Black Sabbath : Sabotage Album CD Remaster and Super Deluxe Box Set Review and a RANT
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ก.ย. 2024
- This video was originally going to simply review the Sabotage Super Deluxe Edition Box Set but then I thought it would be good to look back at the original vinyl album and then the CD Remasters from 1996 and 2009.
In the video, I show you the booklets and the inside of the box set and give an overview of the album itself. I also recommend which version I feel is the best. My answer may surprise some of you.
I also give an honest opinion of what I think of the box set which is really a lost opportunity.
In this video
The original vinyl on NEMS Records 1975
CD Remaster 1996
CD Remaster 2009
Super Deluxe Edition Box Set 2021
Phil Aston
Now Spinning Magazine
Please become a subscriber and get exclusive videos and early access from just $3/£3 per month - cancel anytime.
nowspinning.co...
I've been known to call this my fave album of all time by anybody - great tour of it, Phil!
Hi Martin, thank you for watching. It certainly is an epic album and my favourite Black Sabbath album alternates between this and Sabbath Bloody Sabbath. I would say at the moment it is Sabotage. It is certainly the most played. Phil :)
In agreeance Phil, sabbath needs to lift its game when it comes to giving fans value for money.
Hi great review. I was really going to take a hard pass on this set basically because the sound quality on my original Canadian Warner bros press and UK original Nems press are really fantastic. I also have two vinyl bootlegs of the very same live show which sound really great. As for the 7" single I have one that came with the BMG boxset Supersonic years. So I was really gonna pass this one by. I ended up with the cd version first and I was actually quite surprised by the sound of the remastering. But honestly I was more happy to have the tour program and book. Then I got the Vinyl copy of the boxset. I couldn't believe the difference in the quality of the over all packaging. The album sleeves to the booklets and and tour program and man they did a terrific replica of the 7" single. I was pleasantly surprised by the vinyl copy. So if anyone is reading these comments and maybe considering this boxset, the vinyl version is far superior to the cd version
There was a japanese 45 with Am I Going Insane (Radio) bw Hole In The Sky released in 1975. Released on Vertigo SFL-2060
I will here during the premier. This is quite a long one for me so I hope you like it. Thank you for watching and your support. Phil
I have the 96 and 2009 don't own a turntable at the moment so the 96 will have to do Thanks for the review ❤
Great video. Thanks for sharing your insight. I bought Sabotage when it first came out in September 1975. After a few listens, it was my favorite album. Almost 50 years later it's still my favorite album. BTW - I also own numerous Sabotage remix versions and the behemoth Super Deluxe Box - both CD and vinyl.
Hello Mr. Aston. What a review!! Well done, in my opinion, very honest and very easy to follow. Thank you for sharing your thoughts. Keep on rocking.
Hi Jorge, thank you for watching and your words of encouragement, they mean a lot. I love this album and feel I need to talk from the heart as a growing number of people are watching these videos now. This ended up being a longer video than normal but I am so pleased music fans have found it useful. If any record labels stumble across it I hope it makes them think… even if it is just a little! Phil :)
if there's a super deluxe box set of sabbath bloody sabbath of course the live material is going to be a "remaster/mix" of CAL JAM . what else - "road to pittsburgh 74" bootleg ?
Great, honest review. I bought the vinyl version. So hard to say what sounds best, unless you have all different versions to compare. These deluxe box sets should be the best of everything, especially for their price point. I just hope that effort is being made by these bands.
Hi, thank you for watching. From the CD perspective this one is not better than the original vinyl version. The other Black Sabbath Deluxe editions are excellent. Phil
Great review and attention to detail Phil. I always favour the sound of VOL 4 on my vinyl from the seventies. Compression being the curse of some CD reproductions. They just don’t capture what Sabbath were about at that time. The thick , heavy primordial mix that comes through on Sabbath vinyl.
I Still Have All Albums CD's & Cassettes Of Black Sabbath & OZZY Osbourne Too.Worth Buying. Masterpiece Song & Voices Forever.
Thanks Phil… Right on for your superb overall choice with… selecting the vinyl record of Black Sabbath’s Sabotage ! ❤😎🎸
Why is there no live soundboard quality recording of a correct time period concert… with live footage of the songs from Sabotage ? Give the fans the best that you can, especially after supporting different formats over the years….! 💰💵🚧
Im a bit late to the party, but as always I appreciate the brutal honesty Phil. Looks like I'm gonna have to track down the 1990s one, as I only have the 2009/2014 one.
Hopefully I can track down a good pressing here in Canada for a decent price. Doubt I'm gonna find a NEMS pressing here, and I'm not sure how our Canadian pressings compare. Also going to have to find bootlegs of their live performances, as im not gonna pay $100 for these sets when my main reason for buying is the live performance.
Like you, I adore this album. Its JUST behind Master of Reality as my favourite, and Vol 4 is just behind Sabotage. I really want to hear this album as it was intended. The thought of Symptom of the Universe being even more brutal than the version I've been listening to since high school? Its enough to make me drool!
Yes! The Sabatage cover is about witchcraft. I’m not into that sort of thing, but in 1975 that cover, along with Sabbath Bloody Sabbath, had a major impact. To be honest, I thought both covers were slightly disturbing.
IT's one of the greatest ALBUM COVERS I have ever seen.
But people who who didn't grow up with Sabbath don't "get it".
The cover is so Sabbath it's just perfect.
And you are absolutely correct with the original UK LP press on N.E.M.S. just crushes those CD's you have shown, I own all three of the CD's versions you discussed and I own the original UK LP press and first U.S. Warner Brothers Lp press. Either of the NEMS (my favorite) or WB press on LP is the only way to really hear the power and detail on Sabotage......which is just astounding.
Great Review Phil!
Keep it up and I hope the Technical Ecstasy Box Set comes thru for us!
I am looking forward to the next box set to see what Steven Wilson will have achieved with the remix. Fantastic to meet someone else who loves the Sabotage album cover. I was a bit worried when I did this review but the feedback has been very positive and I was really surprised when I went to my NEMS original vinyl and heard the sheer power of the guitars compared with the CD. Thank you again for watching - Phil :)
Sabotage is my favourite album by Sabbath..it's epic from start to finish..I mean Symptom of the universe is just off the scale it's that good..I've got the 75 vinyl Lp,cd and this box set..I like the box set and only paid £20 so I was made up,I know people have a go at the live stuff but ol I love it..it's Sabbath at the peak of their Live career in my opinion..by the way I absolutely love Technical Ecstasy..especially the box set..that album is so underrated..great detailed review.
Hi Colin, thank you for watching. You got an absolute bargain there which makes up for any faults it may have. Phil
Cool review. The Sabotage box was a bit disappointing but I never had the live 1975 stuff so I was happy to get that. I wanted to mention that there is a 1975 Japanese single release of Am I Going Insane/Hole in the Sky listed on Discogs with identical artwork to CD 4 of the box set.
Hi Barry, thank you for watching and also pouting out the single did exist. As you say they probably did not have the material to draw upon. The price point should have been cheaper to reflect this. I will be going for the Technical Ecstasy box as well ! Phil
Thanks for your "objective" honest review, I too am an old fan (64yrs) and I totally agree with your comments about the cover. I can remember staring at it and thinking how brilliant and artistic it was/is. I do own the '96 remaster and I think I'll stick with that , I previously owned the original CD and the remaster is far superior (the same with "Master of, Vol. 4, Paranoid, Sab. bloody....) . Maybe the next deluxe version(s) will be less of a rip-off???? cheers mate.
Hi Stan, thank you very much for watching and it is great to know I am not the only one who loves the cover. Phil :)
I just got the 2009 version this year. I shall stick with that one even though the vinyl is better. Reminds me of Sheer Heart Attack by Queen. The guitar solo in Stone Cold Crazy on the 90s CD is so week compared to the original vinal from the 70s. I bought the 2011 CD and what a difference.
I also prefer cd's for my music medium. I'm old enough to remember going from Mono to Stereo vinyl and was blown away by the effect ! While I still have 50-60 original's from that period, their cd counterparts blow most if not all away. I don't know about purchasing this box set, but one box set you reviewed I did purchase, and that was Iron Butterfly "Unconscious Power !" Excellent set and I was pleasantly surprised at how well cd's 6-7 sounded, being live performances. Nice job Esoteric Recordings. Thank you for these video's, take care.
Hi Jerry, thank you for watching, that Iron Butterfly box is excellent. I am so pleased you are enjoying it. Phil :)
Curently hunting all these sets own. Im enjoying your honest reviews. I as rally looking for these to be definitive editions of the albums, but it doesnt look like thas the case. This one's only cost me £27 so it's not too bad, part of the collection.
Hi Phil, I became very wary of new editions after the travesty of the Genesis remixes (some, not all) so when it came to Sabotage I went down the Steve Hoffman rabbit hole and came up trumps with the Castle '96 CD and I've since bought the 2015 Sanctuary/Vertigo/BMG reissue (not remastered) on vinyl, so hopefully that's on a par with the NEMS (a little too pricey on Discogs). Yours is the first channel I've found that goes into different versions, and that's a great service to the music, the fans, and hopefully the bands! I only got into Sabbath 3 years ago having decided to go back and check out all the bands I missed during the 70s, and what a find! Iommi's handbrake turns, like on Megalomania, take my breath away - discovering new 'old' music is proving to be a real adventure. Cheers, Ian
Hi Ian, thank you for watching and it is wonderful to know you find my videos useful as well as interesting. Phil
I have the vinyl boxed set of this. I understand many people's complaints with it. I was just glad to get the Asbury park show on vinyl. Even though it was a bootleg, it was a soundboard. Not sure if the same source was used for both CD and vinyl. Good review.
Thank you for watching - the vinyl set is actually a good price right now and a lot more impressive than the CD set. Phil
That Japanese single was real, but claiming that this is a four-disc set when Disc 4 is just two songs is very misleading on their part.
And I agree, I do not get why people practically get angry about the cover. Is it the reflection they don't like? Maybe they just think they're supposed to hate it because it's on all the bad album cover lists.
Invaluable review Phil thanks, you have set my mind straight about these remasters... I don't think they are worth the money for the most part.
Thank you for watching. This one is the runt of the series. The others Vol 4 and Technical Ecstasy are the best - Phil :)
Good reviews! 🙂👍 For my ears, the last 3 or 4 Sabbath albums with Ozzy in the 70's there was some frequency in Ozzy's microphone that was just shrill and deafening to my ears (especially on Sabotage and Sabbath Bloody Sabbath). I got some vinyl to mp3 rips of the 2012 vinyl reissues and those have some of the microphone issues filtered out to where the levels aren't too hot in the mix. To my ears, the 2012 vinyl reissue sounds the best especially for this album! 🤘😎
Hi Brian, thank you for watching and your positive feedback. Also a big thank you for the extra info about the 2012 vinyl pressing. Phil
Great review, great explanation! I love Black Sabbath. Here in Brazil they are so many fans! And "Sabbotage" is a great álbum. Thanks!👏👏👏
Hi William, thank you for watching and finding me from Brazil! I am really pleased you found this useful. Sabotage is such a killer album, every track is on point - rock on Phil :)
Superb and brutally honest overview Phil. This latest box set has clearly made the cardinal mistake of falling short of being an exceptionally desirable package for the Sabbath collector. It's a somewhat lazy effort, overall, that relies on the fact that, as you say, many fans will buy it anyway. But that is no way to treat devotees who, let's face it, are usually getting much better bang for the buck from other artists. They, and the band's legacy, deserve much better than a thinly disguised live concert bootleg regurgitation.
Hi Chris, I may have been less brutal if I have not played each version and then compared the bootleg to the live CDs. Also the 4th CD was just put in there to increase the number to 4 like the other box sets. Thanks, Phil :)
A man who knows what he is talking about ! Thanks
Hi Anders, all my reviews are honest and independent. I want to help collectors decide if it is for them. I am passionate about physical music and will always tell it like it is. Phil
Excellent review..my favorite sabbath album. Had it in all medium except 8 track. Quadraphinia (the Who) never translated to cd the way vinyl delivered either. But for the most part, I do like CDs.
Hi Andrew, thank you for watching, it is also in my top 3 Sabbath albums as well - Phil
Anyone has a cassette? I had a record issued on official license (from vertigo) by record company Radio TV Belgrade 1975 in former Yugoslavia and sounded great; Nowadays listen to 1996 CD ....Great review as usual...
Thank you - Phil
Good lord! What a phenomenal channel. I've just finished watching all of the Black Sabbath Box reviews. Superb! I'll admit I was surprised that you didn't mention the US based Rhino remasters by DigiPrep's Dan Hersch and Bill Inglot. Definitive version(s)? Keep up the good work!
Hi Phil (great name!) thank you for watching and finding me, plus your positive feedback. I am based in the UK so I need to look up the Rhino Remasters. I really appreciate you dropping by - Phil :)
@@NowSpinningMagazine The pleasure has been all mine. Watching the Thin Lizzy review now. I appreciate the sincerity, as a fan. There is so much sensationalism and hype out there. I should clarify that the Rhino releases I mention are from 2014. The exist as separate discs but were also compiled in 'The Complete Studio Recordings 1970 -1978" & "The Rules Of Hell" box for the albums Sabbath did with Ronnie. As a mastering engineer, myself...I find that I'm sensitive to almost what could be explained as geographical biases in mastering. Some might argue this idea but that's alright. The many and various UK releases have a more unified sound between them whereas the USA based DigiPrep masters standout...they might have been remastered digitally? Likely. They are clearer with a more defined bottom end. Sharper treble. The UK versions are fatter and warmer but more with a more diffuse presentation. However, the 2021 remasters are as good or better that anything before attempted. I simply have to buy them all!
@@phildemetro Thank you for such an interesting and informative comment. So happy you are enjoying my channel - Phil ;)
Just watched this Phil .
Totally agree.
Fans not asking for much just something a little bit extra to make it special.
Having said that curse of the collector i had to buy it .
Thanks Phil, a very informative review. I still have my pristine NEMS copy bought in 1980 (I wore out the one I bought 2 years before). I still love the first 10 BS LPs, but Sabotage is probably my favourite. I did have the original CD version, which I thought sounded very 'flat' like the majority of early analogue to digital. I got rid of it very quickly as it lost the power and sharpness of the LP IMHO. My regular listen is the 1996 remaster (the LP is a rare treat). I was looking forward to the Super Delux Edition, but now I think I'll give it a miss!.
Hi Craig, thank you for watching. The price for this set has plummeted since this review but it could have been so much better. Phil
Yes the sound on the live one is a bit average, good to have that show though.lucky I got the box for really cheap, and for the books.
Hi ian, thank you for watching - Phil
It's really not that confusing for me as a young fan...I just stream it. Whatever version is on Spotify or TH-cam is what I get. I'm kind of wondering now what I'm missing out on, if as you say the original 70s master was better. They usually only include the latest remasters on streaming.
Hi, thank you for watching and sharing your thoughts. I actually love your comment, it is very enlightening and freeing really. You are right when I stream an album what version I get never crosses my mind. I think the record labels fixate on this to make older fans feel they are missing out on a newer version. When I was in my teens to late 30s and someone asked do you have Sabotage by Black Sabbath the answer was simply yes or no. At some point that became yes, I have the vinyl, CD, Deluxe edition and remaster. I actually love streaming as well and I’m currently doing that in the car! Phil
Good stuff Phil. I bought this on cassette when it originally came out. Loved the album and played it a lot until it met its demise being chewed up in a friends car stereo. To my shame I did not get round to replacing it until about ten years ago with the 2009 remaster. Part of a '2 for £10' offer on CDs at my local HMV. I never thought the sound was that great on this reissue. Now on a sort of a mission to find a decent copy of the original vinyl based on what you have discovered. If I get lucky I am sure it will cost less than the Deluxe Box Set.
Hi Peter, I am am sure you can find one at a reasonable cost. I was really surprised by my findings, but Tony Iommi's guitars sound much better on the vinyl copy. Phil
I have the 2009 and the 1996 remastered versions and you are right the 1996 version is far far better.
My original copy of this album was on 8-track. It's long gone, but I can bet that anything from that is an upgrade! I do agree about the value of the super deluxe edition - I was also really disappointed with the cheap cardboard sleeves holding the CDs + there's not much in there begging for repeat listens. I also have a 2016 digipak... and I think that's just a reissue of the 2009 remaster. I'll have to listen for those differences you mention.
Hi Brett, thank you for watching. I agree any of the versions I mention will improve on your 8 Track ! The 1996 / 2009 are very close really and far better value that the deluxe box. Phil :)
i like all albums with O OSBOURNE , but i have a little "preference" for the first it was an time "un veritable coup de poing" a great sound !!!! a great band !!!!! and the first band of hard rock !!!! for me !!!! again thanks phil !!!
Hi Jean, thank for watching so many of my videos! The first Sabbath album is very important. I must do a separate video on this. Phil
The concert was or is Ashbury park,new Jersey which I had as an bootleg.Great concert
That’s right, it’s Ashbury Park - Phil
Like you Phil,love Sabbath,love box sets,but I own none of the deluxe box sets...too expensive as you say and not enough of anything different to make me get them above what I have.unfortunately as you know I struggle with the price of vinyl too so I will stick with what I have,and your great review hasn't changed my mind 🤟🤟
Hi John, They are over priced and I think the people behind the Black Sabbath brand know they can charge a premium for them. Hard core fans will still go for them but I just feel with the latest one they have not given value for money or respected the the fans themselves. I hope this video helps people seek out a version that best suites them. Phil :)
Hey man, good hearing your thoughts. I agree with the not fairness of the SD packages' prices. I only bought Sabatoge because here in the US I found it for $33 USD. Technical Ecstasy is less, Paranoid and esp. Volume 4 are over $100 - and it's the damn secondary market that did it.
There had to have been Ebay sellers who bought these by the case just to double the price. Same thing happened with the Heaven And Hell and Mob Rules Deluxe vinyl, but not the CD's.
In defense of the live recordings. You're not acknowledging the bootleg soundboard recording market at all. And the Black Sabbath unofficial release catalog is vast. I've done some research this year (As well as purchased about 40 now) and it seems that Black Sabbath rivals The Grateful Dead for sheer amount of unreleased material.
So to think that the "North American Tour" CD's have Had to be released (officially) needs to take this into account... The book does state "taken from various concerts"...
Here's what I've come up with, and you can simply listen to what's said between songs as well as check track length.
8.5.75 on Masters Of Reality 4 CD set is actually a remaster of "Black Sabbath - Convention Hall August 5th 1975, Asbury New Jersey." 2 CD set. 15 tracks. Track 6 before Megalomania is "Talking." It matches up with the MOR remaster perfectly otherwise.
Funny for me, is I bought a worn out copy of this recently and then realized, it's on the MOR compilation, so I calmed down about it.
So I've identified the MOR original source, and will say it isn't the one in the Sabatoge SD pack.
I also have "Symptom Of The Universe" AKA "Symptom Of The Paranoid" AKA "Spiral Sabbat live '75 - Baltimore, 8.2.75". I'm not sure of the source. I'd say good quality audience recording.
And I have Providence RI 8.3.75. Source is audience, with higher quality recording equipment. Converted from cassette to FLAC w no EQ. This version of Megalomania is exceptional.
I'd love to find 8.4.75, if a recording exists. It could be the missing link and prove you right, that it's ever been (even unofficially) released. But out of the 4 versions I have, 8.2, 8.3, 8.5 '75 and also the Deluxe concert, they're all unique.
I used Megalomania as a reference because there are so few live recordings of it. And it's also one of my favorite BS songs.
I suggest you get on EBay and just type in Black Sabbath CD's. We used to have Bootleg conventions here in the 90's. Double albums for $50, $5 cassette recordings of the albums. CD's were just coming into popularity as well.
The unofficial market's really evolved since. You can get a recording of every tour from '70 to '13 pretty easily.
My goal is one of each leg of each tour. And attempt to find each song that was ever performed live.
If anyone gets really involved in collecting, my advice is ignore titles and make sure you find out the recording date.
Happy hunting for the Sabotage '75 tour origins, I'd love to see the 1st edition.
Hi Joe, thank you so much for watching and taking the time to share your very interesting and resourceful comment. This will be of great use to many of my subscribers and especially me! I will now be heading off to eBay to see what I can find. Phil :)
You're welcome Phil, and thanks for the cheerful reply. I didn't want to sound overbearing or anything. But the bootlegs, can't ignore them. I think they're very vital in understanding a band like Black Sabbath's sheer breadth of music history. Let me know if you decide to buy any of them. None are perfect, they're unedited, as is live recordings. That's the real charm of it all. @@NowSpinningMagazine
I would like for you to do Yngwie Malmsteen box set
I greatly appreciate all of your insight, knowledge, passion, and honesty! I will skip this release.
Thank you - Phil :)
Great vid Phil. Was thinking of buying the boxset due to loving Sabotage. But now?? Have the original Lp bought as a kid of 14 whilst on hols in Devon during the summer of 75. Bought it on a visit to Dartmouth, John Menzies I think. Still love that vinyl production to this day as you mentioned. Cheers for your insight. Brian Ps Also have the 96 remastered cd
Hi Brian, thank you for watching. If you see it for less than £30 maybe, but otherwise it is a ripoff. The vinyl captures the power of Tony Iommi's guitar better than any CD. I am still surprised this was my finding!. Phil
Thanks Phil really enjoyed watching this and all your points. I was sent the Japanese Remasters plus the Castle box that came out way back when. I really enjoyed the comparisons you make. I think record companies need more of these sorts of videos. Though I doubt that Sharon could give a toss. Just keep the Ozzie bandwagon rolling.. Well done.
Hi Jim, thank you for watching and your support. I approached this one thinking if Ozzy or Sharon stumble across it what would I say? Phil :)
@@NowSpinningMagazine She would shrug her shoulders and say thats his opinion and he can think what he F'ingwell likes. Then she might send you a small package with a box in it and make Ozzie post it.lol
Very true :)
Just discovered this great channel. I do think you should check out the first issue US Warner Bros cd from 1988. Fantastic sounding with zero compression or brickwalling like other remasters (Black Box 2004 by far the worst). You can really crank it and it will still sound great.
Hi Bryan, thank you for watching and your great tip! Welcome aboard - Phil :)
Black Sabbath Technical Ecstasy deluxe box set coming on October 1st 2021. Just thought I'd let you know! 👍
Hi Shaun, This one does look better and anything with Steven Wilsons name on it is worth looking at. I will wait for the price to drop to £39 (ish) before going for it!
@@NowSpinningMagazine Hi Phil, I've started to order these box sets from America as you can usually pick them up for less than £30. I know I've probably got to wait an extra week or so for delivery but I think it's worth it to get it practically half price. The website I've been using is called Deep Discount.com. 👍
I think I first heard this album in the mid-nineties and I didn't like it much. (I'm 45) It has grown on me in the last 30 years. I now love this album and I can't understand why I didn't like it at first. I have my first U.K. press and I love it!
Do you like the "Never Say Die" album Phil? That was actually my introduction to Black Sabbath as a kid. That album has a special place in my heart. Maybe you could do a show about that album if you like it as much as I do. Many fans don't like this one and I can't figure out why.
Well...the truth is it took me years to like Never Say Die. I saw them on that tour and Van Halen destroyed them, Ozzy was washed up and the band were lost. I bought the Never Say Die single and follow up Hard Road and heard a could of tracks at a friends house in 1978 and just left it. It would be the late 1990s when I actually bought a copy of CD. It is still the only Black Sabbath album I do not have on vinyl. Your comment has made me think I need to rectify that soon! Phil
@@NowSpinningMagazine I think 'Never Say Die' get's a bad rap. I mean the title track, 'Johnny Blade' and 'Junior's Eyes' are excellent.
sabotage salio en mexico en los 70s en LP funda doble dificil de conseguir ahora
Wow, I did not know that! - What was in the inner gatefold? Thank you, Phil
Great video. Really interesting comparison of the different releases. I've seen a few reviews now of the new deluxe release on TH-cam, but they don't have your insight that comes from your knowledge of the band. I don't own a 1975 vinyl copy of this album unfortunately, but I'm going to try and find a decent one. I liked what you said about the cover and the photograph of the band. Most people seem to say it's terrible as you pointed out, but I liked your perspective, it was interesting and good to hear.
Hi Gary, thank you for watching and your kind words! I have also done similar videos on this channel covering Paranoid, Vol4, Technical Ecstasy and Heaven and Hell. I always try to give insight on the different versions and help collectors choose the right version for them. Phil :)
@@NowSpinningMagazine Hi Phil, I've not watched those yet but will check them out.
Phil! Just wanted to say thank you very much!! This was very helpful indeed my friend.
Love watching your videos especially the ones related to all things Sabbath.
Was wondering if you had a chance to check out the vinyl version of the Sabotage boxset yet? I definitely noticed a definite quality difference in the packaging and books themselves as well as the jackets for the vinyls are quite nice. I was quite impressed myself
I have not got any of the vinyl sets apart from ‘Live Evil’ so can’t comment.phil
Great Review to expensive for only 3 cds
Great review. As a fan I'm disappointed of this two last boxes, they came with any new or rare material and the presentation has lost quality. Since I lost in a third world country this boxes are pretty expensive and pisses me off to find some things that could have been done better...
Hi Rodrigo, thank you so much for watching. As a Black Sabbath fan I am going to buy these box sets but I hate feeling ripped off and that corners have been cut. They are way too expensive. I will be doing a review for the next one ! - Phil :)
What are your thoughts on the vinyl deluxe set ?
I don’t have it so can’t comment. A couple of friends have it and are very pleased with it. Phil
I thought they were mysterious and very cool that’s the only way I can think of the describe the album cover. I actually would stare at each ones garb especially Ozzys and it out him on a different level Than us.oh is it just me or isn’t Geezers arm bent in front but hanging down from the. A k photo?
Hi G, thank you for watching and for your interesting comment. Since doing this video it has been heartening to realise that so many people actually like the album cover. I have also looked at the back cover and your are right Geezers arms are in a different position! - Phil :)
Honestly, there are just too many versions. It can be perceived as a cash grab. I am purchasing the Super Deluxe reissues, simply for the extra content. Although some of it, like the Sabotage set, doesn't really carry much. Also, the Sabotage disc in the box set is NOT remastered from the original master tapes, but a copy.
Hi Mark, thank you for watching. Sabotage was certainly a cash grab but as a fan I still bought it and will certainly be getting the Technical Ecstasy set! I hope there will also be a Sabbath Bloody Sabbath set as well ! Phil
I have a 2009 remaster of this album on vinyl. Those original 2009 pressings came with a CD copy. In my opinion that is the best version of Sabotage, I have always found my original vinyl album muddy and lacking clarity (I have decent equipment to play them on).
I noticed that some of the tracks on the live album with the box set are also on Past Lives CD2.
I have a 70's single of Am I Going Insane (edit) which has Hole in the Sky on the B-side (the end is faded out). I know this as track 'T6' as that was its number in the Duke Box of my local pub back then!
Incidentally - I have a box set, The Complete Replicas 70's CD Collection, (Black box with all 8 Ozzy albums) issued in 2001 - these sound like totally different mixes to the 1996 and 2009 re-masters. Any idea Phil?
Hi Marc, thank you for watching and sharing your feedback on the 2009 vinyl version, I have not heard that so thank you - Phil
@@NowSpinningMagazine Thanks for your reply. There's a lot of confusion the 2009 Ozzy era vinyl remasters. They weren't released on vinyl until 2015 (form what I have come to understand). They all came with a CD copy in a floppy plastic CD bag. All stunning remasters on vinyl. Sabotage is mind blowing, and much preferred to my 1975 original.
Then they were re-pressed. The re-pressing is shocking, but all have the same catalogue number. for added confusion. I bought Sabbath Bloody Sabbath (this has only side 1 tracks listed on the back), and its bad. Tony's guitar is barely audible. I took it back to HMV for a refund.
I spent a long time tracking down the 2015/2009 remastered vinyl with a CD copy. They are all stunning. I couldn't get Vol 4 (my favourite Sabbath album). I bought a copy which was '2009/2015 re-issue, re-master' but a re-press with no CD and gave it away. Awful compared my WWA 1974's pressing.
They are still selling the same product (2009 remaster/2015 re-issue but re-pressed with no CD). I have no idea what they now sound like now, SBS has side 2 listed on the back cover now again.
It is a great album from beginning to end.
Hi, thank you for watching. It certainly is, everything about it is class. Phil :)
@@NowSpinningMagazine Indeed! Have a safe and happy holiday. You bring a lot of joy to people with these excellent videos. Cheers!
So what happened. They didn't find any mastertapes? And so they didn't call Steven Wilson this time.
I think that is exactly what happened unfortunately
Crikey! Gutted! I've just ordered it and yes..It cost me a fortune! Oh well... Vol.4 , Sabbath Bloody Sabbath and Sabotage is my all time favourite run of albums! Great, in depth review non the less. 👍
Hi Shaun, Thank you for watching. It is overpriced and it could have been so much better but as you can see I also have a copy! If it is your favourite Sabbath album then nothing was really going to stop you from going for it. I just felt I had to be honest as it is hardly a deluxe box set. Phil :)
@@NowSpinningMagazine I agree with you Phil! They have us by the balls as they know we're always gonna buy the stuff. I played it last night and you're right, my original vinyl copy from back in the day still sounds best! 👍
@@shaunsmith3538 CD is my prefered format and I have recently posted a video on why I think CDs still rock so this was quite a surprise to me as well. They have had 4 attempts to get this right and the vinyl still wins. Phil :)
@@NowSpinningMagazine Yes Phil, very true. CD's are also my preferred option. As I've only just stumbled upon your channel, and it would appear that our musical tastes are very much the same, can I ask what your thoughts are on the band Rival Sons? Personally, I think they are the best new-ish band I've heard in more than 30 years! Thanks 👍
Well said Phil!
Thank you. I will always ensure my reviews are honest and independent. Phil
It's such a shame they dropped the ball with this set. All I ever really wanted were single edits of Hole in the Sky and Symptom of the Universe and sounds like we only get one of those.
Geezer once said that they never thought about album covers they just thought it was a place to put your album
Hi Phil, how do you feel the quality of the SDC of Sabotage in vinyl ?
Do you mean the vinyl in the super deluxe edition?
Yes. Is the vinyl issue the same poor quality like the cds' one ?
Hey Phil, I've got a question regarding your person. You've mentioned being a brummie...just as the guys in sabbath. They are from Aston.Your second name is Aston. Give us insights...can't be just a coincidence...;-)...keep up the good work.
It is a coincidence, we are all from Aston in Birmingham, my name is Aston and I used to work in the area as a teenager. Phil
When I bought the record back in 1975, my first pressing vinyl had a short “hidden” snippet of a track in the Side 2 run out groove. Ozzy singing “ everyone got to blow on the jug”. Can anyone tell me if this was ever replicated on any of the cd editions?
Yes it was
Super! Thanks for letting me know!
I believe when the Remasters would have done properly they could blow away the Vinylversions in Sound Terms.I think there was too much Compression.The latest Remaster ist often not the Best,the Masterengineers getting the CD's too loud,near Brickwall.It's not the Fault of the Media i believe.And you are right,in this Boxset must be more Stuff for the Money,for this it's too expensive
Hi Ronny, as you know from my ‘Why CDs Still Rock’ video CD is my favourite format. However as you say something has happened here in the mastering process where something is amiss. I agree it is not the media which is at fault but the remastering. Perhaps the original multi tracks are missing and tapes used for the remaster were several generations away from the masters? Thank you for watching - Phil
What's the brand of that vinyl plastic sleeve you have on Sabotage? It's really nice and clear.
Regarding the new 2021 Sabotage boxset. Steven Wilson should've remixed and remaster the whole thing.
I claw to the vinyl as the best one so far as well. I'm not having the original from 1975 like the one you have, but the 1980 NEMS NEL6018 version, it's says DE LUXE on the back. LOL
Hi, I use Spincare. This is a video I did on them - thanks Phil th-cam.com/video/gMbe5SqLi1Y/w-d-xo.html
@@NowSpinningMagazine I will try and get my hands on these. Looks awesome. Thank you for your wonderful videos.
So glad I didn't get sucked into the Sabbath Super Deluxe money grab. When you compare the price for what you get it's a rip off. Does it come under "put anything out and they will buy it"?
Hi John, I hope this saves some people being sucked into this but I understand some fans (that would be me!) will still feel they need to have it. I was really surprised to admit the vinyl winds over any of the CDs. Phil
Why? Only 2 song in the second cd?
Hi Phil. Have rewatched this and agree that Sabotage is by far the worse of the box set releases, and time has not changed my mind. To call a 7inch single as part of a four disc box set is unforgivable. The live stuff as you say is terrible. The actual albumof course fantastic but this sounds nowhere near the 2009 release in my opinion.
Hi Duane, thank you for watching. These sets have dropped in price considerably since I did this as well. Phil
Does your vinyl copy have Blow on a jug fade in briefly after the writ?
Hi Brett, Thank you for watching, yes it does - Phil :)
Wow we are in the same wagon I got tons and tons of Black Sabbath vinyl,cd! Box sets !!!! We spend a lot of $$$ lots of time looking and searching for what???? Ask tony can I have your autograph !!!! Nop they don’t have the time !!!!! So F !!!!! that guy !!!!! Ozzy 2 !!!!!!!
I purchase the BS Deluxe Editions on vinyl (which in my opinion are far superior to the CD versions in every way) from Rhino in the US. They each cost US$125 (including shipping) and I live in New Zealand. I actually this is a pretty reasonable price but here in NZ the BMG version is a lot more. I agree that Sabotage lacks a bit but did they have enough material? This was the case for Master of Reality. Also is it possible they didn’t have the master tapes for the live show? I guess they should say so if it’s the case.
Hi Tom, thank you very much for watching and taking the time to comment. Great to meet other Black Sabbath fans. Will you be going for the Technical Ecstasy box ? Phil
@@NowSpinningMagazine Hi Phil. Haha yes I’ve already preordered it. Like you I’m a huge technical ecstasy fan (I saw your video on that). I’m pretty excited about the new mix as it might offer something new that might get more people into it. Hopefully the live album sounds good too. I’ve heard there might be a NSD box too, that would be awesome😀
Yes, I am going for it as well! I guess the one many Black Sabbath fans are waiting for is a Sabbath Bloody Sabbath box set! I would also like to see a Tony Martin era Box set as well - Phil
@@NowSpinningMagazine Yes I’m looking forward to the Toby Matin box set too. I have a feeling there will be no SBS set though. In an interview, Tony said there wasn’t enough material for a MOR set so they did the RSD drop instead. They are going to release a splatter vinyl for SBS so I suspect it’s for the same reason.
Tom Mandeno. Regarding Sabotage Deluxe box set; Also your vinyls with the live material is sourced from MP3s. It is a shame the whole thing.
No remixes?
No nothing new at all - this is the poorest of the Sabbath Deluxe Sets. Phil
Thank you, I will not be buying this. Sadly.
Hi Craig, BMG dropped the ball on this one. Phil
sabatage is me fav BS...luv it. tho i aint brought no delux boxsets tho...most r a bladdy rip off
Unfortunately this one is !