🎵⚠️ Think you CAN'T SING, but wish you knew HOW?? Join my Karaoke Club!! We host live Masterclasses, get feedback on your singing videos, vocal warm up drills, and just hang out with me! 👉 SingWithAudrey.com
I was her director when she was in High School. In press junkets she talks about asking Spielberg if she can finish her senior show. I directed her in that show. It was "Shrek the Musical". When she was a freshmen we knew from the second the first note came out of her mouth we knew that what we were witnessing was historical talent. However no one could have guessed that he rise would have been this amazing!
@@doritobandito_1323 It was a crazy time! Exciting for everyone involved. She was supposed to start rehearsals when "Shrek" would have been performing. You can imagine my reaction when, she told me "I'm going to ask Steven if I can finish "Shrek"!!
@@elenacruzlopez Yes, that was one of many completely crazy and awesome things that was going on during that time! She told me later that when she was filming her and Tesori were exchanging stories about their respective Shrek experiences!
i cannot believe this is rachels first professional gig. i've been watching her on social media for YEARS in her school musicals and clips of her singing just waiting for her to get cast in something like this, and shes just incredible
IMHO it’s the last 4 minutes of her performance that ruined her chances. I feel she wasn’t convincing enough as being De aster and definitely underperformed compared to Natalie Wood in the 1961 version. Her heartbreaking left me emotionally cold. Other than that she was absolutely marvellous and IMHO a much better Maria overall.
@@gpapa31 I love both the '21 and the '61 versions and for me Zegler's Maria is captivating. For the last scene in WSS in general, I think it could be written differently. To many words, talking about how many bullets, killing, possible suicide, and hate. Gets in the way of showing it, emoting I think.
@@gambledw you’re probably right. To be honest with you I didn’t cry jn the 1961 version when I first saw it as a kid back in the 90s back I did feel Natalie Woods devastation, it was quite there in your face. I don’t know Rachel didn’t deliver that here and the scene felt kind of rushed to me. Overall I loved the new version and IMHO is right up there with the 1961 by Robert Wise. It’s really really ashamed that it was overlooked this year bombed at the Box office and snubbed by the award committees.
@@gpapa31 I think maybe another factor is that the part of Maria may not have enough range that the Academy would want to nominate someone in that role for Best Actress? Iirc Natalie Wood didn't get a nomination for Best Actress either. WSS 1961's acting nods were in the Best Supporting Actor and Actress categories. Plus with her being a newcomer to acting on screen/the way Maria is written it's possible Rachel didn't give as good a performance as the others nominated in Best Actress this year. I have yet to see the films the Best Actress nominees are from yet so I can't speak my opinion on those nominations.
@@hierophantpurple5163 the other nominees in the category are pretty big performances, the movies basically revolve around the actresses performances. Zegler might have just been perceived as a beautiful singer but not a particularly extraordinary actress yet.
I thought Ansels acting and dancing were both really great - his singing was good but Rachel has one of the best voices I’ve ever heard. Hard to hold your own next to her.
Some fun facts: Rachel Zegler auditioned on the first day of auditions and set the bar so high with Steven Spielberg, he couldn’t find anyone else that matched her performance. There’s a wonderful story of how Ariana Debose (Anita) turned down a request from Steven Spielberg to read at her first audition because she didn’t feel confident that she was going to give her best and asked for another day to read (she was only supposed to sing that day anyway). David Alvarez (Bernardo) won a Tony Award at I think age 10 alongside Trent Kowalik and Kiril Kulish for their joint portrayals of Billy Elliott on Broadway.
"I'm being really picky cuz she's really good." And that to me is the Death Blow for Ansel in this movie. He's not bad per se, But when you put him up against Rachel Zegler, Ariana DeBose, Mike Faist, David Alvarez, Rita Moreno: He's out acted out danced out sung by everyone. Everyone else is greater then excellent and that's why he nearly sunk this movie for me even though I love the movie and it's still one of my 10 Best of 2021, Everyone/Everything else is just that great.
I really feel like you’re undermining how much he put his all into his performance. He sings very lovely, his dancing is up to par with pretty much everyone else, and there are some moments where he really gets to shine as an actor and I can name a few examples if you really care. You’re acting like he was the equivalent of Russell Crowe in Les Mis. Lol, get over yourself. XD
@Charles's Movie Channel That's an interesting perspective; I think I liked his performance for the same reasons you disliked it. His singing, while beautiful, is stylistically different and lacks the power of the rest of the cast, and his acting is significantly more subdued and laidback compared to the more fiery performances. For me, this set him apart from the other characters, showing how isolated and different Tony is from the rest of the Jets, and it brought a very unique charm to the character. That said, I definitely understand how someone could find his understated performance subpar compared to the other actors
I’m just now hearing that people have a problem with his performance and singing. Pretty stunning, because I thought he was fantastic and had a beautiful voice. I thought both he and Rachel Zegler had better voices than the voice doubles from the original film. I much prefer Elgort’s style of singing to Jimmy Bryant’s style. (Bryant was Tony’s singing voice in the original.) Their performance of “One Hand, One Heart” is literally one of the most beautiful things I’ve ever heard in my life. Their voices were beautiful together. And their chemistry was great, too. I truly believed they were in love, unlike the original film. Zegler/Elgort had a natural, more realistic chemistry that didn’t seem like over-the-top acting. It makes me wonder if any of the critics here have ever been in love.
See, I actually really enjoyed Ansel's performance. He is a little softer and less bold, but I think it also reflects where his character is at in his life, where he has learned a lot and doesn't want to be get involved with the things he used to. His voice is soft, as he has softened as a person. I don't know, I think that he did really well and held his own against some broadway icons.
I loved Ansel in this role and thought he did really well. He may not be the best singer in the cast but the way his voice melts with Rachel’s so well it actually elevates her which is what he should be doing.
And what makes the performance more impressive is that Rachel, who doesn't have a natural Puerto Rican accent was able to sing with an accent. (Unless someone Puerto Rican thinks otherwise) In the original West Side Story Marni Nixon's accent sounded odd.
although her singing does not demonstrate a puerto rican accent, it does maintain that spanish-speaking element. when she responds “me estoy vistiendo” to her brother, i heard more of a colombian/venezuelan accent in her voice. nonetheless, her accent portrays what her character needs in an eloquent and seamless manner. as a matter of fact, when i first watched the movie, i believed that rachel naturally spoke w the accent.
@@JavierRodriguezTX She is in fact Colombian and so that’s probably why you heard that type of accent, but they did do Puerto Rican accent training extensively.
If velvet could sing, it would be Rachel. She is so captivating. I agree with another poster that it is a crime she did not get an Oscar nod for her performance.
I love how much you get into the plot/story/characters but also are able to give your vocal critiques and technique commentary! It's so endearing and fun to watch!
Can't wait for the reaction! I really loved this version of Tonight. Honestly, I did like it better than the 1961 version, but ngl that was the case for most of the musical numbers in this new version😅 That's not to say the original film isn't great but man I really love this new version.
Rachel is phenomenal! I feel like Ansel lacked in the character and singing in my opinion. I felt like Tony didn't like Maria as much as she did. Maria seemed so inlove idk.
Yes! Ansel had zero spark. And in the gym scene he looked like a lion stalking his prey. I actually thought Chino was a much better catch. I mean the guy initially came off as a wet noodle, but when he busted it out at the dance, like Napoleon Dynamite, he totally charmed me. That took guts to do that in front of his friends and "enemies".
@@becca8803 I thought Ansel looked too old for the part. Mike Faist was 28 when he filmed it, but I honestly thought he was at least in his early 20s. Same with pretty much the rest of the actors, minus Rachel, who was actually 18, like her character. With that, and with all the unsavory allegations against Ansel, it makes it a bit hard to enjoy when he’s on screen, doesn’t do anything to ruin the movie for me tho. I just wish they chose a younger guy to play Tony, maybe a newcomer like Rachel too.
@@hierophantpurple5163 yeah tbh Maria did Chino dirty by leaving him on the dance floor after he pulled off those moves. Chino deserved so much better. ☹
Honestly, I really hope she does reactions to all the West Side Story songs! Though the ones I'd be most curious to know her thoughts on are A Boy Like That/I Have A Love, I Feel Pretty, and America
I've been a huge fan of rachel since we were both juniors in high school (2017/2018) I always knew that she was going to be amazing and now she's finally getting the recognition that she deserves. she's perfect
The whole cast should have gotten Oscars everyone had amazing singing voices not just picky about everything else I had some negatives just a little bit but it was still good in everyone in the movie that sing a song was amazing too I have no negatives about anyone singing voices
I have to defend the guy who has to sing Tony. it's a tricky I think he found a pretty good balance. part to sing. You don't want to go full opera, but you need a little pop in there as well.
It appears I am just the biggest Ansel Elgort defender in this movie. I think dancing wise he is a less talented than the other cast members but then again all of those people have been dancing on Broadway since they were preteens, but vocally and acting wise I think he is at the peak level. I felt the spark of chemistry and romance immediately.
No, I'm RIGHT there with you!! However, Ansel is actually a FANTASTIC Dancer in real life, but unfortunately he didn't get a whole lot of opportunities to show off his STELLAR Dancing skills in this Movie, although the number "Cool" with Mike Faist as Riff and others, SURE shows just HOW talented at Dancing he REALLY is!; He SURE holds his own (and THEN some), against Mike Faist and Mike Faist is VERY well known for his Dancing in "Newsies", etc.!!
I finally broke down and watched this on Saturday.. I felt I was cheating on Lin and Andrew and John .. it did not disappoint. Love a mike being rip .. I was bitter that it got a nom instead of tick tick boom.. then I watched it and was like ok. And omg the orchestra chills
I would love to hear what’s your opinion between this version and the one from the 1961 WSS with Natalie Wood and Richard Beymer (dubbed by Marni Nixon and Jimmy Bryan respectively). I personally loved this performance way way more. Tony has been weak in both versions but in this one Ansel did a good job given the fact he doesn’t have that operatic register and is not as professionally trained as Rachel.
Please react to crazy ex-girlfriend, it's a show about mental illness and the point of view of that person. It's a comedy and musical, Rachel bloom is the protagonist, co-creator, writer, and songwriter of this show. She's amazing and the show is amazing! ❤
Awesome assessment. Zegler is amazing and, while Elgort isn't AS amazing, he has a lovely voice and they sell the chemistry. Great video again, Songs From A Suitcase!
The only people saying that Ansel is terrible here are people that are hung up on his allegations. Yes, pretty bad, but he does extremely well here for somebody who doesn’t sing or dance. I love this musical, and he brought this great gentleness to Tony that I think made the entire production better
Ansel is definitely not terrible by any stretch. I think solely looking at him and his performance, it was lovely. But comparatively to the rest of the cast, he's a weak link to me. There were several other members of the cast that are much more powerhouses and I feel have better technique. His acting chops though are spectacular.
Well, I guess I'm a defender of Elgort's performance in this film, because to me, outside of a couple of moments where he's outperformed by someone else, there's other moments where another performer doesn't give a performance sent by God. One moment like that to me is Riff's little "explosive anger" dance spasm that felt *very* random at the end of his verse in "Cool." Again, not saying Mike Faist didn't give the performance of a lifetime, but everyone has a few cracks here or there. Though I do find it funny how I found Elgort's singing to be the stand-out portion of the film that really impressed me out of nowhere and stuck with me (not saying the other performers weren't absolutely fan-friggin-tastic mind you).
@Shardae 100%. I think it might have been because I didn't know many of Tony's songs from the musical in general, because I was really only shown "America" or "Cool" before from the original. It might have played into how impressed I was by Elgort's performance, but overall I also just remembered his performance the most because I wasn't expecting that amazing talent from him.
TOTALLY agree!! Ansel's Performance as Tony, is PHENOMENAL in this new 2021 Movie in my humble opinion! I actually thought he WAS one of the strongest Singers, if NOT the Strongest Singer in it! He's just got a different kind of Voice, (in the best possible way)!; from the others in the Cast! Low, Deep, Sexy, Sensual, INCREDIBLE lilt and Vibratto, more "jazzy" and throwback, which I personally LOVE!! He doesn't have to be an absolute powerhouse, although he definitely DOES have a very strong voice when it is necessary for the song! On the other hand though, he emotes SO much feeling and emotion into every song and you "feel" every word he's trying to convey! His pitch and Timbre is also STELLAR!
Like.... I loved loved loved it!and You will be flying with it! I already loved Your face and expression on it. This should have won best picture. And Spilburg, best director! The greatest!
I do think this song isn’t showcasing Ansel’s best when compared with Rachel. But he really killed in something’s coming (which happened earlier). This is her first song and she steals his heart here. I did not walk away from the movie thinking he was weak in any way. I think this song out of context might give people a different conclusion though.
AMEN, he SURE does!! He's INCREDIBLE as Tony and I'm SO sick of hearing he didn't measure up to the other Performances/Actors in the Movie!! He was PHENOMENAL in EVERY way and DEFINITELY held his own in EVERY way!!
Love your videos! My mom wasn't sure of Ansel playing Tony at first but he did do a good job. He can also dance really well too. Rachel's singing was superb. I am not a singer @ all but her notes sound very on key and on point. Ansel has an interesting voice. Very unusual. I don't know where to place him. Steven Spielberg did an amazing job on this movie and deserves a lot of attention. If anyone was going to do a remake of a famous musical it would be Spielberg definitely. The "Tonight," balcony scene is my favorite scene of the whole movie and when I think of WSS its the first scene that comes to mind. This Tony was more aggressive than Richard Beymer's Tony and Rachel's portrayal of Maria was much more vocal and liberating than Natalie Wood's Maria. 1961 was a different era for women back then. 2021 is more female empowerment than it was back in the late 50s early 60's. You're awesome! Keep up the amazing work!
If you are amazed, let me tell you that some parts of this song were live, as well as some in Maria, I Feel Pretty and America. Then A Boy Like That/ I Have A Love, Somewhere, One Hand One Heart and La Borinqueña (this one is new) were COMPLETELY live. You'll flip out with A Boy Like That/I Have A Love, even more knowing this. It's mindblowing
I much prefer the 1961 version of Officer Krupke. Russ Tamblyn was great. He performed a mini gymnastics routine in the song. I did not like the 2021 version.
The most complete versions of Puerto Rican Meistersinger Ana Maria Martinez singing Tonight with Placido Domingo on TH-cam are entitled "Ana Maria Martinez to Placido Domingo-Tonight (West Side Story)-Pecs 2008" and "Placido Domingo, Ana Maria Martinez 'Tonight'" Both singers hit some really high notes at the end of these versions..
I think that Rachel Zegler could teach the vocal coach a few things about musical expression. I also think that Ansel's more subtle approach perfectly matches the persona of his character. He was recently released from prison, is trying to forge a new life, and has learned that "coming on strong and aggressive" didn't work for him. Also, as in ballet, his primary job was to make sure that his partner shined through... and he did that admirably. His performance was not subpar.
These two as Tony and Maria I live so much more than 1961 Tony and Maria... not that they're bad or anything, but it doesn't have the same chemistry between the actors. 2021 Tony and Maria have so much more chemistry... but in both versions Anita and Bernardo are PERFECT
A thing to keep in mind about Elgort's portrayal of Tony is that this is a Tony that almost killed a kid in a gang fight and did a year in prison for it. As a result, as he says to Riff earlier in the movie, "I'm scared of myself . . ." Ever since he got out of prison, he's been bottling up his emotions, and it's only after he meets Maria that he lets himself exercise those emotional muscles. I might be reading too much into it, but at least there's an in-universe explanation for why Tony's singing isn't as bold/emotionally charged as Maria's.
You're an amazing channel! Can you please react to Glee - To Love You More? Rachel out did herself on this one, TRULY!!! she didin't breathe for 27 seconds. this is her best solo. take care!:)
Another delightful reaction video to this performance by another vocal coach on TH-cam is entitled "Vocal Coach Reacts to West Side Story (2021)-'Balcony Scene (Tonight)' & 'One Hand One Heart'" explains the difference between unison and prime unison singing.
Sorry folks, but I have to disagree with many of the commentators here. A big fan of the 1961 version and while yes Rachel Zegler did sing lovely, Ansel Elgort did not take a back seat to her. He was equally as effective and many as I were impressed that he could sing that well. In fact as I've told many it is for these two one should see W.S.S. Elgort and Zegler embody "Tony and Maria" beautifully. As a matter of fact Elgort's rendition of Tony is superior to Beymer's of the original 1961 version. Zegler is an absolute delight as Mara but personally Natalie Wood still holds the candle on that role.
Completely agree, Rachael's voice is beautiful but his portrayal of Tony was spot on in every aspect. I thought his vocals were fantastic. Maria was my favorite scene in the film. It just boomed in the theater and gave me chills when I first saw it
This performance is superb but the official Puerto Rican version of this is sung on the internet by Spanish Meistersinger Placido Domingo and Puerto Rican operatic soprano Ana Maria Martinez. It is interesting how Martinez takes the solo after the words "shooting sparks into space" and catapults this song into another dimension of beauty.
Puerto Rican soprano Ana Maria Martinez who sings this song with Placido Domingo on TH-cam videos entitled "Ana Maria Martinez & Placido Domingo-Tonight 2016" and again on"PLACIDO DOMINGO-ANA MARIA MARTINEZ-'TONIGHT Duet" has a fascinating video about her vocal music education at Juilliard on the TH-cam video entitled "Advice from Ana Maria Martinez".
Honestly agree with everything you said about Rachel, she couldn’t have done it better in my opinion. You said Tony’s tongue was getting in the way but I actually found his vowel placements too lazy and low and could have done with more lifting which I think in turn would have added clarity and energy to his voice. It may have helped his slight pharyngeal constriction too. He had the range and the thyroid tilt on the top notes but really needed a little more chest resonance.
She was great... everyone was great... except (hate to say it) Ansel as Tony. He played it too safe and withheld and his vocals were good but, in the same vain as Emma Watson in Beauty and the Beast, they were overshadowed by the amazing vocal talents of the surrounding cast. He is a talented vocalist and actor but just seemed too vanilla in a cast full of flavor and spice and it seemed like it was a choice sometimes because there were times he pulled up and it worked, like the bit at the end there and after THAT scene later in the climax.
🎵⚠️ Think you CAN'T SING, but wish you knew HOW??
Join my Karaoke Club!!
We host live Masterclasses, get feedback on your singing videos, vocal warm up drills, and just hang out with me!
👉 SingWithAudrey.com
Finally a new west side story reaction thank you.
@@o-stone8339 I’m playing Maria in west west side story concert at my new house on 1st of august
Please react to Ansel doing SOMETHINGS COMING - his version is first iv felt the excitement
I was her director when she was in High School. In press junkets she talks about asking Spielberg if she can finish her senior show. I directed her in that show. It was "Shrek the Musical". When she was a freshmen we knew from the second the first note came out of her mouth we knew that what we were witnessing was historical talent. However no one could have guessed that he rise would have been this amazing!
I can only imagine how you felt when you found out she was casted for this
@@doritobandito_1323 It was a crazy time! Exciting for everyone involved. She was supposed to start rehearsals when "Shrek" would have been performing. You can imagine my reaction when, she told me "I'm going to ask Steven if I can finish "Shrek"!!
One can only thank you for contributing to her formative development as a performer! What a gift.
How awesome it was that she got to work with Tesori in WSS after working on Shrek with you!
@@elenacruzlopez Yes, that was one of many completely crazy and awesome things that was going on during that time! She told me later that when she was filming her and Tesori were exchanging stories about their respective Shrek experiences!
i cannot believe this is rachels first professional gig. i've been watching her on social media for YEARS in her school musicals and clips of her singing just waiting for her to get cast in something like this, and shes just incredible
Same!!
Still bitter Rachel didn’t get an Oscar Nomination. She was amazing.
IMHO it’s the last 4 minutes of her performance that ruined her chances. I feel she wasn’t convincing enough as being De aster and definitely underperformed compared to Natalie Wood in the 1961 version. Her heartbreaking left me emotionally cold. Other than that she was absolutely marvellous and IMHO a much better Maria overall.
@@gpapa31 I love both the '21 and the '61 versions and for me Zegler's Maria is captivating. For the last scene in WSS in general, I think it could be written differently. To many words, talking about how many bullets, killing, possible suicide, and hate. Gets in the way of showing it, emoting I think.
@@gambledw you’re probably right. To be honest with you I didn’t cry jn the 1961 version when I first saw it as a kid back in the 90s back I did feel Natalie Woods devastation, it was quite there in your face. I don’t know Rachel didn’t deliver that here and the scene felt kind of rushed to me. Overall I loved the new version and IMHO is right up there with the 1961 by Robert Wise. It’s really really ashamed that it was overlooked this year bombed at the Box office and snubbed by the award committees.
@@gpapa31 I think maybe another factor is that the part of Maria may not have enough range that the Academy would want to nominate someone in that role for Best Actress? Iirc Natalie Wood didn't get a nomination for Best Actress either. WSS 1961's acting nods were in the Best Supporting Actor and Actress categories. Plus with her being a newcomer to acting on screen/the way Maria is written it's possible Rachel didn't give as good a performance as the others nominated in Best Actress this year. I have yet to see the films the Best Actress nominees are from yet so I can't speak my opinion on those nominations.
@@hierophantpurple5163 the other nominees in the category are pretty big performances, the movies basically revolve around the actresses performances. Zegler might have just been perceived as a beautiful singer but not a particularly extraordinary actress yet.
AND it’s Rachel Zegler’s FIRST professional acting gig♥️
I thought Ansels acting and dancing were both really great - his singing was good but Rachel has one of the best voices I’ve ever heard. Hard to hold your own next to her.
.....have you ever heard.... anyone else, at all, do West Side Story....
Some fun facts:
Rachel Zegler auditioned on the first day of auditions and set the bar so high with Steven Spielberg, he couldn’t find anyone else that matched her performance.
There’s a wonderful story of how Ariana Debose (Anita) turned down a request from Steven Spielberg to read at her first audition because she didn’t feel confident that she was going to give her best and asked for another day to read (she was only supposed to sing that day anyway).
David Alvarez (Bernardo) won a Tony Award at I think age 10 alongside Trent Kowalik and Kiril Kulish for their joint portrayals of Billy Elliott on Broadway.
"I'm being really picky cuz she's really good." And that to me is the Death Blow for Ansel in this movie. He's not bad per se, But when you put him up against Rachel Zegler, Ariana DeBose, Mike Faist, David Alvarez, Rita Moreno: He's out acted out danced out sung by everyone. Everyone else is greater then excellent and that's why he nearly sunk this movie for me even though I love the movie and it's still one of my 10 Best of 2021, Everyone/Everything else is just that great.
I really feel like you’re undermining how much he put his all into his performance. He sings very lovely, his dancing is up to par with pretty much everyone else, and there are some moments where he really gets to shine as an actor and I can name a few examples if you really care. You’re acting like he was the equivalent of Russell Crowe in Les Mis. Lol, get over yourself. XD
Makes you wonder why was he even casted in this role?
@@RyansChannel0203
I agree I really liked him in the film, I think he was just as good as everyone else
@Charles's Movie Channel That's an interesting perspective; I think I liked his performance for the same reasons you disliked it. His singing, while beautiful, is stylistically different and lacks the power of the rest of the cast, and his acting is significantly more subdued and laidback compared to the more fiery performances. For me, this set him apart from the other characters, showing how isolated and different Tony is from the rest of the Jets, and it brought a very unique charm to the character. That said, I definitely understand how someone could find his understated performance subpar compared to the other actors
I’m just now hearing that people have a problem with his performance and singing. Pretty stunning, because I thought he was fantastic and had a beautiful voice. I thought both he and Rachel Zegler had better voices than the voice doubles from the original film. I much prefer Elgort’s style of singing to Jimmy Bryant’s style. (Bryant was Tony’s singing voice in the original.) Their performance of “One Hand, One Heart” is literally one of the most beautiful things I’ve ever heard in my life. Their voices were beautiful together. And their chemistry was great, too. I truly believed they were in love, unlike the original film. Zegler/Elgort had a natural, more realistic chemistry that didn’t seem like over-the-top acting. It makes me wonder if any of the critics here have ever been in love.
See, I actually really enjoyed Ansel's performance. He is a little softer and less bold, but I think it also reflects where his character is at in his life, where he has learned a lot and doesn't want to be get involved with the things he used to. His voice is soft, as he has softened as a person. I don't know, I think that he did really well and held his own against some broadway icons.
Righhht? He‘s underrated and gets treated like his performance was bad
I so agree with You, He is a star , and up and coming! He's so charming, in everything.
Agree
I wasn't feeling him at first, but by the time I finished the movie he had definitely grown on me. Ansel felt this role, and he did it amazingly well.
I agree. I thought he was excellent in the One hand, One Heart scene! Such a fabulous voice.
I loved Ansel in this role and thought he did really well. He may not be the best singer in the cast but the way his voice melts with Rachel’s so well it actually elevates her which is what he should be doing.
He was fantastic in the One Hand, One Heart scene.
Rachel truly knocked it out of the park with Maria! I can’t wait to see her as Snow White in the new Disney live action movie!
They're making another Snow White?? I'm so down, but only because of her.
there making a live action movie of Snow White? I’m so down to see her do that
I just love this scene. The singing is beautiful. Prince charming...the song could go on forever.
And what makes the performance more impressive is that Rachel, who doesn't have a natural Puerto Rican accent was able to sing with an accent. (Unless someone Puerto Rican thinks otherwise)
In the original West Side Story Marni Nixon's accent sounded odd.
although her singing does not demonstrate a puerto rican accent, it does maintain that spanish-speaking element. when she responds “me estoy vistiendo” to her brother, i heard more of a colombian/venezuelan accent in her voice. nonetheless, her accent portrays what her character needs in an eloquent and seamless manner. as a matter of fact, when i first watched the movie, i believed that rachel naturally spoke w the accent.
@@JavierRodriguezTX The original 1961 film was definitely lacking this. Which was probably why I didn't care for it much.
It’s a Hispanic accent but not a Puerto Rican one.
@@JavierRodriguezTX She is in fact Colombian and so that’s probably why you heard that type of accent, but they did do Puerto Rican accent training extensively.
If velvet could sing, it would be Rachel. She is so captivating. I agree with another poster that it is a crime she did not get an Oscar nod for her performance.
Every time Rachel sings it seriously just draws me in…it’s just sooo wonderful ☺️☺️
I love how much you get into the plot/story/characters but also are able to give your vocal critiques and technique commentary! It's so endearing and fun to watch!
He actually has a nice older voice, and before they sang this song, he sang so beautifully in his solo leading to the song
Agree 1000%!!!
Yes he sang Maria so beautifully
During the whole movie Tony and Maria gave me Christine Daaé and Phantom vibes! I loved it so much! Thanks for your reaction you’re awesome!
Whatever you think about these two (who did an amazing job) will be put down by Ariana DeBose absolutely slaying as Anita
I thought Rachel and Ansel were great together and adorable. Well done, actually.
Can't wait for the reaction! I really loved this version of Tonight. Honestly, I did like it better than the 1961 version, but ngl that was the case for most of the musical numbers in this new version😅 That's not to say the original film isn't great but man I really love this new version.
The girl my dear is simply... AMAZING! Remember she was a mere 18 when this was done and basically only had high school musicals 😂 under her belt.
Aw I wish you reacted to the very last part with "goodnight, goodnight..."! So good!
and Rachel was casted at 17 years old...let that sink in...she is insane!
Rachel is phenomenal! I feel like Ansel lacked in the character and singing in my opinion.
I felt like Tony didn't like Maria as much as she did. Maria seemed so inlove idk.
Yes! Ansel had zero spark. And in the gym scene he looked like a lion stalking his prey. I actually thought Chino was a much better catch. I mean the guy initially came off as a wet noodle, but when he busted it out at the dance, like Napoleon Dynamite, he totally charmed me. That took guts to do that in front of his friends and "enemies".
Really didn’t like Ansel as Tony at all. Didn’t convince me of thier love story. He was just flat. Also thinks he looks too youthful for the part
@@becca8803 I thought Ansel looked too old for the part. Mike Faist was 28 when he filmed it, but I honestly thought he was at least in his early 20s. Same with pretty much the rest of the actors, minus Rachel, who was actually 18, like her character. With that, and with all the unsavory allegations against Ansel, it makes it a bit hard to enjoy when he’s on screen, doesn’t do anything to ruin the movie for me tho. I just wish they chose a younger guy to play Tony, maybe a newcomer like Rachel too.
@@kathrynlouiseberman7919 Chino dancing at the gym was honestly adorable and charming.
@@hierophantpurple5163 yeah tbh Maria did Chino dirty by leaving him on the dance floor after he pulled off those moves. Chino deserved so much better. ☹
You must do the tonight quintet from the new west side story
Honestly, I really hope she does reactions to all the West Side Story songs! Though the ones I'd be most curious to know her thoughts on are A Boy Like That/I Have A Love, I Feel Pretty, and America
I've been a huge fan of rachel since we were both juniors in high school (2017/2018) I always knew that she was going to be amazing and now she's finally getting the recognition that she deserves. she's perfect
Vocal Coach you are better to watch than the actors. you show so much compassion.
I really really like his voice indeed
COULDN'T agree MORE!!
I ADORE Ansel's Voice!!
The whole cast should have gotten Oscars everyone had amazing singing voices not just picky about everything else I had some negatives just a little bit but it was still good in everyone in the movie that sing a song was amazing too I have no negatives about anyone singing voices
The movie is incredible.
She can sing! I enjoyed his performance also. His tone sound great to me.
When ever I watch these style videos and I’ve never seen the movie that anyone is reacting to it’s the best
I love your content on West Side Story. I'm researching the two versions for my masters and your videos are beyond inspiring
I have to defend the guy who has to sing Tony. it's a tricky I think he found a pretty good balance. part to sing. You don't want to go full opera, but you need a little pop in there as well.
Did you really think Steven Spielberg would allow this film to be anything less than perfect?
It appears I am just the biggest Ansel Elgort defender in this movie.
I think dancing wise he is a less talented than the other cast members but then again all of those people have been dancing on Broadway since they were preteens, but vocally and acting wise I think he is at the peak level. I felt the spark of chemistry and romance immediately.
No, I'm RIGHT there with you!!
However, Ansel is actually a FANTASTIC Dancer in real life, but unfortunately he didn't get a whole lot of opportunities to show off his STELLAR Dancing skills in this Movie, although the number "Cool" with Mike Faist as Riff and others, SURE shows just HOW talented at Dancing he REALLY is!; He SURE holds his own (and THEN some), against Mike Faist and Mike Faist is VERY well known for his Dancing in "Newsies", etc.!!
Please do A Boy Like That / I have a love from WST 2021!
I finally broke down and watched this on Saturday.. I felt I was cheating on Lin and Andrew and John .. it did not disappoint. Love a mike being rip .. I was bitter that it got a nom instead of tick tick boom.. then I watched it and was like ok. And omg the orchestra chills
Wait you didn't watch the clip to the end 😭😭😭 The end is my favourite part.
the new Maria was wonderful.
Ansel was amazing. They both deserved awards
I would love to hear what’s your opinion between this version and the one from the 1961 WSS with Natalie Wood and Richard Beymer (dubbed by Marni Nixon and Jimmy Bryan respectively).
I personally loved this performance way way more. Tony has been weak in both versions but in this one Ansel did a good job given the fact he doesn’t have that operatic register and is not as professionally trained as Rachel.
Please react to crazy ex-girlfriend, it's a show about mental illness and the point of view of that person.
It's a comedy and musical, Rachel bloom is the protagonist, co-creator, writer, and songwriter of this show.
She's amazing and the show is amazing! ❤
Awesome assessment. Zegler is amazing and, while Elgort isn't AS amazing, he has a lovely voice and they sell the chemistry. Great video again, Songs From A Suitcase!
Like it all , love west side story so much ❤
Haven't seen it yet either but need to! Love the videos!
Such a great video! I would love to hear what you think of the tonight quintet as well!
Don’t want to wait??? Watch this video RIGHT NOW on my Patreon account: www.patreon.com/SongsFromASuitcase
wow, a voice coach with vocal fry. Amazing
The only people saying that Ansel is terrible here are people that are hung up on his allegations. Yes, pretty bad, but he does extremely well here for somebody who doesn’t sing or dance. I love this musical, and he brought this great gentleness to Tony that I think made the entire production better
AGREED, but actually Ansel is a FANTASTIC Singer and Dancer and is actually known for both, fortunately!
Ansel is definitely not terrible by any stretch. I think solely looking at him and his performance, it was lovely. But comparatively to the rest of the cast, he's a weak link to me. There were several other members of the cast that are much more powerhouses and I feel have better technique. His acting chops though are spectacular.
Well, I guess I'm a defender of Elgort's performance in this film, because to me, outside of a couple of moments where he's outperformed by someone else, there's other moments where another performer doesn't give a performance sent by God. One moment like that to me is Riff's little "explosive anger" dance spasm that felt *very* random at the end of his verse in "Cool." Again, not saying Mike Faist didn't give the performance of a lifetime, but everyone has a few cracks here or there. Though I do find it funny how I found Elgort's singing to be the stand-out portion of the film that really impressed me out of nowhere and stuck with me (not saying the other performers weren't absolutely fan-friggin-tastic mind you).
@Shardae 100%. I think it might have been because I didn't know many of Tony's songs from the musical in general, because I was really only shown "America" or "Cool" before from the original. It might have played into how impressed I was by Elgort's performance, but overall I also just remembered his performance the most because I wasn't expecting that amazing talent from him.
TOTALLY agree!!
Ansel's Performance as Tony, is PHENOMENAL in this new 2021 Movie in my humble opinion!
I actually thought he WAS one of the strongest Singers, if NOT the Strongest Singer in it!
He's just got a different kind of Voice, (in the best possible way)!; from the others in the Cast!
Low, Deep, Sexy, Sensual, INCREDIBLE lilt and Vibratto, more "jazzy" and throwback, which I personally LOVE!!
He doesn't have to be an absolute powerhouse, although he definitely DOES have a very strong voice when it is necessary for the song!
On the other hand though, he emotes SO much feeling and emotion into every song and you "feel" every word he's trying to convey!
His pitch and Timbre is also STELLAR!
They were certainly better than I thought they would be. I could have like a little more power from her and him. But they do fit together.
Like.... I loved loved loved it!and You will be flying with it! I already loved Your face and expression on it. This should have won best picture. And Spilburg, best director! The greatest!
I do think this song isn’t showcasing Ansel’s best when compared with Rachel. But he really killed in something’s coming (which happened earlier). This is her first song and she steals his heart here. I did not walk away from the movie thinking he was weak in any way. I think this song out of context might give people a different conclusion though.
Please react to Rachel and Ariana singing "A Boy Like that/I Have a Love". You would LOVE it!!
Have you done Maria yet? Because he sings so beautifully in that song. I really enjoyed his voice in this movie. Suited the character so nicely
In West Side Story (1961) Natalie Wood's singing was dubbed by Marni Nixon.
pls react to One hand, one heart❤️
Maybe this will teach you not to judge someone at the beginning of the video with her voice. Rachel is always great.
Ansels voice is amazing. He's got way more than a sparkle, he's perfection on screen.
AMEN, he SURE does!!
He's INCREDIBLE as Tony and I'm SO sick of hearing he didn't measure up to the other Performances/Actors in the Movie!!
He was PHENOMENAL in EVERY way and DEFINITELY held his own in EVERY way!!
I think you should check out The Blues Brothers with Dan Ackroyd and John Belushi
Do you have a date for the watch party? No pressure though, just wanted to ask in case you knew already :)
love them , you should react to Maria it is AMAZING
Agreed 1000%!!
Love your videos! My mom wasn't sure of Ansel playing Tony at first but he did do a good job. He can also dance really well too. Rachel's singing was superb. I am not a singer @ all but her notes sound very on key and on point. Ansel has an interesting voice. Very unusual. I don't know where to place him. Steven Spielberg did an amazing job on this movie and deserves a lot of attention. If anyone was going to do a remake of a famous musical it would be Spielberg definitely.
The "Tonight," balcony scene is my favorite scene of the whole movie and when I think of WSS its the first scene that comes to mind.
This Tony was more aggressive than Richard Beymer's Tony and Rachel's portrayal of Maria was much more vocal and liberating than Natalie Wood's Maria. 1961 was a different era for women back then. 2021 is more female empowerment than it was back in the late 50s early 60's.
You're awesome! Keep up the amazing work!
And to think Rachel was only 17 when she filmed this!
The bit she sings through the step is as perfect as is entirely possible. He really is outclassed though and it is embarrassingly apparent.
If you are amazed, let me tell you that some parts of this song were live, as well as some in Maria, I Feel Pretty and America. Then A Boy Like That/ I Have A Love, Somewhere, One Hand One Heart and La Borinqueña (this one is new) were COMPLETELY live. You'll flip out with A Boy Like That/I Have A Love, even more knowing this. It's mindblowing
You gotta review when he sings "Maria" alone please...I'd beg to hear the review
Office Krupke next! It’s my favorite song
Love that scene
I much prefer the 1961 version of Officer Krupke. Russ Tamblyn was great. He performed a mini gymnastics routine in the song. I did not like the 2021 version.
Just found your channel! I’d love to hear your thoughts on his Something’s Coming from the same movie
Ooh! God I love that song since whenever!
I truly feel like their voice really match their characters. Tony being more of a firecracker and messy while Maria is very reserved and innocent
The geniuses are Bernstein and Sondheim.
On Glee, Rachel and Blaine sing this song. I would love to see your reaction.💖
The most complete versions of Puerto Rican Meistersinger Ana Maria Martinez singing Tonight with Placido Domingo on TH-cam are entitled "Ana Maria Martinez to Placido Domingo-Tonight (West Side Story)-Pecs 2008" and "Placido Domingo, Ana Maria Martinez 'Tonight'" Both singers hit some really high notes at the end of these versions..
You cut off the end.....lol..
omG.....it was sweet. Coach Hoot
You should do I feel pretty critique from
West Side Story
I think that Rachel Zegler could teach the vocal coach a few things about musical expression. I also think that Ansel's more subtle approach perfectly matches the persona of his character. He was recently released from prison, is trying to forge a new life, and has learned that "coming on strong and aggressive" didn't work for him. Also, as in ballet, his primary job was to make sure that his partner shined through... and he did that admirably. His performance was not subpar.
These two as Tony and Maria I live so much more than 1961 Tony and Maria... not that they're bad or anything, but it doesn't have the same chemistry between the actors. 2021 Tony and Maria have so much more chemistry... but in both versions Anita and Bernardo are PERFECT
A thing to keep in mind about Elgort's portrayal of Tony is that this is a Tony that almost killed a kid in a gang fight and did a year in prison for it. As a result, as he says to Riff earlier in the movie, "I'm scared of myself . . ." Ever since he got out of prison, he's been bottling up his emotions, and it's only after he meets Maria that he lets himself exercise those emotional muscles. I might be reading too much into it, but at least there's an in-universe explanation for why Tony's singing isn't as bold/emotionally charged as Maria's.
You're an amazing channel! Can you please react to Glee - To Love You More? Rachel out did herself on this one, TRULY!!! she didin't breathe for 27 seconds. this is her best solo. take care!:)
Yesss, pleaseeee
Tony has a really strong accent, I think that’s why he couldn’t really make it bolder cause he is trying to be consistent with his voice
ABSOLUTELY agreed!! 👍
Another delightful reaction video to this performance by another vocal coach on TH-cam is entitled "Vocal Coach Reacts to West Side Story (2021)-'Balcony Scene (Tonight)' & 'One Hand One Heart'" explains the difference between unison and prime unison singing.
CONGRATULATIONS TO ARIANA ON HER OSCAR WIN!
Please react to all West Side Story songs!
PLEASE REACT TO THE WSS 2021 MARIA
please react to “a boy like that”!!
Sorry folks, but I have to disagree with many of the commentators here. A big fan of the 1961 version and while yes Rachel Zegler did sing lovely, Ansel Elgort did not take a back seat to her. He was equally as effective and many as I were impressed that he could sing that well. In fact as I've told many it is for these two one should see W.S.S. Elgort and Zegler embody "Tony and Maria" beautifully. As a matter of fact Elgort's rendition of Tony is superior to Beymer's of the original 1961 version. Zegler is an absolute delight as Mara but personally Natalie Wood still holds the candle on that role.
Completely agree, Rachael's voice is beautiful but his portrayal of Tony was spot on in every aspect. I thought his vocals were fantastic. Maria was my favorite scene in the film. It just boomed in the theater and gave me chills when I first saw it
COMPLETELY agree!!
This performance is superb but the official Puerto Rican version of this is sung on the internet by Spanish Meistersinger Placido Domingo and Puerto Rican operatic soprano Ana Maria Martinez. It is interesting how Martinez takes the solo after the words "shooting sparks into space" and catapults this song into another dimension of beauty.
West side story is freakin amazing! Still not sold on the new one yet. Like ur reactions tho
Puerto Rican soprano Ana Maria Martinez who sings this song with Placido Domingo on TH-cam videos entitled "Ana Maria Martinez & Placido Domingo-Tonight 2016" and again on"PLACIDO DOMINGO-ANA MARIA MARTINEZ-'TONIGHT Duet" has a fascinating video about her vocal music education at Juilliard on the TH-cam video entitled "Advice from Ana Maria Martinez".
you should react to maria
this song and "a boy like that" are the two songs from the film sung live!
Not correct!
"Maria" is almost completely live and "One Hand, One Heart", is 100% live!!
@@janebarry-fraundorf4623 Rachel Zegler tweeted (11.19.21) that "A Boy Like That/I Have A Love" were sung completely live
@@emmarosegraddy3014not arguing that fact, just stating that a number of others were also!
Honestly agree with everything you said about Rachel, she couldn’t have done it better in my opinion. You said Tony’s tongue was getting in the way but I actually found his vowel placements too lazy and low and could have done with more lifting which I think in turn would have added clarity and energy to his voice. It may have helped his slight pharyngeal constriction too. He had the range and the thyroid tilt on the top notes but really needed a little more chest resonance.
She was great... everyone was great... except (hate to say it) Ansel as Tony. He played it too safe and withheld and his vocals were good but, in the same vain as Emma Watson in Beauty and the Beast, they were overshadowed by the amazing vocal talents of the surrounding cast. He is a talented vocalist and actor but just seemed too vanilla in a cast full of flavor and spice and it seemed like it was a choice sometimes because there were times he pulled up and it worked, like the bit at the end there and after THAT scene later in the climax.
Can you please react to Schmigadoon songs? Love your reactions! ^_^
Ansel talks with his tongue in the way lol
you should listen to one hand one heart is even better than this scene that is absolutely amazing already
She reminds me of Leah Salonga - she has the same chemistry
I wish you react to "west side story" songs performed by the Glee cast