Hogwarts Reacts: GoTS06E10 "The Winds of Winter" (part three R+L=J video)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ก.ย. 2024
- Hogwarts reacts to THAT video...right after learning about you-know-who...
.
.
.
New to the channel? Check out our Intro and Q&A's to see what we are all about! • Welcome to Hogwarts Re...
Follow us around everywhere else!
Twitter: @hogwarts_reacts
Instagram: @hogwartsreacts
Questions, Comments, or Promotional Requests?
Email us at ravens@hogwartsreacts.com
Send us love letters here:
Hogwarts Reacts
PO Box 60726
You know a character is awesome (Ned Stark) when all the others, even his enemies respect and talk about him even 6 seasons after his death.
Aerys Targaryen: am I a joke to you?
What about Aegon Targaryen? 300 years after his death, everyone knows him hahaha
What about Rhaegar, he doesn't appears in the show, or the novels, and still all the story seems to be around him
Ned Stark forsook his honor to save his family and took his sister's secret to the grave...ughh...chills.
But it was still honorable in its own right. A nice reference to what Ned told Arya in the first book.
"You can't get your hands on this one can you" Oooh Ned :'(
yeah what a reference
"He's a stark and a targaryen!" Its almost like he's some kinda mix of ice and fire or somethin 🤔
The night king has passed the wall we need you Sandor now more than ever!
All this shit just to make bran the boring be king at the end , what a disappointing ending man
@@rahilrameez8635 Thanks for the spoiler
@@timy.4818 it’s your fault for looking in TH-cam comments years after the finale
@@skyrimaddic87 How DARE you Jared !!!😂😂😂. You are right though.
All those clips just reminded me of how great of an actor Sean Bean is
@Maylevka May How does that take away from his acting?
He wasnt saying the theory made his acting great, he meant becasue its been ages since weve seen him, we forgot how good he was in season 1.
That was the most satisfying reaction I have seen to the R+L=J.
It's also the best edited video about the R+L =J theory(or fact now that it's been confirmed i suppose)
What video is this?
still im for book N+A=J !
Gabe Logan Ashara Dayne?
Of course the biggest clue was that Rhaegar liked to sing and Jon's a great singer - ("Wild-ling! I think I love you!!")
victorsixtythree LOLOL EXACTLY!
Actually I think he goes a little bit flat on the "-ling"
No he doesn't. You know nothing, hotsauce69247. -wink-
I find the biggest clue was Ned his honour honourable man dont cheat on their wife and also his reactions to when someone brings up his sister or Jons mother he always looked sad
One scene that wasn't included in "that video" was Jon's conversation with Benjen. It sounds like Benjen is trying to make Jon really think about whether he wants to join the night's watch. Jon says something like "I don't care what I'd lose, I'm ready." And Benjen says "Maybe if you knew what you'd be giving up you would." This has me convinced that Benjen knew who Jon was. If that is true then that means that Ned trusted his brother with that information but not Catelyn.
FoxInRoch I agree. I'm convinced Benjen knew. Even if Ned didn't tell him right away, maybe Benjen joined the dots (he was close with both Lyanna and Ned) and Ned had no choice but to explain. Benjen joined the NW almost as soon as all of this happened... Hmm.
To be fair, Benjen is Ned and Lyanna's brother whom Ned knows he can trust and has a right to know too as he was most likely the closest to Lyanna (they spent the most time together and if Lyanna was the knight of the laughing tree then most likely Benjen helped her).
Catelyn was a stranger and even when Ned learned more about her he knew she couldn't be trusted.
There's also the simple possibility that little Jon looked a lot like little Lyanna, so that might have helped Benjen figure it out. Catelyn was a stranger. They'd only just gotten married. Did she ever even meet Lyanna? I agree that Ned couldn't know whether it was safe to trust Catelyn or not.
I've always believed that Benjen figured it out on his own and that he had an 'unspoken' understanding with his brother, which may have been the reason he went to the Wall in the first place.
Very cool!
"LOOK AT LITTLEFINGER'S FACE" ... never noticed that before.
I think it was smart to pause here and show her this. Many of my friends who were unsullied couldn’t function after they realized it. They pretty much didn’t pay attention to the rest of the episode and had to watch again. For reactions sake, good move.
I love how Papa Brian was so excited to show Hogwarts this video that he couldn't wait until the end of the episode. *lol* Awesome! Great reaction to this and to the season 6 finale!
Love how you're guiding Hogwarts...the pause to make sure she fully understood the magnitude of what we were given in that scene...Jeez...good work.
I LOVE how Hannah wasn’t spoiled at all and never suspected R+L=J. And I love the way you showed her that video of all the relevant mentions over the course of the series!!! What a perfect way to show all the details instead of having to actually explain every detail that ever came up about it. This is BY FAR my favourite of her reactions!!!!
Yeah i wish i learned it this way. I learned Jon's real name and heritage in season 5 beacuse i looked him up in the GoT wikia.
Eddard Stark, man of the show -- *crying hard*
I want to thank all the people behind Hogwarts Reacts. I was one of the few people to have watched the first ever video when it was released and have been watching every video and livestream since. It's been real great for passing the time and keeping the Game of Thrones hype going until season 8 starts. And of course, Hannah's reactions have been great and hilarious. 😁😂
Keep up the good work and keep being funny Hannah.
Thanks Again,
Ellis Farrow / Fazza
+Ellis Farrow thank you so much for being such a loyal hogsquad member! We are so grateful for you!
Yes love this channel..Been here from the first video...Can't wait to see the season 7 reaction of all u guys.
Yeah of course, would love one.
I m one of them too who watched from 1st Episode 😄
Amen.
Now I can't wait for Brian's reaction when Gilly finds that Maester's journal entry, in season 7.
maynard's shitz!
Especially because they messed this up. They are calling the bastard a legitimate son. It was stupid.
@@unwanted107 Rhaegar and Lyanna were married before Jon was born. That makes him a legitimate son, not a bastard.
@@unwanted107 wait, are you arguing purely from the books, and discounting the show entirely? Because everyone else, including me, are talking about the show here.
What everyone thought was Ned's greatest moment of weakness was actually one of the most honorable things he ever did. He was even more honorable then everyone thought he was, and that's saying something!
Jon is literally the song of ice and fire, the prince who wad promised. I'll never forget the feeling I had while watching that scene for the first time, it was absolutely incredible.
nope thats Arya
Thanks to the people behind this channel. You are all awesome and watching seasons 7 & 8 will be awesome.
Also, don’t let the muggles get you down.
Jasmine Jackson brilliant
And the Oscar for best editing in everything is Brian ! 👏Absolute perfection replaying all the Rhaegar mentions for Hannah to put it all together.
Brian didn't made that video. Is a video made by youtuber Robbie McD, 2 years ago, before season 6 came out.
That's cool, thanks for the correction. :)
Brian is excellent though
agreed
THAT WAS AMAZIIIIIIIIIIIIIINGGGGGGGGGGGGG!! Don't you just love Brian?
So when Ned Stark refuses to take part in King Robert's plan to execute Daenerys, it is a bit more than his honour that is at stake. He's trying to protect Jon's kin. He was being very practical and political.
It's probably already been mentioned before but I always thought that the reason Ned said to Jon "The next time we meet I'll tell you about your mother" was because Ned knew that Jon would be safe from King Robert once he was a member of the nights watch.
Once Jon had joined the nights watch Ned would be able to tell him about his mother etc...
I have been a huge fan of this channel from the beginning and all I have to say is AMAZING JOB, with the reactions the editing and absolutely everything you guys do is awesome! Many thanks
Watching this actually made me cry... again!
Elza Chavira me too!!! Thanks for being here
So that's how genuine R+L=J Reveal Reaction looks like :)
Excellent! Enjoyed it a lot
The theory is that Petyr Baelish started Robert's Rebellion with the lie of Lyanna's kidnap to begin with. This has not been discussed in the books or the TV series but it is a big fan theory and could be the moment when Petyr realized how far a lie will go and possibly what it could do for him.
"This is CRAZY!!!"
A Song of Ice and Fire... a dragon raised by wolves...
Hogwarts is lucky that she have the best people around her to not spoil the biggest mystery of this show.
+KidZoneChannel it was such a challenge but we were so proud to accomplish it!
A son of ice and fire!
The Song of Ice and Fire
flyflip87 a son
A Son
At first I did question the decision to pause the episode to watch the R+L video, but the more I think about it I think it was a good decision. I've seen a few videos where the reactor did not know about the theory and they are either so blown away that they can't focus on the next scene or they do focus on the next scene and don't have time to think about R+L=J until later. Pausing it for Hogwarts seemed to work well! Her mind started at BLOWN and slowly went to TOTALLY BLOWN.
victorsixtythree exactly!!! Brian knows how my brain works :)
I'm a big fan of pausing! People need to pause more, much more!
Jon is a song of ICE and FIRE and the prince that was promised -> 'promise me Ned'
Then s8 ruined it lol
9:42 "I'm a fucking tree wizard! I know things!" made me laugh haha
The best scene compilation of R+L=J scenes! ❤️
Ok ok ok. I've seen part 2 and 3 10 times over now. #perfection
Hannah missed two small but ultimately crucial points - Jon is not just a Targaryan, but Dany's nephew. More importantly, he's the son of her older brother Rhaegar, the Prince of the Seven Kingdoms, and so the ONLY legitimate heir to the iron Throne.
you guys have made the wait for season 8 that little bit easier an you made the weekdays fly by I can't thank you enough great job all of you x
I was already crying during the reaction of Jon's parentage... then I saw that there are 4 videos today and now I'm crying more 😭 thank you guys so much for this channel. We appreciate your work so damn much . Thank you thank you thank you ❤
And it's crazy how watching the "R+L=J" video Again after the reveal from the end of S7 becomes even MORE of a mindblown moment :'D
I was hoping Hannah would figure out that Rhaegar was the father by herself. Because the fact that Rheagar ran off with Lyanna came up like 10 times in the show. I guess she forgot. Still, awesome reactions!
I watch and I've seen A LOT of reaction videos (it's my thing), but I have to say your's is the best. It was pure and organic and just priceless. You just gained another subscriber.
thank you so much! We are so glad you joined the party! new shows to come in 2018 :)
This one is probably the best one so far!
The Dragon raised by Wolves..
Although it was a pretty radical idea, I really like that [you] paused Ep10 to insert the R+L video.
we like to be extra radical when necessary
You probably should have explained to Hogwarts that at the time the video was made R+L=J was just a theory and had not been confirmed yet in the show or in the books. That might have helped her understand the last part, about Dan and Dave meeting GRRM and him asking them who Jon's mother is.
victorsixtythree. Yeah...The video would have a lot more credence for me if it had been produced by GRRM. But as it stands, it just feels like a fan theory played out against some well chosen clips that help to "support" it. I'm not convinced this is totally the way GRRM originally envisioned this story. For all we know, he might have given D&D permission to do it because he thought their theory was interesting. We'll see how the real master chooses to tie these loose ends with his next book... if there is a next book.
thank you everyone at hogwarts react for doing this.. its been a long 4 months and I loved every second of it! heres to more bonus videos, sneaky livestreams, Q+As, stranger things and season 7!!
Did Benjen Know?
When the show started there were tons of Targaryans alive. Robert's grandmother was a Targaryan, So, Robert, Stannis, Shireen, Renly , Gendry, Viserys, Dany, Jon, and Aemon.
Now we are down to three, Gendry Jon and Dany.
and CONGRATULATIONS to Brian and friends for successfully keeping the secret from Hogwarts! Must have been tough.
+victorsixtythree SO HARD
omg i didnt realize this part was all just R+L=J im glad u showed this to her...one of my fav compilations
Ned's plan was that once Jon took his oath and no longer had a claim to the thrown he would tell Jon who he really was, because Jon would be safe at Castle Black. In the book the clues aren't nearly as blatant but once you start piecing them together it becomes pretty obvious.
The only real question is, Is Jon really dead in the books, when he is stabbed in the books, Lady Stoneheart (Dead Catelyn Stark brought back to life) and the brothers without banners are only a few hours from Castle Black.
The theory is Jon is inside Ghost, and in The Winds of Winter Lady Stoneheart will give Jon the kiss of life allowing Jon's body to heal and for him to return to his body and leave Castle Black to avenge House Stark. And that she will also give him Robb's will, which while he was King in the North, many believe he secretly legitimized Jon as Jon Stark.
This channel is more entertaining than a lot of tv programs! Good job, especially you Brian!
Love you guys!
My favorite moment when Margeary finally understand that she's been outsmarted.
Oh my gosh I didn't realise part 3 and 4 would be out so soon!
Yes!!! 3 parter!!! This is how you know an episode is so damn good... thank you all for your time... #TeamHogwarts is one hell of a team... Love you all so much
+Philip Simmonds we love you as well! Thanks for your support!
It's good editing..everything comes in together. Wish my classes were like this! :)
that was the best video.. but the rest you came to this knowledge a bit earlier.. but the unique thing is how Hanah gets so happy
🖤🖤🖤
He has no idea he was a rightful heir to the Iron Throne, made King in the North anyway.
i really do appreciate how much work u put into these videos Brian! excellent job on the montage! the effort u put in these videos really makes them so much more awesome!!!!!
So glad Hanna wasnt spoiled about this. Her reaction to it is amazing.
Watching this video, more than anything, truly shows how Ned got the "Most honorable Man" tag, always will miss Ned
The shit he went through to protect Jon, all the way to his death, smh
Mhh, no. Ned chose family over honor. What he did was not honorful at all. He lied to his king and best friend, to his wife all those years, to protect his nephew.
He was honorful, but atleast twice he decided against honor. There and when he confessed his „crimes“ in KL.
MrColler123 Well when put like that I guess you're right. Not like choosing family over honor doesn't make him an even more awesome character
8:23 "So did George Martin Know?" OH...MY...FUCKING...GOD!!!
LOL! I guess he did after D and D told him!
Crazy thing is...what Ned did, saving Jon and bringing him up, was treason in a way. Harboring what Robert would have seen as a enemy. I think when Ned said that he was confessing his treason, I think this is what he was thinking about in his head.
The entire thing is so messed up....Rhaegar and Lyanna loved each other and ran off....Ned's father and brother think he kidnapped her....the mad king kills them...that sets off a war. I wonder if Rhaegar truly was going to kill his father if he had won the battle of the Trident?
Rheagar was aiming to gather the great council to overthrow his father, the mad king, who obviously unfit for the job. he wasn't going to kill him.
The books hint that Rhaegar would have overthrown his father, but I don't know if he would have killed him
5.53 for me from the very begining the time he spent with maester was a spoiler to he was the hiding prince.. I love how martin is using Homers tragic moment in his writing
Amazing work to put together all those clips. My hats off to you.
Another great thing about this revelation is that it showed that Eddard Stark did not cheat on his wife, and he was honorable all the way
Christmas just came early! I have been waiting all year for this video
Do (GoT) Jaime Lannister | The Kingslayer!
Just when I thought that after a hundred viewings and a million tears that the well was dry,you proved me wrong. Your reaction was phenomenal and moved me beyond my most heartfelt depths of emotions. The clips from the previous episodes made it all the more poignant. Thank you.i I think,lol.
Eugenia McManus you're too sweet! I'm so glad it moved you
Hence the name of the books, "A Song of Ice (Stark) and Fire (Targaryen)".
8:05 ...Well, that seemed uncalled for.
George has said that if D&D didn’t know who Jon’s mother was then he wouldn’t have let them continue the show
Not continue, them knowing who Jon's mother was was a condition for HBO getting the show. If they had gotten it wrong GRRM was going to shop the show to someone else.
The midwife would know. Whoever she is.
Points to Jon Snow: This one here is a true son of Ice and Fire.
I wish I never heard about R+L+J before this episode like Hannah
Girl, Jon Snow(Aegon Tagaryan) is the Embodiment of THE SONG OF ICE AND FIRE
Jon Snow is the son(g) of Ice and Fire
OMG! That moment when she realizes that Jon IS the Song of Ice and Fire.... Priceless!
"Three-eyed Raven" v "Psychic Tree Wizard". It's all about the branding.
I fucking love you guys! You can literally see Hogwarts mind slowly being turned to ash as her core processors slowly wither and die from running on 600% capacity from sher mind-blowing xD
I shall patiently wait for Wednesday for s7 :-D
Fucking spectacular
thanks for being here always - so glad you loved it
Pretty sure its Monday
Theguywhoisright Always Yir it said so in the next video, so I had incomplete data avaliable at the time of writing. But I thank you for the information.
Remember when we thought this mattered? :( Sigh... Season 8.
Not only is he Targaryen, he is the rightful heir to the iron throne, even before Dany (who is Rhaegar's sister / his aunt)!
OMG THIS IS AMAZING!!! SO GLAD YOU GUYS DID THIS FOR HER.
Sam and Bran know two parts of the same secret. Sam knows about the secret wedding which means he isn't a bastard. From the recorded history in the books he read. Then he tells Bran.
Oh perfect! You did show her the supercut! 💯
Dany is Jon's twin. This is why Ned had such a difficult moment when he saved his daughters at his endgame knowing he favored Jon as an heir at the deathbed scene. Women werent as important. Ned fought with Robert over killing dany because he was amazed dany had survived. Note there were TWO midwives in that deathbed childbirth scene. Now jon and dany have done what viserys and others foreshadowed. Sister brother alliance. AND now we see women rising.
+LaDonna Louise well that is an interesting opinion!
I wish they had asked her if the way Barrister Selmy was describing Rhaegar in those clips if that sounded like a man who kidnaps and rapes women since Hannah thought Rhaegar was a monster.
WAY past the time this series is done I present to you something not talked about yet, at least much. "If the day shall ever come when your Lord Father was forced to choose between Honor on the one Hand and those he loves on the other..what would he do?" Ned chose to protect his family with his death so that his entire family would not be wiped out. Jon chose to kill his love so that all others he loved would not perish. In Aemon Targaryen's speech to Jon in Season ONE...Season ONE...he spelled out how this show was going to end. So much so that the other quote in Aemon's speech to Jon included the comment the "Love was the Death of Duty"... is a direct reflection of how Jon's "Duty, was the Death of his Love" in how he mirrored Ned Stark from beginning to end.
I wish the editor of that video made an updated one with season 6, but it is still effective
"I'm a tree wizard I know things."
React channel videos 'zurik 23m'
Jon Snow || The White Wolf
Jon Snow || The Wolf With Dragon's Blood
Jon and Daenerys || Ice and Fire
and the other videos from game of thrones by zurik 23m is the best
Yassss
Agreed, the Ice and Fire one was amazing just shows it wasn't fan service but planned from the beginning
Why does everyone think Ice and Fire are Jon and Daenerys, instead of the Lord of Light and the Night King or Drogon and the Night King If the Red God is real, why wouldn't he posses Drogon one of his priest/priestesses and battle the Night King? Who has shown they are so cold, they can walk through fire? Maybe even the Three Eyed Raven will posses Drogon and battle the Night King? Isn't Bran supposed to fly.Think about it.
Ice and Fire can stand for more than one thing. So It could stand for Jon and Dany or Rheager and Lyanna along with those other things. Like ep 7.07 title The Dragon and the Wolf. You could say that's about Jon and Dany. Rheager and Lyanna. Or just Jon himself.
Rheagar was never a bad man. You will know this after seeing house of dragon. He loved lyanna. Rhearar was one of the finest Targeyren
I loved your video on Jon and all the clues that were dropped along the way, beautifully done. We know how you feel, it's an OMG moment.
LAST PART, I PROMISE, No, we seriously want this to be coming at us no matter the parts....
0:32 Aaaaaaaand Hannah's mind is blown.
Love Hannah's reactions!!!!! So excited for season 7!!!!!! I really want Ned & Ashara to be Jon's parents.
I liked strictly for the Dick punch! Lol
That was funny
Oh! 😄I have been waiting for this for so long! 🤧 your reaction was perfect🤗
this video is BRILLIANT!!!!!!!
Jon is ice and fire
A Son(g) of Ice and Fire
Ah, I see what you did. Jon is Ice and Daenerys is Fire and they have a Son/Song who will be...LUKE WARM WATER!!
victorsixtythree or Jon is literally the son of Ice (Lyanna) and Fire (Rhaegar)
lovec 1609 - yeah, that's the more plausible interpretation. It didn't occur to me until later.
If she hasn't seen it already, can you do a video of Hogwarts reacting to Hunter Boyle when she deduces R+L=J? (It is towards the end of her after-episode discussion of 6.04, beginning around the 31 minute mark.)
I was also confused at the end and then i started to think a little about what they said about Rhaegar my mind was also blown.