WHAT IF Erwin had the COLOSSAL TITAN (Part 3) | Attack on Titan
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ก.ค. 2024
- This video explains how Attack on Titan would’ve changed if Erwin Smith inherited the Colossal Titan instead of Armin. The Colossal Titan is one of 9 titan shifters in AOT and this video is PART 3 of a series exploring this alternate timeline!
Erwin Colossal Titan Series:
If Erwin got the Colossal Titan PART 2: • WHAT IF Erwin had the ...
If Erwin got the Colossal Titan PART 1: • WHAT IF ERWIN had the ...
Socials:
SUPPORT ON PATREON: / turtlequirk
Stay updated on INSTAGRAM: / turtle.quirk
FOLLOW ON TWITTER: / turtlequirk
Join TurtleQuirk DISCORD: / discord
OTHER VIDEOS:
All FOUNDING TITANS Explained! - • All FOUNDING TITANS in...
All ARMORED TITANS Explained! - • All ARMORED TITANS in ...
All BEAST TITANS Explained! - • All BEAST TITANS in Hi...
All ATTACK TITANS Explained! - • All ATTACK TITANS in H...
All JAW TITANS Explained! - • All JAW TITANS in Hist...
All COLOSSAL TITANS Explained! - • All COLOSSAL TITANS in...
ARTISTS:
/ velupium
/ 0mizukiart0
/ narutorenegado01
www.deviantart.com/jairlc/gal...
/ raijin_75
TIMESTAMPS:
00:00 Warriors vs Scouts
14:56 Attack on Marley
18:52 Aftermath
20:17 The New Female Titan?
22:46 Willy Tybur
25:08 Historia’s Fate
28:06 Revenge
INFO:
Part 3 picks up with the warhammer titan confronting the scouts in Liberio. Given everything that’s happened it’d be pretty obvious to her that Zeke has betrayed Marley, and before anyone can react, she’d sends spikes directly through the beast titan. This would be followed up by doing the same thing to Eren, meaning that within just a few seconds, Lara Tybur would’ve used has used her hardening against 3 separate enemies. It’s worth remembering that as we continue since this shifter is known for not having the best stamina. Anyway in response to all this Zeke would call out for his pure titans to defend him and across the city they’d each start running towards his direction. At the same time Mikasa would spring into action from the rooftops, and fire a solid amount of thunderspears at the Warhammer titans nape. This massive explosion would send it crashing into the ground as if it was dead, giving the Yeager bros an opening to free themselves from the spikes of hardening. I imagine Zeke would then take a minute to also free Floch’s pure titan, while captain Levi would swoop down to retrieve the helpless Reiner.
Outside the internment zone commander Erwin would still be walking around in his colossal titan but he’d begin to emerge as a whole fleet of airships descend from the clouds. As the airships get closer Erwin would then fully exit the colossal and hitch a ride to the centre of zone, where the warhammer titan is fighting for it’s life. At this point all of Zeke’s pure titans are now in the area, forcing Lara to protect herself from Pieck’s dad, Porco’s mother and Floch, not to mention constant thunderspear attacks from Mikasa. In a situation like this the warhammer would have to keep using more and more hardening to stay in the fight, which naturally continues to drain energy. Off to the side the Porco would’ve manifested a new jaw titan body so he can try and take down Eren but Zeke would make a move to protect his younger brother. In particular he’d command his last remaining pure titan to attack Porco, and if you do the math you’ll realise this pure titan is actually Porco’s own father. Earlier that night Mr and Mrs Galliard were spiked at dinner with Zeke’s spinal fluid alongside Reiner’s mother and Pieck’s dad, but with Karina being crushed in the last video, only 3 of the parents became titan when Zeke eventually screamed. The Beast would try to psych Porco out by telling him the truth and it wouldn’t take long for the warrior to realise this isn’t a bluff, since the titan attacking him would look exactly like his dad. He’d then look over to see his own mother fighting against the warhammer and this is the moment his soul would break in two. Galliard would consider for a second whether he should just let his father eat him but while he’s distracted Levi would pounce in to chop off the jaw titans legs, with Eren following this up by ripping off Porco’s arms and smashing his face into the ground. Meanwhile the warhammer titan would be getting seriously overwhelmed and in this moment she’d have to use her last drop of energy to try and push Mikasa and the pure titans away. Although a move like this would temporarily give the warhammer some space, the downside is that she’s no longer able to create any weapons, which is exactly what Zeke had been waiting for.
#aot #attackontitan #attackontitanthefinalseason
Tags:
Talking titan
abnormal titans
Attack on Titan the final season
AOT
AOT S4
Eren Yeaeger
Coordinate
Rumbling
Ancient founding titan
AOT final season
AOT Season 4 - บันเทิง
Let me know your favourite moment in the comments 🔥 Also be sure to drop a LIKE if you want this series to continue!
Floch titan!
This sould of been two parts inside of one
This is too good to let it end
Spend more than a year since season four started with that story arc
superb work brother what a video
Erwin wouldn’t try to destroy the world the way Eren did but Marley would definitely be wiped off the map.
Kinda sucks he'd have to use fellow Eldians as basically fodder, turning them into Titans.
If Erwin managed to convince the Warriors or their families to support them, maybe a mass evacuation of the Eldians in Liberio could've occurred... would've been pretty cool
@@thalmoragent9344 He’s had plenty of practice in using soldiers as fodder unfortunately. And as a Commander, it’s just hard for me to imagine Erwin taking the diplomatic route the way Armin wanted. And whereas Hanji really had no idea how to proceed as Commander, Erwin would have the Majority of Paradis in support of him because he definitely would have had a clear strategy. It would be a game of chess for him.
@@AstonishingRed
Well, sure he wouldn't be as passive and diplomatic like Armin, but he'd have made more alliances where he could, use his words to perhaps gain as much an edge as possible before just going in with his army.
There's more people to negotiate with, tbh, since he's not just dealing with Pure Titans or other Shifters anymore
Hange is delusional. Erwin doesn't exist past this point in the story for a reason, his goals ambitions ended with the basement.
It's hard to know exactly how a fictional character would act, but I really doubt Erwin would just sit by and watch Paradis doom itself.
Maybe he wouldn't go with a full rumbling like Eren, but he wouldn't be flailing around without a plan like Armin/Hange.
@@donovantucker5166
Precisely. Erwin would've done something, anything to make sure the sacrifices made on Paradis weren't for nothing.
Would he try to delay the Rumbling in favor of another course of action yes, but actively fight against his own Scouts the way Hange did? There's no flipping way
Honestly i wonder if Isayama wrote a alternate story where Erwin survived, its safe to say he killed Erwin because Erwin as a titan shifter would probably cut the number of manga chapters in half
And the final season could have finished in one piece
agree it would cut the manga in half, why? cause that timeline was a failure, there's a deeper reason why armin was chosen, armin's role isnt over yet...
@@thedireside4219 If Armin was dead at that timepoint, he would be like the Nobara(from Jujutsu Kaisen) in Attack on Titan
@@thedireside4219 you want spoilers?? or nah?
@@thedireside4219 Armin is USELESS
Erwin-No eren you can’t have the jaw titan.
Eren-But it’s so cool
Erwin-I know but you can’t have it
Eren-But-
Erwin-We’re giving it to louise and that’s final!
Eren-Fine.
😂😂
Lol
i feal that this would be shorter bc levi would just yell at em to shut up and act like adults
"Eren, you already have that cool looking Jaw! You just ate the Warhammer!
"Fine! *Drops Porco so hard* "
Porco: “Do i have a say in any of this?”
Eren and Erwin: “NO!”
Porco: “ok just curious”
It's crazy how one different disicion could change a whole timeline.
Levi chooses Erwin
Hizurus alliance with Paradise still happens
Marley loses
Paradise gains more shifters
The rumbling can still happen
And thats just off the top of my head(memory form the other what ifs)
@@Gold_Gamer_100
Yeah, having Erwin or hell, even Bertholdt living instead of Armin would've made a far more interesting setting
and thats because.... you need to observe and think harder...
@@Gold_Gamer_100 levi randomly choosing armin isnt it? ahahahahahaahahahahahaha
@@thedireside4219 Quit whining. Armin is useless and you can’t do shit about it
The entire plot would've changed, and not to Zeke's or the other allied forces liking. Erwin would be extremely cautious of trust from outsiders. The whole Wine incident with Zeke's Spinal fluid would also NOT happen because Erwin wouldn't allow gifts to be accepted by outsiders whom, just 4 years ago, were killing his comrades. He would definitely be a big deterrent to Zeke's plan for him and Eren.
On the other hand, this would purposely push Eren even moreso into doing the Rumbling. His bestfriend Armin is dead, and that would've pushed him even more to keep his friends safe and kill anyone coming after them on Paradis Island. He would definitely try to not let Sasha die and would be even more ruthless.
Sasha’s death was unavoidable as Gabi’s involvement is near impossible to predict and as a result impossible to plan around.
Floch wouldn't be the floch we now know of
Things to remember, since Armin died here and Erwin lived, I believe Eren in this alternate timeline is more on shouldering his worries to Erwin himself. Since the commander lived and his closest friend died, he then had to unconditional give his faith and trust to the commander. If this were then broken, the trust and faithfulness, Eren thoughts on going to carry the burden (Going rumbling/protectiveness for everyone's/his closest friends sake) would have then be plausible, possible.
For the part with Eren still wanting to do the rumbling, I agree with your opinion. For Erwin's case, being more cautious/about not trusting outsiders, I slightly agree too. But despite this, I think he would have still cooperated with the outside world, such us when meeting Yelena (Zeke's Anti-marleyan volunteers), and Zeke the person himself. The idea here why Erwin had to "gamble" and be more open to outsiders would be the fact that, he knows that Paradis is really in a complete disadvantage. Given that he learned about the truth (Eren's basement) about other nations existing, this would have then gave him the idea to focus more on learning what's on the outside world. In my opinion, even though if they never met Zeke's volunteers, they would still had to go outside of Paradis to gather more intel of what they are facing. (Basically the whole idea here would be gathering information), but since Zeke's volunteers eventually ended up in their hands, they had to take a choice, kill them or take the opportunity (cooperate). Having the opportunity in their hands, I think it's plausible for Erwin to cooperate with them despite their battles with Zeke in Shiganshina, cause again, learning and gathering more information about the outside world plus new resources would be their next step if they were then going to go headbutts with other nations.
Ok time skip, about in this video... The chances of the spine fluid scenario happening would hence be plausible, given that the scouts and Zeke have already then made in contact through letters. Of course since Erwin had then cooperated with Zeke, he already have thought about Zeke having second plans/objectives of the matter since the entire situation of them cooperating together after their encounter sounds suspicious or ridiculous for not having an alternate motives. So during the Marley and Scout arc in this alternate timeline, Erwin would have then just use Zeke and cooperate in the meantime just like how Eren manipulated Zeke the same way in the og timeline. Do remember, Erwin doesn't really know what Zeke's plans yet, actually everyone doesn't, this is to say that they really haven't gained total trust yet with Erwin and the scouts, so the entire time they're just gaining trust. But if Erwin does learn Zeke's motives, I definitely believe he would be against with it, I mean who wouldn't who resides in Paradis as an Eldian...
Ok going back with Eren going rumbling... quite possible... Following the timeline in this vid after Jean's death, I believe he would have then be more on having doubts of letting commander Erwin in control. Given that he already lost Armin, at this phase he would have then be more ever protective with his friends and close ones. Since Jean's death I think he would have then went out to look for Zeke since he knows that Zeke is the only other way to achieve control of the founding powers. But since things happened in this video, the "going with rumbling plan" for Eren is already gone.
Conclusion, I honestly think everything in this Vid part series was quite plausible.
@@bijuutamer729 Not if they kill Gabi before that happens which could have happened about 5 times during the Liberio raid
@@bijuutamer729 mabye not, this battle takes starts in an a different area it stand to reason that the warrior candidates wouldn't be near the discreet when Eren and refiner change saveing those two characters form death and that likely would prevent gabi form throwing her life away to try and get back at the new eldain empire
The fact that floch and loiuse became titan shifters is pretty interesting ngl
Erwin being the upper hand man in this timeline is really something erwin would've been if he became the collosal in the canon timeline
Although now with zeke being eaten by pieck things are kinda complicated
Anyway this theory is amazing and really well thought and i hope someday you make a part 4
Erwin was a commanding presence in season 3. The man was more intimidating than reiner and reiner could become a 15 ft giant while erwin was a normal human. That really says something. That and he was had a natural charisma and people chose to follow him I mean even Levi as rebellious as he was in his early days was really loyal to erwin that says something as well. Also, no doubt erwin and magath would have been trying to one up each other using war mindgames.
*15 meter or 45ft giant
The long awaited episode i have been waiting for like 3 months checking everyday for this THANK GOD (This is edited Ty for the likes and Ty turtle quirk for the highlight 😁)
Sameeeee
We need part 4 now lol
Part 4 bout to take a year😂😂
@@jonathanclerger1776 part 4 boutta take a light year
@@legallyunofficial1254 Part 4 botta start a new bigbang
hypothetically speaking, imagine the cart titan merged with the colossal, idk if it would work this way but it might be the most op combination not counting royal blood as it would be an unlimited number of nukes
Giant mobile tank
War hammer titan. It gets hardening and can escape much easier.
Yeah but the cart would give it many more transformations
Imagine this story being animated, it would be so epic. It changes all the story completely. Great work.
Love seeing your thoughts and interpretations of this alternate timeline, Turtle! I'll be eagerly awaiting Part 4!
urchin tittan
same, i'll be _yeagerly_ waiting for part 4
*ba dum tss*
@@nasgor22 lol
@@nasgor22omg bruh🤣🤣😂😂🤣😂😂
I can’t wait for part four. This series brings me so much joy
Same
not really don't like the fact that jean dies -_-
@@Joppeh1 me neither.
@@Joumae_Saori man get him outta here he ain't important
@@Joppeh1 he comes bck
If this scenario happened, pieck would be as hated as gabi was
Yes. Yes she would.
Maybe?? Not so sure?
Definitely.
Yes
Maybe... but the simps probably wouldn't
I love how this rewrite truly gets the unnerving spirit that Attack on Titan always had. It's not a shounen. Literally anyone could be a goner at any second, and we wouldn't even have the courtesy of seeing their last moments. That is the tragedy of this setting, and you nailed it.
After all the times this “Final” Season has been continued I really hope Isayama & Mappa have been making an alternate ending secretly. This alternate timeline is masterful, a missed opportunity.💯🔥🔥
I KNEW IT!!!! I knew that I wasn’t the only person who was constantly thinking about this what-if alternate storyline had Erwin inherited the Colossal Titan instead of Armin. These possibilities are amazing. I can literally imagine this alternate storyline animated by MAPPA. Thinking about and visualizing Commander Ervin in the new and updated ODM gear alongside the rest of the Survey Corps is insanely awesome. Erwin’s presence and command would’ve made the storyline all types of different…. In a good epic way of course
The long wait is finally over
You might have answered this already but if a Titan shifter drank Zeke’s spinal fluid what would happen? Would Zeke have some form of control over the shifter?
No
Interesting question! I think they’d at least have a small chance of gaining some beast titan characteristics (eg fur like falco’s jaw Titan or maybe screaming powers like Annie had). I doubt he’d have any actual control over the human inside the shifter though
Yeah kinda like when eren drank the armored bottle from season 3 in the reiss chapel, that gave him the hardening ability
He never disappoints with these theories
The fact that pieck thought she gave Marly a chance made laugh cause she had no idea of erwin secret plan 🤣🤣😎
Well she did give the world a chance by taking the beast
But I'm pretty sure all you need for the rumbling is the founder of royal blood or a founder coming in contact to q royal blood member
@@dripinc.5781 It has to be a titan of royal blood
@@bigbro5290 oh
Thank you
I love just how massively different this storyline is! But it still feels true to attack on titan! You know and understand the characters and imo you have a perfect idea how certain things would play out!
Man... this is absolutely incredible!!
I actually prefer this timeline to be brutally honest, the thought and depth you go into with this is insane
I want to see a spin off series where this was the actual time line. Insanely well done man, loved it.
This series is so good, I love seeing content on Erwin
Haijme Isayama should do this manga! _"What If Erwin Had the Colossal Titan?"_
I know for damn sure he wouldn't be simping for annie and turning his back on his people after all the sacrifices they made and observed how wrongly people in the mainland were being treated
That's funny considering all the people Erwin got killed.
@@Tyrantofthewind Ok?
@@Tyrantofthewind F
U
C
C
Y o u B i t c h B o i
Yeah, now we can simp for Shifter! Hitch.
@@Tyrantofthewind lol Armin is literally a mass murderer
I can tell this took a ton of work, great video this was well worth the wait. You’re the best anime youtuber. Thanks for always making great content that never disappoints
Love the fan made art used in these kinds of videos, especially when it comes to new titans like Floch’s Armored Titan!
Yeah, me too. I wonder what animal his beast-like armored titan is supposed to be?
Yes I’m so happy this is finally here. Thank you for an amazing video, love the series bro
this is so well made! Thank you so much for putting so much effort into this
I am willing to wait 6 more months if you could make a 1-hour special for part 4. I'm just saying that you should take your time because we'll all be waiting for you.
Yes finally part 3 for this, I really like this series
I'm impressed. You outlined such a detailed and plausible scenario. I'm excited for part 4!
I've been waiting for this!! It's finally here!!
I was literally shaking while watching that masterpiece.
(Also, I don't think they would left Zeke unsecured)
yeah bro fax they would have security Guard like Levi and Mikasa Same what happened to Eren in the Cristal Cave, Kenny Ackerman being a Security
If Erwin got the colossal:MY SOLDIERS TRANSFORMMMMM!
That's one hell of a ending, good on you Cart Titan.
I loved it all! I can’t wait for more! Keep up the good work,keep up making more Titans and keep up making more fan made Aot stories like these 😄😄😄
Man Jean instead of Sasha dying I still feel the same way as how Sasha died. 💯😭
Your sad cause a horse died
Bruh 😂
The best fan fiction I've ever heard. Letting the story conclude based on the premise that was presented and not shoving in fan service. Great job.
I loved how you made an accurate design of the Jaw, Colossal, and Armor titans shifters.
Wonder what hitchs female titan form whould be?
@@parrotking8315 me too
@@teentitans0 it's gonna look like *not a surprise *
@@jamein2812 most likely. Still look forward to it
This is fire 🔥 ! Please keep making these! You can do ALOT if alternate endings or what ifs with AOT!
The amount of work that you put into your videos is so admirable. I think you are the best anime youtuber for sure. Thank you for all your hard work. I enjoyed the watch so very much. I hope you're well :)
This is a amazing storyline. I am in no doubt, it took long hours to just think about this. Keep this up man. Love the content.
Awesome video! can't wait for part 4
This series is amazing dude, please keep this series up, its so engaging
Please put on community the picture’s of luis and floch’s titan please because they look awesome!
TURTLE QUIRK! I HAVE BEEN WAITING AND IM BEYOND HAPPY WITH THE END PRODUCT! YES!
Just found this series. I’m freaking hooked can’t wait for part 4
Amazing work, love the cliffhanger at the end. Can’t wait til part 4
Yes! Been waiting on part 3.
This is really interesting, but what about the involvement of the young warriors? I feel like they would’ve been significant to these events too, or were they killed by Erwin’s transformation in Liberio?
Probably (hopefully Gabi got incinerated)
23:23 I don't why but here looks so awesome team
Bro I love your videos.....ur videos are like actual episodes that I cant wait to watch.
Finally, been waiting for this.
Been waiting for this for months let’s go
This was great I can tell you put a ton of thought into this new story. Kinda feeling excited for whats next. I wrote a story fan fic of what if Armin won the fight between him and Eren. I’d love to send it to you to possibly give you new material to work on for a future video.
(I didn't want to comment until part 3.) I like how you did a completely different timeline if Ewrin took the Colossal Titan. At 1st I was like “why thou?” then as you continued the alternate timeline my mind changed and I get it now.
Loved this alternate timeline can't wait to hear the ending of it 🤩
the goat returns
Great video man it's 🔥🔥
LOVE UR VIDEOS
This was awsome. I loved seeing the pure titan, and titan shifter forms of floch, and louise.
Watching this has been AWESOME!! I’m so invested 😭
we need a part 4 for this, this is the best story timeline ever and keep up the good work
I absolutely LOVE your videos. There's a lot of What If AOT videos on TH-cam but these are top tier. I have an idea for a new series after this which is somewhat similar. What If the scouts had 2 or more syringes in the Return to Shiganshina? My thought is Armin would still get the Colossal but Erwin could get the Armor, Beast or Cart.
LETS GOOOOOO THIS IS SO LIT!!! ITS FINALLY HERE!!!
Amazing, can't wait for part 4
Yes sir finally a new video
loved this!
Finally part 3 is out waited so long for this
I really love this series. I'm waiting for the 4th part
can't wait for the next part :D
love this series keep it up!
Damn this was very brutal
Bro I've BEEN waiting 😭❤️
These are always amazing much love man
The amount of thought and energy that goes into these is seriously commendable, super enjoyable watch!
I am not so much into What if scenarios but with Aot I was always wondering about this seemingly small change in the story that would turn the timeline completely upside down. I really enjoy your takes, especially with the new titan shifters and Pieck's role in this.
i love u bro.What a video it was i loved it . It is better than the real aot manga.what a video
This video is so cool!!!!. Cant wait for part 4!
This is peak fan-fic content, brother. Keep it up!!!
what i love about this is that you dont forget to put some twists
Long wait is over les GOOOOO
Erwin has that presence, that when he shows up, you feel like everything is alright and you're gonna win
Great video
Your theories are very interesting. waiting for part 4
This was an amazing video, had to subscribe
Let’s go it’s finally here
Im pretty sure that erwin could perceive beforehand that imprisoning zeke would put them in a spot where the founding titan wont be able to be used as eren would be against historia inheriting the beast titan.
Im positive Erwin could foresee that situation.
He would figure out some way to deceive zeke rather than imprison him.
Can't wait for Part 4. Do you also plan to make more What If's for Attack on Titan in the future?
Yessss finally🔥
It's been a long but it was worth the wait.
_"It's been so long..."_
Finally part 3
been waiting for part 3!
This what if scenario needs to be animated!!!
im so invested in this please continue bro
When Levi and Eren got The Jaw titan🔥💀
Thats my favourite moment, its just very badass to be animated ⚡⚡
And gosh man I wish you could make a series like this, u're very good at it, and the videos are so enjoyable n fun 🧡
Love ya , SHINZOOUU SASAGEYOOUU ✊🏻
I wish Isayama and mappa did a bunch of ‘what if’ specials or ova’s
Few things
1. I fucking love this video, its so detailed and entertaining and gets my brain flowing
2. Your voice is great to listening its almost calming
3. Louis’s jaw is one of the ugliest titans and i love it
These are great so pumped for pt 4
u have no idea how long i waited for this
3 months?