Guilty Crown Is the Answer to Code Geass, and It Was (Almost) Beautiful - Anime Analysis
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 พ.ย. 2020
- Is Guilty Crown a Code Geass clone and nothing more? Or is the divisive anime something more--a spiritual successor, a love letter, a response? We dive into it on today's Anime Analysis with Spoons.
I've found that many people are quick to dismiss Guilty Crown as a knockoff of Code Geass largely because of the (MANY) similarities between the two anime. But I believe these similarities go beyond intention and into integral--they are part of the intended message of Guilty Crown.
Follow me on Twitter: / fourteenspoons
Join the Discord: / discord
#anime #guiltycrown #codegeass #fourteenspoons - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
What are your thoughts on the connections between Guilty Crown and Code Geass? Let me know! And be sure to like and subscribe!
I also thought it was like a what if of Code Geass but I like it.
when i began watching guilty crown i noticed the inate similarities between the two but kept watching as it was still enjoyable. The issue for me came when they turned shu into a lelouch like character in the second half of the show. I really enjoyed his character and seeing the dramatic change after the death of a friend that bothered me and made it so I couldn't finish the show.
Young people who were previously exposed to the "spores" but not developed them inmediatly have some form of inmunity [and/or achieved some form of symbiosis], in a way that makes it possible for them to SURVIVE both an extraction of their "essence" & a later restoration of it.
Is not that the "Voids" can not be "extracted" from much older people (it is posible), but rather the problem is that those could not be then RETURNED without killing them from the inside (by an unavoidable "crystalization" process).
-> The Voids are not a "natural" (or supernatural?) aspect of reality that was always present on humans beings, but rather a form of "magitech" [derived from a "recent" contact with aliens, fay or eldrich horrors].
The way they manifest & their varied "functionality" sugest that some kind of "artificial inteligence" (trascendental & sentient, but not necesarily sapient), is creating the devices based on the "whole depth" of the psyque of an individual (SuperEgo, Id, Ego & Tulpa), rather than just their superficial mind.
Tbh while they may be similar i love both shows and both have their ups and downs e.g. code geass has lelouch's amazing mind while guilty crown has its amazing and beautiful animation
English auto subtitles please
You literally explained why Shu's behavior in the show's second half made sense. Thank you. Oh, and Lelouch's biggest weapon is still his charisma. He's so good at making people stick to him
including the viewers
I love guilty crown because this is what a normal human being would have reacted in the situation that Shu was placed in.
No i dont agree with the term normal while yea probably no one was gonna be lelouch but does not necessarily mean everyone was gonna be like shu people are varieties in the concept of normal
Agree
No ur wrong...anime was bullshit no story, disturbing and to sentimental
Yes finally someone who understands guilty crown
I agree with you
So you caught on to the connection between the two: Code Geass (CG) - Guilty Crown (GC)
CG ≈ GC
They don't hold back the connections do they.
Buddy, the original titles are Japanese. You think they were thinkin of Engliah acronyms? Gimme a break.
@@ibn_adham The japanese titles are in english though.. It’s not an Attack on Titan situation
Lol
@@ibn_adham A quick google search proves you wrong mate kek
Time for a lesson in algebra
code geass = cg = cXg
Guilty Crown = gc =gXc
cXg=gXc
cg=gc
Solved
I love Guilty Crown. I found myself more invested in Shu. And that ending broke my heart more that it was broken already.
Watch Sukasuka for true heartbreak
Everytime i remember Shu siting on the bench, eyes closed, listening to Inori's song, can't help but feel like crying. Epic ending
@@TheZetamx at least him and Inori are still together in a way, although bittersweet
@@TheZetamx I actually watched Guilty Crown before Code Geass. I liked seeing Shu more than Lelouch because he displays what a normal person would do. The Funeral Parlour characters were a lot more interesting and cooler than the Black Knights as well. I really don't find any characters interesting in Code Geass. Suzaku and Cornelia were a bit interesting. Inori was boring as hell but the rest were shining. I like the having the Voids and Apocalypse Virus aspect as well
Also the most memorable Shu moment for me was Hare's death episode :(
@@naylisyazwina6836 Brodie. Inori was half emotionless so obviously "shes boring"
Code geass captivated my mind, how I process the world and a clash of ideals between groups, it’s ideas push my thoughts forwards and pose interesting ideas. Guilty crown captivated my heart, the music and visuals drew me in, the protagonist relatability and power choice both open up a lot more opportunity to feel empathy and understand people. I don’t think either anime is completely accurate on what would happen, but they both bring up profound and interesting points and they are great foils of each other
This is facts. Guilty Crown is deliberately different from Code Geass - and seeing Shuu come into his own as opposed to Lelouch who things came natural to is an interesting spin. Which ends up making Guilty Crown unique in its own sense instead of being a Copy.
Fair enough, since Lelouch has his massive intellect going for him as a natural advantage. Personally, I didn't find Shuu as compelling a character, but I do understand the appeal behind Shuu a little more now.
can't wait to see your channel become popular, this analysis is quite interesting
I think a lot of people bash Guilty Crown a little to hard without acknowledging the humanity and vulnerability that Shu has. Even though he was not the most liked character, he did what any actual human would do in a situation where they got an unknown power and he freaked out. He had his ups and downs but he obviously made the right decisions in the end because he saved humanity. GC is not as bad as people make it out to be.
Mmm I never thought about it that way. I have watched both anime and while I agree Code Geass is the better of the two. I think Guilty Crown isn't as bad as some make it out to be. I enjoyed the show but hated the ending.
I know the ending was just a kick in the balls to the main character all he’s been through and he can’t even be with his love
@Bulak lol for all intent and purpose she is dead yes her soul lives on in shu but they can’t have a life together have a family ect
Its tragic by design. Even the title name says so
Are you a Tower of God reader?
@@BlueCircle0 yessir
Is it funny that I watched guilty crown then I watched code geass and I noticed they were similar
I just finished code geass then I went looking around and found this lol
Same lol
well. which was better to you seeing how you saw them in that order?
Even though I saw them in a weird order code geass was still better in every way
I only really found about how much better code geass was afterwards because I’m horrible at telling if something is good or trash I watched through guilty crown and never though wow this is really bad. Either way looking back at both of them even when I didn’t really know if they were good or not I still likes code geass even better because it made me exited for every episode while guilty crown didn’t do that or maybe it did like once idk.
Lol
Nothing can beat code Geass ending
I now understand why Hare's death had to happen in s2...because she had the same role as shirley, and both served only to hurt and challenge the MC emotionally.
Although shus development was still better
Hare was also a Lois Lane figure in that her death triggered a tyrannical turn to someone trying to do good. I was more shocked by Shirley’s death, but more saddened by Hare’s.
Two halves a whole? Looks like your mustache is missing a half..
ikr
To all the people saying GC is a copy or knockoff of CG, it’s basically the same as saying the shounen animes/ mangas are copying each other lmao. The only thing these two animes are similar is that the protagonists become terrorists to overthrow the government. Otherwise, it completely have different components. Like in shounens, the main protagonist is weak/ alone but they have a big dream so they try hard and face hardships, gain friends, fight evil and ultimately fulfill their dreams? That’s typical shounen and you can’t say they’re copying each other. I love both GC and CG but I’ve never thought GC is a copying. I see them as complete different animes with similar genre/ theme that I enjoy a lot.
Finally someone addressed this. I like the way TV Tropes described GC: the spiritual successor to CG. I appreciate the perspective you used to analyze the two, but as a magic system nerd I feel the need to point out a bit more (spoilers for the uninitiated). Geass is indeed meant to dominate, and CG's ending heavily relies on it to manipulate everyone else involved for the sake of the greater good. Whereas in GC, at Shu's rise from his dark night of the soul, his revelation is that the king must inspire himself (bringing out his own void) and gets stronger by taking on the burden of others (taking others' voids and saving them from crystallization). These are very different paths to kingship, and had GC gone about it differently (no mechas for starters if you want kids with superpowers to fight) I think it could have been better than CG.
The only thing that ruined Guilty Crown from me was the lack of development on the secret organization of Daath. Otherwise, the series has kind of become a cult favorite of mine
Also. One thing I must explain. The Visual novel "Lost Christmas" and concept art explain that voids can only be drawn out of people born after the meteorite fell to Oshima, and the meteorite fell 17 years ago. Like in Evangelion, kids only born after the impact could ride Evas.
Also the missing plot points that made it feel like they were pulling out new shit out their ass mid story
I still like guilty crown but it honestly cant really even compare to code geass
Yep the lack of daath and mana really showed in the end sadly. Also everyone was so related with no good explanation like everyone was related at one point
I found it very similar to NGE actually.
idk why people think a show is automatically bad if it has similarities with another . i always try to judge shows for what they are by themselves. why would similarities ruin a show? this show was visually stunning , the music was beyond great and the plot wasn't bad at all.
People are hypocrites friend.
Most times derivative works aren't worth the time. If something is trying to copy a work, just watch the original
@@OrangePandaBear1every work is derivative, thats how humans make shit.
I've never drew a comparison to the two animes and you make some great points. I suggest watch/play guilty crown:lost chirstmas. It expands the world of guilty crown a little bit and overall an enjoyable read.
I remember watching Guilty Crown at 15 and thinking it was pretty original.
And THEN I watched Code Geass and Evangelion (with the scared protagonist with no ambition) and completely changed my mind.
This goes to the saying as a ruler, Would you rather be loved by your people or feared by your people?
I finished this anime just now and I have my own review of it. Shu to me was a very human protagonist and I loved seeing his development. In the beginning, all he wanted was to be useful to society which is a common thought to anyone. He knows what’s going in society, but the moment, he met Inori, his life changed and he was asked to tie the strings together but he was asked if he was a coward. His insecurity refuted the offer from a danger and didn’t know less from the situation. From my perspective, Shu always wanted to be a hero because he did follow Inori and at the beginning, he let Inori be captured because of his insecurity and his self conflict. When he saw Inori being captured, he didn’t take any hesitation to come to the scene. When he used Inori’s void, Gai was disappointed and it was foreshadowed later that Mana was the reason he wanted Inori to let him use his void. Shu also didn’t trust Gai’s harsh conduct and he would call it unrealistic, which is a good concept. One thing I did wish Shu would have done is going rogue because I predicted Gai wasn’t in the good side because he used others for his own gain and for Mana which is revealed later on. Plus if he went rogue, hare, the betrayal of others wouldn’t have happened and I think he should have went rogue the moment he saw the citizens being killed for not listening to their orders. I knew Shu and every funeral parlor members were manipulated and shu at the beginning even knew there was something wrong with Gai. The death of Yahiro brother did put a emotional scar on Shu and he was treated badly and everyone in shu place would be traumatized because the death of yahiro brother made him remember his past. He was afraid of himself. I knew something was wrong after he sacrificed Gai because Gai isn’t the type to sacrifice himself first but we knew Gai was Triton and so he wanted to end the apocalypse in his own way. However the apocalypse would continue because Keido was still alive and they still had Mana. The ranking system was a problem because of the inferior complex and Souta was an example of it, because of the system, he wanted to be useful and due to that, Shu came to the rescue only knowing Hare sacrificed herself. He realized he couldn’t win without sacrifices and he knew he was too kind, which is why he became unstable and we could see a lot of Gai in him. Using others for his own gain and get out of the wall. Of course he would be betrayed because his secret was revealed and his power would cause him trouble. I predicted that Gai would come back and it was pretty obvious because Keido didn’t die but escaped. I like that Inori always was by Shu’s side and even felt cold when he left Funeral Parlor. The climax was fast paced and the keido backstory made sense because I knew Keido wanted to use the virus to end humanity and restart anew. Daath was also the main influence because it was outside influence that would make Keido use the virus for his own gain and curiosity. The final episode showed how far Shu became and he was a better leader than Gai because he showed his sacrifices, his failures, his victories not through his words but his actions. Inori was the only person who truly believed in him and Shu developed so much for being abandoned and he had many losses. The ending where Inori dies made sense to me because Inori is the vessel of Mana to prevent the apocalypse to continue and we saw an important moment which is Shu finally holding the strings to show that he had nothing to fear and that he was ready to move forward. It was a sad but meaningful ending which I liked because Inori and Shu are one in my eyes, they are made for each-other.
To this day I still listen to that Guilty Crown OST
Idk what it was about the show that impacted me so much growing up
The most difference the mcs have is lelouch is a genius and he’s a incredible tactician while shu is atfirst kinda a loser mc which u would usually hate atfirst
Yes but in terms of writing, shu felt like a real and flawed human and better written regardless of Lelouchs achievements.
This channel is so underrated. I finished the video thinking this was like a 50K+ subs channel just to realize it's way smaller. Keep it up and u'll go big!
What makes Code Geass famous is the ending, and Guility Crown doesn't even have a stable ending.
The funny thing is that Shu was LeLouche when he was younger and Gai was Shu. The personalities swapped due to a shared traumatic experience they both shared. Gai embraced it and became Shu, Shu repressed it and became Gai.
So nobody goin to talk about this man mustache🤣🤣
Hm. Haven't heard of Guilty Crown, but now Im actually a bit excited to see it. Thanks
Eu ainda não tinha visto, por sua boa comparação me deu vontade de ver. Muito obrigado pela crítica e agora vou dar uma olhada nos seus outros vídeos, espere mais comentários vindos daqui do Brasil :D
I love both Code Geass and Guilty Crown so much. The ending of both were beautiful, and I particularly like Guilty Crown's simple and bittersweet ending. But I don't think that you can call Guilty Crown a knock-off due to it being written by the same person.
code geass has better story guilty crown has great music and insane visuals
You know what dude loved this video you just gained another new subscriber (with notifications on btw) also if it's hard to write a character that people hate then props to shingeki no kyojins author cause everyone i've talked too hated gabi with a passion
I know it is thoughts on the two series posted in comment but did some of you guys even finish watching the video?
I was never a fan of Guilty Crown but this video definitely gives me more to think about when thinking about the series. Nice video.
Well, the only reason people hate guilty crown because people expected the main character to be the archetypical good leader without considering how people's behavior would work in a very stressful scenario which is very prevailent in the 2nd half of the show, and the fact that the show killed the female mc in the end. Otherwise, for me its an 'okay' anime about how human behavior affects the power they possess and vice-versa
watched both the series but never thought they're so comparable...it was an eye opener...really loved it❤️
I'm slightly biased because Guilty Crown was one of the first animes I watched that for me into it, but seeing this makes me want to rewatch it. I personally really loved guilty crown and loved the art style, animation, music; I also felt like this is one of the few animes where they characters are written pretty well and act/think like normal people to a degree. Like you pointed out Shu isn't meant to be likeable at all because he's flawed but those flaws help him make the right decision and his insecurities and low self esteem make it more believable when he messes up and feels remorse compared to other anime protagonist
he feel too much that what fourteenspoons mean. lelouch also have some scene show that he criple from some circumstance but he know that cost he had to pay. and after get some bitch slap he back on his feet.while shu don't.
@@user-wf9ht5tw6v that's because shu never wanted to deal with that shit to begin with. He was simply running after a cute girl and had no interest in starting a revolution nor in leading anyone.
the only reason im aware of Guilty Crown's existence is because it kept showing up when I would try to find Guilty Gear art and then being immediately disappointed upon finding out Guilty Crown wasnt a Guilty Gear spinoff.
I should probably actually watch it at some point
This video made me curious enough to watch Code Geass, which I hadn't till now cause I don't enjoy older anime, but I'm SO glad I did
Keep Working man your gonna Blow up Soon great voice
Watched guilty crown as one of the first anime ever since I found It almost right After I was able to have internet. Became almost istantly my favorite anime even tho I had already seen GTO, slam dunk and death note for example, that's because shu and everything that happens to him and Inori touched me really deeply, long story short I found code geass several months After and even if mamy years have passed guilty crown has still a special place in my Heart, with code geass too. I totali agree with your thoughts, short video but surely not poor, It Is clear that you put a true effort in trying to explain the bound and even the differences between the anime, your Channel Will grow for sure if u keep up the good work!
Huh, weird ive rewatch both series alot of times and never thought of the connections...
Me too dude
this is kinda crazy now that i think about it. code geass is what got me into anime back in like 2014, and i watched guilty crown because someone said it was in the same genre, i NEVER made the connection because i was like 14 lol. but after stumbling on this video, my mind was kinda blown by the fact that it was so glaringly obvious and i never saw it as such...
Amazing Analysis bro🔥🔥
hi i'm stumbling across your video on this literally like a year and a half after it came out but i think you made some really great points!! i'm someone that actually really enjoyed BOTH code geass and guilty crown, and honestly i thought that guilty crown was given a bit TOO much flack. gc, despite its faults, was still a compelling narrative to me that really Hit. and while code geass did the same - i dunno. i don't know how to really put it into words.
great video tho : D glad i stumbled across your channel am gonna subscribe.
Just realized half his mustache is shaved...now I can’t stop staring at it...
If you don’t mind me asking, what would you have done differently if you could remake GC?
The interesting thing is seen when looking at the character that dies, the coward shu saves the world and lives. Lelouch ends up dead and hated
Don’t know how I’ve never see the comparisons before… 😂
I wondered why they named it "Gulity Crown" and this video connected the points in my head. Sho has the king's powers, but doesn't accept it until later. And doesn't realize HE was the creator of this new world only in the fact of his father being the creator of the black Christmas and such
Both are great, but my love for Guilty Crown comes with it’s soundtrack. That shit is haunting and vibrational to this day.
As someone who parades around the internet saying Guilty Crown is my favorite anime of all time, I have to first and foremost thank you for not dunking on it outright.
What's funny is to me, Code Geass bores me. It's not bad, not at all, it really is good. But ignoring the obvious connections between the two. These are almost separate genres.
Let me explain. Where Code Geass is a political power struggle with intelligent and supernatural strategy, Guilty Crown is a supernatural battle anime, with a focus on romance and what it means to be human, that also has a political power struggle.
I don't watch Guilty Crown to see the government be taken down, and the world be set right. I watch it to see Shu grow, to learn to use his powers, and to see his relationship with the people around him. I watch it to see the amazing setting of the virus and voids. I watch it to see what happened in their pasts.
Essentially, The main reason I liked Guilty Crown is one reason a lot of people hate it.
The ending. The ending of Guilty Crown left many story threads untouched, it didn't tell us everything about what was going on with the voids and the king's power. And to me, that was what was great. That ending is the proof it never really was about the politics, or the king's power, and voids. It was about Shu, and Inori.
And that's all it needed.
But that's just my opinion, I hope it can be respected.
In summary you value character more than plot, isnt that a waste to focus and build up the plot so much only to conclude that "its all about the character" i think u just want to reason out the flaws of guilty crown but hey i still respect ur opinion cant change ur mind if u think guilty crown iws better cant blame u for having a different preferences
@@areare3990Yeah, I can admit I'm probably just doing that. Guilty Crown was one of my first Anime, and that was what I genuinely thought about the ending. I thought it was interesting that there was more to the world, but was satisfied with not exploring it. The show could have been easily about Shu becoming King and fighting off those virus monsters from lost christmas, but I like to think they intended to not do anything with those threads.
Very well said!
@@mahikamihan I'm glad to see people still love Guilty crown even today!
bit late, but the way i see it, there are many times in real life that we go through situations that leave us with questions that will never be answered, and the ending reflects that. not every story needs to be a perfect open and shut case, where everything is figured out, because in reality, that's almost always how it goes regardless. I'm personally content with not knowing the full story, as its always something i can go back to and speculate about, which makes it far more memorable to me than most other media.
I never got around to finishing Guilty Crown. I got around episode 10 or 11, I think? and I really tried to continue but the main character annoyed me too much and I got a bit bored around then too. However, I believe if I ever tried to re-watch it again I might be able to get through it if I think of it as a response to Code Guess which I believe would make the experience more interesting, so thanks for this video.
Just finished Guilty Crown yesterday, and now I feel obligated to watch Code Geass. As nervewracking and heartbreaking as GC was, I did enjoy it. I still miss Best Girl very much. CG has sounded enticing from the getgo, so thanks for this vudeo that clinched my interest.
So, did you like cg?
two of my favorite animes, i love guilty crown soo much like it's so human and same thing with code geass. I can see how code geass is better but guilty crown is beautiful in it's own unique way. I mainly agree with everything you said so great video.
Finally someone who doesn't immediately say mid when talking about guilty crown
This whole time I had NO idea there was an age limit to voids XD it was a point so small it never occurred to me and I wondered why- I vaguely recalled something countering this weird info. So I looked it up "Voids can only be extracted from people 17 years or younger. The reason for this is unknown at this time but it is suggested that a person's Void needs time to properly form. This is similar to saying how humans develop over time. Age part could be referring to its user's age, like Shu is 17 and can only extract Voids from the ones who are 17 or younger." this make sense since there is a user who has a void but he himself is over 1000 years old. So he can do whatever he wants- but Shu consistently can only use voids of those equal or younger than himself in the series. huh, never noticed that.
OMG I never realized that??
I loved guilty crown but then I was so disgruntled with Shu but that explains so much
I should rewatch it now OMG
I also think this is more a question of what will the wrong person do and how will they grow after obtaining the power, and shows a linear path that actually goes through many of the options available that power can develop a person into. Coward, Entitled, Unsure but trying, Unsure and kind and trying, dictator, before ending with a character who is willing to take the full weight of all the heart's he's taken to the point of even taking a form of crystalizing cancer from others and bearing it himself, then even going blind in the end.
The real question is, which one had the best openings tho
i love code geass sm but i liked guilty crown's opening better 😭
Great information! Upon discovering Guilty Crown, I surmised that the climactic "Return of the King" would be inevitable, given how Lelouch even uses his ability on himself. What that exactly meant for Shu was a mystery at the beginning, but it worked out decidedly well IMO.
I loved GC, I liked CG, Both are worth watching.
GC has a special place in my heart though. Despite it's seemingly rushed story I thought it was great. Just breaks my heart, it could of been SOOOOO much better if they had explored the world of GC more and expanded and explained everything.
The ending is a great example... Unless you watched and noted every little detail the ending is very confusing and makes no sense whatsoever.
Also props man for not being one of those "GC is just poor mans CG" people like most youtubers are....
Exactly same feeling with the both series.
Nice job on the video man that's some rly good anime opinion.
Never thought of it that way
as a solid lover of romance animes, i loved both of them equally. U got Code geass to fill my obsession with power and strategy, and then u got guilty crown for me to ship another two characters. the only reason i prefer code geass, is it would have been nice to see Shu die along side Inori in the end, code geass also has another season and a good movie to follow up.
Subbing just for this...finally, someone who is not straight up hating on Guilty Crown.
I was so excited when Guilty Crown first starting airing, for many of the reasons you cited; its focus on gorilla-tactic revolutionaries vs. a tyrannical government and the dissection of a "chosen hero" in Gai vs the "unwitting hero" in Shu, all of it was so promising.
I really enjoyed bits and pieces of the series but felt after its halfway mark it became something utterly strange and divorced from its initial ideas and characterization. Some parts and character decisions were baffling because they seemed to be complete 180s compared to the earlier setup.
The animation was gorgeous, the soundtrack kickass, and the character designs still stand on their own as fantastically memorable. I wish the story could've been better executed and Shu made to be a more likable/sympathetic character. I ended up wishing for that Code Geass Redo feeling in thinking, "I wish Gai had been the protagonist," which is never a good sign.
I found this video after finally watching Guilty Crown. It's one of the few pieces of analysis out there, and it's really good. I hadn't actually thought about Code Geass while watching Guilty Crown because obviously by this point there's no discourse to really see about Guilty Crown and I saw Code Geass many many years ago. So it was really interesting to think about. In the end the title of the series very much sums it up. Guilty Crown. Shu was a coward king who in the end valued helping others at the expense of the greater whole, which is why Inori loves him I think because the whole plan of Mana is the opposite. Sacrifice everyone for the advancement and evolution of mankind. Shu rejects that evolution, instead choosing the present for as long as it will last, even if in the end nothing will be left and catastrophe won't be avoided. He was a coward to the end, which makes him at times a deeply romantic character, and maybe the show could have played that up even more. I think there's also a lot of parallels to be drawn with Evangelion and Shinji--though Shinji is much more anti-social than Shu. It's hard to see Shinji ever making the number of friends that Shu does.
Guilty crown was a beautiful anime its in my top 10 It was so emotional sad ending 😭❤️
I still listen to the soundtrack of this series, it’s just fucking beautiful
Guilty Crown is having its 10th Anniversary this year
Guilty crown is my guilty pleasure but putting it in the same sentence as code geass is blasphemy💀
I can't speak for others but personally when I watched the events just seemed like a series of coincidences that the characters were moving through. None of them felt like they had agency, not even in their cowardice. Although I noticed the similarities between Code Geass and Guilty Crown, they were only really ever in the same genre to me. I don't think I've really heard a criticism of Guilty Crown that went along the lines of comparing it to Code Geass before.
I don't agree with the notion that two series of different IPs can be inseparably linked. Guilty Crown should be able to stand alone as its own story and message but it patently fails at doing that because of its confused writing. It's not a good show if it relies on the cultural context of another work to be used as a comparison against.
At some point I saw someone describe Guilty Crown as "a really great album with some gorgeous accompanying visuals." and I honestly don't think it deserves higher praise than that. There are some excellent emotional moments, but the plot is entirely too confused and the many coincidences and inexplicable decisions that characters make just makes the whole thing impossible to be taken seriously as a whole.
I never thought it was a copy of Code Geass 😅 Which is great. I enjoyed the show for itself.
WTF this channel is totally underrated...
I love guilty crown a lot when it out. And I like Shu as a main character.
I really agree with your analysis, but man do I hate Guilty Crown.
Why hate it? Its disappointing at best.
i had it too and it was far from beautiful. pure trash. could have been great. as disappointing as sao.
I’ve seen both and well I have to say that the music in code geass pales in comparison to guilty crown besides the 1st op of code geass colors
Great analysis
I never tought about this but i agree 100% on this.
I first watched guilty crown before code geass
This was a good analysis
I really love this analysis
I would say code geass was objectively better
But I subjectively loved Guilty Crown more than Code
Makoto Waltz Segai was the most interesting villain.
Because in the OVA we saw he was trying to find something isn't puppet to the world. New and untouched. But sadly having very little episode to focus more on explaining the characters of the story. And instead of showing through events to explain their message they use symbolism.
Which is the cheap way of squeezing big story into smaller runtime. Since, an object or a single event and it's imagery is given meaning to.
Like in the Akira movie.
Have you watched Oregairu?
Wow i never thought of it like that,
good point must rewatch Guilty Crown
I had to pause the video to laugh the idea of Rivalz as the protagonist It's just throw me off so much, now I need to watch GC
Guilty Crown: No idea what the fuck goin on but it look pretty
There is never an in-between with Guilty crown. You either hate the living guts out of it, or you love it to death. I am the former.
Where on earth are you finding people who love it? I feel like I'm the only one.
@@magicheesecompany Hii
I dropped the show early on back when it came out. Interesting to see that there might be a bit more going on under the hood.
Never seen Code Geass, but I did like what they did with the MC. It feels similar to Subaru in Re Zero where a loser is thrown into a world of gods
Code Geass is so much more interesting to watch than Guilty Crown, and the end is in no way anti-climax. The complexity of Lelouch's character is never paralleled by any character in Guilty Crown, not to mention the world view and dynamics between different parties in Code Geass. I would not go as far as to say Code Geass's influence is as big EVA or flcl, but you can tell the production team at least tried to make something serious. Guilty Crown however is just a knockoff of a series of popular anime at the time from the beginning to the end. They saw things like Code Geass made good sales and wanted to make some good cash; that's it. Inory and bios are beautiful, but the show just ain't it.
Well they have the same writer...
You realise they had the same writer right?
Yet shuu was more well rounded and felt more human than Lelouch
@@mmallowsmallows2575 you see that's MY problem with Shuus character: The show acts like and calls him human, but what human discovers trust and consent and than just goes brrr mentally because a friend died saving him, and im not even done: that friend who literally died saving him, being kind and telling him not to do what the others want (the establishment of the ranks) the death of HER drove him to the conclusion that her whole world view was whack and that he should do the opposite to what she and his best friend said. And finally he says that he didnt want her to have died in vain... How is that human or logical at all?
@@LibraryofAcousticMagic3240
That is human because only a machine after witnessing death of a close person would come to logical conclusion. Humans after emotional trauma act on emotions especially if they blame themselves.
I had similar situation in life. My girlfriend was kind, forgiving person who believed that everyone deserves a second chance. I was kinda opposite of her but I accepted her world views. One day her ex (he was a psycho) tried to murder me because I stood in the way of him getting back her but he failed. He got away from police and week later he shot me in shoulder and shot her in chest, she died. And now I blame myself for not killing him when he attempted to kill me because I didn't stick to my world views.
Right after she died I came to conclusion that she was wrong about forgiving every single person and that shows that humans don't come to most logical conclusions when they literally lost a person who loved and cared about them.
I must be the weirdo here. I LOVED Guilty Crown and have gone through it several times. Oma's faltering hero stance makes me want to root for him more. When he turns to be more of an ass, we see it's because he is trying to imitate another ass (Gai). to protect and defend. I hated that it ended too quickly, and wasn't prepared for it.
The funny thing is, I liked both anime. But, only Code Geass was in the realms of 'top anime'. What I loved about Guilty Crown wasn't so much its premise or anything along those lines, it's what it led to in a few key moments. I'd say most of the show was average, but when it came to putting out emotion, eliciting a response from viewers, it at times could manage it. Spoilers for Guilty Crown, Hare's Death and Shuu's reclaiming his void powers are still some of the most emotional scenes for me. With Hare, you have this thing I love that I've never seen done as well. You actually have the hero's love interest define why she loves him in this impactful way before dying to save him, and then as a result of her death, he goes in the exact opposite direction of what she loved about him. She loved his kindness, and her death led to him breaking. Meanwhile, when reclaiming his void, he's taking up the mantle for real, risking his life and dining it time he took on the traumas of everyone else's hearts rather than just using their hearts. I honestly feel both were enjoyable as wholes, don't get me wrong, but Code Geass more consistently could hit those emotional moments. Shirley, Nunnally opening her eyes... I would list out everything, but then this already grandiose comment would be even longer.
My point is, both have their values. Yes, Code Geass has more value in my eyes, and Guilty Crown does follow it pretty closely, Guilty Crown also has some scenes that I think honestly led to my love for tragedy and what overcoming it means in writing.
Shu, mana and gai are childhood friend, right? And mana wanted shu to be the adam...... That's what i thought in guilty crown so gai isn't really gonna receive the king power.
So shu was destined for it not by choice due to mana's plan or intervention.
I actually watched Guilty Crown before Code Geass and I like Guilty Crown more than Code Geass for some reason. I liked seeing Shu more than Lelouch. The Funeral Parlour characters were a lot more interesting and cooler than the Black Knights as well. I like the having the Voids and Apocalypse Virus aspect as well
I need some animes like these two 😭😭
I got only 3. Aldnoah zero, valvrave the liberator and gundam iron blooded orphans
I like both shows I prefer code Geass. I honestly believe guilty crown would have been received better if it had changed the ending slightly spoiler ahead
If Shu died at the end I think it would have been better or alternatively have Inori survive in some fashion but left mute and keept Shu blind giving the ending a more hopefull spin while still showing the scars of some choices leave instead of just inverting code Geass ending.
I just finished Guilty Crown lately and I like it because its theme feels like Code Geass. My only issue in this anime is the ending dosent feel right or satisfying enough.
After watching Guilty Crown and then Code Geass 2 years later, I didn't notice the similarities because that's all they really are. Similarities. Both the shows are very different, very good things.
I never heard of this comparison but I can definitely see it now