur, a split is avoided by extending an invitation to the octogenarian Dadabhai Naoroji to take the chair by Surendranath Banerjee, and some contrite resolutions favouring Swaraj (self-rule). In the 1907 Congress meet at Surat, the divisions between ‘radicals’ like Tilak and ‘moderates’ like Gokhale can no longer be contained.
As Nehru summarises, the 1907 clash in Congress resulted apparently in a victory for the ‘moderates’ through organisational control. There was, however, no doubt that the vast majority of political-minded people in India favoured Tilak and his ‘radical’ group.
Connect with Prasar Bharati Archives:
Visit PB Archives WEBSITE: archives.prasarbharati.org/
Like PB Archives on FACEBOOK: / ddarchives
Follow PB Archives on TWITTER: / centralarchives
Follow PB Archives on INSTAGRAM: / pbarchives
You can watch our Archivals footage also at android platform on NewsOnAir PrasarBharati Official app AIR News+Live from the Google play store: play.google.com/store/apps/de...
Subscribe our channel for more updates. - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
What a classy man *Gopal Krishna Gokhale* was? A true man of honour and reason! 🙏🏻🙏🏻
Gone are the days when leaders used to think about the people first and then about themselves.
5:53 everyone needs to listen to this.
41:50 Todays generation should listen to what G K Ghokhle is saying
Aaj bhi Mahadev Govind Ranade ke vichar prabhavi or sacchai ke sath khade lagte hain 👍👌
When Tilak ji says janta janardan I get goosebumps because my name was janardan
,,😅
@@anandnag8305me yptt
Jay hind for all indian freedom fighter 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Wagle Newpaper company was started around 1675 and owned by my Great Great Grandfather Bhagwan Waga Chitroda Ji. Since then it is still in operation today in Nepal and is noted as the oldest newspaper company in the World. 🤴🏽🕉🔺➕
Abe chutiye kya bhang kha kr betha h
Wow!! Great🙏
1675 नसेल रे मित्रा 1875 असेल छ. शिवाजी महाराजांचा म्र्युत्यु 1680 ला झाला
Wow
How come when there were no print blocks for any Indian language? First book printed in Goa used English blocks for Marathi Language, leave aside Nepal. Check the year! 🤔
Thank you so much for uploading this treasure! I am watching this on the hundredth death anniversary of Sri. Tilak and I have never felt more proud about having born in this mystery land that is India!
@Lucila Sasportas you guessed it right nobody gives a shit
Once upon a time Maharashtra used to be neucleas of Indian polity.Now it has become a battleground for different castes.
Sudhir Kulkarni as Balgangadhar Tilak.
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Waah kya vichardhara hai Bal Gangadhar Tilakji ki 🙏🇮🇳
Great informative episode 💫💫
बहुत सुंदर
The lawyer of Tilak was Jinnah
Also , he was the champion of Hindu-Muslim unity during 1930s , but , at last ended being the divider of india and creator of pakistan in 40s . We can wonder how a person can keep his/her personal prestige above all , nation,religion, humanity, everything.
@@praveshtyagi8382
Everything has a limit. Everyone has a limit to tolerate oppression.
Once I used to be a patriot Indian. My best friend was a Hindu. My sister's and wife's best friends are also Hindus.
My best friend was poor. I was from a upper middle-class family. I used to help him.
I used to hate to think in terms of Hindu-Muslim.
Now I'm a panislamist. I hate my country. Because its government and system hate me. I can't remain alive without retaliation. Still I don't hate Hindus personally. But I hate them politically. They support BJP and RSS. They want to expell us.
Now I understand the situation of Quaid-e-Azam Mr Jinnah.
My forefathers were wrong. They should have migrated along with Mr Jinnah.
I'm trying to migrate.
@@praveshtyagi8382
I'm not talented so much.
But he was talented. Apne auqat dikha diya.
@@king_hhh Bro go as soon as possible. We know u people find excuses to be pan islamists.Just go bro find a better place and take your extended family as well.
And last me Jinnah ne apna chera dikha diya
Make a playlist for this series.🙏👍
Please
Jai ho tilak ji ki koti koti naman mahan byakti the dono mein kitne different views the but tilak ji fir v kitni respect fully baat kiye
Gokhle is the best. Tilak is the worst. Gokhle wanted to change society and reform Hindu culture. Tilak hasn't even seen the brutality in Hinduism. Tilak is an asshole.
Good....
Lok manye tilak Jativaad me aur km age ki girls ki shaadi me vishwas rakhte thhe...aaj pta chala
@@shivajishilkantham agar galat kaam aaj b hota h to iska ye matlab nahi ki wo pehle theek tha. Jin maha purausho ne child marriage ki us wakt un par pressure tha..lekin jab wo bade hue to unhone aawaj b uthayai. Jaha tk baat angrejo ki h to law unhone hi India me introduce kiya. Yaha k logo ne nahi kiya. Har kiis system me kami ho skti h jisko wakt k sath sudhar lena chaiye..
Freedom is not the most important thing. Reform of religion is most important.
Tilak is stupid. Gokhle wanted to change society and reform Hindu culture. Tilak hasn't even seen the brutality in Hinduism. Tilak is an asshole.
Yes.. Tilak सनातनी ब्राह्मण थे
@@sukantg7846 यदि जातिवाद करते थे तो फिर किस बात के ब्राह्मण
Bal Gangadhar Tilak ek santani brahman hai unhone sc st obc kabhe bhi support nahi kiya
Look at सौमित्र. So young
बहुत सही
Tilak replicates modern Chanakya!! 🙏😊
There was no Chanakya!! Chanakya is a fictional character
❤❤❤
Tilak was the first leader of the Indian Independence Movement.
First independence leader is muslim university DARULULOOM DEVBAND Reid history 1857
@@lookdownlookdown8434
Lol Lokmanya Tilak was the first popular pan Indian leader and the next was Mahatma Gandhi
In 1857 Rani Laxmibai, Tatya Tope and Nansaheb Peshwa were freedom fighters
Which Muslim University freedom fighters ??
@@lookdownlookdown8434
Hahahahaha, AMU founder Sir Syed Ahmad Khan openly said that mzlms should not protest against British rule, either they should demand a separate nation or should live under British rule bcoz the british are atleast "The people of the book". Go and read history, mzlms didn't join the national movement until british removed the caliph of turkey after defeating them in 1st WW.
Bahadur shah Zafar was the leader of first Indian movement .
@@skandsrivastava8387 it is false he never say that.
Jai jai bal gangadhar tilak
Gopal Krishna gokhale ❤
Support to Extremists 🇮🇳💪 *Lal Bal Pal*
DHANY DHANY LOKMANYA TILAKJI
Freedom is not the most important thing. Reform of religion is most important.
Tilak is stupid. Gokhle wanted to change society and reform Hindu culture. Tilak hasn't even seen the brutality in Hinduism. Tilak is an asshole.
The show is based on a book ! Just a book. Our history has been interpreted by so many historians and there are different views to look at everything. There is nationalist view, feminist view, Marxist view etc. Please be cautious that whatever this show showed is not the entire history it's what This Book by Jawaharlal Nehru says. Or an effort towards depicting the same on screen.
Just a book. Every history is JUST a book sometimes written in mystical ways. They can be epics ( Ramayan, Mahabharat ) or just simple poetry story telling ( Rani Laxmibai, Rani Padmavati etc). How else will history be conveyed. Maybe Jawaharlall Nehru wrote a book, but this series is more than the book and I will not be surprised if it has deviated from the book and based on actual documented history ( see the Casting titles and research credits ).
I would gladly like to quote the example of Henry vivian derozio from episode 41 of Ram mohun roy.... According to derozio.... Have guts to question everything which has been fed to you... Constantly or intermittently through tools of societal conditioning, pedagogical methodology......
This episode has put Tilak into bad light... He has been portrayed as a firey rudimentary Hindu.... But those who have read Tilak know that there are several nuances/layers associated with the ideology of particular person.... His ultimate aim was swaraj and freedom... By any means....
He knew very well without gathering masses it is impossible to attain substantial changes in status quo... Due to this very reason he used religion as a tool to gather masses... Through ganesh puja, through propogating about shivaji maharaj....
Know I have arrived at this truth by studying both sides of Tilak.... Whether he was right or wrong ,nobody can comment upon it as morality is bound to change with time.
Sata history to book pe hi based hoti h mam, jha tk content ki bat h to humanity me subjectivity ho h,
. was àaàààà ,.w.w.w.⁷88777
Absolutely spot on.. History has countless versions.
When you see the epidemic plague control, it reminds us what happened to control Corona Pandemic in China and all over the world.. It was necessary for that administration at that time to control the epidemic. It was life and death situation. It was insensitive to the local culture, but doing it to saved lives. People were Ignorant. If you don't control epidemics by following local culture, still people will blame you. Another thing I noticed, is how Shivaji Maharaj is being manipulated by leaders. There are evidences Shivaji Maharaj wanted to kill Afzal Khan when he left Rajgad. He was all prepared to kill. He had made up his mind, wether Afzal Khan tries first or not. It is now always mentioned that Afzal tried to attack first to make Shivaji Maharaj ethical! People forget in war there is no Ethics! History is manipulated, the Truth is distorted. Indian history is not trustworthy to a real objective historians. This series is bit closer to the Truth but still shows how ignorant and biased people are and how wrong the history is or was.
Jaati me vishwas tha inka...am I right
जो मांगे तिलक ने 1894 ने रखी थी उस मांग को कांग्रेस ने 1930 में रखा। जैसे स्वराज की मांग और अंग्रेजों से असहयोग। इससे सिद्ध होता है कि कांग्रेस की सोच कितनी धीमी थी और तिलक कितने आगे सोचते थे।
Or aise to age of consent bill ko lekar kya kahoge tilak k baareme. 😅😅 isliye dont compare two things which are both equally important!
What about age of consent bill?
Tilak bhi to congress me hi the garmdal se
🎉
5:55
I was waiting for the shoe throwing incident from the beginning .. but you haven't shown it😀
Tell something about that incident
Reporter wagley tewha paan 😂😂😂
Why so less comments on this video?
Delete mat marna ye episode plz ye mere liye bhut mayne rakta hai.....🙏
kyu?
@@machine.g civil services ki taiyari😅
@@XAVIERLove69 revision krna hoga bichari ko 😂
Why But Dear ??? 📢📢🤧
What ranade said is appropriate for the muslim women who support wearing Burkha
Age of consent bill par tilak ke vichar rudhivadi tha
Tilak 🔥
Freedom is not the most important thing. Reform of religion is most important.
Tilak is stupid. Gokhle wanted to change society and reform Hindu culture. Tilak hasn't even seen the brutality in Hinduism. Tilak is an asshole.
Lok manta Tilak ji was great
Freedom is not the most important thing. Reform of religion is most important.
Tilak is stupid. Gokhle wanted to change society and reform Hindu culture. Tilak hasn't even seen the brutality in Hinduism. Tilak is an asshole.
Bhai BG Tilak kabhi bhi samaj sudhaar ke virodhi nahi the unko glat tareeke se btaya jaa rha h
तिलक sc st ओबीसी के परम विरोधी थे
Vo bhi samaj mein sudhaar chahte the ekin unhone age of consent act ka virodh kiya tha
@@shivajishilkantham beautiful
Freedom is not the most important thing. Reform of religion is most important.
Tilak is stupid. Gokhle wanted to change society and reform Hindu culture. Tilak hasn't even seen the brutality in Hinduism. Tilak is an asshole.
Lokmanya Tilak is represent of extremist movement in congress..
he was a brahmin.lived by manus principle
Congress gayhi bhad mein
Chaphekar brothers 🔥
Kayarta aur atyachar seh kr ek din v jina karodo baar marne se jyada peda deta hai
Us zamne m logo ne apni age se bd kr kam kiye
Education ki value smjhi
Sirf bookish knowledge ni
Knowledge+ecthics
Se ange bd kr
Britishers ko sbk shikhaya
.
But ja ka youth kitna pichhe hai
Aj ke zamne me ,inke comparison m ,
(Hme sb mil gya h,ab to,hm azad h) ye man kr aj ki generation desh ke bare m kch ni sochti
ऋषियों के कुल का पता लगाया और राजाओ पर अभियोग भी चलाया जा सकता है
Tilak rudhivadi man tha
"Azadi bheek mangne se nahi milti hai , bheek me sirf roti ke tukde milte hai" .
Wish extremist movement lasted one more decade .
Weak leader produces weak followers.
We all know how manly was our So called महा आत्मा Gandhi .
great u want to make our country like afghanistan or Nigeria..wake up man.read books and grow with knowledge
Freedom is not the most important thing. Reform of religion is most important. Sometimes weakness is good. Manhood is a weapon of stupid people. Gokhle is intellegent. Tilak is stupid. Gokhle wanted to change society and reform Hindu culture. Tilak hasn't even seen the brutality in Hinduism. Tilak is an asshole.
You are right pensioners of britishers, who said sorry to britishers should not be considered hero, now a days people are doing that
Ye gopal Rao aur gokhle ek hi actors he kya?
Tilak is orthodox person
38:52 .... Gambhir hokar bhashan krte h.. :-)
feku baba
हर तरह के👫👬👭 विदेशी👽👽देश🌏 के लिए खतरनाक हीं साबित होता है!
Mg ranade himself married with 11 years old girl
That's why Kashiram and mayawati said... Congress Brahmadwadi party hai... Jaise BJP Brahmadwadi hai
तिलकजी के विचारो का नेहरुजी द्वारा किया गया इंटरप्रिटेशन जैसा होने की अपेक्षा है वैसा ही है| यानी गलत|
उस सिरीयल के वक्त नेहरुजी का बहुत कुछ सही लगा था| लेकिन अब उनकी वो क्रेडीबिलिटी मन मे नही रही|
tilak was castiest and against women empowerment. agar tilak jase log raaj karte to bharat abhi bhi 500 sal pichhe rehta.
@@abhia6775 Life me balance hona jaruri hai
@@abhia6775 right 🙌👍
@@abhia6775 सही कहा भाई | टिलक ब्राह्मणवादी और समाज के प्रगती के लिये घातक था | टिलक दोगला इन्सान था | 'टिलक ने राष्ट्रवाद का धंदा किया और बहोत पैसा कमाया था' एसा खुद टिलक के बेटे ने लिखा है |
Angrejon NE AUR INSE BHI pahle musalmanon NE hindustaniyon SE AUR khaskar BRAHMIN SE YAHI seekha " devide and RULE " . We were devided in castes , wasn't this ? Makkaar hi jhuthla SAKTE HAIN.
🤣 🤣 nehru ne India ki history apni taraf se bana di
Accha? To mat dekho...jab NEHRU ne Shivaji ke bare me and so called tum jese bhakt logo ke chahite ke bare me accha likha tab wah wah kitne acche log the esi bate krne lgte ho . Tab NEHRU ki tarif nahi hoti but Chugli karne dode aate hai IT cell wale....Jake padho and balance views rkho faltu ka chit chat me mat pdo.Party perspective se dekhne ka DOGLAPAN bandh krdo.
सभी लेखक हिस्ट्री को अपने तरीके से लिखते हैं।
आज हम जो कुछ भी जानते हैं, वह किसी का अपना विचार है।
@@XAVIERLove69 aur ye chutiya upsc wala haii😂😂😂
Ye bht short story h
Spectrum or vipin Chandra books me or jankari milegi
Tilak was great patriot and too much conservative. He was against the age of consent bill.that increase the sexual intercourse for girl age from 10 to 12.
Classic Serial Superhero "कर्मा -मायावी नगरी "
"Kindly upload on TH-cam all episodes Most Popular Superhero "Karma -Mayavi Nagari" Popular Superhero TV Series (1999-2001) "Yash Tonk " as "Karma"
"Balaji Telefilms"
Concept : Ekta Kapoor
Produced by :"Ekta Kapoor" & "Shobha Kapoor "
on aired on "DD National" every Saturday midday time 1pm to 2pm
Running Time : 45 minutes
"Karma Black Mask Superhero
"Karma Costume Up "Collar.
"Karma fights evil spirits and Tantrik, Witch more powerful Supervillan etc.
"Karma Costume fornt side and back side "big Circle inside Big Stylish "K"
"Karma - Mayavi Nagari" title song running song flying Karma
Superhero "Karma -Mayavi Nagari" "Classic" Superhero TV Series "Yash Tonk" as "Karma" "Balaji Telefilms" on aired on "DD National" every "Saturday midday time "1pm "Karma -Mayavi Nagari" title "song running song flying Karma"
" Karma Costume "big Circle Circle "inside Big K" on Costume" front and back side Circle inside Big K on Costume
"कर्मा - मायावी नगरी" का शीर्षक गीत
एक वीर बड़ा जोशीला है कर्मा कर्मा कर्मा
सच्चाई का पूजक है कर्मा कर्मा कर्मा
कब तक जुर्म करेगा मायावी नगरी का पुजारी पुजारी पुजारी
वीर को हर लेता है कर्मा कर्मा कर्मा
कब तक जुर्म करेगा मायावी नगरी का पुजारी पुजारी पुजारी
कब तक जुर्म करेगा मायावी नगरी का पुजारी पुजारी पुजारी
कर्मा कर्मा कर्मा
कर्मा कर्मा कर्मा "
भारत के दूसरे सुपरहीरो "कर्मा -मायावी नगरी" ("कर्मा -मायावी नगरी")
"लोकप्रिय टीवी श्रृंखला"
उत्कृष्ट धारावाहिक "कर्मा - काल्पनिक" (1999-2001) "यश टोंक" को "कर्मा "/ "करण" "
निर्माता: "एकता कपूर" और " शोभा कपूर "9 अक्टूबर 1999 को" डीडी नेशनल "हर" शनिवार "दोपहर के समय दोपहर 1 से 2 बजे
"कर्मा -मायावी नगरी" "शीर्षक गीत" में कर्मा उड़ रहा है
"कर्मा " बुरी आत्माओं "और" तांत्रिक "," चुड़ैल "और अधिक" सुपरविलेन "आदि से लड़ता है
"कर्मा "मास्क" कॉस्टयूम अप कॉलर "" दोनों हाथ "" आसमान की ओर "और नीचे की ओर" पोशाक पर लिखा है के।
"कर्मा " अलौकिक शक्तियां अन्य भूमिका निभाती हैं "सामान्य मानव" "नाम
"करण "कार्यालय में नौकरी" और "रिपोर्टर "करण" बुरी शक्तियों के बारे में जानते हैं"
"करण" पहनता है" "हाफ शर्ट" और "औपचारिक पैंट" और
"करण " हेयर स्टाइल मिडिल साइड बालों को कंघी करता है और पारदर्शी बड़े
Theek hai jativadi Vani brahmanwadi Hote
bjp bhakkats n company cant even imagine the sacrifice of the congress for the country
This is not the same Congress which BJP oppose.
@@tusharathour But this is not the same Bjp to which now a days kishan,doctors,students dissenting...this is not a bjp of Atal ji....this is a bjp of corporate dalal
@@towhidmomin2019 that's an illusion. It is called weath creation for distribution.
But what happened to the Atal's BJP . Lost 2004 inspite of good work. Politics is never for idealism. It is always for retaining power with compromises.
Laate ke bhooto ko Baat karne wale Atal aur gandhi nahi, peechwade pe laat marne wale Savarkar, Tilak aur Modi, Shah aur Yogi jaise Neta chahiyee.. No wonder u guys want soft leaders so that u can do ur manmani. Acche din tumhare beet gayee..
Hindus were never united shame
Ye angrejo ke jamane me bhi kitne moj me the or ek tarf logo ko jine ka haq bhi nhi tha ..
Tilak is philosophically flawed, historically deaf & politically immature.
This series shows the Brahmin and the Brahmans trying to control the Hindu people as they did not want to create a modern India or Government. The Samavidhan or constitution was put together by my Great Grandfather Natha Chitroda and then played and installed by my Grandfather Mepa Chitroda.🤴🏽🕉🔺➕
Yes absolutely
Brahmins are villan and oppressors and backward thinkers even after contributed so much to India' in every field?
Tilak should have been our father of nation
Why He was Superstitious ✍️🇮🇳🗣️
He is call maker of india
Only Jyotiba Phule deserves to be called the father of the nation!
@@birindersingh2215 tera baap lage
@@sushilsharma-re1gn Tilak tera baap tha........apni maa se poocch!!
Subash Bose aur ajad k bare nahin dikhana kya kuch kami nahin hai ish main
लाल बाल पाल
Sab ke sab ghor jativadi Brahman
देश की लढाई क्या सिर्फ ब्राम्हणो नेही लढि है.... क्या बकवास दिखावा है ऐ
Etna jayada e budha urdu bola h ki samjh me nahi ati h
BGT was typical conservative, orthodox narrow minded person.
You are not comptent enough his mind depth
It is similar to saying Baba Saheb Ambedkar was British stooge.......plz learn to grasp contex of them before making outlandish comments🙏
Everyone should be conservative and open minded.