Finally ...someone pointing out how good is chae..i can agree she lack about her stage presence..but her movement are very elegant..shes like a dancing water..i dont know how to describe..if i can compare her sister is fire and she is the water...i very love to see her in loco..so sharp and clean..she is underrated dancer..like i always see yeji and ryujin got best dancer (which is cannot be deny)but pliss dont appriciate chaer too
Because Ryujin has this masculine, tomboyish aura to her that is unique in girl groups including her own while Yuna is competing with Yeji and Chae with that feminine, powerful aura.
First of all dey aren't on de same level wen it comes to dancing. Wen it comes to idol dancing, then yea, they r on de same level, but wen it comes to normal pop dance, Ryujin surpasses Yuna by far
delulu. Their choreos are these normal pop dances and in every comeback Yuna outshines Ryujin as a dancer: icy, wannabe, not shy, mitm etc@@favouronwuanumba2014
From this very informational, methodical video what I got was: Lia: The most hardworking dancer Yuna: The most performative dancer Ryujin: The most dynamic dancer Yeji: The most energetic dancer Chae: The most skilled dancer And together, this is why Itzy is the dancing powerhouse that they are because they all have diverse performance styles. It's not just one member that shines all the time. They all have their individual strengths and colors that give them all a chance to shine.
My mother used to compete in ballroom dancing I asked her who’s was the better dancer in ITZY in her opinion, she said Chaeryeong was the better dancer but Yeji was the better performer. Whatever that means, lol
I agree w her.Technically Chaeryeong is the best dancer of her generation along w Xioting and her sister but it’s a fact that Yeji is the best performer of her generation along w Soyeon of Idle
if they were to join dance competition yeji for sure will since her dancing has no limitation cause she can dance to whatever genre especially boy group dances.
Wow,im SURPRISED with their scores. I thought both yeji and chae would be 90-91,but i can see why you gave them 87. Loved the analysis,loved how you explained RYUJIN especially. I feel like some things could have been mentioned: ryujin lackig extensions sometimes,yeji footwork and lower area control,yuna sudden torso stiffness, etc... but basically,i agree with everything you said. GREAT VIDEO(AS ALWAYS)🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🥰🥰🥰.
Well I mentioned that Ryujin had some tendencies to dance small (meaning she doesn't always extend them). I don't know if I noticed anything crazy about Yejis footwork, but yes I did also consider Yunas stiffness (which was not mentioned in the analysis) but gave her a moderate score in upper body control.
@@psychorious Yeah,i think i didn't see you mentioned ryujin dancing small,i may have missed that,sorry...my bad😬! and sometimes we can't mention everything right haha,the video would be 30+longer. For yeji's footwork,i think it's solid enough,not outstanding,but she does have consistent execution for it,but i would say her legs are definely stronger than her feet. I loved the Ryujin and Yuna "movement quality" explanation,you took the words out of my mouth. Do you have any idea which group comes next???i just know that i'm already excited😎🙏🏻.
@@whysotensepottah463 Well actually, Yeji almost got a full score in lower body control. She only missed one point, but again I'm quite strict about giving people a full score. Yes, Ryujin n Yuna scored pretty high on movement quality, and with good reasons😌 Umm I can already spoil and say It will probably either be Blackpink, Aespa or a boy group. If Aespa gets a comeback in about a month I'll do them. If not, It might be another group
@@psychorious honestly,saaame.usually i tend to not give full scores(except for facials😎).You really did Yuna and Ryujin justice🙏🏻🥳. Blackpink would be so interesting,i would love to see lisa's score🧐. I think Ateez ,TXT or Stray Kids would fit your project soooo much💯,but let's see what the future holds for us🤞🏻.
@@whysotensepottah463 Well I never give full score in facials unless I think they deserves it. The only person I can think of, that would get a full score in facials, is Soyeon. Tbh Yuna and Ryujin did justice for themselves. Ryujin almost got 2nd place, because of "the movement quality" criteria. So in fact the ranking would look something like this 1. Chae 2. Ryujin 3. Yuna 4. Yeji 5. Lia. I thought about doing TXT, but they haven't had a comeback in about a half year, so I might wait... Yeah and about my concept. I really hope it's not gonna be that controversial, since the main dancer can easily rank lower than 3rd place, if they don't score high in movement quality... So I might change my ranking system again... Oh well
If it were for me I would have worded the title a little more different:Ranking the best technically dancers in Itzy.Because It’s a fact that when It comes to Idol performers,Yeji is one of the best or may I say the best of her generation along w Soyeon from Idle
I love your videos because of how concise and clear your explanations but I just want to say that here ( 20:31 ) chaeryeong is known as " inconsistent performer "by other dance ranking channels because of how often she changes her power and energy when performing live vs when just dancing, she has great power, energy, speed etc. But it's really inconsistent, and I think one of the factors why she often changes her executions is that so she can be stable when singing Just my opinion tho
Yeah My opinion is that dancers with years of experience know how to control their energy, when to take a “break” or release their tension in their body, and I feel like Chaeryeong is one of them who knows how to handle the intensity of a choreography. The reason they call her inconsistent is probably because she seems to lack strength, and prefer “fluidity” rather than executing with “power”. But in my opinion, she has power. I’m not sure if my comment made any sense tho
@@psychorious I feel like chaeryeong is more comfortable when executing some moves using fluid techniques. But she never lacks in strength and power because she can execute pops and locks correctly and that is something that sets her apart from other fluid base dancers in kpop. She really just have to adjust her energy when performing live so she can sound stable and I think that is not a weakness ( imo ). I think one of her weakness is her leg angles cause I've been watching and comparing her and yejis fancams and she( chae ) really lacks precision in her feet, it's like she can't transfer her weight correctly when doing leg work like in loco ( you got me cray crazy in love part ) And yesss I can understand your point, still, your videos are enjoyable to watch hoping for more content in the future
Just wanna say a few things. 1. I changed Mias ranking. It's only 1 point difference. 2. I also changed my ranking system AGAIN, so that's why Mia got a lower score. 3. Thank you for being so active. It's crazy to see that you enjoy watching my content. Give yourself an applause 4. I'll explain my ranking system in the future. When the audience gets bigger, I'll do it. I have the video ready but guess I gotta make some changes again. 5. Nothing important to say here, but just ask questions etc. I love it. about the itzy analysis... I actually finished the editing in about 4 days to a week. But since the clips went gone, I thought "well okay, why not change the whole theme?". That's also why it took way longer time to finish the video. Don't read this part, if you don't want any "spoilers". I've warned you... The girls are pretty much interchangable. Yuna and Ryujin changed their place (4th and 3rd) all the time, and I couldn't decide which one was better. It was a point where Ryujin got 2nd place, but then changed back to either 4th or 3rd place. So it was a roller coaster. The same went to Chae and Yeji. Since they got the same score, I was going to put Yeji on top because as my title says... "the best performer" is Yeji. However, The most important part of the ranking is part 3 (movement quality). That says a lot about a dancers character imo. Yeji is skilled, but Chae got more persona. So yeah, since this isn't a highly "technique" based analysis, it was harder to place the girls as they all had their unique characteristics. But don't see it as a permanent ranking. It's definitely not Okay, bye
It makes sense!!! What is mia score??? So let me see if i get it right. Yeji and Chaeryeong got the same score?but chae ranked first,right??? And Yuna and Ryujin are tied up?likr a legit TIE. Is that it? I'm SOOOO EXCITED.
@@whysotensepottah463 I changed the ranking many times, so I don't actually remember (Although I can watch the video). But hey, that was supposed to be a "spoiler warning"😂
I know people always say chearyeong's sp is so weak and boring but I've never felt bored watching her fancams in fact they are my fav and you can even see how she improved in Cheshire era , i mean if you didn't see her go check her facial expressions in those stages !!
I’d love to see one of these with billlie. I consider a lot of the members to be fierce dancers so I’d love to see how you rank them overall in a full video like this
I've gotta disagree with your score for chaer's performance quality... she definitely is not the most obviously engaging performer of itzy, but I would not give her just a 10. For sure she has improved a lot since debut and if this was a ranking of just debut era than I think a 10 would be fair, but chaeryeong has come a long way. Her facials are very engaging if you ask me, and she never stops performing tbh. Her presence isn't quite as out there as Yuna or Ryujin, but she still has strong stage presence nowadays. I will say I'm a lil biased, and I'm all too familiar with what chaeryeong looks like when she actually is spaced out (we love a good spaced out chaeryeong edit) so it's hard for me to say she isn't charismatic or engaging on stage when I think she is. I understand that her style of stage presence might not be for everyone, but I do think she deserves a higher score.
Yes, me again So I changed my ranking system again... I don't know why I keep doing it, but for now, it will be permanent. The new ranking system will be explain in another video.
@@Jeanz4haerin You mean technique wise? Yeah I agree. Both Chae and Yeji scored higher than Mia in that part. It's actually my fault for not explaining my ranking system yet, so I get if ppl don't agree with the ranking. I'll explain the system shortly now: Another well known youtuber focus a lot on technique. It covers 70% of the whole analysis. I see technique and "artistry" as equal. They both weight almost 50/50, so therefore it's important for the idols to score high on both. If you watched my Everglow video, Mia scored high on every part. Yeji scored high on part 1 and 2, but low on part 3. Chae got affected by part 1, but could've scored higher if it wasn't for her "stage presence". IN short: you gotta have a high average on every part :) Hope that cleared things up
I personally disagree with the final ranking but that is a type of analysis I am not accustomed to 😊 Seems interesting tho! For me: Chaeryeong (A) > Yeji (A) > Mia (high B) > Yuna (high B) > Ryujin (B) I really wish Chaeryeong would improve her performance quality. She has the potential to be one of the best (she already is) but her facial expressions are holding her back.
Yeah, I get what you mean tho. The tricky part about my ranking is that it's not all about the technique. I value "style" as much as body control. Chaeryeong got high on both body control and movement quality, but her score on "stage presence" was low, so that affected her "whole" score. If you look at Mia, she got high score on everything. I wouldn't normally put her that high, but I did take the analysis very seriously, and couldn't see myself to bring her down just because the other dances better. You can call my analysis "style" based, rather than "technique" based 😊
@@psychorious Makes a lot of sense! Artistry is very important in idol performing! KDDD only values artistry as 10-15% so the outcomes definitely changes here.
@@shujinko2944 Yes I've also watched her video. Her technique counts 70% (I believe) and artistry + musicality: roughly 15-20% This is how mine works: artistry+movement quality: aroung 50-55% body control: around the same percentage. I'll do an explanation video on my analysis in the future😄
@@psychorious Do whatever you think is right! This is your channel and you can have your own rubrique to analyse idols. If you think that movement quality is that important in idol dancing, I do not see anything wrong with that.
Naturally I think Lia is better performer cuz she has natural stage presence, BUT her dancing is what make her overall performance weak, cuz she tend to be focus in do right the movements what I understand cuz remember when she get so much hate for her dancing.
Hey did you watch their sneakers dance practice and face cams at these time i think it's time to give lia a c tier that just look at her lower area coordination has improved a little and her footworks are also became good and her stage presence wow although there are still many problems with her like uncontrolled flexibility, body locks are weak , musicality issue but still now she clearly deserve to be in c tier
I don't think she's in C tier yet. The dance focuses a lot on lower body and footwork, and even if she improved, there are still many aspects in her dancing that haven't been fully developed. I want to see how well she executes in more complex choreos like wannabe and mafia.
@@psychorious i Mean lower c not higher cause if we compare her from loco to sneakers her leg coordination has improved and her stage presence is also became good she was enjoying and that's what I am proud of her I can see potential in her becoming grovvy or Fluidity base dancer and i want to tell one more thing that in video you mentioned that lia has good torso flexibility i agree that she has good flexibility but sometimes it can be uncontrolled for eg not shy and can you suggest me more groups who have good dance line plzz
@@PureHoneyBoo in itzy chaeryoung is not that much great performer even in everglow their weakest performer is better than some.of itzy performer eg lia and chaeryeong , and in everglow all are in top 15 and then we have mia who is basically the best performer in 4th gen with soyeon so basically she will be the best performer in itzy and everglow is not decent at all in performance and rap they all are in top 15 and in rap they have best rap line in 4th gen they both are versatile (aisha and eu) they can freestyle, has great flow, tonality even mia( these i am telling very confidentiality cause right now i am studying rap and i am gonna make a rap ranking video of 4th gen ) is a very good to be a sub rapper like in other groups she can be the lead rapper so i disagree with you and everglow rappers are not underwhelming, itzy rappers are underwhelming
Hi, thank you for your vids. I was wondering what sort of background in dance did you have? How many years in each style? Thank you for the helpful analyses :)
I explained that on my other video called "my ranking system - explained", but I did a lot of hip hop back in middle school (started dancing during primary school). It's been idk how many years... 5-6-7? not sure since I kinda took some breaks in between. I also started learning other styles like jazz and break dance half a year ago (during my time with hip hop, there were many other elements included into my classes like Waacking, popping, break dance, a bit of housing etc). Next year I'll take more classes such as ballet to learn more about the "techniqual" aspect (since my style relies a lot on groove and hits) and also a class that has its focus on the girly/feminine side. thanks for asking btw :)
I feel like Yeji is the better idol dancer (more consistent angles, more power, generally executes their title track choreos slightly better), whereas chae is the better professional dancer (more fluid and has better open style groove).
Timecodes
0:00 - intro
1:45 - 5th place
4:33 - 4th place
7:21 - 3rd place
11:35 - 2nd place
17:45 - 1st
Finally ...someone pointing out how good is chae..i can agree she lack about her stage presence..but her movement are very elegant..shes like a dancing water..i dont know how to describe..if i can compare her sister is fire and she is the water...i very love to see her in loco..so sharp and clean..she is underrated dancer..like i always see yeji and ryujin got best dancer (which is cannot be deny)but pliss dont appriciate chaer too
I think Chaes talent is recognized among the international fans, but not in korean in general.
@@psychorious tq so much for appriciate her
ryujin and yuna are literally on the same level. but why do people only talk about ryujin?
Because Ryujin has this masculine, tomboyish aura to her that is unique in girl groups including her own while Yuna is competing with Yeji and Chae with that feminine, powerful aura.
First of all dey aren't on de same level wen it comes to dancing.
Wen it comes to idol dancing, then yea, they r on de same level, but wen it comes to normal pop dance, Ryujin surpasses Yuna by far
delulu. Their choreos are these normal pop dances and in every comeback Yuna outshines Ryujin as a dancer: icy, wannabe, not shy, mitm etc@@favouronwuanumba2014
From this very informational, methodical video what I got was:
Lia: The most hardworking dancer
Yuna: The most performative dancer
Ryujin: The most dynamic dancer
Yeji: The most energetic dancer
Chae: The most skilled dancer
And together, this is why Itzy is the dancing powerhouse that they are because they all have diverse performance styles. It's not just one member that shines all the time. They all have their individual strengths and colors that give them all a chance to shine.
My mother used to compete in ballroom dancing I asked her who’s was the better dancer in ITZY in her opinion, she said Chaeryeong was the better dancer but Yeji was the better performer. Whatever that means, lol
I agree w her.Technically Chaeryeong is the best dancer of her generation along w Xioting and her sister but it’s a fact that Yeji is the best performer of her generation along w Soyeon of Idle
@@dorismilo7340 there's better dancers, juhyeon from lightsum, the girl from majors etc
Yeji is still the best idol PERFORMER
No she ain’t 😂
@@choerrychile5042 lol yes I think she is but u can have ur own opinion
@@choerrychile5042 she is one of the best or may I say the best along w Soyeon
@@dorismilo7340 no u may not say that
@@dorismilo7340 mia is the best performer in 4th gen along with soyeon
if they were to join dance competition yeji for sure will since her dancing has no limitation cause she can dance to whatever genre especially boy group dances.
I really enjoy these videos! They help me learn.
Wow,im SURPRISED with their scores.
I thought both yeji and chae would be 90-91,but i can see why you gave them 87.
Loved the analysis,loved how you explained RYUJIN especially.
I feel like some things could have been mentioned: ryujin lackig extensions sometimes,yeji footwork and lower area control,yuna sudden torso stiffness, etc... but basically,i agree with everything you said.
GREAT VIDEO(AS ALWAYS)🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🥰🥰🥰.
Well I mentioned that Ryujin had some tendencies to dance small (meaning she doesn't always extend them).
I don't know if I noticed anything crazy about Yejis footwork, but yes I did also consider Yunas stiffness (which was not mentioned in the analysis) but gave her a moderate score in upper body control.
@@psychorious
Yeah,i think i didn't see you mentioned ryujin dancing small,i may have missed that,sorry...my bad😬! and sometimes we can't mention everything right haha,the video would be 30+longer.
For yeji's footwork,i think it's solid enough,not outstanding,but she does have consistent execution for it,but i would say her legs are definely stronger than her feet.
I loved the Ryujin and Yuna "movement quality" explanation,you took the words out of my mouth.
Do you have any idea which group comes next???i just know that i'm already excited😎🙏🏻.
@@whysotensepottah463 Well actually, Yeji almost got a full score in lower body control. She only missed one point, but again I'm quite strict about giving people a full score.
Yes, Ryujin n Yuna scored pretty high on movement quality, and with good reasons😌
Umm I can already spoil and say It will probably either be Blackpink, Aespa or a boy group. If Aespa gets a comeback in about a month I'll do them. If not, It might be another group
@@psychorious honestly,saaame.usually i tend to not give full scores(except for facials😎).You really did Yuna and Ryujin justice🙏🏻🥳.
Blackpink would be so interesting,i would love to see lisa's score🧐. I think Ateez ,TXT or Stray Kids would fit your project soooo much💯,but let's see what the future holds for us🤞🏻.
@@whysotensepottah463 Well I never give full score in facials unless I think they deserves it.
The only person I can think of, that would get a full score in facials, is Soyeon.
Tbh Yuna and Ryujin did justice for themselves. Ryujin almost got 2nd place, because of "the movement quality" criteria.
So in fact the ranking would look something like this
1. Chae
2. Ryujin
3. Yuna
4. Yeji
5. Lia.
I thought about doing TXT, but they haven't had a comeback in about a half year, so I might wait...
Yeah and about my concept. I really hope it's not gonna be that controversial, since the main dancer can easily rank lower than 3rd place, if they don't score high in movement quality...
So I might change my ranking system again... Oh well
:00 i watched all of it and i loved your explanations and i've subbed to you, loved your video
thank you so much😁
If it were for me I would have worded the title a little more different:Ranking the best technically dancers in Itzy.Because It’s a fact that when It comes to Idol performers,Yeji is one of the best or may I say the best of her generation along w Soyeon from Idle
chaeryeong is more fluid and a better "idol" dancer
yeji is a better overall dancer and performer
interesting i usually hear the other way around online which i believe too
I love your videos because of how concise and clear your explanations but I just want to say that here ( 20:31 ) chaeryeong is known as " inconsistent performer "by other dance ranking channels because of how often she changes her power and energy when performing live vs when just dancing, she has great power, energy, speed etc. But it's really inconsistent, and I think one of the factors why she often changes her executions is that so she can be stable when singing
Just my opinion tho
Yeah My opinion is that dancers with years of experience know how to control their energy, when to take a “break” or release their tension in their body, and I feel like Chaeryeong is one of them who knows how to handle the intensity of a choreography.
The reason they call her inconsistent is probably because she seems to lack strength, and prefer “fluidity” rather than executing with “power”. But in my opinion, she has power.
I’m not sure if my comment made any sense tho
@@psychorious I feel like chaeryeong is more comfortable when executing some moves using fluid techniques. But she never lacks in strength and power because she can execute pops and locks correctly and that is something that sets her apart from other fluid base dancers in kpop. She really just have to adjust her energy when performing live so she can sound stable and I think that is not a weakness ( imo ). I think one of her weakness is her leg angles cause I've been watching and comparing her and yejis fancams and she( chae ) really lacks precision in her feet, it's like she can't transfer her weight correctly when doing leg work like in loco ( you got me cray crazy in love part )
And yesss I can understand your point, still, your videos are enjoyable to watch hoping for more content in the future
@@ButchikRibo yeah I actually agree with you. Her leg alignment was not as precise as Yejis during Loco.
I don't even dance but I find these so interesting ! Kudos
Just wanna say a few things.
1. I changed Mias ranking. It's only 1 point difference.
2. I also changed my ranking system AGAIN, so that's why Mia got a lower score.
3. Thank you for being so active. It's crazy to see that you enjoy watching my content. Give yourself an applause
4. I'll explain my ranking system in the future. When the audience gets bigger, I'll do it. I have the video ready but guess I gotta make some changes again.
5. Nothing important to say here, but just ask questions etc. I love it.
about the itzy analysis...
I actually finished the editing in about 4 days to a week. But since the clips went gone, I thought "well okay, why not change the whole theme?". That's also why it took way longer time to finish the video.
Don't read this part, if you don't want any "spoilers". I've warned you...
The girls are pretty much interchangable.
Yuna and Ryujin changed their place (4th and 3rd) all the time, and I couldn't decide which one was better. It was a point where Ryujin got 2nd place, but then changed back to either 4th or 3rd place. So it was a roller coaster.
The same went to Chae and Yeji. Since they got the same score, I was going to put Yeji on top because as my title says... "the best performer" is Yeji.
However, The most important part of the ranking is part 3 (movement quality). That says a lot about a dancers character imo. Yeji is skilled, but Chae got more persona.
So yeah, since this isn't a highly "technique" based analysis, it was harder to place the girls as they all had their unique characteristics.
But don't see it as a permanent ranking. It's definitely not
Okay, bye
It makes sense!!!
What is mia score???
So let me see if i get it right. Yeji and Chaeryeong got the same score?but chae ranked first,right???
And Yuna and Ryujin are tied up?likr a legit TIE.
Is that it?
I'm SOOOO EXCITED.
@@whysotensepottah463 I changed the ranking many times, so I don't actually remember (Although I can watch the video). But hey, that was supposed to be a "spoiler warning"😂
@@psychorious haha!
I just really like spoilers,and i'm soooo excited for the videeeoooo,sorry🤭🤭🤭.
I know people always say chearyeong's sp is so weak and boring but I've never felt bored watching her fancams in fact they are my fav and you can even see how she improved in Cheshire era , i mean if you didn't see her go check her facial expressions in those stages !!
I’d love to see one of these with billlie. I consider a lot of the members to be fierce dancers so I’d love to see how you rank them overall in a full video like this
I've gotta disagree with your score for chaer's performance quality... she definitely is not the most obviously engaging performer of itzy, but I would not give her just a 10. For sure she has improved a lot since debut and if this was a ranking of just debut era than I think a 10 would be fair, but chaeryeong has come a long way. Her facials are very engaging if you ask me, and she never stops performing tbh. Her presence isn't quite as out there as Yuna or Ryujin, but she still has strong stage presence nowadays.
I will say I'm a lil biased, and I'm all too familiar with what chaeryeong looks like when she actually is spaced out (we love a good spaced out chaeryeong edit) so it's hard for me to say she isn't charismatic or engaging on stage when I think she is. I understand that her style of stage presence might not be for everyone, but I do think she deserves a higher score.
Thanks for your perspective :)
I judge them based on 3 criteria. You can see the criteria on my other video called "my ranking system" explained :)
Please do a Twice dance analysis. Your content is so interesting :(
Yes I'm thinking about doing twice one day.
I'm working on another group now☺
@@psychorious can u tease a little bit about Momo's skills 😄
Yes, me again
So I changed my ranking system again...
I don't know why I keep doing it, but for now, it will be permanent.
The new ranking system will be explain in another video.
tbh i think chae and yeji r better than mia
@@Jeanz4haerin You mean technique wise? Yeah I agree. Both Chae and Yeji scored higher than Mia in that part.
It's actually my fault for not explaining my ranking system yet, so I get if ppl don't agree with the ranking.
I'll explain the system shortly now:
Another well known youtuber focus a lot on technique. It covers 70% of the whole analysis.
I see technique and "artistry" as equal. They both weight almost 50/50, so therefore it's important for the idols to score high on both.
If you watched my Everglow video, Mia scored high on every part.
Yeji scored high on part 1 and 2, but low on part 3.
Chae got affected by part 1, but could've scored higher if it wasn't for her "stage presence".
IN short: you gotta have a high average on every part :)
Hope that cleared things up
@@psychorious so like if chaes presence was better she would be first bc chae is better than mia in every way besides facials
@@Jeanz4haerin Chae would get an A, yes. Mia scored higher on part 3 tho, and I can't give her a lower score since she does so well in that section :)
I personally disagree with the final ranking but that is a type of analysis I am not accustomed to 😊 Seems interesting tho!
For me: Chaeryeong (A) > Yeji (A) > Mia (high B) > Yuna (high B) > Ryujin (B)
I really wish Chaeryeong would improve her performance quality. She has the potential to be one of the best (she already is) but her facial expressions are holding her back.
Yeah, I get what you mean tho.
The tricky part about my ranking is that it's not all about the technique.
I value "style" as much as body control.
Chaeryeong got high on both body control and movement quality, but her score on "stage presence" was low, so that affected her "whole" score.
If you look at Mia, she got high score on everything. I wouldn't normally put her that high, but I did take the analysis very seriously, and couldn't see myself to bring her down just because the other dances better.
You can call my analysis "style" based, rather than "technique" based
😊
@@psychorious Makes a lot of sense! Artistry is very important in idol performing!
KDDD only values artistry as 10-15% so the outcomes definitely changes here.
But then, I have a question.
Should I increase "the points" in body control and lower down in movement quality?
@@shujinko2944 Yes I've also watched her video. Her technique counts 70% (I believe) and artistry + musicality: roughly 15-20%
This is how mine works:
artistry+movement quality: aroung 50-55%
body control: around the same percentage.
I'll do an explanation video on my analysis in the future😄
@@psychorious Do whatever you think is right! This is your channel and you can have your own rubrique to analyse idols. If you think that movement quality is that important in idol dancing, I do not see anything wrong with that.
Naturally I think Lia is better performer cuz she has natural stage presence, BUT her dancing is what make her overall performance weak, cuz she tend to be focus in do right the movements what I understand cuz remember when she get so much hate for her dancing.
I’m pretty sure Lia is anemic which alters her dance performance
Hey did you watch their sneakers dance practice and face cams at these time i think it's time to give lia a c tier that just look at her lower area coordination has improved a little and her footworks are also became good and her stage presence wow although there are still many problems with her like uncontrolled flexibility, body locks are weak , musicality issue but still now she clearly deserve to be in c tier
I don't think she's in C tier yet. The dance focuses a lot on lower body and footwork, and even if she improved, there are still many aspects in her dancing that haven't been fully developed. I want to see how well she executes in more complex choreos like wannabe and mafia.
@@psychorious i Mean lower c not higher cause if we compare her from loco to sneakers her leg coordination has improved and her stage presence is also became good she was enjoying and that's what I am proud of her I can see potential in her becoming grovvy or Fluidity base dancer and i want to tell one more thing that in video you mentioned that lia has good torso flexibility i agree that she has good flexibility but sometimes it can be uncontrolled for eg not shy and can you suggest me more groups who have good dance line plzz
4th gen queen groups
Aespa queen of vocals
Itzy queen of dance
Everglow queen lf performance and rap
I would say Itzy for performance too, maybe even Nmixx. Everglow are pretty decent and the rappers are kinda underwhelming…
@@PureHoneyBoo in itzy chaeryoung is not that much great performer even in everglow their weakest performer is better than some.of itzy performer eg lia and chaeryeong , and in everglow all are in top 15 and then we have mia who is basically the best performer in 4th gen with soyeon so basically she will be the best performer in itzy and everglow is not decent at all in performance and rap they all are in top 15 and in rap they have best rap line in 4th gen they both are versatile (aisha and eu) they can freestyle, has great flow, tonality even mia( these i am telling very confidentiality cause right now i am studying rap and i am gonna make a rap ranking video of 4th gen ) is a very good to be a sub rapper like in other groups she can be the lead rapper so i disagree with you and everglow rappers are not underwhelming, itzy rappers are underwhelming
Hi, thank you for your vids.
I was wondering what sort of background in dance did you have? How many years in each style? Thank you for the helpful analyses :)
I explained that on my other video called "my ranking system - explained", but I did a lot of hip hop back in middle school (started dancing during primary school). It's been idk how many years... 5-6-7? not sure since I kinda took some breaks in between.
I also started learning other styles like jazz and break dance half a year ago (during my time with hip hop, there were many other elements included into my classes like Waacking, popping, break dance, a bit of housing etc).
Next year I'll take more classes such as ballet to learn more about the "techniqual" aspect (since my style relies a lot on groove and hits) and also a class that has its focus on the girly/feminine side.
thanks for asking btw :)
Will comment later
I feel like Yeji is the better idol dancer (more consistent angles, more power, generally executes their title track choreos slightly better), whereas chae is the better professional dancer (more fluid and has better open style groove).
Can you do Momo twice for me please!!
I'll do Twice one day. Right now, I'm working on another group :)
Oh this is my 1st comment